Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 hours ago

Category

šŸ“ŗ
TV
Transcript
00:02my mom called me a liar from the day i was born not because i actually lied but because of
00:07this
00:07thing around my neck the verity choker mom was luna of silver moon pack and she believed one
00:12thing above all lying was the mark of a weak wolf we were her daughters future alpha heirs
00:18weakness was not an option so when my twin sister emma and i were born mom clasped these chokers
00:25around our throats which had witch magic to detect lies green light means truth red light means you
00:30were lying emma's choker always green she could shred mom's ceremonial cloak and blame the cat
00:36and gem would glow a steady green not me green light believed me mom i'm hungry and flash red
00:46light the choker choked tight i shifted on instinct a small white wolf pawing desperately at the gem
00:53around my neck claws scraping against it unable to get it off i'm not lying not lying please but mom's
01:00eyes had already gone cold instant punishment mom's punishment wasn't gentle no food locked in my room
01:07no contact with anyone in the pack the truth necklace doesn't lie stella starve now study later
01:13i'm doing this for your own good after 10 years of this i started believing it too maybe i really
01:19was
01:20born wrong new year's eve everything changed mom was getting ready to take emma to the pack's bonfire
01:26celebration and that's when the pain hit like a knife twisting in my gut i collapsed on the floor
01:31my skeletal frame curling into itself mom please the choker flashed red and choked tight she looked down
01:40at me disgusted in her eyes in your dream stella faking an illness to ruin our night she grabbed emma's
01:48hand and headed for the door i wanted to howl but my wolf was too weak to answer i shifted
01:54anyway forced
01:55it a small white wolf trembling on the floor ribs heaving maybe in this form the pain would hurt less
02:01it didn't i couldn't even hold the ship i slipped back into myself without meaning to sorry mom i won't
02:08lie anymore but the pain got worse way worse the door handle turned for one second i thought mom's
02:15coming back she came back for me hurry up the bonfire is starting emma's waiting mom i reached out with
02:23a
02:23shaking hand please something's really wrong i feel like i'm dying she glanced at my neck the gem was
02:30flashing red over and over she crouched down grabbed my chin stella how long are you gonna keep this up
02:37can't you just be honest and stay here and think about what you've done dad appeared in the doorway
02:44honey should we at least leave her some food food she has a stash of snacks she bought with stolen
02:51money she won't starve lock the door when that gem turns green we'll talk but but what it's because
03:01you spoil her that she turned out this way look at emma her gem has always been green stella is
03:08a liar
03:08an alpha heiress who can't tell the truth she needs discipline but my cabinet was empty emma stole that
03:16money emma ate those snacks emma just stood there with her glowing green gem saying not me and mom
03:23believed her i tried to defend myself it wasn't me red light the choker choked tight i tried to shift
03:31nothing happened deep inside my wolf barely stirred mom locked me up for three days with nothing but water
03:39and stale bread mom turned to leave emma peeked through the door made a face at me bye sis we're
03:47gonna see the bonfire her gem glowed a steady green so pretty the door locked the house went silent i
03:55called my wolf nothing came back not even a whisper just me alone the pain was unbearable but i kept
04:04thinking mom's right the gem doesn't lie it's red so i must be lying i'm not in pain i'm not
04:13in pain i'm not
04:15in pain i kept repeating it like a prayer eventually i almost believed it the pain dulled or maybe i
04:25was
04:25just going numb i crawled to my desk i had to write that was the rule if the gem glowed
04:32red i had to pen
04:33a thousand word apology or mom would never let me out i am a liar write it down and maybe
04:41mom would
04:42forgive me maybe she'd even let me out i opened my journal pages and pages of apologies i'd written
04:49over the years sorry i lied i won't do it again but this time i wanted to write the truth
04:56my vision
04:57blurred my hand shook as i wrote mom i really love you it really hurts why won't you believe me
05:06please believe me just once the moment i finished the last word the pain vanished just gone i felt light
05:16weightless i looked down i was floating and there slumped over the desk was my body motionless
05:25the gem still flashing red around a dead girl's neck oh i'm dead and then she came out my wolf
05:34stepping out of my body like she'd been waiting all along small skinny barely holding together
05:41she looked up at me and once soft and low in the pack's old stories they say when a wolf
05:49dies young
05:50her spirit doesn't cross over alone her wolf walks beside her until they find the door together
