- 2 days ago
Episode 01: Buried Truths
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:08ETHICS POLICE
00:09Essex police, what's your emergency?
00:25Can I take his name then, please?
00:32ORCHESTRAL MUSIC
00:33ORCHESTRAL MUSIC
00:40Everybody know him from here.
00:43Everybody worrying.
00:45We check everybody, but he was not here.
00:52I'm not sure, but I think people see him like barista restaurant.
00:57What's the name of that barista restaurant?
00:59Yeah, and after that, nobody seen him.
01:29Yeah.
01:31OK.
01:34I was called last night to talk about a missing person, Jamali Turhan.
01:40He is a Turkish national, and Jamali's friends reported him missing
01:45at 8 o'clock on the Tuesday night,
01:47because they were really, really worried that something had happened.
01:55We started looking through CCTV to understand where Jamali had been.
02:00They've got Jamali and another person congregate around here somewhere.
02:05Then they walk off and appear to go up around the back barista.
02:10We then watched Jamali on the Monday night go into the barista bar,
02:15which was closed at the time with another male.
02:20A few hours later, we see the male leave the bar, but not Jamali.
02:29We think something had happened in the barista on Monday night,
02:34so we are now 36 hours behind.
02:41We now need to get officers into the barista.
02:47Police!
02:48Police!
02:49If you're in there, come out! Show them your hands!
02:55Police! Anyone in here? Come out! Show them your hands!
02:58Oh, the chair's broken.
03:03There is blood in there.
03:04Right, OK.
03:05By the bar, there's a mop bucket with blood on there.
03:07Speed across the walls, the corridor.
03:10Right, OK.
03:13We were expecting to find the body, but...
03:15We're going to go into that premises in a moment.
03:18So now we're going to slow time.
03:20We need to do this methodically,
03:21and with due regard for forensic evidence capture.
03:30Right.
03:41We're trying to see where the lights are.
03:48Is that better? Yeah.
03:50Yeah.
03:53Oh, there's an area over here, I think.
03:56There's blood on the floor just down there.
03:58You've got cards on the door here, Paul.
04:01Yeah.
04:02And this carries on to this chair.
04:04Yeah.
04:08Oh, there are. The floor.
04:10Yeah.
04:11This is covered.
04:12This has all been moved.
04:13That pepper pot is covered, and I think it was here,
04:15because you've got witness mark on it.
04:17This is saturated.
04:19There's some slight marks on the floor as well.
04:21Yeah.
04:22And on the television.
04:23Yeah, all across the telly.
04:25Ceiling?
04:26Oh, yeah, look at the ceiling.
04:35Have you heard that Barista is our murder scene?
04:38Oh, yeah.
04:39Blood everywhere.
04:40Yeah.
04:40Been open for two days.
04:42Been trading for two days.
04:43Can you imagine what people must think?
04:44If it's saying that that amount of blood is literally everywhere,
04:47they've had a fight, you know,
04:49have they used some sort of machete or a kebab-type knife?
04:54Yeah.
04:54Yeah.
04:55All right.
04:56Well, we're getting closer.
04:58I've got the times of the collection.
05:01So, we talk about golden hour policing, but we've lost that,
05:03so we are behind.
05:07We've got several crime scene investigators in the Barista.
05:11And it's just round the corner from the police station.
05:14But, um, still no body.
05:19We've also had a Romanian male come forward by the name of Illy.
05:26He was arrested a few hours later because he said that Chamali was dead
05:31and that he was involved in a clean-up in Barista.
05:36Can you ask the chap if he understands why he's been arrested today?
05:45Yeah.
05:57So, currently, we suspect he may be involved in the murder.
06:03Well, I need to follow, my colleague.
06:06Thank you, sir.
06:06All right.
06:07Have a nice day.
06:07Thank you, sir.
06:09And just sit here for me.
06:11Yep.
06:21My name is Ilia Ciprian Joseph.
06:24I burn in Romania.
06:27I received a phone call from Jay.
06:30Yep.
06:311, 2, 12.
06:34This was at night.
06:361 o'clock, 2 o'clock, 12 o'clock.
06:38I do not know exactly.
06:40I m-am pus încolo.
06:41So, I went there.
06:47M-am pus înăuntru.
06:49I went in.
06:51Sânge pe jos în cornea.
06:54Am văzut unul.
06:57Nu m-am dat seama că-i mort.
06:59Sânge ple că sânge pe tood.
07:01M-am pus încoe.
07:02I did notázic că ea stânăzatâ.
07:04M-am pus în canale în genunci.
07:12Sânge pe tood.
