- 10 minutes ago
Watch Game of Thrones Dragonstone Episode Season 7 Episode 1 online in HD on Dailymotion.
Category
🐳
AnimalsTranscript
00:28You
00:32You're wondering
00:33Why I brought you all here
00:35After all
00:37We just had a feast
00:39Since when does old Walder
00:42Give us two feasts
00:43In a single fortnight
00:47Well it's no good being
00:49Lord of the Riverlands if you can't
00:51Celebrate with your family
00:53That's what I say
01:02I've gathered
01:03Every fray who means a damn
01:05Thing so I can tell you
01:07My plans for this
01:09Great house now that
01:11Winter has come
01:13But first
01:15A toast
01:18No more
01:19Of that Gornish horse piss
01:21This is the finest
01:23Arbor gold
01:24Proper wine
01:26For proper heroes
01:33Stand together
01:35Stand together
01:45Not you
01:47I'm not wasting good wine
01:50On a damn woman
01:54Maybe
01:55I'm not the most
01:57Pleasant man
01:58I'll admit it
02:00But I'm proud of you lot
02:02You're my family
02:04The men
02:04Who helped me slaughter the Starks
02:07At the Red Wedding
02:08Yes
02:11Yes
02:12Yes
02:13Cheer
02:15Brave men
02:16All of you
02:18Butchered a woman
02:20Pregnant with her babe
02:23Cut the throat
02:24Of a mother of five
02:28Slaughtered your guests
02:30After inviting them
02:31Into your home
02:34But
02:35You didn't slaughter
02:37Every one
02:38Of the Starks
02:40No no
02:42That was your mistake
02:44You should have
02:46Ripped them all out
02:47Loot and stem
02:54Leave one wolf alive
02:57And the sheep
02:58Are never safe
03:02And the sheep are never safe
03:03And the sheep are never safe
03:27what happened here. Tell them the North remembers. Tell them winter came for House Frey.
04:09The Marsалась. I guess they happened a year. Your chocolate has collapsed details.
04:13Later, Susan, Robb, I want to enjoycknowledge that أي甘 were all comfortable in this world.
04:14My North competitor wanted to�� YouTuber gezBA en STAR.
07:59You wildlings.
08:01I'm Meera Reed, daughter of Howland Reed.
08:05This is Brandon Stark, son of Ned Stark.
08:14Now how do I know that's true?
08:19You were at the fist of the first men.
08:22You were at Hardhome.
08:26You've seen the army of the army of the army of the dead.
08:29You've seen the night king.
08:32He's coming for us.
08:35For all of us.
08:44Hey, come on.
08:46Let's get them inside.
09:17I want every northern maester, I want every northern maester to scour their records for any mention of dragonglass.
09:24Dragonglass kills white walkers.
09:26It's more valuable to us now than gold.
09:28We need to find it.
09:29We need to mine it.
09:30We need to make weapons from it.
09:33Everyone aged 10 to 60 will drill daily with spears, pikes, bow and arrow.
09:39It's about time we taught these boys of summer how to fight.
09:43Not just the boys.
09:45We can't defend the north if only half the population is fighting.
09:50You expect me to put a spear in my granddaughter's hand?
09:55I don't plan on knitting by the fire while men fight for me.
09:58I might be small, Lord Glover, and I might be a girl.
10:01But I am every bit as much a northerner as you.
10:03Indeed you are, my lady.
10:05No one is questioning.
10:05And I don't need your permission to defend the north.
10:10We'll begin training every man, woman, boy and girl on Bear Island.
10:17While we're preparing for attack, we need to shore up our defenses.
10:21The only thing standing between us and the army of the dead is the wall,
10:25and the wall hasn't been properly manned in centuries.
10:28I'm not the king of the free folk.
10:32But if we're going to survive this winter together...
10:36You want us to mind the castles for you?
10:39Aye.
10:40Last time we saw the Night King was at Hardhome.
10:43The closest castle to Hardhome is Eastwatch by the sea.
10:46And that's where I'll go.
10:48Looks like we're the Night's Watch now.
10:53If they breach the war, the first two castles in their path are Last Hearth and Carhole.
10:59The Ambers and the Carstarchs betrayed the north.
11:03Their castles should be torn down with not a stone left standing.
11:06The castles committed no crimes.
11:09And we need every fortress we have for the war to come.
