Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 year ago

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00The U.S.A. is in a state of shock on discovering that the Soviet Union possesses the atomic bomb.
00:14The Reds have now become the new enemy.
00:17In every walk of life, the FBI is carrying out a real manhunt.
00:23Soviet spies could be anywhere.
00:28Panic ensues.
00:30What if your neighbors were traitors?
00:33Almost immediately, two faces embody this collective paranoia.
00:38That of a man with a dark mustache and that of a woman with a wry smile.
00:43The headlines read, Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, Reds' spies arrested.
00:50Their trial begins and people are divided into two camps.
00:53Are they victims of a witch hunt or are they atomic spies?
00:57On the eve of the court proceedings, one question is on everyone's minds.
01:05Who are the Rosenberg couple, really?
01:08Julius and Ethel grew up in New York in the Jewish quarter of the East Side, where poverty was rife.
01:29They were part of the first generation to be born on American soil after their families had come from Eastern Europe.
01:39Julius and Ethel had a lot in common, but at this point of the story, they hadn't yet met.
01:44For a while, Julius considered becoming a rabbi before changing his mind to study engineering.
01:51He had a loving family who supported him, whichever direction he took.
01:55Life was much harder for Ethel, her mother was always very critical of her.
02:03During her teenage years, along with the chores, Ethel also had to look after her brother David, who was seven years younger than her.
02:12But despite the daily hardships, Ethel dreamed of only one thing.
02:16To go on stage and sing.
02:18Reality caught up with her.
02:34To support her family, Ethel found a job as a stenographer.
02:37Her mother had told her to stop dreaming.
02:40At last, a real job.
02:42But nothing could stop her singing.
02:52Like on this New Year's Eve of 1936.
02:59In Among the Dancers, one young man stood out.
03:03He was 18 years old.
03:04She was 21.
03:05It was love at first sight.
03:12Three years later, in an old Orthodox synagogue on the Lower East Side, they were married by a rabbi.
03:24There was no party to celebrate the wedding due to lack of money.
03:28They were not concerned, since they were to be together for always.
03:32Another bond united them.
03:39The firm conviction that communism would save the world.
03:46Julius and Ethel spent their time in meetings and watching propaganda films.
03:50They took Ethel's younger brother, David, along with them, and he ended up joining the party, too.
04:09On the other side of the Atlantic, war was about to break out in Europe.
04:13In 1939, Hitler invaded Poland.
04:16Ethel and Julius could not remain indifferent to the sounds of marching Nazis,
04:21who both threatened Jews and invaded the countries their families came from.
04:27The U.S. only entered the conflict at the end of 1941.
04:32This was a turning point in the life of the Rosenbergs.
04:37Julius was not called up to fight.
04:40As an engineer, he was essential to the war effort at home.
04:43The younger brother, David, was not so lucky.
04:48He had to leave his young wife, Ruth, because he was called up and sent to Los Alamos in New Mexico.
04:56This site, built in the middle of the desert like a bunker isolated from civilization,
05:02housed a top-secret project.
05:05Its codename was the Manhattan Project.
05:13Among the dozens of scientists, David was a mechanic in the explosives laboratory.
05:20At Los Alamos, all types of trades were brought together
05:23to ensure that the Americans would be the first to build the world's most powerful weapon.
05:29In just two years, the atomic bomb was created.
05:32In August 1945, the U.S. dropped two bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
05:41And a few days later, Japan surrendered.
06:01The end of the war brought a halt to the Rosenbergs' militant activities.
06:04They were no longer even members of the Communist Party
06:09and devoted their time to bringing up their son, Michael.
06:12But what was going through their minds when, four years later,
06:15the Soviet Union carried out its first atomic bomb tests?
06:18This sent shutters throughout the U.S.,
06:35especially as China had fallen into Moscow's orbit.
06:39For the Americans, this was confirmation that communism was not just an ideology,
06:44but a military force extending its power over part of the globe.
06:48John Q. Citizen wonders what happens now
06:51is to tighten security regulations at all atom installations.
06:58Atomic shelters were built all over the country as protection from Russian bombs.
07:06Let us face, without panic, the reality of our time.
07:11The fact that atom bombs may someday be dropped on our cities.
07:15Endless public information films were shown on television,
07:18explaining what to do in the event of a nuclear attack.
07:21That signal means to stop whatever you are doing
07:24and get to the nearest safe place fast.
07:27You duck, and then you cover.
07:31It's a bomb. Duck and cover.
07:34He knew just what to do.
07:36He ducked and covered.
07:39People were looking for atomic spies in all walks of life.
07:45And the Reds were all the more dangerous for being invisible.
07:49They could turn out to be your next-door neighbors.
07:53J. Edgar Hoover was the intransigent head of the FBI.
07:57Communism, in reality, is not a political party.
08:03It is a way of life, an evil and malignant way of life.
08:06It reveals a condition akin to disease that spreads like an epidemic.
08:11And like an epidemic, a quarantine is necessary to keep it from infecting this nation.
08:16Did the Rosenbergs know what they risked as former communists?
08:23They should have done,
08:24because the Cold War was at the forefront of everyone's minds.
08:29People were afraid the Reds were hatching a plan,
08:32enabling America to be attacked from within.
08:34Joseph McCarthy, an unscrupulous senator with an eye for the main chance,
08:53claimed that communist spies had infiltrated the whole of American society.
08:57Even if there are only one communist in the State Department,
09:01there could still be one communist, two many.
09:04The Rosenbergs could no longer be unaware of this witch hunt.
09:16But in the short term, their family was shaken by an unfortunate event.
09:22The winter in New York that year was a severe one,
09:24and David's wife, Ruth, who was seven months pregnant,
09:28was victim of a domestic accident.
