Skip to playerSkip to main content
TTIOT
  • 1 day ago
Australia's Debt – Is Our Money System a Pyramid Scheme



━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━▲━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
╬╬══ TTIOT ══╬╬

▲▲▲👽👽 MY CHANNELS 👽👽▲▲▲

🟠 Blog - pudszttiot.blogspot.com

🔴 Bitchute - bitchute.com/channel/pudszttiot

🔵 Dailymotion - dailymotion.com/pudszttiot

⚫ GitHub - github.com/pudszttiot

🟠 Reddit - reddit.com/user/puddsszz

🟠 SourceForge - sourceforge.net/u/pudszttiot

🔴 YouTube - youtube.com/@pudszTTIOT

⚪ PlayStation (PSN) - psnprofiles.com/snippapudsz

━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━▼━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00Welcome to TTIOT, the show that proves anyone can have opinions.
00:06Have you ever wondered what really drives our money system?
00:08What if Australia's debt-based economy operates a lot like a pyramid scheme,
00:13constantly relying on new debt to keep going?
00:16Today, we'll uncover who wins, who struggles,
00:19and why understanding this matters to every Australian.
00:22Let's get this circus started.
00:24Have you ever taken out a loan, you know, maybe for a house or a car,
00:28and just wondered about the sort of invisible mechanics behind it all?
00:32Or maybe you felt that pinch of rising debt yourself and thought,
00:35hang on, how does this whole system actually work?
00:38It's a common question, definitely.
00:40Yeah, and when I first read this analysis we're looking at today,
00:43the idea, well, the idea that our nation's money system, Australia specifically,
00:49could share striking similarities with a pyramid scheme, that was fascinating.
00:54Genuinely, it's a bold claim, a very provocative one.
00:57It really is, and that's the claim we're diving into today.
01:01Our mission really is to unpack this analysis.
01:03It argues that Australia's debt-based monetary system operates structurally a bit like a pyramid scheme.
01:10We'll be looking at the mechanics, who wins, who loses.
01:12Exactly, and the potential future implications.
01:14And importantly, this isn't just, you know, someone's wild theory.
01:18No, not at all.
01:18It's built on official data.
01:20We're talking RBA, ABS, major banks, combined with economic principles, some from MMT,
01:26modern monetary theory, which looks at government's role in money.
01:29And broader historical monetary analysis, too.
01:32So solid foundations for the argument, even if the conclusion is startling.
01:37Right.
01:37So the core argument, the absolute heart of it from the source's executive summary is this.
01:42Australia runs on a debt-based system.
01:45Structurally, it's strikingly similar to a pyramid scheme.
01:49And it's built on two key pillars.
01:51Fractional reserve banking.
01:53Where banks only keep a fraction of deposits, right?
01:55Exactly.
01:56And fiat currency.
01:58Money backed essentially by government decree and, crucially, public trust.
02:04Not gold or silver.
02:05And the analysis argues the system needs constant debt expansion just to keep functioning.
02:10Which leads to this concept the source calls the debt treadmill.
02:13And it's more than just a catchy phrase.
02:15Okay, tell us about that.
02:16It describes a mechanism, really, that leads to these exponentially growing obligations for
02:20households.
02:21It just keeps accumulating.
02:22While benefiting who?
02:23Well, simultaneously and pretty consistently, it benefits the financial institutions at the
02:27top.
02:28Think of it like the more debt gets pumped in, the faster that treadmill spins.
02:32Making it harder for regular people to keep up.
02:34Precisely.
02:34Often, just to pay back what they already owe, plus the interest.
02:39That really goes against what I think many of us learned in school, doesn't it?
02:43It does.
02:43The old idea that banks are just intermediaries.
02:46They take deposits from savers, lend them out, and the reserve bank controls the total
02:50amount.
02:51That's the textbook version.
02:52Yeah.
02:53But it's not quite how it works in practice.
02:54So if that traditional view is wrong, how fundamental is that change to understanding how money is
03:01actually created?
