Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 year ago
Dive deep into the intricacies of President Trump's latest tax and spending law with our comprehensive guide, "Inside Trump's Tax and Spending Law: Uncovering Medicaid Cuts & a 'Backdoor Abortion Ban'." Understand how these changes may impact you and your community in an easy-to-read format.

Category

🎈
Fun
Transcript
00:00There have been many Supermans, supermen, and now, after much anticipation, there is another.
00:06And the new Superman movie is pretty great, and it's bringing exactly what we are looking for, hope.
00:13We'll tell you why on Pop Culture Happy Hour.
00:15Listen on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:20Hi, this is Megan in Hartford, Connecticut.
00:22I'm walking out of my last supervised shift as a pediatric emergency medicine fellow doctor
00:28after 11 years of medical training.
00:30This podcast was recorded at 1.05 p.m. Eastern Time on Tuesday, July 8, 2025.
00:37Things may have changed by the time you hear this, but I will be thoroughly enjoying some time off
00:41before starting back here as a pediatric emergency medicine attending doctor
00:46at the same hospital where I was a patient as a child
00:49and the place that helped inspire me to become a pediatrician.
00:52Enjoy the show.
00:53Oof, that's a big job.
00:58That's so cool, though.
00:59Yeah, very cool. Congratulations.
01:01Hey there, it's the NPR Politics Podcast.
01:03I'm Ashley Lopez. I cover politics.
01:06I'm Deirdre Walsh. I cover Congress.
01:07And NPR health correspondent Katia Riddle is here.
01:10Welcome to the pod, Katia.
01:11Hi, thanks for having me.
01:13And today we're taking a look at how the big tax cut and spending bill
01:16President Trump recently signed into law will affect health care.
01:20Katia, there's been a lot of focus on cuts and changes to Medicaid.
01:24This is the government program that provides health insurance to people who are low income
01:28or have disabilities.
01:29Can you tell me what exactly is happening to the program?
01:33Yeah, so the Congressional Budget Office is saying that the cut will save close to $1 trillion.
01:39And one of the primary ways they'll be realizing these savings is through increasing the demands
01:45around paperwork and the work requirements.
01:48Most states will now require that people volunteer or work 80 hours a month.
01:55Proving that can be onerous, though.
01:57If you're balancing a bunch of different gig economy jobs, for example, it may be difficult
02:02to document the number of hours that you worked, especially if you just have to keep doing
02:07that frequently.
02:08So if people fail to do that, then they will be kicked off the program.
02:12So, Katia, some states have already experimented with things like additional Medicaid work
02:18requirements and more paperwork.
02:20How did those experiments fare in states that took them up?
02:25Yeah, so as you said, you know, this is an experiment that we've run before on a smaller
02:30scale in several states.
02:32Arkansas and Georgia are two of the states that have tried this.
02:36In both of those places, we've seen a lot of administrative hassle and confusion.
02:41For example, in Arkansas, it was difficult just to reach and find all the people that
02:49they needed to to inform them of these changes.
02:51And then once they did find them, many people didn't have the computer literacy that they
02:57needed or the access to the Internet in order to comply with the program and file all the
03:04paperwork that they needed to.
03:07In Georgia, the program is ongoing and it has ended up costing the state a lot of money,
03:13significantly more per patient than they were expecting.
03:17And they've spent just more on administration than they have on health care.
03:21Yeah, and I want to talk about how these cuts would affect health care in general.
03:27We're talking about the Medicaid cuts here.
03:29Like, how would this affect people who maybe aren't even part of that program?
03:33Yeah, you know, the Biden administration really pumped a lot of money into the Affordable
03:37Care Act, health insurance, and it made it more affordable than it had been in the past.
03:44So this law takes away that extra funding.
03:47And it's also going to make it harder to actually get the insurance.
03:53You know, people generally just don't like to think about their health insurance.
03:57They want it to be there for them when they're sick.
04:01By increasing the administrative burdens or increasing the price, that is just going to
04:06make it more difficult for people to get it and then to use it when they need it.
04:11The CBO says millions of people as a result of these changes will lose their health insurance.
04:16I think the other thing that's worth noting here, too, is that Republicans structured this
04:24so that a lot of the changes to Medicaid, both to people who are eligible and the work
04:30requirements and the way states finance their own Medicaid programs in partnership with the
04:35federal government, Medicaid as a state-federal partnership.
04:38And states rely on provider taxes to help them sort of increase the amount of money they get
04:48from the federal government to cover Medicaid programs.
04:52This issue, a lot of lawmakers worry, will have a particular impact on rural hospitals because
04:59those states rely more on the sort of existing system that helps those states get a certain
05:04amount of money from the federal government.
05:05That's going to be cut because of the changes in this new law.
05:10And although those don't go into effect until 2028, there is still some concerns about the
05:17financial viability of rural hospitals and what that means for anyone seeking care, right?
05:23It's not just people on Medicaid that go to rural hospitals.