09:30Their little heater set her dressing gown on fire.
09:37From then on, all David cared about was protecting his wife at all costs.
09:42Meanwhile, the FBI was buzzing with action.
09:49I do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States
09:57against enemies, foreign and domestic.
10:02Soviet spies became the obsession of FBI Director Hoover.
10:06To list potential spies, Hoover introduced an ingenious system of perforated cards,
10:30on which there were no fewer than 20,000 names of communist sympathizers.
10:36The Bureau's work is made easier by the wholehearted cooperation of the American public
10:42to report to the FBI knowledge of subversive activities.
10:46The loyal and alert citizen may help to protect the innocent,
10:49as well as to reveal the guilty.
10:51Day after day, photos of suspected spies were pinned up on FBI notice boards.
11:04The first spy to fall was Klaus Fuchs,
11:06one of the scientists who'd been involved in the research at Los Alamos.
11:14He confessed without a struggle,
11:16and even gave up the name of his liaison officer.
11:19Immediately afterwards,
11:22chemist Harry Gold was arrested.
11:24Harry Gold is seen here in Philadelphia,
11:26just after he'd been granted postponement of extradition to New York for trial.
11:30He's accused of passing atomic secrets to Russia,
11:33having, it's alleged, acted as a go-between for Dr. Fuchs,
11:36the scientist convicted as a traitor in Britain.
11:39Gold is reported as saying,
11:40I meant no harm to America.
11:42In the FBI offices,
11:47Harry Gold gave a very detailed description of a second spy
11:50who had worked at Los Alamos,
11:53a well-built GI mechanic with curly black hair,
11:56recently married to a woman called Ruth.
12:02The FBI needed only to consult its perforated cards.
12:05On one of them,
12:08Julius's brother-in-law David appeared.
12:15On the orders of the FBI,
12:17David Greenglass was arrested at home.
12:19The scene was filmed,
12:21and the press invited.
12:22The arrest of this ordinary citizen
12:27and head of a family
12:28sent shivers through the neighborhood.
12:30People gathered out on the street
12:32or watched from windows.
12:33This man,
12:34whom they all knew well,
12:35was in fact a spy.
12:39In the FBI offices,
12:40David could not withstand the pressure
12:42and readily admitted his guilt.
12:47David Greenglass confessed theft of the secrets
12:49while stationed at the Los Alamos atomic project.
12:54Since the FBI were threatening
12:56to charge his wife for being an accomplice,
12:59David went further
13:00and accepted an agreement.
13:02Immunity for Ruth
13:03and a shorter punishment for him
13:05if he gave up some names.
13:08Without a shred of remorse,
13:10he denounced his brother-in-law.
13:12He accused Julius
13:13of having recruited him
13:14to spy on behalf of the Soviet Union.
13:19FBI agents turned up
13:21at the Rosenbergs' small apartment
13:23at 10 Monroe Street
13:24and conducted a thorough search.
13:30Ethel, now mother to two small boys,
13:32watched in horror
13:33as her husband was escorted away
13:35by the dreaded government men.
13:37cameras focused on Julius.
13:50In his impeccable suit,
13:51he could have easily passed
13:52for just another Wall Street traitor,
13:55a far cry from the fantasy
13:56of what a red spy should look like.
13:58On the contrary,
13:59this ordinary man's appearance
14:01helped feed the paranoia
14:02that a fifth column
14:03had infiltrated the whole country.
14:07After the initial shock,
14:14Ethel pulled herself together
14:15and decided to do everything
14:16in her power
14:17to help Julius.
14:22An improvised press conference
14:24took place in their kitchen.
14:26She tirelessly repeated
14:28to the journalists,
14:29no, my husband is not a spy.
14:31But she added this unfortunate phrase,
14:35Neither Julius nor I
14:36have ever been communists,
14:37nor do we know any.
14:40Why did she lie?
14:41Was it fear she was governed by?
14:43Because the events happening
14:44on the other side of the world
14:46did not spell good news for them.
14:55The U.S. had just sent troops
14:56to support South Korea,
14:58but barely had they set foot
15:00on Asian soil
15:00when thousands of their soldiers
15:02were killed
15:03by North Korean communist forces,
15:05backed by the Soviet Union
15:07and Mao's China.
15:099,600 United Nations prisoners
15:11have been wantonly murdered
15:12by Chinese Reds
15:14since their entry into the war,
15:162,500 of them Americans.
15:19For Americans
15:20and for President Truman,
15:22the specter of a third world war
15:24was becoming a real threat.
15:26Our homes,
15:28our nation,
15:30all the things we believe in
15:31are in great danger.
15:34This danger has been created
15:36by the rulers
15:37of the Soviet Union.
15:39This is the real meaning
15:41of the events
15:42that have been taking place
15:43in Korea.
15:45Even thousands of kilometers away,
15:47the Korean War
15:48was sure to have
15:49terrible repercussions
15:50on Julius' fate.
15:53The distraught Ethel
15:54wrote to her husband
15:55every day.
15:58My darling,
15:58I love you.
16:00I miss you,
16:01and I can't wait
16:02for Sunday
16:02when I can see you
16:04in prison.
16:06I still can't believe it.
16:11Love from your two sons
16:12who never stop asking for you.
16:14However,
16:17the worst was yet to come.
16:20On August 11, 1950,
16:22a month after Julius' arrest,
16:24Ethel was summoned
16:25to appear before the grand jury
16:26as the wife of a spy.
16:29At least,
16:30that's what she thought.
16:32No sooner had she descended
16:34the courthouse steps
16:35when two FBI agents
16:37grabbed her arm
16:37and announced
16:38that she was under arrest.
16:40At the FBI HQ,
16:47flashbulbs went off.
