• 1 day ago
A German U-boat captain stepped onto a Canadian corvette with dry feet—while more than 40 of his men were still aboard. In this Second World War military history story, two newly commissioned Canadian ships, HMCS Chambly and HMCS Moose Jaw, force U-501 to the surface off Greenland in September 1941. Captain Hugo Förster scuttles his submarine, then crosses to the enemy as his crew watches.

From Commander James Prentice’s unconventional tactics to the desperate effort to save the German sailors, this historical documentary explores the split-second decisions behind the Royal Canadian Navy’s first confirmed U-boat kill. Hear the story of the sinking, the rescue, and the crew’s bitter judgment of their captain. A compelling account for listeners seeking WW2 stories, naval warfare history, U-boat battles, and Canadian military history.

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00On the night of September the 10th, 1941, in the Denmark Strait off the east coast of Greenland,
00:08a German submarine broke the surface 400 yards in front of a Canadian Corvette that had been in
00:14commission for less than three months. On the bridge of HMCS Moose Jaw, a ship named for a
00:22prairie city in Saskatchewan and launched that April at Collingwood, Ontario, Lieutenant Fred
00:27Grubb had one four-inch gun on his forecastle and a crew on their first operational cruise.
00:35Many of them had spent the passage seasick. They were short of hands. The gun fired one round and
00:42jammed. Grubb did the only thing he had left. He put his ship at the U-boat. The two holes
00:49came
00:49together and ran along each other side by side, close enough for a man to step across. Grubb called
00:56on the Germans to surrender, and a man did step across. He came off the submarine's bridge and
01:03landed on Moose Jaw's forecastle. Grubb wrote afterward that it was not clear how he did it.
01:09What was clear was that he had not got wet. Behind him, on the casing of the U-boat, more
01:16Germans were
01:17already moving to follow. Remember that detail. His own men never forgot it, and they never forgave it.
01:25The man standing dry on a Canadian deck was not a seaman looking for a rope. He was the captain.
01:33Corvetten Capitan Hugo Förster, 36 years old, commanding officer of U-501, one of the newest
01:42ocean-going boats in the German Navy. He was the first man off his submarine. More than 40 of his
01:49crew
01:50were still on it. Grubb had no men ready to repel boarders and no wish to have his forecastle fill
01:57up
01:57with Germans. He sheered away. The U-boat, still moving, tried to cross his bows. Grubb rang for full speed,
02:07swung in, and rammed her. Not far off, on the bridge of HMCS Chambly, a man with a monocle was
02:16bringing his own
02:17ship around. Commander James Douglas Prentiss, 42, from Victoria, British Columbia. Seven years earlier,
02:26he had retired from the Royal Navy and gone home to ranch. A senior officer would later call him
02:33persistent almost beyond endurance. Minutes earlier, it was his depth charges that had driven this
02:40submarine to the surface. Prentiss had not come here to watch a German captain change ships. He wanted
02:47that boat. If what the Canadians did in the Denmark Strait that night matters to you, a subscribe helps
02:54these stories reach more people. So here is the question this whole story turns on. Why would the
03:02captain of a brand new U-boat, a regular officer with 18 years in the German Navy, a man his
03:09crew said was a
03:10close friend of Admiral Donnett's, leave his own bridge first and leave it for the deck of the enemy?
03:18His crew had an answer and they gave it to British interrogators within weeks. It was a hard answer
03:24and a simple one, but it does not explain why it happened that night in those few minutes in front
03:31of
03:31those two Canadian ships. For that, you have to see the night the way Prentiss saw it, from the moment
03:38he
03:39decided to go looking for it. And keep one more thing in mind. Again and again on that patrol, Forster
03:47had lectured his young crew about duty and about death. He had a favorite phrase for it. You will hear
03:54that phrase later, and you will hear what his men did with it. Look at the water around those two
04:00corvettes. They were not alone out there. A few miles away in the dark, a convoy of more than 60
04:08merchant ships was steaming for Britain at the speed of its slowest freighter. Slow Convoy 42, out of
04:17Sydney, Nova Scotia. It had been routed far north, up toward Greenland, to slip past the U-boats. It
04:25had not slipped past. Since the night before, ships had been going down in it, one after another. The
04:33convoy's own escort was one Canadian destroyer, HMCS Skeena, and three Canadian Corvettes. That was all,
04:43to guard twelve columns of merchantmen against a pack of U-boats that kept growing. On the night
04:49of the 9th, one of those Corvettes, Kenogami, new to the group, fired at a surface submarine,
04:57and the flash of her own gun blinded her lookouts. The U-boat was gone before their eyes recovered.
05:06Skeena, racing through the columns, only just missed colliding with a merchant ship in the chaos.
