• 1 year ago
Speaking with FRANCE 24's Sharon Gaffney, Robert Manning, Distinguished Fellow at the Stimson Centre's Global Foresight Hub and China Programme, says that Chinese leader Xi Jinping sees US President Donald Trump as "a gift that keeps on giving", as Trump's measures tend to facilitate China's economic and geopolitical dominance.

Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com

Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English

Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00This is apropos. On the eve of crunch trade talks, Donald Trump is again voicing optimism
00:08that a deal can be reached with Xi Jinping when he meets the Chinese president in South Korea
00:13on Thursday. Global markets will be watching closely to determine whether the pair can draw
00:18a line under a tussle that snarled supply chains and unsettled businesses the world over, as Yinka
00:24Oytari reports. For days, US President Donald Trump has been successfully charming allies
00:32across Asia. But his biggest test yet comes in Seoul Thursday, when he meets Chinese President
00:38Xi Jinping on the sidelines of the APEC summit, a leader unlikely to be easily swayed. At stake,
00:45whether the world's two largest economies extend their fragile trade truce or plunge back into
00:50economic hostility. Trump, though, appears unfazed.
00:55Tomorrow morning is the one that most people find most interesting. And I think we're going
01:00to have a great meeting with President Xi of China. And a lot of problems are going to be
01:05solved.
01:05You're optimistic.
01:07Yeah, very optimistic. The relationship with China is very good. So I think we're going to
01:11have a very good outcome for our country and for the world, actually. I think it's important
01:16for the world. The two sides are under pressure to extend their trade ceasefire, set to expire
01:22in November. If talks collapse, both nations could reimpose tariffs of more than 100 percent,
01:29levels U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Besant once compared to a trade embargo.
01:34Tensions escalated further this month after Beijing proposed new curbs on exports of rare
01:39earth minerals. A possible deal may see China delay those restrictions. Washington, meanwhile,
01:45maintains a 20 percent tariff on Chinese imports, citing Beijing's failure to curb chemicals
01:51used in fentanyl production, a drug responsible for more than 500,000 deaths in the U.S. But
01:57China says it wants to cooperate.
01:59China expresses sympathy with the American people for the fentanyl crisis, has provided assistance
02:05with positive results and remains open to continuing cooperation with the U.S. side. The U.S.
02:12should take concrete actions to create the necessary conditions for cooperation between the two
02:17sides.
02:17Also looming over the talks, Taiwan. Some analysts fear Trump could offer concessions on the self-ruled
02:26island, which U.S. law obliges Washington to defend. It's been six years since the two leaders
02:32last met in 2019. The world may have changed, but one thing hasn't. Washington and Beijing are still
02:39locked in a battle over trade, and the stakes remain as high as ever.
02:45To discuss, we're joined now by Robert Manning, Distinguished Fellow at the Stimson Centre's Global
02:50Foresight Hub and China programme. Robert, thanks so much for being with us on the programme. A big
02:55test awaits Donald Trump, as we heard there. He says he's confident he's going to be able to reach a
03:01trade deal with China. Would you share that optimism? And who actually has the upper hand
03:06heading into these talks? Well, I think what produced this was a series of events, mainly
03:17that I think Trump has come to, and the Trump people have come to the conclusion that these
03:21tariffs with China are not sustainable, that they had in the past underestimated China. And when the
03:29Chinese raised the question of rare earths and past these really mirror image export controls borrowed from
03:39the U.S. that really micromanaged the flow and threatened really all things electronic, from
03:47cell phones to jet fighter planes, that got Trump's attention. And I think what we're seeing is
03:55a sense that they have to sort of manage this relationship better. And so I think what we're
04:06seeing, they've agreed, from what I understand, they've agreed to a number of things. The things
04:11that are matter to Trump are the guarantee assurances on the role of rare earths, fentanyl, which is a huge
04:19political issue for Trump space in the United States, that the Chinese have been cooperating to some
04:25extent, but I think they're going to further lengths from what we hear. And of course, soybeans, because
04:32China is a 50% of the market for American farmers on soybeans. So those are the things that Trump got.
04:40But I think Xi was looking for predictability and stability. And so I think he's interested in
04:48stabilising things and kind of buying time because he's got his own domestic problems.
04:55When China, though, has such a monopoly, is Xi likely to budge on those threats to expand
05:01curbs on exports of those rare earth minerals? We've been talking a bit about this a lot over the last few
05:07weeks. Well, I think the Chinese may have overplayed their hand in the sense that they
05:14control 90%, about 70% of rare earths, but more importantly, 90% of processing and refining.
