- 1 year ago
Brussels, my love? Is the future of the car electric?
In this edition, we hear about the battle between the automotive sector and the Commission to postpone the combustion engine phase out and explore if national armies can fight the war on drugs.
READ MORE : http://www.euronews.com/2025/09/20/brussels-my-love-is-the-future-of-the-car-electric
Subscribe to our channel. Euronews is available on Dailymotion in 12 languages
In this edition, we hear about the battle between the automotive sector and the Commission to postpone the combustion engine phase out and explore if national armies can fight the war on drugs.
READ MORE : http://www.euronews.com/2025/09/20/brussels-my-love-is-the-future-of-the-car-electric
Subscribe to our channel. Euronews is available on Dailymotion in 12 languages
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Hello there and welcome to Brussels, my love, our weekly European politics show, bringing
00:17you up to speed on the happenings in Brussels. I'm Maeve McMahon. Thank you so much for tuning
00:22in. Coming up this week, car sales in Europe are down and stress levels among European
00:28carmakers are up. With Chinese carmakers leading the way in EVs and batteries, the EU Commission
00:35President sat down with the European car CEOs in a bid to calm their fears. With additional
00:41pressure on the sector to be clean and go electric, we're taking a look at the existential crisis
00:46facing the car industry and the climate. And remember Mario Draghi, the former ECB chief
00:53and Italian premier? He filed a damning report to the European Commission this time last
00:58year. He warned that the EU should fix its fragmented single market or quote, die a slow
01:04agony. One year later, we hear if anything has changed for the better or if the EU is
01:09still a laggard and not a leader. A warm welcome to our guest this weekend, Conor Allen, a lobbyist.
01:15Welcome. Chloe Michalak-Jack, climate influencer and activist. And Julius Fintelman, editor and
01:21founder of the European Correspondent. Great to have you all with us. Thank you. But as
01:25usual, before we bring in our panel, let's just hear why the European car industry is
01:29hogging all the headlines of late.
01:37Stuttering sales, high energy prices, growing global competition and an uncertain trade
01:43environment have plunged the European car industry into a spiraling crisis.
01:54Last spring, the EU launched an industrial action plan, which includes funds for battery
01:59producers. But such initiatives have failed to change the overall gloomy outlook. The car
02:08makers are particularly frustrated over a lack of pragmatic policy plan for the industry's
02:13transformation. They demand lower energy costs for charging, more purchase subsidies and tax
02:20reductions and especially a better charging infrastructure to make switching to electric
02:25vehicles an obvious choice for a critical mass of European consumers.
02:30If this doesn't work out, should the ban of new combustion engine cars from 2035 be delayed?
02:46So that is the question. Interesting times for the sector that employs some 13.8 million people.
02:52Conor, let's bring in you first on the biggest challenge perhaps for the sector. Is it transitioning
02:56to zero emission cars? Is it rising Chinese competition or is it perhaps the Trump tariffs?
03:01Well, I mean, all three of these, well, they all reflected one particular example of this,
03:06which is the Commission's 2035 ban. We need some sort of runway in order to have this transition
03:12happen. OK, we've had electric cars for a long time now. They've been around for a very long time
03:17and they have not broken into the market in the way the Commission would have liked. There is small
03:23growth in the amount of EVs being uptaken, but it's not enough. It's not where it needs to be.
03:28And at the moment, the industry is being squeezed between a rock and a hard place. Yes, we have
03:32competition in China. Yes, we have some issues for Trump tariffs, but it's being squeezed by the
03:37regulation on one end and the consumer reality on the other. So in fact, if all these things aren't
03:43going in the industry's way, I think the Commission has to look at that 2035 ban and maybe think about
03:49postponing that. Just five years, just five years, give us a bit more runway.
