• 9 months ago
In this episode of 5 Live, watch an India Today special investigation that exposed the unauthorised sale of GLP-1 weight loss injections, including Mounjaro, Wegovy, and Ozempic, in chemist shops and online in Delhi-NCR.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Hello and welcome. This is a special broadcast here on 5 Live. I'm Sonal Merodra Kapoor.
00:06Now the team and I have put together a very special broadcast for you over the next one hour.
00:11So stay tuned because this one is an eye-opener.
00:15The world is calling them miracle drugs, skinny pens, fat melting injections, basically GLP-1.
00:25The biggest pharmaceutical breakthrough of our time.
00:27But here's the uncomfortable question.
00:30In India, have these very powerful prescription drugs become just another over-the-counter trend?
00:39Our hidden camera investigation spanning several weeks and months now have found that no prescription means no problem at all.
00:50A phone call to the neighborhood chemist and a munjaro or a vigovy is arranged by the evening.
00:5610% discount included. No doctor required.
01:01In the second leg of our investigation, we went online to very popular e-pharmacies.
01:07There as well, just a few clicks.
01:09No questions.
01:11Within hours, these drugs were at our doorstep.
01:14Like making a food order online or maybe making any, you know, delivery online.
01:22No physical consultation, no lab tests, no verification, no doctor needed.
01:29Now these are not cosmetic supplements.
01:31These are potent drugs meant for diabetes in certain cases, in other cases for weight loss as well.
01:39But they are being bought by people who want to lose a few kgs before a wedding or perhaps go on a holiday and make a quick fix.
01:47But before you fall for this trend, I'm sure you've seen all celebrities and wondered why is suddenly the world getting slim.
01:58This is the reason why.
01:59But before you decide to get on this trend, watch this report.
02:04We tried e-pharmacies.
02:34Some phone calls and a few clicks.
02:45And there you go.
02:46The most powerful drugs for weight loss in the world are in our hands.
02:51Like ordering a dolo or perhaps just getting some food delivered online.
02:56We are talking about what has been hailed as the biggest drug innovation of our times, GLP-1 or weight loss injections.
03:11The same injections which in India by the end of 2025 crossed 100 crores in sales, selling more than augmented.
03:32Clearly the world and India can't have enough of these skinny pairs.
03:37And while it has been projected to bring down the global obesity burden, the bigger question doctors are raising is its misuse.
03:46GLP-1 drugs are not just weight loss drugs.
03:51They're actually medications like your blood pressure medication and of course your diabetes medication.
03:57Do not use these drugs on your own.
04:00You have to check with your doctor whether you're a candidate or not.
04:04The dosing, the indication, the adjustment of dose, management of side effects.
04:10Please do not venture into this journey on your own.
04:14Do not use them for short periods.
04:16Do not use them for purely cosmetic reasons.
04:19Striking words from a leading doctor of the country.
04:23But while domain experts and endocrinologists like Dr. Amrish Mittal have better sense of who these skinny pens are really for.
04:31Or perhaps not for.
04:33They also tell us that it's hard to say no to those people who come to their clinics determined to drop for cosmetic reasons.
04:42For example, somebody would pop up to a clinic saying I need to lose 3 kgs before my wedding.
04:48Or 5 kgs before a beach holiday.
04:50Or maybe some people who think they are fat.
04:53But it's all in the head, right?
04:54Seasoned doctors are aware that if they say no, these very determined people will dangerously self-prescribe.
05:05Which got us thinking.
05:07How easy or difficult could it be to procure a GLP-1 injectable without prescription?
05:14Without any doctor verification here in the national capital?
05:18Our reporters and producers spent months and weeks really to bring you this reality check.
05:28We started by calling our local chemists.
05:32Hello.
05:34Hello.
05:35Yes, brother. I'm talking to you.
05:38What?
05:39You need a weight loss injection.
05:42Is it Monjaro or Vekovie?
05:45Which one of the ones in Monjaro?
05:46Monjaro is 2.5 mg.
05:49It's not even in the evening.
05:50Today?
05:50What's the price?
05:52Today?
05:52What's the price?
05:53The PMR is Rs. 13,520.
05:57This is about 10% of it.
06:0010%?
06:00Placed the order over the phone.
06:02And then wearing our mics and hidden cameras, stepped out to collect the medication.
06:08I had a message for Monjaro.
06:10It's been medicine.
06:12There are two health-well journalists here.
06:14One pretending to be a bystander, and the other who actually placed the order.
06:19What's the price of Monjaro is Rs. 13,520.
06:26Okay.
06:27And the discount is Rs. 11,813.
06:31Okay.
06:32Okay, give it to you.
06:37What is this donation?
06:38Rs. 8,000.
06:39What is this donation?
06:40Rs. 8,000.
06:42Rs. 11,813.
06:43Rs. 11,000.
06:44What is this donation?
06:45Rs. 11,000.
06:46What is this donation?
06:47What's this donation?
06:48This donation is very small.
06:49This donation is over.
06:50It has a service.
06:51OK, here is the donation.
06:53This donation, the donation is over.
06:53Okay.
06:55What does this happen?
06:56The donation is over.
06:57What does this donation do?
07:00There are many people in our house.
07:02Will it be?
07:03Injection will it be.
07:04Injection will it be.
07:05Will it be?
07:06Yes.
07:08The donation will come.
07:09Do it?
07:10Do it.
