Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 5 hours ago

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00now the next case all parties in the matter of kelly versus mcmillan step forward karen kelly
00:05and her 16 year old granddaughter kiana are suing kiana's ex-boyfriend 19 year old tyler
00:12mcmillan for breaking her brand new ipod mr mcmillan this case is about a broken ipod
00:19that belonged to this young lady the ipod cost i don't know something like 173 dollars to fix
00:26she says that it's your fault that it broke you acknowledge that you were at least in the area
00:32when that happened but you said it's not your fault no ma'am okay so let me start with you
00:40in as much as you acknowledge that you were present when the ipod broke yes ma'am and at that
00:47time you
00:48and this young lady were no longer a couple correct no ma'am oh yes ma'am sorry you were
00:55not a couple
00:56no okay so now tell me what happened um me and some friends were at the complex park
01:01and i seen a sock in her pocket a sock yes ma'am what color was the sock i think
01:09it had um like
01:11decals on it or like a design i'm not sure the color and it was hanging out of which pocket
01:16pants pocket
01:17um i'm pretty sure it was the jacket the right jacket pocket so you saw her with a sock hanging
01:22out of her pocket her jacket pocket yes ma'am go and i asked if i could play a song
01:27or two
01:28and on a sock all right i asked if it was her new ipod and she replied yes well why
01:35would you think
01:36that a sock housed an ipod i've used a sock as a case for my ipod as well oh okay
01:43so that's what
01:43kids do i guess so so you used a sock for your ipod so since this was a decal sock
01:49and she looks like
01:50a young lady that's pretty put together she wouldn't have a sock hanging out of her jacket
01:55pocket unless it contained an ipod right so you asked if you could play a tune on it yes ma
02:03'am and
02:03when you asked her if you could play a tune on her ipod what did she say she didn't say
02:09anything
02:09she didn't say yes and she didn't say no no ma'am before she could really react i kind of
02:15lean towards
02:15the ipod or the sock how do you lean towards the ipod mean like this with your hands behind your
02:22back no ma'am well where were your hands let me see your ipod like this yeah i mean i
02:27play a song
02:27on it and she jolted back and it fell out of her pocket and broke on the ground well it
02:33wouldn't
02:33have jilted out of her pocket as you indicated unless you had your hand on the sock no ma'am
02:39no ma'am
02:40what my hand was not on the sock it never touched the sock it was hanging out of her ipod
02:46or out of
02:46her pocket and as when she jumped back it fell out judge judy continues in a moment want justice
02:57go to judge judy.com or call 1-888-800-JUDY go ahead okay so me and a few of
03:05my friends listen
03:06please i can't hear this english speak louder i'm sorry me and a few friends were
03:15your friends go first oh my friends and i sorry my friends and i were at the apartment complex park
03:25and tyler came up to me and he pulled the sock without asking out of my jacket pocket that's
03:31exactly right out of my jacket pocket that's right and it fell out and it landed screen first
03:36on the sidewalk and i started crying because i just got that three weeks prior it's fixed now
03:44do you want me to unlock it here's the broken piece as well oh it's like you saved the broken
03:47pieces they gave it to me the repair shop when i had it repaired i have the receipts for that
03:52as well and the receipt please thank you you must have pulled on it pretty hard no ma'am
04:10just for my own information sir what did you say to her when it broke i apologize what did you
04:17say
04:17you said i'm sorry yeah and what did she say she's crying so what did you do i hugged her
04:24and said i'm
04:24sorry for like jolting towards you and making you drop your ipod you didn't say that at all i'm sorry
04:30i jolted towards you and made you hurt my ipod what are you kidding me this job is really so
04:36easy
04:38okay cost you 118 dollars yes it did judgment for the plaintiff thank you very much that's all
04:43the parties are excused you may step out judge judy continues in a moment order all rise
04:54the honest case number 489 on account in a matter of crumb versus granbury fultz williams
04:59flies have been sworn in you may be seated miss crumb somehow you are related to these three young
05:04ladies yes yvonne folks it's my um aunt and who's the aunt yes angelisa and janica are my cousins are
05:13they your children yes for some reason there was a falling out with your aunt and her children and
05:20is your claim that one or all of them are responsible for keying your car yes when was your car
05:26keyed
05:27december 10th in the parking lot of walmart who had driven the car there um yvonne was driving her
05:33vehicle who had driven the keyed car oh i drove my car what time did you get to the parking
05:38lot i'd
05:39say i was probably there around 9 30 ish because i just got off of work and 9 30 in
05:45the in the morning
05:46what kind of work do you do i do medical assistant who was driving your car your honor at that
05:52point
