- hace 1 año
Categoría
🗞
NoticiasTranscripción
00:00Ladies and gentlemen, as we now hand it over to Professor Ngari to take it away. Professor.
00:05Good afternoon, folks. Great to be here.
00:09You know, 15 years ago when I started building the Blavatnik School of Government at the University of Oxford,
00:15people kept asking me, okay, so who is a great political leader if this school is about building great political leaders?
00:23And it was, it's a hard question. But I'm going to leave it to you to adjudicate today's leader.
00:33He's definitely right up there among the greats. Let me just explain.
00:38The guy on my left was governor of the Bank of Canada when Canada had to navigate through the global financial crisis.
00:46And it did better than most other countries. He was governor of the Bank of England when the Brexit referendum happened.
00:56And when all the politicians fled the stage, it was this guy that stood calmly in front of the press and calmed the markets.
01:05Then he became prime minister of Canada in March of this year.
01:09So, sometimes I wonder, do you attract trouble, Mark?
01:14And what a year it has been.
01:19As he calmly understated last week, the United States has changed its policies.
01:27And we've all seen the flurry of even just the last 24 hours.
01:32So, Canada has a very calm, collected leader at its head.
01:39And that's vital in these times that we've all been speaking about at this conference.
01:44So, Prime Minister, my first question is really, because U.S. policies changed and because Canada needs to find, I think you mentioned, reliable allies and partners around the world,
02:03how quickly can Canada diversify its trade and what role can ASEAN play in that?
02:11Well, first off, I wanted you to keep going, talking about me.
02:16I was very much enjoying that.
02:18And now the question is now the hard part.
02:21Look, first, just to give a bit of context in terms of our ambitions, and they are large.
02:27We laid out last week that we want to increase our non-U.S. exports by 50 percent within the next decade, a shorter time frame than that.
02:36It's about $300 billion to give context to that.
02:39We would expect that a substantial proportion of that will come from ASEAN.
02:46And it's one of the reasons why we're looking to complete the free trade agreement with ASEAN within the next year.
02:53And I met with both, obviously, and I want to pay tribute to Prime Minister Ibrahim for his chairing of ASEAN.
03:04Great success this year.
03:05So I met and discussed with him, but also with next year's chair, President Marcos, and made that a priority.
03:13So ASEAN will play an important role in that.
03:16As well, we will pursue a series of bilateral FTAs.
03:21And as it happens, again, with the Philippines, we decided today that we would accelerate.
03:27Both we would pursue a free trade agreement, but on an accelerated basis between Canada and the Philippines.
03:33We have a free trade agreement with the EU.
03:36We have one.
03:37We are, of course, a core to CPTPP.
03:41In fact, we have free trade agreements with 15 jurisdictions around the world, two-thirds of global trade.
03:48Now, some of those free trade agreements operate a little more predictably than others.
03:53No prize for guessing which ones.
03:57And our strategy is to broaden and deepen with those partners who believe in rules-based trade,
04:06who are complementary to us, and who share the same values.
04:09Because in the end, you can write a lot down in terms of trade agreements.
04:13You know trade agreements well.
04:14They're about this thick.
04:16There's a number of negotiators I can see here in the front row here,
04:20and business people who rely on the letter of the law.
04:23But it's also the spirit of it.
04:24And having the interests aligned.
04:26I'll finish on this, which is I found it interesting coming into ASEAN this morning.
04:34As I walked in, the neon banners were with the themes of ASEAN this year,
04:42which is inclusivity and sustainability.
04:45So it's growth with inclusivity and sustainability.
04:47It's very recognizable for Canada and our approach.
04:50And that's the type of partnership that will help us realize that diversification.
04:56And what is it Canada is going to bring to ASEAN?
05:00Again, I would start with the values around inclusivity, sustainability, a sense of solidarity,
05:07so you're building in true partnership.
05:08But then we look to the economic and where the complementarities are.
05:13So apart from that trading network that I just referenced, we're an energy superpower, unabashedly energy superpower.
05:20We have the third largest reserves of oil.
05:22We have the fourth largest reserves of LNG.
