• hace 11 minutos
Cinco países de la UE anuncian el primer centro de retorno de migrantes en Ruanda

En esta edición de nuestro programa de debate, los eurodiputados Lena Düpont (PPE) y Robert Biedroń (S&D) se enfrentan cara a cara sobre la política migratoria de la UE.

MÁS INFORMACIÓN : http://es.euronews.com/2026/11/19/cinco-paises-de-la-ue-anuncian-el-primer-centro-de-retorno-de-migrantes-en-ruanda

¡Suscríbete a nuestro canal! Euronews está disponible en 12 idiomas

Categoría

🗞
Noticias
Transcripción
00:08Hola y bienvenidos a The Ring.
00:11Soy María Tadeo y en este show,
00:13nos vamos a dar a la parte del Parlamento de la Europa
00:16donde debemos hablar de las más relevantes
00:18que se basan en la Unión Europea.
00:21Y esta semana, nos vamos a hablar de migración.
00:24Especialmente polarizando,
00:25pero también es muy relevante esta semana,
00:28como cinco países de EUA han entrado en un parcero con Rwanda
00:33para retornar a los asilo de asilo.
00:35Este es un primer para la Unión Europea
00:38y podría señalar una política más difícil de migrar.
00:41Mi productor Luis Alberto has more.
00:46En marzo de este año,
00:48el Parlamento Europeo adoptó una reforma
00:50enabling los Estados Unidos de los Estados
00:51a tener migración de retornos en terceros países
00:54para rejecutar asilo-seekers.
00:57Esta semana, cinco EU países
00:58anunciaron el primer retorno hub
01:00para migrantes en Rwanda.
01:03Denmark, Austria,
01:04Alemania, el Nétero y Grecia
01:06anunciaron el primer proyecto
01:08durante el Viena Migración Conference.
01:12Y es no,
01:13sin suerte de la controversia
01:15sobre respeto por fundamental rights
01:16y compatibilidad con EU law,
01:18especialmente después de la UN
01:20arraste concerns sobre el track record
01:22de respeto por human rights en Rwanda.
01:25Cuando suponexas argue
01:26que el sistema de migración
01:27necesita efectivo retornos,
01:29better control de regular arrivals
01:31y más mejor cooperación
01:32con terceros países,
01:33los países,
01:34pero,
01:35anunciaron que el sistema de migración
01:36de gestión de acceso a asilo
01:39y dejar vulnerable personas
01:40sin legal protección.
01:43¿Es Europa
01:44el balance entre seguridad
01:46y la dignidad?
01:47¿O?
01:48¿O?
01:48a more restrictive approach?
01:51¿Are Return Hub
01:52part of the solution
01:53and can the EU balance
01:54stricter migration policies
01:56with growing human rights concerns?
02:01And that is certainly
02:03the question,
02:04it's not an easy question
02:05and then it's a lot here
02:06to unpack,
02:07so let's meet
02:08our two MEPs,
02:10our two contenders
02:11for this week's
02:12The Ring.
02:14Lena Dupont,
02:15a German MEP
02:16from the Central Right
02:17European People's Party.
02:19She serves on the Committee
02:20on Civil Liberties,
02:21Justice and Home Affairs.
02:22She says,
02:23effective returns
02:24are an integral part
02:25of a functioning asylum system.
02:27Those who need protection
02:29must receive it.
02:30Those who do not need protection
02:31cannot be allowed to stay.
02:33Return hubs
02:34operating within a clear
02:35legal framework
02:36and in cooperation
02:37with reliable
02:38third country partners
02:39can help ensure
02:40that return decisions
02:42are effectively implemented.
02:44Robert Biedron,
02:45a Polish MEP
02:46from the Socialist
02:47and Democrats Group.
02:48He is the Vice Chair
02:49of the Committee on Development
02:50and a member of the Committee
02:51on Foreign Affairs
02:52and the Subcommittee
02:53on Human Rights.
02:54He says,
02:55the EU is still
02:56the world's strongest
02:57protector of human rights.
02:59It is a requirement
03:00under the treaties
03:01for all of our policies,
03:02including migration.
03:04As the Parliament's
03:05co-rapporteur
03:05on the Global Europe Instrument,
03:07I will fight
03:07to make sure
03:08that the EU
03:09will continue
03:10to support democracy
03:11and human rights
03:12around the world
03:13and that the EU
03:14will never fund
03:15migration actions
03:16that violate human rights.
03:19So let me now welcome
03:21our two members
03:22of the European Parliament,
03:24Madame Dupont
03:24and Mr. Biedron.
03:27Let me begin
03:28perhaps by you,
03:29Madame Dupont,
03:30because you voted in favor,
03:32you have expressed
03:33a support
03:34for this policy.
03:36Is this a good idea
03:38to send rejected
03:39asylum seekers
03:40to countries
03:41they have
03:41no connection with?
03:43Well, first of all,
03:43I think it is a bit
03:44good to have a reminder
03:46of where the policy
03:47comes from.
03:48I mean,
03:48in the last term,
03:49we extensively
03:50negotiated
03:50the so-called
03:51asylum and migration pact
03:52where return
03:53was always part
03:54of the package.
03:56There were political reasons
03:57why it was taken
03:58out of the packet,
03:59but it was always clear
04:00that there are two sides
04:01to an effective,
04:03let's say,
04:03an effective promise
04:05of protection.
04:06So, A,
04:06good and efficient procedures
04:08to grant protection,
04:09but also,
04:10and this is the second side
04:11of the matter,
04:12is that if you don't have
04:13the right to stay
04:14within the European Union,
04:15if you're not eligible
04:15for protection,
04:16you need to go.
04:17And I think everyone
04:18understands if you don't
04:19have the right to be
04:20in the EU,
04:21you have to go,
04:22but there is
04:22a substantial difference
04:23between a return
04:25to a country of origin
04:26to a third country
04:28like Rwanda.
04:29Would you feel safe
04:30as a woman
04:30if you ended up
04:31somehow in Rwanda?
04:33Well,
04:33also there,
04:34let me remind that,
04:36as it was mentioned
04:37also by Robert,
04:38actually,
04:38in his starting remark,
04:39that under the EU principle,
04:42under international law,
04:43under also the national
04:44principles of legality,
04:46there is the right
04:47to protection
04:48and, of course,
04:49the safeguards
04:49also to human rights.
04:51But if you are,
04:53and if you're,
04:53you say,
04:54your home country
04:55is not cooperating
04:56with the European Union
04:58and you cannot be sent
04:59back to your own country,
05:00then, of course,
05:01member states
05:02need to find a way
05:03of actually really
05:04also offering
05:05an opportunity there.
05:06And the very important
05:07thing there is
05:09that based on the agreement
05:10that you also have
05:12a perspective
05:13in that country.
05:14And I think that this is
05:15also part of the whole debate.
05:17And that means
05:17off to Rwanda,
05:18but still,
05:19I'm not sure you would
05:20want to go as a woman
05:21to Rwanda,
05:21even if you ended up
05:22in the European Union.
05:24We'll go back to that later.
05:25We'll go back to that
05:25in a second.
05:26But, Robert,
05:27you have said
05:28that this is bad policy
05:29and it's not going
05:30to fix the problem.
05:31Why?
05:31Because it didn't work
05:33in the past.
05:33We have example
05:34from UK
05:35where lots of taxpayers'
05:38money was spent
05:38for the return hubs
05:40in Rwanda.
05:40The fact that
05:41it was ruled
05:43unlawful
05:44by the UK Supreme Court.
05:46And the plane
05:46couldn't take off.
05:47And the plane
05:48couldn't take off.
05:49And it didn't work
05:50in Albania
05:50where the populist,
05:52Meloni's government
05:53has spent
05:54a lot of taxpayers'
05:55money again
05:56to fund
05:57this return hub.
