• 1 year ago
Charlie Kirk, Charlie Kirk news, Charlie Kirk killing, Charlie Kirk death, Charlie Kirk assassination, Charlie Kirk shot, Charlie Kirk latest news, Charlie Kirk America, Charlie Kirk political violence, Charlie Kirk breaking news, Charlie Kirk Utah shooting, Charlie Kirk Turning Point USA, Charlie Kirk conservative leader, Charlie Kirk politics, Charlie Kirk update, Charlie Kirk killed, Charlie Kirk murder, Charlie Kirk US news, Charlie Kirk tragedy, Charlie Kirk Americast, BBC Americast Charlie Kirk, Americast podcast, BBC news Americast, Americast latest, BBC Americast analysis, BBC Americast episode, Americast podcast today, Americast new episode, BBC Americast Charlie Kirk killing, US political violence, America dangerous moment, US democracy crisis, America polarization, US political division, America in crisis, US political assassination, violence in America, American politics crisis, US democracy under threat, America dangerous, political turmoil US, America violence, US security issues, political assassination America, American democracy danger, US extremism, rising violence US, America dangerous moment 2025, BBC news podcast, Americast podcast episode, Americast discussion, Americast analysis, BBC Americast dangerous moment, Charlie Kirk Americast analysis, America future politics, America divided, political crisis USA, America dangerous politics, Americast latest episode, BBC world news podcast, US breaking news, America breaking point, US democracy danger, America at risk, US security danger, political threats America, assassination news USA, political killing America, America instability, US leadership crisis, American politics danger, US violence crisis, BBC Americast latest news, Americast US politics, Americast full episode, BBC Americast listen, Americast Charlie Kirk episode, Americast democracy danger, America violence news, US election danger, America threat, US society violence, America divided nation, dangerous America, Americast BBC news podcast, Americast America crisis, Charlie Kirk Americast episode, America unstable, Americast news analysis, BBC podcast Americast, Americast dangerous America, Americast democracy crisis.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00America is once again facing the horror of political violence.
00:03Charlie Kirk was not elected to any high office,
00:06but he was an enormously influential voice on the right of American politics.
00:11He was only 31 years old.
00:14He leaves behind him a wife and two young children.
00:17He was a friend of President Trump,
00:19and he did a huge amount to get President Trump elected for his second term.
00:24Welcome to AmeriCast.
00:28AmeriCast.
00:29AmeriCast from BBC News.
00:33Hello, it's Sarah here in the BBC's Washington Bureau.
00:37And it's Justin in the worldwide headquarters of AmeriCast in London, England.
00:40And it is Mariana sitting next to Justin in the worldwide headquarters.
00:44Only one subject to discuss today.
00:46Mariana, bring us up to date.
00:47Tell us what we know about what happened.
00:49So I'm sure that a lot of people who are listening to this episode, AmeriCasters,
00:53will have heard the news about Charlie Kirk.
00:55Charlie Kirk, who was 31 years old, was a very, very prominent conservative activist,
01:01social media influencer, media personality.
01:04He has a huge following online.
01:08His accounts, the accounts are just massive.
01:10And he was doing this tour around, he was starting this tour around different university campuses,
01:15because he's really well known for having debates with students about particular issues,
01:20people he doesn't agree with, people he agrees with.
01:22And he was at Utah Valley University yesterday, speaking inside a white tent when he was shot and killed.
01:30There are loads of very, very, very graphic clips of this, which, to be honest, have been quite hard to miss, really.
01:37And that are quite disturbing.
01:39And he was actually answering a question about mass shootings in America just moments before he was killed.
01:45He speaks quite a lot about things like gun rights, etc.
01:47And as ever, that means there's a huge vacuum in terms of people speculating about why this happened and how it happened and everything else.
01:54When you say right at the beginning, Marianne, he's a huge figure.
01:57You can't overestimate, actually, can you, his reach, really, among young Americans, the importance of him.
02:03I was talking to a congressman earlier today who said he thought,
02:08he actually thought that Donald Trump would not have won last time round without Charlie Kirk's help.
02:14So he was an extraordinary figure.
02:16He brought to Trump a load of young people who I don't think otherwise would have bothered to vote.
02:23He energized them.
02:24Some would say he radicalized them.
02:26But it's a much more varied thing, isn't it, than just the politics of him, because he had this podcast.
