- 6 weeks ago
- #clashofthegods
- #documentary
- #odysseus
Documentary, History Channel - Clash of the Gods - S01E07 Odysseus Part 2
#ClashoftheGods #Documentary #Odysseus
#ClashoftheGods #Documentary #Odysseus
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00His name is Odysseus, and he's on a mission.
00:05To return home to the woman he loves before she marries someone else.
00:10Blocking his way are bloodthirsty monsters,
00:14enchanting seductresses,
00:16treacherous seeds,
00:17and angry gods.
00:21This is the continuing journey of Odysseus,
00:25the epic quest of the greatest mythical hero of all time.
00:30To us it is myth,
00:31but to the ancients it was reality,
00:34and perhaps even a blueprint for one of the Christian gospels.
00:39This is the real story, as it was originally told,
00:42of the Odyssey.
00:56The story of Odysseus, king of Ithaca,
01:00is not like tales of other mythological heroes.
01:03He's not a god with special superpowers.
01:07Instead, his character is written as a regular man,
01:11trying to get home from a ten-year war to his wife and son.
01:16Everybody can relate to this guy.
01:18This is all of us.
01:19I'd like to spend more time with my family.
01:21I don't like my job.
01:22I'm not treated the way I ought to be.
01:24And I'm tired.
01:25I want to go home.
01:28That's Odysseus' story.
01:31But the Odyssey is not just a return home.
01:35It's a race against time.
01:37As Odysseus battles danger on the high seas,
01:41his wife, Penelope, anxiously awaits his return
01:44and wonders if she's become a sailor's widow.
01:48Meanwhile, a rogue's gallery of suitors is knocking at her door,
01:52pressuring her to forget her husband and marry again.
01:55And according to custom,
01:58he who wins the queen will win the crown.
02:02If Odysseus doesn't get home in time,
02:05he'll lose his family and his kingdom.
02:09The aristocracy of the area starts saying,
02:13Odysseus isn't coming home.
02:14We don't know what happened to him,
02:15but he's not coming back.
02:16So we need to decide who's going to be king instead of him.
02:20The person who would be a candidate
02:22would be the person who marries Penelope,
02:25since everyone assumed that she was now a widow.
02:30Odysseus' struggle to get home in time
02:32is the central focus of the Odyssey.
02:36This epic myth was the Greek author Homer's most famous work.
02:43And to the ancients,
02:45it was more than just entertaining fiction.
02:49It was a guidebook to living in a dangerous world.
02:53We need to understand,
02:54we need to tell stories to make sense of our world.
02:58And so the Greeks had myths.
03:02These are incredibly human characters
03:05going through incredibly human emotions.
03:09Odysseus' adventures on the high seas
03:11reflected how the Greeks viewed the unknown world
03:14beyond their shores.
03:16His myth was written at a time
03:17when their empire was just beginning
03:19to expand across the seas.
03:22Odysseus represents someone
03:23who is very, very prototypical Greek.
03:27Greece at that time was a very poor country.
03:29It's a rocky place
03:30surrounded by the sea.
03:33So people had to make their fortunes
03:35by being adventurers.
03:37It was the only way you can make it in ancient Greece.
03:39Odysseus' heroic journey home
03:51began with his departure from Troy
03:52where he had spent ten years
03:55fighting the Trojan War.
03:57He had hoped his return to his home island of Ithaca
03:59would be quick and painless.
04:01But for him and his soldiers
04:03it turned into a trip from hell.
04:07On a stop for supplies
04:08several weeks into the journey
04:09Odysseus narrowly escaped death
04:12at the hands of a man-eating cyclops
04:16only to draw the wrath of the monster's father
04:19the powerful sea god
04:21Poseidon.
04:25By attacking the son of a god
04:28he makes a double mistake.
04:29One is he angers a god
04:32but the second is
04:33he angers the god of the sea.
04:35He's sailing home.
04:39And that's the curse
04:41that is working against Odysseus
04:44the entire rest of his journey.
04:46Poseidon, one of the most powerful gods
04:49has this personal antipathy to Odysseus.
04:55Now Odysseus is way off course
04:58months into a journey
05:00that should have taken weeks.
05:02Little does he know
05:03he's got years still to go.
05:14But Odysseus is not one to surrender
05:16in the face of adversity.
05:18He may be knocked down
05:20just as much as all the rest of us
05:21and even harder than all the rest of us
05:23but he always can get back up.
05:25he can always find a way.
05:26And I think that really crystallizes
05:28this desire that all of us have
05:30to make it through
05:31to persevere.
05:33He's just a human being
05:34up against all kinds of odds
05:36up against gods
05:37and he has to make it through
05:39simply on his intelligence.
05:46Desperate for an escape
05:48from Poseidon's stormy seas
05:49the hero and his men
05:51make landfall
05:52on a coastline
05:53overflowing with food.
05:56Odysseus sends a scouting party
05:58to investigate
05:58while he stays close to shore.
06:02The men discover
06:03a stone palace
06:04surrounded by wolves
06:05and lions.
06:09There they meet
06:10the beautiful sorceress
06:12Circe.
06:14For these Greek warriors
06:17who have been out at sea
06:18for the past four months
06:19she's a stirring sight.
