• 8 minutes ago
Some murder cases are chilling enough on their own — but what happens when the supernatural gets involved? Join us as we count down real-life murder cases where paranormal claims, ghostly visions, and eerie premonitions took the crimes to a whole new level of disturbing. Which case sends the biggest chill down your spine? Let us know in the comments below!
Transcript
00:00Welcome to WatchMojo, and today we're diving into real-life murder cases where claims of the
00:05supernatural made the crimes even more twisted. The tragic premonitions of Kathy Hobbs. Kathy
00:21Hobbs's anxiety was so severe that she sometimes refused to leave her home. As her 16th birthday
00:27approached, her fears intensified, and she became increasingly withdrawn. When she was in the 7th
00:33grade, a very good friend of hers died of a heart disease that affected Kathy very much. But shortly
00:40after her birthday, Hobbs seemed to embrace life anew and became more outgoing. Sadly, she wouldn't
00:46have much time to enjoy it. On July 23rd, 1987, she left her Las Vegas home to buy a book
00:52and never
00:53came back. Kathy had walked to the store late at night many times. Usually her friends were gathered
00:58at the apartment complex swimming pool, chatting and gossiping, so Kathy's mother wasn't concerned
01:03for her safety. Days later, a geologist discovered her body near Lake Mead. She had died from blunt
01:09force trauma to the head. You want to run home, grab your daughter by the arm, and bring her to
01:15the
01:15scene and say, this is why I say no, you can't go out late at night. Investigators eventually suspected
01:22serial killer Michael Lee Lockhart. Carpet fibers reportedly linked the case to a car he'd stolen,
01:28while other evidence placed him near the scene. Yet Lockhart was never tried for Hobbs' murder.
01:33After her death, her family found her diary. Since the age of 8, Hobbs had been convinced she would
01:39die before her 16th birthday. About two months before her 16th birthday, she got very teary-eyed one night
01:44and told me, Mom, I don't want to get any older. In letters written before she turned 16,
01:49she asked her family not to grieve. According to her mother, Kathy was 16 years, three months,
01:55and three days old when she died. Pet cemetery murders. In Louisiana, a bizarre claim helped crack
02:01Dorothy Lou Thompson's 1985 murder. But by all accounts, she was a generous person.
02:07A sweet person. After her mother's death, Thompson became increasingly depressed, and grew close to
02:13Brandon Nodier and his wife. That relationship soured when she discovered that they had tricked
02:18her into transferring ownership of the Azalea Original Pet Cemetery, which she owned.
02:23They had birds, cats, dogs, all sorts of animals. Any animal you could think of was buried in that
02:29pet cemetery. To reclaim her land, Thompson sued them, with a court hearing scheduled for April 1985.
02:36But 10 days before the hearing, she disappeared. Her body was found in the Mississippi River on May 2nd,
02:41strangled, and weighed down with heavy chains. Investigators suspected former groundskeeper
02:47Nodier, who had taken control of the cemetery. But without enough evidence, the case went cold.
02:52Brandon Nodier wanted that land. He had told people he wanted that land.
02:55Years later, an anonymous caller claimed Thompson's ghost had been haunting them,
03:00and said Nodier had confessed to the murder. The report was unusual, but the investigation gained
03:06further momentum when Nodier's former assistant, James Tregler, came forward with information
03:11about the killing. Nodier eventually pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in 2014,
03:16and received a 10-year prison sentence.
03:18He admitted what he had done.
03:20To the question of, are you pleading guilty? Because in fact, you are guilty to the killing
03:26of Dorothy Thompson. He stood before the judge and said,
03:31The Hinterkaifeck Farmstead Massacre. To this day, nobody knows who was responsible for the deaths
03:37of the Gruber family at Germany's Hinterkaifeck Farmstead in 1922.
03:42I've seen these footprints.
03:48You believe me?
03:49Months earlier, the family's maid had quit, reportedly believing the house was haunted
03:54after hearing strange noises in the attic.
03:57And why do you think Fauriga left?
03:59Because of footsteps in the attic.
04:01Ghost stories, Anasur.
04:03Then-farmer Andreas Gruber heard footsteps from the attic, but found nobody when he investigated.
04:09He also discovered footprints leading from the woods toward the farm,
04:13with none leading back, and a newspaper nobody recognized.
