00:00All right, a clear cinematic face-off here between the state of Kerala and the centre.
00:04Let's cut across to our panellists to get a larger understanding.
00:07Kasturi, actor and activist, joins us from Chennai.
00:10Jisha Surya, independent journalist.
00:12Girish Wankare, movie trade analyst.
00:14Appreciate all three of you for taking the time out and joining us.
00:17Jisha, would you like to give us some context on what really is happening
00:20and how much does it actually have to do with politics?
00:23Yes, this is the 30th year of International Film Festival of Kerala.
00:31It's been cited as one of the very most popular film festivals in the country.
00:37And it is credited with a lot of, you know, Kerala's film history has a lot of credits to go with.
00:45You know, the IFFK has contributed a lot to Kerala's film history.
00:49And this was the first time. We have never heard about such a kind of a ban happening for the first time.
00:57Normally, the IFFK's films do not need any censorship certificates per se,
01:05but it needs an exemption from the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.
01:10So, this time, the film festival began and one of the films, which has now been on the list of 19 films,
01:18was denied screening just one of the inaugural films, Palestine 36.
01:23And it was on the third day that this became a controversy that we,
01:26the delegates started getting messages saying this film is getting cancelled.
01:31That's when this controversy broke out.
01:33That was when everybody realized that 19 films were not given the censorship extensions this time.
01:39So, this includes some of the Palestinian films like Palestine 36 and Once Upon a Time in Gaza.
01:46And there was one interesting film named Beef, which has nothing to do with beef.
01:51It is a Spanish film about a rap singer.
01:54And there are other films like Battleship Potemkin, which is, we all know it's a classic film.
02:01And it is available even on YouTube.
02:03And this is the centenary year of Battleship Potemkin.
02:05That's why it is being screened all over the world.
02:07And it's been celebrated as one of the greatest films of modern cinema history.
02:13And these are some of the films.
02:14And again, an Indian film, this film named Santoj, which was won a lot of critical acclaim in Cannes Film Festival.
02:23That is one of the other films.
02:25And there was one African director who is getting a Lifetime Achievement Award at IFFK.
02:31His two films are also being denied permission to screen.
02:35Kasturi, would you want to come in?
02:37Because this also, you know, sets the precedent here, where a centre versus state face-off.
02:43Censor boards have clearly banned these 19 films.
02:46And now you have a state government saying, we don't care what the censor board of the country thinks.
02:50Well, I see what you're trying to ask me.
02:57But unfortunately, with this, I think it's more a case of a very misinformed bureaucracy and a state government which really has nothing to lose.
03:11So let's talk about the bureaucracy.
03:14I think the people who are in charge of clearances haven't really heard of these movies.
03:21For instance, All That Is Left, that's a movie that if my memory serves right, and I'm just recalling from memory,
03:31that was nominated for Best Foreign Feature in that year at the Academy Awards.
03:40It's one of the most celebrated movies.
03:43I've seen it.
03:45Beef, again, has nothing to do with beef.
03:48I haven't watched it, but, you know, I've heard a lot about it.
03:51These are acclaimed movies.
03:53And, you know, movie lovers are looking forward to watching these movies.
03:59They are apolitical as well.
04:01I believe the Palestinian movie is about a divorce and two parents moving apart and something like that.
04:09I remember it.
04:10These are apolitical movies.
04:13So while I understand that a few movies which could cause political embarrassment or political, you know, inconvenience could be not clear,
04:2719 movies, around 15 of them are really innocuous films.
04:31So I think the people in the MEA and in the INB ministry haven't done their homework.
04:38They have to at least look up the movie.
04:40Every single one of them is available in parts on social media.
04:46And definitely, it's not difficult to find them.
04:50But Battleship Potemkin, if you take that, it's a classic.
04:55It's 100 years old.
04:57It's 100 years old.
04:58I think most of us have already seen it, but I agree with you.
05:01So, you know, I understand.
05:02We have to watch it in film school.
05:03It's mandatory watching.
05:05It's a lesson plan.
05:07So suddenly, I don't know why suddenly, I don't know if Eisenstein has suddenly become persona non grata in Putin's Russia.
05:16Because as far as we remember, he was like the godfather of filmmaking.
05:22So don't know what's going on with that.
05:24But I'll say this with the politics.
05:27Pinarayi's government is on the way out.
05:31It's down and out and on the way out.
05:34They have really been routed in the local body polls.
05:40They have, let me be very frank, they don't have much to look forward to in the assembly elections.
