The Truth About Evan Peters' Dating History

Feelings Drama

Transcript

00:00Evan Peters may have had a colorful dating life, but he admits he never got to date his

00:05childhood celebrity crush. Can you guess who that is? Check out this list of famous Evan exes to

00:12find out. Before starring together on 2011's American Horror Story Murder House and then

00:182013's American Horror Story Coven, Evan Peters was rumored to have dated Alexandra Bruckenridge.

00:24This would have been around 2007. Neither ever officially confirmed a romance,

00:30but there are some photos from what appears to be that time floating around the internet of them

00:34looking pretty affectionate. While Peters may have dated someone who was gorgeous enough to be cast

00:39as Moira, the maid seductress in AHS, he was also feeling unconfident during that time in his life.

00:46Peters told Cosmopolitan,

00:48"'I recall definitely being insecure and wanting to date a girl,

00:52but being too insecure with myself to even talk to her.'"

00:55If Breckenridge and Peters did date in the late 2000s,

00:58they were broken up by the time they had to work together on AHS. Still,

01:02they appeared to still be on good terms, or at least were professional.

01:06When it comes to all her AHS co-stars, Breckenridge told Interview in 2011,

01:11"'I couldn't say a bad thing about anybody I'm working with. I love them all, they're awesome,

01:16and it's so nice.'"

01:18While Breckenridge eventually left AHS, she went on to find success in the popular series This Is Us,

01:24as well as Netflix's Virgin River. She also moved away from Peters and married Katy Perry's

01:29guitarist Casey Hooper in 2015. As for Peters, it definitely wouldn't be the last time he dated a

01:36co-star.

01:37Like most young and hot celebrities of his time, Evan Peters found himself at the California music

01:43festival Coachella in 2010. There, he sparked romance rumors with British model and singer

01:48Pixie Geldof. The two were seen holding hands while walking through the festival.

01:53According to Bustle,

01:54Geldof was said to have been quite taken with Peters at the time,

01:57though the two only dated for a year before calling it quits sometime in 2011.

02:02Although a reason for their breakup wasn't given, it can be assumed that distance played a role,

02:07since Geldof was based in London and Peters in Los Angeles.

02:11Evan Peters' next relationship was made a little more public, partially thanks to who he was dating,

02:17fellow actor Alexia Quinn. The two became an item in 2011 after starring together in the play

02:23Living at Home, before Peters' career took off later that year when his first season of American

02:28Horror Story aired in October. Apparently, Quinn didn't mind having a more famous boyfriend,

02:33though, since fan accounts claim that she had a popular blog on Tumblr where she would often write

02:38about their relationship. She supposedly didn't hold back when discussing their sex life either,

02:43and would even answer questions about Peters from fans. However, luckily for Peters,

02:48Quinn's alleged blog has since been deleted. Peters and Quinn became red carpet official in January 2012

02:55when he brought her as his date to his birthday party in Las Vegas. Yet the former couple didn't

03:00make it through the rest of that year, and some say actor Emma Roberts was to blame. According to

03:05People, around that time, Peters met Roberts on the set of Adult World. Despite them both being in

03:11relationships then, Peters told Vulture,

03:13"'I had a crush on Emma. I tried to talk to her a few times, but I kept saying the wrong thing.'"

03:18Clearly, Roberts didn't think that was the case.

03:22Perhaps Evan Peters' most famous relationship so far was with his American Horror Story co-star Emma

03:27Roberts. The two dated on and off for about seven years, and it seemingly came with a lot of drama.

03:34They did start out pretty cute, though. After initially working together in 2012's Adult World,

03:39Roberts said on Chelsea Lately,

03:41"'I actually on the set was like,

03:43"'Oh yeah, we're totally gonna date. And I would, like, flirt with him.'"

03:47Yet Roberts said that she thought her affection wasn't returned. She added,

03:51"'He literally didn't speak to me the entire movie.'"

03:54As crazy as that sounds, it makes sense when you hear his side of the story. Peters was supposedly

04:00just as smitten with Roberts, which is actually why he gave her the cold shoulder. He dished to Vulture,

04:06"'I didn't really know how to approach her. I was really kind of awkward and stupid and like,

04:10"'Oh God, this is just not working out well. I'm just going to shut up and not talk.'"

04:14Even still, as Roberts explained to Nylon,

04:17"'It turned out that we both liked each other, so months later, we started dating.'"

04:21"'Yes! Yes! This is the best day ever!'

04:24The two went on to make their red carpet debut at a 2013 Golden Globes party — and, of course,

04:30starred in several seasons of AHS Together after Roberts joined the cast in Season 3.

04:35Peters apparently loved having his girlfriend on set, telling Yahoo,

04:39"'It was awesome. She's so nice and so funny and really talented. It was really easy to work with her.'"

04:46It seems that things started to go south for Evan Peters and Emma

04:50Roberts pretty early on in their relationship. In 2013, the former couple was involved in a

04:55domestic violence incident while in Montreal. According to TMZ, Roberts was arrested after

05:01someone reported a fight in their hotel room and police found Peters with a bloody nose. Yet,

05:06Peters decided not to press charges, and she was quickly released. Not only did Peters not want his

05:12then-girlfriend in trouble, he was photographed just days later comforting her as she sobbed in his

05:17arms right after news of her arrest broke. According to People, a rep for both Peters and Roberts

05:23seemingly tried to downplay the arrest, saying,

05:26"'It was an unfortunate incident and misunderstanding. The couple are working

05:30together to move past it.'"

05:31While Roberts and Peters kept quiet about the whole thing, Roberts was quoted telling Nylon before the

05:36incident, "'I can't say I'm never going to mess up, but if I do, I'll definitely be very sorry.'"

