- 2 hours ago
Judy Justice S04E51 Episode 51 Engsub
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:01You were in a rush, yes, ma'am.
00:03Okay, well, that's an answer, but it's not a good answer.
00:07I hurt. I was hurt.
00:09She wasn't hurt by this accident,
00:11and we're now driving around a vehicle with no A.C., no heat.
00:15Oh, my God, you know I'm going to get out my violin.
00:18This is Judy Justice.
01:00You claim that the other is responsible for an automobile accident.
01:02Yes, ma'am.
01:03Yes, ma'am.
01:04So why don't you tell me, Ms. Voss, when this accident took place, time, date?
01:08It took place on September 5th at 8.05 a.m.
01:13at the intersection of 31st Street and Yale Avenues in Tulsa, Oklahoma.
01:18Tell me where you were going.
01:19I was going to work.
01:20I see there's a monitor up. Is that a video of the location?
01:24It's dash cam footage from the accident.
01:26From you?
01:27Yes, yeah, it's my dash cam footage.
01:28Okay.
01:29Would you go over to that video and show me where you were?
01:32Absolutely.
01:32And then we'll get it moving.
01:35So these are the two southbound lanes on Yale.
01:40I was in the left turn lane.
01:43I had pulled forward just over the line when I had a green light.
01:47So the light turned yellow.
01:50I waited a beat and nobody was moving.
01:53So I went into my left turn where I was hit in the middle of an intersection.
02:00And I was hit so hard that my car was turned 180 degrees.
02:04Show me where the defendant was coming from.
02:07She was in this far lane right here.
02:09In the far lane?
02:10Yes.
02:11So there was a car coming to a stop because the light was yellow.
02:15And she, the defendant...
02:17Just a second.
02:18There was another car right next to her.
02:20In front of her that was coming to a stop.
02:22Well, how did she get around that car to hit you?
02:25She went like that.
02:27So she was behind that black car?
02:31No, it's like a silver...
02:33I think she's back here.
02:34It was a silver car.
02:37But that silver car came to the stop, came to a stop.
02:40And you can see the difference.
02:42But she went around that car?
02:44To run the light.
02:45Could you step back, please?
02:47Of course.
02:47And hit you?
02:48Yes.
02:49Okay.
02:50All right, Ms. Gladden, you want to tell me your version of what happened?
02:54Yes.
02:54So my version is pretty much the same thing as her version,
02:59except for from her dash cam, you cannot see my light at all.
03:03So even if the person that was...
03:06No, no, no.
03:07Not even if.
03:07I don't want you to tell me even if, shoulda, woulda, coulda.
03:09Yes, ma'am.
03:10I'm saying that I...
03:11My question is...
03:12I sped up to catch the yellow light.
03:14Did you go around a car that had stopped is my question.
03:17No, she had not stopped yet.
03:18Was she...
03:19She was slowing down, yes.
03:21So if the car in front of you was slowing down to stop because the light had turned yellow,
03:27why didn't you?
03:28Because I was hurrying my daughter to school.
03:30Okay, so you were in a rush.
03:32Yes, ma'am.
03:32Okay, well, that's an answer, but it's not a good answer.
03:38Now I'll see the video.
03:54Okay, so the car was slowing down and you sped up.
03:57Mm-hmm.
03:58Well, then it's your fault.
03:59I do.
03:59I have an insurance...
04:00Then it's your fault.
04:01Yeah.
04:01I have a police report.
04:02It's not my fault.
04:03I have a police report that says she's at fault.
04:05Just a second.
04:07I know what your insurance company said.
04:09Your insurance company wasn't there.
04:11Well, the police called.
04:12Yes.
04:12And did they arrive at the scene of the accident?
04:14Yes, they did.
04:16Now, you have the police report.
04:18May I see it, please?
04:19Yes, ma'am.
04:22Because of the court.
04:34Did you show this officer the dash cam video at the time the officer wrote this report?
04:41No.
04:42I had not submitted it probably by the time.
04:43When did you submit it?
04:44Later that day, the police officers emailed my husband a link, and I uploaded it via that link.
