• 10 months ago
On today’s episode, Editor in Chief Sarah Wheeler talks with Lead Analyst Logan Mohtashami about home prices, the Fed meeting and why Trump might be delaying his pick for a new Fed Chair.

Related to this episode:

Home prices up 1.4% in November, Midwest leads gains
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/case-shiller-home-price-midwest/
HousingWire | YouTube⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXDD_3y3LvU60vac7eki-6Q
More info about HousingWire
https://lnk.bio/housingwire

To learn more about Trust & Will visit trustandwill.com

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Welcome, everyone. My guest today is lead analyst Logan Motoshami to talk about home prices,
00:15the Fed meeting, and why Trump might be delaying his pick for a new Fed chair.
00:19First, I want to thank our sponsor, Trust in Will, for making this episode possible.
00:24Logan, welcome back to the podcast.
00:25It is wonderful to be here. Today is one of those days where I reaffirm my belief that my father has never, ever read anything I've written,
00:33and he has never listened to this podcast once, ever.
00:37Which is very funny because he's not just your dad, right? Like, that's kind of a dad move.
00:41But, like, he's in the industry. He is a lone originator.
00:44Yeah, he's been in the banking business since 1979. He's still working.
00:47So, today my father sends me a text message, tells me, hey, I don't know what this spread is.
00:55What's the meaning of the spreads? Can you send me anything, an article that I could read about it?
01:01And I'm like, really, homie? Really?
01:06You have no idea what the spreads is, and you're my father.
01:09He's like, what? And I was like, whatever.
01:10You know, so, it is what it is. It's really funny. I'll put this on social media.
01:15And he's done this with me, like, over the last 15 years where it's so random.
01:20And it's like, clearly, you've never listened to your son's work or at all.
01:24But since it's the mortgage spreads, and that's our big thing over the last few years, it just reaffirms my belief.
01:30He never listens to anything.
01:33That's so funny.
01:34Also, I feel like what we've learned over the last couple of years is a lot of people in the business don't really know what spreads are
01:39because you'll ask different audiences, and a few hands will go up.
01:43It's gotten better over the last year because you keep talking about it.
01:45But, you know, what do you see there?
01:47Yeah, I mean, it's just – I can understand.
01:49Mortgage spreads are about as nerdy as you get.
01:51And, you know, if people never heard about it, you know, now they do after we give a presentation.
01:58But this is like three years we've been really emphasizing the spreads.
02:02I mean, really since 2023, highlighting this and trying to teach people this because it's such a big thing for everyone in real estate and mortgage.
02:11And we never really had to deal with the spreads in the last decade in any meaningful way.
02:16But after 2022, it was a big thing.
02:21But for him to ask, can you send me a link to talk how you've never read the tracker one week?
02:28You're like, okay, well, let's talk about – so we've had some data come out.
02:35Case Shiller, of course, let's talk about home prices because I'd love to get your take on what they found
02:39and how that, you know, changes or doesn't change or compares to what you have in the 2026 forecast for home prices.
02:47You know, 2025 was just so much fun because, you know, my hypothesis going into the year is I had one of the lower nominal home price growth forecasts.
02:59And what happened toward the end of 2024, pricing firmed up when mortgage rates got towards 6%, but then they shot up toward the end of the year.
03:08So when we were going into the year, we have another round of inventory growth, but mortgage rates are elevated.
03:13So price growth should cool down.
03:15Then you have amateur hour.
03:18You had all these people that saw the month-to-month decline in the Case Shiller Index and go, oh, my God, we have never seen this since the second half of 2022 or 2008.
03:30I was like, that's not what it's really telling you, but go with it.
03:35And then, of course, Redfin.
03:37Redfin came out and gave all the trolling, grifting sites and YouTube pages this data line that, oh, my God, whole prices are going to crash in the second half.
03:46And the funny part is, you know, for my forecast to be right, the month-to-month data had to be weaker because the year-over-year growth had to slow down.
03:54And then what happened, Sarah Wheeler?
03:57When did the housing market change?
03:59Yeah, in mid-June.
04:00And then it was like, oh, my God, these people are not going to have an idea what's happening toward the second half because they're going to miss it again.
04:08And then a bunch of smart people came on the Internet and said, oh, home prices are – national home prices are falling, right, in the second half.
04:16Oh, my God, the Fed is behind the curve.
04:18Unemployment rates are rising.
04:20It's like home prices are not falling in the national data.
04:24So what occurred is when the full R4-looking data started to get better, pricing started to firm up.
04:30And then what happened is that the month-to-month data in the caseholder index started to firm up.
04:37But these people didn't care.
04:38They saw the cancellation rates.
04:39And they said home prices are crashing in the second half because of seasonal.
04:42And this is just a lack of not being a data scientist, not being an analyst, not forecasting every year in your life and not following a model.