07:14Sânge pe tood.
07:20Sânge pă ...まあ
07:25căpă a- choc.
07:29Oh, and the broken chair.
07:31Right.
07:36It's absolutely saturated.
07:41Jesus, can you see how it is?
07:48And that is when he had a knife and he put the knife here at the back.
07:54He was pointing with his finger like this.
07:59He said that if I will not help him, you and your wife,
08:02he will end like that man the same way.
08:05That's what he said.
08:07I got scared.
08:09I was shaking.
08:13You can see he's really comfortable conversing with the police.
08:16He talks about he was with his wife and he got the phone call
08:20saying come and do some cleaning from a person called Jay.
08:25I received the phone call from Jay.
08:29Ili goes to meet him at the barista.
08:31And we've been able to identify Jay as Cheyhan Dinla.
08:36He is the manager of the barista.
08:44Cheyhan Dinla was born in Turkey.
08:46He's a Turkish national.
08:47He is known in the Turkish community in Chelmsford.
08:55Cheyhan is spelled C-E-Y-H-A-N.
09:00And with Turkish pronunciation, the C is a J.
09:03Which is why we think that Ili would have referred to him as Jay.
09:10I think Dinla killed Chamale.
09:13We now need to find him.
09:18It's still LEE.
09:23I grabbed the man by the hand.
09:27He grabbed him from the other side.
09:30The other side.
09:32And we put him in the bin.
09:34OK. OK.
09:37Are you OK? Happy to carry on?
09:41OK.
09:47I put the man in the rubbish.
09:51And where was this bin?
09:53It was behind the bar.
09:57The bar.
10:04Hello, Adam.
10:06Yep.
10:07Right.
10:08Thanks, then.
10:09OK, bye.
10:11Right, so our suspect, he helped put the victim in a bin outside the back.
10:23This is the bin outside.
10:27Are we ready for this?
10:29Yep.
10:42If I lift it up by a corner?
10:44Do you want me to do the other corner?
10:45Yeah, can you do two corners?
10:47Ready?
10:47Yep.
10:52This is some rubbish.
10:55This obviously hasn't been emptied because it's got...
10:57It's got stuff, isn't it?
10:58OK.
10:59Let's look at these ones over here.
11:03There's nothing in that either.
11:13From what we've been told from the witnesses we've spoken to,
11:16we believe the body's gone into one of the bins outside the back of the barista.
11:19There's a number of companies that collect different bins,
11:22such as trying to work out which bin is where and where they've gone to.
11:26In that alleyway, you've got a mixture of private and county council.
11:30Oh, I see, OK.
11:31Yeah.
11:32Number two is the food waste.
11:34So he could be in there as well, couldn't he?
11:36Yeah.
11:36OK.
11:37We need that footage now of bin collections outside the back of baristas.
11:41All right.
11:42Chasing bin lorries.
11:43Honestly, I'm losing my...
11:45I'm losing my marbles over bins.
11:53Right, OK, let's start at the beginning.
11:55So, we've got Ely, who's in custody,
11:59and Chehan Dinla, who's outstanding.
12:03Dinla was seen in company with our victim.
12:08So, do you want to come in with CCTV, Reuben?
12:11Right, OK.
12:11So, so far we've got a timeline of movement for the victim.
12:15He caught on the council CCTV camera on Rainsford Road heading towards the Globe,
12:21and he's alone at that point.
12:32We then know he arrives at the Globe pub.
12:36And, Leanne?
12:37Yeah?
12:37Are you able to quickly come over and just cover the footage at the Globe?
12:40Yeah.
12:41Um, the victim.
12:43He's seen to enter the pub.
12:50He obviously knows the mail.
12:52It's bald mail.
12:53Um, he's in the pub with him for a considerable amount of time.
12:59He's seen to go to the bar.
13:05He received a phone call.
13:07He takes the phone call.
13:08He walks outside.
13:18He's seen to stand by the road.
13:22Um, and then you see, um...
13:26Dinla.
13:26Yeah.
13:36They meet.
13:37They shake hands.
13:38They walk into the Globe.
13:46They walk straight to the bar.
13:56And they have, I wouldn't say heated, uh, discussion, but there's lots of hand gestures.
14:13And then I've got to the point where they shake hands.
14:20So, it looks like we can assume Dinla has called victim then, hasn't he?
14:25And they've met at the pub, possibly had a discussion, and Dinla's maybe said,
14:30I don't worry about it, mate.
14:31We're all good.
14:33OK.
14:34Yeah, four calls to victim from suspect.
14:37Four calls to victim from suspect.