05:56i knelt down she pressed her nose into my ghostly palm finally we were together now but i never learned
06:05how to be honest sorry mom i heard laughter mom dad emma coming through the front door tonight's bonfire
06:13was beautiful the best one yet just like our emma perfect in every way i'd never heard her sound
06:22like that when she talked about me i floated toward them my wolf patting silently at my side
06:27moving on instinct i wanted to help them take off their cloaks that's what i always did mom my arms
06:34passed right through her body like wind is it so cold here is the hearty out i stood there staring
06:42at
06:42my transparent hands my wolf pressed against my leg and looked up at me with sad eyes right dead wolves
06:49couldn't hug the living shall we go and see stella she hasn't eaten yet still the good cop i looked
06:56at mom
06:56hopefully if she found me dead would she be sad would she regret it she won't starve she is a
07:05werewolf
07:06not a human pup this whole fake sick for attention thing is out of control i laughed bitterly mom wasn't
07:14wrong werewolves heal but i hadn't been able to in a long time last winter the choker left bruises that
07:20stayed for days that hadn't happened before i reached for my wolf she was still there but
07:26the warmth never came she was too hungry just like me mom never noticed she only ever looked at my
07:35neck for one thing the gem and whether it was red or green mom pushed open my door didn't even
07:42turn
07:42on the light just for a second her eyes flashed gold her wolf might have known mom didn't listen
07:48in the dim glow from the hallway she saw me slumped over my desk i looked like a skeleton hadn't
07:55moved
07:55still putting on an act you're 10 years old not five grow up mom i'm not playing i'm dead look
08:05at
08:06me touch me i'm freezing she couldn't hear me she only believed what she wanted to see emma squeezed
08:13past her held up her choker with that smug little grin look my gem is green stella's is still red
08:20she's lying even in her sleep that's my good girl ignore the liar let her stay there maybe she'll learn
08:28how to be honest should we at least put her in bed it's freezing put her in bed look at
08:35that red gem
08:36still lying come on leave her we have to visit grandma tomorrow the door locked again i floated
08:44next to my corpse my wolf curled silently at my feet staring at that single point of red light in
08:50the
08:50darkness mom if you just stepped closer if you just touched my hand you'd know i was ice cold but
08:57you
08:57didn't you believed the choker not the daughter you carried for nine months that night a rat crawled out
09:04of my empty cabinet i used to scream whenever i saw rats but now i just floated by the ceiling
09:10watching it
09:11scurry across my dead body the rat bit into my toe i didn't feel anything my wolf charged at it
09:17anyway
09:18and passed right through landing on the other side she turned back to look at me confused lost i pulled
09:26her close and buried my face in the fur of her back it's okay you can't feel it anymore it'll
09:32be over soon
09:34she let out one low growl then went still against me finally no more pain for either of us the
09:41next
09:42morning sunlight streamed through the window no warmth reached my body in the kitchen i could hear mom
09:48making breakfast the smell of roasted meat crept under my door my favorite but mom always said liars don't
09:55deserve meat so i only ever got steamed vegetables she was clanging the pots extra loud on purpose trying to
10:02tempt me out trying to make me give in and apologize for things i never did in the old days
10:08i might have
10:09caved i might have confessed to anything for one bite of roasted meat but i don't need food anymore
10:16stella still hasn't come out yet dad asked reading the pack notices she is so stubborn she can eat or
10:23not
10:23i don't care emma walked to my door and made a big show of sniffing the air then she screamed
10:32dramatically mom stella's room smells like poop did she poop in there i floated by the door watching my
10:40sister with a bitter smile my wolf sat beside me ears flat eyes low the hearth was burning hot after
10:49just one
10:50night my body started to rot mom stormed over pounding on the door stella who does that the toilet
10:58is right there did you sit on the floor to spite me i remembered being six i had food poisoning
11:05couldn't
11:06make it to the toilet in time mom didn't help me clean up she made me stand outside pointed at
11:12me
11:12and told the neighbors look at this she's such a mess she can't even use the toilet herself now she
11:19thought i was dirty again leave her let her sit in her own stink but dad stood up frowning that
11:27smells
11:27really bad i should check could it be a dead rat or something my heart if i still had one
11:34lept
11:35dad please open the door i'm right here just turn the handle and you'll see i'm not moving