16:51After being measured,
16:53her fingerprints were taken.
16:56And just like her husband,
16:57bail was fixed
16:58at $100,000.
17:00This was an astronomical sum
17:02for a couple
17:03on a modest income.
17:04Ethel was taken the same day
17:12to the women's penitentiary
17:13in Greenwich Village.
17:15She was on the ninth floor
17:17in a cell overlooking
17:18such a noisy avenue
17:19that she was unable to sleep.
17:27My dear Julius,
17:29you need to know
17:30what's happened to me
17:31and why I'm writing
17:32to you from prison.
17:32My darling,
17:34I'd like to be able
17:35to tell you
17:35that I'm calm
17:36and collected,
17:38but I've been crying
17:39my eyes out.
17:40I wasn't even able
17:41to organize anything
17:42for the children.
17:45Michael and Robert
17:46were looked after
17:47by Ethel's mother,
17:48Tessie.
17:49It was a disaster.
17:51The two boys
17:52were terrified
17:52and upset
17:53and Tessie
17:54was not a patient woman.
17:57She did not care
17:58for them for long
17:59and decided
17:59to abandon them
18:00at the local Jewish home.
18:02Tessie unashamedly
18:08went to visit
18:08her daughter in prison.
18:11She ordered her
18:12to divorce her husband
18:13and cooperate
18:14with the government
18:15to help free
18:16her brother David
18:16from the hell
18:17he was going through.
18:19As the older sister,
18:21it was her role
18:22and responsibility
18:23to save him.
18:24The man who took
18:30the risk
18:31of defending Ethel,
18:32Emmanuel Bloch,
18:33was not a criminal lawyer
18:34and he had almost
18:35no experience
18:36of trials.
18:37As for his father,
18:38Alexander,
18:39who defended Julius,
18:40he was specialized
18:41in store sales.
18:43These two lawyers
18:44clearly did not have
18:45what it took
18:46to handle
18:46a case of espionage.
18:47The conditions
18:53for the defense
18:53were not ideal,
18:54but the interviews
18:55with their lawyers
18:56enabled Julius and Ethel
18:57to be reunited.
19:04The journalists
19:05were quick
19:05to immortalize
19:06the couple's kiss
19:07inside the prison van
19:08and it became
19:10the iconic image
19:11of the case.
19:12On March 6, 1951,
19:19after eight months
19:20of investigation,
19:21the trial began.
19:23News from the first day
19:24was broadcast
19:25across America.
19:26One of the greatest
19:27peacetime spy dramas
19:29in the nation's history
19:30rages its climax.
19:34The Rosenbergs
19:35emerged from the van
19:36at 10 a.m.
19:38The husband
19:38was handcuffed,
19:39but as an indulgence,
19:40the wife's hands
19:42were free.
19:52Julius seemed calm
19:54and elegant
19:54in his dark overcoat.
19:57Ethel attempted
19:57to smile for the cameras.
19:59Despite both their efforts
20:01to soften public opinion,
20:02journalists pointed
20:03to the coldness
20:04of the husband,
20:05while others
20:06were convinced
20:06that their deathly eyes
20:08were the mark
20:08of true spies.
20:10The hearing
20:15was opened
20:15by Judge Kaufman.
20:17He happened
20:18to be a personal friend
20:19of FBI Director Hoover,
20:21a fact he'd never
20:22kept hidden.
20:28A third person
20:29was sitting in the dock
20:30along with the couple.
20:32On Ethel's left,
20:33Morton Sobel,
20:34Julius's best friend,
20:35who allegedly
20:36recruited him
20:37as an informer.
20:40The Attorney General
20:42Saple,
20:42known for being
20:43the terror
20:44of the Reds,
20:45opened proceedings.
20:47Ethel and Julius Rosenberg,
20:49you are accused
20:50of having participated
20:51in a carefully
20:52planned conspiracy
20:54aimed at providing
20:55the Soviet Union
20:56with intelligence
20:57and weapons
20:58which that country
20:59could use
20:59to destroy us.
21:00The Attorney General
21:07and his deputies
21:08were determined
21:09to obtain
21:09the death sentence
21:10and even bragged
21:12to journalists
21:12about it
21:13outside the courtroom.
21:15Saple continued,
21:16We will prove
21:17that the Rosenbergs
21:19put into place
21:19a complex plan
21:21which enabled them,
21:22through the intermediary
21:23of David Greenglass,
21:24to steal
21:25the atomic bomb.
21:32But how could
21:33this seemingly
21:33innocuous couple
21:35be guilty
21:35of being atomic spies?
21:38Ultimately,
21:39this was the simple question
21:40that the jury
21:41would have to answer.
21:52On the fourth day
21:53of proceedings,
21:53David Greenglass,
21:54Ethel's brother,
21:55appeared in court.
22:02Julius boasted
22:03about having contacts
22:04with scientists
22:04in every state.
22:06They would drop
22:07envelopes full of
22:08secret documents
22:09into his hiding places.
22:12Julius would pick up
22:13the mail,
22:14microfilm the documents,
22:15and then hand them
22:16directly to his
22:16Russian agent.
22:23Without once glancing
22:25at his sister,
22:26David continued
22:27to answer
22:27the prosecution's
22:28questions
22:28and dug
22:29the Rosenbergs' grave
22:30a little deeper
22:31by the minute.
22:34When I was called
22:35up to Los Alamos,
22:36I told my brother-in-law
22:37about the nature
22:38of my work.
22:42Julius kept telling me
22:43that the USSR
22:43had a vital need
22:45for scientific information
22:46and he believed
22:46that the atomic bomb
22:47should be shared.
22:48He asked me
22:54to pay attention
22:55and gather any
22:55information that I could.