14:40OK.
14:43Effectively, they leave together.
14:45The suspect and the victim then continue along Jude Street towards barista.
14:52So, he wanted to take him into the barista when the bar is closed?
14:58Yeah.
14:59OK.
15:02What we're able to now say is Chehan Dinla was the last proof of life.
15:09Um, Tara, is it good to bring you in?
15:11Because I know you've been working on the location of Dinla.
15:14Yeah.
15:14So, we've just got data back from Stidla's mobile number.
15:18Um, by having a look at it, he was in Statstead airport yesterday at 22.02.
15:25And there's an account from a taxi driver that he's taken him to Stanstead.
15:29How interesting.
15:32How interesting.
15:53We're now getting attack mobile event data, which means that he's abroad.
16:00So, we are trying to get the location of that.
16:03Alan, you had your hand up just then.
16:06Yeah.
16:07Hi, Mum.
16:08He scans into Stanstead around nine o'clock on the 19th for a flight to Istanbul.
16:15OK.
16:16So, that potentially shows that Dinla has gone to Turkey.
16:29And the sergeants, I suggest, we crack on in the morning and then meet later in the day.
16:33Right.
16:34Thank you, everyone.
16:46Essex police are continuing to question a 44-year-old man on suspicion of murder.
16:51Following the disappearance of Jamali Turhan earlier this week,
16:54police inquiries are focusing on several locations in the city,
16:58including in Duke Street and around the Barista Bar.
17:02We are 27 hours into my part of the investigation.
17:07But the murder happened early hours of Tuesday morning.
17:12So, we are now Thursday.
17:13So, we're considerably sprinting to catch up.
17:17For a usual homicide, I would probably look to brief 30.
17:21But yesterday, I briefed 70.
17:24There's a side door there to the kitchen.
17:27We've got the barista, where we now know the murder happened.
17:31Suspect number one, Ili, is in custody.
17:34Suspect number two is Dinla.
17:36He fled the country Tuesday evening.
17:40He flew to Istanbul and I haven't tracked him further.
17:45But we can't find Jamali.
17:47We don't know where his body is.
17:50So, we've got a sister and a nephew in Turkey that we want to reach out to.
17:55We've managed to establish his sister's details.
18:00So, Jamali has got family in Turkey, but they do only speak Turkish.
18:04So, it's not been the quickest and simplest thing to do.
18:08The impression that I've gleaned from speaking to family members is that Jamali was a very loved person,
18:16certainly from his sister who brought him up.
18:19And we also have managed to track down an ex-partner, who's called Brittany.
18:25It's been a very big shock to her.
18:27So, we have to speak to Brittany.
18:31Am I all right with my shoes on?
18:33Yeah, that's fine. I'll take a seat.
18:37So, my reason for being here today is to basically go through who Jamali was to you,
18:45how you knew him, any knowledge that you have in sort of like the lead up to him going missing.
18:51I think you'll point us in the right direction.
18:53Yeah.
18:54When was the last time you saw him?
18:56I was meant to see him the day that he went missing.
19:01But I wasn't feeling well, so I cancelled.
19:05He FaceTimed our little girl about five o'clock that day.
19:09And he seemed in a really good mood.
19:14And he was like, I can't wait to see you again soon.
19:17And I said, we'll see you next week.
19:20Yeah.
19:26We met in early 2020 on a dating site.
19:32And he would come round and we would cook dinner together.
19:37We would watch TV together.
19:41So, to me, I saw a really caring side of him.
19:44But I think a lot of other people would know the side probably of at the pub when he was
19:50drinking.
19:51And he was very charming.
19:54He always had a bit of a wandering eye.
19:58He didn't know when enough was enough.
20:01You've got that experience of him.
20:05From my understanding, there's been a few things that have gone on in the relationship.
20:08Yeah.
20:10Everything changed after our twins were born.
20:15Our little boy passed away.
20:18And he struggled with the loss really, really badly.
20:24He was drinking heavily all the time.
20:26He was angry.
20:28He wanted someone to blame.
20:32That was kind of the beginning of the end of our relationship, really.
20:40How's your daughter doing?
20:42I mean, because I noticed that you've got your pictures.
20:45She's very young and luckily she doesn't really understand what's happened.
20:51It upsets me because I think she was his little princess.
20:56She just melted him.
21:01He texted me before he went missing and he said,
21:04I'm sorry for everything.
21:06I'm sorry that I failed my family.
21:10That's a message I think I read over and over.
21:19She's an amazing strong lady considering all the circumstances
21:23and what she's having to face and going through everything there.