04:51Can I play that video one more time, please?
05:06I got over before they slowed down.
05:08Hmm?
05:09I got over before they slowed down into the other lane.
05:12No, he was slowing down.
05:13You went around him.
05:14I know.
05:15I went around him, but he wasn't, like, slowing down at the light yet.
05:18You can see in the video that I just got over.
05:21No, he was slowing down because he was yellow.
05:24Yes.
05:24Let's play it again.
05:28Now it's yellow.
05:29Yes.
05:30Now he's slowing down.
05:32And you went around him.
05:33Yes.
05:34It's your fault.
05:35And I made the yellow light.
05:36It's your fault.
05:38Did you have the car fixed or was it totaled?
05:39It was totaled.
05:40Did you have insurance?
05:41I did.
05:42Okay.
05:43I would like to add, I tried to file a claim against the defendant's insurance, and they
05:47told me that she did not have it.
05:49You didn't have insurance?
05:49It had elapsed two days before.
05:51So the answer was I didn't have insurance.
05:53Yes, ma'am.
05:54Okay.
05:54Good.
05:55And the insurance is under her partner's name.
05:58Whatever.
05:58It's not in anybody's name if she didn't have any.
06:01Yes.
06:01And then we got it reinstated that day.
06:03I have the paper that says that.
06:04Who cares?
06:05I don't care.
06:06You drove without insurance.
06:07How long were you driving without insurance?
06:09Three days.
06:11And you shouldn't have been speeding up to get your daughter to school.
06:16She wasn't hurt by this accident, and my family was.
06:20We're now driving around a vehicle with no AC, no heat, no nothing, and I have a baby.
06:25If your kids don't go to school, you have to go to jail for truancy, too.
06:29Oh, my God.
06:29You have to go to court for that.
06:30You know I'm going to get out my violin.
06:31And later today.
06:33This was money sent to you for her taxes and gratuities.
06:37You owe it to her.
06:38No, that is not what they sent it to me for.
06:40I have the cancellation policy that states that if she cancels within 60 days, she loses
06:46it all.
06:47Sorry, sorry.
06:48I don't believe it.
06:49I don't believe it.
07:00Kaylee Voss claims fellow motorist Jordan Gladden ran a red light and struck her vehicle.
07:07Jordan is countersuing Kaylee for the cost of her car.
07:11Okay.
07:12Just tell me what the damages were to your car.
07:14It was totaled.
07:16It was like $23,000 worth of damage.
07:18I had to come out with a deductible.
07:20We now have to pay tag, title, and tax on a new vehicle.
07:23Okay.
07:23What was the deductible?
07:25$500.
07:26What making...
07:27It was a 2023 Hyundai Kona.
07:29And when did you purchase it? In 2023?
07:32Yes.
07:32Almost a year.
07:33And you had insurance.
07:35Was there a loan on the car?
07:36Yes.
07:36Okay.
07:37So the loan covered the cost of the car?
07:40No, not all of it.
07:41We still owe about $2,000 on the car.
07:43Did you have gap insurance?
07:44Yes.
07:45So you had gap insurance.
07:46You don't owe anything anymore.
07:47The bank has totally paid off.
07:49Yes.
07:50Okay.
07:51So as far as actual damage is concerned to this vehicle, you were made whole by the insurance
07:58company.
07:59I was.
08:00So tell me what you're suing her for $5,000 for.
08:04I am suing to recoup the cost of the deductible, the tag, title, and tax.
08:08You mean the $500?
08:10Yes.
08:10The tag, title, and tax for my new vehicle that I would not have had to purchase.
08:15Um, I had to miss two full days of work and then four half days to go.
08:20Why?
08:21Immediately after the accident, I, I hurt.
08:24I was hurt.
08:25Um, she hit me very hard and my whole body was just aching.
08:28You didn't act like you were hurt after the accident.
08:30Ma'am, that's because I got out of the car and consoled you.
08:33Shh, just stop talking.
08:33You were over there laughing with the cops and making jokes and calling your husband.
08:37Yes, because.
08:38Ms. Gladden.
08:39Ms. Gladden.
