- 1 year ago
What does it take to land a song on a Billboard chart? Billboard’s managing director of charts & data operations, Keith Caulfield, joins host Kristin Robinson to unpack the evolution of the Billboard charts. From the origins of the Hot 100 and Billboard 200 to the modern formula of blending radio, sales and streams, Caulfield breaks down how his team evolves alongside the industry. Caulfield digs into why catalog albums keep finding new life, how Billboard determines an artists’ genre and how artists like Taylor Swift, Morgan Wallen and Drake achieve so many No. 1s. From artists releasing multiple vinyl variants to the comeback of CDs and cassettes, Caulfield explains how today’s musicians are using every format, and every fan connection, to make chart history.
Category
🎵
MusicTranscript
00:00:00Ask any musician what they dream of, and somewhere on that list is probably a Billboard number one.
00:00:05But here's the thing. Almost everyone has a theory about how the charts work,
00:00:09but very few people really know what goes into it.
00:00:12So this week, we're going to set the record straight.
00:00:15How do the Billboard charts actually work?
00:00:22Welcome back to On the Record, a music business podcast from Billboard and Sick Bird Productions.
00:00:27As always, I'm your host, Kristen Robinson, and today we are going to dive into all things Billboard charts.
00:00:33Even if you're not in the music business, you're probably familiar with our charts.
00:00:38The Hot 100 is the gold standard for measuring the success of singles,
00:00:41and the Billboard 200, which is our albums chart, measures the success for full bodies of work,
00:00:47whether that's an EP, a full album, or even a deluxe.
00:00:51But if I had a dollar for how many times I get asked by my friends about how the Billboard charts work,
00:00:57I don't know exactly how much money I would have, but it would be a solid amount of money.
00:01:02And the truth is that as a music business reporter at Billboard,
00:01:05I'm in our editorial department, not our charts department.
00:01:08So I honestly don't have a lot of answers to give people,
00:01:11but I do know someone that does, and that's our guest today.
00:01:15His name is Keith Caulfield.
00:01:17He's the Managing Director of Charts and Data Operations for Billboard,
00:01:20which is a very long title to basically say that he is the mastermind behind the Billboard 200.
00:01:26He's also the co-host of Pop Shop, another podcast from Billboard, which is all about pop culture.
00:01:31So be sure to check that out if it sounds like it's up your alley.
00:01:34We're going to dive in to how the Billboard charts are actually calculated,
00:01:38how they've evolved over the years, how fandom is increasingly playing a role,
00:01:42and what some common misconceptions are about the charts that Keith hears.
00:01:47So without further ado, let's bring in Keith Caulfield.
00:01:51Keith Caulfield, welcome to On The Record. Thanks for being here.
00:01:54Of course.
00:01:55I'm so glad that you're my guest this week because I personally have a lot of questions about the charts
00:01:58that I still don't think I've even asked you, even though we sit right by each other at work.
00:02:04So I appreciate you being here.
00:02:06I wanted to get started by asking you a little bit about how you got into Billboard in the first place
00:02:11because you've been working on the charts for a couple decades now, right?
00:02:14Neons.
00:02:15Millennia.
00:02:16Okay, so tell me about that.
00:02:17How did you get into it?
00:02:18So many eras.
00:02:19I was an intern at Billboard in college.
00:02:21Nice.
00:02:22USC?
00:02:22Yes, USC.
00:02:23Shout out.
00:02:24Interned for three semesters, which is two semesters longer than you typically should intern somewhere.
00:02:31And then badgered the folks at Billboard until they hired me, and I got the job right out of college.
00:02:40And they haven't gotten rid of me.
00:02:43So I've been here.
00:02:43Okay, so when was this?
00:02:46What's the timeline?
00:02:48Exact dates.
00:02:49Now we're going to reveal exact dates here.
00:02:51It's been forever.
00:02:52It's been forever.
00:02:53It's been over.
00:02:54I'm ancient.
00:02:55You can just look at me.
00:02:56I'm an elder man.
00:02:57I don't think that's true.
00:02:58Then I have amazing skin.
00:03:00I don't know what the lights are doing.
00:03:02Okay, well, okay.
00:03:03Let's get into the history of the Billboard charts, which very much so predates you at Billboard.
00:03:09Maybe, yeah.
00:03:09Maybe, just a few years.
00:03:11So can you tell us about the history of the Billboard charts?
00:03:13Because obviously the Hot 100 and the Billboard 200 have been kind of the standard for measuring the success of albums and singles.
00:03:21But they haven't been around forever.
00:03:24I mean, close to forever.
00:03:25Yeah.
00:03:26Well, not really.
00:03:26I mean, the Hot 100, the Billboard Hot 100 is a songs chart.
00:03:30It's been around since 1958.
00:03:31Okay.
00:03:32And the Billboard 200, which is an albums chart, has – we say that its history dates back to March of 1956 when the chart began publishing on a regular weekly basis.
00:03:46There was an album chart or album charts before that, but they weren't published consistently.
00:03:52So we start the Billboard 200 in March of 1956.
00:03:55Interesting.
00:03:55Okay, so someone like Frank Sinatra was not using Billboard to measure his, like, 1940s hits.
00:04:01Well, no.
00:04:02We did have – there were songs and album charts before the Hot 100 and the Billboard 200.
00:04:08So Frank does have chart history dating back to the 1940s.
00:04:11So all those artists that maybe don't have a chart history on the Hot 100 do have a chart history on other charts.
00:04:19We had other songs charts going back to 1940 when we first started publishing a regular songs chart.
00:04:25It was based on, I think, sales, like in stores, I believe.
00:04:29We do have history on those folks from the 1940s and 50s.
00:04:33Got it.
00:04:33Okay, that's interesting.
00:04:34So what makes the Hot 100 the Hot 100?
00:04:36Is it just the fact that you named it that in 1956 and started publishing it weekly?
00:04:4158.
00:04:42Sorry, 58.
00:04:43It's all right.
00:04:45Numbers.
00:04:45I got numbers.
00:04:46I'll start quoting numbers, actually.
00:04:48I think it's because there was a special formula that combined, at the time, radio airplay and sales of songs, singles, in stores,
00:05:00in a way that attempted to measure the most popular, the 100 most popular singles in the United States.
00:05:08Singles meaning the songs that you could purchase inside record stores.
00:05:12Yeah.
00:05:12Just as a standalone.
00:05:14Yeah.
00:05:15Okay.
00:05:16So it wouldn't measure, like, a song on an album that's track number seven that was never pushed as a single.
00:05:20Right.
00:05:20But now we do.
00:05:21Yes.
00:05:22Yeah.
00:05:22Which we'll get into all of the changes that have happened over time.
00:05:25But, yeah, I mean, I think that a lot of people will ask me about, like, what the formula is for how the Hot 100 and the Billboard 200 are calculated.
00:05:35And I don't have much information beyond its radio, its sales, and its streams, right?
00:05:41Can you give us, like, a little bit of a breakdown as to how you'll tabulate that today?
00:05:45So, I mean, first, we have a zillion charts.
00:05:49Yes.
00:05:49The two most familiar charts are the Billboard Hot 100 and the Billboard 200.
00:05:54The Hot 100 is a songs chart.
00:05:56The Billboard 200 is an albums chart.
00:05:58And then we have a bunch of, I guess, like, children of those charts that use the same methodology but have different genres covered in them.
00:06:08So, for example, the Billboard Hot 100 is an all-genre chart for songs.
00:06:13But then we have a chart like Hot Rap Songs, which uses the same methodology as the Hot 100, but it has just rap and hip-hop songs on it.
00:06:20And then the Hot Country songs, Hot Latin songs, you get the idea.
00:06:23Billboard 200, same idea.
00:06:25You have the Billboard 200.
00:06:26And then you have charts like Top Country albums, Top Rap albums, Top Latin albums.
00:06:30Same methodology, different genres.
00:06:32So, backing up a little bit, the Billboard Hot 100 combines airplay of songs, streams of songs, and sales of songs, both physical and digital.
00:06:43So, if there's something on a 12-inch vinyl or a CD single, we will count that.
00:06:47Or if it's just purchased as a digital track.
00:06:50Billboard 200, it's straight album sales, like pure physical and digital downloads, you know, CDs, vinyl, cassettes.
