• 8 minutes ago
It's always a relief when filmmakers sidestep a predictable disaster. Join us as we explore 20 movies, from superhero blockbusters to sci-fi classics, that could have made a glaringly obvious mistake but thankfully avoided it entirely.
Transcript
00:00It's always refreshing when smarter heads prevail and the most glaringly predictable mistakes that Hollywood has made time and time
00:07again are actually avoided entirely.
00:10The following movies all seemed destined to make a fatal mistake, but thankfully skirted them unexpectedly.
00:17So with that in mind, I'm Ellie and these are movies that avoided obvious mistakes.
00:24Going PG-13, Deadpool and Wolverine.
00:27The moment that Fox was acquired by Disney, many Marvel fans understandably questioned what would become of Deadpool.
00:34Namely, would he be integrated into the Marvel Cinematic Universe in infuriatingly neutered fashion by being stuck with a PG
00:42-13 rating?
00:43Even when Kevin Feige, Ryan Reynolds and company promised that this wouldn't be the case,
00:49there was still the fair concern that both would ultimately be overruled by a Disney higher up
00:54and that Deadpool's first cinematic foray under the MCU banner would short-sightedly ditch the R rating altogether.
01:01Thankfully though, that wasn't the case at all,
01:04with recent Deadpool 3quel Deadpool and Wolverine being the very first R-rated entry into the ongoing wider superhero franchise.
01:13And more to the point, the film showed no sign of compromise,
01:17fusing Deadpool's usual brand of ribald, button-pushing humour with gleefully meta-gags about Disney, Kevin Feige and even the
01:25very state of the MCU itself.
01:27Given that the movie ended up grossing a stonking $1.338 billion worldwide,
01:32it should embolden Disney to develop more adult-skewing Marvel projects in the future.
01:37Just repeating the same movie, Aliens.
01:40Ridley Scott's Alien is such a perfect cinematic organism that it would have surprised nobody if it led to a
01:46glut of more of the same sequels
01:48that basically just regurgitated the same space slasher formula ad nauseam.
01:53But in 1986, a little-known filmmaker called James Cameron rose to the challenge to deliver a sequel, Aliens,
02:00which basically sidestepped every last mistake an Alien sequel could possibly make.
02:05First and foremost, Cameron clearly had no interest in just doing the same thing again.
02:10Because while Ripley returns to LV-426 and comes back into contact with Xenomorphs, the context is very different.
02:18If Alien was a slow and suspenseful horror film, Cameron's film is far more action-centric,
02:23with Ripley being joined by the gung-ho, ill-fated colonial marines,
02:27who lend the movie a considerably different energy to the original's Nostromo crew.
02:32Beyond that, Aliens also invests us far deeper in Ripley as a character,
02:37per her surrogate mother interactions with young Newt,
02:40ensuring it's anything but a sequel that merely paints within the established lines.
02:45Yet Cameron's film also sets such an impossibly high bar for the series,
02:49and sequels in general honestly,
02:51that nothing else in the Alien series has been able to touch it.
02:54Bringing Russell Crowe back, Gladiator 2.
02:57Even accepting that Russell Crowe's Maximus Decimus Meridius of course died at the end of the first Gladiator,
03:03many fans questioned whether or not Crowe might somehow appear in the sequel in cameo form.
03:08You know, given Hollywood's insatiable infatuation with shoehorned fan service and all,
03:13Ridley Scott certainly isn't above including a dream sequence in which Maximus' now adult son Lucius encounters his father.
03:20But evidently, smarter heads prevailed, as Crowe's Maximus is nowhere to be seen.
03:26Despite a late film moment where it appears that Crowe just might show up as a vision to his son,
03:31Scott mercifully resists the urge.
03:34Given that Crowe's physicality has understandably changed a lot over the last quarter century,
03:38and the moment would have likely required some garish deepfake de-aging CGI to pull it off,
03:44it's surely for the best that Crowe stayed out of the sequel entirely.
03:48All the same, many Gladiator fans remain curious about Nick Cave's scrapped original mid-2000s script for Gladiator 2,
03:56which would have seen Maximus revived and sent on a mission to end Christianity by killing Jesus Christ.