05:24We've just started our first LNG shipments helped by Malaysia Patronus in the last six months.
05:32We will be up to 50 million tons annually of LNG by the end of this decade.
05:38We'll double that by 2040.
05:40So this is very large scale.
05:41At the same time that we're that, we have an 85% clean grid back at home.
05:46We're going to increase that by 50% over the course of the next decade, including with utility scale nuclear and SMRs.
05:54We just launched the process for the first commercial SMR in Canada.
06:01So technology that's relevant here, grid optimization, other technology.
06:05So energy superpower, one aspect.
06:07You move up the chain.
06:08We are one of the largest reserves of critical minerals.
06:12We are the largest center of mining finance in the world.
06:16So we have the resources, we have the mining finance, and we have the standards around sustainable development.
06:21It's a natural partnership with many of the countries in ASEAN who have their own reserves and their own potential.
06:28And the world has figured out what many of us knew.
06:32We talked about, I think, you and I even in the past about the need for diversification.
06:36You extend that up or on into positions in AI and quantum and cyber, which are world-leading, twinned with our research universities,
06:50and layer on to that that in a moment of catch-up, we are quadrupling, that's quadrupling, our defense spending between now and the end of this decade.
07:01Much of that will be in areas of, I just listed, in AI and cyber.
07:09Again, natural partnerships that work with the digital economies that are being built out here.
07:14I could go on.
07:15I will go on.
07:16I'm conscious you probably have other questions.
07:18But there's quite a range, the point is, there's quite a range of hard and soft expertise and financial expertise.
07:28I'll list one final one, which is that our pension funds are amongst the largest and most sophisticated infrastructure investors in the world.
07:38And they have initial partnerships in the region, but alongside the sovereign wealth capabilities in the region, we see opportunity that's there.
07:46All of which, maybe, let me make one final point, if I could, which is, that's all outbound, if you will.
07:55It's Canada potentially exporting partnerships into ASEAN, investing here.
08:01The flip side is the opportunity in Canada.
08:04And one of the lessons we take from the big change in the world that's happened over the course of the last few years,
08:11intensified in the last year, is that we need to build at home and we need to build at scale at home.
08:17And the orders of magnitude are, you know, in the half a trillion up of investment domestically in Canada,
08:25in many of the areas that I think would, many of the investors and businesses here would find attractive.
08:30Fantastic. So energy, nuclear modular reactors, defence, investment, lots on offer for ASEAN.
08:39Just picking up on your last point about investing at home.
08:44Folks here in ASEAN have been speaking over the last day and a half about the need to reduce barriers within ASEAN,
08:51to improve trade within ASEAN.
08:55In the European Union, Draghi, Leta, etc., have talked a lot about reducing barriers within the European Union.
09:02And you've spoken quite a lot about the need to do this in Canada,
09:05so that there's less barriers between the provinces.
09:09What makes that hard?
09:11Like, what are the things you need to do to make that happen?
09:14And how could, you know, because I think both in Europe and in ASEAN, countries need to learn this.
09:21Well, and let's put this in context.
09:27The worst case global trade war scenario, many of which various organisations were running earlier this year,
09:35the IMF and others, we calculated, well, others calculated for us,
09:40that just reducing domestic barriers in Canada alone would have a bigger economic payback
09:47than would be taken away by the worst case scenario.
09:51So that's just reduction of barriers.
09:54I was, I don't think she'll mind me quoting this, well, I'll do a Chatham House rule side.
09:59But I would, financial institution here in Kuala Lumpur may have said earlier today in a closed-door session
10:08that their calculations of removing the barriers within ASEAN, the main barriers,
10:13I think even on just goods trade, was about 4.5% of GDP, of ASEAN GDP.
10:19Those are big, big numbers.
10:21So that's more than a percentage point of global GDP if you just do the multiplier on that.
10:27So these are large.
10:28Now, how do you do it?
10:29In Canada, we have done it at the federal level.
10:33That was one of the things we did within the first few weeks of getting into office,
10:38is we passed a law which removed all the federal barriers.