04:17On March 31st, the family and their newly hired maid were murdered.
04:21But the killer apparently didn't flee.
04:24Someone stayed for days, fed the livestock, and ate food inside the house.
04:29The killer chopped himself a quart of wood, made himself at least four meals,
04:33and cleaned the dishes afterwards.
04:35Left cash on the table, everything in his place.
04:37He was not Eve.
04:39The bodies were discovered on April 4th, but investigators faced another problem.
04:44Curious visitors had already contaminated the crime scene.
04:47The murder weapon itself remained undiscovered until 1923,
04:52when the farm was demolished and a blood-stained mattock was found in the attic.
04:56No one was ever convicted.
04:58Was something genuinely unworldly happening before the killings?
05:02Or had a terrifying killer been hiding in plain sight?
05:05These people, Schlittenbauer, Carl Gabriel, Frau Rieger, the American, and so many more.
05:12No evidence, dozens of suspects.
05:14For more compelling deep dives into disturbing true crime cases, join WatchMojo's live stream.
05:20Scan the QR code to tune in.
05:22The Flannan Isles Lighthouse Mystery.
05:24James Ducott, Thomas Marshall, and Donald MacArthur were stationed at the Flannan Isles Lighthouse on Island Moor.
05:31On December 26th, 1900, a relief crew arrived to find the station deserted.
05:37A lightkeeper's duty actually was 24 hours a day.
05:41Anything that went wrong at the station had to be seen to, had to be taken care of.
05:47The light had reportedly gone dark 11 days earlier, and nobody could find the keepers.
05:52No light, what had happened.
05:54The lighthouse was orderly, but two sets of outdoor clothing were missing.
05:58Outside, investigators discovered severe damage near the western landing, including displaced railings and a massive stone moved by powerful waves.
06:07The Flannan Isles are very exposed and very open to the waves of the western ocean.
06:16The men's bodies were never recovered.
06:18Stranger stories followed about sea monsters, ghost ships, abduction, and a fight on the cliff.
06:24Years later, logbook entries surfaced describing a terrible storm, a silent Ducat, and MacArthur weeping while all three men pray.
06:34There was one thing on it that said that everything had now been calm, and God is over all.
06:42But those entries may be fiction.
06:44The official explanation is a giant wave.
06:46Damage at the western landing suggests Ducat and Marshall went down to secure equipment, and were swept into the sea,
06:53with MacArthur following.
06:54It was a tragedy at the time for the local community.
06:57It was a tragedy for the lighthouse service.
06:59But here's the problem.
07:01The worst weather didn't start until December 16th, after the light had already gone dark.
07:06So what happened on December 15th?
07:08I don't think anybody else will ever have an answer for it.
07:12Just one of the mysteries of the sea.
07:14John Allen Rubio.
07:16A case of terrifying delusions, or a motive rooted in desperation.
07:21In 2003, John Allen Rubio and his partner, Angela Camacho, killed her three children in Brownsville, Texas.
07:28I felt like I had to catch my breath, so I crossed the street, and I did.
07:34Rubio was the biological father of the youngest, and stepfather to the other two.
07:39Rubio claimed his dead grandmother's spirit had possessed the children, and was communicating through one of them.
07:44He believed killing them would eliminate the supernatural threat.
07:48When I go into the room, I see that Julissa has Johnny's hand in her hand, and they have the
07:58scissors, and they're about to put it into the light socket.
08:01So they were going to electrocute themselves.
08:03Convinced the family's pet hamsters were possessed, he also had them killed.
08:07In the days surrounding the murders, the couple had even sealed themselves inside their apartment, and nailed the back door
08:14shut.
08:14But that wasn't all to the case.
08:16Rubio had a history of substance use, and Child Protective Services had previously removed Camacho's two older children.
08:23When they took the kids, they could see that neither Angela or John really were capable.
08:31They couldn't take care of themselves.
08:33Although they were eventually returned after the couple met CPS requirements, money remained tight, and the family feared eviction.
08:41On March 11, 2003, Rubio did the unthinkable.
08:44While the pair thought about fleeing, they were discovered by Rubio's brother, who alerted the police.
08:50And he asked me what happened, so I told him that it was witchcraft.