03:54Chloe, would you agree with that? Postponement of just five years, a better runway in Conor Allen's
03:58terms? No, absolutely not. You know, I mean, this target has been around for now a few years
04:03and there were discussions already on transitioning for the industry for years. And what we've been
04:09seeing this year is that we've already given in a lot of flexibility to the industry, even though
04:13they've known for years and years and years that this change was coming. The, you know,
04:18President Commission von der Leyen has said it, Draghi has said it, the future is electric
04:23and Europe will be part of it. And I'm really glad to see that they're showing positive signs
04:27that they're going to hold on to this target, even though there's a massive pressure from the
04:31industry. But I think what's the most worrying to me is really all of those talks about tech
04:37neutrality, which basically is a catch-all buzzword to say we're going to try to get loopholes
04:44in the regulation to not be complying by 2035, right? So there's on one side the possibility
04:49to extend, as Conor suggested, and then there's what the industry is doing and is asking for,
04:54which is tech neutrality. And I think in Brussels, lobbying battles tend to be won not by big
04:59announcements such as delaying by five years. I think that's completely unrealistic. But I think
05:04what the industry is really trying to do is push for those technical victories that the vast majority
05:09of people are not going to know about, but which eventually will be a disaster for the climate,
05:13which will be a disaster for people's health, but also for the industry from a competitiveness
05:17perspective. And whatever happens, the industry needs clarity and the consumer also needs clarity,
05:21right, Julius? Yeah, absolutely. And I mean, for me, I think much of this debate of delaying this ban
05:26of combustion engines seems a bit made up because I cannot really imagine consumers in 10 years' time
05:33still buying combustion engine vehicles. We see now that vehicle, electric vehicle sales are up in
05:39Germany alone, 35% in the first half of 2025 compared to last year. These numbers will keep
05:46going up and EVs are already now so much cheaper in maintaining them, not in buying them. You have a
05:51bigger initial investment as far as I understand, but in actually then maintaining them, charging is
05:56cheaper than gas. And I don't think that will change. Well, Conor, go ahead. Sorry, can I just jump in
06:01there? Because Julius, everything you're saying is right, OK? And if the consumer demand is there,
06:06why do we need the regulation if the consumer demand is there? We're inflicting enormous damage
06:11on the car industry. We're seeing factories close across the continent. That's beginning to change.
06:16We saw Toyota invest in Czechia recently, but it's not enough to combat the closure after closure
06:22after closure. We saw the Audi factory in Brussels. How many people's jobs have to be sacrificed in order
06:27to enable this transition? If I may, on the jobs, I think it's completely non-realistic, sorry, to say
06:33that we're not going to have job closure even if we keep combustion engine vehicles. I mean, the
06:38transition is going to happen. China is transitioning. India is transitioning. We're seeing South Africa
06:42as well. So I think it's actually lying to people to maintain the illusion that we're going to maintain
06:47jobs if we don't transition to electric. There are jobs that are going to be lost. Let's not kid
06:51ourselves and let's not lie to the workers, but also to consumers. I think the question is,
06:56how do we ensure that there are as little job losses are possible? How regions where there are
07:01jobs linked to the industry are supported in order to transition? And where do we create these new
07:06jobs? And that is in the new e-mobility ecosystem. But to say they're not going to be job losses if we
07:11don't transition, that's a massive lie. And I think we need to start being really realistic with
07:16people and tell them the truth.
07:17There won't be any job losses if the transition is guided by the market and not regulation because
07:23you're responsive to consumers.
07:24It's absolutely not true. There will be job losses even if you transition. But the question is,
07:29how do we make sure that there are as few job losses as possible and that this transition is
07:33supported, especially in the regions that are the most affected? But to say if we transition,
07:38there's not going to be any job losses if it's supported by the market. I'm sorry,
07:41Conor, but that's a lie.
07:42If we're making the profits, there's going to be no job losses.
07:44There's going to be 100,000 job losses this year, according to the German Federal Ministry.
07:49Yeah. I mean, and I think 50,000 already this year happened in the first half when I looked
07:55numbers up. And yeah, but I do believe what Chloe is saying is absolutely right. I mean,
08:00as you know, Conor best, I think electric vehicles are so much easier to produce. They need less
08:06manufacturing than internal combustion vehicles. So there will be job losses even if it is regulated
08:11by the market. And I think hinging on to that goal of now delaying that ban for internal combustion
08:19engines just seems a bit like a scarecrow. It doesn't really actually change the reality.
08:24It's just five years. It's just five years.
08:26Then it's five years once and then it's five years again.
08:28Well, no, what we just talked about, 155,000 job losses. 10% of Europe's labor force works in
08:34automotive or automotive adjacent. How many people's jobs have to be sacrificed for an
08:39extra five years? Okay. Or what about changing the 100% to 90% hybrid technology? Fantastic.
08:45We can reduce transport emissions by 90% instead of 100%. That's fantastic.
08:51But is the political support there then for that extension?
08:55I'm not too sure. I'm not too sure. I think one of the very...
08:57That's definitely an interesting debate.
09:00Well, absolutely. And, you know, there are obviously two sides to the debate,
09:04but very well reflected in this room.
09:06Because we had this debate, by the way, two years ago when the announcement was official.
09:10Yeah. And I was lobbying. I was lobbying on that then. And I went to the commission and I had
09:14commission officials tell me, oh, well, you're the car industry. You can afford to dip into your
09:19pocket. Well, now the car industry is dipping into its pocket. And look at how many people are losing
09:23that jobs because of it.
