00:00This is SQ, and if you double or triple, there is no problem.
00:05But why don't we put it in Parliament? How can you do it?
00:09Then what is the value and the sanity of this democracy from a way of the downside?
00:16This is the CAG report, sir, which I can do in the paper.
00:19No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
00:27But what I have read in the paper, sir, I have read a little bit.
00:30We have reached 90 for now.
00:32But I have asked for two small measures for the country's clarifications.
00:37Thank you very much.
00:40Sir, I want to speak on this today.
00:43Thank you for giving me the permission to speak on the Health and Security, National Security CES Bill 2025, sir.
00:50Sir, I appreciate the reason of bringing the bill.
00:55I won't say I object to the bill.
00:58I would like to support the bill because I am not taking away from the intention of the government.
01:02We had a very detailed discussion yesterday.
01:04And in her reply yesterday, she at length was very practical and a very pragmatic approach of the Honourable Finance Minister of the challenges of tobacco and what the position is today in the larger interest of society.
01:18But my first question to the Honourable Finance Minister is why in the form of CES?
01:24Just yesterday in her reply, sir, you were present there.
01:27She talked about taxation at length and we have no objection to any of taxation.
01:31And we are happy to pay tax on these pre-merited goods.
01:38But why in the form of CES specifically for this?
01:41And the other question I would seek, I mean I hope she indulges us in a clarification.
01:47My very learned friend who spoke extraordinarily well today is Sumati.
01:52She also asked the same question.
01:54Is that if this CES ever has to be doubled, they don't need to bring it back to Parliament.
02:01We are not against it.
02:02We will support any such thing if you want to increase taxes on any good, which is not good for society at large.
02:12We will support the government.
02:14GST is a good bill.
02:15We are standing with you.
02:17After Operation Sindhuur, we are standing with you.
02:20Whatever you do for the country, we will leave the power of the country.
02:24And if this bill is for the country, I want to ask them, why do you do it?
02:36And if you want to double or triple, there is no problem.
02:39But why do we not bring in Parliament?
02:41How can you do it?
02:43Then what is the value and the sanity of this democracy?
02:46For more of the downsides of Parliament.
02:49Why do we come here, sir?
02:51You have a very long language today.
02:55I will give you some clarification.
02:57You have a very good language.
02:59It is always good.
03:01Two, three important questions I would like to ask her.
03:04That in the CES in the last ten years, in the Honourable Prime Minister Modi regime, or ERA, you can call it,
03:10the CESs have gone from 10% to 25%.
03:14I still remember.
03:15I miss Arunji Itali ji.
03:16I was a very good minister.
03:17When I was the finance minister,
03:19I always had a good answer to them.
03:22Cooperative federalism.
03:23I always talk about cooperative federalism.
03:25I always talk about the federalism.
03:26I will give you everyone.
03:27I will give you every rule.
03:28Every rule will give you the right to the right.
03:29And if you will give you the right to the right,
03:31whatever you will do, the government will do.
03:33But today, I have seen the government in 5-7 years,
03:37It is a little bit of a policy level.
03:39You will not say that you will say a well-ish just like that.
03:42There is some change in the CESs.
03:44So our objective is not to increase.
03:47Our objective is not to increase ourselves.
03:49It is not to make the CESs.
03:51We share the US.
03:53Every ruler has a need for money.
03:55Another one is to give you more physical.
03:57We have a double engine government in all parts of the country, so what is the issue?
04:00Why is it more than you have a double engine government in the country, so what is the issue in the government?
04:06This is what we want to ask everyone.
04:08Sir, there is another thing I want to ask for a clear clarification.
04:11I am not yielding, sir, that I want to know what it is.
04:16The split between health and national security.
04:19You have a good deal for health.
04:20If you have something for the country, you have a good deal for the government, we will have a good deal.
04:24If you have something for the national security, then obviously the government will remain with you.
04:28Like I have been standing with you in the first operation.
04:31But what will this split happen?
04:33There is no clarification, sir, so if you can say it in the reply, it will be a good deal.
04:40I will not repeat the points, but this business is a high profit margin business.
04:46It can be a tax evasion, I believe.
04:48And it is very bad for the public health.
04:52It will be a tax evasion of the government.
04:54But I will not say that the government is a high profit margin.
04:59But I will not say that the government will be a great deal.
05:03It will not be a tax evasion in jail.
05:05We will not accept the income tax, the insolvency, all of us will be working.
05:07And we will be a great deal.
05:09If you have a person in jail, then what will it happen?
05:12The law of the inspector is going to be a harassment.
05:15It will be harassment.
05:17I don't know if it is true or wrong, but if there is no business,
05:21I am against this business. I also want to ban this country from Pan Masala and Ghutka.
05:26But I know that we have banned Ghutka in Maharashtra.
05:31It is so black. What can I tell you?
05:33Yesterday, I have already spoken.
05:35In any country, in any country, in any country, in any country,
05:38in any country, in any country, in any country.
05:40But in any country, go to any country, sir.
05:42Go to the college.
05:44There is such a good rule in the parliament,
05:46that there is no Ghutka or Tambakou in the past.
05:48But I am so surprised to see that every college and school is in the past.
05:51This is a shame.
05:53And this is happening in every country.
05:55I am not saying that any government is not saying that.
05:57We are all in our homes.
05:58But we can change our lives.
06:00We all need to think about this.
06:02We all need to think about this.
06:03And this is a success.
06:05I will give you a report.
06:07I will give you a paper.
06:08I am not a finance expert.
06:10I am always saying that.
06:12But this is a report.
06:14It is a report.
06:15I will give you a paper.
06:17I will give you a paper.
06:18Otherwise, there is no doubt.
06:19I will give you to the Nishikaki,
06:20so that you are too.
06:22I will give you a report.
06:24This is my report.
06:25If you have read the paper,
06:28you will have to say it.
06:29Because health is.
06:30And education is.
06:31I once said,
06:32I told them all a few times.
06:34I was even asked to them.
06:36You always collect their money.
06:38The collection is really going there.
06:40And the CAG report is saying,
06:42the report says that the health says education says inventor education and protection fund and
06:54monetization of national highway fund all the money is collected and the money is collected
07:01is no full of money.
07:06finance minister g is asking if the price has gone where is the price?
07:13if the report has gone the price has gone where?
07:17we have tax to the government to put your trust on the government
07:21which you are taking, which you are not taking, you are not taking part of the school
07:25you know that you have to be connected with the land
Be the first to comment