Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 6 months ago

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Welcome to a special edition of In The Room, where we are talking about the local election results in England,
00:07Wales and Scotland.
00:08We're recording this on Friday at 3pm, so there's still plenty of important results still to come.
00:13But the early indications are clear, and one of the very strong things is that Reform UK, a party that's
00:18only existed for five short years, has made unprecedented gains right across the country.
00:22Yes, and I'm just looking at the BBC results page just here. It's a very worrying time if you're a
00:27Labour or a Conservative backer.
00:29Yeah, that's for sure. And it's a particularly worrying time if you're the Prime Minister, Keir Starmer, who is now
00:34facing many calls to step down.
00:37I'm Helen McNamara, the former Deputy Cabinet Secretary.
00:39And I'm Cleo Watson, a former Special Advisor in Number 10.
00:42And this is In The Room.
00:46So, Cleo, you've been talking just then about refreshing the BBC results page, which I know you've been doing religiously
00:52since 10 past 11 last night.
00:55What is your take on where we've got to?
00:57Well, in some ways, it's exactly as predicted. Everyone was saying it's going to be a bad night for Labour,
01:02it's going to be a pretty bad night for the Tories, and the Lib Dems are going to do well,
01:07but particularly Reform are going to do brilliantly well, and of course the Greens.
01:11And it was kind of striking to see the Reform results page, because they only had two councillors elected a
01:20couple of years ago, so it's a kind of amazing change for them.
01:23I think the point I really want to make, and this is something I've had to fight so many times
01:29since the European referendum on our EU membership,
01:35is that I think these results will push people even further into their existing corners, on their basic core beliefs.
01:44So, quite a lot of my more right-leaning friends, if that is even the fair dynamic on how to
01:50judge these things now, because Reform and the Greens wouldn't necessarily pit themselves in those terms,
01:56they feel quite positive, they feel like people are understanding where they're coming from, and that they actually have a
02:04quiet majority supporting a lot of their views on immigration and tax and so on.
02:11And similarly, I've got a lot of left-wing friends in London who feel quite upbeat as well, because they
02:18feel that, certainly in East London, where Hackney Mayor is now Green Mayor, they feel like they're being listened to
02:27too.
02:28So I suspect when we hear from the centrist dads at The Rest is Politics, Alistair Campbell and Rory Stewart
02:35will be feeling quite sad about today's results.
02:37And the thing with these results is it's pushing these people even more into their kind of entrenched camps.
02:44And the thing I keep hearing today is, particularly on the reform vote, lots of people I know just can't
02:52believe people would vote reform.
02:54You therefore must be racist, you therefore must hate immigrants, you therefore must be a terrible person who loves Donald
03:02Trump.
03:02And I can see how people will fall further into this narrative if they're feeling more despondent about these results
03:07today.
03:08I used to get this a lot after the EU referendum when I worked on the Vote Leave campaign, where
03:13people felt that the Vote Leave campaign had tricked people into voting to leave.
03:19Which I happen to think is just downright rude to assume all voters are that ignorant and that over half
03:25the country would be that stupid and able to be tricked.
03:29I think it's this understanding from the people I know who are a little better off, who actually don't have
03:36the same problems interacting with the state,
03:39the vast ways of the country do, that really don't understand what voters are saying when they are doubling down
03:47and voting against the establishment.
03:50So whether it was against the Remain campaign, whether it was against the Conservatives in 2024, and now it's against
03:58the Labour government, it's, you know, you don't have to be a genius.
04:03All you have to do is to read what people are saying in focus groups, what people are just saying
04:07on Facebook and Twitter and so on, just normal people.
04:10They are deeply, deeply discontent with how the country is being run.
04:15I'm not saying that reform of the Greens would do a better job, but you can see how they think.
04:19We've had a go with the establishment. We may as well just try something new.
04:23We already feel like our lives are shit. Let's try something else.
04:26And that's something we talked about on our main podcast earlier in the week, isn't it?
