- 1 year ago
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00The quality of education depends on the competence of its teachers.
00:04In response to falling standard, the federal government is moving to sanitize this profession
00:08by flushing out unqualified teachers. Today, we will be looking at the federal government
00:13moving to flush out unqualified teachers nationwide. And we are doing this alongside
00:18our esteemed guest, Professor Fawoyumi, a seasoned educationist. I am Temitayo Olumothe.
00:25Welcome to Guardian Talk.
00:30All right, welcome, Professor Abayomi Fawoyumi. Welcome to Guardian Talks.
00:41First of all, in a decisive move, the Minister of Education, Dr. Tundia Lausa, has mandated
00:47the immediate removal of unqualified teachers from classrooms across the country. And this
00:52happened during a recent education stakeholders forum where Dr. Lausa stressed the importance
00:58of upholding professional standards, declaring that this is not a business as usual. How
01:03do you make sense of this statement from the Minister of Education?
01:06I want to commend the Minister for Education for this direction is taking. And I'm endorsing
01:16and congratulating him and celebrating for the fact that we are taking decisive actions about
01:22the questions about having unqualified teachers teaching our children. By law and by the expectations
01:28of the United Nations and by the law of Nigeria, every Nigerian child has a right to quality education.
01:34And part of the ingredients of quality education is the quality of teaching, which includes teachers
01:40and the teaching equipment. So it's great we're going in this direction. It's also important to mention that
01:46when he said those teachers will be removed, it then becomes problematic because of the fact
01:53that he knows himself that they can't be removed. Because the reality of this is that if you check
01:58the arithmetic of the situation, the number of unqualified teachers that we have in Nigeria,
02:03we don't even know. We don't know. Because don't forget, we don't even know the number of schools
02:09we have in Nigeria. I mean, that's a fact. Nigeria had to rely on the external funded agency SPIN to
02:16count the number of schools we have in Nigeria. Research done by people like two SPIN has shown
02:20that the numbers have been estimated over a couple of years. As we speak now, somebody may just start
02:25a school today and will not be registered and we will not have the data. So if we can't get all
02:33schools registered, how do you want to get all teachers in those schools registered?
02:38Let's now move to, because you made mention of something that is very, very strong, a strong
02:43point at that, that how do we even get to number the unqualified teachers across the country? And
02:49that's really a big question. That moves me to how do we even get to the point where we
02:55are having or having to deal with unqualified teachers in our education system?
03:00Okay, great questions. Thanks for asking. I mean, if we want to categorize our schools based on sectors,
03:07there are two categories of schools in Nigeria. You have the primary, the public schools and the
03:11private schools. By the public schools, I mean schools owned by the government. By the private
03:16schools, I mean schools owned by anything that is not government. So it includes private, individual
03:21companies, non-profits, churches, mosques, and things like that. So if we do that categorization.
03:26There are unqualified teachers in public schools in Nigeria. So even the schools that Dr. Lausa said
03:34he wants to send teachers from, he has their unqualified teachers there. And why is that the
03:39case? It's just because of the fact that the reality of this is that we keep sending unqualified
03:44teachers to our government school. A very good example that doesn't mean any argument is the NYC
03:49teachers scheme. A good number of public schools in Nigeria rely on NYC to teach their students.
03:55When I was in school, I was in secondary schools in the 80s. I had teachers who are NYC
04:00who are NYC that studied all manner of courses that taught me they were not qualified. And I
04:06attended a federal government college. That has not changed. There are people that have argued that
04:10they go to a school and they were the only graduates sent by NYC to the school. We have heard reports
04:16of people that said they go to the school and they became the vice principal or they became
04:20whatever they were. So in government schools, we have unqualified teachers. So that's what should
04:26be easier for Dr. Lausa to do. And he starts from there. But he knows he can't start from there
04:31because those teachers belong to unions. And the Nigerian union of teachers will likely resist that.
04:36Um, so let's talk about the private school. Now, why do we have cases of unqualified teachers
04:42in private schools? It's because of the range of private schools we have in Nigeria. So we have
04:46the high fee paying schools that target the elites that can afford to have qualified teachers. And then
04:52we have at the other extreme, the schools that will have low fee paying or some even no fee paying.