06:24And so are her maids.
06:30Circe invites the men
06:31into her home
06:32to enjoy a sumptuous feast
06:34of food and flesh.
06:37Circe is supposed to show us
06:39what happens
06:40when men
06:41get led astray
06:43not by drugs
06:45but by sex.
06:48And men coming home
06:50when you've got
06:51sexy woman
06:52with great power
06:53that can make you
06:54happy,
06:55give you anything you want
06:56well what does that do?
06:57It turns men to pigs.
07:00As Odysseus' men
07:02indulge their appetites
07:03the sorceress
07:04teaches them
07:05a hard lesson.
07:07She literally
07:07transforms the men
07:09into swine.
07:32But one man
07:33manages to escape
07:34Circe's spell
07:35and returns
07:36to warn Odysseus.
07:37without hesitation
07:39he sets out
07:41to confront
07:41the goddess.
07:43He has this
07:44almost optimism
07:45about
07:46the way
07:47things are.
07:49He has this idea
07:50that any challenge
07:51that comes his way
07:52he can overcome.
07:54And he never really
07:55seems to falter
07:56in that.
08:02According to the myth
08:03on the way
08:04to Circe's palace
08:05where his men
08:06have been turned
08:06into pigs
08:07Odysseus crosses
08:09paths
08:09with a valuable ally
08:11the ancient Greek
08:13messenger god
08:14Hermes.
08:16He's often the god
08:17who is sent
08:18from Mount Olympus
08:19down to earth
08:20to perform errands
08:22essentially.
08:23He's sent
08:24to Odysseus
08:25with a drug
08:26called mole.
08:27We don't really
08:30know what this was
08:31but it has
08:32mystical powers.
08:33He gives it
08:34to Odysseus
08:34and Odysseus
08:35takes it
08:36so that he's
08:36actually not
08:37subject to
08:38Circe's powers.
08:39Ancient
08:40storytellers
08:41may have referred
08:41to this mythical
08:42wonder drug
08:43as holy moly
08:44and inspired
08:45the phrase
08:46we know today.
08:51With the power
08:52of his moly
08:53protecting him
08:54Odysseus
08:55swaggers
08:56into Circe's palace
08:57Circe tries
08:59to turn him
08:59into a pig
09:00but fails
09:01so she changes
09:03tactics
09:03she lures him
09:06into her bedroom
09:07but Odysseus
09:09plays hard
09:10to get.
09:12Odysseus responds
09:13not so fast
09:14before I agree
09:15to this
09:16you have to promise
09:17to turn my men
09:18back into human beings
09:19and you have to promise
09:20no more funny business
09:22no more turning
09:23any of us
09:23into animals
09:24and Circe agrees
09:25to these terms.
09:30With that
09:31Odysseus enters
09:32the inner sanctum
09:33of the sex goddess
09:34and doesn't come out
09:37for a whole year.
09:39This to us
09:40seems like
09:40an extramarital affair.
09:42Homer doesn't really
09:43seem to think
09:44that this is
09:44a problem
09:45in any way.
09:49This likely
09:50has to do
09:51with the double standard
09:52in Greek society
09:53that is to say
09:54women were expected
09:56to be chaste
09:57and loyal
09:58not to seek
10:00or particularly
10:01enjoy sexual relationships
10:03whereas men
10:04could go out
10:05and have really
10:06a lot of different
10:07extramarital affairs
10:09without anybody
10:10thinking that it was wrong.
10:11after one year
10:16Odysseus decides
10:18enough is enough
10:19he's had his tryst
10:21but his heart
10:22is with his wife
10:23Penelope
10:24and he must get home.
10:27I think at this point
10:28the Odyssey
10:29is trying to show us
10:30something about
10:31Odysseus
10:32he is a man
10:33like any other man
10:34he should be
10:36striving
10:36to get home.
10:39He owes
10:40Penelope
10:41and he owes
10:42Ithaca
10:43a king
10:44and the longer
10:47he spends
10:48with Circes
10:49the more
10:50he is denying
10:51what is owed.
10:53But before
10:54he can set sail
10:55for his home island
10:56of Ithaca
10:57he'll have to make
10:58another detour
10:59to visit a place
10:59that isn't on the map
11:01but beneath it
11:04the underworld
11:07of the dead.
11:10It is a harrowing
11:11chapter
11:12in Odysseus' journey
11:13that some scholars
11:14believe
11:14even influenced
11:15one of the
11:16Christian gospels.
11:28Odysseus
11:29the mythical hero
11:30in Homer's Odyssey
11:31has been away
11:32from his family
11:33and kingdom
11:33for almost 12 years.
11:36He spent a decade
11:37fighting the Trojan War
11:38and a full year
11:40in the bedroom
11:41of Circe
11:41the sex goddess.
11:46Now he knows
11:47the time has come
11:48to move on
11:49and get home.
11:53Circe consents
11:54to his leaving
11:54but imparts
11:55an ominous warning
11:56to overcome
11:59the curse
12:00of the sea god
12:01Poseidon
12:01and get home
12:02he'll need
12:03instructions
12:03from the blind prophet
12:04Piresias.