11:12We should give the Last Hearth and Carhole to new families.
11:15Loyal families who supported us against Ramsey.
11:22The Ambers and the Carstarchs have fought beside the Starks for centuries.
11:26They've kept faith for generation after generation.
11:29And then they broke faith.
11:30I'm not going to strip these families of their ancestral homes
11:33because of the crimes of a few reckless sons.
11:36So there's no punishment for treason and no reward for loyalty?
11:45The punishment for treason is death.
11:48Small John Umber died on the field of battle.
11:51Harold Carstarch died on the field of battle.
11:54They died fighting for Ramsey.
11:56Give the castles to the families of the men who died fighting for you.
12:13When I was Lord Commander of the Night's Watch
12:17I executed men who betrayed me.
12:20I executed men who refused to follow orders.
12:23My father always said
12:25the man who passes the sentence should swing the sword
12:29and I have tried to live by those words.
12:32But I will not punish a son for his father's sins.
12:35And I will not take a family home
12:37away from a family it has belonged to for centuries.
12:41That is my decision.
12:43And my decision is final.
12:51Ned Umber
13:00Alice Carstarch
13:17The centuries our families fought side by side on the battlefield.
13:22I ask you to pledge your loyalty once again to House Stark.
13:27To serve as our bannermen
13:29and come to our aid whenever called upon.
13:41Stan.
13:46Yesterday's wars don't matter anymore.
13:49The North needs to band together.
13:52All the living North.
13:55Will you stand beside me, Ned and Alice?
13:57Now and always.
13:59Now and always.
14:21You are my sister but I am king now.
14:23Will you start wearing a crown?
14:25When you question my decisions in front of the other lords and ladies
14:28you undermine me.
14:29So we can't question your decisions anymore.
14:31Of course you can but...
14:32Joffrey never let anyone question his authority.
14:34You think he was a good king?
14:38Do you think I'm Joffrey?
14:43You're as far from Joffrey as anyone I've ever met.
14:49You're good at this, you know.
14:51At what?
14:52At ruling.
14:54No.
14:55You are.
14:57You are.
15:01They respect you.
15:02They really do.
15:03But you have to...
15:05Why are you laughing?
15:07What did father used to say?
15:09Everything before the word bot is horseshit.
15:12Never said that to me.
15:13No.
15:14No, he never cursed in front of his girls.
15:16Because he was trying to protect us.
15:19He never wanted us to see how dirty the world really is but...
15:23Father couldn't protect me, neither can you.
15:25Stop trying.
15:26All right, I'll stop trying to protect you and you stop trying to undermine me.
15:29I'm not trying to undermine you.
15:32You have to be smarter than father.
15:36You need to be smarter than Rob.
15:38I loved them.
15:39I missed them.
15:40But they made stupid mistakes and they both lost their heads for it.
15:44And how should I be smarter?
15:45By listening to you.
15:49Would that be so terrible?
15:52A raven from King's Landing, your grace.
16:05Cersei of House Lannister, first of her name, queen of the Andals and the first men,
16:10protector of the Seven Kingdoms.
16:11What does she want?
16:15Come to King's Landing, bend the knee or suffer the fate of all traitors.
16:20You've been so consumed with the enemy to the north, you've forgotten about the one to the south.
16:24I'm consumed with the Night King because I've seen him.
16:27And believe me, you'd think of little else if you had to.
16:30We still have a wall between us and the Night King.
16:32There's nothing between us and Cersei.
16:34There's a thousand miles between us and Cersei.
16:36Winter is here.
16:37The Lannisters are a southern army.
16:39They've never ranged this far north.
16:41You're the military man, but I know her.
16:44If you're her enemy, she'll never stop until she's destroyed you.
16:48Everyone who's ever crossed her, she's found a way to murder.
16:53You almost sound as if you admire her.
17:00Learned a great deal from her.
17:17I've learned a great deal from her.