05:00And because it's of, they don't pay so, the students don't pay so much of tuition fee. Um,
05:06the schools can afford the kind of teachers we're talking about. So as a result of that,
05:11they have to rely on unqualified teachers. So the question today, access,
05:17so that's how we go there. It's a question of economics. Uh, if you want to have qualified
05:22teachers, qualified classroom, qualified, everything for a private sector,
05:26then the school fees is going to increase and many people cannot afford it. You can't be the
05:31poverty capital of Nigeria and be selective when it comes to teachers you have in your classrooms.
05:36Because we have, we have schools in Nigeria today where the, the parents of the kids are so poor,
05:42they can't pay per time.
05:45They pay per day. So children or people who are daily paid workers, the father comes from work and
05:51he has changed. If he doesn't have money for tomorrow's class, the child does not go there.
05:55So we have classic schools today, for example, that has to rely on those people. Again,
05:59there are structural reasons why that's the case. Another case in point, think about it. States,
06:03I won't mention the name of the state for obvious reasons. There are states, for example, that keep
06:07students in SS2 for too long because the state government, for example, pays the YAG fees and
06:15they want to only pay YAG fees for those that are very, very brilliant. So anybody who doesn't get
06:20a particular mark does not leave SS2. So people repeat SS2 the first time, the second time, they
06:27just want to become teachers in this low fee paying school. And the reality of this is that in Nigeria,
06:33particularly in some states, those are the people meeting the needs of the educational needs of
06:38people at the bottom of the pyramid. So that's the challenge we are dealing with. So in the public
06:42sector, there are, there are, there are, there are untrained and qualified teachers that are protected by
06:48unions or protected by institutions like NYSE. I have to interject here. I have to interject here,
06:55Professor. I mean, if we say the NYSE is actually sending students or sending core members to schools,
07:03to government schools to go and teach, shouldn't there be a form of training for these core members
07:10before they are even being, you know, sent to any of the government schools to go and teach? Because
07:16it's seeming like either you have a background in teaching or you don't have any background in
07:20teaching, you just go to these governments and go and teach. And maybe at the end of the day,
07:24they get peanuts.
07:25Dr. Yeah, I mean, you make a very great point. And interestingly, this same minister at some time
07:31ago had actually recommended that the NYSE will become a two-year program where people also get
07:37the certification to go and teach. If he has started doing that, then it becomes easy. But that has not
07:41been done. And he has also come back to say, that's not what I meant. So we can't, we really sometimes,
07:49I mean, sometimes our public officials sometimes don't speak as if they recognize the enormity
07:55of the issue they are dealing with, right? They are, as of today, some schools rely on NYSE
08:02for teachers. So maybe an opportunity we have is that in the orientation of CAP, they start to have
08:08people that have some training, some quick, fast training. It's not effective, it's not thorough,
08:14but something to start. At least a process. Yeah. And I think it's a recommendation that
08:19that can happen during orientation. It can also happen along the time of the NYSE, where maybe,
08:25for example, there are CBTs that COPPA can use, or some training guide for what we teach every NYSE
08:32sent to a school. So if you are posted to a school, that will just be a portal that you can download how
08:37to deal with adolescent, how to understand learning, how to write study notes. Something like that can be
08:44done to help at the end of the day. Because again, one part of the conversation we should not forget
08:49is that this fascination on qualified teachers essentially refers to not having TRCN certificates.
08:57So you could be a good teacher, but you don't have TRCN certificates, right? So it's just, it's if
09:04and if you remember where he made those pronouncements, it was with reference to a regulatory body. So
09:09the question of, so because somebody does not have a TRCN certificate,
09:15but he's a good teacher and he's getting good results, should we chase him out? I don't think so.
09:19Let us also remember that we have had cases where some governments have tried to do this. Remember,
09:24it happened in Farah State. You remember the most, the one that brought both noise was the one that
09:29happened in Kanuna State, when Nero Pai was going up. And he said he was going to sack them. Oh, there was a lot of
09:34noise. It was sacked them. She sacked them and all of that. What happened? The union came in, there were court cases, all of them are back in the system. So
09:41it's not a little, but the good thing is that we're agreeing is a problem. And then we can start to
09:48gradually, what I would expect the minister to have said is all unqualified teachers who are currently
09:54teaching to have a one or two year gap to write their exams. That looks like a plan. But then you can
10:02put a mandate and put a target for the TRCN to ensure that exams are written every month, not the
10:08number of times they do, so that they can capture everybody. I can actually recommend that the exam
10:12should become CPT, so I can be current and model and write the exam, right? So we can quickly rev up that
10:20process, which is something that I think you should do. Right. We're flushing them out, right?