23:03The proceedings
23:04took on another dimension
23:05when Exhibit 2
23:07was shown to the jury.
23:11A sketch by David
23:13based on the same model
23:14as those he'd observed
23:15at Los Alamos.
23:18Was it credible?
23:21David had never been
23:22an engineer,
23:23but a mechanic.
23:25Nevertheless,
23:26the sketch made
23:26a strong impression.
23:28And there was more.
23:30Another Exhibit
23:31induced panic.
23:34The cross-sectional diagram
23:36of the Nagasaki
23:37atomic bomb.
23:40David explained.
23:42During one of my periods
23:44of leave in New York,
23:45I handed over
23:46the sketch to Julius,
23:47and had also written up
23:48notes on everything
23:49I'd noticed
23:49at Los Alamos.
23:51But my handwriting
23:52was illegible.
23:53Julius suggested
23:54that Ethel
23:54should type up my notes,
23:56just like she did
23:57with all his other reports
23:58he gave to the Russians.
23:59With this latest revelation,
24:09David transformed his sister
24:10into an active spy.
24:13Up until then,
24:14she had just been
24:15the wife of a spy
24:16whom she'd protected
24:17with her silence.
24:20The journalists
24:21had made up their minds.
24:22A brother could not
24:23betray a sister
24:24who had virtually
24:25brought him up,
24:26unless there wasn't
24:27some grain of truth.
24:28On the seventh day
24:35of the hearings,
24:36it was the turn
24:37of David's wife,
24:38Ruth,
24:39completely recovered
24:39from her burns,
24:40to take the stand.
24:42The murmurings
24:43in the gallery
24:44turned into a hubbub.
24:47Surely this witness
24:48should be in the dock, too.
24:50But since she was sure
24:51of the deal
24:52that had been made
24:52with the FBI,
24:53she didn't downplay
24:54the degree
24:55to which she had helped.
24:56She was convinced
24:57she would remain free.
25:01When my husband
25:02was called up
25:03to Los Alamos,
25:04I moved as close
25:05as I could
25:05to the atomic site.
25:08Julius wanted me
25:09to spy for him as well.
25:13I was supposed
25:14to meet a liaison officer
25:15and hand over documents.
25:20As a way
25:21of recognizing each other,
25:23Julius had torn
25:24the side of a food carton
25:25in half.
25:26Each part
25:27was supposed
25:27to fit together
25:28like two pieces
25:29of a puzzle.
25:31On the agreed day,
25:32our liaison officer
25:33turned up
25:34with the missing torn part.
25:35We showed him
25:36the other part.
25:39Trust was established
25:40and we could hand over
25:42the latest secrets
25:43that David had stolen.
25:44It was now time
25:50for the Rosenberg's defense.
25:53As soon as
25:53the questioning began,
25:55Emmanuel, the lawyer,
25:56went straight
25:57to the heart
25:57of the matter.
26:00Do you owe allegiance
26:01to any other country?
26:03No, I do not.
26:04Have you any
26:05divided allegiance?
26:07I do not.
26:08Would you fight
26:09for this country?
26:11Yes, I will.
26:12If it were engaged
26:13in a war
26:14with any other country?
26:15Yes, I felt
26:16that the Soviet government
26:17has improved
26:18a lot of the underdog there.
26:19At the same time,
26:20I felt that they
26:21contributed a major share
26:22in destroying
26:23the Hitler beast
26:24who killed six million
26:25of my co-religionists
26:26and I feel emotional
26:27about that thing.
26:30Julius's replies
26:31were not just brave.
26:33They were above all naive
26:34because he'd underestimated
26:37the extent of anti-communism.
26:42Then came Ethel's turn
26:44to testify.
26:46On Monday, March 26th,
26:47a journalist penned
26:48this cruel profile of her.
26:51It's difficult to imagine
26:52that this slightly overweight,
26:54ordinary-looking woman
26:55could be involved
26:56in something as exciting
26:58as espionage
26:59because she looks
27:00as appetizing
27:01as a stodgy pudding.
27:02On the advice of her lawyer,
27:05Ethel pleaded
27:06the Fifth Amendment,
27:07which meant
27:07she couldn't
27:08incriminate herself.
27:10In response
27:10to the prosecutor's question
27:12have you ever been
27:12a member of the Communist Party,
27:14Ethel declared,
27:15I refuse to reply
27:16because it might
27:17damage my defense.
27:21This defense strategy
27:22was almost certainly clumsy,
27:24for it did Ethel
27:25no favors
27:26with either the public
27:26or the press.
27:27This was not the case
27:33for the following witness.
27:35Elizabeth Bentley,
27:35a former spy,
27:37was now working
27:37for the FBI
27:38and was a regular
27:39prosecution witness
27:40at Communist trials.
27:46She took advantage
27:47of these hearings
27:48to promote her autobiography
27:49of a repentant spy.
27:51In the witness box,
27:56she had no special revelations
27:57except to say
27:58that all American communists
28:00were committed
28:00to spy for the Soviets.
28:04Well,
28:04I think they're
28:05the usual activities
28:06for a communist member
28:09of participating
28:10in picket lines,
28:11helping in strikes,
28:15going on demonstrations
28:18to help the unemployed
28:19or to other outfits
28:22who were demonstrating.
28:24Nor did she recognize
28:25the faces of the Rosenbergs.
28:27However,
28:27at the end of her evidence,
28:29she did claim
28:29that she'd gone
28:30to their neighborhood
28:30to drop off an envelope
28:32for an engineer
28:33called Julius.
28:34For the press,
28:38this was overwhelming proof.
28:41That's correct.
28:47After 24 hours
28:48of deliberation,
28:49the jurors
28:50were in agreement.