05:13That was the Royal Canadian Navy in September 1941. A Navy that two years earlier had owned a handful
05:22of destroyers, was now being asked to hold the convoy route from Newfoundland to Iceland with
05:29Corvettes built in Great Lakes and St. Lawrence yards, and crewed by bank clerks, farm boys, and
05:37furniture salesmen. The captain who ran those escorts out of St. John's had written that most of them
05:44were equipped with exactly one weapon of approximate precision. The ram. You have already watched Fred
05:52Grubb use it. Hold that thought, because the ram was supposed to be the last resort of a navy that
05:59could
05:59not yet hit anything. That night, it was not the first thing that hit U-501. The first thing was
06:07Chambly. And Chambly and Moose Jaw were not part of that convoy's escort. They should not have been
06:15anywhere near it. They were there because one retired rancher asked to take two half-trained ships to sea
06:23four days early, and because of a signal he received on the way that made no sense at all. On
06:30September
06:31the 5th, 1941, two Corvettes slipped out through the narrows of St. John's, Newfoundland, and headed out
06:39to sea. HMCS Chambly led. HMCS Moose Jaw followed. Neither ship was due at sea for another four days.
06:51Prentiss had asked for this. He had been reading the reports on a slow convoy heading north toward
06:58Greenland, and he did not like what they said. His orders were to work up these two ships,
07:05to drill them in screening a convoy, finding a submarine, and attacking it. He went to Commodore
07:13Leonard Murray, the Nova Scotian who ran the escort force out of St. John's, and asked to do that
07:19training early, at sea, and where the trouble was. Murray said yes.
07:26You need to know only a little about him. His English-born father had forbidden him to join
07:33Canada's new navy, so in 1912 he joined Britain's instead. He gave it 22 years. And he wore a monocle.
07:44Once, his crew turned up for inspection with a monocle in every eye.
07:49Prentiss flipped his own into the air, caught it in his eye socket, and told them,
07:54When you can do that, you can all wear monocles. That was the joke.
08:00The work was something else, and Prentiss drove his crews hard on one idea. When a Corvette picks up a
08:07submarine on its ASDIC, its underwater sound gear, the instinct is to ring for full speed and rush it.
08:15Prentiss taught the opposite. Hold the speed steady. Run in on the contact without the sudden surge of
08:23engine noise that tells the U-boat it has been found. Attack quickly, and attack without warning.
08:3018 months later, that idea would be in print, in a manual circulated to Canadian escort commanders.
08:38In September 1941, it lived in one man's head and in the drills of two ships. Remember that.
08:47Steady speed, quick attack. In five nights, a German captain is going to find out what it feels like
08:54from underneath. And notice what Prentiss was really doing. He was not waiting for the enemy to come to
09:01his training. He was taking his training to the enemy. That same day, September 5th, roughly 450 miles
09:11southwest of Iceland, that captain found his first ship. U-501 was a month out of Trondheim in Norway.
09:21The ship she found was the Einvik, a Norwegian steamer carrying pit props and lumber from Quebec to
09:29Cardiff. She had fallen behind her convoy and had been sailing alone for about a week.
09:36Furster torpedoed her, then finished her with gunfire. Twenty-three men got away in two lifeboats and
09:45turned for Iceland. An aircraft sent out after her distress call searched the area, found nothing,
09:53and reported that there were probably no survivors. Hold on to those two lifeboats. They are still out
10:01there, and before this story ends, they will come back into it. The Einvik was the only ship U-501
10:10would
10:10ever sink. And the man who sank her was not a submariner by trade. Hugo Furster had joined the
10:19Navy in 1923 and spent his career on the surface. He had commanded a torpedo boat. He had served as
10:27a
10:27senior officer in the heavy cruiser Blücher in April 1940, when Norwegian shore guns and torpedoes sank
10:36her in the Oslo Fjord. He had already been in one ship that went down. Then came a transport. Then
10:43a
10:43shortened course for U-boats. Then this boat. This patrol was his first as a U-boat captain. His crew
10:52was
10:52newer still. Of nearly fifty men aboard, seven had ever made a war patrol. The youngest was 17. The
11:01British officers who later questioned them called their training hasty and most inadequate. British
11:08intelligence noted something else. The exceptional seniority of their captain and how new he was to
11:14the U-boat arm. Stop and think about that combination. A veteran captain can carry a green
11:21crew. A seasoned crew can sometimes carry a new captain. U-501 had neither. What she had was a
11:30captain senior to most U-boat commanders at sea, on his first patrol in command, about to meet two
11:38Canadian ships that had spent the week rehearsing one thing. Because by then, Prentiss had made a
11:45decision that put them within reach. A signal from St. John's had reached Chambly in garbled form.