05:52in time i was at work you were at work yes ma'am what kind of car do you have
05:572008 kia rio black four
05:59and where do you work at that time i was working at target distribution in woodbury minnesota you're
06:05still working there no ma'am who was your supervisor my supervisor there was uh i forgot her name because
06:11i i'm not working there anymore due to all this stuff that's going on now i'll wait remember who
06:16your supervisor was and the phone number i don't have that with me right now we'll wait go get it
06:20excuse me
06:29how old are you 22 and you 17 where do you work um don't work right now what do you
06:36do i'm looking
06:37for employment what were you doing on december 10th 2010 i was at my cousin's house cousin's house
06:43where in st paul minnesota and where is this walmart parking lot it's in blaine minnesota how far is that
06:51from st paul like 50 minutes how did you get to st paul my cousin came to pick you up
06:57yes how long did
06:58you stay there i was there for like three days from when to win saturday and i don't know what
07:06date
07:06it was because december 10th never happened at walmart and the 10th would have been a monday i just asked
07:12you what date you were visiting i'm not sure your cousin i didn't ask you december 10th did in fact
07:17happen it was a day yeah i went over there before december 10th and it was that weekend so it
07:22was a
07:22saturday what i'm saying is december 10th i don't know the date but it was days before that who went
07:27with
07:27you my sister and my daughter she was suspended that day so that's also why she was suspended
07:32how old is your daughter no my sister oh your sister we were together because it was a weekday
07:37and she was suspended from school so we were together in st paul how old is your daughter
07:41she'll be four in april 21st miss crump can you tell me whether this was a trip that you had
07:48planned
07:49to make to walmart yes indeed it was i was gonna go to walmart to go shopping for christmas shopping
07:55for
07:55my kids yes and as i was on my way there i saw yvonne carr following me just a second
08:02you have the
08:03phone number yes ma'am and the name of your supervisor june just hand it to me thank you
08:18so you were on your way to walmart and you passed the defendant's car yes go ahead that's
08:25when i seen her make a really quick um right turn behind me so i kept going and at the
08:30time i'm on
08:31the phone with my mom too saying like oh i see your sister and she's following me and she's like
08:36just
08:36keep going to where you're going and i drove to walmart which was probably about a couple blocks from
08:41there and um once i got there i noticed they were still behind me so then i hurry up and
08:46park over
08:47there look at me so i hurry up and parked and once i parked they parked only about i say
08:52a few cars from
08:53me who was in the car it was yvonne janica and jalisa go ahead so anyhow i parked and they
08:59were
09:00still behind me and my mom was on the phone so i'm like okay they still here why are they
09:03here so she
09:04said just go into the walmart and before i get out my car i can hear them yelling oh i'm
09:09gonna f this be
09:10up if she don't get out the car we'll break the windows and get her out and um if she
09:17just act
09:17funny or say something funny we're gonna beat her up so miss crumb there is no question in your mind
09:22that the defendants were at the walmart parking lot on december 10th correct that she was not at work
09:31at december 10th at 9 30 in the morning correct and these two were not in i don't know visiting
09:37a
09:37cousin for a couple of days they were with their mother correct and i don't really have to get into
09:43what this family dispute was all about i don't want to know suffice it to say i assume that at
09:50one time
09:51you were a close family and because of something you're not a close family anymore right and nobody
09:57knows how to just not be a close family without being destructive exactly or i don't care that's
10:04not my problem i don't want to put this family back together i don't care if you're not back together
10:08all i care about is your keyed car me too exactly did you go into the walmart i did i
10:14actually ran and
10:15uh afraid of being assaulted by them three so i ran into walmart and when you came out is when
10:21you
10:21noticed your car was keyed i noticed the damages on my car and you did not see any of them
10:26key your
10:26car no but i'm pretty sure they did it because they were saying it's very easy to determine
10:31how can i see pictures of your car please
10:43would you show me where it was keyed are you talking about this these marks i don't know it's
10:48very hard when you do these blow up pictures to see what you're talking about
10:56circle with damages please did you take those pictures with your phone i did i'd like to see
11:02it in your phone rather than blown up so that i can't see a thing
11:12and you can just move your finger towards the left and it should keep going
11:22got it now i got it much easier to see thank you okay so far there is no proof other
11:32than your
11:33statement that they were in fact there you didn't see them do it but certainly she says she was at