28:56We, the jury,
28:58declare Julius
29:00and Ethel Rosenberg
29:01guilty as charged.
29:06At that precise moment,
29:08the couple
29:08didn't even blink an eye.
29:11In the public gallery,
29:12packed with people
29:13curious for the verdict,
29:14crude and angry
29:15shouts rang out.
29:16Before announcing the sentence,
29:25Judge Kaufman
29:26sought advice
29:27from FBI Director Hoover.
29:30Surprisingly,
29:31the latter
29:31was not in favor
29:32of the death penalty
29:33for Ethel.
29:34Don't forget
29:35that this woman
29:35is mother
29:36to two young children,
29:37and her execution
29:39could affect people
29:40psychologically.
29:40Judge Kaufman
29:44ignored his advice.
29:47A month after
29:47the beginning
29:48of the trial
29:48on April 5, 1951,
29:50the judge declared,
29:51I consider that your crime
29:54is worse than murder.
29:57I believe
29:58that your conduct
29:59in placing the bomb
30:01in Russian hands
30:02brought about
30:03the communist assault
30:04in Korea
30:05and caused
30:06thousands of deaths.
30:08Your crime
30:08has altered
30:09the course of history
30:10and harmed
30:11our country.
30:12Julius Rosenberg
30:17is the chief
30:18instigator
30:19of this conspiracy.
30:21Ethel Rosenberg
30:22helped him,
30:24and since she's
30:24an adult
30:25three years older
30:26than her husband,
30:28she is an equal
30:29partner in this crime.
30:32After administering
30:33a tongue lashing
30:34in which he charged
30:35them with the indirect
30:36death of thousands
30:37of men in Korea,
30:38he sentenced
30:39both Rosenbergs
30:40to death
30:40in the electric chair,
30:41this was the first
30:46time in peacetime
30:47that spies
30:48had been sentenced
30:48to death.
30:51It was a
30:51disproportionate
30:52sentence,
30:53all the more so
30:54when compared
30:54to those handed
30:55out to the other
30:56defendants.
30:58Morton Sobel,
30:59who was allegedly
31:00recruited by Julius
31:01and therefore
31:02an accomplice,
31:03had refused
31:04to testify
31:04in the trial.
31:06He was given
31:06a 30-year prison
31:07sentence.
31:08Confident of his
31:09agreement with the FBI,
31:11David assumed
31:11he would
31:11get a year's prison
31:12at most.
31:14He was disappointed.
31:16Even though he
31:16escaped the death
31:17penalty and his
31:18wife walked free,
31:19he would still get
31:2015 years behind bars.
31:27As the prison-band
31:28doors shut behind
31:29Ethel and Julius,
31:30Emmanuel stood
31:31on the courtroom
31:32steps in front
31:32of an array
31:33of microphones.
31:35He strongly
31:36reaffirmed the
31:36innocence of his
31:37clients and maintained
31:38that they'd been
31:38victims of political
31:40hysteria.
31:41His fight to save
31:43the Rosenbergs
31:43was not over.
31:45The President of the
31:46United States...
31:47As if this sentence
31:53wasn't horrific enough,
31:55Ethel was transferred
31:56from her prison
31:56in Greenwich Village
31:57to Sing Sing,
31:58a dreadful penitentiary.
32:03The women's quarters
32:04were empty.
32:06The only company
32:06she had
32:07were four female
32:08wardens
32:09who took turns
32:10in keeping an eye
32:11on her.
32:15Was this a form
32:16of psychological torture
32:18inflicted on Ethel
32:19so that she would
32:19break
32:20and give up the names
32:21of other spies?
32:22After all,
32:23while she was still alive,
32:24there was leverage
32:25to be had.
32:32Julius was not
32:33given the same
32:33treatment.
32:34He was left
32:35in his Manhattan
32:35prison,
32:36where he went
32:37about his days
32:37as best he could,
32:39reading the newspapers,
32:40playing chess
32:40with other prisoners,
32:41and chasing the
32:42cockroaches crawling
32:43all over his bed.
32:47He told his wife
32:48that he'd also
32:49developed a passion
32:49for a brand-new
32:50occupation.
32:54I've started
32:55smoking furiously.
32:57Just imagine,
32:59I'm on more
32:59than a packet a day.
33:00I've become
33:01surprisingly good
33:02at flicking the stubs
33:03expertly into the sink.
33:08These small details
33:09were intended
33:10by Julius
33:11to bring a smile
33:11to Ethel's face,
33:13for he understood
33:13her isolation.
33:18So as not
33:18to abandon his wife,
33:19Julius requested
33:20a transfer
33:21to Sing Sing.
33:22He was granted
33:23this unusual favor
33:24which no prisoner
33:25had ever
33:25previously asked for.
33:28In contrast
33:29to his wife,
33:30he was not alone.
33:32There were dozens
33:32of men like him
33:33on death row.
33:37But that evening,
33:38all that mattered
33:38was not the other prisoners,
33:40nor the concreted steel
33:41that separated
33:42their quarters.
33:43That evening,
33:44the Rosenberg couple
33:45slept under
33:46the same roof.
33:47The prison director
33:55even allowed them
33:56to meet up
33:56every Wednesday morning.
34:01A cage was brought
34:02in which Julius
34:03was locked up
34:04and placed outside
34:05his wife's cell.
34:08They could only
34:09look at each other
34:09through two rows
34:10of bars,
34:11gauging each other's
34:12solitude.
34:13Ethel wrote,
34:18My own dear
34:18sweetheart,
34:19what heaven
34:20and what hell
34:21to welcome you
34:22to monotonous days
34:23and joyless nights.
34:27How unhappy
34:28I am
34:29to be sitting
34:29opposite you,
34:30unable to touch
34:31your face.