03:02Oh, it changes everything completely.
03:05The reality, and this is confirmed by the Bank of England, even the RBA acknowledges this.
03:11Yeah.
03:11It's quite different.
03:12Okay.
03:13So how does it really work?
03:15Well, when you go for a loan, the bank doesn't check its vaults for spare cash or look at existing
03:19deposits.
03:20No.
03:20No.
03:21They create new money digitally.
03:22They literally just type the numbers into your account.
03:25Poof.
03:25New money exists.
03:26Okay.
03:27Wow.
03:27But here's the kicker you mentioned.
03:29Yes.
03:30And this is absolutely crucial.
03:31They create the loan principle, let's say $100,000 for your loan.
03:35Right.
03:35But they do not create the interest that will be owed on that loan.
03:39Right.
03:39Say an extra $30,000 over the years.
03:42That interest money isn't created at the same time.
03:45So, wait, if the bank only creates the $100,000, where does the $30,000 to pay the interest
03:52eventually come from?
03:53Exactly the question.
03:55It has to come from somewhere else in the money supply.
03:57Which means?
03:58It has to come from other people taking out new loans, more principle being created.
04:02Yeah.
04:02Because only the principle is newly created by banks.
04:05There's never enough money in the system in total to cover both all the principle and
04:09all the interest owed.
04:10So, the system needs constant new borrowing just for people to be able to pay the interest
04:15on the old borrowing.
04:16Precisely.
04:17Yeah.
04:17It inherently creates a kind of scarcity of the money needed to pay interest, forcing constant
04:21new borrowing.
04:22And that is the engine of the debt treadmill.
04:24Okay.
04:24That's a really fundamental point.
04:26Let's ground this in some numbers for Australia.
04:28What does this look like in real terms?
04:31The numbers are pretty stark.
04:32Looking at 2024 data, average household debt, it's $261,492.
04:38For a household.
04:39Yeah.
04:40Add it all up.
04:41Total household debt for the whole country.
04:43$2.66 trillion.
04:45Brilliant.
04:46It's hard to even grasp.
04:47And it puts Australia's debt to income ratio at 182%.
04:51That's a third highest in the OECD, the Group of Developed Nations.
04:55It really highlights the pressure.
04:56It's a lot to unpack, isn't it?
04:58When you see numbers like that, you realize the financial tightrope so many families are
05:02walking.
05:02And those numbers, they really paint a detailed picture of the system's mechanics, like you
05:07said, and also where the value flows.
05:09Okay.
05:09So what about the other side?
05:11The banks.
05:12Well, look at the big four banks here in Australia.
05:15Together, they pull in around $44.6 billion in pre-tax profits annually.
05:20Wow.
05:20$44.6 billion.
05:22And if you break it down per home loan, the source estimates the profit a bank makes over
05:26the entire life of a typical mortgage is about $200,800.
05:30200 grand profit on one loan.
05:33Which works out to be roughly 35% of the original loan amount itself, just in profit.
05:37Okay.
05:37So those figures clearly show a massive concentration of wealth, of profit, within that financial
05:42sector.
05:43Directly linked to this process of debt creation and interest charges.
05:47Right.
05:48You know, the source makes this incredibly bold comparison, saying our money system is like
05:53a pyramid scheme.
05:54What are the actual parallels?
05:56What makes that comparison stick, according to the analysis?
06:00Well, the comparison is striking because the structural similarities, when you lay them out,
06:04are, well, they're hard to ignore.
06:08Okay.
06:08Like what?
06:09One of the big ones.
06:10The system's survival depends on a constant flow of new participants.
06:14In a pyramid scheme, that's new recruits paying in.
06:17Here?
06:18New borrowers taking on new debt.
06:20That's the fuel.
06:20Okay.
06:21What else?
06:21Just like a pyramid scheme, the early participants think early property buyers who bought low,
06:27or the banks themselves.
06:28They profit directly from the burdens taken on by those who join later, the new borrowers
06:33paying higher prices.
