00:00 Hello everyone this is Aminan Sari welcome to SW News English
00:04 There is a controversy going on. This controversy is over the transfer of Justice Dharam Chand Chaudhary
00:12 from the Armed Forces Tribunal Chandigarh bench to Kolkata bench. Now what is the Armed Forces
00:18 Tribunal? The AFT which stands for Armed Forces Tribunal is a judicial body responsible for
00:26 adjudicating service matters related to armed forces in India. The ongoing controversy over
00:33 the transfer of Justice Dharam Chand Chaudhary of the Chandigarh bench of AFT has taken a turn
00:39 with the AFT Chandigarh Bench Bar Association claiming to have proof of direct interference
00:45 of the Ministry of Defence in the AFT's functioning. The AFT Chandigarh Bench Bar
00:51 Association has alleged that there is a direct interference of Ministry of Defence in the transfer
00:56 of Justice Dharam Chand Chaudhary. The Bar Bench in a letter to the Chief Justice of India D.Y.
01:02 Chandrachud has alleged that the Defence Minister openly admitted the interference of Ministry
01:08 in the matter of transfer of judicial members just before Justice Chaudhary could hear the case.
01:14 Justice Dharam Chand Chaudhary, the senior most judicial member of the AFT's Chandigarh bench
01:20 was transferred to Kolkata bench for administrative reasons in public interest on September 25.
01:26 AFT Bar Bench Association in the letter to the CGI has alleged that Justice Chaudhary's transfer
01:33 was the result of strict orders passed by him against senior officials of the Ministry of
01:38 Defence. They have asked the Chief Justice of India to cancel Justice Chaudhary's transfer.
01:45 The Bench Bar Association has alleged that this transfer of Justice Chaudhary comes a day prior
01:50 to the date of contempt hearing in the court to save an officer in the Defence Department.
01:55 The bench bar further alleged that the chairperson who made this transfer of Justice has now transferred
02:02 the contempt application to himself. The letter reads, "It is now highly regretted to inform you
02:09 that a video clip which has gone viral on social media of an event conducted by the Defence Account
02:14 Department on 1st October 2023 shows the Honourable Defence Minister openly admitting the
02:20 interference of the Ministry in the matter of the transfer of judicial member just before he could
02:26 hear the case of contempt wherein he openly heard saying that one cannot keep everybody happy and
02:32 one of your officers just got saved and escaped. And further adding that a hint was enough regarding
02:39 this incident leading to laughter from audience which shockingly included the same contempt he
02:45 was referring to. The AFT Chandigarh bench bar has also made it clear that they are not questioning
02:52 the integrity of the Defence Minister or the Defence Secretary. But they are pointing out
02:57 how they are being misguided by Ministry of Defence officials.
03:01 That's all for this news report. For more such news and updates subscribe to SW News English.
03:07 [Music]