04:30That you can, you don't have to stretch your mind very far to make an argument that what people were
04:34voting against in 2016 in the referendum,
04:38against in 2017 when they voted very, very big numbers for Jeremy Corbyn, voting again, kind of against everything and
04:45for Boris Johnson in 2019,
04:47and then for Keir Starmer in 2024, that there is just a kind of reaction.
04:52This doesn't work for me and it doesn't work for me for a reason.
04:54And I do think in the conversations you and I have, I mean, sort of, of course it matters what
04:59your politics are.
05:01But what really matters is the inability of the people who can make decisions to actually listen to what they're
05:06being told.
05:07And if they even can hear it, to not blame everybody else, but to actually try to do something about
05:12it.
05:13Should we talk a bit about where we think Labour are after?
05:15So we haven't had the full results of Wales and Scotland yet, but where do we think the Labour Party
05:20have landed today?
05:22I think in a sentence, Labour have lost votes to the Greens and they've lost seats to reform.
05:29And by that I mean the Greens and reform have inadvertently worked together to dig into Labour.
05:37And obviously there are certain pockets where, you know, reform have absolutely tranched the Conservatives or the Lib Dem have
05:44tranched the Conservatives.
05:46And also there are certain places where the Conservatives have done well against Labour because actually people have decided to
05:52vote Conservative to keep Greens or the reform out.
05:55It's kind of an interesting tactical voting monstrosity in some ways.
06:00But I think that's the easiest way to put it, is that Labour have suffered on both sides.
06:06They're left flank to the Greens, they're right flank to reform.
06:09Perhaps because they've not made a case in either direction.
06:11In order for Greens to try and keep reform out, reform to try and keep the Greens out, they've essentially
06:16eaten away at Labour.
06:18And so far that's translating into a major popular vote for the Greens, major seat wins for reform.
06:26And I suspect a new campaign for the left will be to change our voting system from first past the
06:33post to proportional representation.
06:35It's funny how suddenly that goes up the list of things that really matter when you get results like this.
06:40I suppose the other thing that, you know, you and I weren't expecting that whatever the results, that there was
06:45going to be a direct leadership challenge to the Prime Minister today.
06:49I'm not because we're some prediction wizards, but just because it would be a bit obvious to do that during
06:53the day.
06:53Obviously, he's already come out, so before the Wales and Scotland votes, he's come out with a quite personal message
06:59saying like,
06:59I am not going to, you know, I'm going to carry on fighting, I'm going to deliver my mandate, sort
07:04of watch this space.
07:04I think one of the striking things, I know we'll talk a bit more about this in a second,
07:08one of the striking things about just sitting back and looking at the messaging around this election,
07:13it's very individual and personal.
07:15Like all the leaders are referred to by their first names and possibly without the exception of Ed Davey, I
07:19guess.
07:20But it's very kind of, what does Zach think? What's Nigel doing? What's Kemi doing? What's Keir?
07:24It's very kind of individual and not movement based.
07:28And I wonder whether there is something in, you know, we don't know yet whether there will be a direct
07:32challenge to Keir Starmer.
07:34There may well be the usual suspects are out there grumbling in the way the usual suspects are within the
07:38Labour Party.
07:39But I suppose one of the reasons not to act is that it's not really about the individuals.
07:46And I think for Labour, it's kind of, what's the plan?
07:50Is changing the guy at the top really going to make all of that difference?
07:53And I suppose that's where, to your point, or to both of our points about listening, is that, OK, absolutely
07:59fine.
08:00But does changing the Prime Minister really make that much of a difference?
08:03Don't you have to change much, much more than that?
08:06Yeah, I agree with that.
08:07Just very quickly on the messaging, I was really struck by that too, that he said, you know,
08:12I can't sugarcoat it, these are very bad set of results, I'm not going to walk away.
08:16And I was thinking, what, you know, why are you helping to frame this as a referendum on yourself?
08:22This is, you know, regardless of whether they keep the Prime Minister or not,
08:26the entire Labour Party and the government have to have a real think about how they start listening to people,
08:32understanding what they really want, and then implementing it.
