00:00Chief Justice of Pakistan, Justice Qazi Faiz Ishaq-e-Janab say,
00:03guzishta rooz maqsoos trishishton se mutalik samad ke doraan
00:0613 January ke faisle ka bharpoor defa kiye jaane ke baad,
00:09aaj Justice Muneeb Akhtar ki taraf se yeh observation saamne aayi hai
00:12ki Supreme Court ka maqsad tariq-e-insaaf ko intiqabad se waahar karna hargiz nahi tha.
00:16It seems Justice Muneeb did come to the rescue of the Supreme Court for his 13th January judgement.
00:22Nazreen, iske alawa Adalati Samad se yeh bhi waazeh hota chala jaa raha hai
00:26ki judges tariq-e-insaaf ko balle ka nishaan na diye jaane ko
00:29election commission ya tariq-e-insaaf ki ghalti karar de rahe hain.
00:32Aaj Supreme Court me Sunni Ijtihad Council ki maqsoos trishishton ke maamle par
00:35Samad Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Ishaq ki sarbarahi me 13 rukni bench ne ki.
00:39Samad ka aghaaz hua to election commission ke waqeel Sikandar Basheer ne dalaay ka aghaaz kiya
00:44aur phir poori samad ke doraan judges ke sakhtareen sawalat ka saamna karna pada
00:49jiska wazahir waqeel election commission jawab na de seke.
00:54There are only two appeals before this. Nor matter of allotment of symbol or PTIA before us in these matters.
01:0490% of the arguments and the questions relating to I am astonished how this is going on.
01:12It's about the 5 member bench. It's neither binding nor persuasive on us.
01:16We don't need to look at it. We need to look at the issue.
01:18Aur aapne kaha kyunki symbol nahi mil sakta tha humne socha ke basko independent kar den.
01:23Not realising the impact of that.
01:25A constitutional body hai. Istana bada sab faisla kaise kariya?
01:29Kab bethe kab meeting ki is baat pe?
01:31Kya aapke paas ye ikhtiyar hai ke aap kisi ko independent declare kar rahe hain?
01:34When you are thinking of declaring him independent, do you not require any withdrawal from him?
01:40Yeh agreement party aur candidate ke beech mein hota hai ki wo independent hoga ya party affiliated hoga.
01:46Major political party was excluded from the election process.
01:52Merely because the election commission grossly misinterpreted the judgement of this court.
01:57Is that understanding correct?
01:59No my lord.
02:00Your interpretation of that judgement, aap kehte hai wo durost tha?
02:03Bilkul ji.
02:05So when the bench itself is telling you that your interpretation was wrong.
02:12Samaat ke shuru mein Chief Justice ne kaha ke humne Tehreek-e-Insaab ki maqsoos nishiston ki list talab ki thi wo nahi mili.
02:18Jis par election commission ke vakil Sikandar Basheer ne jawab diya ki saara record jama karwa chuka hu.
02:22Election commission se kaha hai ke 81 azad umeedwaron ke qaqzaat-e-naam zadgi muhiyya karein.
02:27Main Tehreek-e-Insaab ki form 66 bhi adalat ko faraam kar dunga.
02:30Is par Chief Justice ne daryaft kiya ki aap is sawal ka jawab de sakte hain ya nahi?
02:34Is mauke pa Justice Naeem Akhtar Afghana aur Justice Mian Muhammad Ali Mazhar ne
02:38Election Commission vakil se umeedwaron ki wabastagi aur declaration ke hawale se sawalat uthayein.
02:43Aapne chart diya hai 81 candidates ka jinko independent symbol mile.
02:49Isme zara 6 column mein aayiye.
02:51Statement and nomination form given in declaration and oath by the person nominated belong to which party.
02:57Isme 81 waise 35 nae ye blank rakha hai.
03:01Ye zara note karein.
03:03Agla column hai 35 nae blank likha, kuch nae likha PTI, kuch nae likha independent
03:10Aur 2 nae likha ki shall be provided at the time of symbol.
03:14Agla column mein hai certificate of party affiliation under section 66 of the election act 2017.
03:19Isme 81 meise 48 nae isko nil rakha.
03:22Agla column mein aayiye.
03:24Statutory declaration affidavit accompanying section 66 certificate.
03:28Ye 65 nae nil rakha.
03:30Written application to RO for allotment of symbol to contest election as independent candidate.
03:36Ye bhi 65 nae kuch nahi likha.
03:39Blank.
03:40Phir symbol 81 ko independent allot hua.
03:43To ye manifest nahi karta ki PTI ki candidates ka non-serious attitude tha election ke din.
03:48Sir, can I use the word confuse me atleast.
03:51Isme 12, isme 12, isme 12.
03:53And self-contradictory.
03:54But sir, that is the answer to my question.
03:58Sikandar sahib aap tasalli rakhein.