02:32And my daughter, Clara, the American citizen, very aware of him,
02:37actually knew about the attack on him and his death before I did.
02:41Friends of hers I was talking to, who are not American citizens, just young people in Britain in their 20s,
02:47an awful lot of people know about Charlie Kirk and feel whether they agree with him or not.
02:53And plenty, actually, who are aware of him don't necessarily agree with him,
02:57because he had some pretty extreme views and all sorts of things.
03:00But there is just this sense, exactly as you said, he was a talker.
03:05He was someone who wasn't just spouting off his own stuff and just putting it out there.
03:11He actually wanted to engage people.
03:14And it seems to me, isn't that right, Sarah, that that is the key to who he was and what he was trying to do?
03:20Oh, absolutely.
03:20And he was prolific.
03:22I mean, he was a broadcaster and a podcaster spreading this message.
03:26But at the same time, he was out there organizing youth groups and students,
03:30as well as taking part in live debates himself all of the time.
03:33And that was one of the things that he did.
03:35He said he would take on and debate anybody who wanted to come and disagree with him.
03:39So rather than being somebody who did exist in their own echo chamber,
03:43he was very much taking on debates from the left,
03:47people who had a different point of view and hashing that out.
03:51Now, as you say, there were a lot, a lot of people who didn't agree with him.
03:54But among those who think that he was absolutely material to Donald Trump being returned to the White House
03:58is Donald Trump himself and close members of his family and many important people in the administration.
04:04So they are in shock at the moment about this.
04:09I was at the White House yesterday when, firstly, when the news came in that he had been shocked
04:13and there were gasps around the place and people looking extremely worried about it.
04:19It became obvious quite quickly that the White House had a bit more information
04:22than was being released publicly yet and Donald Trump started referring to Charlie Kirk in the past tense
04:28before there had been an announcement about him actually having been killed.
04:33By the time that information was widely known, people were openly in tears, White House staff.
04:40And a lot of people then gathered on the north lawn to watch the flags over the White House
04:45being lowered to half-mast, which happened pretty quickly.
04:48And you could tell. There's always shock when there's a political killing like this.
04:54But this was sadness, grief and anger that was perpetrating the White House.
05:01And that is a measure of what a big figure Charlie Kirk was, but also what impact this might have.
05:06Yeah, I don't really think it's possible to overstate how influential someone like,
05:11well, how influential Charlie Kirk has been,
05:14because in lots of ways he's the pioneer of a certain type of blueprint
05:18for a certain type of political influencer or activist in the social media age.
05:23He started this group, Turning Point USA, when he was just 18.
05:27And the whole point of it was to spread conservative ideals,
05:31to talk about conservative issues, discussions,
05:36at what were considered liberal-leaning, left-leaning US colleges.
05:40And he absolutely, like Sarah said, is someone who has perhaps become best known
05:46for being willing to debate people, often on very, very controversial subjects.
05:51And I know that I always talk about the algorithms.
05:53In fact, it's almost as much as I talk about Elon Musk.
05:56But I think it is worth saying that one of the reasons why Charlie Kirk was so effective
06:00at what he did is because he was very, very good at getting that content,
06:05clips of him, clips from his podcast, promoted to people beyond the echo chamber as well,
06:11people who don't agree with you, because a lot of this is about outrage.
06:13It's often what we call sort of rage bait.
06:16And his positions, therefore, there are some people who really, really, really
06:19took serious offence to some of the positions he held, and others who liked them.
06:24Let's hear a few of those positions.
06:26Why I believe that abortion should be legal is because of instances like rape and incest.
06:30But I already know that your belief on that, because you've already stated that if your
06:33daughter were to be raped at 10 years old, you would make her give birth to the baby.
06:36Well, the baby would be delivered.
06:37And let me tell you why.
06:39And so, but first of all, let me try to find common ground.
06:41If I say we will make rape and incest abortions legal and get rid of all the other abortions,
06:46would you agree with that?
06:47Yeah.
06:48See, I don't believe that abortion should be used as a form of birth control.
06:51So 99% of the time it is.
06:52That's all that we're debating in the country right now.
06:54So Charlie Kirk's position is a very fringe minority.
06:57People are talking about still exceptions.
06:58So we should get rid of 99% of abortions.