05:26It's people on private insurance who can't drive a couple of hours to get to more urban medical
05:33centers.
05:33Yeah, I mean, and even though like the bulk of these cuts to Medicaid don't take effect
05:38for a little while, we are already seeing Democrats, you know, starting to campaign on this issue.
05:43Deidre, what are you seeing so far from Democrats?
05:46Right.
05:46I mean, even before the votes on these bills, just throughout the debate, Democrats in both
05:52the House and the Senate were targeting Republicans who represent swing districts, Republicans in Senate
05:59races this year about the Republican bill focusing on getting a lot of the savings from the Medicaid
06:08program and what that would mean for people in their districts.
06:12And this week, we're starting to see some of the actual political ads.
06:16Both the campaign arms for Democrats in the House and the Senate have released digital ads in the last
06:24couple of days that target Republicans who voted for these bills.
06:29A lot of the ads in the House districts focused on lawmakers and the impact on rural hospitals.
06:35Some of the Senate focused ads are more on, you know, sort of numbers of people in those states that could be impacted by Medicaid.
06:44And I think Republicans on the flip side are really trying to explain the benefits of the bill because so much of the debate was like, oh, the split inside the Republican Party on Medicaid.
06:57And now I think they're trying to get out and educate people about, you know, the things in the bill like no tax on tips, no tax on overtime that will potentially boost certain people that supported Trump.
07:10Yeah, I wonder how effective that's going to be considering that more than 78 million Americans, right, are enrolled in either Medicaid or CHIP, the children's health insurance programs.
07:19I mean, how effective will that actually be for Republicans to sort of like the look over here approach?
07:24Because this is a lot of Americans who could potentially be affected by these cuts.
07:29I mean, I think it's kind of early to predict or to speculate, you know, how effective ads will be.
07:33I mean, the midterm elections are not till November of 2026.
07:37But I mean, I think you could look back at the 2018 midterm after Republicans had a trifecta and controlled both chambers of Congress and Trump was president, where there was an effort to repeal the Affordable Care Act ultimately didn't pass.
07:53But Democrats campaigned on that issue and won back control of the House.
08:00All right, we're going to take a quick break.
08:01More in a moment.
08:02This summer, ditch land with Shortwave's Sea Camp.
08:07Because when's the last time you had an ocean getaway?
08:09Every Monday, we bring you insights from a different ocean zone, starting with the sunlit surface until we hit the deep sea floor where there's marine snow, weird critters, carbon sinks and so much more.
08:21But first, you got to take the plunge.
08:23Follow NPR's Shortwave wherever you get your podcasts.
08:27Have you heard people saying things like palm-colored people?
08:32That would be white people.
08:34Or unalive.
08:35Could be, depending on context, it could be kill, murder, suicide, anything related to death.
08:41Listen to how self-censorship online impacts the way we talk about real-life issues.
08:47That's on Code Switch from NPR wherever you get your podcasts.
08:52I want to tell you a dirty little secret.
08:55Gen Z is not getting it on.
08:58Gen Z is having sex later in less than past generations.
09:01But I would say that they are, in general, not less horny.
09:04But wait, then why aren't they having sex?
09:07Fear around sex really doesn't lead people to want to have it.
09:10Why might Gen Z be scared of sex?
09:13Listen to the It's Been a Minute podcast today.
09:17And we're back.
09:18Katia, one of the law's provisions specifically targets Planned Parenthood.
09:23The organization just won a temporary injunction against that provision from taking effect for two weeks.
09:28But can you explain to me, like, what that provision does?
09:32Yeah, so the law, it doesn't actually say the words Planned Parenthood.
09:36But it makes it illegal for states to make Medicaid payments to nonprofits that offer abortion and receives more than $800,000 in federal funding.
09:46I want to lay this out clearly because it gets confusing.
09:49It is already illegal to use federal funds to pay for abortions in all but a few extreme circumstances.
09:56So what this provision does is it disallows for providers who offer abortion to take Medicaid for any reason.
10:05Planned Parenthood has become known as a provider of abortion care.
10:09But it also provides a lot of other basic reproductive health care, things like cancer screening and birth control, STI testing.
10:18So two things.
10:19One, it threatens clinics that provide this basic care.
10:23Many are in rural parts of the country.
10:26Planned Parenthood is warning that 200 clinics across the country are now in jeopardy.
10:31And two, by closing these clinics or potentially closing them, it ends access to abortion even in states where the procedure is legal.
10:40I spoke last week to an attorney for Planned Parenthood in Wisconsin.
10:45There are 21 Planned Parenthood clinics across that state.
10:48And she called this a, quote, backdoor abortion ban.
10:51You know, in theory, Planned Parenthood could still receive Medicaid payments if it stopped providing abortion.
10:58But the organization has said vehemently that it will never stop.
11:03I also want to talk about SNAP.
11:04This is also one of the changes that Congress made.
