00:00 >>Mrs Theodora Broughton (Westminster) (Lab/Co-op):
00:11 Last week, the Leader of the Opposition was unwilling or unable to answer my question
00:15 about her Government's latest immigration mess. Instead, she gave Scots another lecture
00:20 from Westminster, this time about morality and her own global leadership—a lecture
00:26 on morality from this Tory Government. The pantomime season is truly upon us. Was she
00:32 talking about the morality of her "pile the bodies high" Government? Or maybe she
00:36 was recalling the time her Government said, "We are breaking the law, but only in a
00:40 limited way"? Or is it the morality that allows water companies to make a fortune in
00:44 profits as children get sick swimming in raw sewage off the coast of England? Or is it
00:49 about the families of service personnel forced to live in quarters so riddled with damp and
00:54 mould that they are judged too poor for human habitation? Maybe that is the morality she
00:58 had in mind. Could it be the morality of the return of near-Victorian levels of destitution
01:03 across the UK? Maybe she was thinking of the WASPI women, deprived of their rightful pensions.
01:08 Perhaps she could lecture them about morality and see what they have to say to her.
01:13 But before she launches into mercifully her last video nasty of the year, I hope she can
01:18 answer my question today. It is the same question I asked last week, which remains unanswered
01:25 and mired in confusion, thanks to her Prime Minister. It may be that this morning's
01:29 statement entitled "Citizens' Rights" will address this, but we should have debated
01:33 these drastic changes before now in this place anyway. It is supposed to be the season of
01:38 goodwill, but so many of our constituents are now deeply concerned and frightened by
01:43 this announcement. So I will ask again on their behalf. If the spouse or partner of
01:48 a British citizen is currently living in the UK on a leave to remain visa, could they be
01:53 deported if their salaries are less than £38,700? Yes or no?
02:00 >> The Prime Minister I start by wishing the hon. Lady and her
02:07 SNP colleagues a very happy Christmas. I would point her to what the Prime Minister said
02:12 yesterday in her questions with regard to further information coming forward in the
02:20 new year. I said last week that I fully understand that people in particular professions, including
02:27 the armed forces, will want to have answers to this. My office stands ready to facilitate
02:33 any particular cases or requests that people have in the meantime, but transition arrangements
02:39 will be announced shortly. The Prime Minister got that on record loud and clear yesterday.
02:47 The hon. Lady mentions vulnerable people, and yet this very week the SNP has announced
02:59 that Scotland's national care service is going to be pushed back by three years. She
03:04 mentions the armed forces, and it is her Government who are insisting on them paying higher tax.
03:09 This Government are compensating her for that. If she wants to go and find Victorian levels
03:14 of rats and rickets, she should go to SNP-run local authorities.
03:20 I think we should have a festive round-up on SNP morality. Twelve hours of police questioning,
03:28 11 grand roaming charges, 10 years without school inspections, nine sham embassies, eight
03:33 years of poor child mental health, seven years without ferries, six years shirking welfare
03:39 powers, £500 million overspent on Edinburgh's tram, £4 million to install a heat pump,
03:46 three high-profile arrests, two overseas jollies and a dodgy Jaguar EV. I have succeeded in
03:56 bringing a smile to the hon. Lady's face, and I must thank her for being the gift that
04:00 keeps on giving at business questions. I hope that in 2024 better things are destined for
04:07 the Scottish people—better education, better health, better transport and opportunity,
04:12 and better values for the taxes they pay—and that all their MPs will come here and represent
04:18 their interests and take responsibility for the authority that they are given. That is
04:24 my Christmas wish.
04:29 [Music]
04:35 (music)
04:37 [BLANK_AUDIO]