- 3 hours ago
Finding March Madness' greatest non-champion
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00Every March, madness descends upon the college basketball universe when the NCAA tournaments
00:06unfold. While we always justifiably forever remember the champions who are etched into
00:11immortality, the best of the rest are seemingly relegated to the dustbin of history.
00:17But for so many unbelievable squads, that amounts to criminal negligence.
00:22For instance, when the 2015 Kentucky Wildcats men's basketball team was undefeated entering
00:27the Final Four, it was a foregone conclusion to so many, myself included, that they were gonna win
00:34it all. Until they didn't. Which Kevin McCallistered their Coach Cal. It raised the question to me of
00:42who the greatest non-champions of all time are, and where teams such as those 15 cats would fall
00:47within that pantheon of the greatest men's college hoop squads to have ever come up short.
00:51And I wanted to apply hardcore science to find out.
01:03To have some uniformity, we'll only be going back to the 84-85 season because that's when the tourney
01:08first expanded to 64 teams. That larger field makes the arguments substantially more compelling,
01:14and also captures the period where the strongest contenders reside anyway.
01:19My North Star in this endeavor will be the full-season per-game point differentials of
01:23every single Division I team. While not accounting for factors such as strength of schedule, it's still
01:29a great, pure way to assess a team's level of proficiency, certainly more so than, say, win percentage.
01:36To gather this heaping set of data with ultimate precision, I went to this website within StatHead,
01:42which provides the total points both scored and allowed by the well over 13,000 D1 team seasons
01:48played from the fall of 84 through the spring of 25. Following endless copy and pasting to a spreadsheet,
01:55I finally had consolidated all the pertinent team data I needed. After entering an extraordinarily complex
02:02formula, voila, I had all the per-game point differentials to form my y-axis. Another formula
02:10provides me with a single number to represent the season, reflected along the x-axis, and after some
02:15manual data reconciliations and corrections, a whole lot of abbreviating to make legible as many identities
02:21as possible, and some miscellaneous minutiae, I was all set to construct this bad boy. The first observation
02:29that jumps out to me is… oh dear, I hope Jerry Rice hasn't been watching the hoops of his alma
02:34mater.
02:35Woof. My second observation is that 22 of the top 24 per-game point differentials here were accomplished
02:43by teams that ultimately did not win their final game. The top complimentary sidekick to full-season
02:49per-game point differential, upon which I'll also lean quite heavily, is overall point differential in
02:55the tourney, which will underscore how dominant the top nonchamps were in that cauldron before they
03:00met their ultimate demise. Since we're essentially only talking teams that went either 4-1 or 5-1 in
03:06the tourney, you know, teams that were amazing but on one cruel day not quite amazing enough, point
03:12differential provides a more substantial delineation than does something like win-loss record.
03:17On a lesser level, the specific tourney round reached will also be considered along with other
03:22factors such as number of pre-tourney losses, the specific circumstances surrounding their demise,
03:28and strength of schedule. These ingredients help split the hairs that emerge when comparing teams
03:34soaring at such lofty heights. While some very worthy honorable mentions exist, we'll count down in
03:40reverse order the 5 greatest nonchampions. To kick it off, we've got the 2024-25 Duke Blue Devils,
03:48who in over 56% of their games smacked around their opponent by at least 20. Their super-duper star
03:54is
03:54the precocious Cooper Flagg, one of the most hyped college players ever and just the fourth-ever
03:59freshman to win National Player of the Year. Although even calling him a freshman belies his youth, as his
04:05accelerated path to Duke saw him play his first 11 college games as a 17-year-old fresh boy.
04:11Throughout the first 26 seasons of the 21st century, no team that resides outside Spokane,
04:17Washington can match their per-game point differential of plus 20.5. When the tourney rolls around,
04:24they cumulatively outscore their opposition by 91 points, the fifth-highest all-time mark by a
04:30nonchamp, and one that comfortably clears every other 21st-century nonchamp except 09 UConn. But
04:36they meet their demise in wicked fashion. After cruising all throughout their Final Four matchup
04:43with Houston, they hold a 14-point lead with just over 8 minutes left. They still hold a 7-point
04:49lead
04:49with 80 seconds left, but down the stretch at the worst possible time, a stew of missed free throws,
04:55turnovers, and one hell of a cold shooting stretch conspired to produce a collapse of epic proportions.