10:26Okay, so let's look at the quarterly performance checks that he also made mention, because he said
10:33aside from flushing out, there's going to also be quarterly tech performance to improve the quality
10:38of teaching and learning in Nigeria. So how will the introduction of this quarterly performance checks
10:44improve the quality of teaching and learning in Nigeria classrooms?
10:50You know, the minister is a medical doctor. Okay. So he's also, he's also in, you know,
10:58he's also doing education. Maybe I should also ask him whether he's also qualified to be a minister
11:05I mean, because what he's saying is introducing is what we have already had. There's an inspectorate
11:11education of the federal ministry of education. There's an inspectorate in all the state ministry of
11:15education. Their duty is to inspect and do that. You remember those days when you were in schools,
11:21you will hear people come, they'll say people are coming from ministry to come and inspect.
11:24That's what they come to do. They come to inspect teaching, teaching quality, quality of teaching
11:29notes and all of that. But the federal ministry and state ministry dropped the ball. So when he said
11:35we will start, we're not starting. We had this. He died. So he's just resurrected and that's part of his role as a minister. So it's not
11:41they will play. What will happen before was that. And I feel if we do that to be very effective. But again,
11:48the question is, where are we going to get those inspectors that will go to every school in Nigeria? Remember,
11:54and this is very important. We don't know all the schools we have in Nigeria. As we speak today,
11:58there are some people that will start schools today by just opening or using the bedroom in their house.
12:04And the school has started. We had a case many years ago where a governor in Lagos state came
12:09and said Lagos state was going to, you know, it was, it was where it was sworn in that part of his
12:15goal is that all unregistered schools in Lagos will be closed down. And then there was some engagement
12:20that will say, hey, you don't even know the data. So when the governor got the data in that time,
12:25there was no, the data came from a work that was done by DFID 15 project. And the data came out to
12:33say the number of unregistered schools in your state is more than the public schools in your state.
12:39And the number is increasing. As we speak today, I mean, go to areas in Lagos like Makoko,
12:45go to rural areas. There are people starting schools or as, as, as you can imagine, there are churches,
12:51mosques, starting schools in the evening. Now this is vacation time. Um, this is about time for
12:56vacation in Nigeria. Somebody is going to say, I'm going to start coaching for people. And then by
13:01the beginning or end of coaching, he says, you can come and start primary one or primary two.
13:06Uh, there is what they call a Yoruba land, jealousy, which is a pre, pre, pre, pre, pre primary education.
13:13Yes. Yes. Jealousy, early, early child education. Many of those jealousy mean they, they don't charge so
13:19much and the parents will come and tell the person, why don't you let's start primary one?
13:22And then the person starts primary one and then let's start primary two. And then the person
13:25just keeps doing it. And it's, that's where we have because of the level of poverty.
13:31I mean, let's also remember, parents are not fools. Parents make irrational people.
13:37Why will a parent send his child to a school that has untrained teachers? Because that's what they can
13:43afford. Now, let me tell you what we amuse you. That is what the minister should also be concerned about.
13:49I had to go do a walk in a, in a, in a village, uh, somewhere in the southwest of Nigeria.
13:55The number of schools in the unregistered private school was more than the number of,
14:01the number of students in the public school that was free. So these villagers,
14:07there is a public school in their community. It's free. They send their children. They don't
14:13send their children to that free public school. They send their children to a private school in this
14:18village where they pay fees. So I spoke to one of the women and, and the mothers. I said,
14:24so what, why, why do you send your child? There is a free school there. She told me something that
14:28I've never forgotten. He said, sir, when a child goes to the public school that is free, the child
14:33can't speak English in, in good time. But when a child goes to, um, um, goes to the, the private
14:42school, the child will learn to speak English after one time. Do you know the funniest thing about
14:48private school? They have only one teacher for the sixth classes? Wow. Yes. But that one teacher
14:56is effective enough that this mother said, when I send my child there, my child will learn to speak
15:03English after one time. So parents are making rational decisions. They are making rational
15:08decisions based on what they see in terms of learning outcomes. They are making rational
15:12in terms of what they can afford. And we need to accept that. I think what we should do is to set
15:18the targets. Any teacher who is not registered, you have two years to become registered. We give
15:25that target to every teacher. We also give a target to the teacher's registration council, say to me,
15:30this targets start to make, turn your exams to become CBT. Run the exams every month so that anybody
15:37can write it. If somebody fails in January, can write it. I mean, just make it an IALTS.