34:33Your lonely wife.
34:35Julius replied,
34:36My precious woman.
34:38It was so good
34:39to see you
34:40this afternoon.
34:41I wanted to take
34:41you in my arms,
34:42smother you in kisses,
34:43and convey to you
34:44in more than just words
34:45my consuming love
34:46for you.
34:50If the Rosenbergs
34:51are executed...
34:52Meanwhile,
34:53the lawyer,
34:53Emanuel Block,
34:54had been busy.
34:56He lodged an appeal
34:57against the sentence,
34:58seeking a stay
34:59of execution.
34:59For the sake
35:02of American tradition,
35:04prestige,
35:05and influence,
35:07urge redress
35:09for Rosenbergs.
35:13Demand you be
35:14afforded sufficient time
35:16to consider
35:17this serious matter.
35:19The Rosenbergs
35:21clung to this faint hope
35:22and counted down
35:23the days
35:24until their next
35:25Wednesday meeting.
35:28Finally,
35:29the children
35:30were permitted
35:30to visit.
35:31Reporters,
35:35always quick
35:36on the scene,
35:36filmed the lawyer
35:37Emanuel Block
35:38with Michael
35:38and Robert
35:39almost happily
35:40making their way
35:41into Sing Sing.
35:45The prisoner director
35:46didn't allow
35:47both parents
35:48to meet the children
35:48together.
35:50This time,
35:50they only saw
35:51their mother.
35:55It had been
35:56almost a year
35:57since she'd seen
35:57her boys,
35:58and as she wrote
35:59to Julius that evening,
36:01For a first visit,
36:03after a year's separation,
36:04one can hardly expect
36:05to do more
36:06than just to break
36:07the ice.
36:10Between several
36:11awkward hugs,
36:12she felt duty-bound
36:13to tell the children
36:14of the sentence.
36:17Ethel and her husband
36:18had been firm
36:19about this.
36:20Michael and Robert
36:20had to hear directly
36:22from them
36:22what was going to happen.
36:23On leaving
36:30the penitentiary,
36:31the boys were mobbed
36:32once again
36:32by photographers.
36:43They put on
36:44a brave face,
36:45perhaps because
36:46Emanuel Block
36:47had whispered
36:47something reassuring
36:48that he was still
36:49hoping for.
36:51I will do
36:51everything I can
36:52to save your parents.
36:58Ethel and Julius
36:59decided to keep
37:00all the letters
37:01that they wrote
37:01and asked their lawyer
37:02to make an album
37:03of them.
37:05You never know,
37:06these exchanges
37:07might come in use.
37:12Block did everything
37:13in his power
37:13to get their letters
37:14published,
37:15and he managed it
37:17as a selection
37:17of them appeared
37:18in the newspapers.
37:19The lawyer
37:25hadn't been
37:26particularly inspiring
37:27during the trial,
37:28but was determined
37:29to fight to the end
37:30and pull out
37:31all the stops
37:32in the legal proceedings.
37:37First,
37:38he appealed
37:38on the grounds
37:39that Judge Kaufman
37:39hadn't been impartial
37:41and hadn't prevented
37:42accusations of communism
37:43from interfering
37:44in the trial.
37:45Thanks to Block,
37:48opinions shifted
37:48and supporters
37:49of the couple
37:50felt emboldened
37:51to make their voices heard.
37:53However,
37:54among the pro-Rosenbergs,
37:56not everyone agreed.
37:58Some were convinced
37:59that the trial
37:59had been a travesty
38:00of justice,
38:01while others believed
38:02that Ethel and Julius
38:03were indeed guilty,
38:04but should not face
38:05the death penalty.
38:11A support committee
38:12was quickly set up.
38:14The headquarters
38:15was registered
38:15in a tiny office
38:17on 246th Fifth Avenue.
38:19The aim was to raise
38:21a maximum amount
38:22of money
38:22to fund the appeal proceedings.
38:25Initially,
38:25there were just
38:26a few hundred members.
38:30At the beginning
38:31of 1952,
38:32this support
38:33carried little weight
38:34for the anti-Rosenbergs
38:35were far more numerous
38:36and very vociferous.
38:48Ethel trembled
38:49as she listened
38:50on a small wireless
38:51to the court
38:52of appeals decision.
38:54She hurriedly
38:55wrote to Julius.
38:57My darling,
38:59I've just heard
39:00the terrible news.
39:01I don't know
39:02what to say,
39:03except to express
39:04the horror I feel
39:05at the haste
39:06with which the government
39:07seems to want
39:08to send us
39:08to our deaths.
39:12Julius replied,
39:15Dearest wife,
39:16we must soberly realize
39:19that our only hope
39:20rests with the people
39:21and that they be aroused
39:23to stop this legal lynching.
39:25He added,
39:27Keep singing and punching,
39:29my wonderful girl.
39:30Julius knew
39:34that her passion
39:35had never left her.
39:39Morning and night,
39:40Ethel sang
39:40to an audience
39:41of one,
39:43her warden.
39:43While this was happening,
39:58a new protagonist
40:12entered the fray
40:14and transformed
40:15hundreds of supporters
40:16into several hundred thousand.
40:19The Communist Party,
40:20which up to then
40:20had been conspicuous
40:21by its absence,
40:23not wanting to be associated
40:24with potential spies,
40:26finally came
40:26to the Rosenbergs' rescue.
40:30World communism
40:31set up an organized demonstration
40:32against the sentence.
40:35Demonstrations
40:35that erupted
40:36into violence
40:37kept the police
40:37on their toes
40:38in the days
40:38that followed the sentencing.
40:39The Rosenberg case
40:40had become
40:41a cause celebre
40:41in every communist cell
40:43around the earth.