08:34Just on the leadership contenders, by the way, who, you know, who have been making all sorts of noises,
08:40and I'm sure being extremely helpful today, I do think it is worth noting that in the North West,
08:47around Andy Burnham's patch and Angela Rayner's patch, reform have made astonishing inroads there.
08:54I mean, it's sort of unprecedented what is happening around Manchester and the North West.
09:00Boris Johnson never managed to touch those places, and reform have.
09:04So I don't think that they can make a particularly good case for we can row against the tide,
09:10and people really love us.
09:12And similarly, I suspect, you know, Wes Streeting being a London MP,
09:18I don't suppose he'll be able to have a fantastic record to defend after this as well.
09:22So it's going to be a funny weekend.
09:23If I were working in the Prime Minister's office, I'd be gearing up to point those results out to sort
09:29of on-the-fence MPs and party members,
09:32because they are not proving to be winners in their own patches either.
09:37It's interesting, though, as well, isn't it?
09:38In terms of the commentary, at least from within the Labour Party, it's looked like in recent days and weeks,
09:43they've been very focused on losing votes on the left,
09:45so that the correction to him, and that's the leadership candidates people are talking about,
09:49are probably more to the left of Keir Starmer than to the right of him, for sure.
09:53But actually, your point is not just that the Labour Party have lost votes to the Greens.
09:57They have lost votes to the Greens, they've lost seats to reform,
10:00but they have also lost votes to reform in some areas.
10:03So there's an interesting, I think you said earlier in the week that people,
10:08the Labour Party needs to pick a lane, needs to decide where it was.
10:11Now it sounds, and we don't know if this is true,
10:13but it sounds like one of the lanes that Keir Starmer is still determined to pick is being very pro
10:18-EU.
10:19So apparently he's going to make a speech at the beginning of the week
10:21and set out all of these things that the Labour government are going to do, rather.
10:26And one of them is about ever closer alignment with the EU,
10:29which I think strikes me as a slightly discordant messaging,
10:32if one of the problems is how Labour is performing in the seats and areas that voted very strongly for
10:38Brexit.
10:39And the other point that I'm, you know, we will continue to be a bit boring about this,
10:43she says, hurrah. But one of the reasons why people voted Brexit is because it's the sense of powerlessness
10:51in our own country. And standing up as the Prime Minister and saying,
10:54I can't really fix these things for you, but I can definitely fix them better if we go back
10:58and align with those other guys is quite a hard message as well,
11:01because I think there's lots of reasons just as individuals to feel pretty powerless.
11:05And we can see in this dynamic, people are voting in a way that's like,
11:09this doesn't work for me, I want change.
11:12But to then, you have to think quite carefully as a leader in response to that sort of reaction
11:16and look like you are, look like you are more in control.
11:20And that would definitely be my critique of some of the missteps of the Labour government
11:24since they got elected, is they have quite often lent into looking powerless.
11:28So they have said, well, it's not our fault, it's because, you know,
11:31the nasty Tories did this before, or it's not our fault,
11:33because this is the way the market works, or it's not our fault,
11:36because there's lots and lots of reasons why they can't do things.
11:39I think you're bang on. I really hate it when people say,
11:41it's not a policy problem, it's a communications problem,
11:44but it has slightly managed to be both.
11:46And two things that I know have come up on the doorstep in the last month,
11:51and which also feel true, sort of anecdotally,
11:55are the welfare reforms row and the winter fuel payments row.
12:00And those are really, they were really tough decisions for the Labour government to make.
12:05And they ultimately made them, and this is how they communicated it out,
12:08as we've been left with a shit show,
12:12and we're going to have to make some cuts somewhere,
12:15and we've got choices, and these are the things we're going to choose.
12:19Instead of making a really good fairness case,
12:21which is, we are Labour, we are literally the party of the worker,
12:27and we want people to have pride in finding jobs again,
12:30and we want to help cut joblessness,
12:32and we need to have a serious conversation about welfare,
12:35and how that works out, and how we spend things.