11:53As Prentiss read it, he was to support the next slow convoy, SC-43. The obvious move was to turn
12:02around
12:02and go back to meet it. Prentiss did not go back. He held his two ships where they were, east
12:09of Cape
12:10Farewell, the southern tip of Greenland, and kept drilling them there. It is a small choice, the kind
12:17no one writes a book about. It is also the reason two Canadian Corvettes were close enough to matter
12:23when the real order came. By then, slow convoy 42 was already losing ships. The new signal told
12:31Prentiss to go and join it. He worked out where the convoy should be, and Chambly's navigator,
12:38a mate named Picard, laid the course. On the way, Prentiss told his first lieutenant what their job
12:45would be. That first lieutenant was a furniture salesman born in Vernon, British Columbia, named
12:52Ted Simmons, and in a few hours he would be climbing down into a sinking U-boat with a flashlight.
13:00What Prentiss told him sounds, in its first half, like an order to forget the convoy altogether.
13:07The second half is the reason a German captain ended that night on a Canadian foc'sle.
13:13On the evening of September the 10th, 1941, HMCS Chambly was closing on a convoy her crew had never seen,
13:22off the coast of Greenland, and her captain was explaining to his first lieutenant why they would
13:27not be guarding it. When we get there, Prentiss told Ted Simmons, we'll not have to worry about
13:34the convoy. Their job, he said, would be to find the enemy and kill him. Hear how strange that sounded
13:42in 1941. An escort's whole duty was the convoy. Stay close, keep the U-boats down, pick the survivors
13:51out of the water, get the merchant ships through. Prentiss was about to arrive at a battle that had
13:57been going badly for two days, and he had decided that the most useful thing he could do for those
14:03merchant ships was to leave them to the escort already there and go hunting. And it had been going
14:10badly. Earlier, Skeena and the corvette Kenogami had caught one U-boat, U-85, and depth charged her
14:19so hard she had to give up and turn for home. That was the first Canadian answer of the battle.
14:25But one damaged boat did not stop a pack. Every time a ship went down, a corvette had to stop
14:32for
14:33survivors. And the night before, for stretches, the convoy had been left with almost no one guarding
14:40it. The Admiralty would later call Jimmy Hibbard's group a slender escort, overwhelmed by a wolf pack
14:48more than three times its size. So Prentiss did not simply chase the convoy up its own wake. He took
14:56Shambly and Moose Jaw past the convoy's line of advance, out ahead of it, and then turned back to
15:03close it from the dark side, after the moon was up. Now put yourself in a U-boat captain's place
15:09for a
15:10moment. Where do you wait for a slow convoy? Not behind it, where you would have to chase it.
15:17Ahead of it, where it comes to you. The night before, under that same moon, an ore carrier called
15:24the Munaric had been torpedoed and gone down with every man aboard. Prentiss turned the moon around.
15:32Coming in from the dark side, his two corvettes stayed black against black. Anything sitting on the
15:38surface between them and the bright southern sky would stand out. Remember where he put his ships?
15:45Out ahead, on the dark side. It is the first layer of the answer to why a German captain ended
15:52up on
15:53Moose Jaw, and it has nothing to do with courage. It has to do with where a Canadian rancher chose
16:00to
16:00look. Following Chambly, Fred Grubb in Moose Jaw saw the battle before he reached it. At about nine
16:08that night, by his own account, flares and starshell were going up ahead. At half-past nine, he sent his
16:16men to action stations. A crew on its first operational cruise closed up at the gun and the depth-charge
16:23rails in the dark. Grubb's own ASDIC was in the hands of three men. The senior of them, ordinary
16:31seaman E. Thomas, held one of the lowest ratings in the Navy. Grubb would later single out his energy,
16:39initiative, and professional knowledge. Four miles ahead of the convoy, U-501 was underwater.
16:46Not long before, she had crash-dived to avoid aircraft, her crew said. She was holding at about
16:53a hundred and thirty feet. About half an hour later, through the steel of the hull, they began to hear
17:00something else. A faint, regular ping. Then, the hydrophone operator picked up the beat of propellers.
17:09Ships, plural, approaching. Stop on that for a moment. The Germans knew they were being searched
17:18for. Nearly fifty men, the youngest seventeen, underwater and listening, with a captain on his
17:26first patrol in command. What they did not know was how close the searcher already was, or what that
17:34searcher had spent the last five days rehearsing. On Chambly, the ASDIC operator heard it first.
17:42A firm contact, about seven hundred yards off. The echo was high in pitch, which meant ship and target
17:50were closing. Think about that distance. Seven hundred yards is less than half a mile. In a Corvette,
17:58it is a few minutes of steaming. Prentiss' report puts what he decided in a handful of flat words.