17:38what is this it's what we've been waiting for our whole lives it's what father trained us for
17:44whether he knew it or not he knew it maybe memorize every damn city town lake forest
17:50and mountain it's ours now we just have to take it you've been quiet since you came home
17:57you're angry with me no i was angry you afraid of me should i be
18:10daenerys targaryen has chosen tyrian to be her hand right now they're sailing across the narrow sea
18:16hoping to take back her father's throne our little brother the one you love so much the one you set
18:25free the one who murdered our father and our firstborn son now he stands beside our enemies
18:31and gives them counsel
18:36he's out there somewhere at the head of an armada
18:40where will they land
18:44dragon stone we have deep water ports for the ships
18:48stannis left the castle and occupied and that's why she was born
18:52enemies to the east enemies to the south in aria sand and her brood of bitches
18:58enemies to the west oh lena the old cunt another traitor
19:06enemies to the north
19:07ned stark's bastard has been named king in the north and that murdering whore sansa stands beside him
19:14enemies everywhere we're surrounded by traitors
19:17you're in command of the lannister army now how do we proceed winter's here
19:22we can't win a war if we can't feed our men and our horses
19:26the tyrells have the grain the tyrells have the livestock
19:29will the tyrell bannermen stand alongside a dothraki horde
19:33and unsullied slave soldiers
19:34if they think daenerys will win
19:37no one wants to fight on the losing side
19:39right now
19:41we look like the losing side
19:44i'm the queen of the seven kingdoms three kingdoms at best
19:48i'm not sure you understand how much danger we're in
19:51i understand we're in a war for survival
19:53i understand whoever loses dies
19:55i understand whoever wins could launch a dynasty that lasts a thousand years
19:59a dynasty for whom
20:02our children are dead
20:05we're the last of us
20:06a dynasty for us then
20:11we never talked about tom
20:16there's nothing to say
20:18our baby boy killed himself
20:20he betrayed me
20:21he betrayed us both
20:23should we spend our days mourning the dead
20:25mother father and all our children
20:27i loved them i did
20:28but they're ashes now and we're still flesh and blood
20:32but the last lannisters
20:34the last ones you count
20:41even lannisters can't survive without allies
20:44where are our allies now
20:47you saw what happened to all the fray and his family
20:49i heard
20:50how could we ever trust a man like that
20:53we couldn't
20:53he was a useless old coward
20:55but the fray supported us
20:57now they're all dead
20:59whoever killed them is no friend of ours
21:00we need allies
21:01stronger better allies
21:03we can't win this war alone
21:08i think i listened to father for 40 years and learned nothing
21:11nobody
21:12has ADHD
21:39how is he
21:48The Greyjoys.
21:50You invited the Greyjoys to King's Landing.
21:53Not all of them.
21:53Well, it looks like all of them.
21:55I invited your own Greyjoy, the new king of the Iron Islands.
21:59You said yourself we needed stronger, better allies.
22:02There you are.
22:03How are they better allies?
22:05How are they different from the Freys?
22:07They both broke their promises and murdered their former friends
22:10as soon as it suits them.
22:12So does everyone, when it suits them.
22:14Unlike the Freys, they have ships.
22:17And they're good at killing.
22:18They're not good at anything.
22:20I know the Ironborn.
22:21They're bitter, angry little people.
22:23All they know how to do is steal the things they can't build or grow themselves.
22:27You're on Greyjoys, who didn't come here for that?
22:29What did he come here for, though?
22:31A queen.
22:45The moment I was chosen Lord of the Iron Islands, they turned on me.
22:50Their own uncle.
22:52They stole my best ships and ran.
22:55They sailed them right across the world and gave them to the Draken Queen,
22:59so she could bring her armies here to attack you.
23:03It's nothing compared to the treason you suffered at the hands of a family member,
23:08from what I hear.
23:09But still, it bothers me.
23:14Murdering them would make me feel a lot better.
23:17And since it appears that all our treasonous family members are fighting for the same side,
23:23I thought we rightful monarchs could murder them together.
23:34You're not a rightful monarch, though, are you?
23:41The Greyjoys rebelled against the throne for the right to be monarchs,
23:44but as I recall, you were soundly defeated.
23:48Come to mention it,
23:50weren't you the one who started that rebellion
23:52by sailing to Casterly Rock and burning the Lannister fleet?
23:56You suddenly caught us there.
23:58Very smart move on your part.
24:01Of course, we all made it to the Iron Islands anyway.
24:05I was there.
24:06I remember very well.
24:08I saw you.
24:09I heard so much talk.
24:12The best in the world.
24:13No one can stop him.
24:15I didn't believe it, to be honest.