04:49So this whole six months – because caseholder lags, it's three months behind where the current data is.
04:55But it started to firm up.
04:57And then when the forward-looking data started to firm up, oh, my God, the slope of the curve, existing home sales started to rise, prices started to firm up a little bit.
05:05That whole talk, any of those grifters on YouTube, my God, what a tragic disaster because we told everybody this was going to happen.
05:13We said – and we told everyone in six months they're not going to get it.
05:16You know why?
05:17Because these are not serious people.
05:19But a bunch of smart people came into the conversation, and they got it wrong as well.
05:24So the month-to-month pricing was a lot firmer than what people might have anticipated.
05:30Nothing shocking to us.
05:31And we go into the new year after the last two weeks of the year.
05:35We don't really count.
05:36And then the first week, and now we move with the tracker.
05:39And just follow that, guys.
05:41Just follow that and go with it.
05:43If you want your own city zip code, go to HousingWire.
05:47Get your Altos data for your own zip code.
05:49Stop listening to these people out there.
05:52By God, 2025 was one of the most memorable years of being an analyst out there, not just the labor overinflation, not that we aren't breaking into recession, but the whole housing year flowed with the tracker very well.
06:06And we're in 2026 now.
06:07Yeah, remind the audience, what is the 2026 forecast for home price, national home prices?
06:13Now, the forecast is for a slight decline, but why?
06:17I'm not fully into the lower rate camp.
06:20But if we have inventory growth, anything similar, then having a slight decline on nominal home prices nationally is there.
06:27However, what we've seen in the tracker so far this year, the growth rate of inventory has slowed noticeably from mid-June all the way down.
06:37Now, if rates stay six and a quarter and lower throughout the duration curve, it's very hard to have, I mean, major nominal home price crashes, but just, you know, softness in pricing.
06:48Our price cut percentage data might be even negative year over year soon.
06:51So we just flow with what the data says, but again, another round of inventory, affordability is still an issue, but because supply is a little bit higher, the pricing curve is a little bit different.
07:02And we track it every single week.
07:04And if anything, if data starts to really improve again, we let everyone know that that's how you go with it out there.
07:12And so far this year, again, like we've stressed and what we've shown, it's been the best start to the year in years, but it's also a much different backdrop.
07:22Spreads are better.
07:23The Fed has already cut a lot.
07:24The growth rate of pricing has slowed.
07:26You don't have home prices up 10%, you know, year over year.
07:30So affordability got better by its own just by price growth slowing down.
07:34So it's the healthiest backdrop.
07:36And CaseShiller just reaffirmed it.
07:39So we're always going to be three to six months ahead of the CaseShiller index, but it just reaffirmed what we've talked about in 2025.
07:46And we still have people today who are using the Redfin's cancellation rates.
07:50Oh, my God, the home sales are crashing.
07:52You know, so, again, trust us.
07:56We've proven ourselves the last three years was as soon as we initiated the tracker toward the end of 2022.
08:01And just let the data talk and ignore all the noise out there now that we've proven ourselves time and time and time again.
08:09But 2025 was just flawless in that nature in terms of guiding people into, OK, this is what real data does and how it looks like.
08:17That is crazy, though.
08:19OK, so you kind of want to stay away from crazy, though, and just work with this.
08:22And, of course, my job always is to talk about the national data, national economy, national things that move because housing data, what are we housing data flows with the 10 year yield really after a qualified mortgage.
08:33So we work off of that.
08:34But you can do this for any of your cities, zip codes, states, counties, whatever you want.
08:39You can break it down.
08:40There's over one hundred eight thousand cities in America in general.
08:42But not shocking with the Case-Shiller and the FHFA, the slope of the curve started to improve a little bit as the forward-looking data start to improve.
08:50And we're so far ahead of the NAR and the Case-Shiller Index that if anything changes, we'll let everyone know.
08:58But it's going to take a few months for the traditional data to hit with what we're showing currently.
09:04So I want to be really specific on home prices because you're like, yeah, a slight decline.
09:10A slight decline in the growth or a slight decline in actual home prices?
09:12No, negative 0.62.
09:15I always go down to the measure because I try to do the slope.
09:18So that's the baseline forecast, right?
09:20And then we just work off of the data because we have enough data to say that pricing isn't going to be very to the upside or to the downside on a nominal basis.
09:28But now we have to work with the 10-year yield.
09:30And so far this year, 10-year yield, mortgage rates, very stable.
09:34Mortgage-backed security purchases were called.
09:36That's a defensive mechanism to keep rates lower.
09:40And then we just kind of go with that.
09:41Where last year was a 1.77% forecast on nominal home prices.
09:47And we're roughly going to stay somewhere around there.
09:49The year before was 2.33%, which was lower than other people.
09:52But I knew when I lost that forecast toward the second half of 2022 when our pricing data started to firm up quite noticeably toward the end of 20.