18:05It was decided to attack at once. Every order Prentiss gave in the next minutes would go down to the
18:13engine room, where Chief Engine Room Artificer W. Spence ran Chambly's engine. He would be decorated for
18:21that night. This is the moment Prentiss had drilled for. Not the convoy, not the rescue. A contact in the
18:30dark. Close. And the choice between rushing it and doing it the way he had taught. Everything that
18:37happened to Hugo Forster that night starts here, with one officer on one bridge deciding not to wait.
18:46Keep the question from the start in front of you. Why does a captain leave his boat first? So far,
18:54you have two pieces. A captain new to submarines, with a crew newer still, and a Canadian who put his
19:02ships exactly where that captain was waiting. Neither piece is enough on its own. The third begins with a
19:09gong. On Chambly's port side, a seaman stood by the depth charges at his first operational action
19:17station. His job was simple. When the firing gong sounded, he acted. In the next two minutes,
19:25he was going to miss it. And Prentiss came to believe that this one man's mistake was probably
19:33what broke U-501. Prentiss did not ring for full speed. He did the opposite. As Chambly ran in on
19:42the contact, he brought her speed down and ordered a pattern of five depth charges fired early, from the
19:50rails over the stern and the throwers on either side. Remember what he had been drilling for five days.
19:58No surge of engines. No warning. A ship that keeps coming. Steady. And then the sea around the submarine
20:08explodes. It did not go the way it had gone in the drills. The port thrower misfired. At the port
20:17rails,
20:17the seaman at his first operational action station missed his cue on the gong. The first two charges
20:25went over late, and they fell close together, instead of spreading out the way they were meant to.
20:31Anyone who knew depth charge drill would have called that a botched pattern. Prentiss himself
20:38thought so, and he also concluded that this was probably what had done the damage. Now you are going
20:45to see why. 130 feet down, survivors remembered two explosions. Inside U-501, the lights went out.
20:56Dials shattered. The depth gauge was damaged, and so were valves. The after hydroplane, the fin that
21:05holds the stern at its depth, stopped answering. Later, the Canadians would find the port one blown
21:12clean off, and a hole about four feet across in the casing aft. A smell of gas spread through the
21:20boat from the cartridges meant to scrub the air. Water came in, not much, through the toilet in the
21:27forward compartment. Think about that for the youngest man aboard, seventeen, on his first patrol.
21:36Darkness. Gas. A boat that will not hold her depth. And the ships still up there.
21:45In the radio room, the telegraphists had one job in a moment like this. Get a signal off to U
21:52-boat
21:53command that the boat was lost, and where? They never sent it. Later, British interrogators asked why.
22:02Their answer is the plainest German verdict of the whole night. Everything, they said, was so unexpected,
22:11and so quick. Hold on to those words. So unexpected. So quick. That is not a description of bad luck.
22:22That is a Canadian drill, done badly by a green crew, and still too fast for the men underneath it.
22:30Step back and look at the whole board for a moment. The battle for slow convoy 42 was still going
22:37on,
22:37and merchant ships would go on dying for hours yet. But in this one patch of black water,
22:43four miles ahead of the convoy, the balance had tipped. A boat built to hunt had become a boat
22:50trying to survive, and it had been done by two ships that had been in commission for less than a
22:56year.
22:56And now, at last, Hugo Forster had to decide something. Here is the fact his own men would
23:04never let him forget. U-501 was a big, new, ocean-going boat. On the surface, she was faster
23:12than either corvette. It was dark. The American historian Clay Blair, who studied the whole U-boat
23:19war, judged that she might have escaped. Her crew said the 20mm gun on her bridge was ready when she
23:26came up. Forster did not run. He did not fight. He decided to scuttle. Of all the officers aboard,
23:34only one had made a war patrol before. The chief engineer, Gerhard Schiemann, 27, from East Prussia.
23:43A U-boat man since 1937. The most experienced officer in that boat was not the one making the
23:51decision. Pause there, because it changes the question. Before Forster ever stepped onto a Canadian
23:58deck, before Fred Grubb ever called on him to surrender, he had already given up the boat. The
24:05jump was not the moment he quit. It came after it. So the question shifts. What made a senior regular
24:13officer in a faster boat on a dark night decide so quickly that it was over? That is the question
24:22the
24:22rest of this night answers. His crew would have their own answer, and it began with a phrase he had
24:28used on them all patrol. When he lectured them about duty and death, Forster liked to say that the Germans
24:35know how to die. Remember that sentence. Within minutes it would be tested on a Canadian forecastle,
24:42and the men who had heard it would judge him by it. U-501 came up. Not out in the
24:49dark, away from the
24:50escorts, but between the two Canadian ships. On Chambly, Prentiss was already swinging his ship
24:57around to regain contact for a second attack. He never needed it. Prentiss had arranged his whole
25:04approach so that a surfaced U-boat would stand out against the sky. Now one did. Fred Grubb had seen
25:12Chambly's signal that she was about to drop charges, and had swung Moosejaw wide to come in on the attack
25:19himself. Now, about four hundred yards off his bow, a long, dark hull rose out of the sea and got
25:27under way. For most of Moosejaw's crew, it was the first enemy warship they had ever seen. Grubb held his
25:35fire until Chambly was clear, so as not to put a shell into his own consort. Then he gave the
25:42order.