07:11Yes, it will be.
07:12I need a bill for this.
07:14Can you give me your name?
07:16Yes, my name is.
07:20$11,813.
07:24Do you need a doctor's name?
07:26No, do it.
07:32And then, if you want me next month, then I'll tell you.
07:36I'll tell you in the morning.
07:38You'll get a few hours.
07:40I'll tell you in the morning.
07:42I'll tell you in the morning.
07:44Payment is made.
07:48Drugs procured.
07:50Assurance for further supply also given.
07:54But no questions asked.
07:56No prescription required.
08:00But what if one chemist was in aberration?
08:03So we decided to try one more.
08:05It's the same drill.
08:06Order is placed over the phone.
08:08Our investigative team reaches the spot to collect it.
08:12What are you going to do now?
08:14What are you going to do now?
08:16$12,050.
08:18$12,050.
08:20$12,050.
08:22$12,050.
08:24What are you going to do now?
08:26What are you going to do now?
08:28What are you going to do now?
08:30You want to pay your bill?
08:32You can pay a payment of $12,050.
08:42I want your bill.
08:46Again, no hesitation, payment made, drugs procured, bills given.
08:52No questions asked again.
08:54He in fact has even boasted about how popular the drug already is in the neighbourhood.
09:16So, two neighbourhood chemists provided us with GLP-1 injectables, Bonjaro to be precise,
09:26without any hesitation.
09:28But then, it got us thinking, is it only one brand that is available freely?
09:33What about other popular brands?
09:35So for the next leg of our investigation, we tried e-pharmacies, two very popular ones.
09:41And this time, we placed an order online for Vigovi.
09:45Now, if you have ever tried these e-pharmacies, you already know that they ask,
09:50or at least are supposed to ask, for a doctor's prescription.
09:54Now, we don't have one.
09:56What did we do next?
09:57Check it out.
10:07This item needs a prescription.
10:09But there is also this option that if you don't have a prescription, no problem,
10:13we'll arrange a free online consultation with a qualified doctor.
10:17So, I am saying continue without prescription.
10:21Standard delivery is by 11.30pm.
10:24We asked for doctor prescription from Booster e-pharmacies and it was no trouble.
10:29Hello.
10:30This is Dr. Lokesh from Tartamaram ji.
10:32Yeah, hi. This is Dr. Haritia speaking.
10:34Regarding your medication, Vigovi is 0.25 order, right?
10:37What is the current height right, ma'am?
10:38Five feet?
10:40And the weight is 70 kg.
10:43Any other medical issues apart from this or any kind of food allergies?
10:46No.
10:47Apart from obesity, should we have any other medical condition, ma'am?
10:50No.
10:51I just take medicine for hypothyroidism.
10:54No other complaints, no other issues, something like that, right?
10:57No, no, no.
10:58Please process my order.
11:00Yeah, of course not.
11:02You should also have taken the phone.
11:06It was delivered the same day within hours.
11:09This is Vigovi 0.25 MG.
11:14Forget going and collecting.
11:16Forget hidden cameras.
11:18E-pharmacies delivered the meds at our doorstep.
11:22With a very legal or at least legal looking doctor's prescription.
11:26Payments, they were all made online.
11:28Receipts are provided as well.
11:30There is technically nothing illegal about the process.
11:35Except the massive abuse of these very powerful medications.
11:41Which in bad hands can create havoc with your body.
11:44But you know more on that in just a bit.
11:47First, let's move to the third chapter of this investigation.
11:51While researching the story, something else came to the fore.
12:05There are no guidelines on who should or should not take the drugs.
12:09I'm on this website called Active.
12:11Which offers what it says is its unique combination of medication and personalized support.
12:18It offers a new generation weight loss injection.
12:21It doesn't name the injection though.
12:23But it says it offers that injection meal plan and a fitness plan.
12:28It's now asking me to punch in some details like height, weight, date of my last weight checked.
12:35It's also asking me for my target weight.
12:38And I'm punching in all these details.
12:40It's also asking me now for a bit of my previous medical background.
12:47And there is one thing here I want you to know.
12:49And that is it also asked for a full size picture of me to actually gauge whether I am overweight.
12:56I did not share that picture.
12:58I actually put on the website that I will share it later.
13:02And despite that I am now on a page where it says that according to the details I have filled, I qualify for the plan.
13:09It also says in real time, I don't know how is that possible.
13:13But it shows a statement by a doctor who is a general surgeon.
13:18And it says that I have considered your medical background and set up a treatment plan that supports safe and steady weight loss.
13:26So basically it's asking me to place an order for the product.
13:30I am now placing an order for the product and let's see what happens next.
13:34So I have filled in all the details here.
13:36I have ordered the product and it says that I will now receive a call from their customer care executive and possibly a call from their doctor.
13:46Let's see if that happens.
13:48A few hours later, a customer service person did call.
13:51But they didn't ask for any doctor consultation as advertised on the website.
13:56It just said the details will be verified by a medical professional.
14:00Nobody verified those details.
14:01No doctor called either.
14:03We just received a prescription in just a few hours.
14:06And soon after, the drugs arrived.
14:09It took us just a few hours.
14:15Some phone calls and a few clicks.
14:18And there you go.
14:19The most powerful drugs for weight loss in the world are in our hands.
14:26No need to see any doctor physically.
14:28No test recommended.
14:30Some formality questions asked, but that was about it.
