00:05In the day 44 of the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte,
00:10the prosecution of Senator Judges is a former witness of a former official anti-money laundering counsel.
00:18The news is Sandra Aguinaldo.
00:31Kinwestiyon ng ilang senador ang kwalifikasyon ng defense witness na si Atty. Rayner De La Fuente
00:37sa impeachment trial laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte.
00:41Si De La Fuente isang CPA lawyer at dating compliance officer ng Anti-Money Laundering Council o AMLAC.
00:48Pero puna ng ilang senador.
00:51Is he a super witness, omni-witness?
00:53Pati ba naman pati amici-coray, pagpakialaman niya, Supreme Court, pagpakialaman niya, ombudsman DOJ.
00:58Na-bother po ako, ginawang Pangulo, at naaalarma na hindi po siya ang DOJ, hindi po siya ang ombudsman,
01:07lalo na hindi po siya ang core party ng korte para magbigay po ng binding legal conclusions
01:13o magdesisyon kung meron nga pong criminal liability.
01:18Bago yan, ipinunto ng depensa ang pagiging confidential ng mga bank record.
01:22Gayaan nila ng bank records ng vice at asawang si Atty. Man Scarpio na inilabas ng AMLAC sa House Committee
01:29on Justice.
01:30What is the propriety of aggregating confidential data from the CTRs and STRs and disclosing them to the public?
01:39Pag mga ganyang sinishare na information, may pamantayan, meron pong rules na nilalagay ang AMLC
01:47as to how the information should be used and for what purpose.
01:52Nagpakita rin ang depensa ng video mula sa impeachment trial ni dating Chief Justice Renato Corona noong 2012.
01:59Tulad ng opinion noon ni Nooy Senadora Miriam Defensor Santiago
02:02tungkol sa pag-withdraw ng ilang articles of impeachment ng prosecution
02:06at confidentiality ng bank account ni Corona.
02:11Kayong sinasabi niyo? Panangalo na kami dito sa tatlo.
02:14Kami ang magdesisyon niyan, hindi kayo. Agayabang niyo.
02:18Ipinakita rin ang pahayag ni Corona na nasira umano ang kanyang pangalan
02:22at apektado ang kanyang pamilya dahil sa mali umanong akusasyon.
02:27Pareho yang hindi na pinatapos ni Presiding Officer Sen. Cheese Escudero.
02:31I do not see the relevance of the statements made by the Chief Justice Corona
02:36about his alleged persecution
02:39except that it is an appeal to a motion that I believe has no place in this impeachment trial.
02:45Pagpahingahin na po natin yung namayapa.
02:48That is a different case. This is a different case.
02:52This is a different set of senators.
02:55Iba rin po yung sinaunang panahon.
02:58Alam natin na diniscuss yung bank records, credit card records, etc.
03:04I just appeal for a little bit of leeway for them to be able to serve their client well
03:10by being able to present their defense.
03:14Natalakay rin ang depensa ang ilang punto sa report ng financial expert na prosecution witness
03:20na si Atty. Alexander Cabrera kung saan nakasaad na may mahigit 800 million pesos umanong unexplained wealth
03:27si Vice President Duterte.
03:29Kabilang dito on tungkol sa kumpanyang Gencorp na idineklara ng business sa kanyang salen
03:34pero hindi raw niya idineklara ang kita mula rito.
03:38How would you characterize a report po that uses conjectures?
03:42Well, we cannot base, especially if it concerns financial investigation,
03:48hindi hulang basis sa conjectures.
03:51Dapat po, ito ay may facts.
03:54Ano po ba yung conjectures sa Filipino, if you know?
03:58Sa aking kong paghalang, ito ay mga haka-haka.
04:01Ipinakita rin ng depensa ang salen ni Pangulong Bongbong Marcos na finail
04:05noong 2023 at 2024 kung saan nakadeklara o mano ang business interest ng Pangulo.
04:12Tumaas din daw ang net worth ng Pangulo sa mga nagdaang taon.
04:15There's a portion po doon na business interest and financial connection.
04:20So si PBBM listed two.
04:23One is Araka Resources Corporation.
04:26And then the other one is El Paraiso Farms Incorporated.
04:30As a financial investigator, what comments do you have on the financial and business interest portion?
04:36This portion po of PBBM salen.
04:38As far as I can remember, this is a harmless information.
04:43From P960,000 in a year, naging P1.1 billion.
04:48And then after another year, nag P200 million increase na naman.
04:52Naging P1.3 billion.
04:55Kailangan humabusising investigahan muna yan before we can make a conclusion.
05:00Kaugday pa rin sa Gencorp, tinanong ng depensa sa financial investigator
05:05ang paggamit ng prosecution ng mga resibo ng fast food
05:09bilang isa sa ebidensya para matukoy na lima ang pag-aari nitong branches.
05:14Kung naisip niyang paraan ay kumain sa Jollibee branches at tingnan yung mga resibo.
05:19Actually, Your Honor, napapakunot ako ng noo kanina dun sa resibo.
05:23I don't see the...
05:24Again, we don't do this sa financial investigation.
05:27It can be verified by official SEC documents.
05:32It is more official.
05:33Matatanda ang bukod sa mga resibong ito,
05:36iprenesenta din naman ang prosecution sa impeachment court,
05:40ang mga dokumento mula sa Securities and Exchange Commission,
05:43at SAL and ang vice-presidente kaugnay sa Gencorp.
05:46Sa cross-examination, binusisi ng prosecution,
05:49ang kwalifikasyon at pagiging eksperto ni De La Fuente.
05:53So, what was your position, sir, BSP ranking?
05:56Bank officer 2.
05:57And bank officer 2.
05:59So, that is not a senior management position, am I correct?
06:02Yes, Your Honor.
06:03Yes, that's entry level.
06:05So, your expertise or your claimed expertise
06:08as a financial expert in financial investigation
06:14only comes from the 25 months you were a entry-level investigator
06:21for the AMLC. Is that correct?
06:24Yes, Your Honor.
06:26Tinanong naman ang Senator Judges kung nabasa ba
06:28ni De La Fuente ang buong report mula sa testigo ng prosecution.
06:33Mr. Witness, any documents provided to you before appearing here?
06:41Nine-year-old.
06:42Nine-year-old.
06:43Kahit na nanggaling pa siya dyan sa AMLOC, etc.,
06:47na yung kanyang expertise,
06:48kung hindi naman niya po nakita pala yung mga dokumento,
06:51STRs, CTRs, what good is it?
06:55Para anong titistigo niya?
06:57Base lang po sa batas, maaari ko na akong sagutin
07:01kung ano yung, kung nasa,
07:03na ito ba ay lawful or hindi.
07:06Pagkatapos ng presentasyon ng witness,
07:08ipinunto ng depensa na ang burden of proof
07:10para mapatunayan na may unexplained wealth ang bise
07:14ay nasa prosecution umano
07:16at beyond reasonable doubt umano
07:19ang dapat nabatayan ng hatol dito.
07:22Sandra Aguinaldo, nagbabalita para sa GMA News.