11:38work they were in some other place so if they were lying to me about her being at work on
11:45that day
11:45that's easy right yvonne right if you were lying to me about not being at work i have no reason
11:52to
11:52lie great and this supervisor would know whether or not you were at work on december 10th at 9 30
11:58in
11:59the morning yes correct great judge judy continues in a moment you swore in an answer i was at work
12:10these two weren't with me they were off someplace else because this one was suspended from school
12:14you said a bad example that's why she's suspended from school and later today them raggedy bees
12:20keyed it and i knew she was directing it towards us the raggedy bees with the two of you yeah
12:25well
12:25she accused her i just want to know the raggedy people that she was talking about with the two of
12:29you
12:31jasmine crumb says family members yvonne false and her daughters jaleesa granberry and janika
12:37williams teed her car jill this is judge judy shindlin good morning i'm in the middle of trying
12:44a case and there was a date in question as to whether one of your former employees was actually
12:51working the date is december the 10th 2010 in the morning thank you jill
13:00was she there at any time that week thank you very much jill i appreciate it thank you bye bye
13:07now
13:18you're not supposed to lie in front of your children then i don't do it you're not supposed
13:24to lie in front of your children and make them co-conspirators in your lie you understand your
13:31honor do you understand i mean maybe i have got a date wrong because i was working a lot
13:35listen don't tell me you have the day wrong you know exactly why you're coming to court you know
13:40exactly the date you swore in an answer i was at work these two weren't with me they were off
13:45some
13:45place else because this one was suspended from school you said a bad example that's why she's
13:49suspended from school no your honor no you don't think so well you weren't working on december 10th
13:55how much did it cost to fix your car i have the repair damages excuse me i'm not speaking
14:00to you i haven't gotten it fixed yet
14:09judgment for the plaintiff from the amount of 500 that's all step out think twice about your mother
14:14right here bodies are excused you may step out i'm pretty sure that they showed you all their drama
14:21right here on camera they're drama queens they are all young adults 18 and older who physically
14:26assaulted my daughter two years ago yvonne cut me with a butcher knife here she cut me here i've been
14:30up and down for months and months with all this harassment i think it's maybe jealousy on their
14:35side i have a son has been shot by somebody on her entourage side of the family i filed a
14:39restraining
14:40order to keep them away from me and my children it was just crazy to me how they thought they
14:43was
14:44gonna come in there alive i wonder why she hated on us we never did anything to her i have
14:47assault
14:48charges i have restraining orders and everything it's just been going on and on and there's so much
14:52hatred and stuff in between the families with them people there is no family i'm glad we came to judge
14:57you today to settle that and for once somebody spoke up for us and it looks right and now the
15:02next case all parties in the matter of lewis versus roe step forward 20 year old shanae lewis
15:09is suing former friend 20 year old brianna roe for keying her car shanae claims brianna admitted to
15:17the crime on facebook miss lewis it is your claim that the defendant keyed your car caused damage in the
15:23amount of about twenty five hundred dollars miss roe says she didn't do it how do you know each
15:28other i know brianna because we were friends in high school we hung out with the same people
15:32and went to the same party so we all right so that's how you know each other correct when was
15:37your car vandalized um in the summer around july 2000 around july july 2010 i don't know the exact date
15:45did you report it to the police no i did not do you remember where your car was yes i
15:50do where was
15:50your car it was parked at a mutual friend's parking spot in an apartment where in citrus heights
15:56california what's the address i do not know the name of the apartment i didn't ask you the name
16:01what's the address i do not know the address what do you know i know that my car was parked
16:06in a
16:06covered parking spot that was allowed by the owner of the apartment well you can't tell me it was
16:11allowed by the owner of the apartment because that's hearsay okay well my car was parked in a
16:15covered parking spot and and it was keyed and and i have proof that brianna rowe did it i'd like
16:21to
16:22see your proof well we were at a um a mutual friend yes i want to see your proof okay
16:27i have documents
16:28of the pictures of my listen to me i want to see the proof okay here's the proof of my
16:33car i don't
16:34have to see the keys car you don't even know when it happened i want to see proof that the
16:37defendant
16:38keyed your car okay well she admitted on facebook to doing it let me see it this is the conversation
16:44right here and it's highlighted right there