14:33Without any fuss, in certain cases, smooth delivery happened at home.
14:38Like ordering a dolo or perhaps just getting some food delivered online.
14:46Under the Indian drugs norm, medicines like Manjaro, Vigovi are not casual pills.
14:52They are specialist drugs, meant to be prescribed only by endocrinologists or internal medicine specialists.
15:00And they are not cheap.
15:02A month's starting dose of Vigovi costs around 10,800 rupees.
15:07Manjaro starts at about 13,000.
15:10Despite that, people are buying them like everyday supplements.
15:15But why exactly is it so dangerous to self-prescribe these skinny pens?
15:19Many patients think that this is a magic drug.
15:26This will solve the problem of their obesity in no time.
15:31If somebody takes these weight loss drugs without prescription, the patient may be in trouble because of the side effect itself.
15:40Side effect could relate to gastrointestinal symptoms, vomiting, diarrhea, constipation, or severe abdominal pain, sometimes pancreatitis holes.
15:52Now these are serious problems which may lower the blood sugar as well as blood pressure and may land the patient into the hospital.
16:03And we have admitted such patients for dehydration and as a result of dehydration, their organs may get damaged.
16:11Doctors warn that even those who think that they can take GLP-1 for a short duration should think again.
16:18Because what you lose is not just fat, also your muscle.
16:22Meaning, in most cases, the minute you stop the drug, most of the weight if not more does come back.
16:29Every time we lose weight rapidly because of any reason, whether it's diet or whether it's GLP-1 molecules, whether it's surgery, we also lose muscle along with fat.
16:42So roughly 20-30% of the weight lost in actually muscle.
16:46And if you then put it back on after losing it, you will end up with more and more fat because the muscle won't come back so easily.
16:55We reached out to both Eli Lilly and Novo Nordis for a response to our reality check.
17:00Eli underlined that it neither promotes nor endorses the off-label use of Trezapatide for any individual or its use for cosmetic weight loss.
17:10From Novo Nordis, the India Managing Director Vikrant Shrothia told us that the company strongly discourages misuse and emphasizes a doctor-driven, science-backed approach.
17:22There is no doubt GLP-1 is the biggest pharma breakthrough of our times.
17:27But every breakthrough requires guardrails.
17:30GLP-1 is powerful.
17:32But here is the part nobody is speaking out loud.
17:36That the real risk has not even hit us.
17:39In just a couple of months, as patents expire, the prices are set to drop close to 90%.
17:45And these drugs then can slip from medical care into a lifestyle demand.
17:50Driven by algorithms, not doctors.
17:52Also, the pill versions are not very far away.
17:55And the day prescriptions feel as casual as a dolo, the line between treatment and trend disappears.
18:04The government of India now has a very small window to regulate before convenience outruns caution.
18:13So, the breakthrough is not the danger.
18:16But the moment it feels like a pill, like a dolo, it could just be.
18:21From the Health Wealth team, this was a special investigation.
18:42All right.
18:43While you've seen that entire report, let's put out a very clear disclaimer.
18:47The intent of this entire reality check has been to understand the ground realities.
18:53To bring you with awareness about what these injections can and cannot do.
18:58This in no way means that you should now start following this trend as well.
19:02Always, always, even if you're considering these skinny pens, even if you see it on your favourite celebrities, your favourite stand-up comic or your favourite sports star.
19:13Everybody from Oprah to some local names here in the country as well.
19:18Do not follow trends.
19:20Go to an endocrinologist.
19:22We've done a detailed report as well, also available on our website, on the tests that you must get done before you even consider getting started on these drugs.
19:33These very, very powerful drugs.
19:35But, like we said, always, always take a doctor's advice.
19:40We're talking about them.
19:41Let's welcome two of them on the programme.
19:43Joining us next is Dr. V. Mohan.
19:45He's the chairperson of the Dr. Mohan's Diabetes Specialist Centre.
19:48And also with us is Dr. Rajiv Kowal, a general physician and diabetologist as well.
19:54Dr. Mohan, let me come to you first.
19:56You just saw the entire reality check.
19:58I think nobody's really surprised by it.
20:02We all knew that it was happening.
20:05What we've managed to do with the Health Wealth team at the moment is just capture all of that on camera as evidence.
20:12Do we have any questions to tell people that A, do not, in caps lock and underline, do not self prescribe.
20:18And also perhaps the question to the government on how will regulations come?
20:24How should they be enforced when in just a month's time, these drugs are going to become much cheaper
20:29and in another six months, they're going to be pills?
20:32Yeah, thank you Sonal. I was also horrified watching this.
20:39I did not know for sure that this is happening, but now from your report I can see that it's actually a reality
20:47and people are able to buy it online, they're able to buy it without a prescription, go to a pharmacy.
20:52This is very scary as was shown earlier in your program.
20:57There are a lot of side effects with these drugs.
20:59These are not drugs like taking an apple or buying something else or even like buying a B-complex.
21:07Even for those I think there should be prescriptions because I have been taught in pharmacology
21:12when I was a student that you can be allergic to anything under the sun including the sun itself.
21:16And therefore when you're taking medicines and that too powerful medicines which work on the brain,
21:22these drugs work on the brain, they're not just working on the stomach.
21:25The number of side effects which have been shown, thankfully they are not that common,
21:30but the common side effects are still there.
21:32The nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, constipation, loss of energy, these are very common.