21:27I think going forward, I'll be there to support her
21:30and just taking it one day at a time at the moment.
21:39When Ili was arrested, I was watching the interview
21:43and there was a bit of context brought up from Ili
21:47about why this may have happened.
21:49He said that he deserved it
21:53because he did something in the past.
21:58He tried to steal his wife or I do not know.
22:04It appears that Chamali and Dinla were friendly at some point
22:08and it's believed that Chamali may have had an affair
22:12with Dinla's girlfriend.
22:14So it appears that this is the reason why this has happened.
22:20Someone's rung up saying that in July time,
22:23they heard the suspect say to Chamali to end,
22:26I'll kill you over this relationship.
22:32What we understand from the witnesses is that Dinla
22:36starts in a relationship with this woman
22:38and I think she goes between the two,
22:42which I don't think Chamali really cared.
22:45With Dinla, I think it was more.
22:50People describe Dinla as being quite possessive
22:52when he had a girlfriend.
22:58As far as he's concerned, that was his woman.
23:25So, we've got one here.
23:27This has got quite a bit of food in a minute.
23:29We'll have to document that.
23:32Syndrome's fingerprinting blood that is.
23:33And there's quite a large section of palm in there,
23:36again in blood.
23:37It could all be our suspects printing our victim's blood.
23:46We know fingerprints, they are unique to you.
23:48There's no one else in the world that's got your fingerprints.
23:55So we're sending those across to our fingerprint hub
23:57to see if they can identify them.
23:59We're expecting it to be the suspect's finger mark
24:02in the victim's blood.
24:04So that's why it's highly significant.
24:11Dinla was the manager of Barista
24:13and he would know when the bins were collected.
24:16I'm just trying to think like Dinla.
24:18Did he organise that day that it would be the day
24:20he decided to go for a drink with his arch rival
24:23and then brought him back to Barista
24:25when he knew he would be alone with him to kill him.
24:28And, oh goodness, the bins go the next morning.
24:44Here they are.
24:45So the guy on the left here is the guy
24:47that we've already got in custody.
24:48That's about seven hours after the incident.
24:51He's returned to the scene of the crime
24:52and seems to be explaining to this unknown male
24:54essentially what's happened there.
24:58He's basically doing a stabbing motion to the neck
25:01as they then walk into exactly where the incident's
25:05actually taken place.
25:09He initially said he didn't see the attack,
25:11he just saw the body.
25:13But that stabbing to the neck would be consistent
25:16with what forensics is showing.
25:19So, obviously, a great interest to us.
25:25If you were to read it that he has seen it,
25:28it's completely blowing what he has set apart.
25:33Did you stab the victim?
25:34No.
25:35No.
25:36No?
25:37No.
25:38I wasn't there.
25:39I wasn't there.
25:41I arrived after.
25:42I don't know what happened.
25:44I do not know what happened.
25:45They fought with him.
25:46They fought with him.
25:46Or shouted.
25:47I don't know.
25:48OK.
25:52In his interview, he kept on bringing up
25:55that the only reason he did the actions he did
25:59was out of fear for himself,
26:00out of fear for his girlfriend.
26:02It's certainly a viable defence.
26:05However, we located some further CCTV.
26:11And around about 3 o'clock in the morning,
26:14Illy leaves barista.
26:20He goes home for two hours.
26:23Dinner then calls him back,
26:24and he comes back voluntarily.
26:29So there's numerous opportunities for Illy
26:31to get out of that situation.
26:35One thing has been confusing me a little bit.
26:38Yes.
26:38Why not just call the police?
26:51The police station is a minute walk from barista.
26:55Which very much weakens his defence, in our opinion.
27:10With regards to Illy being involved in this homicide,
27:14I have to determine whether, at a point,
27:16we have enough evidence that we can go to CPS.
27:19So that's what we're typing up at the moment.
27:20Put it above that bit, this waist.
27:22OK.
27:23So I will send that summary of evidence to CPS.
27:26It will take several hours for CPS to review everything,
27:29and then come up with a decision.
27:33So we're going for murder, conspiracy to murder,
27:36assist offender, and prevent the law for burial.
27:41The advice file has been completed,
27:43and now we're seeking a charging decision
27:46from the Crown Prosecution Service
27:47with regards to the suspect in custody.
27:50And we just wait dead and come back to us,
27:52which we hope won't be too long into the evening.
28:12All the forensic parts of the scene have been done over the last 72 hours.
28:17So today, I'm finally able to go through the scene
28:20to check that Stuart and myself are happy with the evidence that's in there.
