0044 Astrology: Science or Just Belief? The Truth Behind the Stars

Truth N Trends

Astrology shapes many everyday decisions in India—from kundli matching to picking a “lucky” day. But is it scientific or psychological? In this Truth N Trends episode, Deepak and Sonia break down major astrology systems, why people believe them, where the science fails, simple experiments you can try at home, how pseudo-science borrows religious symbols to gain authority, and practical ways to build a scientific temper without disrespecting culture.

Transcript

00:001. Welcome to Truth and Trends. Today we are asking a bold question.

00:12Do the stars really control our lives or is it our mind playing clever tricks on us?

00:16Sonia, in our India, from fixing a wedding date to starting a business,

00:21people look at horoscopes. If astrology is true, it should be consistent and testable.

00:26If it's belief, we should treat it like belief, not like science.

00:31Let's map the landscape first. We have Vedic Astrology or Jyotish with Kundali and Dashas,

00:37Western Astrology with Sun Science, Chinese Zodiac with Animal Years,

00:42plus Palmistry, Numerology and even Nadi readings.

00:45Here's a common doubt. If all these systems claim cosmic truth, why don't they agree?

00:50A person can be Makar by one method and something else by another.

00:54The tropical vs sidereal difference alone shifts dates. If reality is one,

00:59why so many conflicting rulebooks? Then why do millions believe?

01:04Psychology. The Barnum or Forer effect makes vague lines feel personal.

01:09You value independence but need approval. That fits almost everyone.

01:13Add confirmation bias. We remember the one hit and forget 10 misses.

01:18Authority bias. Astrologist speaks with confidence. Sanskrit terms, rings, yantras.

01:23Social proof. My cousin's prediction came true. Our brain loves patterns and certainty,

01:29especially when life feels uncertain.

01:31Let's make it practical with simple tests viewers can try.

01:35Test 1. The Swap. Print two generic horoscopes. Give one tailored for you.

01:41A week later swap and ask which felt truer. Most people say both felt accurate.

01:47Test 2. The Scorecard. Before the month starts, write 5 concrete predictions from your horoscope.

01:54Keep a notebook. At month end, score strictly, no stretching meanings.

01:59Compare to 5 coin toss guesses. You'll be surprised how close they are.

02:04Test 3. The Blind Read. Ask an astrologer for a reading without revealing your details,

02:09then swap readings with a friend of a different sign. If it still fits, it's the Barnum effect again.

02:15Now the science bar. A claim is scientific if it's falsifiable, makes precise predictions,

02:21survives blinded tests, and replicates with large samples. Astrology rarely provides a mechanism

02:27that obeys physics. How do distant planets choose your job result?

02:32Exactly. Science demands pre-registered predictions, control groups, statistical power, and replication.

02:38If a system works, it should beat chants consistently. When tested under these conditions,

02:45astrology doesn't clear the bar.

02:47Another honest question. Why does astrology feel tied to religion? Because symbols matter.

02:53When chats are paired with temple bells, mantras, gemstones, and muhurat, it borrows sacred

02:59authority. Saying no starts to feel like rejecting faith itself.

03:03We can respect culture without outsourcing decisions. Lighting a diya for peace is cultural.

03:09But letting a dosha decide whom to marry or buying costly remedies as guarantees turns belief into a

03:15tool for fear and profit. Viewers often ask, but my astrologer nailed one big event.

03:21Rare hits happen by probability, broad phrasing, or cold reading. Something from the past still

03:27troubles you. A senior will test you. Who doesn't relate?

03:30Another doubt? Astrology helps me feel confident. Isn't that good? Confidence is great. Get it from

03:36preparation. If a lucky color makes you focus, fine. But give credit to your effort, not the color.

03:44Otherwise, you train your brain to depend on magic, not skill.

03:48How do we build scientific temper at home? First, write predictions before events, then check

03:54honestly. Second, ask every claim. What evidence would change my mind?

03:59Third, separate culture from causation. Enjoy festivals, but make decisions with data.

04:05For students, learn the scientific method by doing small experiments. Keep logs, compare to chance.

04:12For families, reward questions, not blind obedience. For everyone, choose experts who show data,

04:19not just confidence. In short, think, test, verify. Let belief, stay personal,

04:26and let big life decisions rest on evidence. Jai Hind!

04:30Jai Hind!

Category

Transcript

Be the first to comment

Recommended