21:37Most people have this at least in the beginning stages, but in the most serious ones like pancreatitis,
21:43stomach paralysis, occasional cases of blindness, thyroid tumors, all these have been reported in the literature.
21:50Thankfully they are not that common.
21:52So certainly without a doctor's prescription and preferably an endocrinologist or a diabetologist prescription,
21:58these should not definitely 100% be used.
22:02They are not something like you go and buy a skipping rope in a sports store or buy a weight or something like that.
22:09Even that should be done under supervision I feel because there are people who die even after doing those kind of things in a gym and so on.
22:16So these are not things to be played about with for sure.
22:19Dr. Rajiv, has this investigation shocked you?
22:24Did you know of it already?
22:26Now that you have evidence, what is it that you would like the government to do about it?
22:30It has shocked me, but I knew this must have been happening because the seals are very, very high.
22:38Importantly, I think every prescribed molecule on a prescription should have a validity.
22:44And the chemist should be allowed to give that only as per the validity of the prescription.
22:49And if that is followed, then whether it is any GLP-1 or an antibiotic or anything, nothing can be abused.
22:56Because today a person is allowed to call up the pharmacy and get the medication he wants,
23:01whether it's an antibiotic or whether it's an antipsychotic or whether it's a diabetic.
23:06I think once that regulation comes in place, then the misuse and the abuse of prescription will not happen.
23:12Today somebody whom I have prescribed 10 years back could just call up and get an antibiotic for example.
23:19So I think these are disease modifying drugs that the doctor ideally goes through multiple algorithms
23:27to find whether the patient fits the right criteria for these drugs and then prescribes it.
23:32And it should be valid for only the validity of the prescription.
23:37He will write whether it's for one month or two months or three months.
23:40But Dr. Rajiv, in India that's not the case, right? It doesn't happen.
23:44It doesn't happen.
23:45Forget these very powerful drugs. Forget drugs that are costing almost 13,000 every week.
23:5013,800 to be precise, every week. People are still buying it. There's an obsession with them.
23:55Which what, you know, makes me think about, I'm sure you guys have anecdotes as well.
24:00Dr. Mohan, tell us, I'm sure patients are coming to you and saying we want these skinny pens.
24:07How are you responding?
24:09No, no. We have very strict criteria and unless they satisfy a weight criteria, unless they are going to use it for a medical condition,
24:19purely for cosmetic reasons, we don't prescribe this.
24:23And only if it is indicated, only after a thorough evaluation, a baseline evaluation is done.
24:28For example, we talk about pancreatitis. So, measuring as amylase or lipase, looking at whether it's fatty liver.
24:35Because even to assess the response, we need that.
24:38It's not just the weighing scale alone.
24:40Is your fatty liver coming down? Is your blood pressure coming down? Is your sugar coming down? Are lipids improving?
24:45All that you have to see. Who's going to see that when you go and do that?
24:48And then similarly, if changes are occurring in the body, that also has to be monitored.
24:52So, only strictly speaking, understood. But then, I think Dr. Rajiv Kowal brought up a very important point.
24:58That it's now, because we are discussing a weight loss drug and it's a costly drug, we are discussing it.
25:03What happens and paracetamol was shown. It's not like buying paracetamol.
25:07Do you know that taking paracetamol can damage your liver? So, people don't know that.
25:11They think it's only a cross and it's only a calpolis, only a paracetamol.
25:14Even that on long-term use can cause damage. So, I don't think any drug, for that matter,
25:19should be sold without a prescription or under without a prescription.
25:21I'm not sure if Dr. Mohan can hear me. So, let me take this question. You can. Okay, great.
25:26I was trying to say this, Dr. Mohan, that, you know, if somebody goes to a good doctor, like the two of you at the moment,
25:32I'm sure you will do your due diligence. But I also know of doctors who have told me,
25:36they find it very hard to say no. Because every time they say no, this is what will happen.
25:41They will go and they will self-prescribe. So, how do we draw the line here?
25:46That's something we can't prevent. How can we, if you tell them not to do something and they go and do it,
25:51that's beyond our control. But I think to the doctor community also,
25:55warnings should be told that unnecessarily don't prescribe. To the pharmacist, it should be done.
26:01Strict governmental action should be taken. I think at all levels. And then,
26:05the warning about these drugs that they are not 100% safe. They are fairly safe. But they're not 100% safe.
26:12They're not without any side effect. That message, I think, things like this will definitely warn the public.
26:18Dr. Rajiv, give me, share some experience with me. I was once sitting with an endocrinologist who told me
26:25that he was treating two brothers in the same family. Both the brothers were on GLP-1, but did not want their families to be told about it.
26:35Both brothers insisted that the doctor does not reveal their identity to the other brother who also comes to him.
26:43This is a very peculiar drug. It's making, it's got stigma attached to it because, you know, let's face it, obesity is a problem.
26:52In India, it is the root cause of almost 90% of the other diseases that we deal with. Right?
26:58This is something that we need to fight against. But is this the right way?
27:04I think majority of these users are using it for cosmetic weight loss. And that's not what the drug is indicated for.
27:11You're saying majority of them?
27:12Yes. And it is for type 2 diabetes and chronic weight management. That's extremely important.
27:18And also, what we have seen is that we start the patient on a 2.5 milligram dose and tell him to come after a month.
27:26And the patient comes after 5 months and he himself has uptreated his doses. And that should not ever be happening.