28:27The decision was made about 9 o'clock last night
28:29by the Crown Prosecution Service
28:30that Illy would be charged with assisting an offender
28:35for the offence of murder and prevention of a lawful burial of a dead body.
28:42A huge milestone for us.
28:44Thank goodness we've got the Crown Prosecution Service saying
28:47we believe that Illy has been part of that process.
28:56So which way do we think they came in on the side door, then sat here?
29:00Through the front, I think.
29:01Or they did come in through the front door?
29:03It's probably sitting, I imagine, at that table.
29:06What, the tall table?
29:07Yeah. You think how close we are to the front.
29:09Bear in mind those screens wouldn't be there.
29:11I just struggle that people have been drinking, socialising,
29:16and no-one has thought,
29:17oh my goodness, what all this bloody...
29:18There's no way you would never be able to see it.
29:20Absolutely bizarre.
29:21Maybe my standards are far too high.
29:25The hypothesis is that he's been attacked into a pressurised vessel
29:30because there's blood directly onto the ceiling.
29:32Yeah, oh gosh, yeah.
29:34That would be consistent, I imagine,
29:35with some sort of thing around the neck.
29:37Yeah.
29:37And then he's probably gone down sort of fairly quickly.
29:41We think the victim's probably succumbed to his injury,
29:43he's gone down low, but he's still under pressure
29:45and then we've got blood under that table.
29:47Oh, look there.
29:48So, the finger marks underneath,
29:51you've been identified to Dinla.
29:53Excellent.
29:58I'm as content as we can be, this is the bin.
30:02And actually there is blood in the interior of it.
30:05Oh, all down there? Yeah.
30:08We've looked in the bottom and there's not a great big pool of blood
30:12that you may expect.
30:14So, we're assuming he's probably on something else.
30:18I think they wrapped him in something.
30:20Yes.
30:21It's really brazen.
30:23I mean, look at all these houses that are looking out.
30:26Yeah, yeah.
30:26Just bringing body out.
30:37We know the wheelie bin that Jamali was deposited in.
30:40We know that that bin was emptied by a council dump truck.
30:46And it would appear that that is now in landfill.
31:17So, I just got back from being at the landfill.
31:19Just to kind of see what this would actually look like
31:21if we were then to start kind of going through it.
31:25You're essentially looking at having two excavators
31:27just sifting through the stuff.
31:29And then obviously the pulse tube would go through.
31:31There's still a really, really low chance of actually finding anything
31:34because what they also pointed out was the lorries that collect the wheelie bins
31:37do have blades internally that do kind of macerate to a degree
31:41whatever goes in to compress it.
31:44Yeah, okay.
31:45That also requires CSI kind of being there just in case they find parts
31:48potentially anthropologists because there's going to be all sorts of
31:51organic material and bones and bits and pieces.
31:53So, this could take months.
31:55We could be two, three months down the line still having not cleared that
31:58whole area.
32:00So, there's going to be significant cost.
32:02Exactly that, Nick.
32:03And, Si, I'm sure you'll want to come in at this point to talk about what that
32:07will look like from a PULSA perspective.
32:10Yeah.
32:11As an initial ballpark figures for four weeks and I've done it at seven days a week,
32:16we're looking at about £110,000.
32:19That doesn't include the specialist equipment included.
32:23It doesn't include CSIs, anthropologists and everything else that comes with it.
32:27So, that's a very low ballpark figure just for officer hours.
32:33Yeah, understood.
32:34And there's no guarantees at the end of it either.
32:36I know.
32:37I know.
32:37Which is why we need to be proportionate, but it's the right thing to do because we've
32:41got nobody to bring back to the loved ones.
32:46The buck stops with me for the decisions, but I'm really fortunate that I get the support
32:51of my senior officers.
32:53But with that comes a promise from me that I'll deliver.
33:17We're at the final stages of the process.
33:19So, we had our Essex Police search team and there was a bin which apparently was behind
33:25the bar and it was the last actual thing they were going to search.
33:30They started to remove rubbish and got right to the bottom of the bin and they've seen
33:34apparently a human penis in the bottom of the bin.
33:41So, we're now just going to go in and have a look.
34:00Right.
34:01So, we've got quite a lot of blood-stained howling.
34:03Yeah.
34:03Let's have a look in the bin there.
34:11Oh, I see down here.
34:12Yeah.
34:12Right.
34:13Okay.
34:14Yeah.
34:14Good spot.
34:15Wow.
34:28Okay.
34:29Yep.
34:34Well done.
34:36There's some blood vessels there so we'll be able to get a swab for that hopefully.