12:08Just one problem
12:09Piresias
12:11is dead.
12:15Odysseus
12:15must now
12:16make an unplanned
12:17stop
12:17in the underworld
12:20of Hades.
12:22You think
12:24you're just
12:25going home
12:25you're going
12:26someplace
12:26that you
12:26didn't expect
12:27to go.
12:28You're going
12:29to hell.
12:32Odysseus
12:33is horrified
12:34at this thought.
12:35No human
12:35has ever
12:36gone to Hades
12:37and survived.
12:39But Odysseus
12:40has no choice.
12:42Poseidon's power
12:43over the seas
12:43is strong
12:44and he's getting
12:45nowhere fast.
12:46If he ever hopes
12:47to reclaim his family
12:48and his kingdom
12:49he must seek out
12:51Piresias
12:51in the underworld.
13:02Today we picture
13:03hell as a pit
13:04of fire
13:05and brimstone.
13:07But the ancient
13:08Greeks
13:08saw it differently.
13:10The ancient
13:11Greek underworld
13:12is mostly characterized
13:13by being misty
13:14and cool.
13:16In contrast
13:16to later ideas
13:18that come in
13:18with Christianity
13:19of the underworld
13:20as being a place
13:21of eternal punishment.
13:23It's not a kind
13:24of nasty
13:24hot fiery furnace.
13:26Instead what we've
13:26got is a grey area
13:27that's difficult
13:28to see
13:29that's misty
13:29murky
13:30and very far away.
13:34Odysseus
13:34makes a harrowing
13:36descent into Hades.
13:38The agonized
13:39cries of perished
13:40souls
13:40echo
13:41from all sides.
13:45Inside the gates
13:47he comes face
13:48to face
13:48with the prophet
13:49Tiresias
13:50who explains
13:53that Odysseus
13:53and his men
13:54can overcome
13:55the wrath of Poseidon
13:56and make it home
13:57if they follow
13:59his instructions.
14:01Tiresias gives them
14:01very specific advice.
14:03Above all
14:04what you need to do
14:05is not eat
14:06the cattle
14:08of the sun god
14:09Helios.
14:10No matter what
14:11else you do
14:12do not eat
14:14these cattle
14:15It's advice
14:19that will come
14:20back to haunt
14:20Odysseus
14:21As the souls
14:31of the dead
14:32begin to close
14:33in on him
14:33Odysseus
14:34makes his escape
14:35from the underworld
14:36more determined
14:38than ever
14:38to get home
14:39He has done
14:46what no living man
14:47is supposed
14:47to be able to do
14:48survive a trip
14:51to Hades
14:52So goes the myth
14:53but what is
14:54the link
14:55to reality?
15:00Some scholars
15:01believe
15:01this chapter
15:02of the Odyssey
15:02influenced
15:03one of Christianity's
15:04most sacred texts
15:06The Gospel of Mark
15:10It's almost impossible
15:13to overestimate
15:14the importance
15:15of Homer
15:15for ancient Greeks
15:17Mark of course
15:19was a Greek speaker
15:20the Gospels
15:21are written in Greek
15:22He almost certainly
15:23would have known
15:24the story of the Odyssey
15:25So if there are things
15:27in the book of Mark
15:27that remind us
15:28of the Odyssey
15:29that may well
15:30not be an accident
15:31A close comparison
15:33of the Odyssey
15:34and the Gospel of Mark
15:35reveals some
15:37shocking parallels
15:38Both stories
15:39revolve around
15:40the hardships
15:41of a suffering hero
15:42Odysseus
15:43and Jesus
15:44Both main characters
15:46have carpentry backgrounds
15:47Odysseus
15:49was a skilled woodworker
15:50who even built
15:51his own palace
15:52in Ithaca
15:53Jesus was the son
15:55of a carpenter
15:55and in one passage
15:57in the book of Mark
15:58he himself
15:59is referred to as
16:00the carpenter
16:01But the most
16:07intriguing connection
16:08is the similarity
16:09between Odysseus'
16:11visit to Hades
16:11and Jesus'
16:13last days on earth
16:14Both stories
16:17begin with a banquet
16:18Odysseus and his men
16:20feasting at Circe's palace
16:22Jesus and his apostles
16:24at the last supper
16:25Then as their comrades
16:28sleep
16:29both men agonize
16:30about their impending
16:31encounter with death
16:33When Odysseus learns
16:34from Circe
16:35that he needs
16:37to go to Hades
16:38he despairs
16:39of it
16:40The reason is
16:41and he says so
16:42that no mortal
16:44has ever gone to Hades
16:45and returned
16:46Jesus is about to die
16:48He has a last supper
16:49with his disciples
16:50He despairs of life
16:52because he knows
16:53he must face the cross
16:54Ultimately
16:57Odysseus would travel
16:58to the underworld
16:59of the dead
17:00and return
17:01Jesus would die
17:03on the cross
17:04and then rise
17:05to new life
17:06Could these parallels
17:09be more than coincidence?