05:58And de facto
05:59the hub
05:59which was
06:00to adopt
06:02except
06:0336,000
06:04immigrants yearly
06:06adopted
06:07a few hundred
06:08and there are
06:09serious concerns
06:10about human rights
06:11situation
06:12in this return hub.
06:14So we have
06:14a situation
06:15where populism
06:17won
06:18against
06:19the human rights
06:20and I'm
06:20really surprised
06:21because we
06:22are social democrats.
06:23We were ready
06:24to negotiate
06:25good migration
06:26policy
06:27for European Union.
06:29And European
06:29People's Party
06:31created
06:32a populist
06:34product
06:34on return
06:35hubs
06:36together with
06:36far right.
06:37And it's
06:37the biggest
06:38surprise to myself.
06:39Let me
06:39shortly react to it.
06:41Your policy
06:41is bad.
06:42That's what he argues.
06:43No, because
06:43I think there are
06:44two remarks
06:45basically to what
06:46you had just been
06:47saying.
06:47First, EU-UK,
06:49UK,
06:50Uganda,
06:51Rwanda,
06:52Italy,
06:52Albania,
06:53they were also
06:54about the
06:55asylum procedures
06:56as such.
06:56For the return
06:57hubs,
06:57we're speaking
06:58about people
06:58who had really
06:59completed
07:00with all legal
07:01safeguards
07:01all procedures
07:02within the
07:03European Union
07:03and were not
07:04granted protection
07:05and have the
07:06return decision
07:06legally fixed
07:07also by all
07:08the judicial
07:09safeguards.
07:09So we're
07:10speaking about
07:10a different
07:11model here.
07:12Second,
07:13it was always
07:14clear for us
07:15that, you know,
07:16two sides
07:16of one metal.
07:17If you want
07:17to grant protection,
07:18you also need
07:19to have a
07:20solution for
07:21the return
07:22use.
07:22And one
07:22in five
07:23return
07:23use just
07:24effectively
07:24leaves the
07:25European Union.
07:26It's also
07:26a question
07:26of, you know,
07:27respect for the
07:28principle, also
07:29of rule of law,
07:30because if we set
07:30rules, we need
07:31to make sure
07:31that they're
07:32also up here.
07:33And the third
07:34remark, just let me
07:35shortly finish,
07:36the third remark
07:36is that when
07:37you look at the
07:38countries actually
07:39now going forward
07:40with this
07:41agreement, there
07:42are EPP
07:43governments, there
07:44is an S&D
07:45government, there
07:45is a liberal
07:46government.
07:47So I don't buy
07:48the, let's say,
07:50the notion that
07:51it's just a
07:51populistic movement.
07:52I think what we
07:53need to deliver
07:54on the ground
07:54is really solutions
07:56that work for
07:56our society.
07:57But this is not
07:58a solution.
07:59This is the
08:00populist
08:00construct which
08:02sends people
08:03who have nothing
08:04in common
08:05with Rwanda.
08:06I just want to
08:07remind you, I don't
08:08know if you are
08:08familiar, Rwanda is
08:10a dictatorship
08:11country.
08:12It's a country
08:13in the human
08:14rights ranking
08:15which is close
08:16to Russia.
08:17I'm appalled.
08:18I cannot imagine
08:19that one day
08:20you will find
08:22an idea to send
08:22people, for example,
08:23to Russia,
08:24because it has
08:25the same human
08:25rights score
08:28as Rwanda.
08:30It's like sending
08:31Ukrainian migrants
08:33who sooner or
08:34later are illegal
08:36in the European
08:36Union to Belarus.
08:38This is the same
08:39concept.
08:39And I want to
08:40remind you, just
08:41few months ago,
08:42we put sanctions
08:44as European Union
08:46against Rwandan
08:47individuals
08:48because of their
08:50engagement in
08:51serious human
08:52rights violations.
08:53And now you want
08:54to send these
08:54people to Rwanda
08:55for what?
08:57They will be
08:57disconnected from
08:58their countries,
08:59they will don't
09:00know the culture,
09:00we don't know
09:01what will be
09:02the conditions
09:03in Rwanda.
09:04And yes,
09:05the argument
09:05of Maria
09:06as a woman,
09:08imagine being
09:09in this country
09:10where there's
09:10serious human
09:12rights violations
09:13similar to Russia.
09:14I cannot imagine.
09:15And you point
09:16to the human
09:16rights record
09:17and you point
09:17to the legal
09:18issues.
09:18We're going
09:19to debate
09:19them in detail.
09:20I see you're
09:21warmed up,
09:21but let's move
09:22into our next
09:23section.
09:28Let me now ask
09:29you to put
09:30a question,
09:30you can put
09:31a question
09:31to Madame
09:32Dupont,
09:32and Madame
09:32Dupont,
09:33you can put
09:33a question
09:33to Robert,
09:35and then we
09:36can debate
09:37the three of us.
09:38Let's start
09:38perhaps with
09:39you,
09:40since I cut
09:40you off.
09:41Yes,
09:41since we
09:42talk about
09:43compassion
09:43and mercy
09:44and human
09:45rights values,
09:45I want to
09:46ask you,
09:47Lena,
09:47because you
09:47come from
09:48a historically
09:50very important
09:51party in
09:51Germany,
09:52a Christian
09:52Democrats
09:52Union.
09:54So you
09:55represent,
09:55you should
09:56represent the
09:57values of
09:57Christianity,
09:58mercy,
09:58compassion,
10:00on democracy,
10:01human rights,
10:02rule of law.
10:03I want to
10:03ask you
10:04personally,
10:06how do you
10:06cope with
10:09merging these
10:10values with
10:11return hubs
10:12when these
10:12values will be
10:13completely
10:14devastated?
10:15Well,
10:15thanks for
10:16that question,
10:16actually.
10:17I do hope
10:17that I get
10:17the time to
10:18answer it
10:19correctly,
10:19because it
10:19actually gives
10:21me the
10:22opportunity
10:22to also
10:23say a bit
10:23about the
10:23personal note.
10:24And it's
10:25serious words
10:25what he's
10:26saying.
10:26It is,
10:27and this is
10:27why I'm
10:27going to
10:27answer in
10:28all seriousness,
10:29because I
10:30entered
10:30politics,
10:31because after
10:32the aftermath
10:32of 2015-2016
10:34in Germany,
10:35where we had
10:35a huge
10:35arrival of
10:37people coming
10:37to seek
10:38protection
10:38within the
10:39European Union,
10:39I saw what
10:40it did to
10:40the political
10:41debate,
10:41I saw how
10:42it put
10:43constraints
10:43on all
10:44our systems,
10:46be it the
10:46social welfare
10:47system,
10:47be it the
10:47health system,
10:48be it schooling,
10:49be it access
10:49to the
10:50labour market
10:51and to
10:51housing,
10:52and I saw
10:53that there's
10:53a European
10:54dimension of
10:54responsibility
10:55that we need
10:56to take up
10:56at the European
10:57You mentioned
10:57the one million
10:58Syrians going
10:58to Germany,
10:59just to give a
11:01historical context.
11:01There are also
11:02other challenges
11:02that came up
11:03in the aftermath.
11:04This is why
11:05we focus so much
11:06on actually
11:06really bringing
11:07together 27
11:08member states,
11:09three institutions,
11:10I would say
11:11three and a half
11:11political families
11:12here in the
11:13House to agree
11:14on what I call
11:15the inner dimension
11:16of the European
11:17asylum and migration
11:17system,
11:18which was
11:18our own rules
11:19here.
11:20But it was
11:20always clear
11:21that because
11:22migration is
11:23something within
11:24the European
11:25Union,
11:25but it's also
11:26something externally,
11:27that the
11:28external dimension
11:28will always be
11:29part of it.