25:43Grubb's gun fired once. What happened next sent Moosejaw straight at the submarine. Within minutes, Fred
25:53Grubb would call across the water to the Germans, and Hugo Furster, the man who had told his crew that
26:00Germans know how to die, would answer him. Not with words. With his feet. Moosejaw's four-inch gun fired one
26:09round and jammed. Grubb turned to what he had left. His machine guns opened up on the U-boat's deck,
26:18to keep any German from reaching the gun there. And he turned the ship herself toward the submarine.
26:25Remember the word from St. John's? One weapon of approximate precision. Fred Grubb was about to use
26:34it. He went in to ram. Then, as Moosejaw closed, he saw something that changed his mind. The German
26:44crew was massing on the deck of the submarine. They looked like men getting out, not men going to their
26:52guns. Grubb broke off the ram and brought Moosejaw alongside instead. The two holes ran together,
27:00corvette and submarine, side by side in the dark. And then Grubb did the thing that makes this story
27:09what it is. He called across the water to the U-boat to surrender. Hold that order of events in
27:18your mind,
27:18because it is the first thing the usual telling leaves out. The Canadian asked, the German answered.
27:26Hugo Furster came off his bridge and across the gap onto Moosejaw's fo' castle. Grubb,
27:34in his report, admitted that it is not clear how he did it. He did not get wet in the
27:40process.
27:41Clay Blair wrote that the leap astonished Germans and Canadians alike. One moment the captain of U-501
27:49was on his own conning tower. The next, he was standing among Canadian sailors on the deck of a
27:56ship named for a city in Saskatchewan, a prisoner of war by his own choice. Behind him, his crew moved
28:05to
28:06follow. And here is the second thing the usual telling leaves out. Moosejaw had no party ready to
28:14repel boarders. Grubb had a crowd of Germans on a submarine's deck a few feet from his own,
28:20and their captain had just shown how easy the crossing was. He could not know what they meant
28:27to do once they were across. So he sheered off. He pulled Moosejaw away and opened the gap again.
28:36Think about what that means for the title of this story. Furster left his crew, yes, he went first,
28:44and he went alone. But he went alone partly because a Canadian lieutenant with a jammed gun and a green
28:53crew decided in a moment that one German on his fo' castle was a prisoner, and 40 Germans on his
29:01forecastle were a boarding party. Now U-501, still moving, began to swing across Moosejaw's bows.
29:11Grubb rang for full speed and aimed for her forward diving planes. Moosejaw struck her at an angle of
29:19about 45 degrees. It would take 10 days in a yard at Greenock in Scotland to repair what that cost
29:28the
29:28corvette. The submarine went on, crossing Moosejaw's bow at reduced speed. Grubb's guns opened up again.
29:37That was the end of it for the men on the casing. The Germans took to the water. Not all
29:44of them,
29:45not yet. With the captain gone, command of U-501 fell to her first watch officer, Werner Albring,
29:54twenty-seven, from the Rhineland. Albring carried on with the scuttling his captain had begun,
30:01so while the boat was being sent to the bottom by his second-in-command, her captain stood dry on
30:07a
30:07Canadian deck. What was he like in those first minutes as a prisoner? Grubb's description is not
30:15what you would expect. He called Furster quiet and well-mannered, a senior commander of the German
30:21Navy, standing on the forecastle of a corvette that had been in commission less than three months,
30:28quiet and well-mannered. He also had a reason ready for what he had done. You will hear it soon,
30:35and you will hear what it did to the men he left behind. On Shambly, Prentiss now had the whole
30:42situation in front of him. A U-boat on the surface, still underway, her crew in the water, and Moosejaw's
30:50men busy hauling Germans out of the sea. Grubb could not rescue men and seize a submarine at the
30:57same time, and Prentiss wanted that submarine. Fifteen days earlier, south of Iceland, the British had
31:04captured a U-boat hole, U-570. A U-boat taken, not sunk, could give up her secrets, her codebooks,
31:14perhaps even a German who knew how to use them. Shambly could not go alongside. The U-boat's diesels
31:22were still running, and she was still moving. So Prentiss did the next thing. He had a boat lowered,
31:29and he put his first lieutenant in charge of it. Ted Simmons, 31, the furniture salesman from Vernon,
31:36went into the boat with his boarding party, a .45 caliber pistol, and a flashlight. In rough seas,
31:44they pulled across toward a submarine that was already going down by the stern. In the boat was a
31:50stoker from Toronto named William Irvin Brown. He was twenty-four. He had been married a year, and at home
31:58there was a baby daughter named Gail. Step back to the question for a moment. You know now that the
32:05captain gave up the boat before he jumped. You know he jumped when a Canadian called on him to surrender.
