Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 5 days ago
The Atlanta Constitution’s same-day report on the arrest of Arthur Mullinax while leaving his sweetheart’s home. Police acted on testimony that he was seen with Mary Phagan heading toward the pencil factory near midnight. Mullinax passed a tough third-degree exam, claiming he barely knew the girl and was home early Saturday night.
The Atlanta Constitution – Monday, April 28, 1913
Support the truth: Get the second revised edition of Mary Phagan-Kean’s book, The Murder of Little Mary Phagan (2025 edition). Available on Amazon or directly at www.littlemaryphagan.com. Proceeds fund a documentary honoring Little Mary. First edition free download on the site.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Mullinax held in Fagan Case, Atlanta Constitution, Monday, April 28, 1913.
00:07Page 1. Former streetcar conductor arrested as he leaves the home of his sweetheart on Bellwood
00:12Avenue. As he was leaving the home of his sweetheart, Miss Pearl Robertson, on Bellwood
00:17Avenue early last night, Arthur Mullinax, a strikingly handsome youth, was arrested by
00:21Detective Rosser and carried to police headquarters. He is being detained under
00:26suspicion of having been implicated in the slaying of Mary Fagan. E.R. Sentell, a resident
00:32of 82 Davis Street, came to the office of Detective Chief Lanford Sunday afternoon, and was closeted
00:38with that official for considerable while. When he left the office it was learned that
00:42he had told the chief he had seen Mullinax and the dead girl together shortly after midnight
00:46Sunday. Sentell's story, according to the detectives, was that as he was walking along Forsyth Street
00:52about 12.30 o'clock Sunday morning, he encountered Mullinax and Miss Fagan walking slowly across
00:58Hunter Street in the direction of the pencil factory in which she was killed. He recognized
01:03both, he said, as they crossed under the street lamps. Mullinax given third degree. Chief Lanford
01:08also declares that he has other information to the effect that Mullinax was seen with Miss
01:13Fagan in the vicinity of the National Factory near midnight. Mullinax was brought immediately
01:17to headquarters, and at nine o'clock was subjected to a rigid third degree in the office of Chief
01:22Lanford. First he was quizzed by the detective chief by Chief Beavers, then by a number of detectives
01:28acquainted with the mysterious tragedy. He told a straightforward story throughout, however,
01:33maintaining that he had spent the early part of Saturday night in company with Miss Robertson,
01:38the woman whose home he had just left when arrested, and that they had come uptown to a theatre.
01:43He and Miss Robertson returned to her home before 10.30 o'clock, he declared, following which time
01:48he went to his boarding place at 60 Poplar Street, retiring for the night. He knew nothing of the
01:54murder, he asserted, until reading of it in the Constitution's extra Sunday morning. He also stoutly
02:00maintained that he was not intimately acquainted with the dead girl, that he had never been introduced
02:05to her, and had spoken to her only once during his life. Several words missing who talked with him
02:10at police station, Mullinax told a story coinciding with the one he told the detectives. He had not
02:16been uptown after 10.30 o'clock Saturday night, he said, but upon leaving the home of Miss Robertson,
02:22he had gone to his own residence. She was Sleeping Beauty. The only time he had ever been in Miss
02:28Fagan's
02:28company, he stated, was last Christmas, when she played a role in a holiday entertainment given in
02:33the Jefferson Street Church on Jefferson Street. He also took part in the performance. The girl played
02:39Sleeping Beauty. He was favorably impressed with her looks. She was a judge, the most beautiful girl
02:44of the neighborhood, and was a favorite among her friends. I couldn't keep my eyes off her,
02:49he said. She noticed it, and while I was standing near her, she remarked that I looked good with my
02:54face blacked. I played a blackface part. I turned to her and replied that I'd keep my face blacked all
03:00the time then. That was all we said. I was never with her after that. Mullinax is an ex-streetcar
03:06conductor. He was working as substitute conductor on the English Avenue Beltline, which traverses the
03:11part of town in which the slain girl lived with her parents. Detectives aver that they have evidence
03:16to the effect that he was well acquainted with Miss Fagan, and that they were good friends during
03:21his streetcar career. Also, that they were often seen talking together as she would have been
Comments

Recommended