11:42i waved my transparent arms frantically my wolf ran straight to my bedroom door willing dad to open
11:50it dad's hand touched the door handle his hand froze one was pounding at the front door a pack elder
11:56urgent business dad's face went pale he grabbed his cloak the border there's an emergency he was already
12:03out the door i froze so close one second away if that knock had come one second later i would
12:10have
12:10been found maybe then i wouldn't have rotted alone that afternoon mom took emma to the pack market the
12:16house was empty except for my corpse when they came back that evening loaded down with food and gifts from
12:21the market the smell had gotten worse mom gagged the second she walked in stella are you trying to turn
12:28this place into a den of inequity she didn't even open my door just grabbed cloth strips and sealed
12:33the gap at the bottom if you want to stay in there and make disgusting stew zoos don't stink up
12:38my
12:38house she patted her hands together satisfied then went to prepare dinner i stared at that sealed door
12:44my wolf pressed her nose against it and whimpered once so that's it i'm worth less than a venison dinner
12:49by day three even the cloth strips couldn't contain the smell mom was arranging fresh wildflowers trying
12:55to cover it up but the stench of death is unmistakable sweet rotten oily she cut a rose stem too
13:02hard
13:02a thorn pierced her hand she snapped in her mind i was doing this on purpose not bathing poop on
13:09the
13:09floor hiding dead rats in my room all to piss her off all to defy her authority as luna stella
13:16she
13:17grabbed a rolling pin from the kitchen stormed toward my room i'm done with you you disgusting
13:22little brat time you learned what real pain feels like i floated in front of her waving my arms desperately
13:29don't come in mom please please even though she never loved me i didn't want her to see me like
13:37that but she walked right through me ripped the cloth strips off jammed the spare key into the lock
13:43the door flew open the smell hit her like a wall she stumbled back retching stella what are you doing
13:50she saw me still slumped over the desk back turned not moving to her this was the ultimate rebellion
13:56i'm talking to you she marched over raised the rolling pin but stopped she wanted to see my face
14:04first wanted to see my get up she grabbed the back of my shirt grabbed my skin the moment she
14:10touched me
14:10she froze through the thin fabric her hand didn't feel warm flesh she felt cold hard dead meat the kind
14:18of cold that seeps into your bones what but momentum carried her forward she yanked crash my body stiff
14:25as a board toppled backward taking the chair with it and there was my face blue black eyes bulging
14:31features twisted in agony dried foam and blood crusted around my mouth around my blackened neck
14:37the verity choker hung lifeless the gem dark no red no green just silence my journal slid off the desk
14:46fell open at mom's feet the last page stared up at her mom my stomach really hurts the choker is
14:52wrong
14:53i'm not lying please don't punish me mom screamed not a wolf's howl a raw guttural shriek that tore
15:01through her throat she stumbled backward slammed into the bookshelf a clay pot shattered
15:07but she didn't seem to feel the pain she just stared at me eyes wide unglinking
15:14no no no no this is not real stella get up stella get up get up i'm not mad anymore
15:22stop scaring me
15:25her hand reached out trembling to touch my arm the second her skin made contact with my corpse
15:31she recoiled like she'd been burned that cold was too real lisa from next door heard the screaming and
15:38went straight to the pack healer when she saw what was in my room she collapsed in the gate within
15:44the
15:44hour heavy boots on the floorboards the pack healer and a handful of pack warriors crowding the entrance
15:51mom sat on the floor a warrior's hand on her shoulder she's speaking it she's always lying
15:59it doesn't lie i'm just teaching her no one responded they all looked at her like she was a
16:05monster the pack healer crouched next to my body he muttered under his breath severe malnutrition
16:11organ failure this puppy has been starved for at least a month he carefully tried to remove the
16:18verity choker but it had fused years of tightening had pressed the leather deep into the skin of my neck
16:25damn it he had to use tools to pry it off even dead my soul flinched my wolf lifted her
16:32head and
16:34long raw desperate the kind of howl that should have shaken the walls no one heard it no one flinched
16:42we were already dead a warrior picked up my journal started reading his face went from neutral to
16:49horrified mom's eyes locked onto that book that's her confession she admits she lied look she wrote it
16:57herself the warrior pushed her back wrapped the journal in cloth and took it we'll report it to the council
17:06that's when dad got home he saw the pack healer and the pack warriors crowding the doorway