10:41Now we need to do the hard part, which is between the various provinces.
10:45And I guess the point is that there are two models to do this.
10:50One is the European one where you move the responsibility up and you have a harmonization across the whole level, the whole grouping.
11:01And the other is you have some form of mutual recognition, substituted compliance.
11:06I will acknowledge that your rules are roughly comparable to mine, so you don't have to meet both of those standards.
11:13It's not really my place, but I would suggest that it's far more likely that it's that type of approach that would work in ASEAN,
11:21given there's no element nor prospect of a political union.
11:27So it has to be that type of approach.
11:29But in Canada, though, those barriers between provinces that still exist, I remember you saying a few years ago that a crisis permits government to move fast and in a coordinated way.
11:47Is this a crisis in Canada?
11:48Is it going to help you reduce the barriers between provinces?
11:53Yes, it's a crisis because it's a fundamental change in many of the operating, I was going to say assumptions, but the operating rules of the system.
12:07I mean, the reliance on the global, open global trading system, a reliance and an expectation of further integration, particularly in North America, I mean, that's not going to happen.
12:19That doesn't mean there isn't still going to be a fair bit of free trade in North America and crossing investment.
12:24But this sort of relentless process of greater integration has reversed.
12:29That's a big change.
12:30And when you have a big change like that and you had your economy oriented towards that, which ours was, some of your strengths become vulnerabilities and you have to do big things.
12:42And so one of the lessons we've talked about this, many in the room have lived it.
12:46I've certainly, by luck, I would like to say, not because of cause.
12:50I didn't cause the crises I've been in.
12:52But my experience of being in them is in a crisis, you have to be bold, you have to act big.
13:01Uncertainty weighs down activity.
13:04And unless you're leading from the center, whether you're a central bank with respect to supporting financial institutions or monetary policy,
13:12or you're a government in terms of charting a new course, you need to be bold.
13:17And that's why we're looking for scale in terms of diversification of our exports.
13:21That's why our budget, which is coming out in two weeks' time, is going to have what we call generational investment in Canada on an order of magnitude
13:32that really changes the scale of the economy, the ambition of the economy.
13:37Of course, it will also, just by its very fact, provide GDP and growth and jobs for Canadians.
13:44But as important as that is, more important is going to be a reorientation of the country
13:50and very much an outward-looking orientation that I think is very complementary to ASEAN.
13:55One of the really hard things for the countries in this region is that although, in theory, they would be able to negotiate,
14:06for example, with the United States much more strongly if they held together,
14:11the new U.S. approach is very much we'll only negotiate with countries one by one.
14:17How can countries in the rest of the world, who want to diversify and sustain cooperation,
14:25how can they balance the need to line up and do one by one deals with the U.S. administration,
14:31with the need to actually forge relations in their own region with other regions?
14:38I mean, it feels like, you know, you've been a bit of an example for European leaders in how to do that,
14:45how to sit calmly and negotiate in the White House.
14:49But at the same time, you're here, you're pursuing those other kinds of deals.
14:55But I just wondered, what's your observation on this for countries in ASEAN
15:01who are being pushed to do the one-to-one deal, but who actually need to think about their other trade partners?
15:10Well, I think there's a couple of things, and with respect to the European Union,
15:15of course, President Costa is here as well, also participated as a partner of ASEAN
15:22in the meetings this morning and through tomorrow.
15:25And that'll bring me to a point I'll make in a second.
15:28I think a few general points about the situation with respect to the United States.
15:34The United States has a new trade policy.
15:37It applies to every country, every jurisdiction in the world.
15:40We understand that and we respect that.
15:42It is a major shift, and the way we're framing it is it's a rupture, not a transition.
15:47This is a very big change, almost overnight, and therefore it's difficult to deal with.
15:53It can be difficult to deal with, but everybody's dealing with it. That's the first.
15:57The second is, if your economy is highly integrated, or certain sectors are highly integrated with the United States,
16:04revealed preference, to use a fancy term, is that you will pay a price to keeping access to that market,
16:12either in the form of tariffs, changes to some domestic policies, commitments for investment.
