00:00Mr. Secretary, a couple of days ago, in the last hearing when you were here,
00:06we somehow settled the issue that restitution is not a requisite for an applicant to the WPP.
00:13Is that correct?
00:14It's not in the law.
00:16But to me, it's not just the law that's dictated this.
00:20It's also what is morally right, what is expected of us.
00:25What do you mean by that, Mr. Secretary?
00:32Because there is no requirement for admission to the WPP.
00:38Yes, it is not.
00:42But you don't have to lay out that we can't lay out, depending on the case.
00:47Mr. Secretary, I am still in the stage where a particular applicant wishes to apply.
00:53Under that program.
00:55And there is a process.
00:57In the process, restitution is not one of the requisites.
01:01Is that correct?
01:03Opo.
01:03Pero in terms of this case being a financial crime, sir,
01:07this is a crime against the financial status of the Filipino people of the Philippine Republic.
01:14I think that it's just right.
01:16Mr. Secretary, are you amending the provision of the law?
01:19No, sir.
01:20No, sir.
01:20But that is how we run the WPP.
01:22As a lawyer, Mr. Secretary, may I ask you?
01:27In a criminal prosecution, the civil liability is impliedly instituted.
01:32Is that correct?
01:34Of course.
01:34Kaya nga eh, hindi naman nangangang hulugan kung sakasakali na natapos na yung criminal prosecution,
01:42kapag ka nakita na mayroong criminal liability yung tao, because it is impliedly implied,
01:48dun lang magkakaroon ng restitution.
01:50It will come after.
01:52Paano mo sasabihin na magre-restitute ang isang tao?
01:56Meron na bang findings kung magkano i-re-restitute on how it can be restituted?
02:00Nag-a-apply pa lang eh.
02:02Huwag po ninyong babaguhin ang requisite ng batas, Mr. Secretary.
02:06I thought nung dumating ka dito, nag-ahindindihan na tayo eh.
02:10Kaya nabablar ang proceedings natin eh.
02:12Kaya nga kinote ni, siguro, ang chairman kanina gusto kong ituloy ito.
02:17Sinabi niya, nagpa-interview siya,
02:18na goodwill and sincerity should be done para i-test.
02:26Pwede ba yung ganito?
02:27I respect your opinion, sir.
02:29It is not my opinion.
02:31It is in the law, Mr. Secretary.
02:32Yes, sir.
02:33Yes, sir.
02:33But I am operating...
02:35The arbiter is the law.
02:36Sir, can I speak, sir?
02:37May I speak, sir?
02:38Yes, you are.
02:38I'm operating from the vantage point of the reason behind the law, sir.
02:44What is the reason behind the law?
02:45So that we can get justice, and justice can only be attained if there is restitution.
02:51So that is the principle behind all of these things that we are talking about now.
02:55Mr. Secretary, restitution will come after?
02:59It cannot be...
03:00Sir, it can come before or after, sir.
03:02It can come before or after.
03:03You cite the law that it come before.
03:06Wala nga po sa batas eh.
03:08Sir, sir, we are operating on a unique set of facts,
03:13and we are...
03:16All of these matters are being evaluated because the gravity of this financial crime cannot be underestimated.
03:25And that the more assets that we're able to preserve at the outset, the better for our country, sir.
03:31Mr. Secretary, I'm very sorry for such a reasoning like that.
03:36I'm very sorry, sir.
03:37Also, sir, I'm very sorry, too, if you do not agree with me.
03:40But I respect your opinion, sir, and we will carry out our job as we deem fit, as we see.
03:47Mr. Chair, I said I am not expressing an opinion here.
03:50I am articulating the provision of law.
03:53You do not change the provision of law, Mr. Secretary.
03:57You may be disbarred from doing this.
03:59Then, it's your opinion, sir.
04:02It's your option, sir.
04:03Then, it's your option, sir.
04:09It is what you wish to happen.
04:12That you may proceed with what you wish.
04:13It is not in the law.
04:22Unless you are able to point out the provision of law that it come before,
04:26hindi ganun eh.
04:27Sabi mo na nga, and we admitted,
04:30impliedly instituted ang civil liability,
04:33but this will come eventually after the court has pronounced
04:36kung magkano'ng ibabalik niya kung meron man.
04:39Not before.
04:40Thank you, Mr. Chair.