09:24But that was, of course, pre-Trump as well. You know, things have changed as well since the
09:27Trump tariffs came in and they're hitting steel and aluminium as well, Julie.
09:31Yeah, absolutely. I think car makers are reporting how much these tariffs cost them. I think 400
09:35million Porsche set or something and Stellantis at 300 million euros. So, yeah. But can we change that?
09:41I think for that to change, I don't really see another way then to either look for other markets or
09:47look internally how we can improve our industries.
09:50I mean, we're talking about job losses, but we're not talking about job creation.
09:53And there will be massive job creation in the whole ecosystem.
09:56Tell our viewers that because I'm sure we have viewers there who have family members,
09:59brothers, cousins who are losing their jobs in this sector. So how can they feel reassured
10:03by this transition?
10:04I think it's interesting to see that some manufacturers, and I'm thinking of Renault,
10:07already has training workshops in some of the factories to ensure that their workers
10:11can transition to start working on electric vehicles. And then, of course, there's the whole
10:15ecosystem because we're really focusing, we're looking at this through the lens of manufacturers.
10:19But the ecosystem is much wider. If we're looking at electric vehicles, there's
10:23the battery, the recycling, the charging infrastructure. These are thousands of jobs.
10:28And there was actually a letter signed by 150 CEOs to the commission of that e-mobility platform
10:33that was saying, we've already invested billions. We've already created 150,000 jobs.
10:38And there will be many more created if we're able to stay strong on that target and have
10:44that visibility that all businesses are asking for in order to secure investments.
10:47They got that signal two years ago. So if you move the goalposts, it creates uncertainty.
10:51But I just want to go back to, you mentioned Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission
10:54president. She was speaking last week, of course, in Strasbourg, and she had a passionate
10:59message about her views on the future of the car here. Take a look.
11:02Millions of Europeans want to buy affordable European cars. So we should invest in small affordable
11:13cars, both for the European market, but also to meet the surge that we see in the global demand.
11:21And this is why we will propose to work with industry on a new small affordable car initiative.
11:32I believe Europe should have its own e-car. The future of cars and the cars of the future
11:38must be made here in Europe.
11:41So is that realistic, Conor?
11:43Well, I mean, I think it's very interesting. I work for a Japanese company and this speech
11:49by von der Leyen really set Japan ablaze because Japan is known for its small electric cars called
11:54a K car. But it raises more questions than answers because really, we're going to have
11:58the Commission designing automobiles for our consumers. That's not going to go well.
12:03OK, it's completely devoid of consumer demand. If the demand is there, automakers will already
12:10deliver. You see things like the Citroen and me, right? You have small European cars now.
12:15Why does the Commission have to get involved if the consumer demand is there, as she says?
12:18I was in the hemicycle when she made those comments and there was heckling from the far
12:22right, from the right and from the centre. Do you think she ruffled some feathers there
12:26with that comment?
12:27Oh, I think absolutely. I think what I found interesting is that with that comment and
12:30with several comments that she made in that speech, that she threw quite a lot of carrots
12:33towards her left partners, the Socialists and Democrats.
12:37And no red meat to her party.
12:38Exactly. And I found quite interesting.
12:40What about you, Chloe?
12:41I think it's really interesting what you just said, Conor, because for years and years, the problem
12:44that manufacturers have been having is that they made the decision to focus on producing
12:50and selling big SUVs that people don't need. I mean, I don't know how many people walk around
12:54Brussels, but there's SUVs everywhere that are taking all the space. And in order to increase
13:00their profits, they've been focusing for years on making SUVs instead of small cars. The demand
13:05is there for small cars. It's not there for SUVs. But manufacturers have chosen that path
13:09instead. And I think globally, if we look at whether the Commission should get involved
13:14in the strategy, we have been presented with a clean industrial strategy, right? So the
13:20Commissioner said we want to support the European industry to decarbonise. And what we're seeing
13:26is that we do need that. It's not happening yet, but with the right support. And I'm thinking,
13:30for instance, a European preference that says that half, let's say, of components from
13:36electric cars should come from Europe. And there has been a study that have found that
13:41if we do implement that, we could actually have 81% of electric vehicles in Europe in
13:472030 produced in Europe. So we just need the right regulatory framework and not just let
13:51it up to the market.
13:52That means monitoring, of course, then the supply chains. You're disagreeing with that?
