00:00First, candles were lit early this morning at Berlin's Holocaust Memorial as people in the
00:17German capital and indeed all across the world mark International Holocaust Remembrance Day
00:21this Tuesday. It is a sombre anniversary dedicated to honouring the millions murdered by the Nazis
00:28who tried to completely wipe out Jewish life here in Europe. In all, 6 million Jews were killed.
00:36Today, the 27th of January, marks as well the 81st anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz-Birkenau,
00:42that is, the most notorious of the Nazi concentration camps. Around 1.1 million people
00:48were killed on that site alone, the majority of them Jewish. Well, our first report this hour takes
00:55a look at how artificial intelligence is increasingly being used to generate fake images from the
01:01Holocaust. It's produced by our team in Berlin and as our correspondent Nick Holdsworth will explain,
01:07the fabricated footage risks trivialising what was one of the darkest periods of modern history.
01:14A man playing the violin at Auschwitz, a young woman dancing at Sobibor. Images of the Holocaust that
01:23are emotionally moving, sometimes shocking, but actually entirely fabricated by artificial intelligence.
01:30At Berlin's Holocaust Memorial, many people say they have already come across such images on social media.
01:37I assume it's meant to represent Auschwitz. It's so inappropriate.
01:41Artificial intelligence can spread false information. We already have enough photographs
01:45showing what really happened. These images are very problematic.
01:49Images that staged the Holocaust while blunting the violence of mass murder. The phenomenon is
01:56alarming researchers and historians, including officials at Berlin's Sachsenhausen Memorial.
02:02Together with 50 other institutions, they are called in on platforms to restrict such content.
02:10These images undeniably change users' viewing habits, and they dilute and distort history by
02:16producing a clean, sanitised picture of what actually happened here that bears no resemblance
02:21whatsoever to historical reality.
02:23Content that is anything but harmless. Some of it is produced to generate clicks and revenue.
02:32Other material aims to blur historical truth. It's a gateway to revisionism, according to the
02:38Antonio Amadou Foundation, which is dedicated combat on racism and anti-Semitism.
02:44Images of the Holocaust naturally generate extremely high click-through rates. But this poses a serious
02:50problem because these images can be used for very different purposes. They can be used to distort
02:54history, to falsify it, and they can also serve as an attempt to relativise the Holocaust by claiming
02:59that some source or another proves that events unfolded differently.
03:03German authorities are now also calling for stricter regulation of such images.
03:10Staying with Holocaust Remembrance Day, UNESCO have today published a survey which shows anti-Semitism
03:17exists in three quarters of classrooms and schools in the European Union.
03:21And that is not the only shocking statistic. The report's authors also say that over 60% of
03:27teachers surveyed reported encountering Holocaust denial and distortion among the students they
03:34have been teaching. Well, with me to discuss the findings of that UNESCO report is Heather Mann.
03:40Hello to you, Heather. You're a project officer in the section for global citizenship and peace
03:46education at UNESCO. You worked on this report yourself for about a year. So thank you very much
03:50for coming in to talk to us. Thank you for having me. Look, it's a long report. It's detailed. As I say,
03:55you worked on it for about a year and you spoke to some 2,000 teachers across the European Union. Just
04:01give us a sense then of what the key findings are. Well, as you already mentioned, we found that three
04:08three quarters or 78% of teachers specifically experienced anti-Semitic incidents in their
04:14classroom. And if you take that three quarters, 27% of them then experienced nine or more of such
04:22incidents. So that's a huge amount. When it comes to denial and distortion, it's over 60% with one in
04:2910 teachers experiencing denial and distortion expressed by their students frequently. So these are incredibly
04:36concerning findings. And we find two examples of anti-Jewish bullying against Jewish students and
04:43even a significant minority of teachers experiencing or witnessing violence against Jewish students in
04:50their classrooms. As you say, all of those statistics are rather shocking. I just want to pick up on one
04:55of them with you in particular, that 60% of these teachers you spoke to heard their students denying the
05:02Holocaust or distorting facts about the Holocaust. And it figures, data not just from UNESCO, but from other
05:09organisations suggest, look, that figure is on the rise year by year. We see more and more young people in Europe
05:15denying what happened during the Nazi period. How do you understand that? How can you explain why we're seeing
05:23this rise?
05:23Well, I think it comes from two spaces. Firstly, from social media. And there's been a huge rise of
05:30Holocaust denial and distortion on social media as well. We had a study from 2022, which found that
05:37one in half of every post on Telegram is either denial or distortion about the Holocaust, of course. But on
05:44TikTok, which is obviously a very youth friendly platform, that's 16% of all videos about the Holocaust.