11:30And your notion
11:31on saying
11:31that indeed,
11:34and there is a
11:34very good reason
11:35why there is so
11:36much emphasis
11:36on the respect
11:37for human rights,
11:38and if you look
11:39at what has been
11:40agreed by now,
11:41there's a huge
11:42section on
11:43exactly that.
11:44But if you
11:45take it together
11:46with the notion
11:47that I was
11:48sending in,
11:48one in five
11:49is effectively
11:49returned because
11:50far too often
11:51we have a lack
11:52of third country
11:52cooperation
11:53undergoing the
11:54international
11:55obligation to
11:55take back
11:56your own
11:56citizens,
11:57member states
11:58do look out
11:59for different
11:59reasons.
11:59And what they
12:00have proposed
12:03now is together
12:04with the
12:05cooperation of
12:05international
12:06organizations like
12:07IOM and
12:08UNFCR to
12:09really have a
12:10legal set to
12:12offer perspective
12:13in that country.
12:14And to your
12:15point on the
12:15question of
12:16whether I
12:16would go
12:16there as
12:17a woman,
12:17we still
12:18have all
12:19the asylum
12:19rules in
12:20place that
12:20allow for
12:21effective
12:22protection even
12:23under regional
12:24let's say
12:25differentiation.
12:26So a woman
12:27will always
12:28have a
12:28different
12:29vulnerability
12:29status.
12:30It's not
12:31part of the
12:31return agreement
12:32actually.
12:33And when you
12:34look at the
12:34text, it
12:35clearly says
12:35that vulnerable
12:36groups,
12:37that children,
12:37that children
12:38and families
12:38are protected
12:40and not part
12:40of the deal.
12:41Well, it's
12:42like really
12:43again, it's
12:43like sending
12:44these families
12:45to Russia.
12:46It has the
12:47same human
12:47rights core,
12:49Rwanda and
12:50Russia.
12:51I cannot
12:51imagine that
12:52you would be
12:53so blinded
12:54on that
12:55issue that
12:55you are
12:56sending
12:56these people
12:57to the
12:58country where
12:59the situation
13:00will be
13:00uncertain.
13:01And by the
13:01way, there
13:02is no
13:02time limit
13:03how long
13:04they will
13:04be kept
13:06in these
13:06It's open
13:07facilities.
13:08It's not
13:08about keeping
13:09people.
13:10But it's
13:10still not
13:11their country
13:11of origin.
13:12Yes.
13:13Indeed.
13:14But if your
13:15country of origin
13:16does not
13:16cooperate and
13:17is not willing
13:18to take you
13:18back, which
13:19is their
13:19international
13:19obligation.
13:20the government
13:20pay the price
13:21for the
13:21individual,
13:22the person,
13:23vulnerable
13:23If you have
13:24the possibility
13:24to develop
13:25a decent
13:26life in
13:26another country,
13:28and to add
13:29to that,
13:30it is part
13:31of the
13:33agreement
13:33that they
13:33have access
13:34to the
13:35labor market,
13:35that they
13:35have access
13:36to health,
13:37that they
13:37have access
13:37to housing,
13:38and that they
13:39have the
13:39possibility to
13:40really develop
13:41a decent
13:41life, which
13:42by the way
13:42will also
13:43be supported.
13:44Robert, let
13:44me give
13:45Madame Dupont
13:45just the
13:46floor to ask
13:47you a question
13:47and she
13:48brings up
13:48a very fair
13:49and also
13:50valid point.
13:51There is an
13:51issue in the
13:52European Union
13:53when it comes
13:53to legal
13:55court orders
13:56that say
13:56this individual
13:57must be
13:58expelled.
13:58They simply
13:59do not
14:00happen.
14:00That is also
14:01a failure
14:01of the
14:01system.
14:02Madame Dupont,
14:03your time
14:03for your
14:03question.
14:04Well,
14:04thanks a lot
14:05and that
14:05actually
14:05already
14:06leads to
14:07my
14:07question
14:07because
14:07I mean
14:08we've
14:08been
14:09through
14:09very
14:09emotional
14:10debates
14:10here in
14:10the
14:11house
14:11which is
14:11always
14:11the
14:12case
14:12when
14:12we
14:12speak
14:12about
14:13asylum
14:13immigration
14:14because
14:14it's
14:14about
14:14people
14:15and
14:15you're
14:15completely
14:15right
14:16on
14:16that
14:16you're
14:16completely
14:16right
14:17on
14:17putting
14:18that
14:18emphasis
14:18over
14:19there
14:19but
14:19at
14:20the
14:20same
14:20time
14:20we
14:21also
14:21need
14:21to
14:21make
14:21sure
14:21that
14:22we
14:31answer
14:31to
14:32one
14:32in
14:33five
14:33returnees
14:34actually
14:34is
14:34only
14:35effectively
14:35returned
14:36and
14:36how
14:36should
14:37we
14:37solve
14:37that
14:37within
14:37the
14:37European
14:38Union
14:38if
14:39this
14:39is
14:39not
14:39and
14:39again
14:39I'm
14:40saying
14:40it's
14:40part
14:40of
14:41the
14:41toolbox
14:41it's
14:42one
14:42tool
14:43complementary
14:44to
14:44every
14:45other
14:45thing
14:45that
14:46we
14:46developed
14:46in
14:46the
14:46last
14:46years
14:47Yes
14:47Well
14:47it's
14:47a
14:48very
14:48good
14:48question
14:48and
14:48I
14:49agree
14:49we
14:49should
14:49look
14:50for
14:50effective
14:51solutions
14:52and
14:53I'm
14:53a
14:53Polish
14:53citizen
14:54I
14:54remember
14:54when
14:55millions
14:56of
14:56Polish
14:56people
14:56were
14:57migrating
14:57outside
14:59our
14:59country
14:59and
15:00I
15:00think
15:00the
15:01clever
15:01thing
15:01we
15:02did
15:02in
15:02Poland
15:02together
15:03with
15:03Germans
15:04and
15:04European
15:04Union
15:05is
15:06to
15:06create
15:06opportunities
15:07in
15:08the
15:08country
15:08of
15:08origin
15:09this
15:09is
15:10important
15:10that
15:10these
15:10people
15:11will
15:11have
15:12a
15:12chance
15:12to
15:12stay
15:13in
15:13their
15:13countries
15:14of
15:14origin
15:15and
15:15not
15:15be
15:16forced
15:16to
15:17migrate
15:17because
15:18of
15:18climate
15:18change
15:19lack
15:19of
15:19job
15:20opportunities
15:20war
15:22or
15:22conflicts
15:23and
15:23in
15:23our
15:24committee
15:24and
15:24global
15:25Europe
15:25instrument
15:25which
15:26I
15:26work
15:26on
15:26we
15:27create
15:27these
15:28opportunities
15:28and
15:29it's
15:29important
15:29that
15:30we
15:30do
15:30that
15:30and
15:31we
15:31don't
15:31go
15:31into
15:32this
15:32populist
15:34which
15:35doesn't
15:35work
15:35but you
15:36say
15:36populist
15:37and you
15:37allude
15:37to
15:37Georgia
15:38Meloni
