- 17 hours ago
EU foreign ministers meet in Brussels to discuss peace talks on Ukraine. We speak to Sweden’s Foreign Minister Maria Malmer Stenergard and explore the wave of cyberattacks targeting Europe with EU cybersecurity chief Juhan Lepassaar.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:14Good morning. It's 8 o'clock Monday, November 16th. You're watching Euronews and this is
00:22Europe Today. Coming to you from our brand new studio in the heart of Brussels with a
00:27new lineup every morning live at 8, 9 and 10 a.m. with more news, more airtime and more
00:34Europe. So I'm excited to start the day with you in the audience. Let's get started with
00:41our top stories. European Union forces boarded a suspected Russian shadow fleet tanker in
00:47the Mediterranean a few days ago. The EU's foreign policy chief Kaya Kala said yesterday.
00:52Troops from the EU's Operation Irini boarded the tanker MV Midak and confirmed that the
00:58vessel was sailing under a false flag. New foreign ministers are set to approve new sanctions against
01:04Russia today, targeting banks, buyers and companies supporting Russia's shadow fleet.
01:10In an escalation of Gulf hostilities, Iran reportedly attacked Bahrain after weeks of relative calm.
01:16Bahrain said its air defense systems intercepted and destroyed several Iranian aerial attacks
01:22yesterday, issuing the first threat alert to the public since September as the Islamic Republic
01:28resumed attacks on the Gulf state. The island kingdom of Bahrain, home to the U.S. Navy's fifth fleet,
01:34had already announced on Friday having intercepted two Iranian drones. And two aircraft collided at
01:42Miami International Airport, leaving two people with minor injuries, according to officials. The
01:48Federal Aviation Administration said a Copa Airlines passenger jet struck the nose of the UPS freight
01:54plane as the two were taxiing. The collision came as travelers across the United States continued to face
02:00disruption following a nationwide ground stop that caused chaos at airports this weekend.
02:06Welcome to the program. I'm Stefan Grobe. Now to our top story. EU foreign ministers are meeting
02:13today in Brussels to discuss the peace negotiations to end Russia's war on Ukraine. European leaders have
02:19agreed on a team of seven representatives to lead the process, but Moscow has so far refused to commit to
02:26a multilateral format. Still, there's some cautious hope that a face-to-face meeting between Europeans,
02:32Russians, Russians, Ukrainians, and Americans could take place in Abu Dhabi in the next two weeks.
02:38To discuss all this, I'm joined by our political correspondent Jorge Liborero, who's been following
02:44the latest. Good morning, Jorge. Hello. So how come Europe has settled for a team of seven instead
02:53of one special envoy? So the news is that Europe doesn't have one special envoy, it has seven. This was
03:01the
03:01deal that EU leaders agreed on to ensure proper representation for this very delicate process.
03:07So who's in this team? Let's break it down. We have the E3, France, Germany, the UK. We also have
03:13Italy and Poland. We have the EU institutions and NATO as well. So seven senior officials from these seven
03:20pillars. Now, many of our viewers might be wondering, weren't we supposed to appoint one person to speak on
03:28behalf of Europe? Well, technically, yes. And there was pressure from Ukraine in the US to do it. But it
03:33was
03:34politically impossible to find one single person that could please everybody. So the compromise was indeed
03:40these seven representatives. It was very clear from the beginning that France, Germany in the UK wanted to remain in
03:47a
03:47driving seat. And I want to highlight the importance of Poland, which was a last minute addition to the team.
03:54This was made to
03:55ensure to avoid actually the perception that Europe will negotiate with Russia over the head of Eastern
04:01Europeans. So I'm trying to understand this. There is somebody in charge of foreign policy in the European Union,
04:08and that is High Representative Kayakalas, who, by the way, is making her way to the council as we speak
04:13to chair
04:14today's meeting. She pitched herself for the job, but was totally dismissed by everybody. What's happening now?
04:22Is her job becoming obsolete? I know it's early, but let me be very honest. This was an incredibly
04:29rough moment for Kayakalas. She flew to Dublin, and she pitched herself very forcefully, I have to say,
04:36as the special envoy, saying that it was incumbent upon her as High Representative, the foreign policy
04:41chief, to do this job. And then she was completely ignored. Actually, let's take a listen at how she put
04:47it.
04:47All the member states actually agreed that I'm the one who is representing Europe in the foreign and
04:54security policy. So, I mean, that was in 2024 when it was clear that, you know, this is going to
05:01be the
05:02case. I know that the Russians don't want me, but, you know, do we have a say who is representing
05:10Russia?