12:38And, you know, basically put some positive spin
12:41on what was quite a tricky series of cuts to make,
12:45which inevitably then didn't happen, and we now spend more.
12:48And similarly, with winter fuel payments,
12:50I don't know why they didn't just come straight out and say,
12:52clearly it is wrong for incredibly wealthy pensioners
12:56to get this winter fuel payment.
12:58We need to have a serious conversation
13:00to make sure we look after our most vulnerable, etc., etc.
13:03So, you know, they have created some of these problems.
13:07They've literally managed to make themselves look like the bad guys a few times.
13:11Just in terms of what to say to the Prime Minister,
13:13there's the first really obvious thing, unfortunately,
13:16which is whether he wants to go or not,
13:18whether he ought to go or not,
13:19he just can't say that at the moment.
13:21The minute you even concede an inch,
13:24then you are completely irrelevant,
13:27and it's a matter of when, not if.
13:30And, you know, we do have a pretty serious economic crisis
13:34and an international situation to keep an eye on.
13:36And in the next few weeks, we've got the NATO summit
13:38and the G7 summit, and we'll just look ridiculous,
13:41or he will, if he goes along
13:43and he starts making commitments on defence spending,
13:46which we've talked about before,
13:47which is due in the coming weeks,
13:49because people will think,
13:51well, mate, we know you're on the way out.
13:53So they're just puffs of air.
13:56So I think regardless of what he's actually thinking with his team,
13:59he can't say that he is going to go or wants to go.
14:04Of course, it may not be up to him.
14:06And I guess the point I wanted to make
14:09by drawing attention to the results in the North West, for example,
14:12is that so long as Number 10 can continue
14:16to muddy the waters on potential replacements for him,
14:22and whilst Labour MPs can't decide on a sort of crown prince,
14:27an anointed leader,
14:29and whilst the party membership are at sixes and sevens about it as well,
14:34he's basically safe.
14:35It's terrible news for the country to have this kind of dawdling.
14:39And I know that there is this case being made
14:41that he'll just cling on like Joe Biden,
14:43and by doing so,
14:44he will kind of poison the chalice
14:46for whoever comes in after Labour
14:49in the same way that people feel
14:51that Biden undermined Kamala Harris.
14:54I don't know if that is particularly true, actually.
14:57I think something quite different is happening here
15:00because we've got this incredible party split,
15:02which obviously is not the case in America.
15:06But I do think it is the case
15:08that he's absolutely sort of,
15:10he remains Prime Minister until just suddenly he isn't.
15:14And you and I have experienced that firsthand,
15:15that, you know, as Boris Johnson said,
15:18the herd can suddenly move and he's in trouble.
15:21Although I read a brilliant piece recently
15:23that, and I forget by Hugh,
15:25and I will put this in the show notes
15:27so they get credit,
15:28but someone was talking about how with Conservative MPs,
15:31you know, the herd moves,
15:31it's like a herd of sheep
15:32and they're fairly easy to control.
15:34When the herd moves with Labour,
15:36it's like a herd of wild horses
15:37and they kind of zigzag out of control
15:39and crash into each other.
15:40And it's like Beech's Brook in the Grand National.
15:44On the doorstep is one of my favourite things,
15:45by the way,
15:46one of the patterns of local elections
15:48or any elections
15:48is that you sit there as a civil servant
15:50and you get your ministers back
15:52and you get your political advisers back
15:54and they are full of telling you
15:56what people have said on the doorstep.
15:58And actually, surprisingly,
15:59what they've heard on the doorstep
16:00is usually literally
16:01what they left the building thinking
16:03two weeks ago was an issue.
16:04And they just play it back to you,
16:05like, well, on the doorstep,
16:06this was playing really well
16:08or this was playing really badly.
16:09I never, I mean,
16:10I think literally never heard someone
16:12have had their minds changed
16:14by on the doorstep.