27:33And too, as you asked Dr. Mohan sir about the abuse of the drug.
27:39Now, if the patient fulfills the criteria for an anti-obesity medication, then only he can prescribe an anti-obesity medication.
27:46Whether he has a comorbidity with the liver or a sleep apnea or a kidney, then only it's prescribed.
27:52You can't prescribe an anti-diabetic or an anti-hypertensive to a patient who doesn't have the disorder.
27:58So, it's very important that we first recognize obesity as a disorder.
28:02We stage and classify obesity as a disorder.
28:05And then the prescriptions will be completely valid.
28:08And then the prescriptions will have waited as we are treating many other chronic metabolic disorders.
28:13And that needs to be impressed to doctor community as well as the patient community that this requires you to go back to the doctor, get it prescribed and then go back again for a follow up if you want to up titrate or down titrate your doses.
28:29It cannot be done on your own. That's what is happening and that's a dangerous trend.
28:32It's quite dangerous. Dr. Mohan, a lot of people, this drug, for the first time it's made medical news become headlines.
28:43Yeah.
28:44For all good and perhaps also bad reasons.
28:47We have a lot of people in the country who are saying, what have you done?
28:52These celebrities are going to be together.
28:55And when we can do celebrities, why don't we?
28:58People are saying when Serena Williams can do it, when Oprah Winfrey can do it, there are a list of celebs abroad who have confessed to it.
29:06In India, they keep very shush about it. They don't speak.
29:09But they are. We all know that they are on these anti-obesity drugs as well.
29:14So for a common person watching, they are saying, what are all these things?
29:17These people care about their life more than us.
29:20They have better resources and more connections and better doctors than us.
29:23How are they getting it?
29:25How do you answer that question?
29:27Oh, they must be 100% getting it under medical prescription.
29:31Because in those countries, it is tightly regulated.
29:34I can't go to the United States as a doctor and say, give me an antibiotic.
29:40I can't get it.
29:41I have had actual situations where I had a diarrhea and I have just got off a flight and I said, can you give me something?
29:47Go and meet a doctor.
29:48If you had to meet a doctor to take a two-week advance notice to get that,
29:53I have seen how difficult it is to get a prescription.
29:56So if some of the celebrities you mentioned are getting it,
29:59100%, 1000%, they are getting it only under strict medical prescription.
30:04They are not buying it offline like this.
30:06And the other thing is, let me tell you that these drugs are fantastic drugs.
30:10Let's not belittle their importance.
30:13For years, we have wanted to have drugs which can help you to lose weight.
30:18I have been in this field for 30-40 years now.
30:20And in the initial days, they would lose 1kg, 2kg.
30:23And I would say, why are you taking a drug to lose 1kg, 2kg?
30:26We never had drugs with which you could lose 10kg, 15kg.
30:31And now with terseptide, Monjaro, even 20kg in weight.
30:35We have never heard of that at all.
30:36And any time we had these drugs, they will be pulled off the market within 1 or 2 years.
30:40Some side effect will come and it will get banned.
30:42To the credit of these drugs, they have lasted now.
30:45Some of them have lasted now 5, 6 or more years.
30:48And while the side effects are there, they have lasted.
30:52So, we should give the credit to them.
30:55But that does not mean that you go and buy it off the shelf and then OTC and then you use it.
31:00That is very, very dangerous.
31:02And I must congratulate you and India Today for bringing this to the attention of the public.
31:09Because I think it is high time we did this before many more people developed side effects.
31:14So, Rajiv, let me give you the last word here.
31:17I want to understand what exactly is the downside of getting on these drugs.
31:23We also speak to so many people who say that it's okay, I can afford to pay 13,000 every month to look skinny and I'll do it.
31:32People often don't understand that the minute you stop the drug, all of the weight, if not more, actually comes back.
31:41Do you want to explain that phenomena to our audience please, Dr. Rajiv?
31:45Yes.
31:46So, let's not trivialize the science of these drugs by calling it just weight loss or cosmetic weight loss drugs.
31:54There's a lot of science behind it.
31:55It actually resets the brain and it resets the brain and reduces the craving and the hunger.
32:02But having said that, these drugs are for chronic weight management and when we say chronic weight management, it's a long term and sometimes it can be lifelong therapy also.
32:10Now, whether we continue the patient on the same dosage or we go down on the dosage depends.
32:16So, as we treat any other chronic metabolic disorder, this also requires to be given that importance and this requires to be long term treatment.
32:25So, there needs to be a lot of follow-up tests which needs to be done, a lot of body composition which will change with this, a lot of dietary changes needs to be regulated.
32:37So, there needs to be a lot of follow-up investigation which needs to be done and seeing that the patient, apart from losing weight, is also getting a lot of other benefit of weight loss.
32:46So, just talking about weight loss is not enough.
32:51It's a completely disease-modifying drug and it continuously will need the hand-holding of an expert all through the journey.
33:01Let's not trivialize the science.
33:03They are brilliant disease-modifying drugs.
33:06Whether we talk about obesity or sleep apnea or the liver or diabetes or all of them, they are completely disease-modifying.
33:13And for every percentage of weight loss, it's modifying something in the body.
33:17So, it requires expert guidance and expert monitoring all through your life.
33:22Yeah.
33:23Also, remember these are at the end of the day, these are medicines, right?
33:27Absolutely.
33:28Every medicine which works for your body has side effects.
33:30Powerful drugs.