34:41Ultimately, we need to establish this is our victim, don't we?
34:45Yep.
34:46Shocked to say the least finding that, hey?
34:48Yes.
34:49Yeah.
34:50It's not a nice job unfortunately, guys.
34:54Hello, Louise.
34:56So, Matt and Craig were searching a bin behind the bar.
35:00They've got about two thirds down and we found a human penis.
35:06They've removed various layers of rubbish and we're just going to now start putting that
35:09out so we can see where else is in there.
35:12There's also bottles and wine bottles and things like that being put on top as well.
35:17So, I'm guessing it's just the bin that they use behind the bar and the staff just put stuff on
35:22top.
35:25I was a copper before and I did 30 years.
35:28You think you've seen everything but actually you haven't.
35:31It's bad enough someone being murdered but actually the dismemberment as well.
35:36Yeah.
35:37Terrible.
35:48Yeah.
35:50So, we've got a homicide investigation in Chelmsford but we don't have a body.
35:56But what we do have now is a body part.
36:01So, a discovery has been made.
36:03I've never been in a case where I've had a penis that's been said that that's quite unusual.
36:09Certainly what I wasn't expecting on a Saturday afternoon.
36:18It fries my brain that someone could act so calmly and normally yet then carry out such a frenzied, horrific
36:28attack.
36:31I think we've got another piece.
36:33We'll just get a torch.
36:39Yeah, it is, isn't it?
36:41I'm hoping it's not part of a finger.
36:44Big.
36:44Do you think it could be a testicle?
36:48It's potentially one of the testicles.
36:58They found the penis initially and then next they found the testicle.
37:02I'll get in touch with CPS and I'll make them aware of obviously that we've got body parts.
37:07Yeah, because they won't know.
37:08They won't be aware of that.
37:10Effectively, we'll run a post-mortem on these parts to understand what they are, i.e. how many testicles I've
37:16got.
37:17How they were removed from the body.
37:19Yeah, how they were sedated, yeah.
37:20Also post-mortem or anti-mortem.
37:22So that's what the plan is this afternoon.
37:24So that's what I'll go straight into.
37:27If the body parts were taken off after death, that tells me that I have a dead body.
37:34So that helps me because I still don't have a body for the homicide.
37:38If the body parts were taken off before life was extinct, then we're looking at significant brutality and torture, ultimately.
37:55We already know our victim had relations with our suspect's previous girlfriend,
38:01which could be the reason why.
38:05But for someone to actually do those acts is absolutely barbaric.
38:23I just need a minute.
38:30The problem with my role is I'm there and I've got all the people underneath me.
38:35And then I've got all the people level with me that want to know.
38:37And I've got all the people above me that want to know too.
38:40And the weekend is always a bit challenging because I don't have the top cover.
38:44I had to brief up, across and down, as well as doing my job, which is fun.
38:55I'm not even entirely sure what day we're on.
38:58It's just been a long slog.
39:04I've been five days where I've done in excess of 14 hours a day.
39:09I think the first day was 17 hours.
39:12That's not a normal day, but it's not unusual for an investigation.
39:19I always wanted to be a detective, and I revel in a bit of pressure.
39:24But you're the first one in, the last one home, and they are long days.
39:30So you do sacrifice your sleep and your sanity sometimes,
39:34but, you know, it's worth it for the convictions.
39:38You do invest a lot of time and effort.
39:41It doesn't matter if you're the Prime Minister's son or the loneliest of low,
39:46you'll still get exactly the same effort.
39:49It's not a nine-to-five job.
39:51But it's all playing our part to try and get to the end result.
40:16CHIRPING
40:16Morning, all. Thank you for coming. Much appreciated.
40:18I know most of you probably didn't have too much choice,
40:22and I apologise for that.
40:24Today is not a nice task.
40:27We're going to a landfill site.
40:29The good news is I have a really good idea
40:32what part of the landfill site that our victim is at.
40:37The bad news is it's within an area about 5,000 square metres,
40:42so there's a little bit of work to do.
40:49Many landfills have been searched by many police forces before
40:53for long periods of time with not a great deal of success.
40:58It's a needle in a haystack.
41:01We are looking for a human body or limbs, arms, legs, head, torso,
41:09something along those sort of lines.
41:20OK, good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us today.
41:24Our specialist teams have been working day and night
41:27to build a picture of the circumstances leading up to Jamali's disappearance,
41:31and this activity will now involve a detailed search
41:35of part of a landfill site in Essex.
41:44We understand that this investigation will be very concerning
41:47for the local community in Chelmsford.