05:02Onto number 4, and the team that did initially pop in my head when thinking of scintillating nonchamps,
05:08we have those aforementioned 2014-15 Kentucky Wildcats. Led by the hyphen-heavy, two-headed
05:15monster of Carl Anthony Towns and Willie Cauley Stein, with Devin Booker coming in hot off the bench,
05:21they're just the second team in 24 years to enter the tourney with an undefeated record.
05:26Boasting a point differential per game of plus 20.1, it's seemingly a foregone conclusion that
05:32they're gonna complete the undefeated season, that they're gonna render the tourney, one in which they
05:37ultimately post a point differential of plus 70, as a sort of Kentucky Invitational.
05:43Especially up through a Sweet 16 bloodbath over West Virginia, the first instance a team doubled up their
05:49opponent that deep into the tourney since the 1940 Hoosiers did so over Springfield College in the
05:55second-ever tourney, one so primitive it started with the Elite Eight. They meet their demise in the
06:01Final Four after being in great position to win when, thanks to a six-minute Wisconsin scoring drought,
06:07they hold a four-point lead with six and a half minutes to go. Then, unbelievably, with a couple minutes
06:13of overlap, Kentucky immediately responds with their own six-minute scoring drought that dooms them.
06:19In a game rife with officiating controversy, I'd be remiss to not allude to the infamous,
06:25egregious non-shot clock violation that ties the game with under three minutes to play and changes
06:30the complexion of the final stretch, which they can't overcome. Cracking the top three is the 2020-21
06:38Gonzaga Bulldogs who enter the tourney with zero blemishes as they scored 21.3 more points per game
06:45than they allowed. Their tourney point differential of plus 83 is excellent, and despite not playing in
06:51a powerhouse conference, they still had a non-conference slate that was quite impressive,
06:56certainly more so than their neighboring dazzling seasons. Two of their first three games are wins
07:02over eventual top three seeds in the tourney. Game four is an 11-point win over eventual two-seed
07:08Iowa, and that kicks off an almost inconceivable streak of 27 consecutive 10-point wins that lasts
07:16through the Elite Eight. In their streak-busting Final Four matchup with UCLA, they still survive in
07:22advance on Jalen Suggs' astonishing bank from a mile away, becoming the first team to enter the title
07:28game with an undefeated record since the 79 Indiana State Larry Birds. Their demise occurs after a quick
07:35turnaround following their emotionally draining, overtime-requiring Final Four win. They come out
07:41completely gassed in the championship game against Baylor and fall behind 29-10 after 10 minutes.
07:47They're also thoroughly outclassed on the glass in a bitter 16-point loss. Down to what I feel is,
07:54in some order, the unequivocal top couple non-champions. For number two, the data would lean toward the 1990-91
08:03UNLV Runnin' Rebels. In their quest to repeat as champions, not only did Coach Jerry Tarkanian's
08:09squad win each of their first 34 games, but an astounding 26 of their first 31 were 20-point
08:16blowouts. Even including champs, their season-long mark of plus 26.8 is over two points better than anyone
08:23since 72 UCLA, and in the tourney they stand at a neat and nifty point differential of plus 69.
08:30This is a team who, up through the Elite Eight, played 40,800 second-half seconds of basketball,
08:37of which they trailed for 81 of them. But even more fascinating than that, one of their players is
08:43H. Waldman, the first person I've ever stumbled upon who's legitimately got a one-letter first name.
08:50But the journey for H and his multi-lettered teammates hits the end of the road in the final
08:54four. Up by five with two and a half minutes left, the Rebels are in the driver's seat late in
08:59their
09:00showdown with Duke, who seeks revenge after getting walloped by 30 in the previous year's title game.