33:31Powerful drugs.
33:32They are not simple drugs.
33:33We also do not have long term data on Indian bodies on what this will do.
33:36Yes.
33:37No, long term data.
33:38These drugs are only 5 to 6 years.
33:40We don't have 10 year, 15 year data.
33:41We don't have that and we don't have it specifically on an Indian, you know, genome makeup.
33:46Yes.
33:47We don't know how it reacts to our bodies as well.
33:48Correct.
33:49So, there's a lot that we still need to know about it.
33:51So, before you jump on the bandwagon and think, hey, that's a quick fix.
33:56Now, I don't have to worry about diets or anything.
33:58Let me just, you know, put this little skinny pen and I'm sorted.
34:03Think about the side effects.
34:05And please, I'm leaving all our viewers with this thought.
34:08Please, please go to a doctor.
34:11Go to an endocrinologist or a diabetologist and let them only understand your body and see
34:17if you're fit for this.
34:19Like we said, it's a miracle drug.
34:21It can really do wonders if you are the right fit and if you take it under doctor's guidance.
34:28On that note, thank you both for joining us on this very, very eye-opening investigation
34:32that we've had.
34:33But we're not done with the weight loss story just yet.
34:40There's another side to it.
34:42Let's explore that.
34:44Words like moti, bhaddi, lazy, unhealthy.
34:49These words aren't new.
34:51They are echoed through classrooms, family gatherings, comment sections, dressing rooms as well.
34:57You see a fat girl and for many the first instinct is to shame her for her looks.
35:02There's no remorse, there's no pause, there's no thought about the damage it does to a person.
35:08And maybe it was this relentless body shaming that has pushed many towards weight loss drugs.
35:15One being the comedian, Aishwarya Mohanraj.
35:19She now has made this very, very personal choice and started her weight loss journey with these drugs.
35:28She has also opened up about it.
35:30Talked about how for a long time she struggled with weight loss.
35:34She says that she tried everything.
35:36Strict diets, regular exercise, tried to stay consistent.
35:40But there were no lasting results.
35:43Listen in.
35:47Yes, I took Munjaro.
35:48To the unaware and uninitiated, Munjaro is tirsipatide, a drug which is used for type 2 diabetes management.
35:54And chronic weight management.
35:56And it's a weekly injection.
35:58That week, I lost 1 kg.
36:01That month, I lost 4 kgs.
36:04I took this drug every week for 6 months.
36:07And in these 6 months, my weight reduced from 74 kgs to 52 kgs.
36:13Now, let's do some questions you may have.
36:15Firstly, Aishwarya, would you recommend Munjaro?
36:17As a person who has used this drug, I would like to say, how no?
36:22Do not consider this video as medical advice.
36:24Consult ChatGPT.
36:26And after consulting ChatGPT, if you still feel enthused about this, consult a doctor.
36:31That's part of her video.
36:34She's not asking you to consult ChatGPT.
36:37You should not do that or Gemini or perplexity or anything else for that matter.
36:41Please ask your doctor.
36:42But what she's really trying to drive home the message is that it worked for her.
36:47She was a candidate.
36:48She went to a doctor.
36:49She did it the right way.
36:50And that honesty has actually drawn praise to Aishwarya.
36:54So, Harley Khan and others have lauded her courage to speak out openly.
36:57Because this isn't just about one comedian, right?
37:00For years, body positivity movement in India challenged these very beauty standards.
37:05Also remember, she's one of those very few, in fact handful, who have spoken up about it.
37:11While the rest of the industry on these pens has decided to stay mum.
37:19I got my first shot of Munjaro.
37:21So, finally someone said it.
37:23They lost a ton of weight, not just by eating right or working out, but by taking Munjaro.
37:28And I think it takes great courage to speak the truth.
37:31Aishwarya Mohanraj also said something very, very important.
37:34She said, please don't look at me for advice.
37:37Don't take advice from influencers.
37:39Talk to a doctor because that is the real conversation.
37:41Zenpik and Munjaro aren't weight loss trends.
37:44They're serious medical treatments.
37:46And they're only meant for certain people.
37:48Sometimes weight loss can be challenging.
37:50Because it isn't just about willpower.
37:52It can be hormones, insulin resistance, PCOS, thyroid metabolism.
37:58Injections can help, but they're serious.
38:00And they have side effects.
38:01They need tests and medical supervision.
38:04So, instead of asking who is taking it, we should ask ourselves who really needs it.
38:10And the only person that can answer that is a doctor.
38:14Wise advice.
38:15But for years, like I said, body positivity movement in India and across the world challenged these very beauty standards.
38:22Influencers and several others built powerful platforms celebrating the curves, celebrating the confidence and also self-acceptance.
38:31They told women that you don't have to shrink to fit in.
38:34That's true.
38:35But scroll today and many of those very faces, they look dramatically different.
38:41They say these are lifestyle changes.
38:43Is it really?
38:44But while no one owes the public an explanation for their body or the visual shift that has sparked these questions,
38:52has the narrative also changed?
38:55Is body positivity also evolving?
38:58Obesity now, remember, is increasingly recognised not as a cosmetic flaw, but as a chronic medical condition.
39:06There are a lot of weight loss drugs in the market like, you know, Ozempic, Manjaro, Vigobi, Suplasia or Peak as well.
39:12Now, these GLP-1 therapies, like I've said before on the programme, they regulate your blood sugar and appetite.
