00:00Dineklarang insufficient in substance ng House Committee on Justice
00:05ang dalawang impeachment complaint laban kay Pangulong Bongbong Marcos.
00:08Yan ay kahit may ilang miyembro nito ang naniniwalang sapatang nilalaman
00:13ng ikalawang reklamo para umusad.
00:15Ayon sa mga nanaig, walang naipakitang may direktang utos
00:19ang Pangulo kaugnay sa mga bintang sa kanya
00:21gaya ng umunoy budget insertions at allocables.
00:25Nakatutok live si Tina Panginiban-Heras.
00:27Tina!
00:30Mel, Emile, Vicky, insufficient in substance
00:36basa sa botohan ng House Committee on Justice
00:38ang dalawang impeachment complaints laban kay Pangulong Bongbong Marcos.
00:43Ask, Honorable Miss I.M.
00:46Pakalipas ang dalawang araw ng deliberasyon,
00:49magkasunod na pinagbotohan ng House Committee on Justice
00:52ang sufficiency in substance ng dalawang impeachment complaint
00:55laban kay Pangulong Bongbong Marcos.
00:58Unang sinalang ang impeachment complaint na inihain ng abogadong si Andre de Jesus.
01:03With a vote of 42 in favor of the motion,
01:11one against the motion,
01:17and three abstain,
01:20the chair therefore declares
01:23the impeachment complaint of the impeachment complaint of the Jesus insufficient in substance.
01:30Sunod na pinagbotohan ang reklamong inihain naman ng grupo
01:34ni dating partyless representative,
01:36Lisa Massa.
01:38With vote
01:39in favor
01:42of the motion,
01:45seven,
01:48and those
01:48against
01:50the motion,
01:5239,
01:54with zero
01:56abstention.
01:57The chair declares
02:01the Massa et al impeachment complaint
02:06insufficient in substance.
02:11Bago ang botohan,
02:12mahaba muna ang naging talakayan
02:14tungkol sa mga inilatag na grounds for impeachment
02:17ng dalawang reklamo.
02:19For a complaint to be sufficient in substance,
02:23let us all be reminded,
02:26it must do
02:26more than
02:28suggest
02:29wrongdoing
02:30by association
02:31or inference.
02:34It must plead
02:35facts
02:36with particularity
02:38showing that the official
02:40personally participated in
02:43knowingly authorized
02:46or culpably ignored
02:48acts
02:48that strike
02:50at the integrity
02:51of the office itself.
02:54Tinalakay kahapon
02:55ang De Jesus complaint.
02:57Kanina naman
02:57pinag-usapan
02:58ang Massa et al
03:00complaint.
03:00Tatlong aligasyon
03:01ang nasa Massa et al
03:03impeachment complaint
03:04na nakaangpla
03:05sa ground for impeachment
03:06na betrayal of public trust.
03:09Itinatag,
03:10pinaintulutan
03:13at
03:14pinatupad
03:15ni Pangulong
03:17Bongbong Marcos Jr.
03:18ang isang
03:19opisyal
03:20napatakaran
03:22ng
03:23allocables
03:24at non-allocables
03:25sa
03:26pagbubuo
03:27ng
03:28DPWH
03:29budget.
03:31At ito
03:32ang
03:33naging batayan
03:35at bahagi
03:35ng isang buong
03:37sistema
03:37ng
03:38sentralisadong
03:39korupsyon
03:40na nagresulta
03:42sa tinatawag
03:43natin ngayong
03:44flood control
03:45korupsyon
03:46skandal.
03:48Ang Pangulo
03:49at tanging
03:49ang Pangulo
03:50lamang mismo
03:51ang may kapangyarihan
03:53na tuluyang
03:54mag-authorize
03:55ng release
03:55ng P213B
03:57na unprogram
03:59appropriations
04:00na naging balon
04:01ng malawakang
04:02korupsyon.
04:03Kaya ito
04:04ay malinaw
04:05na pagtataksil
04:06sa tiwala
04:07ng taong
04:08bayan.
04:08Si President
04:09Marcos Jr.
04:10ay direct
04:10ang nag-utos
04:11ng budgetary
04:12insertions
04:13na dibababa
04:13sa
04:14P100B.