24:18But I must say,
24:19when you rushed through the breach
24:21and started cutting people down,
24:26it was glorious.
24:28Like a dance.
24:30The people I was cutting down were your own kin.
24:33The place was getting crowded.
24:35I enjoyed watching it.
24:36I truly did.
24:38And I enjoyed killing Greyjoys.
24:40A good thing for me.
24:42If you hadn't crushed us,
24:44I wouldn't have gone into exile.
24:46If I hadn't done that,
24:48I wouldn't be the greatest captain of the 14 seas.
24:52You're not the most humble.
24:55You're not humble.
24:58You're the queen of a great nation.
25:01You don't care about the Iron Islands.
25:04They're nothing but rocks and bird shit
25:07and a lot of very unattractive people.
25:11The Iron Fleet, on the other hand,
25:14had something else entirely.
25:17It's the greatest armada Westeros has ever seen.
25:20With the Iron Fleet, you own the seas.
25:25You can defeat the invaders in the east.
25:27And the pretenders in the north and south.
25:30What do you want in return?
25:34Ever since I was a little boy,
25:37I wanted to grow up
25:39and marry the most beautiful woman in the world.
25:42So here I am,
25:43with a thousand ships
25:46and two good hands.
25:53I decline your proposal.
25:57Why?
25:59You're not trustworthy.
26:01You've broken promises to allies before
26:03and murdered them at the nearest opportunity.
26:06You murdered your own brother.
26:09You should try it.
26:10Feels wonderful.
26:13I don't expect you to trust me outright.
26:15You need proof of my honest intentions.
26:17In my experience,
26:19the surest way to a woman's heart
26:21is with a gift.
26:22A priceless gift.
26:24I won't return to King's Landing
26:26until I have that for you.
26:41I won't return to King's Landing.
26:42Things are real good.
27:16Oh, my God.
27:31Oh, my God.
28:01Oh, my God.
28:27Oh, my God.
28:33Oh, my God.
28:42Oh, my God.
29:34Oh, my God.
29:38Oh, my God.
30:06I asked you if, in light of what I'd seen in the north, if I could have access to the
30:11restricted area of the library.
30:12That area is reserved for maesters. Are you a maester?
30:15No.
30:17No.
30:17Not a very strong proposition, is it?
30:28Archmaester, with respect, with respect, I've seen them.
30:32The army of the army of the army of the army of the army of the army of the dead,
30:35the white walkers.
30:38I was sent here, I was sent here to learn how to defeat them.
30:40Everyone in the citadel, everyone in the citadel, those who've even talked to me, they all doubt the walkers ever
30:46existed in the first place.
30:48Everyone in the citadel, everyone in the citadel, but the tales of the long night, but the tales of the
30:58long night can't be pure fabrication.
31:01Too many similarities from unconnected sources.
31:05Sources in the restricted area?
31:07The very same.
31:10And the simplest explanation for your grating obsession with the white walkers is that you're telling the truth, and that
31:17you saw what you say you saw.
31:20So, you believe me?
31:23I do.
31:25You'll finish weighing that heart?
31:29That makes you the only person south of the twins who does.
31:34You're not like the people south of the twins.
31:37And you're not like the people north of the twins.
31:42In the citadel, we lead different lives, for different reasons.
31:48We are this world's memory, Samuel Tarly.
31:51Without us, men would be little better than dogs.
31:54Don't remember any meal but the last.
31:56Can't see forward to any but the next.
31:59And every time you leave the house and shut the door, they howl like you're gone forever.
32:03When Robert's rebellion was raging, people thought the end was near, the end of the Targaryen dynasty.
32:10How will we survive?
32:11When Aegon Targaryen turned his eye westward and flew his dragons to Blackwater Rush, the end is near.
32:18How will we survive?
32:19And thousands of years before that, during the long night, we can forgive them for thinking it truly was the
32:24end, but it wasn't.
32:25None of it was.
32:28The wall has stood through it all.
32:32And every winter that ever came has ended.
32:43Be a good lad, clean this up.
33:07I can't believe it.
33:11What?
33:15What?
33:35No!
33:48No!
34:01You're a lucky man.
34:08I've heard she beat the Hound in single combat.
34:15She's a very impressive woman.
34:18What do you want, Lord Baelish?
34:24I want you to be happy.
34:27I want you to be safe.
34:28I am safe.