16:16But Helen, I think that's a perfect metaphor
16:18for this situation,
16:19which is, like,
16:21when you go into a focus group, say,
16:24it's really important to try and go in,
16:27not deliberately trying to listen out
16:29for something either that you want to hear
16:32or that you're expecting to hear.
16:34And this is sort of the problem.
16:36These sets of results,
16:38I don't necessarily think
16:40will make lots of,
16:42let's just collectively call them
16:44like the Westminster bubble or whatever.
16:45I don't think that'll necessarily
16:46make them think,
16:47hmm, I've really been wrong about this.
16:49I need to think about this quite differently.
16:51Lots of them will think
16:52we've got to double down
16:54on the position that I hold
16:56because that's what I'm hearing
16:58and that's what I'm seeing
16:59from these results,
17:00not maybe a few things
17:02couldn't be true at once.
17:03Like, in terms of Labour's strategy
17:05going forward,
17:06I obviously do talk extensively
17:09about them getting off the fence
17:11and getting a coherent political strategy
17:14tacking towards reform voters
17:16or to Green voters.
17:18It's also possible
17:19you could try and dig out a few of both.
17:21But isn't that the thing?
17:22The magic that the Labour Party has,
17:24like it or not,
17:25is that they are actually able to govern.
17:27So everybody else can make
17:28a massive amount of noise,
17:29they can make all sorts of distraction.
17:32You and I spent a bit of time watching,
17:34there's a thing circulating on social media
17:36which has got the polling
17:38for party leaders back from the 70s
17:40and it's this nice little animation
17:41which I've watched
17:42an unhealthy amount of times.
17:44But one of the really striking things in it
17:46is that you can see
17:46that there are periods of time,
17:48particularly in the 1980s,
17:49say, when Margaret Thatcher
17:51was Prime Minister,
17:51where she was deeply unpopular
17:53and then was able to bounce back.
17:55So I think there might be a thing about,
17:56like, being unpopular by itself
17:58is not a problem
17:59as long as you are being unpopular
18:02with a purpose for a plan.
18:04So it goes back to the,
18:06are you, you know,
18:08it's not great losing elections for sure.
18:10This isn't the German election.
18:11There's still quite a way off
18:12until the German election.
18:14The Labour Party is in government
18:16and has the power and capacity
18:17to actually make things different for people
18:19in a way that,
18:21with the best will in the world,
18:22whichever council you're now in charge of,
18:24you don't really have that much power.
18:26So, you know,
18:27stepping slightly back
18:28from the personality bit of this,
18:30and I wonder whether this is partly
18:31where we haven't seen
18:32a leadership contender
18:33kind of come straight off the gates
18:35because the real question
18:36for the Labour Party
18:37is they were elected in 2024
18:39on a manifesto
18:40you could basically see through
18:41because they didn't want to say too much
18:43so that they could be elected
18:44because they could be the
18:45hope and change people.
18:48And then in practising governing terms,
18:49that's not what they've delivered,
18:51but actually they could do that tomorrow
18:53if they wanted to.
18:54And I wonder whether
18:55that's what we might see a bit,
18:57she says,
18:57because I do think that
18:59we've got a democracy problem
19:00if people keep on saying
19:02in all of the elections
19:04that we're having,
19:05I don't like this,
19:06it's not working for me,
19:07and then they get nothing back
19:08and then they say,
19:09I don't like this,
19:09I'm going to try this,
19:10that's not working for me.
19:11I do think whatever your politics are,
19:13we've got a broader problem
19:14where it matters that you vote
19:15and it makes a difference.
19:17And I'm sort of optimistic
19:19and hopeful that either
19:20we will get a change of leadership
19:21in the Labour Party
19:22because someone's going to come through
19:23and say,
19:24look, I've got this massive plan,
19:26this is what I'm doing,
19:26this is what the party's for,
19:27and Keir Starmer,
19:29you did a great job
19:29in winning the election
19:30but now it's my turn,
19:31maybe,
19:32or a kind of,
19:34this is what we are here for
19:35and we're going to start
19:35actually governing
19:36because they need to,
19:38not dance like no one's watching,
19:39but there is a kind of,
19:41just do some governing please.