00:06:57It's streams of songs from those albums, and then purchases of tracks from the albums.
00:07:04We combine those respective things into each chart using a mathematical methodology.
00:07:11It's not really a great phrase.
00:07:12And then we rank the titles based upon the spit-out totals, and then we get the top 100 songs and the top 200 albums of each week.
00:07:22So, how do you handle things that have emerged over time, like YouTube popped up at some point?
00:07:27Yeah. TikTok has popped up.
00:07:29These other formats where people are consuming music, but it's not very traditional.
00:07:33Well, I mean, for a long time, the Hot 100, as an example, was only airplay and sales, like radio airplay and sales.
00:07:40It wasn't until the end of 1998 that we allowed non-commercially available songs to chart, meaning like album cuts, airplay hits.
00:07:52Because we were getting to a point where lots of songs were not released as, like, commercially available singles, meaning you could go buy it.
00:07:59Also, this is, of course, before digital, before streams, before the iTunes store.
00:08:03So, you had to buy a CD single or a cassette single.
00:08:07How quaint.
00:08:08And then, you know, obviously later we added streaming to the chart, and then we added YouTube to the chart.
00:08:16What we don't currently have in any of our charts is user-generated content, UGC, which is, you know, like you, Kristen, like making a fun video where you're dancing to Taylor Swift.
00:08:26That would not count towards any of our charts.
00:08:28So, that would exclude TikTok, because that's essentially all user-generated content.
00:08:33Also, TikTok doesn't contribute to our charts currently.
00:08:37A lot of streaming services do.
00:08:39So, if something you see, like, pops off on TikTok and becomes a viral trend that usually has a, you know, cascading effect over other streaming services where maybe you see something and then you go and stream it on Apple or Spotify, that stream does count towards our charts.
00:08:52Yeah. So, basically, people have to take action beyond just the viral moment on the app for it to end up having an impact on the charts.
00:09:00Yeah. I mean, who knows what will happen years from now, but that's currently what's happening.
00:09:03Yeah. Because y'all are always evolving it, right?
00:09:06Yes.
00:09:07Okay. So, like, in the charts meetings, which I'm not part of, like, are you guys constantly talking about, oh, this format is becoming more and more popular? How do we integrate it? Can we change the rules?
00:09:17Yes. We're talking about that and all sorts of things that are happening because we're always trying to, as best as we can, make the charts relevant to how music is consumed now and how it will be consumed in the next, you know, five years.
00:09:31So, we're usually pretty cautious about how we include new forms of data into our charts, but we do constantly make tweaks and changes to the charts based upon market conditions and how people are consuming music.
00:09:44Hmm. And going back to when you guys integrated streaming, I think people who are outside the music industry fail to recognize just how much of a seismic shift moving from sales into streaming as, like, the most popular format was.
00:09:58You're no longer buying anything. And you can also, you know, select to stream just one of the songs and then move on from an album.
00:10:05I'm wondering how you guys found a way to integrate streaming into the charts. I imagine that was a challenge at that moment.
00:10:12Well, I think for both the Hot 100 and the Billboard 200, streams came into both charts after streaming had really kind of had a firm, you know, grip on the American public.
00:10:24It wasn't like we added streaming to the charts like when Spotify arrived in America.
00:10:30There was still like a number of years before that reached our charts.
00:10:34So we're always very cautious about adding any new piece of metric or data to our charts.
00:10:43Was it a seismic shift?
00:10:45Initially, initially, it's still I think the charts when both the Hot 100 and the Billboard 200 brought in streaming, I think overall.
00:10:55There wasn't like an enormous change necessarily to what was on the chart because each chart was still dominated by other forms of consumption.
00:11:08So like, for example, on the Billboard 200, when we brought in streams at the end of 2014, it didn't really make a huge difference in what the chart looked like and what titles were on the chart because the vast majority of the activity on the chart was still traditional album sales, pure album sales.
00:11:25Like, I think the first week that we brought in streams on the Billboard 200, like, I think 85% of the chart was still album sales.
00:11:34And that's basically flipped around the other direction now where it's mostly streams.
00:11:40And typically albums will only have a huge number of sales and like their first or second week on the chart.
00:11:45And then most of the rest of the activity, if it stays on the chart, is usually streaming activity and maybe some vinyl sales.
00:11:51It usually doesn't make a humongous difference in the makeup of the chart.
00:11:55But over time, you will you will see a difference.
00:11:58I want to talk about kind of a related thing here.
00:12:01A lot of artists these days are releasing multiple variants of the same project.
00:12:05For example, Taylor Swift ultimately had over 30 different variants of the Torture Poets department.
00:12:11How do variants play a role in those album sales in the first couple of weeks?
00:12:15I imagine some fans are buying multiple.
00:12:17I mean, I wish I knew for sure if, like, there were fans buying multiple copies.
00:12:22I can speak from experience where me being a super fan of some artists, I have done that where I try to, you know, catch them all like they're Pokemon.
00:12:29You know, it's like, get all the vinyl variants.
00:12:30You got to have them all.
00:12:31Why?
00:12:31I don't know.
00:12:32I just have to have them.
00:12:33It's ridiculous.
00:12:34Not everyone is like that.
00:12:36I think I think a lot of people, you know, pick and choose like the versions that they want.
00:12:39And but I mean, we're in a we're in a time now where you don't need to purchase a album in order to consume it.
00:12:47Most people stream music.
00:12:48There are still people that actually engage with their music through a digital download that they purchase from iTunes or elsewhere, or they buy a physical album.
00:12:58And that's how they listen to it.
00:12:59I still think the majority of people today actually just stream music, but there are going to be like big diehard fans that want to go and get a cool version of the album in like a deluxe limited CD edition or, you know, 25 different color final variants or the one that comes with, you know, a special poster inside or the signed CD.
00:13:19Like all those things matter a lot in terms of trying to boost your first week sales.
00:13:24And so, you know, for some artists, if you have the kind of fan that's going to purchase more than one copy of the album in its first week, why not cater to those fans and maybe have a couple options for them if they want to get a CD and a vinyl and maybe even a cassette to Taylor only had one cassette in her first week for the life of the showgirl tortured poets, I think, had four different cassettes in his first week.
00:13:45Interesting. Do you think that that's a sign that cassettes are just not that popular?
00:13:49Oh, ma'am, cassettes died a long time ago, but they've they've come back.
00:13:54Like in like a small way over the past few years.
00:13:57So like artists like Olivia Rodrigo, Billie Eilish, Taylor Swift have found success on cassettes where they're selling like thousands of cassettes to people who I'm not sure if they actually have cassette decks.
00:14:11Yeah. I'm like, do you where are the Walkmans coming from?
00:14:13I don't think that they sell those anymore.
00:14:15I don't have any metrics on that, so I'm not going to spin any numbers at you.
00:14:19But I do feel like there is some small fraction of super fans who are like, hey, now that I have all these cassettes that I bought and they're pretty to look at, maybe I can try to play them.
00:14:31Yeah.
00:14:31If they've taken the shrink wrap off.
00:14:33Yes. Very true. I mean, they are like collectibles.
00:14:36So, I mean, I think a lot of us have heard the stat by now that like 50 percent of people who buy a vinyl record don't actually have a turntable at home.
00:14:43Yeah. That was a stat from Luminate a couple of years ago.
00:14:46I would imagine that number is probably increased since then.
00:14:49Yeah.
00:14:50But it was a pretty, it's an oft quoted number because it's pretty staggering because it's like, really? Really? So like, all right, well, what about cassettes? How many people actually have cassette players? Let's put an album on a floppy disk. Why don't we?
00:15:04Yeah, that's the next variant. Just to expand the variant empire of all these artists. When did you start seeing variants become popular? Because I just feel like I kind of woke up one day and all of a sudden everyone had, you know, a million versions of the same project for fans to collect.
00:15:20I mean, I think it's, I think it's always been a thing, but not in the way that we've seen it. I think maybe since COVID. Like I remember being a kid and like there could be like a special limited deluxe premium packaging version of an album on CD that had like a limited release.
00:15:40That was like pretty rare. Like typically back in the olden days, meaning like the 80s and the 90s. Generally speaking, there was like a CD. Now there could be sometimes like maybe there would be a different CD edition for Japan or maybe one for a different country or maybe one that has a bonus track at Best Buy or something.