32:11You know his crew were coming behind him, and a Canadian decision left them there. What you do
32:18not yet know is what his own men said about him, or how Furster tried to explain himself.
32:26Simmons was about to see the boat Furster had left behind. He would go down her hatch with a flashlight.
32:33After the one thing Prentiss wanted most. And not every man in that Canadian boat was coming back.
32:42The boat from Chamblee came alongside the U-boat in a rough sea, and Ted Simmons climbed onto the casing
32:48of an enemy submarine. Some of the German crew were still on deck. Simmons seized one who spoke English
32:55and ordered him below. The German refused. The boat was wrecked, he said. Simmons drew his 45 and drove two
33:04more Germans toward the conning tower. They would not go down either. The stern, they told him, was going under.
33:13Notice what that tells you. These were men who had been inside U-501 when the charges went off.
33:20They knew her better than anyone. And with a Canadian pistol on them, they still would not go below.
33:27Whatever their captain had decided on his bridge, his men had come to the same verdict about their boat.
33:34So Simmons went himself. He climbed into the conning tower and went down the hatch with his
33:40flashlight. The lights below were out. The instruments were wrecked. Water was surging into the control
33:47room. Somewhere in that boat where the code books Prentiss wanted. Simmons saw that she would soon flood
33:55completely. He gave up the prize. He climbed back to the conning tower and ordered everyone over the
34:01side. His own boarding party. The German prisoners. Everyone. Canadians and Germans went into the North
34:10Atlantic together. In September. Off Greenland. At night. Stoker Brown did not come out with them.
34:19According to the naval historian Mark Milner, Brown had tried to close the seacocks, the valves letting
34:26the sea into the boat. A 24-year-old Stoker from Toronto, inside a German submarine, trying to keep
34:34her afloat. U-501 went down. She went so fast that Simmons, still in the conning tower, was dragged under
34:45with her. Blair wrote that she literally sank beneath his feet. Simmons came back to the surface. William
34:53Brown did not. He was never seen again. Today his name is on the Halifax Memorial, among the Canadians who
35:02have no grave but the sea. On Chambly, Prentiss turned from hunting to rescue. Between them,
35:10the two Canadian corvettes pulled 37 Germans out of the sea, every officer among them. Eleven men were lost.
35:18Their shipmates were sure they had drowned trying to swim to the Canadian ships. And on Moose Jaw, the
35:26survivors her crew had pulled from the sea came face to face with their captain again. Forster had his
35:32explanation ready. He told the British he had felt impelled to get aboard Moose Jaw at once, in order
35:39to insist that his men be rescued. He had gone first, in other words, for them. He also described it
35:47as
35:47crossing over to negotiate the surrender of his crew. Now weigh that against what you have seen. The
35:54Canadians pulled his men out of the water without any help from him. Few Canadians believed his story.
36:01The British interrogators wrote that it failed to convince them. And his own crew? It infuriated
36:08them. There is one small scene in the British report that says it better than any verdict.
36:14Fewster offered his hand to his chief quartermaster, one of the senior men of the crew. The man refused to
36:21take it. And here is what his men did with that phrase. All patrol he had told them that the
36:28Germans
36:28know how to die. Now they told British interrogators that their captain had been the first man off the
36:36boat, that he had jumped across without getting wet, and that he had thought solely of his own skin.
36:43Some said that if a court-martial did not deal with him after the war,
36:47they would deal with him themselves. So now you can put the whole answer together,
36:53and it is not quite the one his crew gave. They said cowardice, and about the man,
36:59perhaps they were right. But cowardice does not explain the timing.
37:04Furster had been at sea for a month. He had hunted, and he had sunk a ship. Nothing broke him
37:11until a
37:11few minutes on the night of September the 10th. In those minutes, Canadians took his choices away,
37:17one by one. A rancher from Victoria put two corvettes out ahead of the convoy, on the dark side,
37:25where a U-boat would wait. He attacked at once, at steady speed, and a pattern, botched by a seaman
37:33at his first action, wrecked the boat before her radio operators could send a word.
37:40Furster chose to scuttle rather than run. And when he came up, he came up between two Canadian ships,
37:47with one of them alongside, and a Canadian lieutenant calling on him to surrender.
37:53He was offered one way out, and it was offered in a Canadian voice.
37:59The man who had told his crew, all patrol how Germans die, took it before any of them could.
38:06That is why the captain jumped. Not only because of what kind of man he was. Because two Canadian
38:13ships, only months out of the builder's yards, had made that jump the last choice he had left,
38:20and done it faster than he could think. But Furster's story did not end on Moosejaw's forecastle.