34:30I'm at home, surrounded by friends.
34:33I have Brienne to protect me from anyone who would harm me.
34:40What about happy?
34:44Why aren't you happy?
34:46What do you want that you do not have?
34:49At the moment, peace and quiet.
34:56No need to seize the last word, Lord Baelish.
34:59I'll assume it was something clever.
35:04My lady.
35:06My lady.
35:18Why is he still here?
35:20We need his men.
35:22Without the veil Ramsay Bolton would still hold this castle.
35:27Littlefinger saved us.
35:33He wants something.
35:36I know exactly what he wants.
35:43We rode through the streets of the city.
35:47Down from this hill and high.
35:50All the winds and the steps and the carving.
35:54We rode to a woman's side.
35:57For she was a secret treasure.
36:01She was his shame and his bliss.
36:04And a chain and a keep are nothing.
36:07Compared to a woman's kiss.
36:10For hands of gold are always cold.
36:13But a woman's hands are warm.
36:16For hands of gold are always cold.
36:20But a woman's hands are warm.
36:24It's a pretty song.
36:26I've never heard it before.
36:27It's a new one.
36:28Are you hungry?
36:29We've got some rabbit.
36:31I don't want to steal your food.
36:33You're not stealing.
36:33We're offering.
36:35Come on.
36:36It's gonna be a cold night.
37:06You heading south?
37:07King's Landing.
37:09Poor girl.
37:12Not so bad, is it?
37:14Depends on your taste, I guess.
37:16If you like your streets covered in shit and pig's blood, it's the town for you.
37:20All my life I wanted to see the Red Keep.
37:23The Septed Bailer.
37:24The Dragon Pit.
37:25Then, when I finally make it, they wouldn't let me within a mile.
37:28The Red Keep.
37:29The Septed Bailer's blown to hell.
37:31And the Dragon Pit.
37:32It's a damn ruin.
37:33The people who live there, they'd skin you alive if they could make two coppers off your hide.
37:37Worst place in the world.
37:40What are you doing in the Riverlands?
37:42There's been some trouble with the Freys up at the Twins.
37:44So, we're part of the army that's been sent to keep the peace.
37:51Here you go.
37:53Guess first.
37:54Oh no, I couldn't.
37:55You don't have enough.
37:56Well, my mother always told me to be kind to strangers.
37:59Strangers will be kind to you.
38:13You're a long way from home.
38:15I'm sure you've had some adventures though.
38:17Yeah.
38:18Endless adventures.
38:20They'll be singing about us for a thousand years.
38:22The truth is, when we left home, we couldn't wait to get away.
38:26But now we've been gone a while, we can't wait to get home.
38:28I just think about my dad out there on his boat all alone.
38:33They ought to be out there with him.
38:35My wife's just had our first baby.
38:38Boy or girl?
38:39Oh, who knows?
38:40You think soldiers get ravens with news from home?
38:46I hope it's a girl.
38:47Why?
38:49Girls take care of their pappas when their pappas grow old.
38:52Boys just go off to fight in someone else's wars.
38:56Are you old enough to drink?
39:13It's blackberry wine.
39:15I made it myself.
39:18It's really good.
39:21So why is a nice girl on our own heading to King's Landing?
39:32I'm going to kill the queen.
39:55A bad night to be outdoors.
39:58You've got real powerful magic to figure that out.
40:01Did the lord of life whisper that in your ear?
40:05It's snowing, Thoris.
40:07It's windy.
40:08It's going to be a cold night.
40:11You're a grouchy old bear, aren't you, Clegane?
40:14You want some rum?
40:16Don't mind.
40:17That shit is too sweet.
40:19Why are you always in such a foul mood?
40:24Experience.
40:30This seems like a good place to spend the night.
40:35These people don't want us here.
40:37Seems deserted to me.
40:39No livestock.
40:40No smoke coming from the chimney.
41:01I don't like the look of it.
41:04For a big hard man, you scare easy.
41:06I'll tell you what doesn't scare me.
41:09Bald top suckers like you.
41:11You think you're fooling anyone with that top knot?
41:14Not a bolt hunt.
41:17Come on.
41:19Maybe they've got some ale hidden away.
41:22They don't.
41:27See if there's a larder.
41:28They always leave something behind.
41:43They aren't going nowhere.