04:02Making Rey related to a legacy character, Star Wars The Last Jedi.
04:07Star Wars The Last Jedi is a divisive sequel for many reasons,
04:10but writer-director Rian Johnson made one incredibly shrewd call when penning the script,
04:16even if said call was ultimately undone by the next movie.
04:19After The Force Awakens riffed vaguely on the mysterious backstory of protagonist Rey,
04:24many fans rabidly speculated that she would be revealed to be related to a major legacy character,
04:30most likely being the daughter of Luke Skywalker.
04:33But Johnson evidently had little interest in tagging a contrived,
04:36familial relation onto the sequel trilogy's lead character,
04:40and so had Kylo Ren reveal to her that her parents were in fact junker nobodies,
04:45entirely unrelated to any established Star Wars character.
04:49Given Star Wars' tendency to draw convoluted links between its characters,
04:52and in turn make its apparently vast galaxy feel incredibly small and incestuous,
04:58it was a major breath of fresh air for Rey to be a hero entirely unreliant on nepotistic ties to
05:04the past.
05:04It's just a shame that amid the inane fan backlash over this revelation,
05:09J.J. Abrams decided to walk it back in sequel The Rise of Skywalker,
05:13where Rey was revealed to be the granddaughter of Emperor Palpatine, yay!
05:17Focusing on a younger cast, Beverly Hills Cop, Axel F.
05:20When a fourth Beverly Hills Cop movie was finally confirmed to be entering production,
05:25there was an assumption from many that it would pull the typical legacy sequel trick
05:29of shoving its beloved protagonist into a supporting role,
05:33even with his name being in the movie's title,
05:35while focusing instead on a younger set of central characters.
05:39After all, Eddie Murphy's star wattage has dimmed considerably over the last 20 years,
05:44and producers are likely looking for someone who can carry the Beverly Hills Cop brand forward for the future.
05:50But praise be, Beverly Hills Cop, Axel F.
05:53Refreshingly does nothing of the sort.
05:55Even though there are new, younger characters like Axel's daughter Jane and Detective Abbott,
06:01the focus is firmly on Axel and returning legacy characters Billy Rosewood and Chief Taggart.
06:06As such, Axel F. was able to defy the odds
06:09and release two unexpectedly positive reviews from critics and longtime fans alike.
06:15Trying to top the original twist, Saw 2.
06:17The moment that Saw became a surprise box office smash,
06:21it was inevitable that Lionsgate would hastily greenlight a sequel.
06:25And though Saw 2 was ultimately released less than a year after the first,
06:29it impressively avoided one potentially fatal pitfall.
06:32Trying to top the original's legendary twist,
06:35the first Saw movie ended with the jaw-dropping reveal that antagonist Jigsaw,
06:39aka John Kramer,
06:40had actually been posing as the corpse in the middle of the grotty bathroom all along.
06:45A twist so brilliantly unexpected, it was basically impossible to outdo.
06:49And so for Saw 2, writers Lee Wannell and Darren Lynn Boozman
06:53smartly decided to not try and top the nobody-can-guess-this insanity of that ending,
06:59opting instead for two more modest twists which were themselves incredibly satisfying.
07:03The first twist is that Detective Matthew's son Daniel was actually safe the entire time,
07:09due to his game taking place days prior,
07:11while the second revealed that Amanda was Jigsaw's secret apprentice.
07:16Both twists are well-executed and genuinely surprising,
07:19yet the writers clearly knew there was no way to beat the original twist
07:22while still maintaining internal credibility.
07:25And so they didn't even bother trying.
07:27It's just as well because later films in the series eventually strain for more outlandish twists
07:31in an attempt to keep fans interested.
07:34Yet these reveals mostly fell flat.
07:36More CGI than practical effects, Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice.
07:40Even when Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice finally went before cameras,
07:43there was anxiety from many that Tim Burton simply didn't have the source anymore,
07:48given the wildly uneven quality of his output from the last 15 or so years.
07:53More to the point, Burton's increasing reliance on excess CGI seems to have dulled his sense of creativity.
08:00And so there was a very reasonable fear that the Beetlejuice sequel would abandon the original's charming practical effects
08:07in favour of relentless VFX sludge.