17:12saw the body wrap being carried out saw the long cord that sealed away my entire life his legs gave
17:20out
17:20he collapsed on the doorstep emma stood nearby sobbing in confusion she pointed at the discolored
17:28verity choker on the table why does stella have a black collar and i have a green one see she
17:34held up her
17:35neck the gem blinked its steady green it was grotesque the council elders arrived before dawn
17:42mom straightened when she saw them even now even with my body three days cold and rotting her luna
17:49instincts kicked in she lifted her chin squared her shoulders it didn't work today they started
17:56questioning mom in the living room mom grabbed the verity choker off the table like it was a lifeline
18:02test it that choker proved she was lying red gem means lie i never abused her the choker told me
18:13i was just educating her the council elders looked at her like she'd lost her mind the pup shows signs
18:21of
18:21extreme malnutrition months of starvation aphelion multiple old injuries consistent with prolonged
18:29that's just discipline that's teaching her to be honest then she did something insane you don't
18:37believe me fine i'll wear it watch it'll be green the leather pressed against her skin cold sticky that
18:50was my blood she took a deep breath tried to calm herself she needed to prove she was innocent needed
18:57to
18:57prove her way of raising an alpha heir was right she held up the gem eyes wild listen i'm rachel
19:05i'm stella's mother this is the truth the absolute truth the gem flashed red mom's confident expression
19:14shattered i said truth i am rachel i never abused her i did it for her own good
19:26i love her and suddenly she remembered me ten years old gasping as the choker tightened around my
19:35throat biting my lip so i wouldn't make a sound is this what it felt like why is it red
19:42i am telling the
19:43truth turn green you're broken you're setting me up but the gem kept flashing like it was mocking her
19:50you're a liar you're a liar you're a liar enough this is just a bloodstone i've seen it before it
20:01changes
20:01color with body heat fear pain anything that makes your heart race temperature rises it burns red that's all
20:11it does no witch magic never was think about your daughter ruptured appendix organ failure the pain
20:20must have been unbearable she was terrified and what did you see a red gem so you punished her more
20:28which made her more scared which made her temperature rise which made the stone turn redder
20:38you are luna you are supposed to protect every wolf in this pack you couldn't even protect your own
20:46daughter you ignored her cries for help you starved your daughter to death mom's world collapsed she sat
20:54there staring at the flashing gem on her own net and finally understood for 10 years every red light
21:01wasn't because i was lying it was because i was scared scared of her anger scared of being misunderstood
21:10scared of eating food that made me sick i was in pain pain that made my heart race and cold
21:16sweat pour
21:17down my face i was desperate desperate for a hug for her to hold me the way she held emma
21:24every signal
21:25from my frightened heart she had interpreted as proof of my lies no get it off
21:35i'm not lying i'm not she tried to shift fur rippling across her skin bones cracking but the leather
21:43cinched harder around her throat the moment her neck began to change she snapped back into human form gasping
21:51i can't get it off stella take it back i'm sorry it's all my fault this little bit of choking
21:59and she was
22:00already breaking mom i suffered for 10 years the council elders needed evidence for judgment so they opened
22:10my journal in front of my parents february 14th sunny mom put celery on my plate i'm allergic my throat
22:19swells
22:19i can't breathe i said i can't eat it but because i was scared of making her angry my body
22:25ran hot
22:26the gem flashed red the choker tightened mom said i was picky lying made me eat the whole plate that
22:36night
22:36i threw up blood my throat felt like it was on fire i shifted to ease my pain mom saw
22:43it and said i'd snuck
22:44berry juice that i was faking the choker tightened for 10 more minutes mom's hand flew to her mouth
22:53she was shaking violently she remembered that she really did think it was berry juice she didn't
23:00even look closely just turned away to read emma a bedtime story that was blood from a swollen torn
23:08throat june 1st pups day emma shredded mom's ceremonial cloak emma's heart is always calm her gem stays
23:17green i tried to explain but i was scared of being hit my body ran hot red gem choker tightened
23:26for 10
23:26months it hurt so bad but i didn't cry because crying makes your body run hotter and mom thinks that
23:34means you're not sorry so i held my breath pretended it didn't hurt mom said see she doesn't even blink
23:44she's definitely faking it dad couldn't take it anymore this man who had always put the pack before