16:18Different countries have done various versions of that.
16:21What you should try to avoid doing, though, is tying your hands about what you can do with other jurisdictions.
16:30Because there are a lot more countries by GDP that are willing and keen to continue to have relatively open trade,
16:45certainly to have rules-based trade, to respect rules-based trades.
16:49And that is happening in parallel to these sharper changes.
16:54So you get a sharp change in the relationship with the U.S.
16:57As the President has said, and I understand this, I respect it.
17:01He said it, me sitting next to him, we are going to charge countries for access to the U.S.
17:07It's like access to a good country club, I think he might have said, or Costco.
17:11To put it the other way, I think he thinks more on country club than Costco.
17:14We understand it.
17:15It is the premium market.
17:17It's the most dynamic economy.
17:19You decide what you're willing to pay, but at the same time, you want to be in other clubs.
17:25You want to be at other tables.
17:26You want to be building that out.
17:28And I said I would make a point about the European Union.
17:31I think it's quite relevant for ASEAN, or if I may broaden it a bit more towards CPTPP.
17:37Some members are part of that.
17:39These are two large trading blocks with not identical, but complementary approaches to trade.
17:47And there is an opportunity.
17:49It's a point I've made.
17:51It's a point some others in CPTPP have made.
17:54There is a possibility of bringing those closer together, having at a minimum a docking between the two blocks or broader arrangements that there.
18:03And that's how you start to rebuild a broader global trading system.
18:09You're approaching more than a third of global trade there, potentially 40%, depending on how you do it.
18:15Provided you have given your, you've retained that flexibility in order to do that.
18:20And as things stand right now, most countries have.
18:24So is this a sort of short term, medium term, long term thing?
18:28In the short term, are we going to see countries doing a lot of deals with the United States?
18:33But in the medium term, needing reliable partners?
18:37If you're going to reorganize your whole economy for trade, you need reliable partners.
18:41So in the medium term, do you think we're going to see a world which trades a little less with the United States and a little more with within regions and between regions?
18:54I think the short answer is yes.
18:59I think as well, there would be a natural, at a minimum, it's an acceleration of a trend that the weight of economic activity and dynamism would drive as well.
19:13I mean, this is one, we're in one of the most, arguably the most dynamic regions in the world.
19:18And naturally, more trade is going to flow to here.
19:24I'll give you another example.
19:27Just the very fact that one of the themes of this presidency is sustainability.
19:35And there's an understanding that moving towards lower carbon energy, lower carbon manufacturing, lower carbon services, et cetera, will be a driver of competitiveness.
19:50It's good for the planet, but it's a driver of competitiveness.
19:53There's an understanding of that.
19:54And it's not just a theme, but a lot of the discussions are around how do we build out.
20:00That is not a priority at present in the United States, or at least it's not an administration priority in the United States.
20:07So naturally, trade is going to shift away by definition.
20:12The other reason is from the U.S. for a period of time on that.
20:15It's also shifting because it's more expensive to trade with the United States.
20:20That's what a tariff does.
20:22And that will drive some of that as well.
20:25But all of that said, the United States is the world's largest.
20:29It is the most dynamic economy.
20:32It is a source of constant innovation.
20:34And everyone, very much Canada included, is going to want to be active.
20:39And look, you've long championed the kind of sustainability in a number of roles, advising the UN, advising prime ministers, et cetera.
20:50Are you optimistic about the sustainability agenda holding?
20:57I mean, the world as I see it, the backtracking of the United States has led a lot of companies to say, actually, let's slow down on the sustainability stuff.
21:09Let's slow down on the net zero stuff.
21:11Are you seeing that?
21:12Are you seeing that?
21:13Is it harder to be an advocate for net zero?
21:18Well, I've got a different job now, which is to advocate for Canada and to manage for Canada.
21:27What I think you're seeing is, and this is in terms of our approach, you're seeing a sharp move towards performance over targets, investment and action over sort of prohibition.
21:43So, in other words, and I'll give an example on that, which is, I referenced earlier, Canadian LNG and the opportunity that's there.