08:54In 2010, Rubio was sentenced to death and executed in November 2026.
08:59The Ghost of Room 1046
09:01A hotel guest who spoke to an unseen visitor and died after a brutal attack sounds like the setup for
09:09a supernatural thriller.
09:10But the mystery of Room 1046 began in Kansas City in January 1935.
09:16A young man checked into the hotel president as Roland T. Owen and asked for an interior room.
09:22He claimed to be from Los Angeles, and those who saw him during his stay at the hotel mostly remembered
09:27him for a nasty scar he had on his temple and a deformed ear.
09:30That led many people to assume he was a professional boxer.
09:33A maid found him sitting in the dark and overheard him on the phone with someone called Don.
09:38Two days later, a bellboy found him in his room severely beaten and stabbed.
09:44Asked about his injuries, Owen claimed he fell.
09:47He died hours later without naming his attacker.
09:49The murder is national news. It's called America's Strangest and Perfect Murder Crime.
09:55Investigators found small fingerprints on the room's phone, possibly a woman's.
10:00They were never matched, and Don was never identified.
10:03It took nearly two years to learn that Owen was actually Artemis Ogletree, a teenager who had left Alabama to
10:10hitchhike to California.
10:11After his death, his mother received letters, supposedly, from him.
10:16I think that I'll be leaving here in a few days to go on across the big pond.
10:20I understand it takes almost a month to get across, and maybe a few more weeks to unload the ship
10:25at different ports.
10:26In 1937, New York police arrested Joseph Martin for an unrelated murder, and his handwriting matched those letters.
10:34He was never charged, and the case remains unsolved.
10:38The Missing Nurse
10:39In December 1980, 31-year-old nurse Melanie Uribe disappeared on her way to work in Los Angeles.
10:45Two days later, Etta Louise Smith, a clerk at a Lockheed plant in Burbank, heard a radio report about the
10:53search and suddenly pictured a body hidden in a remote canyon.
10:56As if someone was talking to me, it was a mental thought, but it was as if someone was speaking
11:02to me.
11:02Unsure what to do with the vision, Smith finally called the police.
11:06A detective asked her to return the next day so they could search by helicopter, but she didn't wait.
11:11She drove to Lopez Canyon with her daughter, and about a half an hour later, they found Uribe's body.
11:17Instead of being treated as a helpful witness, Smith became a suspect.
11:21Detectives questioned her for hours, unconvinced that a vision could have led her to the scene, before arresting her on
11:27suspicion of murder.
11:28The investigating officers, having no other leads or clues, didn't have any other choice at that time,
11:34but presumed she was, in fact, an accessory, either before or after the commission of the crime.
11:39She spent about four days in custody before being released, without ever being charged.
11:45Investigators eventually tied three men with no known connection to Smith to the murder after they were heard bragging about
11:52the crime.
11:53All three were convicted.
11:54Smith later sued over her arrest, and a jury sided with her, awarding her damages.
12:00I think it's one of the mysteries in life that many things happen to us throughout our life that are
12:06unexplainable.
12:07The Salem Witch
12:08In 1991, Salem, Massachusetts, resident Martha Brailsford went sailing with her neighbor, Thomas Maimone, but never returned home.
12:17So a state police helicopter was pressed into the search today in hopes of finding a clue.
12:21Maimone initially denied taking her out on his boat.
12:24He later claimed she had fallen overboard after being struck by a wave, but his changing accounts raised investigators' suspicions.
12:31With the search for Brailsford going nowhere, Salem Police Captain Paul Murphy turned to Lori Cabot, a local witch and
12:38psychic.
12:39Witchcraft means shapeshifter and wise person.
12:44Shapeshifting means that you can use your psychic senses to make things come to be.
12:50Cabot said she entered a relaxed mental state and envisioned a violent confrontation aboard a sailboat.
12:55According to her account, a man struck Brailsford, weighted down her body, and threw her overboard.
13:00She also described where the body could be found.
13:03On July 18th, a fisherman discovered Brailsford's remains in Massachusetts Bay, with an anchor tied to her foot and a
13:10diving belt around her waist.
13:12Maimone fled, but was arrested in Maine days later.
13:15He was convicted of second-degree murder in 1993 and sentenced to life in prison.