05:47So also political posturing to be taking a stand against the government.
05:51They have nothing to lose.
05:52They can snoop their nose at the center because they're not going to win and they have nothing to lose.
06:01I want to bring in Giresh Vankhari into this thing.
06:04Giresh, do you think somewhere down the line this is just lost in translation?
06:07Some of these films are classics.
06:09Some of these films have nothing to do with what they seemingly mean, like the film Beef.
06:14Or what's really happened here?
06:15Giresh Vankhari, can you hear me?
06:23Yeah, yeah, I can't hear the sound is not clear.
06:25Yeah, sorry.
06:27Yeah, so these films which are banned, obviously most of these films are available on various OTT platforms.
06:34And these are quite popular films.
06:37There is an internationally acclaimed film like Battle with Kotem Gain and all these films.
06:42So the decision of center shows that they have not done their homework, their cinema literacy is questionable because these festivals are for the artistic freedom.
06:55They are for all sort of films which should be showcased.
07:00And these are the platforms where we nurture the creativity.
07:03But if a center without understanding the context, without understanding the seriousness, without understanding the POV of point of view of these films, these are the films which are critically acclaimed and the whole world, the new filmmakers learn from them.
07:25So banning such films from the center where state has already approved is something which is uncalled controversy.
07:33It is never the right way of curbing the freedom of expression.
07:40These are the films which are all there in the public domain.
07:45So it is just like a futile exercise.
07:47And you can't ban films in this digital age as such.
07:51Because if anybody who wants to watch the film, he will watch it anyways.
07:56So in fact, we should respect these filmmakers.
08:00We should have more transparency, more acceptability or more liberty in choosing those films.
08:08And if state, this is a very reputed film festival, Kerala is known for voicing their films.
08:14And when Rasul Pakuti is saying something on social media, it means it is a serious business.
08:20He is not there just for the festival's sake, but he is the voice of Kerala.
08:25He is a world acclaimed sound designer.
08:27And they are responsible people.
08:28If they are hosting the festival, we need to respect that.
08:31Fair point.
08:33I think we've lost our connection with Jisha.
08:35But I want to bring in Kasturi back into this conversation.
08:38Kasturi, because, you know, what it's also done somewhere down the line is,
08:41given an opportunity for a left government, which is waning right now,
08:45needs an issue to rally support, to attack the centre on this.
08:53Yeah, I think this is like, you know, at this point,
08:57the communist disposition in Kerala has become like a dying flame.
09:02So it's glowing all the more brightly before they go out.
09:07So I think this is kind of their last stand.
09:09It's December.
09:11But that said, one also has to remember that this is Kerala.
09:16You know, Kerala, regardless of who is in power,
09:19the people are very educated and very aware.
09:24They're very exposed to all sorts of, you know, all schools of thought.
09:30It's a very cosmopolitan society, if you will.
09:35So in a way, I think, even without intending to,
09:42I think the government is representing the liberal outlook of the Kerala society
09:50and their people as a whole.
09:52I mean, look at their movies.
09:54The best movies come out of Kerala.
09:58Arguably, the best movies.
10:00Arguably, yeah.
10:01Arguably.
10:01We could like to just say that.
10:03I'm running out of time, but I just want to get in Jisha for a quick comment as well.
10:06You know, Jisha, do you see this, you know, invariably picked up by the Kerala government,
10:13which has come off, you know, humiliation in the hustings
10:17where local body polls were concerned, to pick it up as an emotive issue to attack the centre?
10:24I don't think so, because all political parties have taken a very strong stand
10:28against this kind of censorship, regardless of political affiliation.
10:33I mean, except BJP, all political parties, in fact, Congress, leaders,
10:37all have said that this is widely perceived as a threat to freedom of speech and expression.
10:44And all political parties are in unison to this protest.
10:48And this is, like I said, Kerala's film culture is very vibrant.
10:52And the film societies and film festivals have played a major role in this.
10:57And I don't agree that these are all apolitical films.
11:00There are a lot of politics and a lot of issues that are being discussed through these films.
11:05And that's how Malayali audience, you know, widened their horrors
11:09and became so politically aware through these films
11:14that also have become a part of Malayali culture.
11:17So, it is not just of an election propaganda.
11:22The protest is, there's white protests.
11:25And I think the government will hear that.
11:28Well, let's hope the government hears that,
11:30because a lot of these films really have nothing wrong with them.
11:32So, maybe there's something lost in translation there.
11:34We're going to leave it at that.
11:35Thank you, the three of you, for joining us and taking the time out.