00:16:03But what we're seeing now where, you know, you have like four or five or six different CDs for an album in its first week and then you have eight or 12 or 20 different vinyl variants.
00:16:13That really only came about with sort of, I think a combo package of the popularity of D2C, like artist official web stores, like really taking hold like in the past five or so years and COVID.
00:16:29And I don't, I think it's the, I think it's the two things like combined and colluded during COVID where like we couldn't go anywhere.
00:16:36So we turned to artist official web stores. Those web stores really super served fans and gave them lots of options of things to buy and leaned into vinyl and leaned into physical purchases of things that were both collectible and music and cost a lot of money and you can make a lot of money off of them.
00:16:52Yeah. I do wonder what you think success is for an album in 2025 in the age of streaming.
00:17:00You know, is it just getting to number one?
00:17:02It's getting onto the Billboard 200 chart.
00:17:04Well, of course.
00:17:05That's the right answer.
00:17:06The right answer is that. But, you know, I think a lot of people can maybe...
00:17:10Also, it's fine if you're never on the Billboard 200. It's fine. You don't have to chart.
00:17:12This is true. We still care about you guys.
00:17:13Success is success in your own way.
00:17:15Yes, of course. Of course. Well, I guess success on the charts is more so what I'm thinking about.
00:17:21So, you know, obviously your first or second week, you're going to have potentially a bunch of sales.
00:17:26You're going to have a lot of interest, a lot of curiosity streams of your project.
00:17:30So I could imagine that an artist charts pretty well in their first or second week.
00:17:33But I think in the age of streaming, because we can measure every single time someone goes back to an album, I imagine that longevity on the charts is potentially a better measure of success.
00:17:46I'm wondering what your thoughts are, though, on that.
00:17:47I mean, just making the chart, making the Billboard 200 or making any of Billboard's charts is a feat.
00:17:53It's hard. It's very hard to make the charts because the volume of either sales or streaming activity that you need is really high.
00:18:03Because now the Billboard 200 and the Hot 100 effectively includes, like, everything that's ever been made.
00:18:09But, like, on the Billboard 200, the oldest albums ever can still chart.
00:18:13Like, we used to have rules that barred older albums from charting on the Billboard 200.
00:18:17Oh, interesting. Okay.
00:18:18We call them catalog albums.
00:18:20Yeah. And what defines a catalog album? Because I know some people think it's over 18 months old.
00:18:26It's over 18 months old. And for us, it has to be below number 100 on the chart.
00:18:31Got it.
00:18:31But, like, we don't, we don't, I mean, we allow catalog albums to chart on the Billboard 200.
00:18:37That's why you see a lot of, like, older Drake and Morgan Wallen albums, you know, chart, you know, for a million years.
00:18:43I think, I think we see a lot of albums that chart for one week or two weeks or three weeks and then fall off the chart.
00:18:50Because they're front-loaded with a lot of sales and don't have tons of streams to sustain their momentum.
00:18:57Yeah.
00:18:57Whereas then you have a lot of albums that hang around forever from currently right now, you know, Sabrina Carpenter or Noah Kahn or Morgan Wallen or Drake or Kendrick Lamar who have so many streams, just constant streams of people just replaying the songs from the album on their personal playlists.
00:19:18And we count all that. That keeps those albums on the chart for a very long time.
00:19:22Yeah. And I mean, I do feel like, kind of going back to my comment before about how I feel it's a seismic shift from moving from a pure sales environment on the charts to sales and streaming, with streaming being the predominant method of consumption now.
00:19:35I mean, streaming really does measure in real time how sticky an album is with a consumer.
00:19:40Whereas sales used to be, okay, so, you know, you went to the store and you bought the record.
00:19:45That's a huge deal. But we don't know how many times you spun that record after.
00:19:49We don't know if you listen to it once and you're like, oh, this album sucks. I'm never going to listen to it again.
00:19:53Yeah.
00:19:53Or if you listen to it every single day for the rest of your life.
00:19:57So I'm wondering when you compare chart success in 2025 to chart success in a different time period of the music industry where maybe let's say like the 20th century music industry.
00:20:11Are they really comparable? Like, remember that time when Drake said, I have more hits than the Beatles?
00:20:17Yeah.
00:20:18And he technically does.
00:20:21Yeah, on the Hot 100, he does. Like, he's got like, I don't know, was it like hundreds of hits now on the Hot 100?
00:20:25Yes. Yeah, exactly. But I mean, things have totally changed since the Beatles to Drake.
00:20:30It's a fun game to play. It's a fun game to play. Like, can you really compare the current era to previous eras? And we do. That's that's the whole point of the Billboard 200 and the Hot 100 in any of our charts that have longevity over time.
00:20:45The methodology may change and how those charts are compiled. But because that chart existed and because the point of the chart, the point of the Billboard 200 is supposed to, you know, recognize or show the most popular albums in the United States.
00:20:59Now, what we defined popularity as has changed a little bit over time. At one point, it was just when you purchased an album. And then it became when you streamed the songs from the album and when you purchased the album.
00:21:13Obviously, it's changed over time. And we've changed the rules on what can and can't chart. Now we allow older albums, catalog albums. There was a time that we didn't.
00:21:21So, yeah, it's it's always interesting to have that discussion of, well, can we really compare 2025 to 2005? It's like, well, yes, we can. I do think it's fair to point out the differences and the caveats.
00:21:42Yeah. Just like we do on the Billboard Hot 100, where people will say, well, you know, so and so has like X number of songs on the Hot 100 this week.
00:21:50You know, how is that comparable to the 1980s when we didn't have streaming? So you couldn't have all the album songs chart at the same time.
00:21:58Like, I understand that. Like, I like playing the game, too, where I would say, yeah, imagine how many songs from, you know, Michael Jackson's Bad album would have charted in its first week when it came out.
00:22:10Yeah. Or how many songs from the Beatles would have charted in the 1960s had we allowed anything that wasn't a single, like a commercially available single to chart.
00:22:20Like Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band didn't have any official singles from it.
00:22:24Really?
00:22:25There were no singles from it. We know a bunch of the songs from the album because we've heard them forever.
00:22:30And certainly radio probably played the heck out of them back in the day.
00:22:32But there were no singles from that album. So nothing from that album charted on the Billboard Hot 100.
00:22:37That is interesting.
00:22:38I mean, maybe they charted later in some other form, but initially there were no singles from it.
00:22:42Yeah. But technically, like, given that we now allow catalog tracks, could they, if there was some resurgence, like let's say there was a sync, it put it in a, like one of the Sgt. Pepper songs made it into a popular TV show and it spiked.
00:22:53We have specific rules around kind of like revived songs on the Hot 100.
00:22:58So as an example, when Kate Bush was running up that hill, had the sync in Stranger Things.
00:23:04That song actually had a chart run back in the 80s, but then it came back and it was revived and it had, it was promoted to radio.
00:23:12It was an official single. It was promoted and it recharted.
00:23:16Fleetwood Mac's Dreams, when it went viral on TikTok with the Ocean Spray skateboarding dude, that song came back as well.
00:23:24So there has to be, I forget exactly what the rule is, but those songs can come back under certain conditions.
00:23:31Got it.
00:23:32Just like every year, like Halloween songs come back, Christmas songs come back, and then they go away after Halloween and Christmas.
00:23:37Yeah, that's one of my dream episodes. Hopefully we'll be able to do it this year.
00:23:42Just, I find Christmas music to be so interesting, or holiday music in general.
00:23:46Can't wait for November 1st to get out here.
00:23:48I know, seriously. I'll be, I'll be pulling out all my Christmas vinyl.
00:23:52But yeah, I mean, it's...
00:23:53But do you have a turntable?
00:23:54I do have a turntable, thank you for asking.
00:23:57Yes, I do have a turntable.
00:23:59Is it the best quality turntable in the world?
00:24:02No, I'm sure one of the audiophiles who, you know, is on our staff would probably say it's not the best.
00:24:08Maybe you should have some, like, expert in, like, the turntable field come on and talk about turntable.
00:24:12I know. Well, they would, like, just wipe the floor with me.
00:24:14I don't know enough about that kind of stuff.
00:24:16That being said, I just want to say for the record that, for the record on On The Record,
00:24:20that it's not one of those Crossley suitcase ones that everyone hates on.
00:24:24Wow, shady. Shading on the Crossley.
