00:00We could do this, keeping with historical quotes, we could do this on March 15th, the Ides of March.
00:05The Ides of March.
00:07And then if that other case has to be continued, we could continue that.
00:11I could do that.
00:12I'm sorry, I don't have any jokes.
00:14I'm not, you know, I'm not saying any jokes, all right?
00:18I'm just trying to talk to both counsel about getting a date.
00:23I hear Mr. Rankin quoting Julius Caesar.
00:26You know, I don't know.
00:27And the Rubicon.
00:28I would, you know, quote Shakespeare.
00:31We can't go tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow.
00:33Creeps upon its petty pace.
00:35We can't do that.
00:35We're going to pick a trial date.
00:37And I understand the Commonwealth thing, but in weighing all that, I see it as either a trial date in
00:44March or a trial date in April.
00:46Before the court today, we have the matter of Commonwealth versus Lindsay Clancy.
00:50Ms. Clancy is present.
00:51She is represented by Attorney Kevin Reddington and Attorney Laura McConnell.
00:54The Commonwealth is represented by Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague and Assistant District Attorney Shannon Buckingham.
01:00Good morning, everyone.
01:02Good morning, Council.
01:02Good morning, Ms. Clancy.
01:04Good morning, Your Honor.
01:05I guess my thought would be to discuss kind of the next scheduling in regards to that.
01:11So Commonwealth, can you tell us what the status in regards to the request, what the next date would be?
01:20Well, I think from the Commonwealth's perspective, given what the charges are, it requires a jury trial, so we'd be
01:26ready to pick a jury trial date.
01:28We haven't heard from the defense counsel about any other direction for the trial, so without that, we'd be ready
01:35to pick a trial date.
01:37Okay.
01:37Yeah, Ms. Ray.
01:45So, as they say, the die has been cast.
01:51I think you can read between the lines that when they say that the case is going to require a
01:57jury, that it's an indirect comment from the DA that they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments, so
02:06we will pick a trial date.
02:09All right.
02:10I think we had talked, as I mentioned last time, maybe sometime in March, and so I think that's what
02:18I'd like to do, and then maybe kind of go backwards in regards to that, in regards to final trial,
02:25if there's other discovery issues or any other kind of things that have to be addressed.
02:30Would you call more?
02:31Your Honor, ABA Buckingham and I have looked at our trial calendars, which are pretty full with other murder trials,
02:39a lot of which are older in this case, and some of which haven't had their first trial date yet.
02:46So, looking at our availability, the first availability we have is in May.
02:54Aye.
02:55Mr. Rankin?
02:56I'd say we split the difference in, say, April.
02:59I mean, they can continue those cases.
03:01Cases are continued all the time.
03:03I think it's readily apparent that this is a case that needs to be tried, and I indicated to the
03:11court that I wanted to, myself, wanted to have it done before the spring ended.
03:20So, I would say an April date.
03:22Your Honor, I do have a trial scheduled in April on a homicide case from 2014.
03:29We've looked at our calendars.
03:31We've looked at the trials that we have between now and May.
03:35I believe all of them are older than this case.
03:38Many of them, as I said, haven't even had their first trial date yet.
03:41So, I don't understand why this defendant would be entitled to a second trial before some of these older, other
03:50cases where people are waiting in custody in jail get their first trial date.
03:55Well, in regards to the 2014 case.
03:59That's separate.
04:00Right?
04:01That's, I imagine that there are other circumstances that have led to that.
04:08Either there's a question of competency or a return to competency or there's been a motion for new trial.
04:17So, that doesn't seem to be, I mean, unless, I can't, and I can't imagine the Commonwealth.
04:23I know this office.
04:24I can't imagine the Commonwealth would just have waited 12 years to try somebody.
04:29No, there absolutely have been issues with competency.
04:32Right.
04:33However, where the defendant has been restored to competency, and they're competent at this moment.
04:38And that there are witnesses to this homicide who were children when it happened and have been waiting for 12
04:46years to testify on behalf of the victim, their mother, in that case.
04:51I would be hesitant to try to take away that date from them.
04:55Because if we do move that date, maybe the defendants are longer competent going forward when we eventually reach it.
05:02But I would like to take advantage of the fact that he's competent now and get that trial done, if
05:07possible.
05:08I suggest, Your Honor, that that case that everybody's pretty much aware of has been kicked around for quite a
05:15while, obviously 14 years.
05:17Because I don't think it's going to, the individual, obviously I don't know about his competency, but I don't see
05:23that all of a sudden he's going to miraculously become incompetent because the Lindsay Clancy case happens to move it
05:30a couple of months.
05:31So I would again reiterate that I believe this case deserves attention from the court.