17:11As the myth continues
17:17Odysseus leaves Hades
17:19and sets sail
17:20for Ithaca
17:21He is finally
17:24on his way home again
17:25But in his path
17:27lurks another obstacle
17:29The Island of the Sirens
17:31The Sirens
17:33are these creatures
17:36whose songs
17:38are so beautiful
17:39that they pull you
17:41off course
17:42and you shipwreck
17:44Odysseus knows
17:53he is approaching
17:54the island of the Sirens
17:55So he orders his men
17:57to plug their ears
17:58with beeswax
17:59to prevent them
18:00from hearing
18:01the Sirens song
18:02But Odysseus
18:04a man of insatiable curiosity
18:06is the exception
18:08to his own rule
18:09He has the crew
18:12tie him to the ship's mast
18:13This way
18:15he can listen
18:16to the Sirens
18:17without steering the ship
18:18toward the island's
18:19rocky shores
18:20As they row through
18:25he is screaming
18:26untie me
18:26untie me
18:27but they can't hear him
18:28And so he hears
18:44what the Sirens song
18:45is
18:45the only human
18:46who's done it
18:47and survived
18:47But for the ancients
18:49you see this scene
18:50depicted again and again
18:52on vase painting
18:53after vase painting
18:54and it's meant
18:55to show you
18:56what the ideal man
18:59is about
18:59doing whatever
19:01is necessary
19:02to learn something new
19:04Odysseus' encounter
19:08with the Sirens
19:09is one of mythology's
19:10best known stories
19:11but new evidence
19:13suggests
19:14the song of the Sirens
19:15may be more
19:16than just a legend
19:17Italy's
19:23Ligali Islands
19:24Traditionally
19:26they have been cited
19:27as the setting
19:28of the story
19:29Centuries ago
19:31they were even called
19:32Le Sirenus
19:33The Islands
19:35of the Sirens
19:35In 2004
19:39a team of German scientists
19:40set out
19:41to investigate
19:41their link
19:42to the Odyssey
19:43and made a stunning discovery
19:45What the German team
19:47found on this island
19:49was that there was
19:49a naturally occurring
19:51formation of rocks
19:52that served as
19:53kind of a
19:53natural megaphone
19:55Any sort of sound source
19:57that happened to be
19:58located there
19:59these sound waves
20:00would bounce off them
20:01and they would
20:01amplify them
20:02out off the coast
20:04But even with this
20:06built-in megaphone
20:07human voices
20:09are impossible
20:09to hear offshore
20:10So what could have made
20:12such a loud sound?
20:19Monk seals
20:20Centuries ago
20:22they were common
20:22throughout the Mediterranean
20:23including
20:25the Ligali Islands
20:26The German team
20:27was able to
20:28demonstrate
20:29the sound of
20:30their cries
20:31actually could be heard
20:32quite clearly
20:33off the coast
20:34Could this be the call
20:37that lured sailors
20:38to a rocky grave?
20:42Back on the high seas
20:48Odysseus has survived
20:49his brush
20:50with the sirens
20:51But an even
20:52deadlier challenge
20:53lies beyond
20:54the next wave
20:55To make it home
20:58to Ithaca
20:58he'll have to confront
21:00one of two
21:01terrifying threats
21:02Some researchers
21:04believe these dangers
21:06were real
21:06and may still
21:08be out there
21:08Odysseus' shrewdness
21:20has helped him
21:20survive a series
21:21of deadly obstacles
21:23on the high seas
21:24But he's not the only one
21:26using his wits
21:27Hundreds of miles away
21:31in his kingdom
21:31of Ithaca
21:32his wife is keeping
21:34her suitors at bay
21:35with a clever ruse
21:36of her own
21:37She promises
21:39she will marry
21:40one of them
21:40as soon as she
21:41finishes weaving
21:42a burial shroud
21:43for Odysseus' father
21:45But each night
21:47she unweaves
21:48what she has woven
21:49during the day
21:50This trick has been
21:51buying her time
21:52for years
21:53Just as Odysseus
21:55is characterized
21:56by his craftiness
21:57and his cleverness
21:58and his ability
21:58to weave plots
21:59and plans
22:00so also Penelope
22:02has her claim
22:03to being able
22:04to weave plots
22:05and plans
22:05Penelope is doing
22:08her best
22:08to remain hopeful
22:09but she doesn't know
22:11what has become
22:12of her husband
22:12She really has no idea
22:14whether Odysseus
22:15is still alive
22:16and if he is still alive
22:17whether he's on his way
22:18back to her
22:19or maybe he's just
22:20decided to go
22:20somewhere else
22:21it's a terrible state
22:23of not knowing
22:23Meanwhile
22:26a horrific set
22:28of new obstacles
22:29stands between
22:30Odysseus
22:30and home