13:55Absolutely, 100%. How are you going to make a cheap electric vehicle? Well, two things to
14:02what you said there, Chloe. Number one, it is cheaper and it's significantly an easier engineering
14:08challenge to electrify a larger car than it is a smaller car. That's because engines way
14:13more, they're larger. SUVs are the most profitable electric thing. So if you want electric vehicles,
14:20you have to go for SUVs first and then produce the smaller ones later. And the second thing you
14:26mentioned is this European preference in the supply chain. So how are you going to make things
14:30cheaper if you're choosing artificially European manufacturers with the highest energy costs in
14:37history, the highest labour costs in the world compared to, yes, even a Chinese-made component?
14:43Or what about Japanese or American or Turkish-made?
14:47But then, Conor, if we don't do that, let's say, so that means that the clean industrial deal
14:50shouldn't exist, that basically the EU shouldn't support its own industry because anyway, at this
14:55moment, it's cheaper to produce elsewhere. So if that is your point, then let's say goodbye to
15:00Europe's industry and let's say, fine, we're going to import everything industrial from China.
15:04So we say goodbye to free trade then? So we should just embrace protectionism, build the
15:09barriers and make sure no product can enter your market.
15:11The US that you love, for instance, that you take often as an example, is...
15:14Where they have a lot of SUVs.
15:16Yes, where they have a lot of SUVs.
15:17Everyone has a massive car.
15:18...is implementing a form of protectionism. And if we're serious about having a true European industrial
15:23strategy, that requires planning, that requires strategizing, and that requires indeed investment
15:29and some sort of policy intervention. We cannot say, let's just make sure that the market is the
15:34driving force here. Because if we do that, that's basically just saying yes to everything that comes
15:38from China. And that basically means we increase our dependency to other countries. And I'm sorry,
15:43but that's not the kind of Europe I want in 10 years.
15:45Well, I mean, if you want to come in, I mean, I think from a consumer perspective, from someone
15:49that wants to buy a car, I personally, as a consumer, I wouldn't really care where that
15:54car comes from. What I want is I want it to be cheap, I want it to be affordable, and I probably
15:58want it to be electric because that is the future. And if that means, hey, do we need to look at the
16:04regulation towards Chinese cars, vehicles in Europe? Yeah, then that means we have to look for that. But
16:09personally, I think from a citizen's perspective, it doesn't really matter if it's European or not,
16:16but we need more e-vehicles in Europe, that's for sure. Absolutely.
16:18Well, on that point, we actually had a chat with Romain Denaire. He's the senior
16:22e-mobility advisor for EV Belgium, because of course, a lot of people, they perhaps want to go
16:27electric, but they're worried about being stuck without a charger. Take a look.
16:32So the main barriers today is perception. And it's a real issue that we see everywhere in Europe,
16:39although we see that buying prices of EV are getting lower, that they are getting more accessible,
16:45and that the total cost of ownership, the TCO, is getting more advantageous every day,
16:51and even often, in most cases, is more advantageous than other types of vehicles.
16:57The second barrier we see today is the presence of charging infrastructure,
17:01still perceived as an issue. While we have celebrated the one million charging points in
17:08Europe, we know that there are still some regions where there are problems,
17:11but also there, the charging will grow in the coming years.
17:15Romain Denaire there. Interesting that he says the biggest roadblock today is perception. Would you
17:19agree with that?
17:20Well, I think that's a kind of big state approach, right? If you have to explain to consumers that
17:25actually, no, you're wrong. Things are cheaper than you think, and things are more accessible
17:28than you think. So you should buy these things. You've gone wrong somewhere because consumers
17:32are smart. They know how to think for themselves. And at the moment, consumer demand for EVs,
17:36yes, it's growing. It's not growing fast enough.
17:38Well, he said we have one million charging points in Europe, but the car sector says we need nine
17:43million by 2035. Is it the charging problem or is it perception, Chloe, in your view?
17:47I think it's definitely perception. And I think, of course, consumers are smart,
17:51but there's also some very targeted lobbying campaigns from the people and the industries
17:55that don't want anything to change, that are presenting EVs as something that is difficult,
18:01that is something that is difficult to charge, that will take longer for people to travel,
18:05et cetera. And for elites as well, because it's too expensive. So perception is definitely a huge
18:11problem there. And I'm glad to see that there's more and more high profile figures. I'm thinking
18:15of this F1 driver. I'm sorry, I'm really bad with F1 driver's name, who made this post on LinkedIn,
18:20I think over the summer saying, basically, I am so happy to have this EV. This has not really added
18:26that long to my trip. It's actually really comfortable. So I think more and more people are
18:31starting to realize, but that perception issue is definitely there.
