- 10 months ago
The Case Against Johnathan E Ross. 13 minutes that blows Trump and Republican lies totally away regarding the killing of an American citizen, female parent.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00so jesse you just said this woman is in severe crisis she was boxed in if you watch the whole
00:14video she was boxed in that's what she was boxed in no i said the team was boxed in okay the team
00:19was boxed in by once she moved over she pulled to the side and then she actually waves another
00:25ice officer passed her right so she's in such severe crisis that she can be polite in traffic
00:31and say you go ahead and then you hear her actually audibly saying i'm pulling out right she
00:37she signals exactly what she's doing she starts to move forward and everyone should go and watch
00:42the new york times has about three and a half minutes of footage coming from every angle and
00:46this is what they brought up to president trump when they were meeting with him last night when he said
00:50uh you know the officer the brave officer and after he tweeted i i it's hard to believe that
00:55the officer is alive when he walked away completely unscathed we can see that on video as well
00:59but the footage contradicts the administration on almost every level of what they've said
01:04renee good waving the vehicle by the officer was to the side of the car when he drew the gun he leaned
01:10over the hood for the first shot you can see that on the angle too that he fired two more shots at
01:15arm's length on a 90 degree angle and it almost doesn't matter actually what she was doing because
01:22she didn't have another weapon d according to doj policy which they should be in compliance with
01:28it says deadly force may not be used solely to prevent the escape of a fleeing suspect firearms must
01:34be discharged at a moving vehicle unless a person is threatening deadly force by other means than the
01:38vehicle and no other means of defense exists including moving out of the path he could clearly move
01:44out of the path because he did and that's why he was unscathed in this i don't know why it wasn't
01:51good enough for secretary noem or the president or the vice president to say this is a tragedy we need
01:57to investigate this and not only do we need to investigate it we need the fbi to work with local
02:02officials on the ground in minnesota which apparently they do not want to do and governor walls was talking
02:07about that as well that would have been the responsible thing to do here and talking as if there is
02:12no potential that this officer is at fault with what happened feels like you're getting a little
02:17bit ahead of your skis especially when there is so much footage that contradicts the story that the
02:21administration is giving
02:23what did you do
02:40you
02:41shame
02:43shame
02:45shame
02:46shame
02:47shame
02:48shame
02:49shame
02:51shame
02:52shame
02:53shame
02:54shame
02:56shame
02:58what's happening to her
03:00what happened
03:01you
03:14have been
03:16you
03:18you shot her
03:19i'm trying to help
03:20no no
03:22You fucking shot someone in the fucking face!
03:36A federal agent films the scene on his phone.
03:40The driver rolls forward slightly, turning left, then stops and waves for others to go ahead.
03:46Two agents exit this silver pickup and walk toward the vehicle.
03:54Moments later, shots are fired.
03:58Let's look at the scene again more closely.
04:02This is the agent who shoots the driver.
04:05He walks around the car filming and disappears from view.
04:09Other agents pull up and order the driver to exit her vehicle.
04:16One of them grabs at the door handle and reaches inside.
04:20The SUV reverses, then turns right, apparently attempting to leave.
04:26At the same time, the agent filming crosses toward the left of the vehicle and grabs his gun.
04:32He opens fire on the motorist and continues shooting as she drives past.
04:36The moment the agent fires, he is standing here, to the left of the SUV,
04:40and the wheels are pointing to the right, away from the agent.
04:45Shame! Shame!
04:47This appears to conflict with allegations that the SUV was ramming or about to ram the officer.
04:53President Trump and others said the federal agent was hit by the SUV,
04:57often pointing to another video filmed from a different angle.
05:00And it's true that at this moment in this grainy low-resolution footage,
05:06it does look like the agent is being struck by the SUV.
05:10But when we synchronize it with the first clip,
05:13we can clearly see the agent is not being struck at this moment.
05:17In fact, his feet are positioned away from the SUV.
05:21The SUV crashes into a white car parked down the road.
05:25A bystander runs toward the collision.
05:29The federal agents on scene do not appear to rush to provide emergency medical care.
05:35Eventually, the agent who shot the motorist approaches the vehicle.
05:40Seconds later, he turns back around and tells his colleagues to call 911.
05:45Shame!
05:47You shot someone!
05:50You shot someone!
05:51Agents block several bystanders who attempt to provide medical care,
05:56including one who identifies himself as a physician.
05:59Can I go check a pole?
06:00No! Back up! Now!
06:02I'm a physician!
06:04I don't care!
06:06At the same time, several agents, including the agent who opened fire,
06:10get in their vehicles and drive off,
06:12apparently altering the active crime scene.
06:21Where is the conservative, who watched and said,
06:27you know, my instinct is to support law enforcement.
06:31But in this case, I see an officer discharging his weapon
06:35against a fleeing vehicle as an excessive use of lethal force.