41:47They've been supposed to wander to throw-
41:48They've got some larders.
41:56They've got some larders.
41:59I don't think they've got some larders.
42:09They're going to be in for a long time.
42:12How do you think it ended for them?
42:15What's death?
42:16The girl died in her father's arms.
42:19Both of them covered in blood and a knife at their feet.
42:24I'd say they were starving.
42:26And rather than let his little girl suffer, he ended it for both of them.
42:31Doesn't matter now.
42:32No.
42:34Doesn't matter now.
42:49I've known you a long time, Dundaren.
42:52All right.
42:53I think the first time we met was at that tournament.
42:57And I always thought you were dull as dirt.
43:01You're not bad.
43:03I don't hate you.
43:04Don't like you, but you're not bad.
43:07Thank you, Clegane.
43:08That warms the heart.
43:10But there's nothing special about you.
43:13You're right about that.
43:15So why does the Lord of Light keep bringing you back?
43:19I've met better men than you.
43:21And they've been hanged from crossbeams.
43:24Or beheaded.
43:26Or just shot themselves to death in a field somewhere.
43:31None of them came back.
43:34So why you?
43:36You think I don't ask myself that?
43:39Every hour of every day?
43:42Why am I here?
43:45What am I supposed to do?
43:46What does the Lord see in me?
43:50And?
43:53I don't know.
43:56I don't understand our Lord.
43:58Your Lord.
44:00I don't know what he wants from me.
44:02I only know that...
44:05He wants me alive.
44:06If he's so all-powerful, why doesn't he just tell you what the fuck he wants?
44:10Yes.
44:14Clegane.
44:15Come over here.
44:18Don't worry.
44:19The fire won't bite.
44:22I want to show you something.
44:24It's my fucking luck I end up with a band of fire worshippers.
44:29Aye.
44:30Almost seems like divine justice.
44:33There's no divine justice, you dumb cunt.
44:35If there was, you'd be dead.
44:38And that girl would be alive.
44:47What do you want?
44:48Look into the flames.
44:50I don't want to look in the damn flames.
44:53You saw me bring him back from the dead after you cut him down.
44:57Don't you want to know what gave me the power?
44:59I keep asking and no one wants to tell me.
45:03We can't tell you.
45:04Only the fire can tell you.
45:19What do you see?
45:22Logs burning.
45:24Keep looking.
45:31What do you see?
45:42Ice.
45:44A wall of ice.
45:49The wall.
45:53What else?
45:54It's where the wall meets the scene.
45:59There's a castle there.
46:08There's a mountain.
46:11Looks like an arrowhead.
46:16The dead are marching past.
46:24Thousands of them.
46:32Do you believe me now, Plaguein?
46:35Do you believe we're here for a reason?
46:50Do you believe we're here for a reason?
47:08What the hell are you doing, Plaguein?
47:13Burying the dead.
47:27You knew these people.
47:30Not really.
48:01All right.
48:32We asked the father to judge us with mercy.
48:36We asked the mother to...
48:42Fuck it, I don't remember the rest.
48:50I'm sorry you're dead.
48:53You deserve better.
48:56Both of you.
49:01No.
49:12Yeah.
49:13Shh.
49:16Shh, shh, shh, shh, shh.
49:20Hey.
49:29You should really sleep, Sam.
49:32The dead don't.
49:44Legends of the Long Night.
49:48The Targaryens used dragonglass to decorate the weapons without even knowing what the
49:53first men used it for.
50:11What is it?
50:14It's a map of Dragonstone.
50:16The Targaryens built their first strongholding when they invaded Westeros.
50:23That's dragonglass.
50:25A mountain of it.
50:27Beneath the ground.
50:28Stannis told me, but I didn't think...
50:31This is important.
50:32John needs to know.
50:33Stay in theости.
50:36I love it.
50:49I got this.
50:54I know I got this.
50:57Oh, you do.
50:58I love it.
51:00I know.
51:02I love it.
51:03I need to goarape the stick with a ships, too, and then I saw a other nest.
51:26Has she come here?
51:29Who?
51:30The Dragon Queen.
51:32Daenerys Stormborn.
51:36Haven't heard anything.
52:03Ha ha ha.
52:12Yeah.
52:14Yeah.
52:16Yeah.
52:18Yeah.
52:20Yeah.
52:21Yeah.
Comments