00:24:25Yeah, I'm so sorry if you have one of those.
00:24:27It's just, it's the one that audiophiles do hate on a lot.
00:24:29There went your sponsorship. We're so sorry, Crossley.
00:24:33I know, Crossley hasn't reached out, but they won't be now.
00:24:36So, okay, so I think in our modern time, we're seeing that certain genres are consumed differently just based on their fan bases.
00:24:45So, like, for example, the commonly held belief is that country does really well with sales.
00:24:50A lot of people still who like country tend to buy albums.
00:24:54Whereas with rap music, a lot of people tend to stream for rap music.
00:25:00Latin music, I've heard, is really popular on YouTube.
00:25:03That's obviously, there's plenty of other formats all of these fans listen to the music on, but that tends to be true.
00:25:09I'm wondering, how have you seen that impact the genre's success on the charts?
00:25:14Country music is getting more popular on streaming services, so it's not just like, I mean, look at Morgan Wallen and Megan Maroney and, you know, Zach Bryan.
00:25:22I mean, he's not, he's country and he's rock and he's...
00:25:25He would say that he can't be defined.
00:25:27I mean, he is a difficult person to define on the charts, but, you know, we try to do that because we've got lots of charts.
00:25:34Country is making inroads at streaming.
00:25:36Latin, you are correct, Latin over-indexes on YouTube.
00:25:41And, you know, certain services, certain streaming services are more popular with certain genres than others.
00:25:48And I think we saw, like, when streaming first came out of the charts, how certain genres kind of over-indexed because of the early adopters,
00:25:56which tend to be younger people who are more inclined to embrace new technology because to them it's just, it's what's, it's how they consume music.
00:26:07A great way to think about this is, like, you know, who were the first people to purchase CDs through the internet?
00:26:17And I remember when we started our internet album sales chart, which we don't have anymore, but it was a chart just for, like, CDs, like, albums that were purchased through the internet, meaning, like, Amazon.com and other stores on the internet.
00:26:30It was mostly a lot of, like, college rock, alternative music because that was the kind of music that, you know, appealed to people who were willing to pay money on a credit card on the internet for something.
00:26:46We're like, I don't know if I'm going to get it.
00:26:48Eventually, everyone caught up and everyone buys music off the internet now.
00:26:51Streaming's the same way.
00:26:52You start off with certain genres that tend to do well initially before it expands to everyone else.
00:26:57And I think we're at the point where a lot of people and a lot of genres, almost all the genres, are doing very well with streaming services.
00:27:03But you are correct that certain genres over-index with streams before they eventually equal out across all the genres.
00:27:10Yeah.
00:27:10So we just mentioned that, you know, Zach Bryan is one of those artists that's a little hard to define in terms of what genre he is.
00:27:17There's plenty of artists that kind of fit that category where maybe you could say they're country, but also maybe you could say they're a million other things.
00:27:24We do have genre-specific charts.
00:27:27Got tons of them.
00:27:28Tons of them.
00:27:29Tons of them.
00:27:30So how do you guys determine who goes where on these genre charts when someone is kind of in between genres?
00:27:37Well, most of the time, categorizing an album or a song by genre is usually simple.
00:27:45Like 95% of the time, it's pretty simple.
00:27:48Sometimes, though, an artist may make a song or an album that kind of straddles genres or maybe is kind of hard to define.
00:27:54Typically, we rely on what the artist and the label, how they define the album, and also what it just sounds like.
00:28:04And also, an album or a song can be more than one genre.
00:28:08Something can be a rap, dance, electronic record, or something can be a country and R&B record.
00:28:19It can be multiple things.
00:28:20That's, I think, different than maybe it has been in decades past.
00:28:25Think like in the 1980s.
00:28:26The only way that you really listened to music was either on the radio, and most radio stations were formatted to particular genres, or you purchased a physical piece of music in a store.
00:28:37That was the only way you could really listen to something on demand, so to speak, at home.
00:28:41Or maybe you watched MTV, or BET, or VH1, or something.
00:28:46And all those things were highly categorized and siloed off.
00:28:51Like even if you went to a record store, there would be a whole section of just country music, a whole section of rock music.
00:28:57There wasn't just A to Z, have at it.
00:29:00There's like the opera singer next to the country singer.
00:29:02Like no, everything would be categorized.
00:29:04And generally that was done just so that people could organize things, just so it's like easier to find things.
00:29:10And I think, you know, today, the way people consume music, the algorithm is telling me that I should maybe be listening to this song, which may not be a genre that I typically listen to, but the algorithm suggests maybe I should.
00:29:24So I don't know.
00:29:24It's just really different today in how people consume music, because that's why I think more artists are willing to kind of go outside whatever box they may have been put in initially.
00:29:33Yeah, I totally agree.
00:29:34I mean, I definitely think that the decline of radio coupled with the rise of algorithmic recommendations has kind of led to people just listening to whatever, you know, it's all over the place.
00:29:46But that's also something I wanted to talk about.
00:29:48So I think that these days we are all kind of in our own silos on the Internet.
00:29:54This is true across music, across the content we're receiving on TikTok, whatever.
00:29:59Whatever the algorithm has determined we're interested in, it takes us further down that rabbit hole.
00:30:05Yeah.
00:30:05For that reason, I feel like I'm increasingly hearing people say, oh, that's the number one song in America right now.
00:30:13I've never heard of that.
00:30:14I've never heard of it.
00:30:15And it's like a giant Morgan Wallen song or it's a giant K-pop Demon Hunters track.
00:30:20And I'm wondering, how do you respond to those kind of comments like that?
00:30:26I mean, you literally just laid it out in the question.
00:30:28I mean, like my running joke is that I'll see a post on Billboard's Instagram about, you know, Morgan Wallen being number one for like a millionth week.
00:30:36And there's inevitably going to be a comment that says, I don't know who this Morgan Wallen man is.
00:30:41Who is this guy?
00:30:42Like, I'm like, are you just a troll?
00:30:44Are you a bot?
00:30:45Like, how could you not know?
00:30:46That is possible.
00:30:47Like, how could you not know who Morgan Wallen is?
00:30:50Even if you don't listen to his music, how could you not know that he exists?
00:30:52And I guess there is some conceivable way that maybe the algorithms have never showed you a Morgan Wallen song ever.
00:31:04It just seems weird to me.
00:31:07It's sort of like me thinking like in the early 1990s when Garth Brooks was like really breaking out in an enormous way.
00:31:14And every album that he put out was like number one.
00:31:15And he was playing Central Park in New York and playing stadiums.
00:31:18And he was just like country became incredibly cool and popular in the early 1990s.
00:31:23He didn't have pop hits on like Top 40 radio.
00:31:27But everyone knew who Garth Brooks was, even if he didn't listen to his music.
00:31:30I'm like, that's sort of the way I think of Morgan Wallen.
00:31:32I'm like, even if you're not listening, actively trying to listen to his music, you must know that he exists and he's really popular.
00:31:38At this point, if you don't, then you're just really shielding yourself or you're just being a troll.
00:31:43But yeah, I think it is interesting to think about how the algorithm can, you know, on streaming services can shape how we become aware of people or are completely unaware of people.
00:31:59Which is just annoying to me that like I was looking at the streaming service that I use on a regular basis.
00:32:07And I was looking at their new releases that came out on that Friday and I was talking to someone on staff and they said, oh, the new so-and-so album is out today.
00:32:18I'm like, it is?
00:32:19Now, obviously, I work at Billboard.
00:32:21I should know these things off the top of my head, but I didn't momentarily remember that the album came out that day.
00:32:26And I looked at the new releases on my app.
00:32:29It was not listed.
00:32:30Like I scrolled, scrolled and there were like, you know, a dozen releases.
00:32:33None of them were there.
00:32:34And this was like a significant artist, a very significant artist.
00:32:37And I was getting like albums that were two weeks old as a new release for me.
00:32:43Because clearly the algorithm was like, oh, you're not really interested in this album.
00:32:47And I'm like, you know, there's something to be said for people just knowing about what is the newest music that is out.
00:32:52Totally.
00:32:53Because, I don't know, I just, it's helpful.
00:32:57It's nice to know what's out.
00:32:58I guess that's like maybe what New Music Friday is for.
00:33:01Although it won't tell you that an album is out.