05:37I would prefer, I would prefer to have it in April.
05:40All right.
05:41Well, I would say, come off, we need to pick a March date or an April date.
05:45Kind of however, whatever the Commonwealth would want to do.
05:52Well, I know A.K. Buckingham has a trial in March.
05:57I have trials, excuse me, I apologize.
05:59I have trials all over the state and I'm willing to move them.
06:01I understand, but this is the case that's in front of me right now.
06:04All right?
06:05I want to get this done.
06:06I want to deal with this.
06:08We had talked about this two weeks ago as a possibility, and I appreciate everybody looking at their calendars.
06:18But, you know, I hear Mr. Rankin quoting Julius Caesar.
06:23You know, I would quote Shakespeare.
06:28We can't go tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow.
06:31Creeps upon its petty pace.
06:32We can't do that.
06:32We're going to pick a trial date, and I understand the Commonwealth thing, but in weighing all that, I see
06:40it as either a trial date in March or a trial date in April.
06:43I would just say for the court and for the record that some of these defendants have filed motions in
06:49court saying that we are prejudicing them by focusing on this case to the detriment of them waiting in jail
06:58for their trial date and that it's unfair to them.
07:01I think this case is being used as an excuse all over the state for a lot of things.
07:06Here's what we can do.
07:08Pick a trial date in March or April.
07:10And then if we have to address that or the other cases have to be addressed, we'll do that.
07:17But I don't have all of those cases in front of me.
07:20I've got this case in front of me.
07:22All right?
07:22This is a case that I want to try, get tried.
07:26You know, the parties want to get tried.
07:29And like I said before, we've all done retrials.
07:33And generally, the sooner the case is retried, the better it is for all of the parties, including the attorneys,
07:42rather than waiting a year to get something done.
07:46So that's why I was asking.
07:47This gives everybody about four months to prepare, four months to make adjustments in regards to their schedules.
07:57That's a pretty significant amount of time.
08:00So, again, March or April?
08:04We'd have to ask, then, for the end of April.
08:06And I'd just ask for the court for some type of order or ruling to protect the Commonwealth in a
08:12Rule 36 motion on the other case that's scheduled for April.
08:15All right.
08:16Well, I mean, I'm not going to rule on something I don't see.
08:18So I'd have to see it.
08:20How about Monday, April 19th?
08:22Or the 12th?
08:24I'd ask for the 26th, if possible.
08:27How about April 5th?
08:30Whatever date you say, I'd make work.
08:32April 5th is fine.
08:34I don't think that would give E.D. Buckingham sufficient time to finish her trial in March and then prepare
08:39properly for this.
08:42Well, when's that other trial going to start?
08:44We could do this, keeping with historical quotes, we could do this on March 15th.
08:48Yeah, it's a March.
08:49Yeah, it's a March.
08:51And then if that other case has to be continued, we could continue that.
08:55I could do that.
08:56Sorry, I don't have any jokes.
08:58I'm not, you know, I'm not saying any jokes.
09:01All right.
09:02I'm just trying to talk to both counsel about getting a date.
09:07So I'm not making any jokes.
09:10I'm just speaking to counsel that I've known for quite a while and I know that wants to serve the
09:18Commonwealth, serve their clients.
09:20I'm just trying to get a date.
09:22You know, I mean, so we came in here last time.
09:27We talked about a possible date in March.
09:29We come back here two weeks later and now we're getting, I'm getting a different position, different arguments.
09:38That's all.
09:39Your Honor, on the last date you suggested March, but I don't think there was a discussion about parties about
09:43availability in March.
09:45How's March 15th?
09:50March 15th, 18th, I'm starting a trial on March 8th.
09:54All right.
09:54How about the 22nd then?
09:56I thought we were in April.
09:58Well, you know, everybody's getting, we say April and then you go to the very end of April.
10:05That's, we've been talking about March.
10:08So that's all.
10:10And then I said the 15th, you said the council can't do it because starting a trial on the 8th.
10:14So I'm saying, let's go two weeks after that.
10:16That becomes March 22nd.
10:18How's that?
10:20And I don't want my silence to be taken that I don't have a case scheduled pretty much every week.
10:25Whatever the court recommends for a trial date, I will make work.
10:29If 88 Buckingham starts that trial on the 8th, it's a murder trial.
10:33If it takes a week and a half, two weeks, that gives us zero preparation time.
10:36We've already tried it for seven weeks.
10:38Do you have a right to present it in a different manner?
10:40Please talk, talk, talk to me, not to each other.
10:45All right, that was the 29th, March 29th.
10:49Another Commonwealth's objection.
10:50All right, all right, why don't we put it on for March 29th then, over the Commonwealth's objection.
Comments