15:41And then you will get more people registered. But again, please note this emphasis on certificates
15:47as proof of registration itself. You actually, you've taken my final question from my mouth,
15:54because I was going to ask the role, uh, what role should teachers, teacher training, uh, institutions
16:01and regulatory bodies play in ensuring that only qualified professionals enter and remain in our
16:07education system. So you're already tilting towards it. So you can, you have the floor.
16:13Yeah. I mean, the question to ask is that when you say, what role do they have? Don't forget,
16:19we can't stop. No, no, no, we can. We have not been able to stop unregistered schools. So if you
16:26cannot stop the school, how do you want to stop the teacher? I mean, it's the problem starts with,
16:33you can't even stop them, the school. You are talking about the teacher. So, but part of the
16:37role of the regulatory system and what they, I think they can do, and they have a very brilliant
16:42technocrat there, Mrs. Huombo, that I believe will be able to make a difference is to let the,
16:48let the certification present very important. Let me also mention that what researchers found is that
16:54the free training is very important, but the post training is more important in terms of quality and
17:02retention. So a child goes to a college of education, a student goes to a college of education,
17:06writes the exams, they becomes a qualified teacher. Data shows that is very good. But what data shows
17:13is that what happens when the person starts teaching for the first two years, what kind of training,
17:18in-service training does he get? What kind of mentoring does he get? What kind of supervision does
17:23he or she get in those first two years? With the timing, the kind of teacher will become,
17:27with the kind to determine the quality of teaching he will do. And finally, it will determine whether
17:32the person will be retained or not. So it's, it's, it's, the question of training is a balanced
17:39approach that emphasizes pre-training before you enter a classroom, and then the unsound mentoring
17:46and in-service training when you get to class. I think the minister should put his attention more
17:51on those trainings. Right. Getting certificates. So he should pay attention to more trainings than
17:58flushing out the unqualified and giving the unqualified a period of time to make sure they
18:03get qualified. And if you're not, you can't be taken out of the system, isn't it? He knows,
18:08he knows they can't flush them out. He's a medical doctor. Have you flushed out the doctor's
18:12unqualified medical personnel in Nigeria? Oh!
18:15You always read in the newspapers a fake lawyer was caught somewhere in court, a fake doctor, a fake
18:22nurse, a fake, I mean, we have not flushed that in those life-threatening situations. He knows
18:29himself that he can't flush nobody out. They are protected by various laws, various unions, they'll go
18:35to labor. All the people that El Rufay claimed they flushed out in Cardinal States, did they not go to
18:40court? Did they not win? Are they not back in service? We should stop using this. And you know the
18:45funniest thing about, I mean, because of my background in HR, if you hired me and you know
18:50I was not qualified, you hired me, so I'm a staff, you can't then constantly say you are sacking me
18:55because I'm not qualified because you knew before you hired me. However, as an employer, you can tell
19:01me I must become qualified in the next two years. But you can't say you sacked me because I am not
19:07qualified because you hired me knowing I was not qualified. The principle of legal law that what you
19:12condone, you can't condemn. So, you have a qualified teacher who has been teaching in
19:17King's College or Badon Grammar School or Undo Boisa School for the last 10 years.
19:22They're not saying you want to flush him away. He's going to go to court and he's
19:25going to win because you have condoned him for 10 years. The minister himself knows. So,
19:30well, let me say I assume the minister should know.
19:33Wow. Thank you so much, Professor Abaya Mufawa. I mean, thank you for this interesting conversation
19:39we just had. And I really hope the minister and every other agency involved in this can
19:45look at the better and a bigger picture to actually tackling this, not just the unqualified
19:50teachers, but the schools too that are not registered properly. I mean, if we can deal with that of the
19:56schools, we can actually handle that of the unqualified teachers very well. Thank you for your
20:01intelligence submission. We really appreciate you, sir. All right.
20:05All right. Thank you. Have a nice day. Yeah. Bye.
20:07Have a good day. Bye.
20:08Improving education starts with empowering the right people to teach. Thank you so much,
20:14Professor Fawai Emi for joining us today on Guardian Talks. I am Temi Tayo, Olummofeh.
20:20Thanks for watching.