23:50his own family chose duty over his daughter for 10 years you monster what did you do that was your
23:58daughter you treated her like a stray blood at the corner of her mouth not my fault not my fault
24:06it's
24:07her it's emma emma's gem was always green emma was a good one if it wasn't for that green light
24:14making me trust her i wouldn't have believed the red light so much this is emma's fault that little
24:20princess everyone who protected one of the council elders walked over gently removed the green verity
24:27choker from her neck took out a blade pried the gem loose right there it rolled onto the table still
24:34glowing green steady unchanged the elder picked up the stone a glowstone that is all your younger
24:43daughter's choker was always going to shine green no matter what she said did or lied about it would
24:51never change your so-called verity choker was a fraud that was her truth for 10 years that was the
25:00evidence she used to convict me a common glowstone that put me in hell while emma lived in paradise
25:07so i wasn't a liar i i laughed laughed until i cried turns out ghosts could cry too the elder
25:14turned to the
25:15last page of the journal his voice broke the handwriting was a mess clearly written while dying mom if i
25:23die
25:23will the choker stop glowing red or if it turns green will you hug me then i'm not lying i
25:29couldn't
25:30heal myself anymore my stomach hurts so much like knives next life please don't make me wear the choker
25:38please i just want to be a normal pup i want to eat mom's roasted meat mom stared at the
25:44broken glowstone
25:45on the table that truth magic she trusted without question a worthless stone because of that stone she
25:52spoiled emma for 10 years because of that cursed red light she tortured me for 10 years
26:02mom started laughing her voice cracking in every sound worse than crying fake all fake
26:14i killed my most honest pup and i worshipped a liar she'd lost her mind for real this time my
26:23death became
26:23the talk of the entire pack lisa the neighbor who had sent for the pack healer told everyone what she'd
26:29seen every wolf knew by morning luna had starved her own daughter to death monster murderer she doesn't
26:39deserve to be luna stones flew at our door the word killer carved into the wall the council convened within
26:47the day the verdict was swift dad lost his alpha title no wolf would follow him now my grandfather
26:55the former alpha read out the judgment himself he didn't look at his son once dad walked out of the
27:02council hall and never looked back he took emma and left the pack that same night emma was a bad
27:08seed sure
27:09but she was still his blood before they left emma tried to take her green choker dad stomped on it
27:16why the hell would you want that piece of trash emma cried as he dragged her away mom got out
27:22of the
27:23dungeon the healer said she had lost her mind the council locked her in the home instead the one
27:29that still smelled like death her mental state deteriorated fast she refused to take off the red
27:35choker she would tighten it herself whenever the guilt got too heavy she said choking was the only thing
27:41that eased it it was her self-imposed punishment i floated in the darkness my wolf curled beside me
27:48watching her unravel day after day she'd talk to the empty corner where i used to stand stella i brought
27:54you some food no celery today it's all roast just how you like it but there was no food there
28:02was
28:02nothing just her hands cupped around air she'd pretend to set a plate down her hands shook the gem
28:09flashed red she was anxious guilty falling apart she smiled but her eyes were empty
28:16the gem is red mom is lying liars don't deserve food she pulled the choker tight with her own hands
28:24let it choke her her body convulsed against the cold floor it hurts so much is this how stella felt
28:33i'm sorry mom started reenacting my diary entries i couldn't eat celery because of my allergy
28:41so she forced herself to eat spoiled food until she vomited blood then swallowed it back down i was
28:47locked in isolation so she locked herself in my old room lights off and bowed to my portrait
28:54until her forehead bled over and over blood on the floor late at night she'd see the red glow of
29:03the bloodstone reflected on the wall to her it looked like my bloody eyes were watching she kept
29:09punishing herself the wounds healed slower and slower her wolf exhausted by months of self-torture
29:17slowly fell into a deep sleep mom didn't care she scrawled on the back of my journal i'm sorry
29:24i was wrong red means pain red means love please come back and say it hurts hurts one more time
29:32i'll save you i promise too bad i'm dead dead wolves can't cry for help eventually the new alpha
29:39intervened mom's self-harm had gone too far she'd nearly choked herself to death with her own hands
29:46he ordered her to move to a small hut at the far edge of the village locked from the outside