00:33:03It'll tell you what the focus track or the single is from that album, maybe.
00:33:06If it made New Music Friday.
00:33:08Yeah, that's true.
00:33:09Because it's still a panel of people or an algorithm showing you what's on a list.
00:33:14I mean, really, is the algorithm and all the playlists and New Music Friday on whatever service you're on,
00:33:18is this really that much different from, you know, the days of MTV and VH1 and radio stations deciding what to play and in what rotation and what they're going to premiere when?
00:33:29I mean, it's just a different way.
00:33:32It's just a different, I mean, there's like a greater amount of music that's on these services now.
00:33:36But in a way, there's still people that are deciding what you're going to listen to and an algorithm that is trying to think what you might want to listen to.
00:33:44Yeah, I think editorial playlists are still kind of, you know, in the same old school tradition of gatekeepers in the industry.
00:33:53You know, they're trained people who know everything that's coming out and they make editorial decisions.
00:33:59Also, gatekeeper is such like a, like, it has such like a negative tone.
00:34:02It's like people are keeping things away from you.
00:34:03It's like, well, I mean, think of it as like someone that's, in theory, helping you learn about music that they think that you might like.
00:34:10Kind of like if you, Kristen, were showing me, like, you made me a mix CD or a mixtape back in the day.
00:34:17It's like, hey, would I call you a gatekeeper?
00:34:20Or would I just say, you're just showing me, like, music that, like, you've curated a list of music that you think that I might like.
00:34:25And you made it specially for me.
00:34:27It's like Keith's mix.
00:34:28Keith's, like, party mix.
00:34:30Yeah.
00:34:30I guess you're a gatekeeper.
00:34:32Yeah, well, very true.
00:34:33I mean, I think that, you know, gatekeepers and curators used to be people, and sometimes they still are.
00:34:38In the case of editorial playlists, they are controlled by real people.
00:34:42Yeah.
00:34:42But, I mean, how is the algorithm any different from that?
00:34:45I mean, it's still guiding you and curating you into a certain, you know, rabbit hole that they think that you'll like.
00:34:52I will say the algorithm is, like, I've learned about a lot of music that I probably wouldn't have found.
00:34:56Same.
00:34:56You know, initially.
00:34:57Yeah.
00:34:57So I'm like, you know, it's great in lots of ways.
00:34:59Like, but, you know, I'm still annoyed where, like, I can't see what a major new album is that came out that day and the app didn't show me.
00:35:06I'm like, come on, guys.
00:35:07Yeah.
00:35:08You should know me better by now.
00:35:09Apparently not.
00:35:11Yeah.
00:35:11So, I mean, it does feel like there are less, like, kind of monocultural touch points in music.
00:35:16We're oftentimes not listening to the same five radio stations in town.
00:35:20I wonder what that, you know, means for the charts.
00:35:23It happens across all media.
00:35:25Like, it's, like, when you watch the Emmy Awards or you watch the Oscars, it's like, well, how many of these shows have you seen or even heard of?
00:35:33Like, I don't know.
00:35:34Like, maybe there are some, like, crazy, like, TV stands and movie stands that are like, I've seen them all.
00:35:39I watch them all on every service.
00:35:41I'm like, I don't know.
00:35:42Like, every, like, media sort of format has the same challenge as we do in terms of music.
00:35:47I still think there obviously are, like, big, like, monoculture moments.
00:35:53Like, the Huntrix song, Golden, from K-pop Demon Hunters.
00:35:55K-pop Demon Hunters is, like, a pop culture moment.
00:35:58The release of Taylor Swift's The Life of a Showgirl.
00:36:00You could not avoid that album.
00:36:02It was everywhere.
00:36:03Everything.
00:36:04Everywhere.
00:36:04Yeah.
00:36:05Everyone was talking about it.
00:36:05You could even argue that that was maybe even a bigger moment than, I mean, with the internet and the hive mind of the internet.
00:36:13That album has had more heft to it than many other moments in the past.
00:36:20I mean, it helps that it's from Taylor Swift, who's, like, the biggest star on the planet.
00:36:24Yeah.
00:36:24I mean, but, like, you could arguably say that she's potentially bigger than any artist has ever been able to be, given, I don't know, is that crazy to say that?
00:36:33No, you just said it.
00:36:34It might be crazy that I just said that, but I do think it kind of feels that way.
00:36:38She is so in a league of her own.
00:36:40Oftentimes, it's many artists' goal to get a number one on the Hot 100 or the Billboard 200 charts.
00:36:45And people kind of do anything they can to get there.
00:36:49I'm sure there are some people who savvily try to, like, get around chart rules.
00:36:53I'm wondering, have you seen any kind of instances where people have tried to use a loophole in the chart rule system?
00:37:01And how did you deal with that when it happened?
00:37:05We love that the charts are popular.
00:37:09And we love that there is passion for the charts.
00:37:15It's a double-edged sword.
00:37:16We, in theory, we would love the charts just sort of represent, here's what's popular, without kind of a bunch of, like, sort of, you know, influences to sort of tinker with what is just sort of measured popularity.
00:37:32But, you know, that's never really been the case.
00:37:35Like, there's always been, you know, things that have, like, you know, tipped the scales or pulled levers.
00:37:40That's just the way marketing and promotion works, you know, at the record labels.
00:37:43Obviously, there are many artists that would love to be number one or be on the charts, or it's important for them to be top ten, and we love that.
00:37:49We also love the fact that some artists are just like, I don't really care where I chart.
00:37:55I'm just making music.
00:37:56And, like, we tell people that all the time.
00:37:58Like, if something, like, isn't necessarily chart eligible, because we have lots of rules that, you know, certain kinds of products may not be eligible for our charts.
00:38:07We always tell people, like, you should still make what's best for your fans.
00:38:11Like, do whatever you want to do.
00:38:13So, you know, just that particular thing maybe can't chart.
00:38:18But we always tell managers and labels, like, you should do what's best for the art and for the artist.
00:38:24Like, it doesn't matter if it's on the chart.
00:38:26I'm like, it matters, but I'm like, you should do what's best for the art.
00:38:31So, all that said, like, yeah, some artists care passionately about being number one or in the top ten or on the chart.
00:38:37And lots of folks will find, you know, crafty ways to be on the charts.
00:38:45You know, and I think, you know, some people may argue that the idea of having multiple variants of an album is kind of an interesting way to find success in the chart.
00:38:57But there's nothing stopping anyone from having multiple versions of an album for someone to purchase.
00:39:03I mean, we could go back to, like, the 2000s and there were lots of instances where in order for you to get all of the bonus tracks for an album, let's say, you'd have to go to Target to get a CD that had one bonus track.
00:39:15Go to Best Buy to get another CD with a different bonus track.
00:39:18Go to Walmart to get another CD with maybe a different cover and a bonus track.
00:39:22That kind of concept doesn't really exist as much today.
00:39:26You don't think so?
00:39:27I think that, like...
00:39:28It's in a different way.
00:39:29Now it's like vinyl variants and CD variants.
00:39:31Yeah.
00:39:32Like, and, you know, maybe the bonus tracks are, you know, maybe parsed out in a different fashion.
00:39:39I'm just thinking, like, there used to be a time where you'd have to go from store to store to pick up all the different versions of an album.
00:39:45Yeah.
00:39:45So have you ever evolved the chart rules to try to close some of those loopholes?
00:39:50I mean, we're always looking at, like, how we can evolve the charts and their rules and the methodology, like, to make sure that we're not completely out of step.
00:39:58Like, the idea is that we're supposed to be, like, you know, in step with how people consume music in America.
00:40:04And so we're always, you know, looking at the rules of the charts and working with the industry to find ways to tweak the charts, to change the rules accordingly,
00:40:16to be more inclusive of new technologies, to maybe invent new charts that cover genres that maybe we didn't have before, or new forms of consumption.
00:40:27Yeah.
00:40:28Well, something that I've noticed this summer is that it felt like the Hot 100 was fairly stagnant in the top 10.
00:40:34It felt like a lot of the same songs were coming back week after week after week.
00:40:37Lose control.
00:40:38Lose control.
00:40:39More than 100 weeks on the chart.
00:40:41Something like that.
00:40:42A record amount of time on the chart.
00:40:43So much time on the chart.
00:40:45And I don't know if this is a new phenomenon or not, but is it a new phenomenon?