05:42She also later addressed the difficulties of having a relationship be so public to Cosmopolitan in 2019,

05:49saying,

05:50"'It's hard enough to be with someone by yourself, let alone with an audience. Growing up is hard.

05:55Sometimes it makes me sad that I can't have a private moment.'"

05:59Evan Peters and Emma Roberts' relationship took another surprising turn at the end of 2013,

06:04when they got engaged just months after Roberts' domestic violence arrest. A little while before

06:10Peters popped the question, Roberts told Nylon,

06:13"'I've grown up in a business where we're taught to think that relationships don't last

06:17and that people are supposed to be married a bunch of times. But I come from the school

06:21of getting married once.'"

06:22However, their engagement didn't end up lasting, and by June 2015, the two split.

06:28Roberts told Allure that she had replaced her engagement ring from Peters with jewelry she

06:32purchased herself. She explained,

06:35"'Always love yourself and always know what you're worth.'"

06:38Yet that energy didn't last either, and just months later, Us Weekly reported that she

06:43and Peters were already back together. Peters didn't seem to have any hard feelings about the split,

06:48because that October, he couldn't help but gush about Roberts at a premiere, saying to People,

06:53"'She is really great. I just love her.'"

06:56The two may have been in love, but they appeared to have many ups and downs, too.

07:01Evan Peters' romance with Emma Roberts apparently turned out to be quite the roller coaster ride,

07:06since the former lovebirds went on to break up multiple times. Their second split came about

07:11a year after their first in May 2016. Then, despite several efforts in 2019,

07:17they finally split for good. While Peters kept things more private, Roberts alluded to their

07:22breakup in an interview with Cosmopolitan. She claimed,

07:25"'I never want to talk about relationships I'm in or that are ending or have ended. I think that no

07:30matter who you are or what you do or wherever in the world you are, anything ending is hard.

07:36Losing something is hard.'"

07:37Roberts also suggested to Los Angeles Magazine that perhaps Peters' rising fame and hardcore

07:43fans played into their split. She dished.

07:46"'People say, why is it so hard for celebrities to have relationships? My answer? Do people

07:51Photoshop their face over yours with your boyfriend? It's just a weird thing.'"

07:56Yet a source allegedly close to the former couple told Us Weekly it was more serious than that,

08:01explaining,

08:02"'Evan was so in love with Emma and their relationship became very toxic. They had the

08:07highest highs and then would not speak for days.'"

08:10The same insider revealed,

08:11"'Evan took a long time of figuring himself out again before he was ready to date.

08:16He did eventually get back out there, thanks to a certain music superstar who seemed to always

08:21have her eye on him.'"

08:23Evan Peters' romance with singer Halsey may have been brief, but the two were pretty

08:27enamored while it lasted. It appears that Halsey had a crush on the mayor of Easttown actor for a

08:32long time. In a now-deleted tweet from 2012, the Without Me songstress wrote,

08:38"'Seriously, Evan Peters stopped making me attracted to alleged sociopaths and accused murderers.'"

08:44She was, of course, referring to his roles on American Horror Story. That next year,

08:48she also posted another forward note about being interested in Peters. She wrote,

08:53"'Petition for Evan Peters to date me.'"

08:56Once Peters was finally single, a source told E! a friend introduced them and they

09:00began messaging on social media. They were then spotted together at Six Flags in September 2019,

09:06before they made their official couple debut a month later at a Halloween-themed party to celebrate

09:11AHS. The twosome dressed up as Sonny and Cher. From there, the love fest continued, with Halsey

09:18referring to Peters as her boyfriend on The Ellen DeGeneres Show, and also when they were seen taking

09:23a romantic trip to Australia. Halsey gushed about Peters in a now-deleted Instagram post from January

09:292020, where she wrote,

09:31"'I can't imagine a world without you in it.'"

09:33She also posted them together that Valentine's Day on a trip to Switzerland. Yet, if you couldn't

09:38tell with all Halsey's posts being deleted, the two didn't last. After their relationship ended,

09:44Halsey quickly moved on to her current boyfriend, Alev Aiden, whom she welcomed a son into the world with.

09:50As of 2021, Evan Peters appears to be single. Perhaps the actor is taking a break from dating

09:56to focus on his booming career.

09:58"'I got one life, and I'm not wasting it.'"

10:01It's apparently proving to be a good move. Peters returned to star in American Horror Story,

10:06won an Emmy Award for his performance in Mare of Easttown, and took on the role of serial killer

10:11Jeffrey Dahmer in Ryan Murphy's upcoming TV series. But if Peters is dating again,

10:17it seems he's looking for a specific type of girl. He told Cosmopolitan in 2015,

10:23"'I guess I'm looking for girls who give me a chance. If I say the wrong thing or do something

10:27stupid, she's cool with that and will give me another chance to say the right thing and get

10:32past my nerves and insecurity.'"

10:34It seems with his star power and relationship history, Peters should have no problem getting a date.

10:39As for who Peters will date next is anyone's guess, but he did admit to having a childhood

10:44crush on the Olsen twins. He revealed to W,

10:47"'They kinda got me out to LA. I was like, I gotta meet them. I met Ashley. She's sweet.

10:52I was a little nervous, but she's cool.'"

10:55While Ashley Olsen is taken, it's obvious that Peters is quite the catch. And if his next love

11:00is anything like his past romances, it's safe to say she'll be used to the spotlight.

11:05Check out one of our newest videos right here! Plus,

11:08even more Nicki Swift videos about your favorite stuff are coming soon.

11:12Subscribe to our YouTube channel and hit the bell so you don't miss a single one.

Category

Transcript

Be the first to comment

Recommended