40:43The Save the Rosenbergs movement
40:54grew and grew.
40:56People marched.
40:57Their letters
40:58were read out at rallies.
41:00Some women even tried
41:01to enter Sing Sing
41:01on Mother's Day
41:02in an act of support
41:04for Ethel.
41:04The communists
41:06were not the only
41:07protesters
41:08in the uproar
41:08raised by the two spies' conviction.
41:10Famous and respected men
41:11such as Albert Einstein
41:12put their signatures
41:13to petitions
41:14demanding a new trial.
41:19Demonstrations
41:20in their favor
41:21sprang up
41:21all over the world.
41:23The Vatican
41:24had received
41:24appeals for clemency
41:25and conveyed them
41:26to Washington.
41:30Support committees
41:31were set up
41:31in England,
41:32Israel,
41:33Italy,
41:33and Germany.
41:35In France,
41:36personalities
41:36such as
41:37Simone de Beauvoir,
41:38Jean-Paul Sartre,
41:39and Simone Signoret
41:40spoke out
41:41against the sentence.
41:44However,
41:45none of this agitation
41:46bore fruit.
41:48The Supreme Court
41:49refused to take up
41:50the case.
41:52The only remaining hope
41:53was a presidential pardon.
41:59November 1952
42:01and Harry Truman
42:02was coming to the end
42:03of his term of office.
42:04He left the ball
42:05in the court
42:06of his successor.
42:07I, Dwight D. Eisenhower,
42:09do solemnly swear
42:10that you will...
42:12The Rosenbergs' fate
42:13was in the hands
42:14of the new president,
42:15Eisenhower.
42:16...president of the United States.
42:21A huge, endless vigil
42:23began outside
42:24the main entrance
42:24to the White House.
42:25A month later,
42:30camps had even been set up
42:31on the Capitol lawn.
42:37Eisenhower could no longer
42:39ignore the fate
42:40of the Rosenbergs,
42:41even if he had wanted to.
42:43He made his decision
42:44and unfortunately,
42:46it was not in favor
42:47of Ethel and Julius.
42:48Julius, the president
42:49confirmed the judge's sentence.
42:56Up until then,
42:57Julius's mother,
42:58Sophie,
42:59had remained
42:59on the sidelines,
43:01worn down by age
43:02and illness.
43:03But at the thought
43:04of her son's tragic fate,
43:06she decided to fight back
43:07and join the demonstrations
43:09in New York.
43:10Then she bravely
43:12took up her pen
43:13and wrote to the First Lady
43:15of the USA.
43:19Mrs. Dwight D. Eisenhower,
43:21I turn to you
43:22in my deep grief
43:23and implore you
43:24to intercede
43:25with President Eisenhower
43:26to grant mercy
43:28to my beloved children.
43:29I beg of you
43:30to act for an old woman
43:32whose days are spent
43:33in weeping.
43:40In a last-ditch effort,
43:43she decided
43:43to travel
43:44with her grandchildren
43:44from New York
43:45to Washington
43:46to protest
43:47outside the Capitol building.
43:50At the entrance
43:51to the White House,
43:52Michael and Robert
43:53handed a guard
43:54a letter addressed
43:55to Eisenhower.
43:57Dear Mr. President,
43:59please don't leave
44:00my brother and I
44:00without a mommy
44:01and daddy.
44:02The boys were on
44:10tenterhooks
44:10for the President's reply,
44:12but for a second time,
44:13Eisenhower refused.
44:17The President was adamant
44:18that justice
44:19had done its job,
44:21and just like
44:21Judge Kaufman before him,
44:23he believed that Ethel
44:24was the dominant partner
44:25and the leader
44:26of the spy ring.
44:28The date of the execution
44:30was finally fixed
44:31for June 19, 1953.
44:33That is two years
44:34after the end
44:35of the trial.
44:39Emmanuel Block
44:40had run out of ideas
44:41for Ethel and Julius.
44:42He had tried
44:43to buy time,
44:44a day,
44:45a few hours.
44:49I requested
44:50the President
44:51of the United States
44:52to defer
44:54the execution
44:55of the Rosenbergs,
44:56which was scheduled
44:57for tonight
44:58at 11 o'clock
45:00until at least
45:03the Sabbath
45:04had passed.
45:07The Sabbath,
45:08as you may know,
45:11is the holiday
45:13observed by the Jews.
45:16The prison director replied,
45:18In that case,
45:20we shall bring forward
45:21their execution
45:22to 8 p.m.
45:23before the beginning
45:24of the Sabbath.
45:33On June 19,
45:34journalists gathered
45:35all day long
45:36outside the Sing Sing
45:37prison gates.
45:40Only a select few
45:41had received accreditation
45:42to be present
45:43at the execution.
45:45On the other hand,
45:47several FBI agents
45:48entered the compound,
45:50still hoping
45:50that the condemned couple,
45:52in a last urge
45:53to escape the electorate chair,
45:55might give up some names.
45:56It was a battle of wits
46:03that the government
46:04and Hoover
46:04still thought
46:05they could win.
46:08Time passed,
46:10and journalists waited,
46:11as if the Rosenbergs' fate
46:12still hadn't been sealed.
46:19After spending
46:20their last day together,
46:22at 7.20 p.m.,
46:23Julius and Ethel
46:24said their final farewells.
46:27Still separated
46:28by prison bars,
46:29they were unable
46:30to embrace.
46:32Only words were spoken,
46:33which no one
46:34would read this time.
46:47Night fell.
46:49The account of the execution
46:50was read out uneasily
46:51by two journalists,
46:53who could not have been
46:54prepared for it.
46:59All right.
47:03They died differently.
47:07Gave off different sounds.