07:00I'm a gay conservative.
07:02And I just want to kind of ask you, like, what do you have to say for people like me
07:06who kind of feel like, I guess, it's kind of hard for gay conservatives because there's
07:11not a lot of us.
07:12So like, what do you have to say to other gay people who need to realize like they do
07:15have a choice?
07:16Yeah.
07:16First of all, welcome to the conservative movement.
07:18I don't think you should introduce yourself just based on your, your sexual attractions.
07:22No, I agree.
07:22Because that's not who you are.
07:23I like to be thought of as a person.
07:25And for sure.
07:25You are a complete human being and I'm sure you treat people well.
07:28And you're studying something.
07:30So I want to get away with this idea that you're gay anything.
07:33I just think that we have gone a long way in the negative direction in this country where
07:37we act as if the most important part of your identity is what you do in the bedroom.
07:42It doesn't mean that much to me.
07:43But if you ask from a perspective as a Christian, I don't agree with that lifestyle.
07:47You will never live in a society when you have an armed citizenry and you won't have a single
07:52gun death.
07:52That is nonsense.
07:53It's drivel.
07:54But I am, I think it's, I think it's worth it.
07:58I think it's worth to have a cost of unfortunately some gun deaths every single year so that we
08:04can have the second amendment to protect our other God given rights.
08:07I'm sorry.
08:09If I see a black pilot, I'm going to be like, boy, I hope he's qualified.
08:12So like you right now should come out and be like, you know what?
08:15The young man who's about to win the state championship in the long jump in female sports,
08:20that shouldn't happen.
08:21You as the governor should step out and say no.
08:23No, and I appreciate.
08:25But like, would you do something like that?
08:26Would you say no men in female sports?
08:28Well, I think it's an issue of fairness.
08:29I completely agree with you on that.
08:30That actually, that last clip that we heard there was really fascinating because that
08:35was with Gavin Newsom.
08:36And Gavin Newsom, the governor of California, when he decided to do outreach to those who
08:41are the enemies of the Democrats, the first person he chose was Charlie Kirk.
08:47And for all that he's labeled by some as an extremist and all the rest of it, he felt that
08:52Charlie Kirk was the right person to come on his show and to defend, indeed to proselytize
08:59for the right wing point of view.
09:01And he, Gavin Newsom, would come up against him.
09:03And of course, that actual, that their discussion there caused quite a new stir because Newsom
09:08chose, I don't think it was forced out of him by Charlie Kirk, but Newsom chose that moment
09:12to say on this issue, Charlie Kirk, which is men in women's sports, he, Gavin Newsom,
09:19was willing to be persuaded by Charlie Kirk.
09:22Some AmeriCasters might be a little bit shocked by some of the things that he said in that montage
09:27because they're not part of mainstream debate in the UK, but they are, of course, talked
09:31about much, much more often in the US.
09:33And that's one of the things that Charlie Kirk did, was not just enthuse young people and
09:37get them involved and excited in politics, but he moved issues like what he's talking
09:42about on abortion, on race, into the mainstream argument.
09:47He was material in taking what were kind of fringe ideas about 10 years ago or something
09:54and turning them into mainstream political discourse, which, of course, allowed space
10:00for Donald Trump to come in and maximise that because he wasn't just somebody who disseminated
10:05a Trump message.
10:06He helped to shape that message.
10:08He took some of Donald Trump's more raw political instincts and had a way of honing them into
10:15something that was easier and better to communicate than Donald Trump himself sometimes articulates
10:21these things and spread them through the political debate, making them both acceptable, popular
10:27and thus paving the way for Donald Trump and very much certainly for his second term.
10:33And this is one of the reasons why he will be missed so very, very badly by people in the
10:37administration who are devastated by this and by people in the wider movement, because
10:42he was an intellectual of it all who both had his fingers on the pulse of the grassroots and
10:48could report that back to the White House and also take what Donald Trump wanted to do and
10:52help find a way of selling that.
10:55And that's almost certainly why Donald Trump sounded quite as angry as he did when he recorded
11:01a video in the Oval Office that he then put out last night.
11:05This is a dark moment for America.
11:09Charlie Kirk travelled the nation, joyfully engaging with everyone interested in good faith debate.
11:16His mission was to bring young people into the political process, which he did better than
11:22anybody ever, to share his love of country and to spread the simple words of common sense.