13:20The Slender Man Influence
13:22What happens when an internet horror story starts to feel real?
13:26In Wisconsin, a fascination with a fictional monster drove two miners toward a chilling plan.
13:32In late 2013, Anissa Weyer introduced her friend Morgan Geyser to Slender Man, a tall, faceless figure born from online
13:40fiction.
13:40It was created in 2009 and by Eric Knudsen under the screen name Victor Serge, as part of a Photoshop
13:47contest to try to create something that looked real, that really wasn't.
13:50As the girls became absorbed in his mythology, they came to believe he was real.
13:55They thought killing someone would make them his proxies and protect their families from his supposed wrath.
14:02Their intended sacrifice?
14:04Their friend and classmate, Peyton Lautner.
14:07On May 31st, 2014, after a sleepover for Geyser's birthday, they lured Lautner into a wooded park in Waukesha, Wisconsin,
14:16under the pretense of playing hide-and-seek.
14:18Anissa pulled her deeper and deeper into the woods.
14:25And then what happened?
14:26And then I went to look for them.
14:29There, Geyser stabbed her 19 times, while Weyer urged her on, before they abandoned her.
14:36Against the odds, Lautner crawled to a nearby road, where a passing cyclist found her and called for help.
14:42The girls were caught later that day, while heading toward a forest where they believed Slender Man lived.
14:47Both were ultimately found not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect, and committed for psychiatric treatment.
14:54After undergoing surgery, Lautner eventually made a full recovery.
14:58Who could ever see something like this coming?
15:01Like, nobody.
15:02A deadly exorcism.
15:03In August 2016, 26-year-old Kennedy Ife died after a terrifying ordeal inside his family home in Enfield, North
15:12London.
15:12Devout Christians connected to Jesus Sanctuary Ministries.
15:16His family believed he was possessed by evil spirits.
15:19What led them to that conclusion?
15:21According to the evidence presented, Kennedy had been unwell for around two weeks,
15:26complaining of a sore throat and struggling to sleep.
15:29Kennedy first complained to his family about his throat hurting after he had gone out to eat at a Chinese
15:35buffet on August 13, 2016.
15:38His brother Colin told police that Kennedy seemed like a different person.
15:42He reportedly heard voices, spoke about the biblical mark of the beast, and became aggressive.
15:49His family interpreted these changes as signs of demonic possession.
15:53Rather than seeking emergency medical assistance, relatives restrained Kennedy with cable ties, rope, and handcuffs.
16:00They had put their misguided religious beliefs about this young man being possessed by a demon or evil spirits
16:05before the obvious and common sense conclusion that he needed help and did not need to be restrained.
16:12For roughly 67 hours, on August 22, his family called an ambulance, reporting that Kennedy had been complaining of dehydration.
16:20He had also developed breathing difficulties, but paramedics couldn't save him.
16:25A post-mortem revealed several injuries, some consistent with forceful restraint, including a possible bite mark.
16:32When the case went to trial in 2019, all seven family members were acquitted of the charges against them.
16:38I'm honestly surprised that nobody was held responsible for this, because it's just so obvious that they played a role
16:46in this young man's death.
16:49The Red Barn. How much stock do you place in dreams?
16:52Back in 1827, English couple Mariah Martin and William Corder were planning on eloping in Ipswich,
16:59and had arranged to meet at a local landmark known as the Red Barn.
17:03Martin's family later received letters from Corder claiming that they were happily married.
17:07Don't be afraid, Mariah. You shall be a bride. A bride of death.
17:16But then, Martin's stepmother began having troubling dreams that Mariah had been murdered.
17:22She instructed her husband to dig in the Red Barn's grain storage bins, where he found his daughter's body.
17:28I didn't do it! I swear I didn't do it!
17:30William Corder, I risked you for the murder of Mariah Martin.
17:33Go!
17:33Corder was publicly executed.
17:35When he was executed at Beryst and Edmunds, it was a national holiday, with thousands of people coming.
17:42While the paranormal element received much attention, there may be a mundane explanation.
17:47There were rumors that Mariah's stepmother was having an affair with Corder before he ran off, and helped plan the
17:54murder.
17:55Leading police to a body
17:56When six-year-old Australian girl Kaisha Abrams went missing in 2010, Cheryl Carol Lagerway believed that she had the
18:04answers.