08:10But what a pleasant surprise it was for Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice,
08:13to be awash in so many physical, on-set props and effects,
08:18from makeup to prosthetics, puppets, and even a sequence rendered in claymation.
08:23Of course, the $100 million fantasy comedy employed plenty of digital effects throughout,
08:28but the foundations were almost always practical,
08:32ensuring that this not only felt stylistically consistent with its predecessor,
08:37but turned out to be Burton's most lovingly produced creation in many years.
08:41Ditching Ilsa after one movie, Mission Impossible Fallout.
08:45As entertaining as the Mission Impossible franchise is,
08:48until recently it's had a bit of a strange relationship with its central female characters,
08:53most often operating a revolving door policy,
08:56whereby each female lead is replaced in the next movie.
08:59The first four films in the series introduced audiences to characters played by Emmanuel Beart,
09:04Thandaway Newton, Michelle Monaghan, and Paula Patton,
09:07each of whom were gone by the next instalment,
09:10beyond two brief appearances by Monaghan in two subsequent movies.
09:13And so, when Rebecca Ferguson was cast as MI6 agent Isla Faust,
09:17in the fifth movie Rogue Nation,
09:19there wasn't much hope that she'd appear in the sequel Fallout.
09:22But thankfully, Fallout finally broke the unsavoury streak,
09:26bringing Ilsa back not for a mere perfunctory cameo,
09:29but another beefy role of equal size to her prior appearance.
09:33Problematic casting, a different man.
09:36When it was first announced that Sebastian Stan would be playing a man with neurofibromatosis
09:40for his new film A Different Man,
09:42there was immediate concern from some about the problematic potential of Stan's casting,
09:48of hiring a conventional-looking person to wear prosthetics to play someone with neurofibromatosis,
09:55rather than just hiring an actor who actually has the condition.
09:59But Aaron Chimberg's Blackley comedic thriller is quite ingeniously built around this very idea,
10:04given that Stan plays a character who undergoes an experimental medical procedure to cure his condition.
10:10More to the point, Adam Pearson, an actor with neurofibromatosis,
10:15best known for his memorable role in Under the Skin,
10:18plays a substantial supporting part in the story,
10:21with a major theme being the duality of Stan and Pearson's characters.
10:26It's certainly an interesting and creative way to immediately diffuse any concern
10:30about Stan appropriating a role potentially better suited to another actor.
10:35Having Rocky win Rocky Balboa
10:37Back when a sixth Rocky film was first announced,
10:40even many die-hard fans questioned the believability of a 60-year-old Rocky
10:44stepping back into the ring to battle a man roughly half his age.
10:49More to the point, many simply doubted Stallone's ability to put his ego aside
10:53and have Rocky lose against the heavyweight champ Mason the Line Dixon.
10:57After all, with Sly promising that Rocky Balboa would give the series a far more fitting ending
11:02compared to Rocky V's miserable climax,
11:05would it have surprised anyone if he overcorrected and gave Rocky an unrealistically happy ending
11:09where he triumphed over Dixon?
11:11But thankfully, Stallone's better creative instincts won out,
11:14and Rocky ends up losing the fight to Dixon via split decision.
11:18Yet in defeat, he goes the distance and proves himself regardless,
11:22circling back quite brilliantly to the original Rocky which ended the very same way.
11:26Bringing Helen Hunt back, Twisters.
11:29Back when a follow-up to 1996's smash hit disaster movie Twister was first announced,
11:34many questioned whether Universal would do the obvious thing
11:37and make it a card-carrying legacy sequel
11:40that teams young new characters with the original surviving lead.
11:43Though Bill Paxton sadly passed away in 2017,
11:47it was simply assumed that his original co-star, Helen Hunt,
11:50would have a supporting role in Twisters,
11:52most likely as the mother of new storm-chasing female lead, Kate.
11:57It just seemed like the most lazy, obvious choice a studio would make
12:00to ensure that they could fully exploit all the nostalgia for the 96 film.
12:05But while Twisters isn't a terribly original quasi-sequel,
12:08it does harbour the restraint to focus itself wholly around a new band of heroes
12:13who have no links to Paxton or Hunt's existing characters whatsoever.