05:22So they have the ability to really hold the world hostage. So I think that in that sense,
05:27they made Europe and a lot of other places in the world nervous. And I think what we're seeing is
05:34they're offering Trump to suspend them or rethink the export process, control process, and so on.
05:43And we'll see where it goes. I think this is really more of a temporary truce, right?
05:48What's important are all the underlining issues that are not on the agenda. They're not talking about
05:54subsidised overcapacity in manufacturing. That's a huge problem. The currency issues.
06:03is another big one. And the underlying strategic competition over technology and dominance in
06:14the Asia-Pacific. So those things are still out there. All those sources of tension have not been
06:21resolved.
06:23And if this is only a temporary truce, then as you suggest, what kind of impact is all of this and
06:27the ongoing uncertainty likely to have on the rest of the world and a potential global trade war that
06:34everybody has been worrying about since Donald Trump came back to the White House?
06:39Well, let me say this. I think it's all fragile. And, you know, one Trump tweet on Taiwan could blow
06:47the whole thing up. But having said that, I think we may be seeing a new stage in the evolution of US-China
06:54relations in the sense that this is going to be followed by an exchange of symmetry. Trump will
07:01be going to Beijing early next year. She is supposed to come to the United States. And so I think what
07:07they're trying to do, they're starting to define the terms of competition and to manage it. So if
07:14that's the case, I think this may be more than a truce. We'll have to wait and see it play out. And as I say,
07:20it could blow up at any time. But I think both sides are looking for a little more stability.
07:27You saw what happened when the Chinese did the rare earth suspension that markets in the US tanked,
07:36and that got Trump's attention. It's probably the one thing that does.
07:40And Robert, you mentioned Taiwan there. Do you think those regional tensions over the island are
07:45going to be discussed? The US Secretary of State saying that Taipei essentially has nothing to
07:49worry about here. But isn't it possible that Trump might offer some kind of concessions to China?
07:57Well, I think Taiwanese and a lot of China hawks in Washington are very nervous.
08:04She would like to have some kind of reassurance on Taiwan from Trump. And I think Trump has been very
08:13ambivalent about Taiwan. He's prevented a visit and stopover by President Lai recently and a number of
08:22other small things. He sees Taiwan as an irritant to some extent. And they've been pressuring Taiwan to
08:32invest more TSMC chip-making facilities in the United States. And I think to the extent they do that,
08:42Trump may consider that making Taiwan less important, because what he mostly cares about is the chips.
08:50Well, do you think then that the Asia Pacific region is going to remain a strategic priority for the US
08:55under Donald Trump?
08:58Well, that's an interesting question, because they're soon to release a national defense strategy.
09:04And I think the Trump administration is much more focused on the Western Hemisphere.
09:10And the reports are that this new strategy will identify the Western Hemisphere and homeland security.
09:18They're already seeing all this military activity. 14% of the US Navy is now in the Caribbean.
09:24And many people think they're preparing for some kind of regime change effort on Venezuela.
09:33There's a lot of hostility, you know, regarding Cuba that could also be putting pressure on Cuba and so on.
09:42So, and we're already seeing an emphasis, you know, they just announced withdrawing troops from Romania, for example.
09:51So I think you're seeing something of a shift in strategy from our traditional Asia and Europe centrality.
10:00Yeah, because a lot of commentators say that, you know, this kind of saber rattling that we're seeing coming from Donald Trump,
10:06it's pushing other Asian nations and even countries here in Europe towards China rather than the US.
10:15Yes, I think Xi Jinping sees Trump as a gift that keeps on giving.
10:23You know, his crusade against renewable energy and EVs is essentially facilitating China's dominance in the future of energy and transport and handicapping the US on that front.
10:39I think with the shutting down of Voice of America, Radio Free Asia, and so on, that irritated China.
10:47And I think the tariffs themselves on all of our allies, India and Brazil, for example, has pushed the global south more towards China and, you know, made their rhetoric seem more credible.
11:02So I think there are a lot of consequences we're only beginning to see.
11:07Yeah, and if these talks don't go well on Thursday, what might happen then?
11:11Well, I think that they've, it seems, it sounds to me like, as I say, they've reached some understandings.
11:22I don't think they have an outline.
11:24There are details left to be sorted out, and it could, it certainly could unravel.
11:30But I think Trump's optimism is not unfounded in terms of the short-term trade truths that they seem to have reached.
11:40Robert, thanks so much for being with us.
11:42We'll have to leave it there for now.
11:43That's Robert Manning from the Stimson Centre's Global Foresight Hub.
11:53Bye.
12:07Bye.
12:07Bye.
12:08Bye.
12:11Bye.
12:15Bye.

Recommended