06:34So value flows upwards.
06:36Yes.
06:36And then there's the maths.
06:38The analysis highlights this mathematical impossibility of indefinite growth.
06:43Exponential systems like this, they just can't go on forever.
06:46They're unsustainable by definition.
06:48Right.
06:48Like a pyramid scheme collapsing when recruitment dries up.
06:51Exactly.
06:52Yeah.
06:52In both cases, if the recruitment or the new borrowing slows down significantly, the
06:58whole structure faces collapse, or at least a major crisis.
07:01Any other parallels?
07:03A couple more key ones.
07:04Both systems are fundamentally based on trust and belief.
07:08Belief that the dollar will hold value, belief that house prices will keep rising, belief
07:13that the scheme will pay out.
07:14Without that trust.
07:15It falters.
07:16And in both systems, the benefits are heavily, heavily concentrated right at the top.
07:21And finally.
07:21Both require this unsustainable exponential growth just to keep the wheels turning.
07:26Not linear growth.
07:27Exponential.
07:28That's quite a list of similarities.
07:30It's powerful laid out like that.
07:32But it does bring up a big question.
07:33If the parallels are so strong, why does the system keep going?
07:38And what are the real world consequences?
07:40Given that it's obviously not an outright scam like a Bernie Madoff scheme, it does create
07:45some value, right?
07:46That's the crucial distinction the source makes.
07:48It points out one key characteristic that doesn't perfectly align.
07:50A pure pyramid scheme, it argues, creates no real value or product.
07:55It's just shuffling money upwards.
07:58But our debt money system.
08:00It does facilitate real economic activity.
08:02Let's be clear on that.
08:03It funds businesses starting up.
08:05It builds roads and hospitals through government borrowing.
08:09It allows us to buy houses, cars.
08:11It fuels the transactions that make the economy hum.
08:15So it's not a perfect match in that sense.
08:17No.
08:17While it shares many, many structural features, it's not a complete one-to-one replica because
08:23it does underpin real economic activity.
08:26But, and this is important, that difference doesn't negate the impact of the other shared
08:32characteristics.
08:33Like the impact on wealth distribution or systemic risk.
08:36Exactly.
08:36Those remain significant concerns based on the parallels.
08:40Okay.
08:40So let's talk about those impacts then.
08:41Who wins?
08:42Who loses in this setup?
08:44The source identifies clear winners at the top of this.
08:47Let's call it a structure.
08:48Definitely.
08:48Thanks are number one, obviously.
08:49They have this unique power to create money from thin air, charge interest on it, earn
08:55billions every year doing it.
08:57Can't argue with that.
08:58Then you've got, say, early property owners.
09:01People who bought houses years ago.
09:04They benefit hugely from asset price inflation, which is largely funded by...
09:07All the new borrowers coming in later and bidding up prices with more debt.
09:11Right.
09:12Their wealth grows, sometimes massively, without necessarily creating new value themselves.
09:17And then other financial institutions, wealth managers, etc.
09:21Yeah.
09:21They profit from servicing all that debt, managing the wealth that accumulates.
09:25Yeah.
09:25It's a whole ecosystem built around it.
09:27So those are the winners.
09:28What about the losers?
09:29Who's at the bottom bearing the brunt?
09:31Well, the analysis points pretty clearly to new borrowers.
09:35People trying to get into the market now.
09:37Why them specifically?
09:38They're forced to pay these hugely inflated prices for assets, especially property, mainly
09:44by taking on enormous amounts of debt.
09:45Often for assets that have already shot up in value, thanks to earlier waves of borrowing.
09:51Who else?
09:52Renters.
09:52They get increasingly priced out.
09:54Home ownership becomes harder and harder to reach because of these debt-fueled asset
09:58bubbles.
09:59Makes sense.
10:00And ultimately, you could say future generations lose out, too.
10:03They inherit higher debt levels across the board, plus these sky-high asset prices.