00:40:50Sort of a new phenomenon.
00:40:51Is the Hot 100 stagnating a bit?
00:40:52I mean, it's, I wouldn't say the, well, I mean, I guess it depends on how you look at it.
00:40:58I think it's just the Hot 100 is measuring how people consume music.
00:41:01And people were playing certain songs a lot, endlessly, for months.
00:41:07Die with a Smile, Beautiful Things, Lose Control, Espresso, like, you know, like tons of songs that have been around for like months and months and months and months and months and months.
00:41:17It's, it's both streaming activity and radio play.
00:41:22Like, both of those things, like, keep those songs around for a very, very, very long time.
00:41:26Shaboozy.
00:41:27You know, all those songs, like, hung around for a very long time.
00:41:30But believe it or not, there are still people discovering those songs months after the fact.
00:41:34Because the algorithm, for some reason, maybe didn't show them.
00:41:37I don't know.
00:41:38I would love to know.
00:41:39I would love to know if there's, like, a metric that shows, like, when people first heard a song.
00:41:43Like, someone should, like, do a survey being like, what was the first time you heard Lose Control?
00:41:48Like, was it on the Grammy Awards when he performed it?
00:41:50Was it after the fact?
00:41:52Was it on a TV show?
00:41:53Was it when it came out?
00:41:54Like, because we don't live in, like, the monoculture, you know, society anymore.
00:41:59Like, you and I think, God, that song's been around forever.
00:42:03To some people, they're like, oh, I only heard it a few weeks ago.
00:42:06I'm like, how is that possible?
00:42:08We just talked about it, like, a little while ago about Morgan Wallen.
00:42:10Like, people, like, haven't heard Morgan Wallen songs.
00:42:13Like, do you live under a rock?
00:42:14I'm like, no, it's just the way music consumption works now.
00:42:18Another thing I wanted to ask you about is, I imagine if I was an artist and my dream was to get a Billboard No. 1 album.
00:42:25And I was like, okay, I'm going to release my album on, let's say, October 1.
00:42:29Because I want to release my album on October 1.
00:42:33And then you figure out that a much bigger artist is going to release their album also on October 1.
00:42:39Do you see a lot of artists switch up their release dates because they're trying to make sure they have a more open week for a possible number 1 album on the Billboard 200?
00:42:47That happens sometimes.
00:42:50It's usually not, like, messaged out in such a way.
00:42:54Yeah.
00:42:54It's not like, hey, everyone, I'm moving my album because so-and-so.
00:42:57Taylor Swift is coming.
00:42:59Right.
00:42:59It really depends on a lot of factors.
00:43:03I think that can still happen and does occasionally happen, though no one will ever actually say that I'm moving away from this date because so-and-so is coming out.
00:43:12But, like, you'll hear things where, like, hey, we're aiming for this date, but we hear that so-and-so might drop an album that week, so, you know, maybe we might avoid that week.
00:43:22When I say they, I mean, like, record label people.
00:43:24Yeah.
00:43:24I think today, in 2025, you can be nimble and move your album around if you haven't announced it if it is a streaming-heavy album and maybe you don't have any physical product in the actual, like, brick-and-mortar marketplace.
00:43:45Like, maybe it's only on your D2C store because then you can control when the album ships out and when you drop it to streaming services.
00:43:55So, like, I fully expect that when Drake drops his next album, we will not know that it exists until it arrives on streaming services that Thursday night, Friday morning.
00:44:04Mm-hmm.
00:44:05Because he will probably deliver the album to his label partners that Thursday before it goes up that night.
00:44:11God bless the label people who get that the same day.
00:44:13And he probably won't have any physical music, like, you know, at least in record stores, like, you know, Target or Walmart or wherever.
00:44:19Now, if you're someone like Taylor Swift where you have physical product in the marketplace, you have to ship that album out in time to get into all the warehouses for Target and for brick-and-mortar and for Walmart.
00:44:30That all has to be in the pipeline days or weeks.
00:44:33Like, if you want to be on Amazon, your album has to be at Amazon, like, I think it's a couple weeks before the album comes out.
00:44:39Yeah.
00:44:39Also, the lead time for creating a vinyl record is pretty long.
00:44:43It's like, what, six months?
00:44:45It's shortened.
00:44:46There are instances where I know that people have created a vinyl album in less than two months.
00:44:51I'm not, I think there are certain manufacturers in certain countries that do very quick work.
00:44:58I think typically you hear about physical, like, albums that have physical product being delivered to the label, like, usually six months in advance.
00:45:06Of course, that can change depending on when they've scheduled the album to be manufactured, blah, blah, blah.
00:45:15There's all sorts of, like, you know, timelines that could be different for who the artist is.
00:45:20In terms of just, hey, I'm going to move my album because someone dropped an album that day, it can still be done.
00:45:25But it really depends on who the artist is.
00:45:30And that's why it always feels like today we know less about what's on the release calendar because most people aren't announcing their albums that far in advance anymore unless they do have a physical campaign.
00:45:40And then if you have a physical campaign and you have physical product in the marketplace and you have your pre-order up, it's harder to kind of push the brakes.
00:45:49It's like if someone suddenly surprises everyone and drops an album that same day, you're kind of screwed.
00:45:55Like, there have been a couple examples in the past, like, year or two where someone had staked out a date with an album that had physical product.
00:46:03And they were probably, they were going to debut at number one.
00:46:09And then out of the blue, like, either, like, a few days before or, like, maybe a week or so before, a big album drops out of the sky that's only on streaming services, essentially.
00:46:20And that debuts at number one instead.
00:46:22Yep.
00:46:22Like, a really good example is when Usher was going to headline the Super Bowl.
00:46:27And he announced his album coming home months before the Super Bowl.
00:46:30Like, when he announced that he was going to be on the Super Bowl, he announced that the album was coming.
00:46:34You could pre-order it now.
00:46:34It's going to come out.
00:46:36I think he announced, like, the weekend of the Super Bowl, like, Super Bowl Sunday.
00:46:40Eventually, it came out on the Friday before the Super Bowl when most albums come out.
00:46:44And he had that weekend all to himself.
00:46:46And his album debuted at number two because the long-awaited Vultures 1 album from Ye and Ty Dolla $ign.
00:46:58Which had been, like...
00:47:00Talked a lot about when it was going to come out.
00:47:02Is it going to come out in December?
00:47:03Is it going to come out in January?
00:47:04When's it going to come out?
00:47:05Finally, like, I think it was, like, that Saturday of Super Bowl weekend.
00:47:09Like, Ye was like, album's coming out today.
00:47:12And then it debuted at number one.
00:47:14So, best laid plans, you know, sometimes can get sidelined a little bit.
00:47:20Yeah, I mean, I think the bigger the artist is, the more likely it is to see kind of a surprise album drop, like your Beyonce's Lemonade example.
00:47:27Or the Beyonce self-titled album, which sort of turned everything in its head.
00:47:31That's the one that, like, really changed things, right?
00:47:34The first visual album, yeah.
00:47:35One of the other things I wanted to ask about, we mentioned Drake earlier, and I'm not trying to single out Drake here.
00:47:40So, no one get mad at me for this.
00:47:42But Drake does release really long albums.
00:47:44Yeah.
00:47:45There are a lot of artists that have increasingly released long albums.
00:47:49I'm wondering, is that some way to help chart performance?
00:47:53Because there are so many tracks, and so you'd have to stream all, you know, 20, 30, 35 tracks.
00:48:01Does that help chart performance?
00:48:03I mean, certainly if you're streaming all the songs from an album repeatedly, yeah, of course it can.
00:48:10There's more songs to play.
00:48:12I do think that it's not just, there's not one answer for this.
00:48:18It's not just, you need to make as many songs as you can for an album because that helps us on the charts.
00:48:22Like, I don't think that's really what's, that's not the discussion that's happening, I don't think.
00:48:26I think what's happening is that the artists themselves has a lot to say.
00:48:30I think maybe the byproduct of that is like, oh, and that can also help you on the charts.
00:48:34Yeah.
00:48:34So, but, you know, look at Taylor Swift's The Life of a Showgirl.
00:48:38There were 12 songs.
00:48:39Yeah, but her last one.
00:48:40Yeah, Tortured Post Department, the deluxe edition had 31 songs.