05:10No, we don't. And really, I mean, we have to have a strong team. And I'm ready to do this
05:16work with
05:16the foreign ministers. We meet every month. We have these formats already in place. And frankly,
05:23I think that leaders have so much on their plate. We should really use the foreign ministers and this
05:30format more to actually, you know, the way you negotiate. First, you know, you put together the
05:37maximum demands. Then you come together. Where are you? Where is our fallback position where we can
05:41compromise? And of course, I'm bound with what the member states say. I mean, I'm not representing
05:47myself. I'm representing 27 like I have done already two years. So Russians do not want her,
05:55but European leaders do not want her either. Why? There are many reasons, of course. But let me give you
06:00one. When you look at this team of senior officials, you don't see any foreign minister.
06:06You see national security adviser who come directly from the cabinets of the leaders. So this shows you
06:13that leaders want to keep a very close eye on this process. There's just too much at stake for them
06:18to deputize on somebody else. I mean, we're talking about the future of Ukraine and European security.
06:23So when they looked at colors, they just didn't see somebody on the same level.
06:29Robert, beyond diplomacy, there is the big question of money. Let's face it. And Ukraine is facing a huge
06:37gap of 70 billion euros next year alone. Can Europe help to plug it? Diplomacy is important, but money is
06:45essential. And we can confirm that on Wednesday, the European Commission will put forward a proposal for a
06:5145 billion loan for Ukraine through joint debt. So this will come on top of the 90 billion loan
06:58that we have already approved. So in total, it's an enormous amount of money that will generate
07:02billions in annual interest. However, I expect the discussions on this proposal to be very difficult.
07:09The mood has changed. Borrowing costs are high. Energy prices are high as well. And four countries have
07:15already demanded and opt out of this loan. So that's the current state of European unity.
07:22All right. Jorge Libero, thank you very much for your reporting. We'll get back to you throughout the
07:27morning as the meeting of the foreign ministers gets underway in about an hour. As we've heard,
07:33Russia's war against Ukraine and Europe's ability to sustain its support for Kyiv are on top of the
07:38meeting's agenda. With Ukraine facing another brutal winter, Sweden is pushing for more military
07:45assistance, particularly air defense, tougher sanctions against Moscow and the use of frozen
07:50Russian assets to help finance Ukraine. Will that push succeed? Joining me now is Sweden's foreign minister,
07:57Maria Malmas-Denegard. Good morning and thanks for coming on the show before even meeting your counterpart in
08:03the European Council. So let's start with the latest development on the diplomatic front. Was there
08:09anything over the past couple of days that made you optimistic? Well, no, quite the opposite. I just came from
08:17Abu Dhabi actually where the talks were being held. I met with foreign minister Sevilla and also
08:21counterparts in the region and it's obvious that Russia is not interested in peace. I think it's
08:28it's good that Europe has finally united in the talks about the talks. So now maybe we can focus on
08:35what
08:35really matters, which is increasing support to Ukraine and increasing pressure on Russia. Because
08:41what we see is a Russia that is losing territory, losing men, losing influence. They are frustrated.
08:47They are attacking civilians. They're attacking Europe. We just saw the news about Estonia and they're
08:54trying to divide us, trying to decrease the support to Ukraine. And what we must do is the opposite.
08:59One of the central points in all these discussions was European representation. Now we've heard there's now
09:07seven instead of one. Why does it matter at all that Europe is part of it?
09:13Because it is about Europe. A lot of the solutions are in Europe's hands. We are talking about EU
09:20integration. We're also talking about NATO membership, where Sweden really wants to keep the
09:25open door policies. So of course, Europe and NATO need to take part in the talks. And basically,
09:32we are the ones providing support to Ukraine right now. So of course, we should be at the table. But
09:37we
09:38should be on Ukraine's side. We are not mediators. Why did it take so long to come up with a
09:44list of
09:45names though? The EU7 instead of Kayakalas? And we've been talking about this for weeks and even months.
09:53Maybe years even. Well, we are not one. I didn't dare to say that.
09:57We are not one country. I think it's reasonable that we have these discussions when we are so
10:04many, many different countries that are to be represented. And I think it's perfectly reasonable
10:09that the big countries will be representing us along with the institutions. And of course,
10:16the fact that Costa is representing the council is also very logical.
10:21And Kayakalas? She has an important role to play, of course, in preparing these meetings,
10:26as she said herself in Dublin. And I know she's very much involved. She definitely has the right
10:33view on these. Okay. Now, Sweden has been among Ukraine's strongest supporters. But how much longer
10:41can European governments ask their taxpayers to fund a war that has no clear end in sight?
10:50We depend on how the war ends. This is about the future security of Europe. And at least in the
10:59Nordics, we mean it when we say it. So it is an investment in peace. It is an investment in
11:06security.