08:40Don't talk to her.
08:41I just, she wasn't hurt by this accident and my family was.
08:45We're now driving around a vehicle with no AC, no heat, no nothing, and I have a baby.
08:51Just a second.
08:51I'm going to tell you a few things that you should keep in mind.
08:55A, you were driving without insurance, which means that you shouldn't have been out on
09:00the street because if you killed somebody.
09:03Yes, ma'am.
09:04You wouldn't have had insurance and it doesn't look like you have enough money in the bank
09:07to cover a major accident like that.
09:09And then also, if your kids don't go to school, you have to go to jail for truancy too.
09:13Oh my God, you know I'm going to get out my violin.
09:16You shouldn't have been driving without insurance.
09:19Your daughter's a big girl.
09:20She can take a bus to school.
09:22You're right.
09:23Okay?
09:24And if you were driving her, I saw the way I, the light was yellow.
09:28The car in front of you was slowing down.
09:31You moved around that car and sped up and the light was clearly yellow for a while before
09:38you did that.
09:38And there's no question in my mind that you knew the insurance had lapsed.
09:41And if you're driving around now in a car that's less of a car than what you were driving
09:46around in before, that's your fault.
09:48You've got to say that was my fault.
09:50I didn't have insurance and I sped up at a light that was turning yellow.
09:55But she says she didn't see any cars coming.
09:58How can you see in that video that obviously I'm coming?
10:01Like you can't.
10:01I can see it.
10:02Exactly.
10:03No, just a second.
10:04I can see that you sped up.
10:05Exactly.
10:06So how didn't she see that?
10:07She said she looked, but she didn't.
10:09I was in my turn.
10:10Just a second.
10:11Who can anticipate you're going to put your foot on the gas?
10:14Most people do at yellow lights.
10:15Okay.
10:15Ms. Gladden.
10:16I know it's my fault.
10:17Oh, okay.
10:18Well, if you know it's your fault, then it's, shh.
10:22Sorry.
10:22If you know it's your fault, then it's your fault.
10:27Okay.
10:27Now, did you go to a doctor, hospital?
10:31I did.
10:31I went to the Tulsa Accident Center.
10:33May I see the report, please?
10:38The top line are medicines that they prescribed me.
10:42One was a muscle relaxer and the other is for inflammation.
10:44I can read.
10:50Okay.
10:50So they didn't find anything wrong in the MRI?
10:53Not anything?
10:54Yeah.
10:54Just inflammation.
10:55Okay.
10:56What kind of work do you do?
10:57I'm an HR assistant.
10:58Okay.
10:59And you didn't work for a couple of days?
11:01Yes.
11:01Two days.
11:01Just a second.
11:02You got paid for those days?
11:04No.
11:05I'm an hourly employee.
11:07Okay.
11:08Judgment for the plaintiff and the amount of her deductible, $500.
11:11We're finished here.
11:12Thank you very much.
11:13This court is adjourned.
11:20Um, I'm just upset about it because the other lady was not hurt by this accident at
11:26all and my family was.
11:27And now we didn't get anything out of it.
11:30I was not at fault and Judge Judy found that to be correct.
11:34The impact, I remember that I tried to swerve to miss her and she just kept on driving.
11:39And if she would have stopped when she saw me, I wouldn't have hit her.
11:42I was afraid.
11:43Um, I, I mean, still now I have anxiety driving just because she came at me really fast and hit
11:49me very hard.
11:50I feel like she ran the red light.
11:52I feel like she ran the red light.
11:52Always have a dash cam and don't drive without car insurance.
11:56So I'm going to propose that every state legislature that handles motor vehicles, think about a law that imposes a
12:09strict rule that if you're driving a car without insurance and you're stopped for a moving violation or in an
12:17accident and you have no insurance, it's an automatic suspension of your license for six months.
12:24Period.
12:25Maybe then people wouldn't drive without insurance.
12:28Yeah.
12:28Just sounds totally logical to me.
12:31You're placing a lot of people, including yourself at risk.
12:34And if you can't afford insurance for a car, take the bus.
12:37Yeah.