18:33Even though the reality on the ground is, it's now in the Netherlands and Germany where we have
18:37the most chargers. So if I wanted to drive from Brussels to Spain, it would be quite risky.
18:43Well, I mean, I don't drive an EV. I don't drive from that many cars myself. But I do think that,
18:49for some reason, cars and electric vehicles have become kind of a culture war battleground,
18:54whereas in my mind, it really doesn't have to be. We see in Germany alone that charges have
18:58increased by 20,000 in the first six months or five months of this year. And that's
19:03huge. And I think there is a perception problem there. As Chloe said, there is massive amounts
19:08of money that's being spent to portray EVs as something that they're not. And there's been
19:13in Germany, especially chronic underinvestment into actually the future of the automotive industry,
19:18which was electric. And that was known for decades. And yet it wasn't really properly addressed.
19:23I've done the trip, just so you know, Belgium to Spain in an electric car and it went perfectly
19:27fine. Well, there you go. Perfect proof there from Chloe, one of our panelists. What's your take on
19:33all this, how we can improve the gap? For example, we have so many charging stations in France, in
19:37Belgium, or in the Netherlands, sorry, and Germany, but not in other parts of Europe.
19:41Well, I think it's a, it's an interesting problem. But I mean, first of all, we know we're,
19:44we're talking about, uh, elites and then holding up Formula One drivers as the, as the examples of,
19:49of EG drivers. But, um, no, I mean, I think...
19:51Cultural influence. It's not that it's just for...
19:53Speaking of the elites, you have this, uh, you know, very urban elite, you know, you have
19:58people maybe in the commission, they, they've never driven a car, they, they ride their bicycle
20:02to work. And, um, you know, they don't have the same experiences as someone in rural Italy,
20:07go to Southern Catalonia, go to rural Greece. And it's a, it's a very different set of problems.
20:13I think people here in Brussels are very much blind to, um, but, but I mean, I'll, I'll more
20:19or less agree with you. Like let's increase some of our charge points. Let's make them fast
20:23as well, by the way, because if you need to do 20 minutes to charge your car, it's useless.
20:28I don't think 20 minutes is useless. I've actually really enjoyed my trip. You know,
20:32you can go for a coffee. If you have kids, it's great for the kids to actually walk around the
20:35car and stretch their legs. If you have furry babies as I do, you know, it's great to walk
20:40the dog as well. It's actually completely fine. And everyone I've met who drives an EV has said that
20:46at the most it adds, depending on the distance, it adds between 40 minutes to one hour to a trip.
20:51I don't think that's completely unmanageable. Um, and most people that drive electric vehicles
20:56just mentioned the comfort, the noise and just overall, I think we haven't mentioned this in
21:01this debate today, but, um, the health angle is really, really important and it's not playing
21:05a big enough part in this debate. One of the main reasons also why we need to phase out
21:09combustion engine cars, it's because it's extremely polluting and it's affecting people's health and
21:14especially children and elderly's health. So if we don't also take that into the debate,
21:20we're going to have, we can going to continue to have premature deaths thousands every year
21:24across Europe. And that's a topic I've covered a lot, in fact, as a reporter here at Euronews. So
21:28if anyone wants to read more about that or anything we have discussed today, do take a look at
21:32Euronews.com. But now we can close this conversation. Thank you so much to our panelists,
21:37but don't you go anywhere because we'll be back very soon. We'll be throwing back to last year
21:42when Mario Draghi presented his report on the EU's existential crises. And this week,
21:47the former ECB bank president said things are actually worse. See you soon.
21:59Welcome back to Brussels, my love, our weekly European politics show with me,
22:03Maeve McMahon. Well, this week, Mario Draghi came to Brussels to remind lawmakers that it's already
22:09one year since he warned in a 400-page report that the EU could, quote,
22:14die a slow death if it didn't overhaul and simplify regulations, improve access to finance,
22:20and make it easier for startups and scaling up. And this week, in a very frank speech,
22:25the former Italian premier said that one year after this damning report,
22:28Europe is actually in a harder place. And EU public debt could rise by 10% in the near future.
22:34So Julius, has anything changed since the Mario Draghi report? Have any of the recommendations
22:38been implemented? Well, of course, Mario Draghi, incredibly important figure in European politics,
22:42and I think his report really gave the new commission and Europe more generally a roadmap of what to do.
22:48And I think one year on, when we look back, we see that not much of that roadmap has been done.