15:38Georgia
15:38Meloni
15:39is also
15:39saying
15:40to a
15:40large
15:40degree
15:41we
15:41need
15:41to
15:42work
15:42with
15:42countries
15:43in
15:43Africa
15:43to
15:43develop
15:44their
15:44economy
15:44so
15:45they
15:45do
15:45not
15:45migrate
15:46into
15:46Europe
15:46is
15:47this
15:47a
15:47double
15:47track
15:48then
15:54also
15:54say
15:54there
15:55needs
15:55to
15:55be
15:55a
15:56way
15:56to
15:56simply
15:57enact
15:57returns
15:58yes
15:58it's
15:59not
15:59one
15:59or
15:59the
15:59other
15:59it's
16:00there
16:00should
16:00be
16:00a
16:00way
16:00but
16:01it
16:01should
16:01be
16:01a
16:01legal
16:02way
16:02it
16:03should
16:03be
16:03a
16:03way
16:03which
16:04respects
16:04EU
16:05values
16:05EU
16:06legislation
16:06and
16:07international
16:08human
16:08rights
16:09standards
16:09and
16:10these
16:10legislation
16:11on
16:12return
16:12hubs
16:13violates
16:13all
16:14of
16:14these
16:14regulations
16:15Lena
16:15has
16:16mentioned
16:16IOM
16:17and
16:17UN
16:19human
16:19rights
16:19commission
16:21they
16:22say
16:22they
16:23have
16:23no
16:23access
16:24to
16:24return
16:25hubs
16:26and
16:26they
16:26don't
16:27have
16:27details
16:27they
16:27need
16:28to
16:28be
16:28invited
16:28by
16:29Rwanda
16:30how
16:30do
16:30you
16:30want
16:31to
16:31invite
16:31IOM
16:32and
16:33other
16:33EU
16:34UN
16:35institutions
16:36while
16:37Amnesty
16:37International
16:40operates
16:40under
16:40cover
16:41in
16:41Rwanda
16:41and
16:42human
16:42rights
16:42watch
16:43has
16:43even
16:43no
16:44access
16:44to
16:44Rwanda
16:45how
16:45do
16:45you
16:45ensure
16:46the
16:46legality
16:46of
16:46it
16:47well
16:47it's
16:47part
16:47of
16:48the
16:48agreements
16:48actually
16:49and
16:50it's
16:50part
16:50of
16:50that
16:51the
16:51five
16:51member
16:51states
16:52of
16:52the
16:52European
16:52Union
16:53reached
16:53out
16:53to
16:54the
16:54international
16:54organization
16:55making
16:56them
16:56part
16:57of
16:57not
16:58only
16:58the
16:58legal
16:59agreement
16:59but
16:59also
16:59the
17:00implementation
17:00on
17:01the
17:01Rwanda
17:01who
17:02has
17:02to
17:02this
17:04is
17:04part
17:05of
17:05the
17:05deal
17:05as
17:05well
17:06and
17:06I
17:06think
17:06what
17:07you
17:07just
17:07mentioned
17:07and
17:08I
17:08fully
17:09agree
17:09with
17:09you
17:09here
17:09that
17:10there
17:10is
17:11a
17:11very
17:12high
17:13value
17:13and
17:13a
17:14very
17:14high
17:14need
17:14actually
17:15of
17:15having
17:16our
17:16development
17:16policies
17:17of
17:17having
17:17our
17:18third
17:18country
17:18corporation
17:19also
17:19focusing
17:20on
17:20the
17:20countries
17:21of
17:21return
17:21this
17:22is
17:22without
17:22any
17:23doubt
17:23but
17:23it's
17:24not
17:24vice
17:24versa
17:25it's
17:25both
17:26ways
17:26and
17:27to
17:27that
17:27point
17:28let's
17:28just
17:28take
17:28a
17:29breather
17:29here
17:29I
17:29know
17:30you
17:30have
17:30a
17:30lot
17:31of
17:31things
17:31you
17:31want
17:31to
17:31say
17:31I
17:32think
17:32it's
17:32not
17:32a
17:32coincidence
17:33that
17:33people
17:34are
17:34being
17:34sent
17:34to
17:34Rwanda
17:35and
17:35now
17:35we
17:35talk
17:36about
17:36Uganda
17:36this
17:37is
17:37not
17:37a
17:37next
17:38on
17:38list
17:38it
17:39would
17:39seem
17:39because
17:40it's
17:40not
17:40just
17:40going
17:40to
17:40be
17:40one
17:41country
17:41it
17:41looks
17:41like
17:41it
17:41will
17:42be
17:42multiple
17:42countries
17:42in the
17:43future
17:43we
17:44will
17:44debrief
17:44that
17:44but
17:45first
17:45let's
17:46take
17:46a
17:46breather
17:46here
17:47let's
17:47take
17:47a
17:47quick
17:47pause
17:47and
17:48we'll
17:48be
17:48right
17:48back
17:48in
17:49the
17:49next
17:49section
17:58now
17:58welcome
17:59back
17:59to
17:59the
18:00ring
18:00I'm
18:01Maria
18:01today
18:01we
18:02continue
18:02debating
18:03the
18:03implications
18:04around
18:04migration
18:05policy
18:05in the
18:06European
18:06Union
18:07with
18:07Lana
18:07Dupont
18:08you are
18:08German
18:08from
18:09the
18:09Conservatives
18:10and
18:10of course
18:10Robert
18:11Biedrin
18:11you are
18:11Polish
18:12and
18:12progressive
18:13which
18:13can
18:13actually
18:14happen
18:14you can
18:15put
18:15those
18:15two
18:15in
18:16the
18:16same
18:16sentence
18:17and
18:18of course
18:18we are
18:19of course
18:21as I say
18:22we are
18:22focusing
18:23on
18:23migration
18:24and a
18:24week
18:25after
18:26five EU
18:26countries
18:27enter
18:27now
18:27a
18:28partnership
18:28with
18:29Rwanda
18:29to
18:29send
18:30back
18:30to
18:30return
18:31rejected
18:31asylum
18:32seekers
18:33away
18:33from
18:34EU
18:34territory
18:35I do
18:35want to
18:36however
18:37look at
18:38the numbers
18:38because
18:38this is
18:39important
18:39in this
18:40debate
18:40to inject
18:41a form
18:41of
18:42nuance
18:42these are
18:43numbers
18:43from
18:43Frontex
18:44in the
18:45first half
18:45of this
18:45year
18:46so
18:462026
18:47more than
18:4733,000
18:49people
18:49were returned
18:50to
18:50non-EU
18:51countries
18:51that means
18:52on a
18:53year-on-year
18:53basis
18:54there's been
18:54a 10%
18:55increase
18:56around
18:57two-thirds
18:57went back
18:58to their
18:59countries
18:59voluntarily
19:00that means
19:01approximately
19:0221,000
19:03people
19:03so
19:04Robert
19:04how
19:05does
19:05that
19:05add
19:05up
19:06to
19:06your
19:07thesis
19:07that
19:08this
19:08is
19:08not
19:08going
19:08to
19:09work
19:09and
19:09that
19:09it
19:10is
19:10simply
19:10a
19:10PR
19:10stunt
19:11well
19:11there's
19:12another
19:13also
19:14number
19:14that
19:16there's
19:16less
19:17and
19:17less
19:17migrants
19:18willing
19:18to
19:18enter
19:19EU
19:20we
19:20see
19:20the
19:21decrease
19:21on
19:22that
19:22so
19:22the
19:23data
19:23go
19:24against
19:24this
19:24populist
19:25ideas
19:26which
19:27don't
19:27work
19:27on
19:29return
19:29hubs
19:30again
19:31while
19:32we
19:32create
19:33opportunities
19:33for
19:34people
19:34in
19:35their
19:35country
19:35of
19:35origin
19:36they're
19:36willing
19:37to
19:37stay
19:37no
19:38one
19:38wants
19:38to
19:38leave
19:38their
19:40country
19:40people
19:41leaving
19:42their