16:53bird you have younger children would it be possible for you to interpret this gibberish
16:58that is highlighted for me i'll give it a shot
17:06okay laugh out loud i could care less for you i keyed your car because my best friend didn't like
17:13you
17:13but i'm too grown to go bad on you on facebook i'll leave being ignorant to you i guess anyway
17:20have a nice day it's almost like reading sans script yes i i don't dig tech speak but i know
17:30it
17:32could you show that to the dentist
17:34it's just judge judy continues in a moment
17:41i need to take deep breaths i need to take deep breaths it's only going to get worse
17:48shanae lewis says former friend brianna roe keyed her car after a falling out
17:53brianna denies the charge okay take a look at that is that your thesis
18:00oh i have one of these two well i'm asking you was that yours did i write it yeah yeah
18:06so why did
18:06you tell you keyed her car because she had made a post that said uh granddad is getting my car
18:12detailed that said what she was getting her car detailed and fixed after them raggedy bees keyed it
18:20and i knew she was directing towards us because she accused us of keying her car the raggedy bees
18:25were the two of you yeah well she accused her i just want to know the raggedy people that she
18:29was talking about with the two of you you knew that yourself without having been named is that
18:34what you're saying because she had already accused of us doing it so even though you weren't named
18:41you decided to tell her that she was right that you did in fact key her car and if officer
18:49bird read
18:50it right you told her why you keyed her car i wrote it to make her mad well why would
18:55you think if she
18:56already knew that you and your raggedy friend were the ones that keyed her car why did you think it
19:01would make her mad if you admitted it no she thought elena had keyed her car no no no she
19:07talked about
19:08two raggedy people she didn't say how many no she just she said after them yes well and raggedy and
19:16she
19:16uses the word with an s plural that would be two yes but so you three of us at the
19:24house three of
19:25you well how many of you keyed the car none of us well then why would you admit to keying
19:30her car
19:31because she accused us of it after her car got keyed she came in the house threw papers at elena
19:35and told us we keyed her car there's something wrong with you honestly there's something wrong
19:40with you i mean i can't get myself overly exercised about this case quite frankly miss lewis
19:44because you don't even remember what date it happened how many times has your car been keyed
19:48none well one well once
19:54can i ask you a question yes this is your facebook page yes and this is you with this bathing
20:00suit yes
20:01if that is a bathing suit well i just i'm just want to know yes that is me on up
20:05there is there
20:07really reason why you think that this is an appropriate picture just to send around the internet i did
20:13modeling and that was a picture that i like and i feel that i wanted to post it
20:20i need to take deep breaths i need to take deep breaths it's only going to get worse
20:27your honor me and the defendant had been friends before this happened the defendant and i had been
20:34friends and i were friends before this happened and the reason why i believe their motive that they
20:40have i don't care what their motive was she admitted it it's okay it's irrelevant to me what her motive
20:44was
20:44okay i assume that you have some sort of a falling out is that right yes yes
20:50yes now i'll see the pictures of your car okay
21:01judge jude continues in a moment want justice go to judge judy.com or call 1-888-800-JUDY
21:12when did you take these pictures of your car i took them when it happened and then i took some
21:18more
21:18before i came and since you don't know exactly when this happened sometime last summer i assume
21:24you've been driving around with your car exactly the way it is yes do you have an estimate to have
21:29it fixed yes i do i'd like to see
21:43now they're not preparing any dents she didn't dent the car he's talking he ate it there's oh very nice
21:50marks on very good fat okay could you explain to me why you filed this lawsuit for twenty five hundred
21:57dollars and the estimate that you had was fifteen because i am suing for i believe that for the
22:04scratches and for punitive damages the punitive damages for what because every time that i have
22:10to drive around my car and have the word written on it that's embarrassing for me to have to ride
22:15around and be disrespected like that i have a newborn son and i don't want that portrayed right for
22:19me i'm not well do you i'm 20 years old what do you have a newborn son for i thought
22:23you went to
22:24school i do go to school who takes care of your new my grandmother your grandmother yes great yeah
22:30spend five hundred dollars get your car painted judgment for the plaintiff from the amount of five
22:33hundred dollars that's all eyes are excused you may step out judge judy continues in a moment
22:40and on the next judge judy now that i'm out of biggert versus reed please have been sworn in judge