11:06And therefore, we need to continue to support Ukraine. However, speaking about the taxpayers'
11:13money, I think it would be fair to use the money that Russia already has in Europe. And therefore,
11:20I continue to constantly push for using the frozen Russian assets. I'm convinced there are ways to do it,
11:27but we need to see a proposal on the table. Believe it or not, that would be my next question.
11:33Where are we on this topic here? Is there any movement that we don't see yet?
11:39I hope that the Commission is working on a proposal that would mean that we would move the assets out
11:45of
11:46Belgium and thereby share the risk, which is absolutely fair to do to Belgium. And then I hope,
11:55if we have a concrete proposal, that the EU member states would be ready for a new discussion on
12:01this. What we see is that we had this loan on 90 billion euros. That was an important step. But
12:08since
12:09then, bilateral support has decreased. And I see tendencies the countries are referring to the loan
12:15instead. But we need more bilateral support. We need more loans, but we also need to use the frozen
12:20Russian assets. As you're from Sweden, I have to ask you that. How do you assess Russia's hybrid
12:25attacks in the Baltic region? Do you fear that there are more coming? And how is you prepared to
12:31counter them? Well, we see that Russia is willing to take more risks. And like I said, it is because
12:38they are frustrated that they are not winning in Ukraine. They've been trying for almost five years
12:44to invade Ukraine. Now they have failed and they are losing at the battlefields. So now instead,
12:50they are killing civilians, they're killing children in the playgrounds, but they are also attacking Europe.
12:55And we see that they take more risks. They do it more frequently. And we have to be united.
13:01We have to increase resilience. Sweden has spent a lot more money on civil defense to make sure that
13:10people are prepared and aware. And we need to stay united in Europe. And what they basically want
13:17is to have us split up and also decrease support for Ukraine. So we should increase support for
13:26Ukraine. Stay united. All right, Swedish Foreign Minister Maria Malmö Steningrad. Thank you so much
13:31for coming on the show this morning. Now, Europe must stop getting distracted by internal divisions and focus
13:38on what really matters, securing Ukraine's future and forcing Russia to negotiate seriously. That's
13:45the message from Latvia's Prime Minister Andris Kulbergs, who says Vladimir Putin is playing tactical games
13:51and that Europe needs to show greater strength and confidence. Earlier, our defense correspondent
13:56Shona Murray had a chance to speak with him. Here's what he had to say. Take a listen.
14:01We're falling in the crap of Putin. He wants us to talk about things which are not important.
14:08We have European defense architecture is already there. We shouldn't discuss anything about it.
14:15It's fine. It's good. We should discuss about Ukraine supporting Ukraine and finding ways how
14:20they can survive the winter and how the peace talks can be on their benefit. We are the ones for
14:26the future
14:27as Europe guaranteeing the security because geographically we're here. We are the ones for the future
14:33for Ukraine and that is our common security and the aggressor which is losing in the Ukrainian war
14:40on the front line for the trying to attack someone which is by far smaller in size and showing the
14:47might for five years and giving us conditions where we have to agree upon. Come on. We are bigger in
14:55size,
14:55bigger in economy and bigger in military. We have to dictate that we have to be at the table and
15:01we should say
15:01what what what is necessary. Indeed, but there still hasn't been any progress. So what has to happen now?
15:06Because we've been saying the same thing for the past five years. And again, President Zelenskyy wasn't optimistic
15:12when he came out of that meeting with Kushner and Witkoch when asked whether things have changed in terms of
15:18Putin's maximalist demands. Simple. This is fake maneuvers in my opinion and Putin just wants, Putin is a tactical
15:28player. He wants to play best cards what is now available for him. So I think we just have to
15:33show
15:33bigger force and we should we should be more confident about ourselves. But what does that actually mean in
15:39practice? Because like tell me what we need to actually do. We're coming into the winter. Ukraine is facing another
15:45brutal few months ahead. So fully aligned support. It's still about money. We're not talking about any
15:52lives or in military. It's just money. So money, support for Ukraine and giving them the survival of
16:00the winter. And next year it's going to change. It's good. There's going to be a big change because the
16:04Ukrainians will be capable of building their own ballistic missiles. So that's an important aspect.