12:38But you're not supposed to drive a car without insurance.
12:40Insurance is mandated by law.
12:44Case 4065, McCoy versus McCaslin.
12:46All parties, please come forward.
12:49Shara McCoy is suing her sister-in-law, Tonya McCaslin, for a refund of cruise fees after Shara was unable
12:57to take the cruise.
12:59Ms. McCoy, the defendant is your sister-in-law.
13:02Yes.
13:02And your sister-in-law won a cruise trip.
13:06You won it to the Caribbean, but you won it in Missouri.
13:09And she asked if you wanted to join her on the cruise.
13:13You said you would.
13:14And the understanding was that there were certain things that were part of the winnings, but there were certain expenses
13:21that were not.
13:22And you each agreed to pay your own share of the expenses that were not covered by the prize.
13:28And your share of the expenses, according to you, was about $1,200 that you paid towards the cruise.
13:36The total I paid was $1,392.
13:39Okay.
13:39I'm asking.
13:40Shhh.
13:42The cruise was supposed to take place on what date?
13:45August 11th through 18th.
13:47And you decided not to go.
13:49And it is your claim through this case that your sister-in-law received a refund from the cruise line
13:56that was for the amount of your expenses,
14:00because you actually called and canceled the cruise to the cruise line, correct?
14:04Yes.
14:05And you want that money.
14:07That's what your lawsuit's about.
14:09Yes.
14:09Great.
14:12What you say is she approached you at a restaurant and threatened you, I assume, after this incident with the
14:19cruise, as it had to do with money.
14:20And she threatened to beat you up.
14:22Yeah.
14:23Okay.
14:23And then you say, I ended up in a hospital.
14:26Yeah.
14:36Shara McCoy claims her sister-in-law, Tonya McCaslin, is responsible for refunding her the cost of a cruise she
14:44never took.
14:45Tonya is countersuing Shara for emotional distress.
14:50Now, your sister-in-law says that she did not receive any money from your share from what you had
14:57put in,
14:58and that you, in fact, did receive a check from the cruise line in the amount of $250.
15:04Did you receive $250 from the cruise line?
15:08No, I did not.
15:09Did you receive any money?
15:10No, I did not.
15:11Nothing?
15:12No.
15:12Okay.
15:13Now, your sister-in-law does not dispute the fact that you each put in your own expenses.
15:18Is that correct?
15:19Correct.
15:20But she says that she did not receive any money back that was ascribed for your ticket because she actually
15:28went on the cruise.
15:29Yes.
15:30With a current boyfriend.
15:32At the time, yes.
15:33There was no longer your boyfriend.
15:35Yes.
15:35Okay.
15:36So what you have to do is to show me, Ms. McCoy, proof that she received a refund.
15:41That makes the case very simple.
15:43Okay.
15:43I have two emails.
15:45Sure.
15:46From whom?
15:46From the cruise line.
15:48May I see it, please?
15:49Yes.
16:03Okay.
16:03Now, the cruise line said in two different correspondence that they refunded to MasterCard a refund for her taxes and
16:16gratuities in the amount of $801.96.
16:19And that was for her taxes and gratuities, and it was credited to your MasterCard ending in 0207.
16:31You want to see the letters?
16:43Yes.
16:44Yes, I got it.
16:44However...
16:45Now the ball is in your court.
16:47Okay.
16:47So the refund is actually for...
16:51No.
16:51I don't want you to tell me.
16:53This is clear from the cruise line that this was for the plaintiff for her taxes and gratuities in the
17:01amount of $801.96 that was credited.
17:05And they say, go contact this person whose credit card it was credited to.
17:11So now I want you to show me, not tell me, show me why you don't owe her $801.96.
17:20Here is where I was double charged $668 for airfare twice.
17:26I don't care what you were overcharged.
17:28That's you to deal with an airline.
17:30They sent $801.96.
17:33That was her money.
17:35They credited it to you.
17:36The airfare is through the cruise line.
17:38It wasn't through the airline.
17:39This had nothing to do with airfare.
17:41It was for taxes and gratuities.
