Should Starmer Stand Up to Trump — or Is Quiet Diplomacy the Smarter Move? An Expert Explains - video Dailymotion

Local TV

Some critics say the Prime Minister has been too cautious in responding to President Trump’s recent actions, while others argue that restraint protects Britain’s influence and its most important alliance.

Transcript

00:00In recent months, the dynamics between the United States and the UK have come under intense

00:08scrutiny, focused in part on how Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has reacted to several actions

00:15by President Donald Trump, from trade disputes, including controversial tariffs on British

00:21industries, to contrasting approaches on foreign policy such as Ukraine and broader global

00:28security, critics at home and abroad have argued that Starmer's public response has been

00:34too cautious or too measured. Others say his careful diplomacy reflects the priorities

00:40of a special relationship that remains central to Britain's economic and security interests.

00:49Keir Starmer's in a really difficult position, not that of course the popular press, particularly

00:55the right wing, would have you believe that. Insofar as that we need to keep Trump on board,

01:00Trump may be a petulant man-child, and I'm happy to take criticism for saying that, but look

01:06at the evidence. So somehow you have to try and appease him. Now of course, the difficulty

01:12we have is the Morono in Venezuela, the method by which he was taken, clearly he's a dictator

01:19of sorts. The whole aspect of the legality of whether he should have been abducted by the

01:25American forces is a whole different ballgame. There's a shaking, if you like, of the kaleidoscope

01:31of the relationships and the geopolitical situation of South American countries. But nonetheless,

01:37it may have a positive effect. So I'm saying this about Trump, although remember, Trump is

01:42just the mouthpiece of the sort of the people behind him who see the world in a very different

01:48way. Now of course, coming back to Starmer, which of course is the main focus, what is

01:53he to do? Because of course, if he falls out with Trump, then that's it, you get nothing.

01:58Now of course, we've got Venezuela. Now in the big scheme of things, Venezuela is important,

02:02but not that much. Greenland, maybe even more so, maybe more important because of course

02:06of the sort of the fact that it's a sort of part of Denmark and indeed is a NATO country.

02:11We'll see how that sort of plays out. I still think the sort of the big issue that Starmer

02:16has to be sort of fully aware of and indeed his cognizance is due to the fact that they

02:21want to keep Trump on board in terms of Ukraine. If Ukraine were to fall, because of course

02:27Trump, in a fit of pique, takes away all funding for the weapons, then Ukraine becomes very vulnerable

02:33to being taken over by the Russian forces, which of course is all the objective, even

02:37though this war has been going on for four years with tremendous loss of life and sort

02:40of injury and whatever else. So that's the big issue. It's always about sort of Russia.

02:46As debates continue, the question for many observers is not just what Sir Keir Starmer

02:51thinks about President Trump's decisions, but how and when he chooses to say it publicly.

02:57Supporters argue that preserving a stable UK-US relationship matters most for long-term peace,

03:04trade and security.

03:06The difficulty for Starmer is he appears weak and in a world of strongmen, which we seem

03:11to be surrounded by, that's not a good thing. Starmer's got his own domestic problems he could

03:16do with sort of looking like one of the strongmen, but perhaps this is not the one to die in a ditch

03:22for. So maybe to save your weapons for a day when there may be a battle that you can win.

03:29But trying to win any battles against Trump is going to be extremely difficult.

03:32So maybe silence is the best defence he's got.

03:37For Sir Keir Starmer, the challenge isn't just what he says about President Trump,

03:41but how Britain is seen when he says nothing at all. Supporters see restraint as strength.

03:47Critics argue silence risks signalling consent, especially when allies are speaking more plainly.

03:54But critics contend that a stronger public stand may have offered clearer leadership on issues

04:00ranging from tariffs to diplomatic rows. The balance between caution and conviction remains

04:06at the heart of this ongoing debate, leaving opinion divided on whether enough has been said.

04:12Let's see.

04:13Let's see.

04:14Let's see.

Should Starmer Stand Up to Trump — or Is Quiet Diplomacy the Smarter Move? An Expert Explains

Category

Transcript

Be the first to comment

Recommended