16:09And one of the issues on the agenda is, of course, European tech sovereignty. So it's not in hock to
16:14organizations in China or the United States. It happened, of course, on the day that Microsoft
16:19email went down. What did you discuss in relation to Europe getting its act together to be sovereign
16:24when it comes to technology? Well, we shouldn't lag behind. That's one thing. It's all the investment
16:31is happening totally on the outside of Europe. And we should have that internally because AI is the
16:38future. It is. It should support our governments should be switching to AI in order to have
16:43efficiency and reduce the costs and improve the whole productivity. And that means we should have
16:51our own. We shouldn't base. It's all about data. There's no AI if the data is not used. So data
16:58is
16:58the main aspect. So the data should not be, or government data, sensitive data should not be
17:03flowing out to some resources which are outside of Europe. But that's a debate how secure it is, how we
17:09should improve our own capabilities. We have a lack of chip manufacturing. So we rely on outside
17:15support of chips. So that's something and energy data centers. We should have our own. So it's about
17:22centralizing and bringing back our own capabilities and being more competitive.
17:30Sean Amari speaking to Latvia's Prime Minister Andris Kulbeks.
17:34Russia is reportedly demanding that NATO roll back its military presence in Europe to its
17:401997 positions, reviving sweeping demands first made before Moscow's full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
17:48The Kremlin reiterated these conditions during the latest US-mediated peace talks in Abu Dhabi.
17:53Meanwhile, Vladimir Zelensky says Washington has floated the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO
17:59in exchange for withdrawing from the Donbas. To get to the bottom of this, I'm now joined by our
18:05Ukraine correspondent, Sasha Bakulina. Good morning, Sasha. So Russia has reportedly renewed its demands
18:12for NATO to withdraw troops from Eastern Europe as sort of part of negotiations over Ukraine.
18:19What exactly is Moscow asking for? Well, it's very interesting, Stefan, because Moscow is
18:24not asking for anything new. All those demands, we've heard them already at least five years ago.
18:29Now, let's quickly go through them. NATO's military rollback back to the positions held before 1997.
18:36No further NATO enlargement, effectively ruling out Ukraine's membership in the alliance forever.
18:42Restrictions on military activity like exercises and missile deployments and nuclear deterrence.
18:47Now, Stefan, when you and I discussed it in the beginning of last week, before the Abu Dhabi peace
18:52talks, we previewed that these demands were going to be back on the table with the presence of Russia's
18:58Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov. He was the one who put those demands to NATO back in December 2021,
19:04less than two months before Russia went in with a full-scale invasion of Ukraine. And he was back there,
19:10so that was sort of not coming as a surprise that him and his demands were back. What is new
19:15here is that
19:16if previously Russia was putting those demands to Ukraine, now Russia is trying to dictate those
19:22demands to Europe and Europe's security architecture and NATO in Europe. Now, that is, of course, new here.
19:28Zelensky says the U.S. has raised the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO in exchange from withdrawing
19:35from the Donbass. Now, how has Kyiv responded to that proposal? Well, Kyiv admitted that this is a
19:42significant development, saying it is the first time American negotiators have raised the possibility
19:47of Ukraine ever joining NATO, because it's not just the Trump administration. Joe Biden administration
19:51was also saying no to Ukraine joining NATO, Stefan. But, of course, it's about this remaining territory
19:57of the region of Donetsk in eastern Ukraine, which Russia cannot occupy, not since 2022, but since the
20:03first invasion of 2014. So, for over a decade, Russia is trying and not capable of occupying that
20:09territory. Zelensky said he will ask the people of Ukraine also to weigh in if it comes to that,
20:13but let me quickly also mention the contrast here. So, on one hand, the American negotiations,
20:18negotiators are reportedly offering some sort of an idea of NATO membership, while Russia is demanding
20:23the rollback of NATO positions to 1997. All right, Sasha Bakulina, as always, thank you very much.
20:31Europe's migration debate is entering another decisive phase, as governments face mounting
20:37pressure to tighten border controls, curb irregular arrivals, and find more effective ways to manage
20:43asylum and returns. Ministers and senior officials from 20 countries across Europe, Africa, and Asia
20:50are gathering in Vienna for the annual migration conference starting today. In France, five months
20:56ahead of presidential elections, migration has emerged as a major campaign flashpoint. Let's cross to our
21:03correspondent in Paris, Estelle Nilsson-Julian. Good morning, Estelle. So, give us an idea how the
21:11different political parties address the issue.
21:17Well, as you say, migration has certainly emerged as a key part of the public debate ahead of France's
21:23elections next spring. The hard right National Rally Party, headed by Marine Le Pen, is polling at around
21:2832 percent, so therefore at the head of the race at the moment, and has made clamping down on immigration
21:34one of its key
21:35policies. The National Rally Party has, for instance, suggested holding a national consultation,
21:41a referendum on whether the government should enshrine further, tougher immigration laws into the
21:49constitution. This, of course, could potentially cause friction with EU laws and call into the
21:55question the sovereignty of French laws, the European ones. This scenario is a little bit different on the
22:03right. I mean, Edouard Philippe, former French president and conservative figure, has been accused
22:10of courting far-right voters, but his proposals are also rather tough on immigration. He's proposed slashing
22:17immigration in half and also pledged to reassess France's historic migration deal with Algeria.
