Skip to playerSkip to main content
Who really holds the matchstick while the world burns? This 2021 speech by Indian historian Vijay Prashad throws all kinds of shade at the global climate debate. #TBT

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00When I listen to Boris Johnson, when I listen to people like Joe Biden, when I listen even
00:06more to Emmanuel Macron, all I can think of is how condescending you are.
00:12Glasgow was the UK's second most important city. Beautiful buildings, beautiful streets,
00:19a gorgeous city. When I see cities like this, I think also about the other side of it.
00:25There's a phrase from Walter Benjamin, every monument of civilization is also a monument
00:31of barbarism. I think of the famines in Bengal, the jute workers in Bengal sending jute to Dundee
00:39through the Glasgow port. I think of human beings from Africa enslaved and brought from Ghana to
00:47the New World and all those prophets getting sucked into cities like London and Glasgow.
00:54Between 1765 and 1938, the British Isles stole 45 trillion pounds from India, 45
01:04trillion sterling from India. We never got paid for that. When the British left India,
01:09when we threw the British out, our literacy rate was 13%, so much for several hundred years of
01:16so-called civilization. Meanwhile, our landscapes were destroyed. Coal was foisted on India.
01:23You foisted coal on us. You were the ones that came and made us coal dependent. Then you left
01:31and now you dare to condescend to us. When I listen to Boris Johnson, when I listen to people
01:37like Joe Biden, when I listen even more to Emmanuel Macron, all I can think of is how
01:43condescending you are. You condescended to us 400 years ago, you condescended to us 300 years ago,
01:50you condescended to us 200 years ago, you condescended to us 100 years ago,
01:55you're condescending to us today. You only know condescension because for you,
02:01colonialism isn't something that happened in the past and we defeated you. It's not that.
02:08For you, colonialism is a permanent condition and that permanent condition happens in two ways.
02:15There's the permanent condition of the colonial mentality. You want to lecture us. You want to
02:21tell us that we are responsible for all the problems because you'll never accept that you're
02:26the one principally to blame. You signed the Rio formula in 1992 on common and differentiated
02:33responsibilities. You like the common part. You like the common part. You like to say we're all
02:39in this together and so on. We're not in this together. The United States, 4-5% of the world's
02:45population still uses 25% of the world's resources. You outsource production to China and then you say
02:52China is the carbon polluter. China's producing your buckets. China's producing your nuts and
02:57bolts. China's producing your phones. Try to produce it in your own countries and see your
03:02carbon emissions rise. You love lecturing us because you have a colonial mentality.
03:07Then there are colonial structures and institutions. You lend us money and every time you
03:12lend us money, which is our money, which is our money. Every time the International Monetary Fund
03:18comes to our societies and they tell us, here's the money we are giving you. We are giving you? No,
03:23it's our money. You give us our money back as debt and then you lecture us about how we should live.
03:30Climate justice movement is a movement that says we're worried about our future. What future?
03:37What future? Children in the African continent, in Asia, in Latin America, they don't have a future.
03:43They don't have a present. They're not worried about the future. They're worried about their
03:47present. Your slogan is we're worried about the future. What future? That's a middle-class bourgeois
03:55Western slogan. You got to be worried about now. 2.7 billion people can't eat now and you're
04:03telling people reduce your consumption. How does this sound to a child who hasn't eaten in days?
04:09You got a clue into this, guys. You got a clue into this. Otherwise,
04:14this movement will have no legs in the third world.

Recommended