17:43And here I have a letter as well that says that we are...
17:46Just a second.
17:47Let me see it.
17:47Okay.
18:04What are you showing me?
18:05It says that they gave you $801.96.
18:07Yes, for the double charge of the airfare.
18:10On my reservations.
18:12Just a second.
18:12Just a second.
18:13Where does that say?
18:15That has anything to do with airfare.
18:17Where does it say?
18:18Well, on there it doesn't say that, but that's what it's for.
18:20It doesn't say anything about airfare.
18:20I have two different invoices where they double charge me for the airfare.
18:24Then you deal with that for...
18:25Listen to me.
18:26Madam.
18:27I did deal with them and that's why I got the money back.
18:29You may deal with them.
18:30On the airfare, this was money sent to you for her taxes and gratuities.
18:35You owe it to her.
18:36No.
18:37That is not what they sent it to me for.
18:39They sent it to me because they overcharged me.
18:41I have both confirmations.
18:42Sorry, unless you have proof to show me that the reason they sent you this was for airfare.
18:50So far you didn't show me anything that suggests that the reason that they sent this had to do with
18:55double billing you anything.
18:57Okay.
18:57I have the cancellation policy that states that if she cancels within 60 days, she loses it all.
19:04Sorry.
19:04That is why I...
19:05Sorry.
19:06Sorry, sorry.
19:07Sorry, sorry.
19:08They sent you 801-96.
19:11You owe that to her.
19:12That's her money.
19:13That wasn't deposited on my credit card.
19:15I don't believe it.
19:16It...
19:16I don't believe it.
19:17That was deposited on his credit card, not mine.
19:20I don't...
19:20Listen.
19:21All I can tell you is...
19:23You see this?
19:24Your name, your credit card account, 801-96, was for her taxes and gratuities.
19:33That's what you owe her.
19:35801-96.
19:36Now I'm dealing with your counterclaim.
19:39You want to tell me what your counterclaim is about?
19:42My counterclaim is for harassment and medical inducement of a seizure.
19:50Just a second.
19:52What you say is she approached you at a restaurant and threatened you, I assume, after this incident
19:59with the cruise as it had to do with money.
20:01And she threatened to beat you up.
20:03Yeah.
20:03Okay.
20:04And then you say, I ended up in a hospital.
20:07Yes.
20:08Okay.
20:08On what date did she approach you in a restaurant?
20:12July.
20:12It was a bar and it was July 24th.
20:15And you had a conversation with her.
20:17No, she had...
20:18I didn't talk.
20:18She had a conversation with you.
20:20Yes.
20:20She yelled at me.
20:20And on what date did you go to the hospital?
20:23I went two days later because it all messed up.
20:25Two days...
20:26You went two days later.
20:27Yes.
20:28You have a hospital report.
20:30No, I do not.
20:31Well, then you have a dismissed counterclaim.
20:34Judgment for the plaintiff in the amount of 801-96.
20:38She's not getting it.
20:45I said I want my money and she said no.
20:47She came in and she threatened to kick...
20:49Hit me and threatened to beat me up.
20:51She said she wasn't going to pay me.
20:53I have PTSD.
20:54I lost my husband.
20:56And so it just added up and then I had severe seizures afterwards.
21:01I have no idea.
21:02I think it was because of the guy she was seeing.
21:04There was no more relationship at all with them.
21:09That case was easy, of course.
21:11Yeah.
21:11But as I was doing it, I was thinking to myself, I don't think I've ever won anything.
21:18You know, even at bingo.
21:20Used to play bingo when you went away for a weekend.
21:23You know, bingo for an hour.
21:26And then I bought raffle tickets.
21:29And I know people who win all the time.
21:32Yeah.
21:33And to have this joyous feeling.
21:36Exactly.
21:36We're lucky in other ways, I guess.
21:37Yeah, I guess.
21:38Other ways.
21:38I guess.
21:41Are you a victim of an assault?
21:43Go to judyjustice.tv.
21:46Go to judyjustice.
21:46Go to judyji.
21:47Go to judy.
21:47Go to judy.
22:13Go to judy строity.
Comments