Senator Rodante Marcoleta insisted on Tuesday, Sept. 23, that under the law, there's no need for restitution in applying someone to the Witness Protection Program (WPP). (Video courtesy of Senate of the Philippines)

READ: https://mb.com.ph/2025/09/23/return-what-was-taken-marcoleta-insists-no-need-for-restitution-when-applying-for-witness-protection

Subscribe to the Manila Bulletin Online channel! - https://www.youtube.com/TheManilaBulletin

Visit our website at http://mb.com.ph
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/manilabulletin
Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/manila_bulletin
Instagram: https://instagram.com/manilabulletin
Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com @manilabulletin

#ManilaBulletinOnline
#ManilaBulletin
#LatestNews

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Mr. Secretary, a couple of days ago, in the last hearing when you were here,
00:06we somehow settled the issue that restitution is not a requisite for an applicant to the WPP.
00:13Is that correct?
00:14It's not in the law.
00:16But to me, it's not just the law that's dictated this.
00:20It's also what is morally right, what is expected of us.
00:25What do you mean by that, Mr. Secretary?
00:32Because there is no requirement for admission to the WPP.
00:38Yes, it is not.
00:42But you don't have to lay out that we can't lay out, depending on the case.
00:47Mr. Secretary, I am still in the stage where a particular applicant wishes to apply.
00:53Under that program.
00:55And there is a process.
00:57In the process, restitution is not one of the requisites.
01:01Is that correct?
01:03Opo.
01:03Pero in terms of this case being a financial crime, sir,
01:07this is a crime against the financial status of the Filipino people of the Philippine Republic.
01:14I think that it's just right.
01:16Mr. Secretary, are you amending the provision of the law?
01:19No, sir.
01:20No, sir.
01:20But that is how we run the WPP.
01:22As a lawyer, Mr. Secretary, may I ask you?
01:27In a criminal prosecution, the civil liability is impliedly instituted.
01:32Is that correct?
01:34Of course.
01:34Kaya nga eh, hindi naman nangangang hulugan kung sakasakali na natapos na yung criminal prosecution,
01:42kapag ka nakita na mayroong criminal liability yung tao, because it is impliedly implied,
01:48dun lang magkakaroon ng restitution.
01:50It will come after.
01:52Paano mo sasabihin na magre-restitute ang isang tao?
01:56Meron na bang findings kung magkano i-re-restitute on how it can be restituted?
02:00Nag-a-apply pa lang eh.
02:02Huwag po ninyong babaguhin ang requisite ng batas, Mr. Secretary.
02:06I thought nung dumating ka dito, nag-ahindindihan na tayo eh.
02:10Kaya nabablar ang proceedings natin eh.
02:12Kaya nga kinote ni, siguro, ang chairman kanina gusto kong ituloy ito.
02:17Sinabi niya, nagpa-interview siya,
02:18na goodwill and sincerity should be done para i-test.
02:26Pwede ba yung ganito?
02:27I respect your opinion, sir.
02:29It is not my opinion.
02:31It is in the law, Mr. Secretary.
02:32Yes, sir.
02:33Yes, sir.
02:33But I am operating...
02:35The arbiter is the law.
02:36Sir, can I speak, sir?
02:37May I speak, sir?
02:38Yes, you are.
02:38I'm operating from the vantage point of the reason behind the law, sir.
02:44What is the reason behind the law?
02:45So that we can get justice, and justice can only be attained if there is restitution.
02:51So that is the principle behind all of these things that we are talking about now.
02:55Mr. Secretary, restitution will come after?
02:59It cannot be...
03:00Sir, it can come before or after, sir.
03:02It can come before or after.
03:03You cite the law that it come before.
03:06Wala nga po sa batas eh.
03:08Sir, sir, we are operating on a unique set of facts,
03:13and we are...
03:16All of these matters are being evaluated because the gravity of this financial crime cannot be underestimated.
03:25And that the more assets that we're able to preserve at the outset, the better for our country, sir.
03:31Mr. Secretary, I'm very sorry for such a reasoning like that.
03:36I'm very sorry, sir.
03:37Also, sir, I'm very sorry, too, if you do not agree with me.
03:40But I respect your opinion, sir, and we will carry out our job as we deem fit, as we see.
03:47Mr. Chair, I said I am not expressing an opinion here.
03:50I am articulating the provision of law.
03:53You do not change the provision of law, Mr. Secretary.
03:57You may be disbarred from doing this.
03:59Then, it's your opinion, sir.
04:02It's your option, sir.
04:03Then, it's your option, sir.
04:09It is what you wish to happen.
04:12That you may proceed with what you wish.
04:13It is not in the law.
04:22Unless you are able to point out the provision of law that it come before,
04:26hindi ganun eh.
04:27Sabi mo na nga, and we admitted,
04:30impliedly instituted ang civil liability,
04:33but this will come eventually after the court has pronounced
04:36kung magkano'ng ibabalik niya kung meron man.
04:39Not before.
04:40Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Recommended