19:42families
19:42in
19:43desperation
19:43looking
19:44for
19:44better
19:44life
19:45so
19:45what
19:46we
19:46should
19:46do
19:46and
19:47this
19:47is
19:47what
19:47this
19:48is
19:48going
19:48back
19:49because
19:49in
19:49their
19:49country
19:50of
19:50origin
19:50the
19:50country
19:51where
19:51they
19:51come
19:51from
19:51the
19:52situation
19:52is
19:52better
19:52you
19:53honestly
19:53believe
19:53that
19:53well
19:54you
19:54think
19:54in
19:55Syria
19:55the
19:55situation
19:56is
19:56better
19:56now
19:56than
19:57it
19:57was
19:5710
19:57years
19:57ago
19:57coming
19:58back
19:58because
19:59of
19:59that
19:59reason
20:00but
20:00what
20:00differs
20:01us
20:01from
20:02global
20:03powers
20:04like
20:04China
20:05and
20:05Trump
20:06administration
20:06as
20:07European
20:08Union
20:08that
20:09we
20:09have
20:09values
20:10we
20:11have
20:11some
20:11standards
20:12which
20:13we
20:13respect
20:13and
20:13this
20:14is
20:14why
20:14Lena
20:15Maria
20:16me
20:16we
20:17all
20:17feel
20:18protected
20:19by
20:19these
20:19values
20:20and
20:20these
20:21values
20:22should
20:22not
20:22be
20:22break
20:23to
20:24the
20:24people
20:24just
20:25because
20:25they
20:26are
20:26migrants
20:26this
20:27is
20:27our
20:27not
20:28only
20:28moral
20:28obligation
20:29but
20:30the
20:30legal
20:30obligation
20:31for
20:31these
20:31people
20:32that's
20:32a
20:32good
20:32question
20:33what
20:33about
20:33values
20:34is
20:34this
20:34Trump
20:34without
20:35calling
20:35it
20:35Trump
20:36no
20:36it's
20:36of
20:36course
20:37it's
20:37not
20:37because
20:37we
20:38have
20:38been
20:38investing
20:39in
20:39the
20:39past
20:39years
20:39quite
20:40extensively
20:40on
20:41the
20:41European
20:41answer
20:42to
20:42the
20:43European
20:43way
20:44of
20:44how
20:45we
20:45handle
20:45things
20:45and
20:45how
20:46we
20:46want
20:46to
20:46do
20:46it
20:46and
20:46this
20:47is
20:47why
20:55with
20:55the
20:56functioning
20:56legally
20:57sound
20:57policy
20:58and
20:58we
20:58did
20:58that
20:59not
20:59only
20:59here
20:59in
21:00this
21:00house
21:00but
21:00also
21:00together
21:01with
21:01the
21:01member
21:02states
21:02the
21:02French
21:02and
21:02Spanish
21:02say
21:03you
21:03are
21:03undoing
21:04the
21:04migration
21:05pact
21:05you
21:07saw
21:07there
21:07was
21:07a
21:08furious
21:08reaction
21:08from
21:09Emmanuel
21:09Macron
21:09just
21:09a
21:10month
21:10ago
21:10at
21:10the
21:10European
21:10Council
21:11yeah
21:11of
21:11course
21:25I
21:26third
21:26country
21:27corporation
21:27was
21:28always
21:28part
21:29of
21:29it
21:29and
21:29has
21:29always
21:30been
21:30part
21:30and
21:30needs
21:31to
21:31be
21:31part
21:31of
21:31it
21:32because
21:32again
21:32like
21:33you
21:33just
21:33said
21:33we
21:33have
21:34a
21:34duty
21:34also
21:35to
21:35help
21:35with
21:36whatever
21:36we
21:36can
21:37to
21:37improve
21:37the
21:37situation
21:38on
21:38the
21:38ground
21:38nevertheless
21:39we
21:40still
21:40have
21:40a
21:40situation
21:41within
21:41the
21:41European
21:41Union
21:42where
21:42we
21:43are
21:43indeed
21:43facing
21:44lesser
21:44arrivals
21:45which
21:45is
21:45part
21:46of
21:46the
21:47pacts
21:47and
21:47of
21:47course
21:48the
21:48measures
21:48that
21:48we
21:48had
21:49taken
21:49in
21:49between
21:49but
21:50we
21:50still
21:50have
21:51a
21:51lot
21:51of
21:51people
21:51within
21:52the
21:52European
21:52Union
21:52that
21:53have
21:53an
21:53effective
21:54return
21:54decision
21:55after
21:55all
21:55legally
21:56procedures
21:56have
21:56been
21:57exolved
21:58and
21:58they
21:58don't
21:59return
21:59so
21:59a
22:00court
22:00order
22:00has
22:00to
22:00be
22:01implemented
22:03and
22:03like
22:03you
22:03just
22:03said
22:04it's
22:04about
22:04the
22:04principle
22:05of
22:05rule
22:05of
22:06law
22:06if
22:06we
22:06set
22:06rules
22:07based
22:08on
22:08our
22:08values
22:09based
22:09on
22:09our
22:10legal
22:10principles
22:10based
22:11on
22:11our
22:11treaties
22:11based
22:18she
22:18is
22:19bringing
22:19a
22:19fair
22:19point
22:20there
22:20are
22:20individuals
22:21who
22:21at
22:21times
22:22have
22:22not
22:22just
22:22one
22:23but
22:23multiple
22:24orders
22:24to
22:24quit
22:25and
22:26please
22:27just
22:28one
22:28very
22:29important
22:29thing
22:30here
22:30because
22:30you
22:31were
22:31speaking
22:31about
22:31the
22:31voluntary
22:32returns
22:33is
22:34what
22:34we
22:35not
22:35only
22:35support
22:36financially
22:36and
22:37with
22:37integration
22:38measures
22:38but
22:39it's
22:39always
22:39for
22:40the
22:40European
22:40level
22:41and
22:41for
22:41the
22:41national
22:42level
22:42the
22:42first
22:43measure
22:43return
22:44hubs
22:44look
22:45at
22:45those
22:46where
22:46we
22:46don't
22:46have
22:46a
22:47cooperation
22:47with
22:48the
22:48country
22:49of
22:50origin
22:51but
22:52then
22:52we
22:53need
22:53to
22:53work
22:53with
22:54the
22:54countries
22:54of
22:54origin
22:55on
22:55that
22:57but
23:01if
23:01they're
23:02not
23:02following
23:02the
23:02international
23:03obligation
23:03to
23:04take
23:04back
23:04their
23:04own
23:05citizens
23:05then
23:06there
23:06needs
23:07to
23:07be
23:07also
23:07a
23:07consequence
23:08in
23:08the
23:08way
23:08we
23:08cooperate
23:09that's
23:09a
23:09fair
23:09point
23:10go
23:10ahead
23:10but
23:10not
23:10sending
23:11people
23:11to
23:11countries
23:12which
23:12are
23:12the
23:12fact
23:12of
23:12dictatorship
23:13imagine
23:14one
23:14day
23:14something
23:14goes
23:15the
23:15solution
23:16is
23:16of
23:17course
23:17better
23:17measures
23:18within
23:18european
23:19union
23:19which
23:20means
23:20what
23:20specifically
23:21to
23:21our
23:21viewers
23:22watching
23:22screening
23:22for
23:23example
23:23these
23:23people
23:23where
23:24they
23:24move
23:24I
23:24understand
23:25many
23:25of
23:25them
23:25are
23:26not
23:26being
23:26screened
23:27when
23:27they
23:27are
23:27there
23:28we're
23:28losing
23:28track
23:29on
23:29them
23:29that's
23:30we
23:30we have
23:30we have
23:31to
23:31screen
23:31these
23:32people
23:32and
23:32you
23:33screen
23:33them
23:33and
23:34you
23:34determine
23:34okay
