• 1 year ago
During a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing last week, Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT) asked DOJ nominee, Stanley Woodward, about the delegation of lawmaking authority to federal agencies.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00I would be happy to, Senator.
00:02On behalf of the chair, Senator Lee.
00:05Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to all of you for being here,
00:09and especially for your willingness to serve.
00:10Mr. Adlo, let's start with you.
00:12The Biden administration turned a lot of things on their heads.
00:17One of the many things they turned on their heads
00:19involves the optional practical training program,
00:23and they turned it into the single largest guest worker program,
00:27bypassing the traditional limitations,
00:29the traditional rules that would otherwise apply by operation of law
00:33on other visas like H-1B in the United States.
00:37What changes would you plan, if confirmed,
00:40to make in order to fix that issue?
00:43Thank you, Senator.
00:45I think the way in which OPT has been handled over the past four years
00:50with the help of certain decisions coming out of the D.C. Circuit Court
00:54have been a real problem in terms of misapplication
00:58of the law.
01:00What I want to see would be essentially a regulatory
01:03and sub-regulatory program that would allow us to remove the ability
01:08for employment authorizations for F-1 students beyond the time
01:12that they are in school.
01:14Right.
01:15Mr. Guiser, I'd like to turn to you next.
01:19You're an issues and appeals guy.
01:21You've clerked for two Federal Court of Appeals judges,
01:25Judges Rao and Edith Jones,
01:28two of the very best judges we've ever had in the U.S. Courts of Appeals,
01:33and also for just Salido.
01:36At Jones Day, I take it you worked in the issues and appeals section,
01:41and that's what you do.
01:43That is exactly what we need inside the Office of Legal Counsel, in my view.
01:48Trial work is important.
01:51It's fundamental.
01:52It's essential to our system.
01:53And it's very, very different than doing appeals.
01:59So I just wanted to note that one of my colleagues made an observation about that.
02:03To me, that matters next to nothing,
02:06whether how much time you've spent in a trial courtroom or in front of juries.
02:11That is not the work of the Office of Legal Counsel,
02:15which has historically been staffed quite appropriately, in my view,
02:18by people with stellar, blue-ribbon, unusually good appellate court experience,
02:24appellate court clerkships, and U.S. Supreme Court experience.
02:27So for whatever that's worth.
02:29Now, you're currently serving as the Solicitor General of the State of Ohio,
02:32further advancing your expertise, your knowledge, your familiarity with the appellate courtroom.
02:39As I understand it, the Solicitor General of the State of Ohio operates a little bit differently
02:43than many of the others do,
02:45and in ways that almost certainly will prepare you exceptionally well
02:49to have the Office of Legal Counsel.
02:51Tell us about that.
02:53Thank you very much, Senator Lee.
02:54In my capacity as Ohio Solicitor General,
02:56I not only am the chief appellate lawyer for the State of Ohio,
02:59I'm also in charge of the Attorney General's Opinions Unit,
03:03where the Attorney General of Ohio is authorized to opine definitively on Ohio law
03:08to certain authorized requesters.
03:10I understand that role is very similar to the Office of Legal Counsel's historic role
03:15of opining on federal questions.
03:19Stunningly similar, in fact.
03:20The U.S. Department of Justice operates as something of a full-service law firm,
03:26the biggest in the country,
03:28and the office that you'll be heading, should you be confirmed,
03:32is that office, that office that provides people with advice.
03:34That necessarily requires you to have extensive appellate experience
03:38and a good ability to read how appellate courts,
03:41including and especially the Supreme Court, will respond.
03:44Mr. Woodward, how, if confirmed as the Associate Attorney General,
03:49in addition to being the number three person at the Department of Justice,
03:52you'll be the man.
03:55You'll be, in Spanish we would say,
03:56the law, when it comes to all of the oversight of all civil litigation,
04:03and a number of other matters as well.
04:05Tell me how, in that position, if confirmed,
04:08you could help the Department of Justice
04:10rein in the burdensome, excessive regulation
04:14and the excessive delegation of lawmaking power
04:18to our executive branch agencies through the non-delegation or otherwise.
04:21Senator, thank you for the question,
04:24and thank you for taking the opportunity to meet with us
04:26in advance of the hearing.
04:28As the Associate Attorney General,
04:30there would be a number of opportunities
04:31for us to challenge the burdensome regulations
04:34that have been imposed on our nation,
04:36on our businesses, on our people.
04:38Affirmative litigation is a critical aspect
04:40of what the Associate's Office oversees.
04:43What we see in the papers today
04:45is the defense of executive orders.
04:47What's talked less about is all of the affirmative cases
04:49that are being brought by the Civil Division,
04:50the Civil Rights Division, the Tax Division,
04:53the Antitrust Division.
04:54And so challenging unconstitutional regulations,
04:57as I alluded with your colleague earlier,
04:59would be a key piece of what I expect
05:01the Department of Justice to do.
05:03Thank you for sharing that,
05:05and I want to follow up on that just briefly.
05:08When some people hear the word unconstitutional,
05:12they might think, understandably,
05:14that what you mean is unconstitutional
05:16in a way that's been recognized by the Supreme Court,
05:18in a way that is directly traceable as unconstitutional
05:22to a particular court ruling,
05:25especially a Supreme Court ruling.
05:28But that's, more broadly speaking,
05:31that's not necessarily the appropriate way to view it,
05:33is it?
05:34In other words, there are certain features
05:36of the Constitution that don't always get tested.
05:38If they are tested,
05:39they're not always directly addressed
05:42by the Supreme Court.
05:43Constitutional avoidance, for example,
05:47is a means by which the court will often try
05:50to decide a case or controversy
05:52on a different ground
05:55if the constitutional question can be avoided.
05:58So, the non-delegation doctrine itself
06:01has been acknowledged by the Supreme Court,
06:03tends not to be enforced by the Supreme Court,
06:06and I would imagine that that's where
06:08the Department of Justice,
06:09that understands the implications
06:11of Article I, Section 7,
06:13the fact that in order to make,
06:15modify, alter, create,
06:18or repeal a federal law,
06:21one has to follow the two-pronged formula
06:23of Article I, Section 7,
06:25which includes bicameralism and presentment.
06:27Is that something that,
06:28in your view,
06:31a good Associate Attorney General
06:33ought to examine?
06:35Yes, Senator, absolutely.
06:36Thank you very much,
06:38and I see my time has expired.
06:41Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
06:42for your characteristic generosity.
06:44I love giving away time
06:46that's not mine, Senator Lee, so...
06:48Especially when we're talking
06:49about the don-delegation.
06:50Exactly, it doesn't get more exciting than that.
06:51In Provo, we speak of little else.
06:53Senator Hirono.
06:56Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
06:59Excuse me.

Recommended