22:31He must now choose
22:33between two deadly routes
22:34The first
22:36runs through
22:37the wandering rocks
22:38floating boulders
22:40that smash ships apart
22:42The second
22:47slips through
22:48a narrow channel
22:49flanked on one side
22:50by a man-eating
22:51sea monster
22:52called the Scylla
22:53and on the other
22:55by a massive whirlpool
22:56known as the Charybdis
22:58Scylla is this terrifying
23:02sea monster
23:03with many heads
23:05and many arms
23:06this terrifying creature
23:08who you know
23:10for a fact
23:11will grab up
23:13six of your men
23:14and eat them
23:15You sail by Scylla
23:18that is what will happen
23:19Facing the Scylla
23:24is the Charybdis
23:25a giant vortex
23:26that twirls around
23:28and sucks into itself
23:30and sort of vomits back up
23:31all the stuff
23:32in any nearby area
23:34If Odysseus
23:35would go
23:36close to that
23:37he would risk
23:38having his whole ship
23:39capsized
23:41and sucked down
23:41into the bottom
23:42of the Teebon
23:42Odysseus
23:46is literally trapped
23:47between a rock
23:48and a hard place
23:49In fact
23:51some believe
23:51this is where
23:52the cliché originated
23:53He orders his men
23:58to avoid
23:58the wandering rocks
23:59and instead
24:00sail for the hard place
24:02the strait
24:04of Scylla
24:05and Charybdis
24:05There Odysseus
24:12faces two grim options
24:14Death to some
24:16or death to all
24:19He realizes
24:21in a kind of
24:21cold calculated way
24:23that losing his whole ship
24:24would be a worse outcome
24:25than losing a few
24:26of his men
24:27So he decides
24:29actively
24:30to steer closer
24:31to the Scylla
24:32There's a lesson here
24:36of course
24:36and the lesson is
24:37the most gentle
24:38and caring commander
24:39sometimes
24:40has to be willing
24:41to sacrifice
24:42some of his men
24:43in order to get
24:44the mission accomplished
24:45As they enter
24:48the strait
24:49the sky
24:50goes dark
24:51Suddenly
24:52multiple tsunamis
24:54appear
24:54out of nowhere
24:55Odysseus
25:00leads the ship
25:01away from
25:01the Charybdis
25:02As they pass by
25:06the giant whirlpool
25:07sucks up the ocean
25:08seizing everything
25:10within its reach
25:11Suddenly
25:14from the opposite
25:15side of the ship
25:16the Scylla
25:17strikes
25:17It snatches
25:30six men
25:31off the ship's deck
25:32and swallows them whole
25:34Odysseus
25:49Odysseus describes
25:51this as the worst
25:52moment
25:53of his travels
25:54His men
25:55being carried away
25:57in the mouths
25:57of this awful
25:58creature
25:58crying his name
26:00Odysseus
26:02help us
26:02help us
26:03and he can't
26:04and not only that
26:06Odysseus knows
26:07that those men
26:08are dying
26:08because of his
26:09decision
26:09For centuries
26:26scholars of the
26:27Odyssey puzzled
26:28over what might
26:28have inspired
26:29Homer's monstrous
26:30Scylla
26:31Then in the
26:37mid-1800s
26:38corpses of
26:39massive tentacle
26:40beasts
26:41washed up
26:41on shores
26:42across the globe
26:43This was the
26:46answer
26:46Giant Squid
26:49Overnight
26:52fiction
26:53became fact
26:54Giant Squid
26:57is a creature
26:57that's basically
26:58as long as
26:58a school bus
26:59Now imagine
27:00how big
27:01a giant squid
27:02had to look
27:03to sailors
27:03who were in
27:04boats that were
27:04just a few dozen
27:05feet long
27:06Was the Scylla
27:10based on real
27:11sightings of a
27:12giant squid?
27:16And what about
27:17its neighbor
27:17the whirlpool
27:19Charybdis?
27:21Modern oceanographers
27:22have discovered
27:23a giant whirlpool
27:24zone that matches
27:25its description
27:26in the narrow
27:27strait of Messina
27:28between Italy
27:29and Sicily
27:30To the north
27:31you have the
27:32Tyrrhenian Sea
27:33to the south
27:33the Ionian Sea
27:35The waters
27:36of the Tyrrhenian
27:37and Ionian
27:37Seas actually
27:38are quite different
27:39As a result
27:40the water moving
27:41back and forth
27:42through these
27:43straits
27:44is tremendously
27:45churned up
27:46and you get
27:47huge whirlpools
27:49and vicious tides
27:50We can scarcely
27:53imagine just how
27:54powerful they
27:55must have been
27:56back in ancient
27:56times
27:57especially for
27:57sailors who
27:58were going
27:58through them
27:59Giant squids
28:02treacherous whirlpools
28:04two real life
28:06threats faced
28:06by ancient sailors
28:07Could they have
28:09been the inspiration
28:10behind this
28:11chapter of the
28:12Odyssey?