38:27He was bound for a prison camp in England, and waiting there was the top-scoring U-boat captain
38:34of the war, Otto Kretschmer, a prisoner himself who had a verdict of his own to deliver.
38:41And on Chambly, Prentiss was already working out what this knight had taught him.
38:47On the morning of September 11th, the help slow convoy 42 had needed for two days came over the horizon.
38:54Five Royal Navy destroyers, two corvettes, and two sloops. By then the worst was over. The last heavy
39:03attack had come in the small hours of that morning. Sixteen merchant ships were gone. It was one of the
39:10heaviest losses any convoy suffered that year, and for most of two days it had been fought by one
39:17Canadian destroyer and a handful of Canadian corvettes. I am not going to pretend otherwise.
39:24Measured in ships, slow convoy 42 was a defeat. But listen to who said what about it.
39:32The admiralty called it a slender escort, overwhelmed by a wolf pack more than three
39:38times its size. And the masters of the surviving merchant ships, men who had watched the ships
39:45beside them burn, went to Admiral Sir Percy Noble, who commanded the western approaches, and expressed
39:52their thanks to the Canadian escorts. They did it, the record says, unanimously and spontaneously.
40:00Hold on to that, because the merchant captains knew something the losses hide.
40:05In the middle of that defeat, two Canadian corvettes had found a U-boat, forced her up,
40:11and sunk her. U-501 was the Royal Canadian Navy's first confirmed U-boat kill of the Second World War,
40:20and her captain was on his way to a different kind of judgment. Hugo Forster was taken to Grizedale Hall,
40:27a country house in the English Lake District that held captured German officers. Among them was Otto
40:34Kretschmer, the top-scoring U-boat captain of the war, captured that march. According to Kretschmer's
40:40biographer, Terence Robertson, Kretschmer convened the Council of Honor to try Forster for cowardice.
40:47Think about that. German prisoners inside a British camp putting one of their own on trial for what he
40:54did in front of two Canadian corvettes. The camp authorities did not let it go further. They isolated
41:00Forster and sent him to another camp. The older petty officers of U-501 had their own version.
41:07They told the British that with better leadership they would have fought, and might have escaped.
41:13Maybe. But set that beside the words of their own radio operators. So unexpected. And so quick.
41:22The petty officers were describing the captain they wished they had had. The telegraphists were
41:28describing the night they actually had. And now back to the man at the center of this story.
41:35Prentiss wrote his report on the action, and the striking thing about it is what he did not claim.
41:41He did not describe a perfect attack. The misfire and the missed gong are in the record,
41:48and Prentiss concluded that the badly delivered first charges had probably done the damage. A captain
41:55who had just sunk his navy's first U-boat put down that part of it had gone wrong. Remember that
42:02seaman at
42:03the port rails? His captain did not hide him. That honesty mattered, because Prentiss was not
42:10finished with that night. In 1942, he built the training for Canada's new destroyers. And in March
42:171943, the navy circulated a manual he had written, hints on escort work. It called for the thing he had
42:26drilled into Chambly and Moose Jaw off Greenland. Quick attacks. What had lived in one man's head that
42:35September was now in print, in the hands of escort commanders. The navy delivered its own verdict.
42:43Prentiss received the Distinguished Service Order. Ted Simmons, the furniture salesman who went down the
42:50hatch, received the Distinguished Service Cross. Fred Grubb was mentioned in dispatches. Mate Pickard,
42:58who navigated them north, who navigated them north, was mentioned in dispatches too. Chief engine room
43:04Artificer Spence received the Distinguished Service Medal. And Grubb gave his statement on the action from a
43:11hospital bed, where he was recovering from pneumonia. Simmons went on to command his own corvette, HMCS Port Arthur.
43:21Off Algeria, he forced an Italian submarine, the Tritone, to the surface with a ring of depth charges. He had
43:29seen the inside of a broken submarine once. Now he knew how to make one. And Prentiss? By the summer
43:37of 1944,
43:38he commanded Escort Group 11, a Canadian group designated to hunt U-boats around the invasion of Normandy.
43:47Notice the job. Not escort. Hunting. It was what he had told Ted Simmons on the way to Slow Convoy
43:5642.
43:57Find the enemy and kill him. In July, in the English Channel, his group shared in sinking U-678.
44:06In August, in the Bay of Biscay, he had a hand in sinking two more, U-621 and U-984.
44:17He developed ways of finding U-boats lying on the bottom, sometimes hidden among wreckage.