41:51There is a missing man at the heart of this investigation,
41:54and we're committed to finding answers for Jamali's family.
41:59A search of a landfill site in North Essex is now underway
42:02in connection with the disappearance of a 45-year-old man in Chelmsford.
42:06A search of a landfill site in North Essex is now underway.
42:16Oh, my word. This is extreme.
42:26The smell is immense, and it hits you as you get out of the vehicle.
42:35Once all the waste is laid out on the floor, our licensed search officers go in a line,
42:40and they'll all come forward together as they're searching through the waste,
42:44looking for our victim, for the clothing, for the knife.
42:48The cycle then starts again with another pile of waste coming through.
42:56It's these guys that I feel really sorry for.
42:59As they go through the waste, it invigorates the smell when it increases.
43:10The threshold for evidence is very high.
43:13By the time you get to court, you've got to have beyond reasonable doubt.
43:17If you have a murder case with no body, then that's a big stumbling block.
43:29I really feel the pressure because I'm now fully aware that I have all eyes
43:34of the investigation team looking at me to find this body.
43:53Can you hear me online?
43:54Yes, ma'am.
43:55All right, okay, listen up.
43:57Let me give you an update on the body parts.
44:00So, um, we have a penis and we have a tongue.
44:06So, not what we expected, uh, but it starts to lead more towards torture type killing.
44:16So, it looks like there was a clean cut on the tongue, but a bruise at the very end
44:20that would suggest it was pulled out to chop it.
44:23And the bruise was definitely happened when he was alive.
44:27So, the tongue was pulled out when he was alive.
44:29So, we can only assume the tongue was then chopped when he was alive,
44:32but we're doing a bit of histology on that because the way that...
44:35Why would you pull his tongue out and cut it off?
44:38He's gone to an extreme in this case.
44:41He doesn't just stab this person, whether that's once, twice or multiple times.
44:45He's then, you know, if it's pre-death, he's caused excruciating pain to this person,
44:52torturing them.
44:54And even if he's done it post-death, to do that in some sort of humiliation,
44:58it's just completely irrational behaviour.
45:09It reinforces the motive that we're looking at, that it is one of revenge,
45:13but at the end of the day, you know, there is no reason
45:16that torture descalate that far.
45:22I think what I find most chilling is that less than 24 hours after,
45:27he was at Stansted Airport with his passport, on a plane, next to strangers,
45:34just going about his business, I think that's what I find so, yeah, so tough.
45:42Europe is just slightly different, obviously, than Turkey,
45:45so I don't know what agreements are in place.
45:47We know he's abroad, we know he's in Turkey from the inquiries we've done.
45:50He's out as wanted, but at the moment, we can't press that button to go and arrest him,
45:55really, until we've got the yes from CPS.
45:57So we are doing everything possible to investigate it,
46:01and doing everything possible to find the body.
46:02MUSIC PLAYS
46:25Morning, all.
46:26I shall just introduce ma'am Metcalfe, who is the SIO for the investigation.
46:31Mum, thank you.
46:32Morning.
46:33So the investigation that I've got in the minute,
46:35I've got a murder in Chelmsford.
46:39I've got no body.
46:40I've got a bit of blood.
46:42And I've got someone in custody
46:43because they admitted to cleaning up.
46:45So we're not in a great place.
46:47So that's why you're here
46:48and that's why it's so important to find that body.
46:52I genuinely...
46:53Sorry, I'm tired.
46:54I genuinely am coming here because it's really...
46:58I'm so sorry.
46:59You can imagine I'm absolutely hanging out my arse.
47:01So it's not lost on me
47:05what you're going to look for
47:07and what you're searching for,
47:08but can I just make it really clear
47:11that don't let it be lost on you
47:13how important it is to find it.
47:21It's going to cost us
47:22in excess of £120,000 a week
47:25to keep this search going.
47:27That's not including your wages.
47:29So kind of double that
47:31and then some.
47:32So Sai and I are under incredible pressure.
47:36So, yeah, just eyes.
47:37All I want is your eyes
47:38and your cooperation.
47:41I'm quite sure there's nothing else I can say
47:42other than thank you, genuinely.
47:47Thank you, Ron.
47:49If everyone's happy, we'll get the buses.
47:52You're looking at the dishes of Jerusalem,
47:54Don't be afraid.
47:55This isSchangaham,
48:02I don't know that you are podem to do it.
48:06You're the only one who lets Marvel do it.
48:06Do you know themselves?
48:06Are you grain of water?
48:11Do you know yourself?
48:13Do you know yourself?
48:14Do you know yourself?
48:15Are you fatty?