06:39But the officer training and legal standards that apply,
06:44they've been developed and are spelled out
06:46in a half a dozen government publications over the last 15 years.
06:49I've read them all, and I've made some notes.
06:52The bottom line is this.
06:54The question is whether the ICE shooter,
06:56when he pulled the trigger, had a reasonable belief
06:59that he faced an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury,
07:03and only then can he use lethal force.
07:06Also, he cannot use the force just to stop a fleeing suspect.
07:10He must reasonably believe that the suspect poses a significant threat of death or serious physical harm,
07:17and that the force is necessary to prevent the escape.
07:21From the documents, it's clear that the policy has been subject to great deliberation over many years.
07:27For example, I found this.
07:28There was an outside review of all CBP uses of deadly force over a two-year period from 2010 to 2012,
07:36and it found this.
07:38Two policy and practice areas especially need significant change.
07:43First, officers and agents should be prohibited from shooting at vehicles unless vehicle occupants are attempting to use deadly force,
07:51other than the vehicle, against the agent.
07:53Training and tactics should focus on avoiding positions that put agents in the path of a vehicle
07:59and getting out of the way of moving vehicles.
08:02That same review contained this.
08:05With regard to restrictions on shooting at vehicles,
08:08it should be explained that shooting at vehicles poses a higher risk to agents and innocent bystanders and should be avoided.
08:16Here's another.
08:18It's a memo from the chief of CBP in 2014, and it notes this.
08:21Agents shall not discharge their firearms at a moving vehicle unless the agent has a reasonable belief,
08:29based on the totality of circumstances, that deadly force is being used against the agent or another person present.
08:36Agents should not put themselves in the path of a moving vehicle or use their body to block a vehicle's path.
08:42and now that new video.
08:49And now that new video, as I said, it is so crucial because it was filmed by the ICE agent
09:12involved, but also because in that it is that, it is providing an angle we have not seen
09:18before. And it does give a whole new perspective. It also, though, raises new questions. Kyung-La is
09:25going to go through this slowly, bit by bit, out front with this special investigation
09:29to look at every piece of video, that one and all the others, to say, what is the story here?
09:34And of course, I warn you, when you put all of these together, you will have to see what happened
09:39again and again.
09:42For the first time, we are seeing the fatal Minneapolis shooting from the ICE
09:48officer's point of view, footage taken on his own cell phone. It's a critical angle of many cameras
09:54on the street that captured Rene Good's fatal encounter with ICE agent Jonathan Ross. Using
09:59surveillance footage, bystander video, and Ross's own phone, CNN synced multiple perspectives of the
10:05shooting and mapped this incident in 3D space. Taken together, they show the fullest picture yet
10:11of what happened that day. A home surveillance camera captures the moment Rene Good pulls up
10:16in a maroon-colored Honda SUV, four minutes before the shooting. 20 seconds after she arrives,
10:23her passenger and wife, Becca, wearing a white beanie, gets out of Good's car. Good then parks
10:28the SUV perpendicular in the road. Here's how Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem described
10:34what Good did.
10:35ICE officers and agents approached the vehicle of the individual in question who was blocking
10:40the officers in with her vehicle, and she had been stalking and impeding their work all throughout
10:45the day. Available video doesn't show any possible contact Good may have had with ICE before this
10:51confrontation. What this video does show is that for a few minutes, while she is perpendicular to the
10:57roadway, several vehicles drive by. Even large SUVs are able to drive around her as she moves back and
11:03forth on the street, and that includes this light-colored SUV. It slowly drives around Good's car
11:09from the rear and stops. Agent Jonathan Ross is recording video from his cell phone as he crosses
11:16in front of Good's car, recording as he sees her up close. She looks calm, and you can see both of her
11:22hands as she talks to the officer. That's fine, dude. I'm not mad at you. Rene Good's wife, Becca, who had been
11:28in the car? When the passenger in the car approaches. Cell phone cameras on the street start recording
11:32as Ross walks around Good's car with Good's wife following. I say go get yourself some lunch, big boy.
11:39Rene Good backs her car up as the agent walks around the front of the vehicle. At the same time on the
11:45other side, two more agents approach. One tries to open the door as Good backs up. Good's vehicle starts
11:53moving. From Ross's cell phone video, you see Becca, the woman in the white beanie,
11:57trying to get into the car again. You also see Rene Good turning the steering wheel to the right.
12:05She then accelerates.
12:09Slowing this down again and matching the exact time of these two angles,
12:13this angle appears to show the vehicle moving close to the agent. But in this angle,
12:18he does not appear to be in the path of the vehicle when he fired.
12:22Seconds later, Becca Good runs to her wife, followed by the agent who fired his weapon.
12:33He briefly looks into the driver's side of the car and then walks away.
12:37Shame! Shame!
12:39Shame!