21:53If we went back five years, there would have been a greater focus on leapfrogging from coal in the region to solar and storage, particularly.
22:04There's probably more of that transition is going to be with gas for a period of time.
22:10There will be a number that do leapfrog, so that's an example, but that's a material reduction in emissions.
22:16It's a different route to it.
22:20Carbon capture, let me give one other example.
22:22Canada has just under 12% of the global capacity in carbon capture, a huge number.
22:29One of the, I referenced about half a trillion of investments over the course of the next five years.
22:34Part of that will be in major carbon capture to decarbonize our exports of oil, decarbonizing scope one, scope two.
22:42To be clear, you can't decarbonize scope three.
22:44Again, that is, that's performance, and that's investment for emission reduction.
22:50So that's, that's a shift.
22:53I can make one last point, which is something coming out of the region.
22:58Singapore, Malaysia, and others have been amongst the leaders here, which is actually tracking the emissions of goods and soon services,
23:07so it's going to be clearer where that performance is.
23:11So you mentioned there that it's one thing to be an advisor on sustainability.
23:17It's another thing to become prime minister for all Canadians, including those who are in the energy sector.
23:23What surprised you about becoming prime minister?
23:26I mean, there's not that many prime ministers in this room.
23:29What's, what was the surprise?
23:32What was the surprise?
23:35It doesn't end.
23:37Well, it does end, actually.
23:39I shouldn't say that.
23:41When you say it doesn't end, that's just before it ends, actually.
23:44But I meant more from a 24-7 perspective.
23:49What's the most surprising thing?
23:51I, look, I, I think I'll give the most positive surprise, is that you have access to unlimited resources for an issue.
24:06So that if, and it doesn't matter what the issue is, it's, it's a, the only thing that's holding you back is lack of imagination and to some degree time.
24:16But, but people will help their government.
24:19People will pick up the phone.
24:21They will respond to your inquiry.
24:23Your, your officials will be able to get the information.
24:26And that, that is a big advantage.
24:28The only caveat to that, you and I know, and many of us in the room have lived through crises.
24:34In a crisis, you're never going to have perfect information.
24:36You, you have to know when you've, you've done enough in order to take a decision with imperfect information.
24:41But you do have the privilege of, in these roles, of being able to draw on the resources of your country, including the intellectual resources of the country.
24:50And it's important to do so.
24:51And look, last question, and it's a big one, but you, you're an economist.
24:57You've, you've been chair of the Financial Stability Board.
25:01You've, you've navigated now both financial crises and trade crises.
25:06Where do you see the global economy in five years time?
25:10Or over the next five years?
25:12What are the, are there big things you think are going to change?
25:15Well, I think it's, um, I will quote, um, I will quote our host, uh, our ultimate host, uh, the prime minister this morning,
25:25uh, which is, uh, where's the effect of the old world or the old system is gone?
25:30Uh, the new one has not yet formed.
25:33Um, and so it's a, it's a big question and it's an important question because in many respects, uh, those of us in this room, uh, will help determine where that is.
25:43Um, and, and what we were talking about earlier is Canada free trade with ASEAN, um, CPTPP with EU, uh, that link, uh, becoming there,
25:55following through on the inclusivity and sustainability.
25:58The extent to which we actually follow that through this room literally, you know, literally and metaphorically will help determine the direction of the global economy or a substantial proportion of the global economy.
26:12And because it's ASEAN, because it's dynamic, because it's forward looking, because it's young, that sort of shows where the world is, is going.
26:20Um, and so I think it can be, uh, incredibly influential.
26:24And we're up, look, we're out of time.
26:26Thank you, Prime Minister Mark Carney.
26:28Do join me in a huge round of thanks to Mark Carney, Prime Minister of Canada.
26:32Yes, ladies and gentlemen, some of you are standing.
26:38Please stand for the Right Honourable Mark Carney, Prime Minister of Canada.
26:44Thank you also to Professor Ngairi Woods for steering that conversation.
26:51A lot of substance, a lot of meat and a lot of food for thought for the global economy in hand.
27:01Thank you.