11:31On campuses nationwide, he championed his ideas with courage, logic, humor and grace.
11:37It's a long past time for all Americans and the media to confront the fact that violence and
11:44murder are the tragic consequence of demonizing those with whom you disagree day after day,
11:51year after year, in the most hateful and despicable way possible.
11:56For years, those on the radical left have compared wonderful Americans like Charlie to
12:02Nazis and the world's worst mass murderers and criminals.
12:07This kind of rhetoric is directly responsible for the terrorism that we're seeing in our
12:14country today.
12:15And it must stop right now.
12:18I was shocked when I watched the president doing that last night, because that is certainly
12:24not the message you normally get from top politicians at a time like this, when there has been this
12:29kind of political violence and atrocity.
12:31It's usually a moment of unity when everybody from all sides of the political debate come
12:36together and condemn political violence.
12:38And that's what was happening with every living former president put out a statement saying this
12:44is completely unacceptable.
12:45This is not who America is.
12:47It is undermining our democracy to have political violence like this.
12:51But not Donald Trump, who, of course, he was angry, but was demonizing part of the political
12:59debate, blaming them for Charlie Kirk's murder.
13:02And he then went on to list a number of other Republicans who've been attacked, referencing,
13:07of course, the attempt on his own life in Butler last year, which was absolutely terrible.
13:12Other right wingers who've been attacked.
13:15But he left off that list, the Minnesota lawmaker who was shot in her home with her husband a
13:22few months ago, another one who was attacked.
13:24He missed out the attack on Josh Shapiro, the Democrat governor's house in Pennsylvania.
13:31You know, he listed only people from the right who had been attacked and blamed the left for
13:35it.
13:36And I was I was genuinely worried that it sounded incendiary.
13:40And I think, Justin, we've we've had an email on this topic as well, haven't we?
13:43Yeah, it comes from Mike in Portsmouth, who says, I've just watched Trump's response to
13:49the Charlie Kirk shooting.
13:50He seems to be going full partisan rather than trying to calm the situation.
13:54He's pouring mountains of petrol on it.
13:56Can you have a mountain of petrol anyway?
13:59Yeah, he says Mike also says it's almost as if he's going to use it as an excuse to try
14:03and become ever more authoritarian, even more authoritarian than he was trying to become
14:08anyway.
14:09Am I reading it wrong?
14:10Mike asks.
14:11I hope so, because from where I'm sitting, the omens of that response are not good.
14:16I was thinking as well, just just to back up what you were saying, Sarah, as well, when
14:21we were listening to Charlie Kirk on the subject of abortion, it's not so much of a big deal
14:25now, is it?
14:26But certainly when I was doing your job, attacks on abortion clinics were a really big deal,
14:30attacks by people who regarded themselves as right wing and an abortion as a progressive
14:35left cause, which I suppose it generally is.
14:38And abortion rights as a progressive left cause.
14:41And it became, you know, when you go to an abortion clinic, as we all have done in our
14:46professional lives to go and talk to people, because it has been such an issue in American
14:51politics and culture recently, you know, there is security, there is real fear.
14:56And there were killings as well.
14:57I mean, there were murders.
14:59So it's not just that Minnesota case that you mentioned that is from this year.
15:02There is also a wider way in which if you are on the left, the kind of moderate left,
15:06you might say, well, hang on a second.
15:08Donald Trump should have mentioned exactly as Sarah said, Mary, and it should have mentioned
15:13a few other things as well.
15:14It's a little bit of a sort of chicken and egg situation here where you've got politicians,
15:20including the president, criticising what they perceive to be demonising and violent rhetoric
15:27from the left, which they feel could have contributed to the climate in which this happened.
15:30But then that seems to have further fuelled this really divisive rhetoric.
15:35So you've got Donald Trump speaking like this.
15:37You need only scroll on X.
15:38Obviously, there is a huge amount of grief, outpouring of support, upset for Charlie Kirk,
15:43his wife, his two little kids.
15:46But then there's also there's really violent language being used to kind of say, right,
15:51we need retribution.
15:52This is it.
15:52We've had enough.
15:54The left need to stop this.
15:55And then if you look on, for example, TikTok, which has got a bit of a different demographic
15:58to X, you've then got people on the left who are saying, well, hang on a second.