22:53I think the most crucial element, what he was calling for, was a massive, massively bigger budget
22:57that basically funds the entire operation of the EU. The budget that the EU commission
23:02presented before this summer is not anywhere close to what Draghi called for, which I believe
23:07was around 800 billion a year. The overall budget for seven years is around two trillion, so it's not
23:13even half. And for that, you know, we need that kind of budget. And to get there, he proposed things
23:21such as joint debt, joint borrowing by EU member states, something that, except when it comes to
23:26defence, we've seen some progress there. But beyond that, that's not really a thing that's popular
23:30among member states. You repeated that again this week. I know the commission has launched this
23:33European Innovation Act. It's to help products get from the lab to the market quicker. There's also
23:37the omnibus packages to this competitive compass. Any kind of things there that you'd like to comment on?
23:43Well, you know, it's always coming so slowly, isn't it? And, you know, like we can talk about
23:49whether we agree with it or not, but this is the approach they've chosen. It's coming so slowly.
23:53I think the commission's quite demotivated because they've taken so many losses recently.
23:57Look at the hit with the Trump trade deal, for example, and look at the omnibus. They are being
24:03asked to go back over the last five years and alter all the legislation. And then what they do,
24:08it's tweaks, OK? It's not actually, you know, someone like me would say total deregulation,
24:13but they're not doing that. Someone like Chloe might say, don't touch it. But they're just
24:18making teeny tiny tweaks and it's not helping anybody. It's crazy.
24:23It's not helping anybody. Would you agree, Chloe? And just reminding our viewers as well,
24:27there was a lot as well in that report about the aging population here in Europe,
24:30labour shortages. Like, it's really worth a read if people have time, even the summary.
24:34Yeah. No, nothing has changed pretty much. It's all words at this stage, you know,
24:37especially on the whole industrial side of things. Once again, not much has changed. And meanwhile,
24:43we're actually increasing our dependence to the US, for instance, with that 700
24:49billions in LNG imports that we've committed to. So Draghi is really saying that decarbonisation
24:55is the key to independence and, you know, strategic autonomy for Europe. And he mentioned it again a
25:00few days ago. And von der Leyen also mentioned it again. And we're actually going in the wrong direction.
25:05And also, I think what we've seen over the past year is that the Draghi report has been politically
25:09hijacked to be used as a justification to kill green rules. And this is not what Draghi actually
25:15says. I've read the line and I don't think many people in Brussels have read that line specifically.
25:19Yes, it calls for simplification, but it doesn't call for that level of simplification
25:25on climate and green rules. So I think it's very important to say there is an intense,
25:30really strong intent on decarbonisation as a pathway for Europe. And this is not respected. And yes,
25:36I agree with you. It's being enrolled way too slowly. A lot of things have not even begun to
25:41be thought about. So there's a massive problem there. But I think I think also important here is
25:45that there's a tendency to always blame the EU commission for this. But a massive, massive reason
25:50for this is the blocking that the member states are doing and parliament and parliament as well.
25:55And if if there is no way for the commission to actually act without member states blocking just
26:00about everything that would nag at their sovereignty, then yeah, much of the Draghi report will remain a fantasy.
26:05Shall we eliminate oversight from the parliament and council? I don't think so. But second time,
26:13I'm glad this is on television. I agree with Chloe again, because you look at the opportunity we have
26:19in net zero industries. It's fantastic. The USA is cutting funding for these industries with the
26:23Inflation Reduction Act. Europe has a great opportunity. Throw the money in there that this is
26:29the approach you've taken. Where is the money? No one knows where the money is.
26:32Instead, 750 billion to LNG. And speed up. I mean, that was the warning as well from Draghi this week.
26:36Speed up or we will fall behind the US, China and India. Another priority that Mario Draghi set out was
26:41closing this innovation gap in advanced technologies, a topic that comes up a lot. But this was disputed by
26:47Michael Pinto. He's the Managing Director of Circular Materials. And we chatted with him earlier this week.
26:51Michael Pinto The problem is not a gap in innovation. Europeans are plenty innovative. What we need is to
26:58make it easier to scale and commercialize the technologies that we do develop and to keep them
27:03here as companies. And the answer to that question is obviously to address fragmentation. We have to
27:08make Europe one single frictionless market that benefits all 450 million citizens. And for that to
27:15happen, we need all the actors to play ball together. And that's not just the European
27:20Commission. That's actually the member states. It's the regions within each country. And we need
27:25to make it a palatable proposition for investors. Making a point similar to what you made, like there's
27:29a lot really in the hands of the member states here in order to have real change. Yeah. And I think also
27:34it's like, of course, there needs to be less fragmentation. But I think overall, there's the issue of
27:40the money. That's also really there. And there's the issue of the policy intervention. And that goes
27:44back to the discussion that we were having before. We need a better framework. And we need more policy
27:49intervention to make sure that the Draghi reports can be implemented. And we can't leave that to the
27:55market alone, like it's been done for years and years, because otherwise we won't have enough
27:59And in the tech field, it was quite interesting what Draghi said about the field of AI. He even suggested
28:04pausing the AI acts, the AI acts that the EU institutions are so proud of. How did that
28:09point go down here? I think the usage of the word pride is very important there. And I see in my
28:15lobbying, all these things on data processing, on AI, this is proud personal attachment to regulations
28:24that are really hurting. I mean, Draghi is saying that AI act implementation will hurt industry.