19:43I've seen a few pollsters
19:44and commentators
19:45talking about the social contract
19:46and how that isn't working
19:47and basically that is,
19:49you know,
19:50you might be somewhere
19:51which is fairly deprived
19:52and you feel like
19:53there aren't opportunities
19:54and you've been promised
19:55all kinds of industry
19:56to return to your town
19:57and it hasn't
19:58and, you know,
19:59education isn't what it should be
20:01and you feel unequal
20:02compared to the rest of the country
20:05and actually,
20:06in some of the kind of
20:07more wealthy areas
20:08where there is more opportunity,
20:09there are tons of graduates
20:10living at home
20:11with their parents
20:12who can't afford houses,
20:13who can't get jobs,
20:15who can't afford holidays either
20:16so it's like,
20:17it's actually quite a universal message
20:20for people
20:21and it's,
20:21these are,
20:22exactly as you say,
20:23these are like
20:24quite straightforward things
20:25for the government
20:25to concentrate on,
20:27to have as your priorities,
20:28I mean,
20:28we have this umbrella
20:29of the cost of living crisis
20:30but in some ways
20:32that's too broad
20:32and they could just choose
20:34three or four
20:36really seismic important things
20:38to focus on,
20:38like driving up,
20:40even talking about growth
20:41I think is too vague for people,
20:43that's like,
20:44it was,
20:44you know,
20:44when Boris Johnson
20:45talked about levelling up,
20:46people thought,
20:47oh yeah,
20:47that sounds great
20:48because you can basically
20:49make it apply to anything
20:50and therefore apply to you.
20:52It was an amazing slogan that
20:53because everybody,
20:55it meant absolutely everything
20:56and absolutely nothing.
20:57I mean,
20:57just,
20:58I want people to know
20:58that the campaign strategist
21:00did not come up with that,
21:01he just,
21:02we didn't,
21:02we hated it
21:03and he just came up with it
21:05on a whim one day
21:06on the stump
21:06and then that's what happened,
21:09then it just came into being.
21:11And lo,
21:12I think there's an even,
21:12there's an act of parliament,
21:13there's an act of parliament
21:14for levelling up,
21:15I think.
21:16There you go,
21:17that's how it really works folks.
21:18Yeah,
21:19exactly,
21:19just literal brain farts
21:20come out of mouths.
21:21One of the things
21:22the Prime Minister said today
21:23in his sort of
21:25mea culpa statement
21:27was
21:29it's clear that people
21:31want their change
21:32to happen faster.
21:34So,
21:34his view is that
21:35they,
21:36you know,
21:36Labour got elected
21:37on a change mandate
21:38which was their slogan
21:39and that it needs
21:40to be happening faster.
21:41But of course,
21:42you know,
21:43if you look at some of the quotes
21:44coming out of focus groups,
21:45they're saying
21:45the toys were a disaster,
21:48Labour were a disaster
21:49in sort of fast motion.
21:52Where do you fall on that?
21:53I don't think it is
21:54that there has been
21:55a really strong programme
21:57of this is what
21:58this government
21:58is going to do
21:59and the problem
22:00is something that's taken,
22:02you know,
22:02has taken six months
22:03rather than three months
22:04or two years
22:05rather than one year.
22:06I think part of the problem
22:07is people can't see.
22:09People can't see the pattern
22:10and the plan
22:11and what is the change
22:13that's really going to happen.
22:14There's lots of talking about it
22:15but we were going to rewire the state.
22:17I can't see any rewiring being done.
22:20I mean,
22:21I would probably do
22:22some slightly more
22:22aggressive interventions
22:23than just a tiny bit of rewiring
22:25but you can't see
22:28the problem being
22:30we're just not going fast enough.