22:46you may be seated sir have a seat mr biggert the defendant is your former wife and it is your
22:51claim
22:51that since you've been divorced separated and under a child support order you have overpaid some thirty
22:57five hundred dollars in child support yes you say that it was not an overpayment the money was used
23:02for the children and there was some sort of an agreement for him to pay you additional money
23:07you have a counterclaim for seven hundred dollars because you say he was ordered to pay seven hundred
23:12dollars in attorney's fees for some sort of a custody proceeding the two of you were involved with
23:16and he did not pay that amount when were you divorced 1988 and you have two children yes how
23:23old are they howard is 18 and sarah is 16. and what was the child support order it was approximately
23:29twelve hundred dollars per month and during what period of time did you overpay um i i'm assuming it
23:35was over the whole period because when i received the paperwork from the court it just said we did an
23:41investigation from the time you started paying child support until the end of august so over 13
23:47year period yes and you can't definitively say over what period of time you made these overpayments no
23:53should have kept better records was the overpayment agreed to be reimbursed by the defendant at any time
24:02in court i was not aware there was an overpayment until i received the paperwork from the court saying
24:06they had done an investigation into the child let me see the piece of paper you received
24:20at the time you received this order it indicates that thirty five hundred and seventy three dollars
24:25and eighty-five cents was overpaid over the course of 13 years yes i'll hear you all the money that
24:31i
24:32got was spent on the kids were you aware of the fact mrs reed that you were being overpaid not
24:38at
24:38the time now because the checks always fluctuating when did you become aware that you were receiving
24:44too much money about a month and a half ago when i got it through the mail and when did
24:48you become aware
24:49of the fact sir that you had overpaid child support when i received that notice in the mail from the
24:54when did you remarry mrs reed may of this year prior to that both children lived with you yes and
25:00did
25:00your former husband see the children regularly no did you see the children at times but not you have
25:06a reasonable relationship with your children yes do either of your children live with you now
25:10i have custody of my daughter and how old is she 16 which she does not live with him who
25:15does she live
25:16with my second ex-wife do you pay child support to your second ex-wife i reimburse her for any
25:21expenses that she encouraged for my daughter or i pay the expenses directly under what circumstances did
25:27your daughter leave your home i think it was because she was i finally got help raising the
25:31kids and i think it was too structured and she didn't like it do you work oh yes i have
25:36a beauty
25:36salon are you under a current child support order for your 16 year old daughter no how come well probably
25:43when she went to live with her dad it was all of a sudden and um i was told she
25:48was moving in with her
25:48father three weeks later i find she's living with her stepmother so i was not very happy about that
25:54and um no one's ever requested child support from me but as my income compared to his income i don't
26:01think there would be much anyways i'm not so sure well how many children do you have five how many
26:07children do you have two i guarantee you if somebody requested child support you would pay it oh definitely
26:13what kind of income did you have at the time that that the children were living with you it was
26:18about
26:18eleven thousand a year so it was like all i could do to keep us in the house that we
26:24bought together
26:25when we were married but i wanted to keep the kids where they were raised i want to do a
26:28calculation for
26:29you mr bigger maybe it will make you feel better difference of thirty five hundred dollars over the
26:34thirteen-year period you know what that comes out to mr bigger 22 a month yes or five dollars a
26:40week
26:41so nobody got rich on that difference and quite frankly i don't feel justified in saying to the
26:47defendants who really didn't know that she had received an overpayment now you have to come up
26:51with thirty five hundred dollars unless you can tell me that you don't think that she spent that five
26:56dollars a week at least in part on the children well i i think your honor that um she's probably
27:02spent
27:02more than that and i spent more than that over that 13 year period myself right that's a good thing
27:08okay you want to tell me about this counterclaim that you have yes i've got um information that um
27:15he was to pay for our son being custody changed last year it was ordered that he pay me the
27:21amount
27:22of nine hundred dollars nine hundred dollars for what the attorney fees for the custody what happened
27:28with that custody proceeding well actually my son come back to live with with us with lg and i and
27:33um
27:34the 900 attorney fees it says here was to be paid to me to pay my lawyer and so far