04:16Direkta rin
04:16daw
04:17na nakinabang
04:18siya
04:18sa dibababa
04:19na P8B
04:20na ipinadala
04:21sa mga
04:22tauhan niya.
04:23Sabi ng ilang
04:23miembro ng
04:24komite,
04:25walang naipakita
04:26sa reklamo
04:27na may
04:27direktang
04:28utos
04:28ang Pangulo
04:29kaugnay
04:29sa mga
04:30bintang.
04:30It is clear
04:31from the complaint
04:32that the president
04:33did not do
04:34any overt act
04:35that will show
04:36that he directed
04:37these three schemes.
04:40Having an imperfect
04:41policy direction
04:42is not an impeachable
04:44offense.
04:45Accusations
04:45are not factual
04:46allegations.
04:48Presidential approval
04:49of the release
04:49of these funds
04:50does not equate
04:52to discretionary
04:54indulgence.
04:55It is actually
04:56a requirement
04:57of law.
04:58There is no
04:58allegation or
04:59statement showing
05:00any administrative
05:01order,
05:02memo,
05:03executive order,
05:04or any directive
05:05executed by the
05:06president himself.
05:08Pero may mga
05:08mamabatas ring
05:09naniniwalang sapat
05:11ang mga nilalaman
05:11ng reklamo
05:12para umusa dito.
05:14Kapag pinatay
05:15ang investigasyon,
05:16kung pipigilan
05:17ng komiting ito
05:17ang pag-usad
05:18ng investigasyon,
05:19ang magiging
05:20imahe ng
05:20kamara
05:21ay may pinagtatakpan.
05:23Lalo na
05:24at maraming
05:24mamabatas
05:25ang
05:26diong manoy
05:27na kinabang.
05:28To support
05:29this charge,
05:29the complaint
05:30alleges
05:31that the
05:32quote-unquote
05:32Saldico
05:34confession
05:34confirmed
05:36the president's
05:37personal and
05:38direct
05:39involvement.
05:40And I
05:41respectfully
05:41submit
05:42that given
05:43that standard
05:45that these
05:46allegations are
05:47assumed to be
05:48true,
05:49the complaint
05:50insofar as the
05:51third ground
05:52is concerned
05:53does satisfy
05:55the threshold
05:56standard
05:57of sufficiency
05:58in substance.
06:00Tatingin ko po
06:01itong third ground
06:02ang pinakamalakas.
06:04Because if
06:04take a look
06:05at the
06:06allegations
06:06of the
06:07complaint,
06:10lalo na
06:11yung
06:12tungkol
06:14sa mga
06:14claims
06:15o mga
06:15sinasabi
06:16through a
06:16video
06:17ng dating
06:18representative
06:20and chair
06:21of the
06:21Appropriations
06:22Committee,
06:24it would
06:26seem
06:26if
06:27hypothetically
06:28admitted,
06:30meron talagang
06:31impeachable
06:32offense.
06:32Sa huli
06:33na naig
06:34ang mga
06:34bumoto
06:35na parehong
06:36insufficient
06:36in substance
06:37ang dalawang
06:38reklamo.
06:39Basa sa rules
06:40ng Kamara,
06:41kung insufficient
06:42in substance
06:43ang impeachment
06:43complaint,
06:44i-dismiss
06:45ito
06:45at isusumite
06:46ng
06:47komite
06:47ang report
06:48nito
06:48sa plenario.
06:50Masasabi
06:50na bang
06:50patay na
06:51ang dalawang
06:51reklamo?
06:52As far
06:53as the
06:54proceeding
06:54today
06:55is concerned,
06:57I can
06:57consider
06:58that.
06:59However,
07:01we should
07:01be mindful
07:02that
07:03the
07:04committee
07:04report
07:05can still
07:06be reversed
07:07by at
07:09least
07:09one-third
07:11of all
07:12the members
07:12of the
07:13House of
07:13Representatives.
07:14I cannot
07:15still
07:16say
07:17it's
07:18dead
07:19because
07:20there's
07:22still a
07:22proceeding
07:22that will
07:23happen
07:23in the
07:24plenary.