22:31You can see the problem much more
22:33as we don't know
22:34what we're trying,
22:35what you're here for,
22:36what you're trying to do
22:37and what you're trying to fix.
22:38It is entirely fair
22:40that the Labour government
22:41has also been very unlucky, right?
22:43I mean,
22:43sometimes governments are lucky,
22:44sometimes they're unlucky.
22:45They have inherited
22:46a really difficult situation.
22:48There have been,
22:49you know,
22:49more external things
22:50particularly the oil crisis
22:51that we're now in
22:52which is going to make it much harder
22:54but those are all reasons
22:55to demonstrate
22:56back to the population
22:57that voted for you
22:58that it's worth having you in charge
23:00because you are going to make a difference.
23:01So,
23:02I'm all for like
23:03go faster,
23:04go further,
23:05do it tomorrow
23:06and I think it's that
23:08urgency
23:08and trying to unpack
23:09the hesitation
23:10that is the thing
23:11that will make a difference
23:12if you want to see,
23:14unless you want to see
23:14exactly the same results
23:16which is effectively
23:17a none of the above election.
23:19I still,
23:19I think,
23:20of course,
23:21of course the people
23:22who have done well out of this
23:23are saying
23:23this is a massive ringing endorsement
23:25of our mandate.
23:27I'm not sure that it is.
23:28It feels to me like
23:29the same thing
23:30we've been living in for a while
23:31which is a massive
23:32up yours to you people,
23:34you're not doing anything for me
23:35and let's try this instead
23:37and that is,
23:38you know,
23:39applies to anybody
23:39who's doing well
23:40out of these elections,
23:41I think.
23:41So one of the bits
23:42of commentary
23:43that we've been following
23:44very closely today,
23:45Cleo,
23:45is people are now saying
23:46ooh,
23:47is Nigel Farage
23:48going to be
23:48our next Prime Minister?
23:49Cleo Watson,
23:50is Nigel Farage
23:51going to be
23:51our next Prime Minister?
23:52Oh God.
23:53You know,
23:53it really reminds me
23:54of that bit
23:54in the Italian job
23:55where they've got
23:56like the van
23:57teetering over the cliff
23:59and that's how it can be
24:01sometimes
24:02with this sort of commentary
24:03where they're like
24:04no,
24:05yes,
24:06and you're right,
24:07there have been a few
24:07like Nigel Farage
24:09will be
24:10the next Prime Minister.
24:11The next general election,
24:13you know,
24:14assuming something weird
24:15doesn't happen,
24:15it happens much sooner
24:16is three years away.
24:17So we are further
24:19from the next general election
24:21than we are from
24:22the most recent one
24:23and anything can happen.
24:25I think it is also
24:26just worth taking
24:27kind of calming breath
24:28and realising that
24:30obviously
24:30this is very seismic
24:32in Scotland and Wales
24:33but across
24:34large bits of England
24:36there were no
24:37local elections
24:38at all today
24:39and in fact
24:40some of the results
24:41today were only
24:42kind of for partial
24:43seats in councils
24:45and stuff like that.
24:46I think what it does show
24:48is that
24:49they've got a
24:50good campaigning machine
24:52and that their message
24:54has serious cut through
24:55and that they are
24:57probably doing
24:58a better job
24:59of understanding
25:00what lots of voters
25:02think and feel
25:05better than
25:06Labour at the moment.
