00:00The right to substitute law refers to the ability of a litigant to ask the national judge to directly apply a law.
00:06superior, in particular a European Union directive, in place of a conflicting or absent national rule.
00:12Unlike the simple invocation of exclusion, where the judge merely disregards the defaulting party's domestic law, the
00:18Substitution allows a claim or decision to be based directly on the European text.
00:22In France, since the 2009 ruling by the Conseil d'État in the Madame Perreux case, this mechanism is fully applicable to all
00:28provision of a European directive which is precise and unconditional, once its transposition deadline has expired and
00:34that the dispute is between an individual and the State, direct vertical upward effect.