00:00Christmas morning 1945, a house in West Virginia burns to the ground in less than an hour.
00:04When the smoke clears, five children are gone.
00:06Not a bone, not a button, not a single trace.
00:09And 80 years later, nobody knows what happened to them.
00:12The family was the Sauters, George and Jenny, Italian immigrants,
00:16raising 10 children in Fayetteville, West Virginia.
00:18On Christmas Eve, nine of the children were home for the holidays.
00:21Nobody there knew that before sunrise, their family would be torn apart forever.
00:25At about one in the morning, Jenny woke to a thump on the roof.
00:28Then the smell of smoke.
00:30The stairs were already burning.
00:32George, Jenny and four children escaped into the freezing night.
00:34But five children, sleeping upstairs, never came down.
00:38Maurice, 14.
00:40Martha, 12.
00:42Louis, 9.
00:43Jenny, 8.
00:45And little Betty, only 5.
00:47The fire department arrived hours late, and by then, the house was gone.
00:51When the ashes cooled, the family sifted through them for any trace of the children.
00:54They found nothing.
00:55No bones, no teeth, not a single fragment.
00:57Yet within days, the fire marshal blamed faulty wiring, and the coroner issued death certificates
01:02for all five, with no remains ever found.
01:05But George Sauter refused to believe it.
01:07He had just had the whole house rewired, and the work had been inspected and approved.
01:11That night, the Christmas lights downstairs stayed lit, and the ladder George always kept
01:16against the house was missing.
01:17It was found tossed down an embankment, 75 feet away.
01:21And there was more.
01:22The telephone line had not burned.
01:23It had been cut.
01:25Deliberately.
01:25By someone who climbed 14 feet up a pole to reach it.
01:28All three of the family's trucks refused to start that night.
01:31Strangers had come to the house before the fire.
01:33One man warned George his home would go up in smoke.
01:36The Sauters never accepted the official story.
01:38In 1949, they hired a pathologist to dig again.
01:41A few small bone fragments were found, and sent to the Smithsonian Institution.
01:45The answer came back.
01:46The bones belonged to one person.
01:4716 to 22 years old.
01:49And they had never been in a fire.
01:50They were not the children.
01:52George put up a billboard on Route 16.
01:53He kept it standing for 40 years.
01:56Then, in 1967, more than 20 years after the fire, an envelope arrived in the mail, postmarked
02:02from Kentucky.
02:04Inside, was a photograph of a young man.
02:06The family believed it was Louis, grown up.
02:09They hired a private detective to follow the lead.
02:12The detective took their money, and vanished.
02:14The trail went cold again.
02:17So what really happened that Christmas night?
02:19Were the five children taken from the house before the fire was set?
02:21Was it revenge against George, who had spoken out against Mussolini's Italy?
02:24Or did they die in the flames, as the officials said?
02:27Even though experts confirmed the fire could not have erased five bodies completely.
02:30Every theory explains one piece.
02:32None explains them all.
02:34Sylvia, the youngest child, the last survivor, believed her whole life that her brothers and
02:39sisters had survived that night.
02:40She died in 2021, still waiting for an answer.
02:43The house was never rebuilt.
02:45A memorial garden stands there now, in Fayetteville, West Virginia.
02:48So tell me in the comments, what do you think happened to the five Sauter children on
02:51Christmas morning, 1945?
02:54Theๅฎะฐัั.
02:55It wasn't even a few countries and I just wanted to.
02:55Have to park the shelf in that time, as you said.
02:55A vereinante and the world, which is going to be gone beyond beyond that.