22:25Stéphane. And on the left, where do politicians and candidates stand on migration?
22:34Stéphane. Yes, so the left is on a very different path when it comes to migration. The hard
22:40left France-embald party is currently polling second at around 17 percent, headed by Jean-Luc Mélenchon.
22:46And the party has promised to implement a more open migration policy. For instance, Mélenchon wants to
22:55document, regularise undocumented migrants who are already working in France. And so this sort of
23:02epitomizes the polarisation and ideological divergences in France's presidential election
23:08campaign, if we compare this stance with Marine Le Pen's parties, for instance. But Mélenchon is also
23:14very critical, for instance, of European policies, such as the European migration pact. Socialist candidate
23:23Raphael Glucksmann, though, who is also a left wing candidate, has argued that it's at the European
23:30level that migration issues and debates should occur while pledging for regularising migrants already
23:38working in France as well. For context, around 9 percent of the French population are from an immigrant
23:45background, Stéphane. All right, Esther Nilsson-Julien, thank you very much from Paris. And now to
23:53something totally different. Food is not just about what ends up on our plates. It is also a strategic
23:59industry for Europe's economic security and competitiveness. The food and beverage sector is
24:05the continent's largest manufacturing industry, but it faces growing pressure from regulatory fragmentation,
24:11uneven enforcement of EU rules and tensions across the supply chain. So what does Europe need to do to
24:19keep its food industry competitive, protect farmers and ensure a fair deal for consumers? Our business
24:26editor Angela Barnes put those questions to Willem Brandt, president of Kraft Heinz Group, in the latest
24:32edition of our revamped programme, The Big Question, premiering tonight. Take a listen.
24:38From your mind-raging perspective, Willem, what trends would you say are shaping the food industry
24:43right now? Listen, if I look at Europe, I would say, first of all, food really matters here and
24:50Europe matters to food. Let me unpack that a little bit. If you look at the whole European and geopolitical
24:55situation, what's going on right now, you see that policymakers here really care about security and they
25:02really care a lot about competitiveness. And food sits right at the heart of both of those things in
25:09Europe, if you ask me. Because ultimately, we've got a very good and strong value chain with farmers and
25:15industry and retailers, but we've got to keep it that way to make sure that we keep the food on
25:19our plates
25:19going forward as well. It's unclear who actually said it, but it was either Trotsky or Lenin who said,
25:25you're only ever three missed meals away from a revolution. Now, at the same time, on the
25:31competitiveness side, and I think that that's actually the more interesting thing and the not
25:35so much known fact, it's the biggest manufacturing industry that we have in Europe. How do you see
25:41the future of the food industry in Europe? As I said, you know, I think we need to continue to
25:47make
25:47sure that the industry continues to be healthy and thriving for all the different players. And this is
25:53also what we discuss when we talk to regulators. And there's a couple of things that need to be in
25:57place for that. First of all, we need to make sure that the rules that are set apply equally everywhere.
26:04And what we now see is that, for instance, some of the retail partners that we work with in the
26:10value
26:10chain, they decide to go to the place that is the lowest common denominator in terms of upholding
26:16these rules. I don't think that that ultimately in the long run creates a very healthy situation for
26:21the industry and for European citizens at large. Equally, there's something called the unfair
26:28trading practices, which is there to protect the farmers. But there's a cap in there on 350 million
26:35of, you know, companies above that aren't protected. We believe that again, in the industry of society
26:42and of industry, but also the farmers and the retailers, we should remove that cap,
26:48because ultimately fairness should apply to everyone, irrespective of whether you're big or small.
26:55The final thing, and that's perhaps one of the most important things as a next step in the single
27:00market is we really need to get rid of this still fragmentation of local rules, because that is
27:07not helping consumers at the end of the day.
27:12You can watch the full interview tonight at 10 past nine CET on the program, The Big Question.
27:18And also coming up tonight, the first episode of your new evening show, Europe Tonight with
27:23Merritt Gwynn-Jones, unpacking the day's news and bringing you the conversations that matter.
27:29Tonight, Lithuania's Foreign Minister Kestudis Budris joins us as Europe Waste talks with Russia.
27:34That's at 6 p.m. CET here on Euronews Europe's newsroom.
27:40And that's it for now. We'll be back in half an hour with more news.
27:44I'm Stefan Grobe. Stay with us.