04:00Aap ek ek sawal ka jawab dekhen.
04:01Dekhen serial number 12 aur 20 pe toh dono hi PTI hai.
04:05Declaration me bhi PTI hai, ticket bhi PTI ka hai.
04:08Ismauke pe Chief Justice Neham observations din aur ye kaha
04:11ke jab ye dono cheezein maujood thiin toh umeedwar ko tehreek-e-insaaf ka kyun nahi samjha gaya?
04:15Election Commission ne iske baad intikhabi nishan se confuse kyun kiya?
04:18Jin umeedwaron ne party ka certificate bhi diya, unhe?
04:21Is Jamaat ka tasawur kyun nahi kiya gaya?
04:23Aap is maamle me intikhabi nishan kahan se le aaye?
04:26Duraane isse baad Justice Qazi Faiz Isa ne remarks diye
04:28ke Election Commission ka jawab mujhe click nahi kar raha.
04:31Saath hi Justice Ayesha Malik ka kehna tha
04:34Kucha toh Election Commission se hi jayega na ke unhone kya kiya?
04:38Azad umeedwar toh Election Commission ne banaye the.
04:40Justice Muneeb Akhtar ne tehreek-e-insaaf ko qaumi Jamaat karar dete hui ye kaha
04:44ke ek umeedwar ki baat nahi, tehreek-e-insaaf ki baat ho rahi hai jo qaumi Jamaat hai.
04:48Election Commission ne tehreek-e-insaaf ko kaha ki aapko nishan nahi milega.
04:53You're not talking of a one-off candidate and going to the President for that.
04:56You're talking of a major level national party.
04:59Or does even not the Election Commission understand that about political parties?
05:03Obviously you do.
05:05So here is a major level national political party
05:09on the opening day of filing of nomination papers
05:13you are saying you will not get this symbol.
05:16At the same time, you accept
05:19that the consequence, the effect
05:23of the final order of the Supreme Court on the 13th of January
05:27which upheld your order
05:30was not to eliminate PTI from the electoral fray.
05:35And that is what your position should be.
05:37Here is a national level political party.
05:39We, the Election Commission, do not absolutely intend
05:43to eliminate them from the electoral fray.
05:46But we made this order.
05:48We can't give them the election symbol.
05:51Justice Muneeb ne kaha ki Supreme Court ka tehreek-e-insaaf ko intikhabaat se bahir karna
05:56maqsad hargiz ye nahi tha.
05:58Balle ke nishan ke faisle ke saath Supreme Court khadi hoti hai.
06:01Lekin, tehreek-e-insaaf ko intikhabaat se bahir karna maqsad nahi tha.
06:04Duraan-e-samaat, Justice Muneeb Akhtar aur Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Issa ke darmain
06:08Ansad Arrebal bhi.
06:09Aur election ko lekar remarks ka tabadla bhi hua.
06:1322-12-2023 ko who was the President of Pakistan?
06:17Dr. Arrebal.
06:20Was it a political government in the field or in office
06:24or was it a caretaker government?
06:26And a caretaker government is supposed to be neutral or partial?
06:30As neutral as you are?
06:32As neutral as I am.
06:34As independent as you are?
06:35As independent as I am.
06:36As much lovers of democracy as you are?
06:38Absolutely.
06:39As much defenders of free, fair, independent elections as you are?
06:43I don't defend the faith, my lord. I just do elections.
06:46Your article says fair.
06:50You can't do that.
06:52I understood.
06:54I understood.
06:56Aap un Sadr sahib ki agar baat karein,
06:58ek toh bilkul wazeb baat thi na,
07:00unhone ka ji mera ikhtiyar hai election date dene ka.
07:04Kiya istamaal unne ikhtiyar?
07:06Nahi kiya.
07:07Dusri baat hai mafrooze ki,
07:08agar hum bejhte, toh wo kartein.
07:10Agar unka past record dekhe karein,
07:13toh wo baith jatein, isbe koi faisla nahi kartein.
07:15Wo toh unka, wo katein, mera ikhtiyar tha bhai,
07:17date dedo election ki,
07:18hume aapne kyu zahmat di,
07:19har cheez Supreme Court mein aana,
07:20humne karwaaya election,
07:22yeh toh koi baat taslim karne ke liye tayari nahi hai.
07:25Aapka Sadar hai,
07:26PTI ka aadmi hai,
07:28kyu nahi dera election ki date?
07:29Mujhe aaj tak,
07:30duniya bar ki baatein karein,
07:32Sadar-e-Muhtaram jo uswa khute the,
07:34yiska aaj tak kisi ne public mein aaya hai,
07:36jawab unke taraf se.
07:37Magar dekhi ye baatein,
07:38mafrooze wali baatein.
07:39Is case pe focus karke,
07:41thoda khatam karein na,
07:42nahi toh hum doha baith rahein na,
07:43still kingdom come.
Comments