27:39herbs paid 200 of it
27:41and um said he would pay me or if i paid the other 700 he would deduct it from the
27:463500 that i owed
27:48and i would only he would only be suing me for the 2800 and i just didn't feel that was
27:54correct
27:55what did you when the court order because i have a court order here stating that he's to pay it
27:59you
28:00have a court order that he was to pay 900 for your attorney and he's got a court order that
28:05says that he's
28:05supposed to pay so much for child support he overpaid you in child support you want me to give
28:11more recognition to your order than to his no so why should he pay you a penny
28:17real cases real people judge judy herbert bigard says ex-wife kim reed owes for the return of child
28:24support herbert claims he overpaid and kim kept the money go ahead this was supposed to be paid back in
28:31january and it was not paid i understand well that's your counter claim he's what we you're not
28:36you're on if i might you said yourself we were talking about five dollars a week over 13 years right
28:45but accumulates to 3500 exactly right this court order was basically after the fact as far as paying
28:53the attorney fees from a change of custody that's why the countersuit when was the order january 9 2001
29:01okay no he was still paying child support in january of 2001 sir yes he was still overpaying child
29:07support in january of 2001 but we didn't know until now i understand that but for you to suggest that
29:13i'm going where anyone would order him to pay you seven or nine hundred dollars for your attorney's fees
29:19when you have collected thirty five hundred dollars in excess of the child support award even over 13 years
29:25it's ludicrous ludicrous especially miss reed since and i don't know all of the facts but you
29:31have a 16 year old for whom you are paying zero support because i was never ordered dead if a
29:37man
29:38miss reed if a man said that to me in court i don't have to pay child support because i
29:43was never ordered
29:44to pay it i would wipe up the floor with them you don't have to be ordered to pay support
29:49for a minor
29:50child that's your obligation that's your obligation as a parent but i do not have the funds that he has
29:56doesn't make any difference if my daughter needs something i do go get her and no no no no no
30:01no
30:01you don't have to have the same funds that he has child support obligations are supposed to be fair
30:07and you have perhaps less funds than he does and he has more obligations than you do
30:13you have yourself and your husband and he's got himself and he has at least four children that he's
30:19supporting one is yes emancipated but he has four children for whom he pays support including your
30:26daughter who is no longer living with you so you should be paying something to his ex-wife every
30:31month to his ex-wife i would well then you should be and you don't have to wait for a
30:34court order to do
30:35that well so i never understood how all this went when i had both my children he paid me um
30:41when he had
30:41howard or one of my children and i had the other it just got cut in half and i didn't
30:46have to pay for
30:46howard so i didn't understand that i really should have to pay for her and knowing that i had no
30:51problem i just didn't know just a minute i mean i just want you to think about this howard went
30:56to
30:56live with his father so he paid you half of what he had been paying right why should he pay
31:01you anything
31:02i don't i don't why should he pay you anything now you have one child he has one child and
31:07you each
31:08support the one child that you have in your custody you think it's sort of fair that his child support
31:13order was cut in half to me you have far fewer obligations you have a working mate and if one
31:21child is living with you and one child is living with him then what you do is you each take
31:26care of
31:26the child that's living with you we shouldn't have to pay you a penny that's fair i try to be
31:30a fair
31:30person in any event mr bigard while i am minorly sympathetic with your position truth of the
31:38matter is if you never got this piece of paper from child support enforcement you would not have
31:43known that you would overpaid over the course of 13 years an additional five dollars a week correct
31:47yes you would have been able to sleep easier yes right not a big deal on the other hand so
31:53because
31:54the money went for your kids there's no question that if she had an extra five bucks a week
31:57she didn't go out and buy herself a sable coat that be a fair statement yes all right on the
32:03other
32:03hand it is the height of chutzpah you know chutzpah i know chutzpah to suggest that i'm going to give
32:10you any part of your counterclaim after you have been enriched over the course of 13 years the amount
32:15of thirty five hundred dollars so your counterclaim is dismissed your lawsuit is dismissed go be nice
32:21parents to your children don't fight anymore i try to be happy thank you your parties i excuse you may
32:28step out thank you when the court determined that i had overpaid and i thought it was fair to receive
32:33the money back i spent it on the children
Comments

Recommended