28:12In the midst
28:18Odysseus has just
28:19seen six of his
28:21men torn apart
28:22by the Scylla
28:22When his ship
28:24reaches safety
28:25he gives in to
28:26his shell-shocked
28:27crew's demand
28:28for rest
28:29Despite the
28:31prophet Tiresias'
28:32warning to stay
28:33away from the
28:34sun god's cattle
28:35he agrees to
28:36make landfall
28:37on the island
28:37where the cattle
28:38are kept
28:39Odysseus
28:41sees the cattle
28:43and he says
28:44to his men
28:45Okay, we're on
28:46the island
28:46overnight
28:46Whatever you do
28:47don't eat
28:48those
28:48Do not eat
28:49those
28:49But with supplies
28:52running low
28:53and starvation
28:54setting in
28:55the crew
28:56disobeys Odysseus
28:57and butchers
28:58the cattle
28:58It will be the
29:01last meal
29:02they ever eat
29:04Helios
29:12Helios
29:12the sun god
29:13is furious
29:14and turns to
29:15Zeus
29:16the king of gods
29:17for justice
29:18Angering a god
29:21in antiquity
29:21was one of the
29:22worst moves
29:23you can make
29:23The gods
29:25didn't have
29:25a lot of
29:26qualms
29:27about using
29:27their powers
29:28to punish
29:29mortals
29:29that they
29:30disapproved of
29:31Zeus agrees
29:33to punish
29:34the trespassers
29:35He sends
29:37a perfect storm
29:38that strikes
29:39down
29:39Odysseus' ship
29:40All the men
29:49perish
29:49Except for one
29:56Odysseus is spared
30:01because he alone
30:03didn't eat
30:03the cattle
30:04But this is where
30:06the good news ends
30:07Now he has
30:09no men
30:09no boat
30:11and no idea
30:13where he is
30:19After three years
30:26at sea
30:26Odysseus
30:27has lost
30:28all his men
30:29and ships
30:29He is alone
30:31isolated
30:32and still
30:34no closer
30:34to home
30:35He is washed
30:39up on the
30:39island paradise
30:40of another
30:41beautiful
30:41seductress
30:42The nymph
30:44Calypso
30:45In Greek mythology
30:50nymphs were
30:52pretty young
30:52girls
30:53with magical
30:53powers
30:54Every man's
30:56wildest fantasy
30:57They lived
30:59in forests
31:01and in
31:01woodlands
31:02As their name
31:03implies
31:04nymphs
31:04or nymphomaniac
31:05is our English
31:06word
31:06They were very
31:07sprightly
31:08in their behavior
31:09At this point
31:15Odysseus
31:16is relieved
31:17just to be
31:18alive
31:18Washing up
31:19on the island
31:20of a beautiful
31:21nymph
31:21is an
31:22unexpected
31:22bonus
31:23While his
31:25wife Penelope
31:26faithfully
31:26preserves
31:27her chastity
31:28back home
31:28Odysseus
31:30treats himself
31:31to another
31:31extramarital
31:32tryst
31:33This time
31:35he winds up
31:35staying
31:36seven years
31:37Odysseus
31:43is given
31:43license
31:44to pretty
31:45much
31:45sleep
31:45with whoever
31:45he wants
31:46There doesn't
31:47seem to be
31:48in Homer's
31:49tale
31:49any particularly
31:50negative
31:51connotation
31:52that's attached
31:53to Odysseus'
31:54dalliances
31:54In fact
31:55they seem
31:55to make him
31:56into a greater
31:56more powerful
31:58kind of man
31:58because he can
31:59conquer all
32:00these women
32:01Calypso
32:04promises
32:05Odysseus
32:06immortality
32:06if he'll
32:07stay with
32:07her forever
32:08but he refuses
32:10knowing he must
32:11return to his
32:12wife
32:12and his
32:13kingdom
32:14In some
32:15ways
32:15it's a stupid
32:16choice
32:17to pick
32:18mortality
32:18and being a
32:20man
32:20over being
32:21a demigod
32:22but for
32:23Odysseus
32:24it's not a
32:24question
32:25he must
32:26reject
32:27Calypso
32:28he must
32:29leave
32:29Calypso
32:30to fulfill
32:31his fate
32:31as a man
32:32but with
32:35no ship
32:35to take
32:35him home
32:36Odysseus
32:38must take
32:38matters
32:38into his
32:39own hands
32:40he builds
32:44himself
32:44a boat
32:45for ancient
32:49Greeks
32:50carpentry
32:51was understood
32:52to be
32:52one of the
32:53great gifts
32:55and intellectual
32:56accomplishments
32:56in antiquity
32:57we often call
32:59Odysseus' craft
33:00a raft
33:01but it's anything
33:02but a raft
33:03it's got a mast
33:04it's got a rudder
33:05it's got gunnels
33:06it was a metaphor
33:08of his wisdom
33:09it's a part of
33:10his cleverness
33:11that he's able
33:12to be such
33:13a wise carpenter
33:14when the boat
33:17is finished
33:18Odysseus
33:19returns to sea
33:20he has spent
33:23nearly 20 years
33:24away from home
33:25now the end
33:27of the road
33:28is finally
33:28in sight
33:29and it's not
33:33a moment
33:34too soon
33:34back on the
33:36home front
33:36his loyal
33:37wife Penelope
33:38has exhausted
33:39all of her
33:40stall tactics
33:40to ward off
33:41the men
33:42who have
33:42pursued her
33:42year after year
33:44her suitors
33:46are losing
33:46their patience
33:47the suitors
33:48say he's not
33:49coming home
33:50he's not
33:50coming back
33:51his ship
33:52must have
33:52been destroyed
33:53on the way
