00:00Jay-Z held the first of his two Tidal B-Sides concerts here in New York City.
00:07During the concert streaming on Tidal, of course, Jay took an aim at his competitors like YouTube, Apple, and Spotify.
00:13In Hope's freestyle, he calls out his competitors for not paying, to quote,
00:17a tenth of what you're supposed to get to artists and questions why Tidal is being given such a hard time.
00:23So, do we slay Mr. Carter for going toe-to-toe with his competitors,
00:26or do we shade him for continuing to draw attention to Tidal?
00:31All right, let me know.
00:32Count of three.
00:33One, two, three.
00:34Slade or Shade?
00:35Shade.
00:36Oh, look at you.
00:37Slade, Shade.
00:38All right, Naturi, I'm going to start with you.
00:40Okay.
00:41Well, I mean, I say Slade because what can you expect from a businessman?
00:47A, you know, he's doing his thing and starting something new.
00:50There's always a challenge when you're, you know, kind of pushing against the masses
00:54of the businesses that have been out there.
00:56He's a new company, and I think it's dope and hot, and he's a hip-hop artist,
01:01that he should be able to say what he feels, and that's part of what I think the culture is about.
01:05And if it's about competition or beefing, which I always used to like, you know, on 106 and Park,
01:10artists used to, you know, rhyme.
01:11So, I think it's part of the culture, and I just think he has the right to do that.
01:16He's earned it.
01:17Here's my thing, Shade, because only because I love Jay, but the base, the fact is, title is not worth $20 as it stands right now.
01:27So, don't bring in anybody else's information.
01:30Spotify does a great job at $10.
01:32Don't sell me something for $20 that's not special.
01:35And bigger than that, don't bring, you know, Freddie Gray, Michael Brown.
01:40Like, don't bring that into the conversation, because that's a business.
01:43Those are lives, right?
01:44Right.
01:45Those things don't go together.
01:46And so, I just felt like it was out of place for Jay.
01:48I think he should have stopped while he was ahead.
01:51And you know what?
01:52Fix your service, and then people will pay $20 for you.
01:55Oh, and that was a read.
01:56All the way, Shade.
01:57Because, like Natori was saying, hip-hop is about bragging and being braggnotious.
02:01Like, my shit is better.
02:03You know?
02:04So, I get that part.
02:05So, I'm kind of like Slade Shade, right?
02:07And the Shade part is, for me, where he was kind of coming at the black community, like,
02:11oh, y'all don't support this.
02:12It's like, I'm a black man.
02:13Right.
02:14And it's not fair.
02:15Right.
02:16We're at the show, first of all, which means we're supporting you.
02:18Hello.
02:19The festivals.
02:20Yes.
02:21That's true.
02:22Your career has been us supporting you.
02:23And for you now to be like, well, you don't support my new venture, so that means you
02:26don't support black.
02:27No.
02:28Right.
02:29But, like Natori said, the part about business, it's business.
02:31You have to make, you know, the consumer feel like your thing is better.
02:35Of course.
02:36It's a $10 version of Tidal, by the way.
02:37Yes.
02:38Okay.
02:39I'm still on Spotify.
02:40Because I can get Beyonce and Nicki, I can get that for free on multiple websites.
02:44So, I don't need to sign up for Tidal.
02:45I mean, I didn't mind that he brought up, I mean, I don't think he, I didn't take it
02:49as his mixing the lives with the business.
02:51I thought it was an opportunity to, you know, people are paying attention.
02:54You know, people are going to be like, you know, gossiping.
02:56Why not, you know, figure out a way to bring some gravity to it?
02:59And I thought that his freestyle, actually, I thought it was cool because he was saying
03:03to the people that are listening, we also need to be aware of what's happening across
03:06the country.
03:07Paying attention.
03:08You know, and just paying attention.
03:09Sometimes, I get what you're saying, and I didn't take it as mixing.
03:11I took it as, this is the opportunity for me to say everything I'm feeling.
03:14While I have all of your eyes on me.
03:15Sometimes it's just one verse that happens to cover.
03:17Artists do that all the time, and it doesn't mean that they go hand in hand.
03:20He got people talking.
03:21I mean, look at us.