12:18While the role of Kate's mother, Kathy, could have conceivably been written for Hunt originally,
12:23the movie ultimately didn't bend over backwards to find a way
12:26to pull Hunt's Joe Harding into the story.
12:29And in this ultra-conservative, cynical era of Hollywood,
12:32that's something to really respect.
12:34Solving the first film's mystery, Blade Runner 2049.
12:38When Blade Runner 2049 was first announced,
12:41the question on everybody's lips was will it reveal the truth about the original film's protagonist,
12:46Deckard?
12:47After all, the agonising mystery over Deckard's true identity,
12:50whether he's a replicant or a human,
12:53has plagued fans for literally decades.
12:55And it seemed basically inevitable that the sequel would finally explain it one way or another.
13:00But instead, director Denise Villeneuve opted not to confirm Deckard's status one way or another,
13:05refusing to even consider the question within the movie itself,
13:09and instead allowing the enigma to endure.
13:11Given that Blade Runner director Ridley Scott and Harrison Ford
13:14have famously argued over whether Deckard is a replicant or not,
13:18Scott says yes, Ford says no.
13:21Effectively ignoring the question,
13:22and perhaps tacitly suggesting it doesn't even matter,
13:25was absolutely the right way to go.
13:27Generally speaking, it's better to let a mythologised mystery live on forevermore,
13:33rather than just demystify it.
13:35Especially considering the backlash confirming it either way would probably cause.
13:39Reacting to the first film's backlash, Smile 2.
13:42Though horror film Smile was generally accepted to be a pleasant surprise by most critics and genre fans,
13:49there were those who found issue with its ending,
13:51whereby protagonist Rose fails to defeat the focal trauma demon,
13:55ultimately being compelled to kill herself and pass the curse on to her ex, Joel.
13:59Some took this rather facile reading from Smile's ending that filmmaker Parker Finn
14:04was telling people afflicted by horrific traumas that there's no hope for them,
14:08rather than simply trying to deliver a climax to his film that was appropriately intense and upsetting.
14:14And while some speculated that Finn might deliver a reactionary sequel
14:18in which new protagonist Skye is able to defeat the demon,
14:22this thankfully wasn't the case at all.
14:24Finn instead stuck to his grim guns,
14:27and once again had the hero fail to win,
14:30with Skye meeting an arguably even more violent and disturbing end than Rose.
14:34While it's absolutely fair to say that the third Smile film
14:37might start to lose audiences if the hero isn't ever able to win,
14:41it was at least a relief that Finn told precisely the story he wanted to hear without compromise.
14:47Making a storytelling pivot because of what online film fans want is almost never a good idea.
14:52Over-explaining the alien invasion, A Quiet Place Day One.
14:56A big problem facing almost every franchise prequel
15:00is the tendency for them to over-explain key aspects of the overarching lore,
15:04demystifying it to the extent that it's actually a lot less interesting
15:08once all the cards are on the table.
15:10This was certainly an exception of A Quiet Place Day One,
15:13whose title seemed to imply it would lay bare the particulars
15:16of how the series' alien invasion kicked off.
15:19But filmmaker Michael Sanofsky clearly had little interest
15:23in poring over the fateful day in forensic detail,
15:26opting instead to focus the story on two embattled people
15:30as they simply try to make it through the day in one piece.
15:34Though we do see the beginnings of the invasion,
15:36the monsters almost play second fiddle to the human drama at the centre,
15:41enough that they still maintain a sense of mystery and intrigue.
15:45Given that A Quiet Place Part 3 is currently in the works,
15:48it was incredibly smart not to reveal too much about the creatures
15:51or their origins in this prequel.
15:53Getting Peter and Gamora back together,
15:56Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3.
15:58James Gunn may be one of the most canny filmmakers making superhero movies today,
16:02but fans were nevertheless worried that sentimentality might get the better of him
16:06in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3.
16:08After all, Gamora's death in Avengers Infinity War created a major creative roblox for Gunn,
16:14who hadn't expected that to happen.
16:16And so he was forced to pivot by effectively replacing the original Gamora
16:20with her 2014 variant who debuted in Avengers Endgame.
