Vai al lettorePassa al contenuto principale
Ci sono libri che ci accompagnano per sempre, ma altri che, col senno di poi, magari vorremmo non aver mai più letto. In questo video, metto sotto la lente d'ingrandimento 3 titoli famosi che ho deciso di rivalutare, esplorando le ragioni che ci spingono ad abbandonare certe opere o a cambiare completamente prospettiva su di esse.

Potrebbe essere l'occasione perfetta per una riflessione sulle tue letture, passate e presenti. Chissà, magari tra i "classici" in discussione c'è proprio quel libro che hai amato perdutamente! Scopri se le tue opinioni cambiano con il tempo e con le nuove esperienze di lettura.

#LibriDaRivalutare #CriticaLetteraria #LetturaAttiva#LibriDaNonRileggere #CriticaLetteraria #LetturaConsapevole
Trascrizione
00:00Three very famous books that everyone loved, but that I honestly would never read again.
00:04Let's start with what might perhaps generate a little more criticism, American Psycho.
00:08This book is sold as a very strong criticism of a certain model of capitalism of the 1980s.
00:13and to the YAPI culture, a true acronym for Young Urban Professional,
00:18characterized by young professionals who were career-obsessed,
00:22from unbridled consumerism and promoted the ostentation of wealth and the pursuit of individual success.
00:27All these concepts are very clear both for the protagonist who uses Alice and for the writing style
00:32and here we have the first problem.
00:34The style is deliberately repetitive, wordy and heavy.
00:37Okay, you want me to live inside the head of a psychopath, but honestly, 400 pages of this kind are just too much.
00:44The second problem for me is that the criticism that everyone is talking about could have been expressed in a much more
00:48effective,
00:49in the sense that it is not perceived, there has never been a moment in which I understood
00:53ah ok Alice is actually criticizing this model.
00:56Now I'm not saying that all stories have to be as clear as Blindness or Exquisite Corpse,
01:01but it seemed to me that that part was missing.
01:04Then thinking about it I realized that Mary Camp Psycho uses narration more for a mental experience
01:08and hopes that an idea will emerge from that mental experience.
01:10The second book is The Stranger.
01:12This book left me with nothing, I simply read it, put it away and didn't think about it.
01:17more.
01:17And basically there's nothing wrong with that, I just expected a very different reaction,
01:20given the hype surrounding it.
01:22I would say that this book has become a bit more inflated because some people know Camus as a philosopher
01:27and therefore they appreciate, let's say, his thinking.
01:30What Camus asks himself in this story is certainly very interesting,
01:33or how a man would be judged who refuses to feign the feelings that society expects of him.
01:38During the story the protagonist is a man, and he is put on trial.
01:42During the trial, however, he realizes that he is not judged so much for the crime he committed,
01:45but above all because he doesn't play the role one would expect from a, let's say, normal person.
01:50Even though the story is interesting, I didn't find any reflections that were particularly profound or triggering.
01:56I mean, I had nothing left, I just closed the book and said, well, it was like I hadn't had it.
02:01Bed.
02:01Finally, one of the books that made me cry the most, A Life Like Many Others.
02:05Well, actually, it's not that I didn't like this book, it's just that I wouldn't read it again.
02:08I didn't actually find any reflections that I then took with me.
02:12and I read it above all because I was very curious to know how far the atrocities that this
02:19poor Christ suffers.
02:20It's a good book to cry about, to become very fond of the protagonist.
02:24Nothing can be said about this because one empathizes too well.
02:27The book is about friendship, love, trauma, impossibility, healing.
02:31However, the novel does not develop a precise thesis around these arguments,
02:34in fact the author also said that she did not want to offer a therapeutic story
02:38or give a reassuring message about recovery.
02:40And this, even though it divided a lot of people, actually wasn't a problem for me.
02:44It's more the fact that after a thousand pages it passes.
02:47Ok, it made me cry all the tears I hadn't cried in twenty years,
02:51but it's not like I actually had anything left to think about.
Commenti
Monia's Books
Creator
voi cosa ne pensate di questi libri?

Consigliato