00:01The Treasurer making an announcement that confirms what he's been saying for several
00:06weeks but with a little bit more detail this morning, which is that the main focus, as
00:10you say, of the mid-year budget update, which is expected any time now in a couple of weeks,
00:14perhaps in early December or mid-December, will include substantial spending cuts.
00:21He says that the cuts will be enough but not too much, that the Government's trying to
00:25strike a fine balance between cutting spending to contribute to the fight against inflation,
00:31as he puts it, but also wanting to make sure that the cuts don't affect key Government services
00:37or cut any of the things that the Government says it doesn't want to cut.
00:40So, few details on exactly what that will be at this stage, but we have had a couple of
00:45hints emerging over the last few weeks.
00:47The Finance Minister, Katie Gallaher, said on afternoon briefing a few weeks ago that the
00:51public service was one of several areas that might be the focus of belt tightening.
00:55The Government has, in the last year or so, asked all departments and agencies to identify
01:00so-called low priority spending, 5% of the lowest priority spending.
01:05So, that might give it something of a short list to be able to pick some items to cut.
01:09There's also been some speculation that some spending that was scheduled to happen
01:13in the current financial year could be pushed back into future financial years.
01:17That would allow the Government to say overall they're not cutting back on things that are
01:23important and that the Government has decided to do and sees some value in doing, but rather
01:27that they're being pushed out of what is the most sensitive inflation window, because inflation
01:32in the short term is really the focus here. The Government has been consistent in saying
01:37that its spending it does not believe is fuelling inflation or is the primary driver of inflation.
01:43And the Reserve Bank Governor Michelle Bullock has been careful in her wording as well,
01:47saying that, look, the economy is in an overall position where every dollar, be it from the
01:52Government or the private sector, is contributing to too much demand in the economy and contributing
01:56to inflation. But she hasn't made that direct criticism of Government spending either. Certainly,
02:01though, the Opposition has, and many economists have, accused the Government's spending of making
02:07the inflation problem worse, leading to higher rates. There's obviously some sensitivity among
02:13Ministers about that. It's been something that's been discussed a little bit in the last few weeks.
02:17The Treasurer has been coming under a reasonable amount of public pressure over the issue of
02:20spending. And he has been saying that there will be savings, as the Government says there are in
02:25every update. What we still don't know is whether this will be a net save. That is whether the savings
02:31substantial, though Jim Chalmers today says they will be, will be bigger than any new spending. That will
02:36be one of the key things to watch. And particularly whether there's a net save, again, as I say,
02:40in this year. Because this is the year where having had five interest rate hikes over the course of the
02:45calendar year from the Reserve Bank, and looking to 2027 with inflation still elevated above the
02:51Reserve Bank's target band, this is the year where the quantum of spending probably matters the most
02:56in the discussion about inflation. So, a lot of details still to come from the Treasurer. And, you know,
03:02we'll see a lot of it in the mid-year budget update. But this language around substantial,
03:07to say that the spending cuts will be the main focus of the budget, I think that's a hint that
03:12we shouldn't expect too many new items of spending, that it will be very much a focus on conveying
03:17restraint.
03:18And Tom, the Treasurer has also spoken about the capital gains tax changes, which are due before
03:23Parliament this week. What's he had to say about that?
03:26Yes. So, a capital gains carve-out, if you like, for start-ups is before the Parliament
03:30at the moment. It's going to be a busy couple of weeks for the Treasurer, because his hope is to
03:35get that passed next week, as well as legislation to enact the minimum tax, 30% tax on discretionary
03:43trusts. So, two of the last key elements from the May budget that will come before the Parliament
03:48next week, and the Senate, which is sitting this week. The CGT proposal has been the subject of a
03:56lot of discussion, because this was one of the things that, way back in the May budget,
04:00start-ups, almost the day after the budget, were saying, we're concerned about how the
04:05government's new plans for an inflation-based capital gains tax discount will affect the start-up
04:11sector, because if you're starting from zero, essentially, you don't get much of an inflation
04:16benefit. That was their argument. The government accepted that argument and has taken several
04:20months to consult on what a workaround might look like. What it has come up with, and what
04:24is before the Parliament, is what it calls an exemption for so-called innovative businesses.
04:30So, if a business of a certain size can classify as innovative, it will have the option to opt out
04:35of
04:36the new capital gains tax regime and choose the old one, if the owners of that business prefer.
04:41What Allegra Spender, the Independent, has been saying is that instead, essentially,
04:45she says that's too complex, that the definition of innovative is too
04:48grey and fuzzy and subjective, and that instead there should be a flat 40% discount,
04:53instead of the current 50% discount for those start-ups. So, it does all get a bit technical,
04:57but she says that wouldn't make too much difference to the amount of money that's raised,
05:02but that it would apply broadly to any businesses with active assets, that it would cover broadly
05:06anyone who is trying to innovate, and that that would be, she says, a better way to do it.
05:11The Greens, whose numbers will be essential in the Senate for this bill to pass, said yesterday
05:16that they would be interested in considering the Spender model. What we've heard from the
05:20Treasurer this morning is that he doesn't believe it's a good idea. He says he took Allegra Spender's
05:24idea seriously, that the pair met and had a lengthy discussion about it, and that he commissioned
05:29Treasury analysis into her 40% idea. He says he sent her that analysis and he will publish it soon,
05:35but that the long and the short of it is that it says that it will not necessarily make the
05:40economy
05:40more productive, that it would be too complex, that it would mean higher tax in some circumstances
05:46for some start-ups, and also that it would raise, he says, some integrity issues. So, it'll be
05:50interesting to see exactly what Treasury has said about this proposal, but the Treasurer particularly,
05:55I think, targeting his message at the Greens, whose votes will be crucial for the capital gains tax
05:59and the trust tax in the next week or two.