18:05The Aboriginal elder had a dream about Kaisha, and claimed that her body would be found in a nature preserve
18:11near Sydney.
18:11She and a friend traveled to the location, and did indeed find a body, just not that of young Kaisha.
18:18I did think it was Kaisha, but it turned out that it wasn't to be.
18:22And it was even more sad for the relatives of the person they did locate.
18:30Instead, they discovered another homicide victim.
18:33The body is thought to be that of missing woman Christy McDougal, and two people were charged in her death.
18:38You can't imagine anybody doing that to anybody, and we're still really trying to come to terms with it.
18:47As for Kaisha Abrams, it was sadly discovered that she had been killed by her mother, who was sentenced to
18:53a maximum term of 22 years in prison.
18:55The arrest finally came when Abrahams and partner Robert Smith unknowingly led police to the grave by going back there
19:03on the one-year anniversary of her death.
19:05Mary Jane Reid and Stanley Skridler.
19:08On the evening of June 24, 1948, young Navy veteran Stanley Skridler and telephone operator Mary Jane Reid went out
19:16for a date in Oregon, Illinois.
19:18They were last seen at a local tavern around 11.30 p.m. before heading out to a local lover's
19:23lane.
19:24Their bodies were later found in separate locations.
19:27Leading suspects included Mary Jane's former bows, but the case was never solved.
19:31There are still few answers in the 1948 cold case in Ogle County of the murders of Mary Jane Reid
19:37and Stanley Skridler.
19:38However, some believe that Mary Jane's ghost haunts the tavern in which they were last seen.
19:44Shortly after buying the building, the new owner started getting odd sensations.
19:48Some employees refused to work night shifts and reported objects moving on their own.
20:02Is it possible that Mary Jane is still trying to get her case solved?
20:07Ghosts and a Masked Grave
20:09Every Thanksgiving, the grandfather of twin brothers Bill and Frank Watson told them the same ghost story.
20:15Back in 1909, a man was walking home in Malvern, Pennsylvania, when he saw a pair of dancing ghosts at
20:22Duffy's Cut, a stretch of railroad tracks in the woods.
20:25The man believed that they were among 57 Irish railroad workers who supposedly died from a cholera outbreak.
20:31So is disease the real culprit behind these deaths?
20:35Some believe that story just doesn't add up.
20:38In 2002, the Watson brothers started digging in the area of Duffy's Cut and found a Masked Grave.
20:45Divots on the skull suggested that they were clunked on the heads.
20:48All of the individuals that we excavated have blunt force trauma or actually bullet-based trauma.
20:57One of the skulls shows a very distinct hole.
21:01The motivation behind the possible slayings remains unknown.
21:05Railroad officials covered up the killings to protect their efforts to recruit more cheap labor.
21:10The Devil Made Me Do It Case
21:12You may be familiar with this case from the third Conjuring movie.
21:16Bruce, stop!
21:19Arnie, help me!
21:22On February 16th, 1981, Connecticut man Arnie Cheyenne Johnson stabbed his landlord, Alan Bono, to death.
21:42Paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren claimed that Johnson was possessed by a demon when he committed the killing.
21:48Johnson pleaded innocent on the grounds of demonic possession.
21:51Look, I don't think he should get the death sentence either.
21:54But I am not going before a grand jury and saying he was possessed by demons.
21:59Making this the first case in United States history in which such a defense had been tried.
22:04The case earned national attention owing to the bizarre defense.
22:08Johnson was found guilty of first-degree manslaughter and sentenced to 10 to 20 years in prison.
22:14The Ghost of Anne Walker
22:16In 1735, author Arthur L. Hayward published a book called Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals.
22:23The following account of an apparition in Durham, England, comes from his book.
22:27One night, the bloody spirit of housekeeper Anne Walker appeared to Miller James Graham and recounted her story.
22:41She had gotten pregnant by a relation of hers, Mr. Walker, who killed her with an accomplice named Mark Sharp.
22:47Graham went to the Justice of the Peace and had Walker's death investigated.
22:51The body was where the ghost claimed it would be, as were the belongings of Mark Sharp.
22:57Both Sharp and Walker were found guilty of the crime and sentenced to death.
