Our #SlayedorShade panel weighs in on Jay Z's recent Tidal concert freestyle aimed at his competitors. Is he right for speaking up or are we shading him for calling them out?
Transcript
00:00Jay-Z held the first of his two Tidal B-Sides concerts here in New York City.
00:07During the concert streaming on Tidal, of course, Jay took an aim at his competitors like YouTube, Apple, and Spotify.
00:13In Hope's freestyle, he calls out his competitors for not paying, to quote,
00:17a tenth of what you're supposed to get to artists and questions why Tidal is being given such a hard time.
00:23So, do we slay Mr. Carter for going toe-to-toe with his competitors,
00:26or do we shade him for continuing to draw attention to Tidal?
00:31All right, let me know.
00:32Count of three.
00:33One, two, three.
00:34Slade or Shade?
00:35Shade.
00:36Oh, look at you.
00:37Slade, Shade.
00:38All right, Naturi, I'm going to start with you.
00:40Okay.
00:41Well, I mean, I say Slade because what can you expect from a businessman?
00:47A, you know, he's doing his thing and starting something new.
00:50There's always a challenge when you're, you know, kind of pushing against the masses
00:54of the businesses that have been out there.
00:56He's a new company, and I think it's dope and hot, and he's a hip-hop artist,
01:01that he should be able to say what he feels, and that's part of what I think the culture is about.
01:05And if it's about competition or beefing, which I always used to like, you know, on 106 and Park,
01:10artists used to, you know, rhyme.
01:11So, I think it's part of the culture, and I just think he has the right to do that.
01:16He's earned it.
01:17Here's my thing, Shade, because only because I love Jay, but the base, the fact is, title is not worth $20 as it stands right now.
01:27So, don't bring in anybody else's information.
01:30Spotify does a great job at $10.
01:32Don't sell me something for $20 that's not special.
01:35And bigger than that, don't bring, you know, Freddie Gray, Michael Brown.
01:40Like, don't bring that into the conversation, because that's a business.
01:43Those are lives, right?
01:44Right.
01:45Those things don't go together.
01:46And so, I just felt like it was out of place for Jay.
01:48I think he should have stopped while he was ahead.
01:51And you know what?
01:52Fix your service, and then people will pay $20 for you.
01:55Oh, and that was a read.
01:56All the way, Shade.
01:57Because, like Natori was saying, hip-hop is about bragging and being braggnotious.
02:01Like, my shit is better.
02:03You know?
02:04So, I get that part.
02:05So, I'm kind of like Slade Shade, right?
02:07And the Shade part is, for me, where he was kind of coming at the black community, like,
02:11oh, y'all don't support this.
02:12It's like, I'm a black man.
02:13Right.
02:14And it's not fair.
02:15Right.
02:16We're at the show, first of all, which means we're supporting you.
02:18Hello.
02:19The festivals.
02:20Yes.
02:21That's true.
02:22Your career has been us supporting you.
02:23And for you now to be like, well, you don't support my new venture, so that means you
02:26don't support black.
02:27No.
02:28Right.
02:29But, like Natori said, the part about business, it's business.
02:31You have to make, you know, the consumer feel like your thing is better.
02:35Of course.
02:36It's a $10 version of Tidal, by the way.
02:37Yes.
02:38Okay.
02:39I'm still on Spotify.
02:40Because I can get Beyonce and Nicki, I can get that for free on multiple websites.
02:44So, I don't need to sign up for Tidal.
02:45I mean, I didn't mind that he brought up, I mean, I don't think he, I didn't take it
02:49as his mixing the lives with the business.
02:51I thought it was an opportunity to, you know, people are paying attention.
02:54You know, people are going to be like, you know, gossiping.
02:56Why not, you know, figure out a way to bring some gravity to it?
02:59And I thought that his freestyle, actually, I thought it was cool because he was saying
03:03to the people that are listening, we also need to be aware of what's happening across
03:06the country.
03:07Paying attention.
03:08You know, and just paying attention.
03:09Sometimes, I get what you're saying, and I didn't take it as mixing.
03:11I took it as, this is the opportunity for me to say everything I'm feeling.
03:14While I have all of your eyes on me.
03:15Sometimes it's just one verse that happens to cover.
03:17Artists do that all the time, and it doesn't mean that they go hand in hand.
03:20He got people talking.
03:21I mean, look at us.

Recommended