28:29And so very, very, you know, if you're talking about people's own personal attachment to these
28:34regulations, which shouldn't happen, by the way, that should inform you as to how that's gone down.
28:40I mean, I think when it comes to tech, and when it comes to data regulations, there's often this
28:45tendency from tech firms themselves to call for, oh, we're extremely overregulated. But when you talk
28:51to some of the actors in the field, when you talk to people inside companies, I've recently talked to
28:55someone at Signal, who was saying it's not overregulation, it's simply regulation. That's
29:01that's also a scarecrow that industry likes to throw to prevent further regulation. I think the
29:08AI act is one example where the EU actually was ahead globally and set a standard and abandoning that
29:13to me seems premature.
29:15Again, it's all about signals. Well, we can actually bring this conversation to a close. Thank you so much
29:20to our panel for being with us. And thank you so much for watching. We'll see you soon here on Euronews.
29:33Hello there, and welcome to Brussels, my love, our weekly European politics show here
29:38on Euronews. I'm Maeve McMahan. And this weekend, I'm joined by Conor Allen, a lobbyist, Chloe
29:44Miklilakjak, a climate activist, and Julius Fintelman, the editor and founder of the European
29:49correspondent. And together, we're just taking a look at the news of the week. And one that stood
29:54out was a proposal to deploy soldiers to the streets of the Belgian capital of Brussels to
29:59tackle drug related crime. The plan, which is spearheaded by the Belgian Home Affairs Minister,
30:04would also include an investment of 20 million euros for a network of security cameras. So I'm
30:09curious to hear what you all think of this proposal. Chloe?
30:13Sure, I can go first. I think it's not a great idea, let's be honest. Yes, there is a problem
30:20with drug related violence in Brussels, for sure. But I don't think putting the army in the streets
30:26is going to help. That's really a communication move by the government at a time where it's deeply
30:31unpopular in Belgium for many, many reasons. And it's not going to sort the real reasons for drug
30:37violence, it's actually just going to probably displace the traffic from one neighbourhood to
30:42the other. We have a very small army, I say we because I'm Belgian, but we have a tiny army in
30:47Belgium. And we keep hearing that we need to be prepared in order for this army to be deployed to
30:53a potential conflict, right in the current context. So putting military industries that won't have any
30:59power to search people or to arrest people. It's just a really bad idea.
31:04That's a big issue, right? That's the big debate here in Belgium. They wouldn't have any legal powers
31:07to actually intervene and they're pretty scandalised by the proposal. What's your take on it, Conor?
31:12I disagree totally. I think if we look across the pond to the United States, they've had some
31:17fantastic successes in making LA and DC crime free. And I'm saying this as a person, last night I was
31:24walking home and I was being hassled by these group of people. The safest that Brussels has ever been
31:31is just after the Malbec bombings in 2015. That's because there was no one in the streets.
31:35Why? We had for three months afterwards, military in the streets. And suddenly you walk around
31:41Garda Nord, which is full of the craziest, weirdest people on planet Earth, and they melt away. They
31:48don't want to be there when there's a man with a gun at the end of the street. They don't have to be
31:51searching people. They are a visible security presence. And you know, these left-wing arguments,
31:56they are always about empathy for the criminal. It's always about empathy for these people who
32:01are making our cities unsafe. What about the empathy for the people who have to live with
32:06weird, I think, addicts hassling them on the streets?
32:09I think we all in this round here live in this city. And I think this comes down to what kind of
32:14city and society do we want to live in. I don't want to live in a society where the only way that
32:18the government thinks it can keep us safe is to deploy the army, which is not meant to be
32:22used inside a country, is to deploy that on its own citizen or on its own residence.
32:27That's not the kind of society that I want to live in.
32:29And many here feel that there should be more investment in the judicial system instead of
32:32perhaps surveillance. But let's hear from more people who live here in Brussels about how they
32:37feel about having soldiers patrolling their streets to find a fight crime.