16:03You know, these kinds of influencers use violent rhetoric and the politicians do on the right.
16:07And this is the consequence of that.
16:08And it becomes this, you know, it further entrenches the polarisation, which people have said
16:13that they're worried about.
16:15Yeah.
16:15I just, Sarah, my feeling, I think you're exactly right in what you were saying about
16:19about what Trump said, but there is a sense, isn't there?
16:24And it's a reasonable sense that a lot of people on the right in America recently, including
16:31Donald Trump himself, have been targeted, called authoritarian, called fascist, called
16:38whatever.
16:39And that has somehow allowed a whole cohort of people.
16:44And it is often young people and it's often online.
16:46So maybe they don't quite mean it or whatever, to use incredibly violent rhetoric in a way
16:53that maybe they wouldn't have done in the past.
16:56I mean, I'm thinking, Sarah, about Luigi Mangione, the guy who's accused of killing that insurance
17:02executive in New York.
17:04People will remember he was shot in the street, got a wife and a young family.
17:09I mean, that death, I mean, it's not putting it too sharply to say it's been actually celebrated
17:15by some on the American left who say the insurance companies have got it coming to them and this
17:19individual had it coming to him, etc.
17:21There is a kind of nastiness there that, albeit I agree with you about Trump, generally speaking,
17:26but I mean, he is pointing at something that is real.
17:30Oh, he is.
17:30He is.
17:31Just because I'm saying he wasn't, he didn't reflect that it was happening on both sides
17:35doesn't mean that he hasn't put his finger on something about the vicious language that's
17:40used on both sides of the debate.
17:42But yes, people like Charlie Kirk are regularly being compared to Nazis and mass murderers.
17:48Luigi Mangione genuinely celebrated around the country by some people who think it was heroic
17:54to go up to a health care executive and murder them in the street.
18:00And when you have reached the point where people are applauding political violence, it's frightening.
18:07And of course, we know that Donald Trump feels this very viscerally because he knows how
18:12close he came to losing his life just over a year ago in Butler, Pennsylvania.
18:16So and then there was, you know, another pretty realistic assassination attempt on him a few
18:22months later as well.
18:23So, you know, he feels it, you know, viscerally how frightening this is.
18:29So I'm not surprised that he's got, you know, a pretty strong reaction to it.
18:33I do think that we should also point out, you know, when we talk about examples of violence
18:38that have happened across the political spectrum, including targeting people on the left, we
18:42think of, for example, the attack on Nancy Pelosi, the former Speaker of the House's husband,
18:48which was that that happened a couple of years ago now.
18:52And then also examples of lawmakers who have lost their lives and political violence that
19:00was triggered, for example, by the suggestion that the election was stolen when Joe Biden
19:04won.
19:06There was also on the right support for some of the people who've done this stuff.
19:12There was like there were people who who kind of celebrated the man who attacked Nancy Pelosi's
19:19husband or spread conspiracy theories about that.
19:21So I think it's worth saying that the the level of polarization here is huge, like both
19:27sides are guilty of rejoicing and celebrating.
19:30I think what people on the right on social media would argue is, well, yeah, OK, we'll do
19:35that.
19:35But we are much more open to debate and discussion.
19:38And the left aren't.
19:40The left would say, well, hang on a second.
19:42You know, you are always the people telling us that words, you know, words don't matter online.
19:47It's it's inconsequential why you're worried about the consequence of it, et cetera.
19:51And now you are.
19:52So there's like levels of hypocrisy sort of across the board here when it comes to the
19:55positions that people are taking.
19:57I think what is worth explaining, though, when we talk about that language that Donald Trump
20:01used and actually some of the language that's being used on X, which is really quite violent
20:05and quite scary, I spent a lot of my time hanging out on social media and on X.
20:11And this language is incredibly common.
20:13Like I think people can't you know, there are lots of people who are really shocked today
20:16because they're looking at it, but it's used all the time.
20:19And I think that that visceral reaction that we're seeing online and even from the president
20:23comes down to what a big deal Charlie Kirk was and how he felt like a family member or
20:29someone who was really, really close to Donald Trump and actually to huge amounts of the
20:34American public who knew him really, really well.
20:36Last night on The Megyn Kelly Show, conservative media commentator Emily Zuzinski, she captured
20:40this, which is why people feel so, this is so emotional.