29:51someone
29:52posted to watch her day and night she was the strangest woman they'd ever seen nobody knew where
29:58she'd found it a frayed red cord tied around her own neck her homemade choker if anyone tried to remove
30:06it she'd snap at them teeth bared snarling wild-eyed don't touch me stella's watching
30:15she'll be angry if you take it every time the guard called her name and brought her food mom would
30:21grab
30:21the red cord and pull it tight against her own throat convulsing screaming red light red light
30:29don't punish punish me i'll eat i'll eat even if the food was scalding hot she'd gulp it down burning
30:37her throat wouldn't spit it out she was reenacting my final moments living my hell on repeat years
30:45later emma grew up without guidance and with a trail of shame behind her she drifted from pack to pack
30:51stealing to survive no one would take her in when she ran out of options she remembered mom was still
30:59alive she slipped back into the silverman pack under the cover of night not for love for money hey crazy
31:08lady dad's dead give me whatever you've been hiding emma stood there face hard eyes full of
31:15contempt she looked at mom's hollow broken form and spat on the floor it's disgusting give me what i
31:23want or i'll send you to meet your daughter for a moment mom's cloudy eyes cleared she looked at emma
31:30and suddenly remembered that choker that always green glowstone that decade of deception it's you you lie
31:41you're the green light that wasn't there you killed stella give her back to me give her back to me
31:49the last shred of maternal love twisted into something feral mom lunged grabbed emma by the throat
31:57should have died not her you
32:02emma thrashed but couldn't break free from a mad woman's grip the guards rushed in pulled her off emma
32:09stumbled out of the hut terrified they're all insane she bolted into the forest she didn't get far
32:17rogues the kind that haunted the borderlands preying on anyone foolish enough to run through the trees
32:23alone at night emma never saw them coming by the time she did it was too late she survived barely
32:31both
32:32legs shattered beyond repair she'd never walk again meanwhile mom was strapped to her cot
32:38staring at the ceiling tears streaming in her dreams she finally saw me i was 10 again no choker
32:47white dress smiling mom she reached for me crying with joy stella but the moment her hands touched me
32:56i burst into ash no she woke up screaming if she'd been wearing that choker it would have been blood
33:04red eternal torment i stood in the void watching it all mom strapped to her bed emma in a wheelchair
33:12begging on the market dad drunk and dead in some gutter i felt nothing no satisfaction just a flat dead
33:20calm my wolf padded over quietly she didn't howl didn't nudge just pressed her head against my hand
33:28and held it there in the distance a door of light appeared soft steady waiting i looked at my wolf
33:35she
33:36looked at me yeah time to leave this life was too bitter nothing worth holding on to i floated to
33:43mom's
33:44hut one final time she looked ancient hair completely white frail as paper she sent something her
33:50cloudy eyes focused on a point in the air right where i stood stella is that you her trembling hand
33:56reached into the emptiness mom destroyed the choker i don't believe in it anymore come back please i'll
34:03cook for you no salary i'll buy you new dresses not emma tears rolled down her face i looked at
34:09the
34:09red marks on her neck from the frayed cord i i reached out my cold ghostly finger touched her forehead
34:16this was my final mercy sleep mom in sleep there's no pain her eyes fluttered shut she slumped into a
34:23deep dreamless rest a breeze blew through the hut the old journal on her cot flipped open the last page
34:30my dying words stared up at the ceiling but below it in shaky handwriting were new lines written by mom
34:37during a lucid moment next life let me wear the choker let me be the liar punish me however you
34:43want
34:44just don't leave me i stared at those words felt nothing too late repentance means nothing to the
34:50dead mom i don't hate you anymore but i don't love you either let's not meet again i turned away
34:57my wolf was waiting in the distance the door of light still glowed soft steady patient i looked at
35:03my neck the phantom verity choker still there even in spirit form the nightmare that had changed me for
35:10a lifetime i grabbed it it shattered into nothing i felt weightless free no red light no hunger no lies
35:17just freedom my wolf pressed against my side together we walked toward the light i didn't look
35:23back morning came a guard pushed open the door rachel time to eat no response she walked closer mom's
35:30hand clutched the torn journal a single tear crystallized at the corner of her eye she crouched
35:35beside her held two fingers beneath her nose nothing she was gone
Comments

Recommended