09:06UNLV squanders that lead and finds themselves down two with seconds left, but still have a prime
09:11opportunity when the renowned Larry Johnson brings the ball up the court and could pull the trigger on an
09:16open three. Though instead, he dishes to the hot hand and his much better three-point shooting
09:22teammate, Anderson Hunt, who can't quite nail the off-balance game winner, which turns out the light
09:27on their sparkling run. Point guard Greg Anthony casts his vote for this experiment, and at the time,
09:33I'd say he was absolutely correct. But eight years later, things will change.
09:39Last but most certainly not least, we have the number one college basketball team of all time for
09:46whom a championship would ultimately prove elusive, the 1998-99 Duke Blue Devils.
09:53Armed with a trio of future NBA stalwarts, they reach the championship game, which they enter with
09:5825-point wins having constituted half their games and 20-point wins nearly two-thirds.
10:04That helps produce a per-game point differential of plus 24.7, a figure that, going back to the 72
10:11Bruins, trails only those 91 Rebels. They also unleash absolute hell in the tourney by scoring 123 more
10:20points than they allow, better than any other non-champ and 83 of the 86 champs here. And while they
10:27do drop a
10:28pre-tourney game, unlike 15 Kentucky, 21 Gonzaga, and 91 UNLV, said loss even provides an excuse to
10:36show you one of the wildest endings in the history of organized hoops. Tied with three seconds left
10:42against Cincinnati, the Bearcats' Ryan Fletcher, a high school quarterback, tosses a perfect downfield
10:48Hail Mary to Kenyon Martin, who deftly delivers a touch pass to Melvin Levitt for the go-ahead slam with
10:53one tick left. Shane Battier tries answering with his own miraculous Hail Mary that gets knocked
10:59right to a Dukie who stunningly banks it in… fractions of a second too late.
11:06That razor-thin loss is part of a relentlessly brutal schedule. Unlike 91 UNLV, who played in a
11:13weak conference and only really had one impressive pre-tourney win, 99 Duke competed in an ACC in which
11:20they twice played and twice beat eventual two-seed Maryland, plus thrice played and thrice beat
11:26eventual three-seed UNC. Then outside their conference, they played and beat eventual one-seed
11:32Michigan State, three-seed St. Johns, and three-seed Kentucky. Oh, also they have the second person
11:39I've ever stumbled upon with a one-letter first name, thanks to the unassailable logic of his father.
11:45The story associated with their demise is as simple as it is excruciating. A fantastic back-and-forth
11:52title bout against UConn comes down to the final seconds. Duke trails by one as guard Trajan Langdon
11:58looks to create a game-winning bucket, but Ricky Moore's suffocating defense forces a travel from
12:04which they cannot recover. I was a bit surprised before diving into this that a team who lost a
12:10regular season game would still emerge to produce what sure appears to be the best resume of a
12:15non-champion, perhaps even by a comfortable margin. They managed to overcome that loss on the back of
12:21their overall portrait of dominance, both all season and navigating as tough a schedule as there could
12:26be, and when isolating their March rampage that came down to the tourney's final possession. And even
12:32that November loss required Cincy pulling off the Sublime before Duke's own Sublime response just
12:39barely didn't count. Larry Johnson's 91 Rebels snagging a top-two spot aligns with perception,
12:45though 21 Gonzaga is a lot closer in their rearview mirror than I'd have thought, especially given the
12:50strength of their top quartet of regular season wins. But the combination of 99 Duke's placement
12:56on both charts, combined with their schedule and the last-second nature of their demise, is a seemingly
13:02impossible labyrinth to topple for any challenger that comes up short of the ultimate prize.
13:08So while that season's championship that they coveted more than anything wound up slipping through
13:13their fingers, those 99 Blue Devils can take at least a bit of solace in knowing that they,
13:18over all the other legendary teams who came up just short, can still stand tallest.
13:31Thank you all so much for watching and supporting Secret Base. If you haven't already, make sure to
13:36subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to get access to even more and see your name included
13:41alongside all these other distinguished folks, subscribe to Secret Base on Patreon.
Comments