47:10And they began,
47:12brought Julius in first
47:14at 8.02.
47:17They applied,
47:18placed immediately,
47:18put him in the chair.
47:19He showed no emotion
47:20when he came in,
47:21looked almost defiant.
47:22Three jolts,
47:30finished him,
47:32and in that time,
47:35he never said a word.
47:38Never looked like
47:39he wanted to say a word.
47:40It was less than five minutes
47:43then until they brought
47:45Ethel in.
47:46She appeared the same
47:48as he,
47:48showing no emotion
47:49whatsoever.
47:52At the last moment,
47:53however,
47:54she turned
47:55into the matron
47:56who's been with her
47:57all this time
47:57and shook her hand
47:59and then very impulsively
48:00leaned over
48:01and kissed her.
48:02Then they put her
48:04in the chair.
48:06She died a lot harder.
48:10When it appeared
48:10that she had received
48:11enough electricity
48:13to kill an ordinary person
48:15and had received
48:16the exact amount
48:17that had killed
48:17her husband,
48:19the doctors went over
48:20and pulled down
48:21the cheap prison dress,
48:24placed the stethoscopes
48:25to her
48:28and seemed surprised
48:29that she was not dead.
48:32And she was given
48:33more electricity,
48:34which
48:34smoke that rose
48:37from her head
48:38and went up
48:41against the
48:41skylight
48:43overhead.
48:53In the streets,
48:54the demonstrators
48:56were no longer
48:57able to hold back
48:58their tears.
49:03The next day,
49:04the photos
49:05of the Rosenberg couple
49:06in their open coffins
49:07were splashed
49:08across the front pages.
49:10Julius was unrecognizable
49:11without his famous mustache.
49:14Ethel had a bandage
49:15over the top of her head
49:16to hide the burns
49:17caused by the
49:18electrode helmet.
49:24cameras were also present
49:29to witness the burials
49:30in the Jewish cemetery
49:32in Wellwood,
49:33an hour west of New York.
49:36The couple were buried
49:37side by side.
49:41Hundreds of people
49:42attended the ceremony.
49:48One figure stood out
49:49from the rest,
49:51Julius's mother howling
49:52in grief
49:52in the arms
49:53of lawyer
49:54Emanuel Bloch.
50:02Only one person
50:03was missing,
50:04Ethel's mother.
50:05Tessie had not
50:06wanted to go,
50:07giving the excuse
50:08to the FBI
50:08that her daughter
50:09had been nothing
50:10but an agent
50:10of Stalin.
50:11At the ages of 10 and 6,
50:16Michael and Robert
50:16were now orphans.
50:19A childless couple,
50:20Anne and Abel Maripole,
50:21both teachers,
50:22adopted them.
50:24The boys had finally
50:25found a loving home.
50:29Less than a year
50:30after the execution
50:31of his clients
50:32and friends,
50:32Emanuel Bloch
50:33died of a heart attack
50:34at only 51 years old.
50:36In 1960,
50:41David Greenglass,
50:42Ethel's brother,
50:43was released from prison,
50:44having served 10 years
50:45instead of 15.
50:48Lift your hat a little bit.
50:50No.
50:50Would you have to lift
50:51his hat and look
50:51at the cameras,
50:52please,
50:52so we can see him.
50:53Lift your hat a little bit,
50:54Mr. Greenglass,
50:55please.
50:57Will there be any
50:57future statements?
50:59No, there will be
51:02no further statement
51:03other than the one
51:04that I have made.
51:05Honest to you,
51:06doesn't he want
51:06to make a statement?
51:07Mr. Greenglass,
51:08do you want to say
51:09anything on your own?
51:11All right, gentlemen,
51:12come at it.
51:14Thank you, Mr. Rogers.
51:15The story could have
51:16ended there.
51:20In 1995,
51:22the American intelligence
51:23agencies declassified
51:25part of their archives.
51:27The Venona project
51:28was made public.
51:30The truth
51:30could finally come out.
51:33During the war,
51:34the U.S. succeeded
51:35in decrypting
51:36Soviet communications.
51:39In these transcriptions,
51:413,000 messages
51:42had been intercepted
51:43and among them,
51:46the proof
51:46of Julius' guilt.
51:50He appeared
51:51under the code name
51:52Liberal
51:53as a recruiter
51:54of spies
51:55and supplier
51:55of secret documents
51:56to Soviet agents.
51:57As for his brother-in-law,
52:01David,
52:01he was known
52:02as Caliber
52:02and Ruth
52:04went by the name
52:05of Asa.
52:07Ethel
52:08appeared under
52:08her real name
52:09for she was only
52:10the wife of a spy
52:11and wasn't part
52:12of the network.
52:15David had accused
52:16her unjustly
52:17to save his own skin
52:19and that of his wife.
52:21What was worse,
52:22the FBI knew
52:23that Ethel
52:24was innocent
52:24and had even hoped
52:25that she would
52:26get Julius to talk
52:27or would denounce him.
52:30Despite all
52:31the agent's skills
52:32and the secret evidence
52:33they had at their disposal,
52:34what the FBI
52:35could not have imagined
52:36was that Julius
52:38was convinced
52:39that the public
52:39would save him.
52:41As for Ethel,
52:42she would never
52:43have betrayed her husband.
52:45She loved him too much.
52:46Let historian Paul Merton
52:50be your guide
52:51next on PBS America
52:52as he sets off
52:54on grand tours
52:55of the Scottish Isles
52:56whilst uncovering
52:58the past
52:58and its connections
52:59with the present.
53:16God bless you.
53:20Amen.
53:20Amen.
53:22Amen.
53:23Amen.
53:23Amen.
53:24Amen.
53:25Amen.
53:25Amen.