33:54you must
33:55choose one
33:56of us
33:56as Odysseus'
33:58successor
33:59can Odysseus
34:01get back to
34:01Ithaca
34:02before it's
34:02too late
34:03like many
34:12elements of
34:13Homer's
34:13Odyssey
34:14the island
34:15home of
34:15Odysseus
34:16has a clear
34:17connection to
34:18reality
34:18for centuries
34:20scholars have
34:20pondered which
34:21Greek island
34:22the author had
34:22in mind
34:23when he wrote
34:24his epic story
34:25traditionally
34:27it is believed
34:27to be a Greek
34:28island known
34:29today as
34:30Ithaca
34:30but Homer's
34:33writings about
34:34Ithaca
34:34don't match up
34:36with its
34:36modern day
34:37namesake
34:37look at what
34:38Homer says
34:39Homer says
34:39Ithaca
34:40is the western
34:41island
34:42the furthest
34:43out to sea
34:44and it's low
34:44lying and
34:45you think
34:45hello this is
34:46completely wrong
34:47Ithaca is not
34:49the furthest
34:49out to the west
34:50it's not the
34:51furthest out to
34:52the sea
34:52when researchers
34:54compared ancient
34:55maps with
34:56modern day
34:57satellite images
34:57an island called
34:59Cephalonia
35:00next to Ithaca
35:01caught their
35:02attention
35:02it seemed to
35:04match Homer's
35:05description of
35:06Ithaca in
35:06every way
35:07but one
35:08what Homer
35:10describes is
35:11four islands
35:11he says there
35:12should be four
35:13islands here
35:13well we have a
35:15problem there's
35:16only really three
35:16where's the
35:17fourth island
35:18and he also
35:19says that
35:20Homer's Ithaca
35:21the disuse of
35:22Ithaca
35:22should be
35:22furthest to
35:23the west
35:23now you solve
35:25the problem
35:25if you split
35:27Cephalonia in
35:28half
35:28if you say
35:29that the
35:29western peninsula
35:30of Cephalonia
35:313000 years ago
35:33might have been
35:34a freestanding
35:35island
35:35could the
35:36single island
35:37once have
35:38been two
35:39in 2006
35:44a team of
35:45scientists
35:45set out to
35:46solve the
35:46mystery
35:47using high-tech
35:50surveying equipment
35:50the kind used
35:52in oil and gas
35:52exploration
35:53they drilled a
35:54400-foot hole
35:56into the ground
35:56of the low-lying
35:57valley that lies
35:59between Cephalonia's
36:00east and west
36:00branches
36:01if there was ever
36:03a split in the
36:03island this would
36:05have been the
36:05place
36:06we went on
36:08drilling until we
36:09ran out of drill
36:10stem actually and
36:11that was about 15
36:11meters below sea
36:12level and at no
36:13point did we hit
36:14solid mountain
36:15bedrock
36:16now you know
36:17how unlikely is
36:18that
36:19the simplest
36:20explanation of
36:21that is to say
36:21that at some
36:22point
36:23the sea went
36:24through that
36:24valley and you
36:25can still see
36:26residue of that
36:27today
36:27these results
36:29suggest that the
36:30valley was once
36:31underwater
36:31and it makes
36:33Cephalonia a prime
36:34candidate for being
36:35Homer's Ithaca
36:36the island
36:38Odysseus finally
36:39saw on the horizon
36:4020 years after he
36:42went off to fight
36:43the Trojan War
36:44Odysseus never gave
36:46up
36:46he spent years
36:47trying to get
36:48home but he was
36:49going to get home
36:49one way or another
36:50against all odds
36:57Odysseus is
36:59finally home
37:00it is the moment
37:15he has been dreaming
37:16about for the past
37:17two decades
37:18but there is no
37:20homecoming parade
37:21waiting for him
37:22instead the final
37:26arrangements are
37:27being made to
37:28redistribute his
37:28power
37:29unless he can pull
37:31off one more
37:32miracle
37:32Odysseus will lose
37:34everything he's
37:35fought to come
37:35home to
37:36it is the setup
37:39for a dramatic
37:40ending
37:40but could Odysseus'
37:42homecoming have
37:43really happened
37:43and if so
37:44when
37:45using clues
37:47buried in the
37:48Odyssey
37:48modern astronomers
37:49have been able to
37:50pinpoint the exact
37:51date Homer had in
37:53mind
37:53Odysseus' return to
38:07Ithaca was a journey
38:08that took 20 years
38:09sent over 600 men
38:11to their graves
38:12and 14 ships
38:14to the sea floor
38:15finally
38:21after all that
38:22the hero is home
38:24but is he too late
38:25to save his wife
38:26and his kingdom
38:28when Odysseus
38:30returns home
38:31his island
38:33kingdom of Ithaca
38:34is in a state
38:35of complete chaos
38:36everything has been
38:40going terribly wrong
38:41his wife is beset
38:43his household is beset
38:44by suitors
38:44108 suitors
38:46Odysseus realizes
38:54he can't just walk
38:55into his palace
38:56and reclaim
38:57his former life
38:58these suitors
38:59have long coveted
39:00his queen
39:01and his kingdom
39:02if they find out
39:04that Odysseus
39:05has returned
39:06they will undoubtedly
39:08try to kill him
39:09before he can
39:09recapture his throne