16:24As such, many fans suspected that Gunn would basically try to revert Gamora
16:28to her original state by film's end,
16:30having her fall in love with Peter Quill
16:32and more or less paper over the fact that the real Gamora actually died.
16:37But instead, Gunn sidestepped this very obvious storytelling gaffe,
16:40directly addressing the fact that this Gamora isn't THE Gamora Peter fell in love with,
16:45and ending the film without the new Gamora also falling for Peter.
16:48Ultimately, this version of Gamora looks favourably upon Peter by film's end,
16:53and gets a nice moment with him before he heads back to Earth.
16:56And so, rather than disastrously attempt to force a romance between them,
17:00Gunn deepened their character development by keeping things emotionally honest.
17:04Making Ripley's daughter the protagonist, Alien Romulus.
17:08When Alien Romulus was first announced and Kaylee Spaney was soon enough cast
17:12in the role of the new protagonist, speculation quickly ran rampant
17:16that the film already confirmed to be set between Alien and Aliens
17:20would revolve around Ellen Ripley's daughter Amanda.
17:23Timeline-wise, it made a tonne of sense,
17:26especially as Ripley spent almost 60 years in hypersleep between the first two films,
17:30during which period Amanda grew into adulthood,
17:33and sadly passed away before Ripley was awoken.
17:37And more than that, Hollywood loves nothing more than a legacy sequel
17:40that revolves around the offspring of the original hero.
17:44And Alien had the major advantage of Amanda Ripley already being a well-known canon character
17:49across movies, video games, and comics.
17:52But for all of its faults, and there are certainly plenty,
17:55Alien Romulus at least had the restraint to make Spaney's new lead
17:59an entirely new creation, with no contrived links to existing franchise characters.
18:05In a film that's jam-packed with so much ham-fisted fan service otherwise,
18:09it's genuinely surprising that the filmmakers didn't go down the Amanda Ripley route.
18:14Going PG-13 Logan
18:16Even though James Mangold's Logan, a quasi-sequel to both The Wolverine
18:20and X-Men Days of Future Past, was shot with an R rating in mind,
18:24fans were understandably sceptical that this rating would stick,
18:28considering how much of a ceiling it would place on the movie's box office prospects.
18:32But to their credit, Fox indeed allowed Mangold to deliver an R-rated finale
18:36to Hugh Jackman's linear tenure as Logan,
18:39excluding his role in Deadpool 3, which is set before the events of Logan.
18:43Rather than be yet another neutered PG-13 movie about a man with metal claws stabbing people to death,
18:49Logan puts his R rating to damn good use,
18:52with ultra-violent action and liberal use of appropriately colourful language.
18:57The result was both the best Wolverine movie
18:59and Jackman's greatest performance in the role to date,
19:02while it also went on to become one of the X-Men series' most commercially successful films.
19:07Basically, everything worked out for the best,
19:09because Fox didn't cynically try to make a post-apocalyptic Wolverine movie appealing to children.
19:15Because that would have been a bit weird, wouldn't it?
19:17Constantly referencing the original, The First Omen.
19:20There wasn't much enthusiasm at all when The First Omen,
19:23a prequel to Richard Donner's 1976 horror classic, The Omen, was first announced.
19:28After all, did anyone come away from that film feeling like it needed more of a backstory?
19:33This had a strong whiff of perfunctoriness from the outset,
19:37existing solely because of Hollywood's insatiable obsession
19:41with milking their existing IP for every drop they're worth.
19:45There was no doubt that The First Omen would be crammed with corny,
19:49forced references to the iconic original film,
19:52and likely end up feeling like a dull facsimile of it.
19:55But credit to all involved,
19:57this is actually a genuinely well-made, brilliantly acted,
20:01and uncomfortably intense horror film
20:03that stands extremely stably on its own two feet.
20:06Yes, there are nods to the original film,
20:08but the picture isn't using them as foundations for its story
20:11or leaning on them as crutches.
20:13You could easily watch The First Omen as a standalone horror
20:16and be perfectly entertained by it.
20:18Now, who could have ever seen that coming?

Recommended