00:00Russia's war against Ukraine is now a test of Europe's economic and political resolve.
00:05Despite years of sanctions, Moscow continues to finance its war machine, while divisions
00:10over frozen Russian assets and Europe's dependence on American security guarantees expose the
00:15limits of the EU's strategy.
00:17So how can Europe put real pressure on Vladimir Putin, and is it finally prepared to confront
00:22Russia on its own terms?
00:24I'm now joined by financier and human rights activist Bill Browder, one of the most prominent
00:29international campaigners against Putin's regime.
00:32Good morning, sir.
00:33Thanks for coming on the show.
00:35Good morning to you.
00:37So you have been fighting Putin for more than two decades.
00:40Is he stronger today than he was when you first started exposing his regime?
00:47Absolutely not.
00:48He's in a very weak position today.
00:50He entered this weak position by basically launching the full-scale invasion.
00:55As everybody knows, he's lost hundreds and hundreds of thousands of soldiers.
01:01There's $300 billion worth of central bank reserves that are frozen.
01:06His oil refining business industry has now been massively destroyed by Ukrainian drones.
01:14And in just about every possible way, he's in a weak and continuing to be weaker position.
01:21But the thing about Vladimir Putin is that he's ready to sacrifice everything in order to continue to be at
01:29war.
01:29Any normal democratic leader would have bowed out at this point because the people of the country would have pressured
01:36the leader to do so.
01:37But he doesn't live in a democracy, he doesn't have to listen to his people, and he's driving Russia into
01:42a total state of ruin.
01:44Do you believe that Putin is generally interested in peace, or does he see the negotiations simply as another instrument
01:52to weaken the West and create further divisions?
01:56He has no interest in peace for one simple reason.
01:59He needs the war in order to distract the people of Russia from his own failings.
02:05He has not been a productive leader.
02:08He has not brought prosperity and good life to the Russian people.
02:13He's been in power for 26 years.
02:15And so he needs a foreign enemy.
02:19He needs somebody for everyone to be mad at, so they can't be mad at him.
02:24And so this war will not end.
02:26And for what it's worth, if you listen to anything that he's said, anything that the foreign minister of Russia,
02:31Lavrov, has said,
02:32anything that their chief negotiator has said, they haven't modified their goals one bit.
02:39They're all in.
02:40This is a full-scale war that they have no intention of backing down from.
02:45And so all these talks about peace, all these meetings in Berlin, that's all hypothetical.
02:50That all requires him to stop being at war, and he has no interest in stopping being at war.
02:56Sir, is Vladimir Putin also buying time with the sort of renewed diplomatic process,
03:02and specifically with the trilateral meeting with Donald Trump and Xi Jinping?
03:07Well, I mean, he's definitely trying to buy time.
03:10I'm not sure that Donald Trump and Xi Jinping can give him anything that he needs.
03:15What he needs, actually, more than anything, and what he's banking on, is that there are various European elections coming
03:21up,
03:21particularly the election in France.
03:23In France, you have Marine Le Pen, who's leading in the opinion polls.
03:27If she were to win, and she follows through on her promise to end French aid for Ukraine,
03:34she might also intervene to try to end European aid for Ukraine.
03:37And if that were to happen, then he buys himself the biggest victory he could ever have.
03:42He would then end up with a similar type of situation that he has with the United States,
03:46where Trump cut off U.S. aid for Ukraine.
03:49If Europe were to cut off aid for Ukraine, then he could win the war.
03:52And so that's what he's holding out for.
03:54All this other stuff is just cosmetics.
03:56It's just, you know, photo opportunities and so on.
04:01It's not material.
04:03But what he's hoping for is Europe fractures.
04:05And that's what he's holding out for.
04:07And that's what he's ready to allow another half million soldiers to die for,
04:12if that's what it takes to bide him that time until he gets to April, May next year.
04:17Sir, and to follow up on that, unlike Europe with the elections coming in France and other countries,
04:24and also even the United States, Putin has the time, has the time that the Europeans and the Americans do
04:30not have to wait.
04:32Well, he does and he doesn't.
04:34I mean, so what Ukraine has done very successfully while waiting for everybody to impose sanctions is impose their own
04:40sanctions, economic sanctions on Russia.
04:42And those sanctions are in the form of destroying the oil refining capacity of the country.
04:47Those sanctions are in destroying data centers, destroying the Crimea, the Kirsch Bridge.
04:52And to the extent that Ukraine continues with this the campaign of economic destruction of Russia, he doesn't have all
05:02that much time.
05:03At some point, I believe that Ukraine will put him in a position where he has to agree to stop
05:09killing Ukrainian civilians with airstrikes on Kiev and other places because he won't be able to afford it.
05:15I think that that's the direction this war is going in.
05:17And it's not going to be negotiated by outside parties. It's going to end up being a point of of
05:23real leverage.
05:24Does Ukraine what will when will Ukraine's campaign of economic bombardment hurt him so much that he has to not
05:30not end the war, but at least end the indiscriminate killing of civilians?
05:36And that could come next year.
05:39And I think that he's holding out to see what happens in France and then he'll have to make a
05:43decision.
05:43And so Putin today is meeting Xi Jinping, who doesn't want to have anything to do with Ukraine, and Donald
05:51Trump, who just moved into lame duck status and is heavily weakened domestically.
05:57So what, beyond the nice pictures and the decorum, could make this summit beneficial for Putin?
06:06Well, he might be able to get some token concessions from Trump, maybe some lifting of some sanctions here or
06:13there.
06:14He might be able to get some strange announcement of recognition of territories or or occupied territories or something absurd
06:23like that.
06:24But but America doesn't have that much leverage in this situation.
06:27So Ukraine is continuing to be armed.
06:30They're being armed by money and weapons coming from Europe.
06:33Ukraine has the capacity to continue to hit Russia with drones and none of that stuff is going to stop.
06:40And so in a certain way, you know, Donald Trump stopped funding Ukraine two years ago.
06:46So he can't withdraw that in to pressure Ukraine to do anything.
06:51They cut off Starlink so that pressure is gone.
06:55And so there's really not that much left that that Donald Trump can do that would change the situation for
07:01Putin on a material basis.
07:03And so I think this is this is all in a certain way for Putin's domestic audience to show that
07:09he's a big leader on the big stage with big superpowers.
07:12We shouldn't forget that China is a superpower.
07:16America is a superpower.
07:18Russia has got an economy the size of the state of New York and they have a military which doesn't
07:23seem to be able to defeat a much smaller military of Ukraine after almost five years of battle.
07:29And so this is this is only an image enhancing exercise for Putin.
07:34I don't see anything that could be all that material that comes out of it, sir.
07:39And finally, we see Putin only willing to negotiate with Donald Trump at this stage.
07:44Are we going to see him also meeting at the table with the Europeans and negotiating with the Europeans?
07:50I absolutely not.
07:51He has no intention of doing that.
07:53He's stated that he has no intention of doing that.
07:55And the reason he's not going to do that is because the Europeans would would come at him hard and
08:00he doesn't want somebody to come at him hard.
08:01He wants he wants a pliant, amenable counterpart, which is what Donald Trump is, for reasons that many people can
08:09speculate, but nobody knows.