00:48:43Yeah.
00:48:44In its first week.
00:48:45Yes.
00:48:46And Midnight's before that had, I forget what it was, like 20-something songs in its first week in the deluxe edition with the 3 a.m. edition.
00:48:52If you added it on.
00:48:53I think there's always, you know, you have to weigh the question of, well, how many songs do I want to put on an album?
00:49:00You know, what does my art need to say?
00:49:03Combined with just sort of the business of it, like, should we put this many songs on here?
00:49:06Should we maybe reserve some songs for a deluxe edition later?
00:49:09Bonus tracks for certain retailers?
00:49:11I do feel like we're seeing more albums that have more and more songs than before, but that happens throughout time.
00:49:19Like, when vinyl was the only way to consume an album, you had one LP that contains, like, what, 43 minutes, 44 minutes, if you count both sides, like 20-something minutes on each side.
00:49:34Like an actual physical limitation.
00:49:35There was a literal physical limitation to how much music you could put on it, unless you wanted to make a double album or a triple album.
00:49:42That's the idea, like, where, like, a triple album means there were, like, three pieces of product inside an album.
00:49:48It wasn't just sort of the amount of content.
00:49:50It was the literal pieces of content.
00:49:52Triple, double album.
00:49:53But then CDs come along.
00:49:55CDs can hold, like, 80 minutes.
00:49:57And then we have digital downloads.
00:49:59It can hold as much as you want.
00:50:00Streaming, you can put as many songs as you want.
00:50:02So I think with certain artists, they will put as many songs as they want on an album because that is their art.
00:50:07Some artists are just like, you know what?
00:50:09I've got 12 songs, and that's the body of work for this.
00:50:12Like, I don't think that Adele's next album is going to have 30 songs.
00:50:16That just isn't going to be the way that Adele operates, as an example.
00:50:20Yeah, very true.
00:50:21And so if an artist's release, I feel like one of the things I'm also seeing right now is a lot of artists are releasing deluxe versions of their records.
00:50:28Well, they will just add on—actually, Tortured Poets Department is a great example of this.
00:50:33These kind of deluxe albums, like Tortured Poets Department, are very common now where you have an initial release that has a pretty normal number of songs on it.
00:50:42But then the deluxe kind of almost doubles the length of the record.
00:50:45Does that all get looped in into the same album for the Billboard charts?
00:50:49Generally speaking, yes.
00:50:50Okay.
00:50:50Like, we have a set of rules about what can be combined together.
00:50:54Generally speaking, when you see a deluxe edition of an album, it almost always is combined with the original version.
00:51:04And I think we've seen lots of instances where it's like an unusual deluxe in the sense where it's almost like it's operating as a second album.
00:51:12An example of this would be SZA's SOS, where she deluxed it, like, what was it, like, a year and a half later as SOS Deluxe Lana.
00:51:22And when you looked for that deluxe edition, it had a new cover.
00:51:27The new tracks were sequenced as the first tracks on it.
00:51:31So that was now the Lana body of work.
00:51:34And then the tracks at the end of the album were the original SOS album.
00:51:38But for us, the title of the album still starts with SOS.
00:51:42It still has all the original songs from SOS.
00:51:45You've added music to it, but it follows all of our chart rules to combine it with the original SOS.
00:51:50So on our charts, it's just SOS.
00:51:53There is no Lana album on our chart.
00:51:55But yeah, it does feel like that's happening more in, like, a different way, where people are deluxing albums with even more and more songs, almost like it's a whole second album.
00:52:03Yeah. And I mean, of course, with Streaming's Infinite Shelf, you can do whatever you want.
00:52:08I often tell people, like, you really have to consider the method of consumption that is most popular at a time period when an album comes out to really explain why the album is the way it is.
00:52:19Like we were saying before, with vinyl, there's really a limited amount of space.
00:52:22Now you can do whatever you want.
00:52:24So the idea of what an album is, I think, is evolving and becoming a little bit more amorphous.
00:52:30Yeah.
00:52:30It's just a collection of however many songs you feel like fits what you're trying to say at that moment.
00:52:36Like an album is still an important statement for an artist.
00:52:39Yes.
00:52:39To be able to make a artistic statement where they have a concept or a message, like a through line, versus just standalone singles.
00:52:49That said, there's still a lot of artists that will put out like mini EPs, just standalone singles, like two packs of songs for whatever reason, because it makes sense for their business model and how they're delivering their art.
00:53:00It really, there's no like perfect, like concept of how to release music for each artist.
00:53:07There's a overarching, like, you know, way that most artists, most big artists do.
00:53:15But that doesn't mean that it has to be applied to every artist.
00:53:17And to end off our conversation, I wanted to do a little bit of a rapid fire of big chart moments.
00:53:24Oh, great, great.
00:53:24Because I had to research these things.
00:53:26So I actually have answers.
00:53:28I must admit, I did brief Keith on this, because I know you're probably not able to recall every moment off the top of your head.
00:53:34God, you underestimate me.
00:53:36But yes, I cannot.
00:53:38What is the longest running Billboard 200 number one album?
00:53:41It is the West Side Story film soundtrack.
00:53:44Wait, really?
00:53:45I love that look on your face.
00:53:46It spent 54 weeks at number one.
00:53:49Okay.
00:53:49And then the album with the by a singular artist with the most weeks at number one is Michael Jackson's Thriller with 37 weeks at number one.
00:53:58Okay.
00:53:58So West Side Story is like a multi-artist, you know, it's a soundtrack to a movie.
00:54:02But the album that is by like one artist that has the most weeks is Thriller.
00:54:07Wow.
00:54:08Okay.
00:54:08The Thriller one makes sense.
00:54:09I did not know West Side Story was that big of a phenomenon.
00:54:12It was enormous back in the day.
00:54:14Wow.
00:54:15Interesting.
00:54:15Okay.
00:54:16What is the longest climb to receive a Billboard 200 number one album?
00:54:20Okay.
00:54:21A little bit tricky.
00:54:22So because of the way the Billboard 200 works now and we allow older albums to chart, an album can come back from being off the chart completely many, many years after it initially came out and then go to number one.
00:54:35So the most recent example of this is Toby Keith's 35 Biggest Hits, which hit number one in 2024, 15 years, eight months, and 24 days after it first debuted on the chart.
00:54:51Prince is the Very Best of Prince also had a similar situation.
00:54:54It went to number one in 2016, nearly 15 years after it first hit the chart.
00:54:59Now, last thing I'll say about this, the album that had the longest continuous climb, because Prince and Toby Keith both left the chart and then they came back years later.
00:55:10The album that debuted on the chart and then just kept climbing or lingering on the chart until it finally went to number one, the record for that in terms of the best weeks is Paula Abdul's Forever Your Girl.
00:55:21Oh, wow.
00:55:21Which took 64 weeks to get to number one in 1989 from its debut, never left the chart, and then hit number one 64 weeks later.
00:55:28Wow. Do you have any understanding as to why that happened?
00:55:33No. Aside from it was like a slow growing album and had to wait its turn.
00:55:37Yeah.
00:55:37And it had tons of hits on it.
00:55:39Yeah. Wow. That's surprising.
00:55:41Okay. So who is an artist who's never had a number one on the Billboard 200 that I would be surprised by?
00:55:47I think it would be, I try to look at this in the most sort of like neutral, even way.
00:55:53Okay.
00:55:54So I was looking at artists with like a lot of top 10 albums, but never a number one.
00:55:59So the rock band Rush has 12 top 10s, no number ones.
00:56:04Huh.
00:56:04Sting has 11 top 10s as a solo artist, no number ones.
00:56:10The Police did have a number one album.
00:56:12Okay.
00:56:12Synchronicity.
00:56:13And The Who, they've had 11 top 10s, but no number ones.
00:56:17I'm surprised most by The Who.
00:56:19Yeah.
00:56:20Wow. Interesting. Okay.
00:56:22Who is an artist with the most Billboard 200 number ones?
00:56:26The artist with the most Billboard 200 number ones as of this recording in October of 2025 is The Beatles with 19.
00:56:34The artist with the second most as of this recording right now is Taylor Swift with 15.
00:56:40Okay.
00:56:41By the time you hear this, Taylor could have 16, 17, who knows how many albums she'll release by the time you hear this podcast or watch this podcast.
00:56:49Wow.