25:08One thing I will say
25:09just on whether
25:10he and Reform
25:11have what it takes
25:12is I have wrangled
25:15in my previous life
25:17with quite a few
25:19members of his
25:20now I guess
25:21their front bench
25:22who are making up
25:23his kind of shadow team
25:24because they used to be
25:25Conservative MPs
25:27and I've not
25:29dealt with
25:30Nigel personally
25:31though I did once
25:32get stuck in a lift
25:32with him for a little bit
25:34but if you just look
25:35at the track record
25:36of the very many
25:37vehicles that he has
25:39been driving
25:40quite often there
25:41are kind of
25:42blow ups
25:43the teams fall out
25:45with each other
25:45they have massive
25:47disagreements
25:47there are big
25:48personalities involved
25:50three years is quite
25:51a long time
25:52for Reform
25:52to also hold
25:53themselves together
25:55and
25:56that actually
25:57does matter
25:59a bit
25:59you know
25:59in my experience
26:00the political projects
26:01I've been part of
26:02have held together
26:03or they've fallen apart
26:05really based on
26:06the kind of
26:06chemistry of
26:07different personalities
26:08and the idea
26:09that everyone's
26:09pulling in the same
26:10direction
26:10and it's been
26:12about a year
26:13since they had
26:13any major hiccups
26:15with people like
26:16Zee Yusuf leaving
26:17and then returning
26:19but I think it is
26:20worth pricing in
26:22that you know
26:23in these things
26:24character can be
26:25destiny
26:25personalities can be
26:27key
26:27and actually
26:28if it's a start-up
26:29or now a scale-up
26:30I suppose
26:31Reform
26:33all kinds of
26:34problems
26:35can kind of
26:36enter
26:36the bloodstream
26:38for them
26:39and
26:39it'll be
26:40really
26:40interesting
26:41to see
26:42in the next
26:42couple of
26:42years
26:43both how
26:44they end up
26:44governing
26:45some of the
26:46areas that
26:46they're now
26:47in charge of
26:47and you know
26:48in some of
26:48those places
26:49that they won
26:50last year
26:51they are making
26:52gains in
26:52so that seems
26:53a bit of a
26:54vote of confidence
26:54but
26:56I think
26:57that
26:57the
26:58scrutiny on him
27:00will increase
27:00the scrutiny
27:01on his team
27:02will increase
27:02and
27:03in some
27:04ways
27:05I think
27:06it's for
27:08the
27:09more
27:09interesting
27:10challenges
27:10for Labour
27:11and Conservatives
27:11to make
27:12themselves
27:12relevant
27:13again
27:13and
27:14for
27:15us
27:15to
27:15just
27:16not
27:16explode
27:17basically
27:17that's a really
27:18good point
27:19like it's
27:19perfectly
27:19possible
27:19for the
27:20mainstream
27:20parties
27:21to steal
27:21some of
27:22their
27:22clothes
27:22and
27:23speak
27:24and
27:24listen
27:24to
27:24their
27:24electorates
27:25in the
27:25same
27:25way
27:26I would
27:26say
27:27reform
27:27have
27:27got a
27:27very good
27:27colour
27:29so
27:32of all
27:32Nigel
27:33Farage's
27:34vehicles
27:35this
27:35is it
27:36cerulean
27:37I don't know
27:37what it is
27:38but they've
27:39sort of turquoise
27:40it has actually
27:41stood out more
27:42on this campaign
27:43so you know
27:45maybe that's
27:45the thing
27:46thanks so much
27:47for listening
27:47to this
27:48bonus episode
27:48we'll be back
27:49next Tuesday
27:50for our
27:50regular slot
27:51but in the
27:52meantime
27:52please do
27:53rate us
27:54and like us
27:54on your
27:55podcast player
27:55of choice
27:56you can follow
27:57us on
27:57instagram
27:57for all our
27:58best clips
27:59on
27:59at
27:59in
28:00the
28:00room
28:00dot
28:00pod
28:01and
28:01you can
28:02send
28:02your
28:02feedback
28:02always
28:03valued
28:03and
28:04questions
28:04to
28:05our
28:05new
28:05email
28:05which
28:06is
28:06in
28:07the
28:07room
28:07at
28:08independent
28:08dot
28:09co
28:09dot
28:09uk
28:09this
28:10podcast
28:10is
28:10part
28:11of
28:11the
28:11independent
28:11podcast
28:12network
28:12and is
28:13produced
28:13in
28:13association
28:14with
28:14next
28:14chapter
28:14studios
28:15thanks
28:15for
28:16listening
28:16we'll
28:16see you
28:17next
28:17time

Recommended