23:02Anneliese Michel
23:03The story of Anneliese Michel is quite famous, having been adapted into several movies, including the 2005 horror film The
23:10Exorcism of Emily Rose.
23:12Michel was diagnosed with epileptic psychosis and depression as a teen, and suffered years of mental anguish.
23:18This is a rare development, to be sure, but one that I have witnessed numerous times.
23:23You mean that Emily was both epileptic and psychotic?
23:26Yes.
23:26When medication failed to help, her family suspected that she was possessed by a demon, and subjected her to 67
23:33exorcisms.
23:34Don't ask it any questions, or pay any attention to what it says.
23:41It?
23:43I won't be dealing with Emily tonight.
23:47She subsequently died of malnutrition at 23 years old.
23:51Following an investigation, her parents, and the two priests that conducted the exorcisms, were charged with negligent homicide.
23:58They were all found guilty of Michel's death and given suspended sentences.
24:02You are guilty, Father Moore.
24:05And you are free to go.
24:08This court is dismissed.
24:10All rise!
24:11It's often seen as a tragic case where mental illness was misdiagnosed in favor of supernatural interpretation.
24:19Teresita Bassa speaks through another.
24:21Chicago resident Teresita Bassa was found dead in her apartment on the night of February 21st, 1977.
24:29Her body was discovered when the fire department was called to deal with a blaze, and it's believed that the
24:34perpetrator set the fire to cover up their crime.
24:37Initially, the apartment seemed unoccupied, but soon the fireman made a grim discovery.
24:45It seemingly worked, as the trail quickly went cold.
24:48A few months later, Bassa's co-worker, Ramibius Remy Chua, helped crack the case.
24:54According to Remy's husband, Remy woke from a nap in a trance, spoke in a different voice, claimed to be
25:01Teresita, and told him that her killer was another co-worker named Alan Showery.
25:05He said the first session only lasted about 30 minutes, and then at the end, his wife woke up.
25:11He asked her if she knew what happened. She said she didn't.
25:15Following a homicide investigation, it was proven that Showery did indeed commit the crime, and he was sentenced to 14
25:21years in prison.
25:22To this day, I'm not quite sure if Teresita came back.
25:28It's one of those bizarre incidents that you don't know is true or not true.
25:37The Greenbrier Ghost.
25:38In 1897, Elva Zona Hester Shue supposedly died of natural causes in Greenbrier County, West Virginia.
25:46The official story was that Shue died in childbirth, but her mother wasn't so sure.
25:51Please don't leave me.
25:52Help her! Help her, please! What's happening?
25:54She can't breathe. Please, please. Just breathe.
25:58Mary Jane Hester claimed that her daughter's ghost visited her in the night, and told her that her husband, Blacksmith
26:05Erasmus Shue, was the true culprit.
26:07She said he had choked her, crushing her windpipe and breaking the top vertebrae in her neck.
26:12Hester approached a local prosecutor, and he had Shue's body exhumed.
26:16Following an autopsy, it was found that Shue had been strangled, and that her neck was broken, which thoroughly debunked
26:22the childbirth story.
26:23Shue's husband was later found guilty of her death and sentenced to life in prison.
26:27He died of an unknown epidemic that went through the prison population in March 1900 and was buried in an
26:33unmarked gray.
26:35Want more true crime on WatchMojo? Check out our dedicated 24-hour livestream.
26:40True crime all the time.
26:42We're going to have a great time together, Cheryl.
26:45The Hammersmith Ghost Case
26:47Locals in the Hammersmith area of London became terrified after a spate of ghost sightings in the winter of 1803.
26:54The Hammersmith ghost was said to be tall, terrifying, and clad in white.
26:59The stories got so out of hand that armed citizens began patrolling the area.
27:03One night, Francis Smith, who was out on patrol, encountered bricklayer Thomas Millwood, who was dressed in white, and mistook
27:11him for the ghost.
27:12Armed with a shotgun, Smith shot and killed Millwood.
27:15Charged with homicide, he was eventually sentenced to one year's hard labor.
27:20Following the trial, shoemaker John Graham came forward and admitted to being the real Hammersmith ghost.
27:27He had been dressing in a white sheet to scare his apprentice.
27:31Do you buy any of these stories?
27:33Let us know in the comments below.

Recommended