07:29Idiniin
07:30ng
07:30House
07:30Committee
07:31on
07:31Justice
07:31na
07:32hindi
07:33nito
07:33minadali
07:34ang
07:34deliberation
07:35sa
07:35dalawang
07:35impeachment
07:36complaints
07:36laban
07:37sa
07:37Pangulo.
07:37Vicky?
07:38Tina,
07:40balikan natin
07:40yung
07:40nabanggit
07:41mo na
07:42committee
07:42report
07:42sa
07:43pagdeklarang
07:43insufficient
07:44in
07:44form
07:45and
07:45substance
07:45yung
07:46mga
07:46impeachment
07:47complaints
07:47laban
07:47sa
07:48Pangulo.
07:49Paano
07:49na yung
07:49susunod
07:50na
07:50proseso?
07:51Kailangan
07:51pa ba
07:52itong
07:52pagbotohan
07:53sa
07:53plenario
07:53para
07:54tanggapin
07:54o
07:55i-reject
07:55ito?
07:56Ayon
08:00kaya
08:00House
08:01Committee
08:01on
08:01Justice
08:02Chair
08:02Jervie
08:03Luistro
08:03babalang
08:04kasi
08:04ng
08:04kanyang
08:05komite
08:05ang
08:06committee
08:06report
08:06sa
08:07sufficiency
08:07in
08:08form
08:08pero
08:09insufficiency
08:09in
08:10substance
08:10ng
08:11dalawang
08:11reklamo
08:12laban
08:12sa
08:12Pangulo
08:13at
08:13inaasahang
08:14tapos
08:14na yan
08:15pagdating
08:16ng
08:16lunes
08:16kung
08:17kailan
08:17nakdakta
08:18ang
08:18susunod
08:19na
08:19pulog
08:19ng
08:19House
08:20Committee
08:20on
08:20Justice
08:21Doon
08:21sa
08:21pulong
08:21na yon
08:22Vicky
08:22ay
08:23pagbobotohan
08:23ng
08:24mga
08:24membro
08:24ng
08:24committee
08:25yung
08:25committee
08:25report
08:26at
08:26pagkatapos
08:27noon
08:27ay
08:27isusumiti
08:28nila
08:28ito
08:29sa
08:29plenario
08:29para
08:30pagbotohan
08:31ng
08:31lahat
08:32ng
08:32mga
08:32kongresista
08:33Vicky
08:34Linawin
08:35na nga
08:35natin
08:35Tina
08:36paano
08:43sa
08:43camera
08:43e
08:44paano
08:44rin
08:44naman
08:45kung
08:45i-reject
08:45naman
08:45ang
08:46report
08:46ano
08:46na
08:47yung
08:47susunod
08:47na
08:47mangyayari
08:48kapag
08:53sumangayon
08:53yung
08:53plenario
08:54Vicky
08:54sa
08:55House
08:55Committee
08:55on
08:55Justice
08:56ay
08:56masasabi
08:57na
08:57nating
08:58patay
08:58na
08:58yung
08:58impeachment
08:59proceedings
09:00laban
09:00sa
09:00Pangulo
09:01pero
09:01kung
09:01binaligtad
09:02ng
09:02plenario
09:03yung
09:03House
09:03Committee
09:04on
09:04Justice
09:04yung
09:05committee
09:05ay
09:06magbabalangkas
09:07ng
09:07articles
09:07on
09:08impeachment
09:08laban
09:09sa
09:09Pangulo
09:09i-re-report
09:10o
09:11isusumite
09:11ulit
09:12nila
09:12yan
09:12sa
09:13plenario
09:14at
09:14pagbobotohan
09:15ulit
09:15ng
09:16lahat
09:16ng
09:16kongresista
09:17kapag
09:18nakakuha
09:18ng
09:18boto
09:19ng
09:19at least
09:20one-third
09:20ng
09:21lahat
09:21ng
09:21miembro
09:22ng
09:22Kamara
09:22aakyat
09:23ang
09:23articles
09:24on
09:24impeachment
09:25sa
09:25Senado
09:25na
09:26uupo
09:26namang
09:27impeachment
09:27court
09:28Vicky
09:28Alright
09:29maraming
09:30salamat
09:30sa iyo
09:30Tina
09:31Panginiban
09:31Perez
Comments