39:18These drugs mimic the gut hormones and reduce hunger, thereby slowing down digestion.
39:23You basically end up eating less and your body ends up burning more.
39:28And help patients lose that significant weight, sometimes in months.
39:32Originally, remember, if you don't know already, these were developed for type 2 diabetes.
39:37And then they found out that apart from just improving your blood sugar control and for boosting insulin,
39:44they also suppressed appetite and people ended up losing weight.
39:48Their dramatic impact on weight loss has expanded their use far beyond diabetic care.
39:54And they are now being used to manage obesity-like conditions, including PCOS and certain fertility challenges as well.
40:02But experts warn that these are powerful metabolic drugs and not cosmetic shortcuts.
40:10They require medical supervision and come with massive side effects.
40:14Ask anyone who's ever tried to take it, they'll tell you.
40:16And they are meant for those who medically qualify, not for those who are fat only in their head.
40:22There is also a heavy cost involved, remember.
40:25Aishwarya Mohanraj revealed she spent nearly 4,000 rupees or little more than that per shot.
40:31Starting dose of Manjaro can cost up to 13,000 rupees a month.
40:35Others are also around the same area, between 10 to 13.
40:38That raises another uncomfortable question.
40:41Medical weight loss becoming aspirational?
40:45As in, access limited only to those who can afford it?
40:48Because beneath the celebrity admissions, the influencer transformation and the trending hashtags,
40:53there lies a deeper issue.
40:55The stigma that exists.
40:57Pressure that still exists.
40:59Judgements that still exist.
41:01So whether you stay plus size or size zero,
41:04the real conversation isn't about shrinking bodies,
41:07it's about expanding empathy.
41:09And we are finally ready then to treat obesity as a disease,
41:13not as a punchline.
41:16Perhaps it's time also we stop policing bodies and start understanding them.
41:22Also, take it if you are these drugs at all under doctor's prescription
41:27to better your health, not better your image.
41:30That ain't happening so easily.
41:34All right.
41:37But like we said, not just Indian celebrities,
41:40there is a particular international celebrity
41:43who got into a lot of chaos for having endorsed these drugs.
41:49I think you know who I'm talking about.
41:51This is the icon of tennis, an inspiration to lax and lax of women,
41:55a role model, Serena Williams.
41:57She finds herself on the wrong end of the spectrum.
42:01If Aishwarya perhaps did everything right,
42:04she is being questioned for all her moves.
42:07The tennis great is now facing backlash following her appearance
42:10in the Super Bowl commercial promoting weight loss treatments
42:14offered by telehealth company Roe.
42:17Why? I'll tell you that in a minute.
42:19The controversy began last year when 23 times Grand Slam champions spoke publicly
42:23about her post-pregnancy weight loss journey.
42:26And it's hard.
42:27Anybody who's given birth will tell you that.
42:29After retiring from tennis and giving birth to her second child,
42:32Serena said she struggled to shed weight despite diet and exercise
42:36and eventually used a GLP-1 medication.
42:39A class of drugs, like you said, includes treatments such as Vigovie
42:42and other anti-obesity injections.
42:45The same year, Serena partnered with Roe, a US-based telehealth platform
42:49that prescribes GLP-1 weight loss medications.
42:52Her husband, Alex Sohanyan, also serves as a board member of that company.
42:59That connection intensified the debate.
43:04It intensified during the Super Bowl 60 when Serena is in a national television advertisement
43:10as part of Roe's healthier on Roe campaign.
43:13In the ad, she described losing more than 30 pounds
43:16and said that the treatment helped her feel healthier, more energetic.
43:19And following the broadcast, criticism surfaced across social media
43:22and in medical circles.
43:23Some critics also argued that featuring a global sports icon
43:27in a pharmaceutical weight loss advertisement could blur the line
43:30between medical necessity and lifestyle marketing.
43:33Others said that the ad risks oversimplifying complex prescription treatments
43:39that require clinical oversight.
43:42The episode again highlights broader ongoing debate
43:45about these GLP-1 weight loss drugs.
43:48Their rising popularity, high demand and the ethical questions
43:51surrounding celebrity promotion of prescription medication.
43:56But like we said, don't listen to Serena.
43:59Don't listen to Aishwarya.
44:00Don't even listen to us.
44:02Listen to your doctor.
44:04They know best.
44:05And please, please do not self-prescribe these very, very powerful drugs.
44:11Our appeal today after this entire broadcast actually goes out to the government of India.
44:15We are now appealing for them to put out the right guardrails
44:19because without that, an entire generation of people and a society,
44:24though facing obesity, will fall into another trap.
44:28Now the onus is on the government to ensure that these drugs fall in the right hands.
44:34On that note, we are going to slip into a break.
44:37Coming right back with all the other top stories.
44:40Delayed arrest, but speedy release.
44:43It took four days to arrest the Kanpur VVIP brat, but just six hours to release him.
44:49After four days of dodging the law, Shiva Mishra accused in the high-profile Lamborghini crash
44:54was finally put behind bars.
44:56But hours later, the court rejected the police application for judicial remand.
45:01Meaning the police did not want to interrogate him.
45:03They just wanted him behind bars.
45:05He is to be released now on a personal bond of 20,000 rupees.
45:09Shiva Mishra appeared in court and argued his case himself.
45:13Now in a mockery of justice as it were, the court merely directed him to cooperate with the police investigation.