05:51So young people are seeing this, they're encountering it, it comes in the form of memes or jokes, things
05:56that really minimise the impact of the Holocaust that it had on Jewish populations in Europe.
06:02So it's something that becomes acceptable to bring into classrooms.
06:06But we also see with the rise of tensions around the situation in the Middle East,
06:13that antisemitism in general has been on a rise in European societies and globally for that matter.
06:20So it's become more commonplace for young people to
06:25have hostility against their Jewish neighbours or fellow classmates,
06:32but also to somehow have higher resistance to learning about the Holocaust.
06:37And that's something that teachers are reporting to us in this survey.
06:40Look, we will come on in a minute to what you think needs to be done,
06:44the kind of work that UNESCO wants to do. But I just want to pick up on another statistic
06:47from your report that this is 42% of teachers have actually encountered other teachers being
06:55antisemitic. That's another particularly shocking stat from your report. Again, I mean,
06:59can you just expand a little bit on what it is that teachers are hearing their colleagues
07:03saying or doing?
07:05Yes, so we don't have that data broken down into the types of incidents. But what we also did was
07:12surveyed teachers about their personal understanding of antisemitism. And the results there are
07:19particularly shocking. So to take an example, 16% of teachers did not recognise the very basic antisemitic
07:28trope that Jewish people have a lot of money, that they're rich to be antisemitic. Another 13% didn't
07:35recognise that Jewish people control the financial systems or control the media to be antisemitic.
07:42So among teachers, there isn't this base level of knowledge or understanding to recognise antisemitism.
07:50And to some degree, we shouldn't expect teachers to be more knowledgeable about other
07:55populations on this particular subject, because we're also not providing them with any specific
08:01training. So 70% of teachers surveyed reported that they have zero access to training to help them
08:08understand contemporary forms of antisemitism. And it's very much left to the teachers responsible
08:14for Holocaust education, that knowledge does not spread among the school populace. But antisemitic incidents,
08:21of course, happen everywhere. They happen on the sports field,
08:24they happen in other classrooms, they happen in the playground. It's not only something that can
08:29be tackled through teaching about the Holocaust, however important that is.
08:33So is that a distinction that you think we need to make more clearly then, educating about the
08:38Holocaust done in history classrooms, we imagine, but just making a distinction between that and
08:44modern antisemitism, which can, of course, take on a number of different forms?
08:47Yes, certainly, certainly. And this isn't that we should advance Holocaust education, we need to invest
08:55in that more. But at the same time, we need to be providing teachers with the support and the
09:00resources to deal with contemporary forms of antisemitism, because that is how antisemitism persists
09:06today. And they don't have the knowledge, they don't have the skills, they don't have the support or the
09:11teaching materials even to touch on that topic. We did another study recently where we're trying to
09:17find good practices on how to teach about antisemitism. And we came up with 10 very good practices from
09:23around the world. But the fact is, in most countries, there does not exist a single program on how to
09:30educate about contemporary forms of antisemitism. And if it does exist, it's very much left to the Jewish
09:36community. So say the Jewish Museum in that country to do that, rather than something that
09:41spread and taken responsibility by the Ministry of Education or teaching unions themselves.
09:47And I imagine that is something that you at UNESCO would really like to change. Do you want to see
09:51governments on the continent taking a more direct role in this kind of education? What is it that UNESCO
09:59now really wants to change on this issue?
10:00I mean, the number one call is to invest in teacher training, because that is where there's
10:05the most urgent need. And it's a difficult message for ministries of education. But each different
10:13form of hatred, each different form of racism needs its own specific solution that all diseases affecting
10:19our society, but we can't solve them all with the same vaccine. So that requires investment and resources
10:26to support dealing with antisemitism, as well as dealing with other forms of racism and prejudice
10:32that are manifesting in our societies. It's complex because the the prejudice itself is complex. But we
10:40have, as ministries of education, as educational professionals, we have a responsibility not only
10:46to the Jewish students in our classrooms, but to all students to prevent these forms of thinking,
10:53these forms of conspiracy theories, because they limit our understanding of the world. And
10:59in the end, they lead to harm, they lead to security issues, and they lead to the restriction of the
11:06right to education to Jewish students in Europe.
11:09All right, Heather Mann, thank you very much indeed, for coming to talk to us there, Heather Mann,
11:13talking to us on International Holocaust Remembrance Day. Thank you very much.