39:10one last time
39:13Odysseus must outwit
39:15outlast
39:16and outplay
39:17his enemies
39:18to survive
39:18when Odysseus
39:21arrives in Ithaca
39:22he doesn't come
39:23with a great following
39:25he doesn't arrive
39:26as the great
39:28returning king
39:29he actually
39:29disguises himself
39:31as an old beggar
39:34and he does this
39:36probably partially
39:37because he's not sure
39:39of what reception
39:40he'll receive
39:41meanwhile
39:44Odysseus' long
39:46suffering wife
39:47Penelope
39:47finally yields
39:48to the suitors
39:49pressure
39:49and announces
39:51an archery contest
39:52to determine
39:53her new husband
39:54whoever can string
39:56Odysseus' bow
39:57and shoot an arrow
39:58through twelve axes
39:59will win her hand
40:00in marriage
40:01it is the fateful day
40:13in Ithaca
40:14just before the game
40:23is about to begin
40:24Homer writes
40:25that the sun
40:26is blotted out
40:27of the sky
40:28for centuries
40:30this one line
40:31has been scrutinized
40:32is it a poetic device
40:34to build suspense
40:35or the record
40:36of a real event
40:37even the ancient Greeks
40:45thought this may be
40:46meant that
40:46Odysseus
40:47was returning home
40:48on the day
40:48of a total eclipse
40:50recently
40:52scientists
40:53examined the Odyssey
40:54for astronomical evidence
40:55that could reveal
40:56the exact date
40:57Homer was referring to
40:59they looked more closely
41:02at all the references
41:03in the Odyssey
41:04that might refer
41:06to something
41:07about astronomical events
41:09they then tried
41:10to match up
41:10those combinations
41:11of events
41:12with their eclipse dates
41:14and they found
41:18and they found
41:18that in fact
41:19it all matched
41:20for one of those eclipses
41:21one that took place
41:22on April 16th
41:241178 BC
41:26so it's possible
41:28that that was the day
41:31when Odysseus
41:32returned home
41:33to Penelope
41:34in the myth
41:41a two decade pursuit
41:43of Penelope
41:43now comes down
41:44to one main event
41:45one suitor
41:48after another
41:49proves too weak
41:50to string
41:51Odysseus' bow
41:52they are all
41:56about to give up
41:56when a tattered beggar
41:59steps forward
42:00and the beggar
42:02steps up
42:03and wants a turn
42:03but by the rules
42:05he should have a turn
42:06their response
42:08is to
42:09be irate
42:10and to deride him
42:13but the beggar
42:17strings the bow
42:18without any hesitation
42:20and the laughing
42:22suddenly stops
42:23he lines up his shot
42:26it flies
42:31straight through
42:32the 12 axe handles
42:33the contest is over
42:37but the suitors
42:39are not about
42:39to give up
42:40without a fight
42:41Odysseus' final battle
42:50ends with the suitors
42:51slaughtered
42:51and the hero victorious
42:53he has won back
43:01his throne
43:01now he has to win back
43:05his woman
43:06the king of cunning
43:08has one last test
43:10to pass
43:10after Odysseus
43:12has slaughtered
43:12all the suitors
43:13then he and Penelope
43:15enjoy a very intimate moment
43:16and they sit across
43:17from each other
43:18lit only by firelight
43:19Penelope has one last test
43:22after a long conversation
43:24she says to her servants
43:26I want this stranger
43:27to be comfortable
43:28so please
43:29bring my own bed
43:30out of my chambers
43:31and put it on the porch
43:32and let this stranger
43:33sleep in my own bed
43:34at that point
43:36Odysseus realizes
43:38that his wife
43:39is giving him
43:39a final test
43:40and he says
43:41Penelope
43:41I know this is a test
43:43I built our bed
43:44around this tree
43:45rooted
43:46into the ground
43:47our bed
43:48cannot be moved
43:49because
43:49she has never
43:50let anyone inside
43:52of that bedroom
43:52she knows for sure
43:54only Odysseus
43:55would know
43:55that that bed
43:56is not movable
43:56Odysseus' long journey
44:01his odyssey
44:02is at its end
44:04but his legend
44:05will endure
44:07it was common
44:09among ancient
44:10Greek warriors
44:11to have as a decoration
44:12on their armor
44:13the figure of Odysseus
44:15he was there for them
44:17as a symbol
44:17of someone
44:18who had always
44:19endured pain
44:19Odysseus' very name
44:21in Greek
44:22means
44:23man of pain
44:24he suffers
44:26like all of us suffer
44:27but maybe
44:30unlike all of us
44:31Odysseus
44:31always also
44:32endures
44:33so it's that ability
44:38I think
44:39to always get back up
44:40after being knocked down
44:41that makes him
44:42a character
44:43that's so relatable
44:44to people
44:44over many centuries
44:45he's pernah
44:46he's
44:59and he's
45:00one guy
45:00and he
45:01now
45:03he
45:04down
45:04he
45:05he
45:06has been
45:06he
45:07he
45:07now
45:07zo
Recommended
53:20
|
Up next
44:52
44:50
44:50
45:00
44:50
44:51
44:53
45:02
45:01
44:53
44:51
45:00
45:00
45:02
1:00
58:04
Be the first to comment