10:02And so, again, we don't believe in the concept of a forecast without a model.
10:08So we roll with the data live because that's the most efficient way to talk about things rather than, you know, stick something on the wall and say, I'll see you guys in 12 months.
10:20Right?
10:20And I just don't think that's efficient.
10:22With how data flows this way, that's where we go.
10:26But 2025 was as flawless as you could get with showing how a real data line tracker works with live information.
10:34And all the variables that go into housing, right?
10:37Labor, the Fed, inflation data, jobs, everything.
10:40Okay, when this comes out, it's going to be Fed Day.
10:45What are you looking for?
10:46You know what's interesting on Fed Day for housing?
10:49Whenever they ask Jerome Powell, and, you know, I kind of make a joke.
10:54I did a video of myself and Jerome Powell staring each other down and talking and basically saying he's probably done his last rate cut as Fed chair last year.
11:04But it'd be interesting how he answers housing again because whenever they ask the Fed about housing, all he talks about is we can't do anything about the shortage.
11:14He never talks about, like, sales or anything.
11:16He was very adamant, like, you know, years ago, said, oh, housing is in a bubble.
11:20And, you know, this, you know, and I'm like, no, it isn't, but whatever.
11:24He's very uncomfortable talking about housing.
11:28Right?
11:28So the irony is that the Fed does control monetary policy and monetary policy is still 65% to 75% of where mortgage rates could range.
11:38And when rates are elevated and demand is low and supplies up production of housing, what we've seen the last few years, the builders are at the march of dives.
11:46Right?
11:47Housing permits went down and housing starts went down.
11:50But when rates fell and demand picks up, then you get a little bit more production.
11:56So I just think he feels so uncomfortable talking about housing that he uses that token answer.
12:02That has nothing to do with any of the questions of what we're saying.
12:06You know, it's very simple.
12:08A less hawkish Fed and rates just staying here, better for housing.
12:14A more hawkish Fed, if they're looking for production, makes it very hard for the builders.
12:20So if they want to keep on going that, that's how people should talk about it.
12:24But now that mortgage spreads are better, I think the last thing they said is they saw housing stabilize with their regions.
12:33But really, you know, we're asking, when's the next Fed chairman going to be announced?
12:38Why is Rick Reeder coming out there?
12:40Like we talked about in the last podcast, I don't believe the White House thinks they could fire a bunch of Fed governors.
12:47So they need someone to get the team in together out there and wash.
12:54Both the Kevins are way too tied to Trump, but Rick isn't.
12:59And he doesn't want Christopher Waller because he's a Fed person.
13:02So that's why his name is picking up.
13:04We'll see if we get any clues about, you know, how it's going to look in a few months when Powell is no longer the Fed chair.
13:13It's been a couple of weeks since Bessent had said, like, hey, look for this around the Davos meeting.
13:21So we all thought it would be like a couple of days before, a couple of days after.
13:24We're a whole week off of that, have not heard anything.
13:27So I'm surprised.
13:28I thought we'd have an announcement.
13:30You know, if you think about it this way, maybe they were waiting for the courts the whole time.
13:35Maybe they were waiting to see if they can fire Lisa Cook, then they could get rid of Austin Goolsbee.
13:41They could get rid of Beth Hammock and Lori Logan and replace them if they if they if Trump had that power.
13:48But if he doesn't have that power, he's got to work with the people in there.
13:52And there's where the Kevins might not be so advantaged to him, where a Christopher Waller or Rick Reeder might be a little bit different.
14:02So maybe this was all we all looked at it differently.
14:04He wanted to wait to see how much power he could, you know, do over the Fed and then pick his person based off of that.
14:12Because let's just say he hypothetically picked a Kevin Hassett already.
14:17And the Supreme Court says you can't fire any Fed.
14:21Well, is Kevin Hassett really or even worse, Warsh?
14:25He picks Warsh.
14:26Everyone hates him.
14:28And now they can't fire anyone.
14:30And now it's just like, OK, this is a guy I don't like.
14:33I really don't want to cut, you know, so maybe maybe it was just waiting to see what the what the courts do and then work off of that.
14:40That is, you know, kind of a plausible mindset to have with the delay in choosing out there, because it's a really big deal if the White House could start firing Fed governors because they're too hawkish.
14:52Like, I would never endorse that because we keep these entities separate from each other.
14:59But maybe that's the reason we haven't got a new Fed chairman announced yet.
15:04I think that makes a lot of sense.
15:06More sense than anything else I've heard.
15:08Logan, thank you so much for joining me today.
15:10As always, appreciate you and talk to you soon.
15:12Pleasure.
15:12Pleasure.
15:22Pleasure.
15:23Pleasure.
15:24Pleasure.
15:25Pleasure.
15:26Pleasure.
15:27Pleasure.
15:28Pleasure.
15:29Pleasure.
15:30Pleasure.
15:31Pleasure.
15:32Pleasure.
15:33Pleasure.
15:34Pleasure.
15:35Pleasure.
15:36Pleasure.
15:37Pleasure.
15:38Pleasure.
15:39Pleasure.
15:40Pleasure.
15:41Pleasure.
15:42Pleasure.
15:43Pleasure.
15:44Pleasure.
15:45Pleasure.
15:46Pleasure.
15:47Pleasure.
15:48Pleasure.
15:49Pleasure.

Recommended