23:35you
23:35are
23:35here
23:36irregularly
23:37legally
23:37each
23:37case
23:37needs
23:38to
23:38be
23:38individually
23:39judged
23:40that's
23:40the
23:40also
23:41ruling
23:41of
23:41European
23:42court
23:42on
23:43human
23:43rights
23:43there
23:44is
23:44the
23:45European
23:46court
23:46on
23:46human
23:47rights
23:47you
23:47cannot
23:47legally
23:48be
23:48in
23:48Europe
23:48so
23:49in
23:49your
23:49view
23:49if
23:50a
23:50return
23:50hub
23:50is
23:51basically
23:51a peer
23:51stunt
23:52in
23:52populism
23:53with
23:53the
23:53far
23:53right
23:54that's
23:54a
23:54very
23:54heavy
23:55statement
23:55what
23:56is
23:56the
23:56alternative
23:56the
23:57alternative
23:57is
23:58to
23:58cooperate
23:59with
23:59the
23:59countries
24:00of
24:00their
24:00origin
24:01they
24:01don't
24:01want
24:01to
24:01do
24:02it
24:02at
24:02times
24:02yes
24:02but
24:04you
24:05cannot
24:06you
24:07you
24:07sanction
24:08countries
24:09that
24:09don't
24:09take
24:09them
24:09back
24:09we
24:11as
24:11European
24:12Union
24:12we
24:12have
24:13tools
24:13to
24:13work
24:14with
24:14these
24:14countries
24:15which
24:16are
24:16for
24:16example
24:16sanctions
24:17on
24:18these
24:18countries
24:18which
24:19is
24:19a
24:19pressure
24:20and
24:20not
24:21to
24:21send
24:21these
24:21people
24:21well
24:24the
24:24thing
24:24is
24:25that
24:25for
24:26your
24:26population
24:27solution
24:28the
24:28taxpayers
24:29will
24:30pay
24:30seven
24:31times
24:31more
24:31than
24:32these
24:32people
24:32would
24:33stay
24:33this
24:33is
24:34an
24:35example
24:35from
24:35Italy
24:36in
24:36Albania
24:37the
24:38cost
24:38for
24:38Italy
24:39for
24:39each
24:39person
24:40is
24:42153
24:42thousand
24:43euros
24:44which
24:45is
24:46seven
24:46times
24:46more
24:47not
24:48about
24:49returns
24:49you
24:50saying
24:50it
24:50will
24:50be
24:50even
24:51more
24:51cost
24:54we
24:56need
24:57to
24:57move
24:57on
24:57but
24:57Georgia
24:57Meloni
24:58would
24:58argue
24:59the
24:59Italian
24:59taxpayer
25:00prefers
25:01to
25:01pay
25:02and
25:02not
25:02have
25:03a
25:03regular
25:03migration
25:04in
25:04the
25:04country
25:05than
25:06to
25:06have
25:06to
25:06integrate
25:07and
25:07put
25:07forward
25:07policies
25:08to
25:08integrate
25:08that's
25:09what
25:09she
25:09would
25:09argue
25:10migration
25:10also
25:11needs
25:11to
25:11be
25:11handled
25:12with
25:13a
25:13possibility
25:13to
25:14enforce
25:14returns
25:15maybe
25:15Georgia
25:16Meloni
25:16is
25:17similar
25:17to
25:17Mertz
25:19the
25:19councillor
25:19of
25:19Germany
25:20who
25:20once
25:20said
25:21he
25:21doesn't
25:21want
25:21to
25:22see
25:22these
25:22people
25:22on
25:22the
25:23streets
25:23because
25:23they
25:24spoil
25:24the
25:24picture
25:25of
25:25the
25:25city
25:25but
25:26that's
25:27really
25:28going
25:28very far
25:29why
25:29at
25:30German
25:30local
25:30level
25:31all
25:32the
25:32MPs
25:32including
25:33the
25:33SND
25:34governments
25:34were
25:35supporting
25:36a
25:36statement
25:36in
25:37October
25:3726
25:37saying
25:38that
25:38they
25:38welcome
25:39and
25:39support
25:39the
25:40initiative
25:40by
25:41the
25:41federal
25:41government
25:42but
25:42we
25:42need
25:43to
25:43now
25:43take
25:43a
25:43pause
25:44here
25:44and
25:45move
25:45on
25:45to
25:45our
25:45next
25:46round
25:46stay
25:46with
25:47us
25:47here
25:47on
25:47the
25:47ring
25:51now
25:52we
25:52need
25:52to
25:52bring
25:52in
25:53a
25:53new
25:53voice
25:54and
25:54that
25:54is
25:55the
25:55Spanish
25:55prime
25:56minister
25:56allow
25:57me
25:57to
25:58read
25:58you
25:58this
25:58full
25:58quote
25:59I
25:59don't
25:59see
26:00a
26:00future
26:00nor
26:01humanity
26:01in
26:02it
26:02we
26:03are
26:03a
26:03country
26:04of
26:04principle
26:04that
26:05respects
26:06human
26:06rights
26:06and
26:07over
26:07the
26:07course
26:07of
26:08this
26:08year
26:08the
26:08aggregate
26:09figures
26:09show
26:10that
26:10irregular
26:10migration
26:11has
26:11fallen
26:12by
26:12around
26:1238%
26:14and
26:14on
26:15the
26:15Atlantic
26:15coast
26:16it
26:16has
26:16fallen
26:17by
26:17more
26:17than
26:1770%
26:18and
26:18this
26:19is
26:19because
26:19there
26:20has
26:20been
26:20a
26:20public
26:20policy
26:21behind
26:21it
26:22that
26:22is
26:22based
26:23on
26:23cooperation
26:23with
26:24the
26:24countries
26:25of
26:25transit
26:25and
26:26origin
26:27the
26:27Spanish
26:27prime
26:28minister
26:28had
26:28a
26:28big
26:28problem
26:29over
26:29the
26:29summer
26:29in
26:29Ceuta
26:30too
26:30so
26:30cooperation
26:31is
26:31not
26:31working
26:32in
26:32every
26:32time
26:33the
26:33Spanish
26:34prime
26:34minister
26:34goes
26:35a step
26:35further
26:35and
26:35now
26:36says
26:36it
26:36is
26:36simply
26:37inhumane
26:38this
26:38is
26:39not
26:39what
26:39the
26:39European
26:40Union
26:40should
26:41be
26:41when
26:41you
26:42hear
26:42this
26:42kind
26:42of
26:42language
26:43do
26:43you
26:43go
26:45perhaps
26:45we're
26:46taking
26:46it
26:46too
26:46far
26:48let
26:48me
26:48differentiate
26:49here
26:49a bit
26:50first
26:51of all
26:51I
26:51think
26:52also
26:52with
26:52the
26:53development
26:53on
26:54the
26:54Canary
26:54Islands
26:54this
26:55week
26:56probably
26:57the
26:58Spanish
26:58government
26:59should
26:59probably
26:59take up
27:00some
27:00responsibility
27:01there
27:01you
27:01think
27:01he's
27:02on
27:02talk
27:02no
27:02action
27:03Spanish
27:03prime
27:04minister
27:04at
27:05least
27:05they
27:05need
27:05to
27:05react
27:06to
27:06something
27:06and
27:06the
27:06history
27:07of
27:07the
27:08reaction
27:08so
27:08far
27:11situation
27:12second
27:13thing
27:13how
27:14on
27:15earth
27:15and
27:16I
27:16fully
27:16agree
27:17with
27:17that
27:17whatever
27:18we
27:18do
27:18at
27:19European
27:19level
27:19leave
27:20aside
27:20the
27:20fact
27:20that
27:20it's
27:21five
27:21countries
27:21it's
27:21not
27:22a
27:22Euro
27:22initiative
27:23it's
27:23a
27:23bilateral
27:23five
27:24lateral
27:25initiative
27:26like
27:26a pilot
27:27however
27:27for
27:28more
27:28countries
27:28how
27:29on
27:29earth
27:30can
27:30we
27:30say
27:30that
27:31if
27:31you
27:31have