10:07It makes achieving financial stability, building wealth.
10:11It's just a much tougher climb for them.
10:13And when we connect this back to your everyday life, the listener's life, the household impact
10:18is just undeniable, isn't it?
10:20It really is.
10:21That stat you mentioned earlier, average household debt quadrupled between 2002 and 2022.
10:27Quadrupled.
10:28Astonishing growth.
10:29That 182% debt-to-income ratio near record highs.
10:33And for many people trying to pay a mortgage, it now eats up, what was it, over half their
10:37income.
10:3850.6% of the median income, according to the source's data, just on mortgage payments.
10:42Half.
10:43That leads to huge economic stress, right?
10:45Less money for everything else.
10:47Reduced living standards.
10:48People are running harder and harder just to stay in the same place financially.
10:51And this constant pressure on households, it must have bigger ripples through the whole
10:55economy.
10:56Absolutely.
10:57There are broader systemic implications.
11:00We see these recurring asset bubbles, especially in property, driven largely by debt-fueled speculation,
11:06rather than just fundamentals.
11:08Okay.
11:09This directly fuels growing inequality.
11:11Wealth gets concentrated with people who own assets, while those relying on wages find
11:16it harder to keep up.
11:18The system itself becomes quite fragile, economically speaking.
11:21It's right, though how?
11:22It's vulnerable to debt deflation.
11:24If borrowing slows or asset prices fall, the whole thing can unwind quite painfully.
11:30And ultimately, it creates this dependency on growth.
11:33It needs to keep expanding.
11:34Yes.
11:35The system requires constant expansion, constant new debt, just to avoid collapsing under the
11:39weight of existing interest claims.
11:41Stability becomes this perpetual chase.
11:43And underpinning this entire structure, as the source explains it, is fiat currency,
11:48money backed by, well, not much besides government say-so and public faith.
11:52That's right.
11:52So if trust is really the bedrock of our Aussie dollar, what are the implications of relying
11:57on that, especially since there's nothing tangible like gold behind it anymore?
12:00That's a huge point.
12:01And it loops back perfectly to why the system is so dependent on that idea of trust and belief.
12:06How so?
12:07Well, the Australian dollar, like pretty much all major currencies today, it has no intrinsic
12:12value.
12:13No gold, no silver, no basket of commodities backing it.
12:16It's just paper or digits?
12:19Essentially.
12:19Yes.
12:20Backed by the government's decree that it's legal tender and everyone's collective agreement
12:25to accept it, which means, in theory, the government or the central bank working with
12:30banks can create, well, infinite amounts of it.
12:34Infinite money.
12:35Sounds good, but there's a catch.
12:36A big catch.
12:38Inflation risk.
12:39Yeah.
12:39If too much money is created relative to the goods and services available, the purchasing
12:43power of every single dollar goes down.
12:45Your savings become worth less.
12:46Right.
12:47And historically, how have fiat currencies fared?
12:50History isn't kind to them, frankly.
12:51The source points out that, historically, all purely fiat currencies have eventually failed.
12:57They either collapse or hyperinflate away or are replaced.
13:00All of them?
13:01According to that analysis, yes.
13:02With an average lifespan, historically, of just 27 years.
13:06Wow.
13:06That's sobering.
13:07It is.
13:08It's a stark reminder of the potential fragility of systems built solely on public confidence
13:14and government decree, without any anchor to something tangible.
13:17So, given all these parallels to a pyramid scheme, these fragilities with fiat currency,
13:23why does the system persist?
13:25What keeps it afloat despite the flaws the analysis highlights?
13:29Well, there are a few key reasons interacting.
13:32First, as we discussed, unlike a pure pyramid scheme, it does actually facilitate real economic
13:38activity.
13:39It's not just shuffling money.
13:40Okay.
13:41That's important.
13:41Second, government enforcement is key.