20:44Yeah.
20:44And just to say about Emily, before we play the clip, and it's a really interesting
20:47exchange because it's with Megyn Kelly, isn't it?
20:49Who we also talked to, I think we've talked to on the pod and I've certainly talked to
20:53on my other job in the Today programme.
20:54I don't know her as well, but Emily, I know well, and she is a conservative commentator,
20:59but she's also someone who's very fair minded.
21:01And this exchange, I think, which you're going to introduce now, I think is fascinating because
21:06in a sense, it underlines what Sarah's just been saying, that this is a really big cultural
21:12deal as well.
21:13I mean, he's almost as close to monoculture as Gen Z gets.
21:17Everybody felt like they knew Charlie Kirk.
21:19Even if they didn't like Charlie Kirk, they felt like they knew Charlie Kirk.
21:22They felt like they knew Charlie Kirk and they saw him grow up.
21:26And so I think you've mentioned this a couple of times.
21:28We are, if anything, underestimating as a society right now, how profoundly this will reverberate
21:37on the culture.
21:40Yeah.
21:40Yes.
21:41This, I don't know if the left fully comprehends how important he was to us.
21:45I really don't.
21:46I'm not sure they appreciate.
21:47They try to marginalize him and make him into this fringy character who is just some sort
21:53of nutcase who would go on campuses and stir up shit.
21:56And that is such a misrepresentation of this noble person.
22:02Yes.
22:02Love him or hate him.
22:03I think the left would make a big mistake if they were to underestimate the influence that
22:09Charlie Kirk had, but also the affection within which he was held because of the way he conducted
22:13himself.
22:14He had very confrontational points of view.
22:18He had some quite controversial ideas.
22:20But he was always, you know, he was open to debate.
22:23He was genial.
22:24He was extremely charismatic.
22:26And he clearly had quite a long way to go in American politics as well.
22:30So, you know, he will be seen as a martyr.
22:34Donald Trump described him as a martyr last night.
22:37And that's going to have a pretty profound influence as well, I think.
22:40And it's worth mentioning, isn't it, I mean, when it comes to being a cultural icon, if
22:44we're really underlining just how key he was and what a big hole is going to be there
22:51now and how angry people are going to be, to be on South Park in any way, shape or form.
22:57I mean, Donald Trump is a lot at the moment and possibly in a form and a shape that he doesn't
23:01want to be.
23:01But for most people, it's the honour of a lifetime to be parodied on South Park.
23:06And in the current series of South Park, Charlie Kirk was and he liked it.
23:14First of all, I just think it's hilarious.
23:15And secondly, the whole thing is like, wait, so a campus thing I've been doing for 13 years
23:21to debate random college kids has now been so important that it gets prominent primetime
23:27placement on Comedy Central.
23:29I think the whole thing is just awesome and hilarious.
23:33There's so much more I want to say about this, but the whole shtick, by the way, Comedy
23:36Central, South Park, you crushed the water.
23:39I compulsively drink water on campus.
23:42It's like, OK, boom, we got to stay hydrated.
23:45Now, the lozenges, we got to work a little.
23:47And by the way, the Holy Bible right next to it.
23:49I even said on this campus tour, I was going to bring a Holy Bible with me to every single
23:54campus stop.
23:55I mean, that does sum up to a certain extent the way in which he was, you know, he was able
24:00to take a message out into the wider culture and, you know, and enjoy and not mind being
24:06mocked about it.
24:07That was part of his charisma.
24:09I think it's interesting as well when we think about, like, we're obviously talking about
24:12the impact that this has on the United States.
24:16But actually, to this point I was making about how he's kind of a blueprint for this new type
24:21of political activist, social media influencer.
24:24He is so well known around the world that there'll be people waking up in every country
24:28who will know him because social media has no borders and his stuff is everywhere.
24:33Like, I look at my social media feed and obviously my undercover voters, my fictional characters,
24:39feeds are a little bit tainted with American politics.
24:41But my own feed, I get this kind of stuff all the time.
24:43There's British teenagers debating with him.
24:46He's come over here to the UK and done these debates at Oxford University.
24:48You know, there's, there's, it's just really profound this in terms of what he is.
24:56And you imagine that actually one of the consequences of this is that there will be
25:01quite a lot of, well, I don't know.