00:56:50Okay.
00:56:50So she's really coming up on that record.
00:56:53That's very interesting.
00:56:54I mean, every album that she puts out typically is number one.
00:56:57And she had a lot of re-records, like re-recording Taylor's versions to help her as well in recent years.
00:57:02Oh, okay.
00:57:03That helps too.
00:57:03All those are separate from their original versions.
00:57:05And I guess as a final question, I'm wondering, does fandom play a bigger role than ever in songs that chart on the Billboard charts?
00:57:13How do you define fandom?
00:57:16Fandom meaning, like, I think we often see on the internet fans congregating and talking about how can we help our favorite artists get a number one album or a number one song?
00:57:26Sort of like Stan Army situation.
00:57:27Yeah.
00:57:28So how much do fans play a role in the charts these days?
00:57:31I mean, they can play a significant role, especially if there's, like, some big motivating factor for people to turn out and, like, let's buy a song this week because we want to, you know, help it into the top 40 or whatever.
00:57:44Like, that can still happen.
00:57:46Like, streaming parties and, you know, those sorts of things, like, can always help.
00:57:52And it's always, like, fun to see, like, fans, like, cheering on and rooting on their faves on the charts.
00:57:58Like, certainly I probably would have been one of those people, like, back in the ye olden days.
00:58:03For Madonna, maybe?
00:58:04I don't know.
00:58:05I'm wearing a hoodie that says Madonna on it.
00:58:06You tell me.
00:58:08But that didn't exist in the old days.
00:58:12But I always think, I always try to put myself in, like, that sort of situation.
00:58:15Like, oh, I wonder, like, had, like, the internet, like, had social media, the internet existed when I was younger.
00:58:23I had men shake my cane at the sky.
00:58:25But, like, had, like, social media existed in the way that it does now, like, when I was sort of a teenager or, like, in college.
00:58:33Like, would I have been, like, a person to, like, organize fans and, like, mobilize the fans.
00:58:41Like, oh, you know, she's number 11.
00:58:43Like, come on, we got to get her to number 10.
00:58:45I'm like, I mean, I called into radio stations to request songs for my faves.
00:58:50Like, that was a way, at the time, you thinking that you could help more people learn about a song by calling in and asking the DJ to play it.
00:58:58Not really understanding that the DJ, like, wasn't.
00:59:01Does not care.
00:59:02Does not care.
00:59:02And, like, the thing that you're requesting was probably the thing they were going to play anyways.
00:59:06But you just happened to be the lucky person to ask for the song.
00:59:08I always remember a time when I called into a radio station and asked if they could play a song.
00:59:11And they said, we'll get to that one.
00:59:13But could you ask to play this one instead?
00:59:15And then I did.
00:59:16And then they played that one.
00:59:17And then they never played the song that I wanted them to play.
00:59:20I'm like, it's all a shady scam.
00:59:23Anyway, my point was, I do think, like, you know, fandom and fan armies can be, like, sometimes a motivating factor.
00:59:31I'm not exactly sure if there's, like, always a direct correlation.
00:59:34But sometimes you can see examples where, like, oh, there was, like, a little bit of a sort of a movement on social media this week to help so-and-so maybe hit the top 40 or whatever.
00:59:45And, you know, sometimes it helps.
00:59:47It's always fun to see that, though.
00:59:49Yeah.
00:59:49I mean, so that's not illegal or it's not wrong to, you know, say, hey, everyone buy five albums this week or, you know.
00:59:56If the fans are doing it, that's fine.
00:59:59We don't want there being, like, an incentive from, like, the artist or the label or the manager being like, hey, everyone, like, if you buy five copies of the album, you might win, like, a phone call from the artist.
01:00:12Like, no.
01:00:13Got it.
01:00:14But if you want to organize something on, you know, TikTok, be like, come on, guys, we got to support our girl and, like, you know, let's all buy an album.
01:00:23Like, that's different.
01:00:24That's just sort of, like, this organic situation.
01:00:27Yeah.
01:00:27So sometimes is it ever possible that the charts reflect the strength of a fan army more than its, like, wide breadth of popularity across, you know, all of America?
01:00:37I think it depends on the project.
01:00:40Like, I mean, I think if you look at certain albums, they might over-index or have a huge first week because there was, like, months of pre-orders from, like, a diehard fan base that maybe doesn't have, like, a conventional span army.
01:00:58Like, if you say, like, okay, the Rolling Stones new album debuts in the top five on the Billboard 200 from, like, months of pre-orders of physical music, the Rolling Stones have a very passionate and large fan base.
01:01:10But it's not a fan base that typically engages in, like, stan wars on social media.
01:01:15Whereas, like, some other artists, like, do.
01:01:17So I think you can look at almost any artist and say, well, they have a passionate fan base that turned out in the first week of the album because they had pre-orders, they showed up in the first week, they went to brick-and-mortar stores.
01:01:29They shared the music with their friends.
01:01:30They told people about the music.
01:01:32And it doesn't really matter who the artist is.
01:01:34Everyone always has passionate fans.
01:01:36That fandom can just sort of present itself in different ways.
01:01:39Got it.
01:01:40And at the end of every episode of On the Record, I ask people to help me make a playlist.
01:01:45Does this playlist exist in the universe?
01:01:47It actually does exist.
01:01:48It is on Spotify.
01:01:49But I ask the same questions every week to my guests.
01:01:53And so I will ask you first, can you pick a song that you can no longer gatekeep?
01:01:57This group is not incredibly well-known in America, but they're well-known in the UK.
01:02:02It's Girls Aloud.
01:02:03It's a pop girl group.
01:02:06They had a really big hit.
01:02:07I mean, they had lots of hits.
01:02:08They had, like, 20 top tens in the UK.
01:02:10But probably their most, like, iconic number one was The Promise.
01:02:15It's a great song.
01:02:17You should listen to it.
01:02:18Perfect.
01:02:19What is a favorite throwback of yours?
01:02:21Something that popped up a couple weeks ago, and I'm, like, still annoyed that it wasn't
01:02:26a top ten hit when it did come out.
01:02:28It was, like, number 15.
01:02:30But it was Tina Turner's One of the Living, which was the second single from the Mad Max
01:02:35Beyond Thunderdome soundtrack.
01:02:38And lastly, what is a guilty pleasure of yours?
01:02:40Recently, there's been a band that's been in the news because we lost one of their founding
01:02:44members recently, KISS.
01:02:46And they have a song that was essentially a disco song.
01:02:52And it was, I think, unfairly judged at the time.
01:02:57It was a big hit at the time.
01:02:59And I do think that now, I think most people view it as a classic, but it's called I Was
01:03:04Made for Loving You.
01:03:06Oh, yes.
01:03:07Yeah.
01:03:09Can you sing it all for us as we go out?
01:03:11That's our exit music today.
01:03:13Take it away, Paul and Jean.
01:03:16Well, thank you so much for being here.
01:03:18It was so much fun talking about the charts with you.
01:03:20And we'll have to have feedback again soon.
01:03:23Another special thank you to Keith Caulfield for coming on the show this week to talk all
01:03:26things charts.
01:03:27Here's the top ten countdown for the week of November 1.
01:03:30At number 10 is Mutt by Leon Thomas.
01:03:38Number 9 is I Got Better by Morgan Wallen.
01:03:43Man I Need by Olivia Dean is number 8.
01:03:49Seven is Daisies by Justin Bieber.
01:03:54Father Figure by Taylor Swift lands at number 6.
01:03:58Number 5 is Elizabeth Taylor by Taylor Swift.
01:04:05Coming in at number 4 is Opalite, also by Taylor Swift.
01:04:11This week's number 3 is Ordinary by Alex Warren.
01:04:14The second spot this week is Golden by Huntrix.
01:04:23And finally, number 1 this week is The Fate of Ophelia.
01:04:27This marks its third week at number 1.
01:04:30Thanks for listening to this week's episode of On the Record.
01:04:32And another special thank you to this week's guest, Keith Caulfield, for coming on the show.
01:04:36If you liked the show today, please consider hitting us with a rating, a follow, a thumbs up, all those good things.
01:04:41They really help a new show like ours to grow and to reach new people.
01:04:44Again, I'm your host, Kristen Robinson, and tune in next week for another peek behind the curtain in the music industry.
01:04:50I'll see you then.