32:41I'm not sure that it would make me feel safer. I think it would draw more attention.
32:47It's a bit naive to feel like that drug violence or drug problems in Brussels are
32:53like something that is isolated. When of course we have another sea like Antwerp, which is
32:57very close and like the old issues with the port.
33:01We already had some soldiers when we had the attacks. So I guess yes, it would be maybe give the
33:08feeling to be more comforting.
33:10I think it was the insecurity and the violence because I think soldiers are soldiers and
33:16their training, it's fighting or whatever. I think that won't help at all.
33:21So most people, Conor, are against the idea?
33:23What do you mean most people? The people who were interviewed there were English-speaking
33:27elites, probably working in the Eurobubble. I have lived in places like Wollenberg. I've worked in
33:32working-class jobs here in Brussels. And if you go and speak to Belgian people, they don't want to live
33:37subject to the whims of the bottom 10% of society who are causing all the problems.
33:42I do feel safe in Brussels, Chloe.
33:44Yes, I actually do feel safe. And I've lived in different cities in Europe and I actually do feel
33:50safe in Brussels. And I think there's several things. You mentioned Gare du Nord, for instance.
33:54The reason why also the crime is so high around Gare du Nord...
33:58That's the north station, the main train station.
33:59Exactly. And this is also because a lot of the people that live around there
34:03are people that came to Belgium and that the government has an obligation to house and to
34:10basically find ways to make them feel welcome in Belgium. And the government hasn't been doing
34:15that. So a lot of these people are actually themselves taking drugs to probably forget
34:20the situation that they're in. And one of the things that we don't really mention when we talk about
34:27drug-related violence in cities, in capital cities, is also the responsibility of consumers.
34:33And I'm not talking about specifically these people, but there are a lot of people that take
34:37drugs for leisure, right? When they party on the weekends. And we're not really talking about this.
34:41And this is a crucial aspect if you want to reduce drug-related violence in Brussels. So yes,
34:46more means in the judicial system, more means for the police. But no, the army industry is not going
34:51to solve anything. You make all the excuses for the perpetrators of the crimes and you don't think at
34:57all about the people who have to live with the crimes. You can explain this away, but people have to deal with that.
35:02I've lived in areas like that. When you talk about these people arriving in the country,
35:05do you think they want to be living with next door to addicts, next door to people committing
35:10crime? That's the most important thing.
35:11Do you think that the military in the streets will seriously solve that problem? Do you think
35:15the military in the streets will seriously solve the problem of drugs coming into Belgium,
35:19coming into the Netherlands? No, this is not something that can be fixed with just sort of a...
35:23The cameras fix it. What about surveillance cameras like we have in London?
35:26I mean, I think surveillance, yeah, to some extent, certainly, but I also think we need to have
35:34more innovative solutions than trying to control public spaces and trying to put people and soldiers
35:39and police and surveillance cameras into places where people are missing.
35:42And it's a problem of a lack of investment in neighborhoods in the cities, in many cities.
35:46And I mean, Brussels is extremely complicated, like the whole of Belgium, pretty much. So,
35:51you know, you've got some police who have authority in certain areas and not in others. There are
35:55problems also of communication between the police. We've seen this during the terror attack.
35:59Some levels of police were informed while some others weren't. So I think let's focus on this
36:04first. Let's invest more in the police and in the judicial system. And let's see where we get
36:09there. But it's not the moment. Also, if we're all talking about, you know, potential conflict and
36:13stuff like that, is it really where we want our soldiers to be? Don't we want them to be in training
36:17centers? But with 57 shootings, and you can see Brussels getting a bad reputation
36:21for this issue, drawing negative headlines. Absolutely. And you mentioned
36:24surveillance cameras being posted in London. London, not exactly a crime free city.
36:29What we need is a visible security presence. We've talked about funding for the police.
36:33How much funding do they want? We pay 50 percent income taxes. I had to use the police here.
36:37I know people who've gone in the police and the police say we're not going to go and solve this
36:42crime. We know where the thief is. We're not going to go into it because it's too dangerous for
36:46us. They're not doing their jobs. So therefore, the military has to step in and provide a visible
36:50security presence. The police is underfunded. The police is underfunded. And that is a debate
36:54for another day, because now we can bring this conversation to a close. Thank you so much,
36:58Conor Allen, Chloe Michalakczak, and Julius Fintelman for being our guests this weekend.
37:03If you would like to join in the conversation, reach out, brusselsmilove at uranews.com.
37:08That is our email address. You can also find us on social media. Take care.