25:04See, on the one hand, you think, well, maybe it will inspire more young Americans to think,
25:07I want to do that.
25:08I want to get into political activism.
25:10I want to have a social media platform.
25:11I want to do this, regardless of your views.
25:12The flip side is seeing people who are celebrating it.
25:18You think, oh, hang on.
25:19Does anyone really realise, it almost doesn't feel very real.
25:23Like, it's a bit like a video game.
25:24Like, you look at it, this, this horrifically violent clip, awful clip.
25:28And it's almost like it's all of this stuff has become so normal online that we don't really
25:34think about, or not we personally, but as society, think about the consequences of it.
25:39I think particularly for the kinds of people that watch and consume Charlie Kirk.
25:43It's worth saying, isn't it, Sarah?
25:44And we maybe ought to have mentioned this more prominently, but we can mention it now,
25:48that the mainstream democratic politicians have been unanimous in coming out and making
25:54very strong statements and senior people.
25:56So we heard from Obama, didn't we?
25:58And Biden and Gavin Newsom.
26:01Every living president has.
26:02Right.
26:02Yeah.
26:03Yeah.
26:03I didn't know that.
26:04They all have.
26:05Yeah.
26:05Yeah.
26:05But also, Sarah, more than that, you know, a lot of Democrats have made it absolutely
26:11plain that those who have celebrated this death are not speaking for them.
26:16Oh, absolutely.
26:17And you even heard from Gabby Giffords, a former Democratic congresswoman who herself
26:22was shot a few years ago in an assassination attempt, saying that she was absolutely heartbroken
26:29and that this was completely terrible.
26:31And yeah, the normal response to condemn the violence and say that this must stop and it
26:39must not happen again has been through most of the political mainstream.
26:45But I think the issue here is that we're not just talking about on the fringes of the
26:52internet.
26:52We're talking about a lot of pretty senior and very influential people who either on
26:57social media or on television are going a bit further than they would normally and are
27:02talking about revenge and retribution.
27:06And I've had I've had a lot of very important MAGA figures on TV using words like that.
27:13And it's not just on the right, you know, on the left as well.
27:17If you listen to what Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez had to say, and this is this is a more measured
27:23message from her, but it's still not what you would expect in a moment like this.
27:29We have a political assassination that happened at the same time as a school shooting where
27:35children are dying on the same day, a week after a shooting at a Catholic school where
27:43children were were gunned down while praying.
27:46Are we going to do something or are we going to argue over rhetoric?
27:49That is my question about this.
27:51We have to pass gun safety legislation and stop this.
27:55What one congresswoman was saying was yelling Republican said there was Democrats fault.
27:59Democrats did this.
28:00That's what we heard her say on the House floor.
28:02I mean, people can finger point all they want.
28:08Look at the record.
28:10Look at the actions of what we are doing.
28:12I don't think a single person who has dedicated their entire career to preventing gun safety
28:18legislation from getting passed in this House has any right to blame anybody else but themselves
28:24for what is happening.
28:25We have to stop this.
28:27We can stop this.
28:29Gosh, Sarah, we talked a little bit about Donald Trump's tone and whether he had hit the right
28:37tone, the kind of tone that you would expect in these circumstances.
28:40If she wants to be president, which I think she does, I'm not sure that that is quite the tone
28:47either.
28:48I found that equally shocking, actually.
28:51I mean, given that this is a man of 31 with two little children, if that's the reaction from
28:58someone who wants to be in the mainstream of American politics, she wants to be president,
29:03she wants to appeal across the aisle to some extent, I suppose, to the extent that that gets
29:08you to the presidency in this day and age.
29:11That seemed to me to be tonally wrong.
29:14And she, of course, was responding to the fact that other elected politicians in Congress
29:20were blaming Democrats for this happening.
29:22I mean, I can't remember a time when there has been finger pointing to this extent or
29:27at this level and certainly not so quickly after somebody has been murdered, essentially
29:33in front of our eyes, because we can all see these kind of things now as well.
29:37This is why I think it just it feels to me that there is something slightly different
29:42about the tone here.
29:44Very different even than there was last year after the attempt on Donald Trump's life,
29:49which, you know, when fortunately he was not badly injured.
29:52It's just there's something febrile in the way that people who frankly know better have
30:00been responding to this.