11:08This was the focus of some negotiations that ultimately helped get Alaska's Republican Senator Lisa Murkowski to vote for the bill.
11:14Can you explain what changed as they got Murkowski on board?
11:18So, like Medicaid, Republicans, in terms of trying to get some savings, added new work requirements to SNAP, requirements for people enrolled in the program to demonstrate that they're trying to get a job working or in a job training program or educational program in order to qualify for the program.
11:41Murkowski, who represents Alaska, made the case to Republican leaders really at the 9th hour, 10th hour, I don't know, the middle of night, whenever those negotiations took place, that Alaska has traditionally had a very high error rate in terms of SNAP people applying to the program, being in the program.
12:03And that parents of children need to be in the program for older children, right?
12:10Initially, the bill that came over from the House had a requirement that, you know, parents of young children were exempted from these requirements.
12:19But once their kids got older, they needed to meet these work requirements.
12:24Murkowski made the case that the age needed to be 14 and over.
12:29She made the case that it's much harder for parents in Alaska to have child care to be able to meet those work requirements.
12:37So they changed the age, they changed the state requirements for what kind of paperwork they needed to be able to submit.
12:46And it just shows you that how much, you know, the narrow concerns of one state's program can impact what's going to happen nationally.
12:56Because by changing these and allowing a state with a higher error rate to still get some kind of carve out, it's almost an incentive for other states to not be as diligent about some of these paperwork requirements, because they'll also just say we need more time.
13:17And that sort of defeats the Republican aim in the bill, which was we're adding all these requirements to eliminate waste, fraud, and abuse to streamline the program for people who are most deserving of these federal assistance programs.
13:31So the SNAP cuts work by changing the work requirements and eligibility for people to qualify.
13:38One change specifically is around age.
13:41It used to be that the work requirements applied to people 54 and younger, but they've changed that to 64 specifically for SNAP eligibility.
13:52Yeah. So, Deirdre, I mean, you kind of got to this a little bit, but, you know, President Trump has said that these cuts are about reducing waste, fraud and abuse in these programs.
14:01I mean, do you think this legislation is actually likely to accomplish that goal?
14:05I mean, I think the reason why Republicans and the president keep focusing on that is because the president made a very specific campaign promise that no one was going to touch Medicaid, that people weren't going to be cut.
14:18And they focus on the changes to the program being only waste, fraud and abuse.
14:24But as we've seen from the independent scorekeeper, the Congressional Budget Office, the changes to Medicaid are expected to generate nearly a trillion dollars in cuts.
14:35That is more than you could get from waste, fraud and abuse.
14:38That is from what CBO says is an estimated 12 million people losing their health care coverage because of the changes in this bill.
14:48So, you know, I think the other political argument that Republicans have been making about the changes to Medicaid, essentially financing the tax cuts in this bill, is that they are trying to focus on keeping Medicaid focused on the people that it was originally intended for, low income, disabled, elderly.
15:09But as we talked about earlier, when Obamacare passed, there was a huge increase to the numbers of people getting health care through Medicaid in the states.
15:21And a lot of people like their health care.
15:24The program is popular.
15:26It's not just low income, elderly, disabled.
15:29It's a lot of, you know, people who can't get health insurance through their jobs and are getting it through state exchanges.
15:35Yeah.
15:36Different political matter, giving benefits as opposed to taking it away.
15:40Yeah.
15:40All right.
15:41Let's leave it there for today.
15:43Katia, thanks so much for joining us today.
15:45Thanks for having me.
15:46I'm Ashley Lopez.
15:47I cover politics.
15:48I'm Deirdre Walsh.
15:49I cover Congress.
15:50And thank you for listening to the NPR Politics Podcast.
16:02It doesn't matter if you're a fan or not.
16:05We have to talk about Season 7 of Love Island, USA.
16:08It's a huge indication to me of this kind of generation of people who don't know how to be open and vulnerable.
16:17I'm Brittany Luce.
16:18And on this episode of It's Been a Minute, I want to show you how reality TV is getting a little too real by revealing what it's really like to date today.
16:27Listen to the It's Been a Minute podcast today.
16:29I'm Jesse Thorne.
16:32On Bullseye, George Takei, he talks about when he learned he was gay.
16:36He was growing up in L.A., surrounded by Mexican-American kids.
16:39I realized I was different in another way.
16:42But this difference was not visible.
16:45It was inside me.
16:46Plus, we remember the life and work of one of America's greatest pop musicians, Sly Stone.
16:51It's on Bullseye for MaximumFun.org and NPR.
16:55These days, there's so much news, it can be hard to keep up with what it all means for you, your family, and your community.
17:01The Consider This podcast from NPR features our award-winning journalism.
17:05Six days a week, we bring you a deep dive on a news story and provide the context and analysis that helps you make sense of the news.
17:12We get behind the headlines.
17:14We get to the truth.
17:16Listen to the Consider This podcast from NPR.

Recommended