44:23Put those two men side by side for a moment. In September 1941, a German regular officer with 18 years
44:32of service was beaten in minutes and left his boat first. Three years later, a Canadian who had been
44:40ranching when the war began was leading a group that went looking for U-boats on purpose. One night
44:46off Greenland had sent the two of them in opposite directions. Remember the two lifeboats. Far to the
44:53east, the men of the only ship Forster ever sank were still at sea, heading for Iceland, written off by
45:01the aircraft that had searched for them. What became of them, and what became of Forster when the war
45:07finally sent him home, is where this story ends. Go back one last time to the forecastle of HMCS Moosejaw
45:16on the night of September the 10th, 1941. A German commander stands there, quiet and well-mannered,
45:24his feet dry. Behind him, his crew are about to go into the sea. Not far off, a man with
45:32a monocle is
45:33sending a boat to take what that German left behind. And in that boat sits a stoker from Toronto, who
45:40will
45:40go inside the sinking submarine and try to close her valves. Everything in this story sits inside that
45:48one picture. Here is what became of the people in it. Start with the men Forster had sunk.
45:56The Einvik sailors kept their lifeboats heading for Iceland. A storm separated them. On September the
46:0312th, an Icelandic motorboat found one boat just west of the island of Heime and took its men in.
46:11The next day, the other boat came ashore on Iceland's south coast.
46:15Every man of the Einvik's crew lived. The aircraft that wrote them off had been wrong. They reached
46:23land two days after the captain who sank them had stepped onto a Canadian deck.
46:28Hugo Forster spent more than three years as a prisoner. In 1945, he was sent home to Germany
46:36in a prisoner exchange. The most often repeated account says he later took his own life,
46:43and that the contempt of other U-boat commanders was part of the reason. The records on that are
46:49thin, and I will leave it there. What is not thin is the verdict of his own crew, given to
46:55British
46:55officers in 1941 about a captain who had told them the Germans know how to die.
47:03Fred Grubb stayed in the navy and rose to commander. Years later, because the accounts of that night
47:09kept disagreeing, he wrote his own. He called it the first occasion on which ships of the Royal Canadian
47:17Navy attacked and sank an enemy vessel in high seas. He also wrote a guide to naval customs for young
47:25officers. In it is a line that reads differently once you know what he saw on his forecastle that night.
47:31The basic law governing etiquette, Grubb wrote, is the same the world over, consideration of others.
47:40Moose Jaw herself served out the war. She was paid off at Sorrel, Quebec in July 1945 and broken up
47:49at
47:49Hamilton, Ontario in 1949. Built on the Great Lakes, she ended on them. Ted Simmons went into business after
47:58the war and became president of Distillers Corporation in Canada. He retired to England. He died in
48:05September 1988 and the following year, at a service aboard the Canadian destroyer HMCS Huron, his ashes
48:14were committed to the sea, the same ocean that had nearly kept him on a night off Greenland. James
48:21Prentiss finished the war as a full captain. He served as aide-de-camp to the Governor-General,
48:27retired in 1946 and went home to British Columbia for the second time in his life. He died at Sanichton
48:35on Vancouver Island in March 1979, at 79. The rancher who came back to the sea in his 40s ended
48:44his life not
48:45far from the city where it began. And William Irvin Brown, Stoker, 24, of Toronto, has no grave. His name
48:56is on the
48:56Halifax Memorial in Point Pleasant Park, with the Canadians the sea never gave back. His daughter
49:03Gail was a baby when he climbed into a sinking German submarine to try to close her valves.
49:10So why did a German submarine captain jump to the Canadians and leave his crew? His men said it was
49:17cowardice, and they knew him best. The British, who questioned his crew, wrote about his seniority
49:23and his inexperience. The Germans, who tried to put him on trial, called it cowardice. Neither was
49:30talking about the Canadian ships. Both were describing what those ships had done to him.
49:35Because no man is tested in general. He is tested on one night by particular people.
49:42On the night of September the 10th, 1941, Hugo Forster was tested by a rancher from Victoria who
49:50went looking for him instead of waiting, by a green crew whose botched pattern still broke his boat
49:56before he could send a word, and by a lieutenant in a three-month-old Corvette who came alongside
50:02and called on him to surrender. They left him one way out, and he took it first. Now set the
50:09Canadians
50:10beside him. In the same few minutes that the German captain stepped across to safety,
50:15a Canadian furniture salesman was climbing down into the boat he had left, and a Canadian stoker
50:21was inside it, trying to stop the sea coming in. The German went first, to save himself. The Canadians
50:29went in, and one of them, a stoker from Toronto with a baby daughter at home, is still out there
50:35off
50:35Greenland, with the boat he tried to keep afloat. Thank you for spending this time with me, and with
50:41the men of Chambly and Moose Jaw. If you think what the Canadians did that night off Greenland deserves
50:48to be remembered, a like genuinely helps it reach more people. And if you'd like to hear more, we're
50:55here every week. And if your father, your grandfather, or your uncle served in the Second World War,
51:02I'd be honored to hear about him in the comments.

Recommended