30:01There was an old world in politics where there was a rule book and you did certain things
30:05when something bad happened and you calmed it down.
30:07And now that you're playing to your audiences online, like if she's if she doesn't sound
30:13like that, she'll get absolutely piled upon by the left wing people that follow her, which
30:19is not to say that that's right.
30:20But you can see how and also, you know, she's consuming like politicians themselves, particularly
30:25younger politicians will be across the board consuming information in their echo chambers
30:30as well.
30:31So the way they view events is different as well.
30:34And lots of things can all be true at once.
30:36I think that the sad reality of this, which is the most difficult thing, is it doesn't even
30:41feel like everyone can agree on the fact that whatever you think or believe, you don't
30:45deserve to be killed.
30:47Well, look, on that, let us give the last word then to the governor of Utah, because
30:52this happened, of course, as we were saying earlier, at a university in Utah.
30:56And quite soon afterwards, the governor spoke.
30:59This is a dark day for our state.
31:01It's a tragic day for our nation.
31:06And I want to be very clear that this is a political assassination.
31:10He comes on college campuses and he debates.
31:15That is foundational to the formation of our country, to our most basic constitutional rights.
31:22Now, that was somebody who did strike a mature tone.
31:27And I thought that was actually that was a very powerful speech that he gave there.
31:32And of course, he has absolutely hit the nail on the head as to what this means for debate
31:37and conversation and the free exchange of ideas, which is, yes, the I mean, the foundation
31:42of democracy and essential to politics to operate in any kind of functional level.
31:49Whenever we have these conversations, the conversation often centers on the different politicians involved.
31:53Obviously, it will center on whoever is responsible for this.
31:56And that is completely understandable and makes sense.
31:59There is very little focus on, in my view, the social media companies, these very rich,
32:04unaccountable companies who, if you removed the platforms, if they didn't exist in the way
32:09they do, if algorithms and recommendation systems didn't exist in the way that they do,
32:14I don't think any of this would have ever happened.
32:16I don't think Charlie Kirk would exist in the way he does.
32:19I don't think the rhetoric and the debate would be as it is.
32:21And that's not to say political violence hasn't existed for absolutely ages, decades, centuries.
32:25Of course it has.
32:26But I just don't think it would be the same.
32:27And no one will be asking questions of what gets us to this point, really, because ultimately
32:33all of the politicians have to play that same system in order to even exist now.
32:38Right.
32:38OK, well, that's a really good point.
32:40My last thought is going to be slightly more optimistic, actually.
32:44And in a way, taking issue with that.
32:48And I absolutely accept what Sarah said.
32:50This is a really critical time for America.
32:53And not only was the event itself horrific, but the potential ramifications of it are horrific
33:00too.
33:01I absolutely accept that.
33:02But to your point about social media and all the rest of it, and you made the point yourself,
33:08Mary Annette, there's been political violence before.
33:10Oh, my goodness.
33:11There's been political violence before in the United States.
33:14You think back to the late 60s and the early 70s, not only the assassinations that we know
33:19about, but also a huge amount of political violence kind of behind the scenes of genuine
33:25domestic terrorism.
33:28America goes through these awful paroxysms of rage and distress and comes out of them the
33:36other side.
33:36And I think even if it is in one of those paroxysms now, there is still at least a chance,
33:44if not a good chance, that the nation will come to its senses.
33:48The Republic will endure, I'm sure.
33:51But I just think for anybody who maybe wasn't that familiar with Charlie Kirk or his place
33:56in American politics, you know, whilst these things have happened in history before, to
34:00give this its historical context, we have to consider that we may be living in one of those
34:06moments that you say, Justin, that America has endured before and come through.
34:10But, you know, this is not minor league stuff that we're talking about now.
34:14My point would be, why?
34:16Why now?
34:17Why is this happening in this period of time?
34:19Which is for all sorts of reasons, but I don't think you can take the role of social
34:23media in it out of it.
34:24OK, well, we've certainly raised an awful lot of things that people are going to be thinking
34:27about and talking about, and we're going to hear unquestionably from AmeriCasters.
34:31And we'll be discussing all of this and plenty of episodes to come.
34:34That's it for now from all of us.
34:36Bye-bye.
34:36Bye-bye.
34:37Bye-bye.

Recommended