48:19Do you know yourself?
48:20Do you know yourself?
48:20I'm happy with my parents,
48:27The area that we're searching is roughly the size of a football pitch.
48:30We've done one metre down on the flat surface and now we're going across the slope.
48:35I think that it's going really well, I think we're making really good progress,
48:38but how long it's going to take us is how long it's going to be string really.
48:43Another bone, so we'll just put it in the trine and then we'll get them looked at.
48:51Our anthropologist, Nicole, is taking some photos of the bones that we've identified up until now.
48:56When we saw these we got really excited, but then we realised that they were plastic.
49:00I know, they're all plastic.
49:05It's just frustrating, isn't it, to have covered such a vast area and still not found them yet?
49:12Yeah.
49:13But we will, otherwise all of this is just a waste of time, isn't it?
49:18I can't comprehend that myself.
49:19Yeah.
49:21He is here and we are going to find him.
49:32It's the 18th of December today.
49:34The site is closing down on Christmas Day and Boxing Day.
49:37And on the 27th of December, we'll be back and we'll continue what we do.
49:43If this was a member of my family, I'd like to think that the police would do everything in their
49:47power to find them and give them the resting place that they quite rightly deserve.
49:51And each day, that's what keeps me going.
50:11We've been searching through Christmas and we can't find Chamali.
50:20The pressure of trying to find the body and all the money that we are spending is a pressure that
50:25I put on myself.
50:27I just need a bit of luck.
50:55I just need a bit of luck.
50:56I just need a bit of luck.
51:15How are you doing?
51:16Yes, good.
51:17He's all bagged up.
51:18So he's all in one piece.
51:19Yes.
51:19Oh, OK.
51:21As soon as I saw a foot hanging out, 100%, no doubt in my mind as to what it was.
51:27I can't describe it.
51:28Every emotion in the world.
51:29This is what we've done it for, for 45 days and here we are.
51:35The experts all told us, yeah, you won't find a body.
51:37Yeah, they did.
51:38Every second sentence, yeah, you won't find a body.
51:40But we did find him.
51:45I want to be celebrated and happy and ecstatic.
51:49But we found a body.
51:50Yeah, yeah.
51:51It's a grim recovery and everything else, isn't it?
51:56Well, I suppose, like, Jamali is now able to go home.
51:59Yep.
52:01Oh, my God.
52:02I'm getting really emotional.
52:03Stop it, because you'll get me going.
52:04Stop it.
52:04I'm not doing it.
52:05I'm not doing it.
52:07But thanks to what you have done...
52:15Sorry.
52:16Done it, haven't we?
52:17Done it.
52:22Yeah.
52:30The search team have searched around 1,500 to 1,600 tonnes of rubbish, which is the
52:36equivalent of, I understand, about 550 double-deck buses.
52:39So it's a massive team effort.
52:48Seems to have an injury around the cheek, neck.
52:51Under his jaw, it looks almost.
52:53Yeah.
52:54Possibly one on the neck.
52:56That's certainly the right area for the blood spar, isn't it?
53:06We've got an identifiable tattoo that we already knew Jamali had that we've matched on the body.
53:12I'm really confident that he is who we're looking for.
53:25He'll now be travelling to Chelmsford Mortary, and the post-mortem will be tomorrow morning.
53:32He'll be w험, I tell ya, I'll be right back.
53:35I'm going to move on to the next day.
53:41I'm going to move on to the next day.
53:53I'm going to move on to the next day.
53:59Yes.
54:00Next day, you're going to move.
54:19He's got to answer for what he's done to Chamalee, so I'm making a real storm out of this.
54:24Our focus now will be to locate Dinla.
54:30I want justice for the family.
54:39Put it down for Daddy.
54:41Good girl.
54:42That's beautiful.
54:44He's going to love that, isn't he?
54:45Yeah.
54:46Who's this in this picture?
54:48Daddy.
54:49Daddy, and it says, you are missed each and every day for you were someone special who meant more than
54:57words can say.
54:58Because we miss Daddy every day, don't we?
55:00Yeah.
55:04I just don't understand how someone could do that to somebody, another human being, you know, how am I supposed
55:09to tell my little girl one day that someone took her Daddy away and threw him in the bin like
55:15he was nothing?
55:20What do you want to say to Daddy?
55:22I think I love you two.
55:25Actually, I love you lots.
55:27You love him lots?
55:29Yeah.
55:30He's watching you every day, isn't he?
55:32Yeah.
55:33He's up in the sky in heaven.
55:36He's up in the sky in heaven.
55:37Yeah.
55:39Yeah.
Comments