45:19The Kanpur police have told the court that a wrong driver
45:22was deliberately presented and a false affidavit filed to mislead the probe.
45:28Police said that Mishra refused to cooperate when contacted for questioning and asked to sign a notice.
45:33Also, investigators have pointed to clear attempts to shield the tobacco baron's son.
45:39His name was earlier kept out of the FIR.
45:41Remember, a ghost driver made the scapegoat claims of no alcohol
45:45and attempt to all change the number plate as well.
45:48All of that, by the way, which is on camera.
45:51The epilepsy excuse that has been made, the sudden move to Delhi citing health crowns,
45:56and now a quiet escort from the crash site.
45:59A pattern that suggests projection actually seems like it's been written out for the movie.
46:04We've heard this script so many times.
46:06The case also exposes glaring lapses in the initial probe.
46:11No alcohol tests, no name, like we said in the FIR, and the list is so, so long.
46:16Serious questions now hang over the initial probe and the delays that followed.
46:21Here is a full report on all the exciting twists and turns on this case that you might have missed.
46:31...
46:38foreign
46:52foreign
47:08foreign
47:20foreign
47:26foreign
47:30foreign
47:36All right.
48:06More developments coming on that case.
48:08Is UP police now shielding the Kanpur VDIP rat?
48:11That's the question we took.
48:13And now we are getting news that courts are now pointing out at several lapses in the UP police investigation.
48:21As you heard just there from the lawyer who said that there were so many lapses,
48:24the court said that you've got to get your act in place.
48:27The court also found that the arrest procedure sort of contained legal flaws.
48:31This court also stated that police failed to properly comply with the legal process of serving a notice under Section 353 of the BNS's Act.
48:41Now, what exactly is this and how will this impact the future of this case?
48:48Let me cut across to my colleague Simar joining us for more on this story.
48:52Simar, you know there's a saying, now I'm a Kanpur girl so, and you've spent some time in Kanpur now, so you must have heard.
49:02There's a saying in Kanpur that,
49:04Chahe Karlo Dunia Tour,
49:07A Gajab Hai Kanpur.
49:09Okay, so this has been quite a Gajab case, as they say.
49:14Quite a Gajab investigation as well.
49:16What an investigation that first there was none, there were lapses.
49:20And now because of those lapses,
49:23the man is now free
49:24on a bail bond of 20,000.
49:27Tell me more about what exactly did the court say?
49:31What happened inside?
49:32Well, Sonal, talking about the police action and the court developments today,
49:43there has been clear statement from the court
49:45that it was a botched up investigation.
49:48The police did not follow the rule book.
49:50In fact, the court went on and said
49:52that the arrest of Shibam Mishra is illegal.
49:55You know, that's because the proper procedure was not followed.
49:58The court, in fact, observed that the notice
50:00which was supposed to be issued to Shibam Mishra,
50:03it should have been accepted
50:04and his signature should have been there.
50:06But the police side presented their facts
50:09that he had been evasive.
50:10He is not accepting the notice
50:12and he is not cooperating in the investigation.
50:14That's why they have arrested him
50:15in this very particular case.
50:16Now, why did the court make such statement?
50:18Let me just tell you.
50:19Because the sections that have been included in the FIR
50:21are so weak that the punishment for this case
50:24is less than seven years
50:25in the sections which have been included.
50:27Now, technically, as for the rule book,
50:29if the punishment is less than seven years,
50:33the police cannot arrest the accused.
50:34But then too, we saw that
50:36after there was pressure mounted
50:37from several sections of the society,
50:40the police arrested the particular accused.
50:42However, they made an argument
50:43that since he is being evasive,
50:45he is being non-cooperative,
50:46then police have the power
50:47to, in fact, arrest him
50:48under the section of, you know,
50:51evasing 35.3.
50:52So, that has been the argument
50:53in this very particular case.
50:54But the fact of the matter is,
50:56court, in fact, came down heavily
50:58on Kanpur police saying
50:59that the protocol and the rule book
51:01was not followed.
51:02So, now, that's an embarrassing situation
51:04for Kanpur police
51:05who have been claiming that,
51:06you know, they have done
51:08a top-notch investigation.
51:09Once, you know,
51:10their investigation came under the scanner,
51:13they alleged that, you know,
51:14even after several claims,
51:15even after the repeated claims,
51:17a claim that, you know,
51:18Shivam was not driving the car
51:20by the side of the council,
51:21a dummy driver was, in fact,
51:23introduced, then to Kanpur police
51:25claimed that we are going
51:26to arrest him.
51:27But arrest after four days,
51:29but then to just after
51:30four to five hours,
51:31he was allowed to go.
51:32So, that has been the situation.
51:33You know, a disappointing news
51:35for all the people
51:35who were expecting
51:36that the justice will be served,
51:37no matter how influential
51:39or rich the person
51:40or the guilty person accused is.
51:42But the fact of the matter is,
51:43But the cops have to figure it out.
51:45Like I said, Gajab case
51:46and Gajab investigation
51:48has happened in this case
51:49because even the courts
51:50are now saying that,
51:51what have you done?
51:52This has been a mockery
51:53of trying to, you know,
51:54figure out the reality
51:55in this matter at all.
51:56And that's why the man
51:57is now walking free.
51:59All right, we leave it there
51:59for the minute.
52:00Siman, thanks so much
52:01for joining us.

Recommended