13:43The law says you have to accept dollars for debts, pay taxes in dollars.
13:48That maintains public acceptance.
13:50Inertia, almost.
13:51Partly.
13:52Also, a big factor is simply that most people don't fully grasp how money creation really
13:57works.
13:57The mechanics we talked about earlier.
13:59Not widely understood.
14:00So, the system isn't broadly questioned on that fundamental level.
14:03Ignorance is bliss, perhaps.
14:05Or at least it allows the status quo to continue.
14:07And finally, let's be honest.
14:08First, there are very powerful vested interests, financial institutions, existing asset owners
14:14who benefit enormously from the current system.
14:17And they have an incentive to keep it going.
14:19A very strong incentive, yes.
14:20But even with all that keeping it going, like any exponential system, surely it faces limits,
14:26long-term challenges.
14:27Absolutely.
14:28It's not infinitely sustainable.
14:30There are inherent constraints.
14:31Such as?
14:32Well, debt-servicing paying interest in principle takes up an ever-increasing slice of national
14:37income.
14:38At some point, households and businesses just can't take on more debt.
14:42New borrowers become harder to find.
14:44The fuel runs low.
14:46Exactly.
14:46Asset bubbles, too.
14:48They tend to burst eventually.
14:49It's happened repeatedly throughout history.
14:51That causes painful economic corrections.
14:53And the trust factor.
14:54That's perhaps the biggest vulnerability.
14:56Public trust, the very foundation of fiat money, can erode.
15:00And sometimes, it can erode very, very quickly, leading to unpredictable outcomes, maybe even
15:05systemic crises.
15:07The source doesn't just critique, though.
15:09Does it point towards any potential alternatives, ways to move beyond this debt-based model?
15:14It does briefly mention a few possibilities for monetary reform looking toward the future.
15:19Like what sort of ideas?
15:20Things like sovereign money, where the government itself creates money debt-free, rather than private
15:26banks creating it as debt.
15:28Okay.
15:28Or full reserve banking, where banks would have to hold 100% reserves against deposits.
15:34They couldn't just create money through lending based on fractional reserves.
15:39A much older model.
15:40Yes.
15:41Then there's talk of public digital currency, maybe using blockchain tech, where the government
15:45provides digital cash directly, bypassing commercial banks for basic transactions.
15:50Interesting.
15:51Any others?
15:52And also looking at public banking models, like the Bank of North Dakota in the U.S., which
15:56is state-owned and focuses on local development.
15:58Or China's state-owned banks funding massive infrastructure.
16:02Or even looking back at the original public mission of Australia's own commonwealth bank
16:07before it was privatized.
16:08So different ways of thinking about money creation and banking exist.
16:12Definitely.
16:13These are alternatives being discussed.
16:14Okay.
16:15So, wrapping this up, what does it all mean?
16:19We've gone through a pretty deep dive here into this analysis, this fascinating, maybe unsettling
16:25idea that Australia's money system has these structural echoes of a pyramid scheme.
16:31Understanding these dynamics seems pretty crucial, wouldn't you say, for everyday Australians, for
16:36policymakers, especially with all the economic uncertainty around it.
16:39Absolutely critical.
16:40As Australia grapples with these record debt levels, the cost of living, growing inequality,
16:46understanding the fundamental mechanics of our monetary system isn't just academic.
16:50Right.
16:50It's vital.
16:51Yeah.
16:52And this analysis, it suggests we might be in what it actually calls the final stages
16:56of this current monetary paradigm.
16:59That's a pretty heavy thought.
17:00The final stages.
17:01What might that look like for you, for your finances?
17:03And maybe the final question for listeners to ponder is, what role does public awareness, just
17:08understanding this stuff, play and maybe shaping what comes next?
17:11What's the future of money?
Be the first to comment
Add your comment