27:31five
27:32member
27:32states
27:32based
27:33on
27:33the
27:33legal
27:34base
27:34in
27:34European
27:35law
27:35under
27:35the
27:36obligation
27:36of
27:37international
27:37European
27:38and
27:38national
27:39law
27:39say
27:40that
27:41this
27:41instrument
27:41is
27:42doomed
27:42from
27:42the
27:42very
27:42beginning
27:43on
27:43the
27:44UK
27:44said
27:44the
27:45same
27:45and
27:45it
27:45didn't
27:45work
27:46are
27:46you
27:46sure
27:46this
27:47is
27:47going
27:47to
27:47be
27:47different
27:47here
27:48it was
27:49there
27:49is
27:49a
27:49difference
27:50when
27:50you
27:50look
27:51at
27:51the
27:51procedures
27:51and
27:51we
27:52need
27:52to
27:52make
27:52that
27:52distinction
27:53because
27:53whatever
27:54Robert
27:54said
27:54was
27:55right
27:55of
27:55course
27:56we
27:56need
27:56to
27:56improve
27:57our
27:57third
27:57country
27:57cooperation
27:58of
27:58course
27:58we
27:58need
27:58to
27:59speak
27:59about
27:59sanctions
27:59if
28:00they
28:00don't
28:00work
28:00well
28:00and
28:01we
28:01have
28:01a
28:02toolbox
28:02there
28:02return
28:03hubs
28:04are
28:04one
28:04part
28:05of
28:05a
28:05broader
28:06toolbox
28:06for
28:06us
28:07in
28:07managing
28:07migration
28:08up
28:09holding
28:09the
28:10values
28:10and
28:11the
28:11protection
28:11status
28:12that
28:12we
28:13grant
28:14based
28:15on
28:16our
28:16treaties
28:17and
28:17laws
28:17and
28:18if
28:18you're
28:18not
28:18eligible
28:19for
28:19protection
28:20we
28:20need
28:20to
28:20find
28:21ways
28:21of
28:22organizing
28:22that
28:23of
28:23course
28:23it
28:24needs
28:24to
28:24be
28:24in
28:24a
28:24humane
28:25way
28:25because
28:25this
28:25is
28:25what
28:25we
28:29of
28:29staying
28:30within
28:30the
28:30European
28:30Union
28:31illegally
28:31with
28:32no
28:32proper
28:33perspective
28:33or
28:34having
28:35a
28:35perspective
28:35being
28:36able
28:36to
28:37build
28:37up
28:37your
28:37own
28:38life
28:38again
28:38in
28:39a
28:39country
28:41and
28:41there
28:41are
28:42probably
28:42others
28:42that
28:43are
28:43in
28:43the
28:43discussion
28:43maybe
28:44Uganda
28:44Kazakhstan
28:45has also
28:46been
28:46mentioned
28:46it's
28:47a
28:47decision
28:48that
28:48you
28:48can
28:48take
28:50I
28:50think
28:51there
28:51is
28:51no
28:51coincidence
28:52that
28:52these
28:52countries
28:53are
28:53like
28:53Rwanda
28:54Uganda
28:56Uzbekistan
28:56and
28:57so
28:57on
28:57and
28:57so
28:57these
28:58countries
28:58have
28:59with
28:59human
29:00rights
29:00violations
29:01but
29:01I
29:02I'm
29:02also
29:03wondering
29:03Lena
29:04what
29:04makes
29:04you
29:04sure
29:05that
29:05Rwanda
29:06Rwanda's
29:07dictatorship
29:07de facto
29:08will
29:08send
29:09these
29:09people
29:09home
29:10will
29:10create
29:11in
29:11Rwanda
29:12also
29:12job
29:13opportunities
29:14they
29:14will
29:14take
29:14care
29:15of
29:15their
29:15families
29:15they
29:16will
29:16protect
29:16these
29:16people
29:17we
29:17have
29:17no
29:18evidence
29:18on
29:18that
29:18opposite
29:19we
29:19have
29:20evidence
29:20from
29:21also
29:21from
29:22Trump's
29:23administration
29:24that
29:24it
29:25didn't
29:25work
29:25that
29:26the
29:26bread
29:27of
29:28the
29:28human
29:28rights
29:29violations
29:29in this
29:31country
29:31is
29:32serious
29:32and
29:33for
29:33me
29:33also
29:34as
29:34a
29:34poll
29:34you
29:35know
29:35I'm
29:36Polish
29:36and
29:36from
29:37my
29:37historical
29:38memory
29:38I have
29:39terrible
29:40terrible
29:40memories
29:42on
29:42camps
29:42really
29:43when
29:43I
29:43hear
29:43camps
29:44people
29:45by
29:45force
29:45you
29:46think
29:46these
29:47are
29:47deportation
29:47camps
29:48because
29:48the word
29:49really
29:50matters
29:50these
29:50people
29:51don't
29:51want
29:51to
29:51go
29:51to
29:51Rwanda
29:52they
29:52will
29:52not
29:52be
29:52willing
29:53to
29:53go
29:53to
29:54Rwanda
29:54they
29:54will
29:55be
29:55by
29:55force
29:56illegally
29:57in
29:57my
29:58opinion
29:58sent
29:59to
29:59Rwanda
30:00and
30:00kept
30:01dead
30:01so
30:02the
30:02EU
30:02it's
30:02enforcing
30:03right
30:03now
30:03deportation
30:04camps
30:04well
30:05how
30:05do
30:06you
30:06want
30:06to
30:06call
30:06it
30:06you
30:07can
30:07call
30:07it
30:09hubs
30:09but
30:09those
30:09are
30:10camps
30:10in
30:10Albania
30:11do
30:11you
30:12have
30:15access
30:16to
30:16Albanian
30:17return
30:18hub
30:18even
30:19human
30:20rights
30:21organizations
30:22well
30:23Robert
30:23please
30:24look
30:25at
30:25the
30:26policies
30:27you know
30:27by just
30:28throwing
30:28in
30:28you know
30:29Trump
30:29a bit
30:29there
30:30and
30:30Russia
30:30a bit
30:30there
30:31and
30:31camps
30:31there
30:32is
30:32a
30:33history
30:33in
30:33Europe
30:33that
30:34does
30:34not
30:34solve
30:34problems
30:35and
30:35believe
30:35me
30:36I've
30:36been
30:36investing
30:37time
30:37in
30:37that
30:37field
30:38exactly
30:38because
30:39I
30:39don't
30:39want
30:40us
30:40to
30:41do
30:41it
30:41right
30:41but
30:42without
30:43overloading
30:44the
30:44debate
30:44with
30:47unbalanced
30:47comparisons
30:48I would
30:48say
30:49and I
30:49really
30:49appreciate
30:50your
30:51stance
30:51on
30:52really
30:52pointing
30:53the
30:53fingers
30:53on
30:54the
30:54respect
30:54for
30:54human
30:55rights
30:55because
30:55this
30:55is
30:55what
30:56makes
30:56us
30:56humans
30:57this
30:57is
30:57what
30:57makes
30:58us
30:58Europeans
30:59but
31:01human
31:01life
31:02and
31:02respect
31:02for
31:02our
31:02treaties
31:03and
31:03values
31:03also
31:04comes
31:04with
31:04the
31:04obligation
31:05that
31:05everyone
31:06within
31:07the
31:07European
31:07Union
31:08needs
31:08to
31:08follow
31:09the
31:09law
31:10and
31:10that
31:10includes
31:11returns
31:12after
31:13legally
31:14but
31:15you
31:15changed
31:15your
31:15mind
31:16and
31:16you
31:16went
31:17the
31:17extreme
31:17right
31:18way
31:18no
31:18I
31:19didn't
31:19voted
31:19with
31:20you
31:20we
31:21put
31:21forward
31:21an
31:22EPP
31:22proposal
31:23and
31:23we
31:23had
31:24invited
31:24you
31:24all
31:25the
31:25way
31:25long
31:26to
31:26be
31:26part
31:27of
31:27it
31:27you
31:28for
31:28whatever
31:28reason
31:28and
31:29I
31:29respect
31:29that
31:29decided
31:30not
31:30to
31:30be
31:31part
31:31of
31:31it
31:31because
31:32we
31:32don't
31:32want
31:32to
31:32participate
31:33in
31:33human
31:33rights
31:34violation
31:34but
31:35not
31:35all
31:35the
31:35policies
31:36that
31:36you
31:36are
31:36just
31:36not
31:36fine
31:37with
31:37are
31:38far
31:38right
31:38honestly
31:39well
31:39I
31:40I'm
31:40appalled
31:41and
31:41I'm
31:41very
31:41emotional
31:42about
31:42that
31:43because
31:43we
31:43have
31:44a
31:44history
31:44in
31:44Europe
31:45we
31:45have
31:45a
31:45history
31:46and
31:46we
31:46are
31:47different
31:49with
31:50China
31:50and
31:51Russia
31:51and
31:52Trump
31:53administration
31:54because
31:55we
31:55don't
31:55do
31:55these
31:55things
31:56we
31:56just
31:57simply
31:57don't
31:57go
31:58this
31:58way
31:58and
31:59I'm
32:00shocked
32:00that
32:01EPP
32:02went
32:03together
32:04with
32:05Le Pen
32:05with
32:06all
32:07these
32:08populists
32:09from
32:09Vox
32:09with
32:11Confederacy
32:11from
32:12Poland
32:12together
32:13to
32:13go
32:13this
32:14dark
32:15narrow
32:16where
32:16we
32:16will
32:16be
32:17people
32:17treating
32:18people
32:18like
32:18toys
32:19that
32:19you
32:19can
32:20replace
32:20them
32:20to
32:20the
32:20country
32:21they
32:21have
32:21nothing
32:21in
32:22common
32:22put
32:22them
32:23in
32:23this
32:23situation
32:23that
32:24has
32:26nothing
32:27to do
32:27it
32:28is
32:28international
32:30law
32:31we
32:31have
32:31a
32:33individual
32:35to
32:36the
32:36country
32:36where
32:37there
32:37is
32:38a
32:38danger
32:39of
32:39breaking
32:40their
32:40human
32:41rights
32:42you
32:42cannot
32:42do
32:42that
32:43there
32:43is
32:43this
32:44yeah
32:44you're
32:44right
32:45on
32:45that
32:45and
32:45the
32:46second
32:46thing
32:47it's
32:48also
32:49about
32:49the
32:49non
32:49russle
32:49more
32:50but
32:50if
32:51this
32:51is
32:51legally
32:52sound
32:52under
32:53the
32:53agreement
32:54assured
32:54that
32:54it's
32:55not
32:55happening
32:55and
32:56also
32:56have
32:57in
32:57mind
32:57that
32:57Rwanda
32:58had
32:58actually
32:58taken
32:58in
32:59quite
32:59a
32:59substantive
32:59numbers
33:00of
33:00of
33:02refugees
33:03from
33:03neighboring
33:04countries
33:04so
33:05there
33:05is
33:06already
33:06a
33:07huge
33:07migration
33:08population
33:08on the
33:09ground
33:09the
33:10money
33:11also
33:11something
33:12is
33:12that
33:12that
33:13bounds
33:13them
33:14to
33:14the
33:14agreement
33:14and of
33:15course
33:15there will
33:16be a
33:16huge
33:16emphasis
33:17in the
33:18implementation
33:18of the
33:19agreement
33:19but my
33:19point is
33:20that we
33:21cannot
33:21just
33:21end all
33:22the
33:23debates
33:24let me
33:25pick up
33:25on this
33:25point
33:29I promise
33:29you we
33:30will go
33:30back
33:31we take
33:31a pause
33:32from here
33:32we'll come
33:33right back
33:33and then I
33:34will put
33:34you yes
33:35or no
33:35questions
33:35before our
33:36final word
33:37stay with
33:37us
33:41now I'm
33:42going to
33:42ask you
33:43please to
33:43keep it
33:44very short
33:44this is a
33:45yes or
33:46no round
33:46of questions
33:47so perhaps
33:48Robert
33:48since I
33:49left it
33:50on you
33:50let me
33:51ask you
33:52yes or
33:52no
33:52will return
33:53hubs
33:53effectively
33:54reduce
33:55irregular
33:55migration
33:56in the
33:56short
33:57term
33:57yes or
33:57no
33:58any
33:58term
33:58no
34:00Madame
34:01Depan
34:01same
34:01question
34:01as tool
34:02in the
34:03toolbox
34:03yes it
34:04can help
34:05Robert
34:05back to
34:06you
34:06do return
34:07hubs
34:07outside
34:08the
34:08European
34:08Union
34:09undermine
34:09the
34:10right
34:10to
34:10seek
34:11asylum
34:11yes
34:12or
34:12no
34:12it's
34:12obvious
34:13yes
34:13they
34:13break
34:14the
34:14human
34:14rights
34:15standards
34:15not
34:15only
34:16in
34:16Europe
34:16but
34:16international
34:17no
34:18because
34:18we're
34:18speaking
34:19about
34:19return
34:19after
34:19all
34:20the
34:20legal
34:20procedures
34:21have
34:21been
34:21exhausted
34:22is
34:23the
34:23rise
34:23of
34:24the
34:24far
34:24right
34:25driving
34:25EU
34:26migration
34:26policy
34:27more
34:27than
34:27actual
34:28facts
34:28when
34:28you
34:28look
34:28at
34:29the
34:29numbers
34:29are
34:30you
34:30enacting
34:30this
34:30policy
34:31because
34:31you
34:31are
34:31concerned
34:32that
34:32you're
34:32going
34:32to
34:32lose
34:33voters
34:33or
34:33because
34:34the
34:34numbers
34:34are
34:34warranted
34:35or
34:35use
34:35whatever
34:36floats
34:36the
34:37boat
34:37but
34:38besides
34:38that
34:38we
34:39have
34:40problems
34:41within
34:41our
34:41societies
34:42that
34:42we
34:42need
34:42to
34:42solve
34:43Robert
34:43same
34:43question
34:44to
34:44you
34:44is
34:44it
34:45being
34:45driven
34:45by
34:45the
34:52on
34:52so
34:53many
34:53issues
34:53I
34:54respect
34:54European
34:55People's
34:56Party
34:56on
34:56so
34:56many
34:57issues
34:57we
34:57have
34:57a
34:57platform
34:58in
34:58European
34:58Parliament
34:59together
34:59and
35:00there
35:00is
35:00no
35:00need
35:00for
35:01cooperation
35:02Is
35:02Migration
35:02Commissioner
35:03Brumher
35:03doing
35:03a
35:03good
35:04job
35:04yes
35:04or
35:04no
35:04I
35:05have
35:05doubts
35:06Is
35:06the
35:07Migration
35:07Commissioner
35:07doing
35:08a
35:08good
35:08job
35:08yes
35:08or
35:08no
35:09yes
35:10well
35:10on
35:10that
35:10note
35:11thank
35:11you
35:12so
35:12much
35:12to
35:12the
35:13two
35:13of
35:13you
35:13for
35:13joining
35:14us
35:14in
35:14this
35:15debate
35:16it
35:16is
35:16clear
35:16you
35:17have
35:17very
35:17different
35:17views
35:18but
35:18that
35:18also
35:19reflects
35:19the
35:20debate
35:20out
35:21in
35:21Europe
35:22so
35:22that
35:22is
35:22it
35:23for
35:23this
35:23edition
35:23of
35:24the
35:24ring
35:25as
35:25always
35:25we
35:25want
35:26to
35:26hear
35:26from
35:26you
35:27so
35:27please
35:27do
35:28send
35:28us
35:28your
35:28comments
35:29and
35:29feedback
35:29to
35:30our
35:30email
35:30address
35:31the
35:31ring
35:31at
35:32Euronews
35:32dot
35:33com
35:33thank
35:33you
35:33so
35:34much
35:45thank

Recomendada