Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 minute ago
Returning now to the gas reservation bill before the senate this week, which would require gas producers to reserve up 20 per cent of their export volume for the domestic market. Professor Bruce mountain is director of the Victoria energy policy centre at Victoria university and he explains the scheme that the government is trying to get across the line with the greens and coalition.

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:02Essentially, the proposal is to require gas producers to sell one-fifth of the gas that
00:11they produce, own or purchase or have a contract for in Australia to make that available in
00:19the Australian market.
00:22There are many details to it and that can be reduced based on a number of factors, so
00:28it need not be necessarily a hard number.
00:31The main point is that it's an obligation to sell a proportion of the gas that they produce
00:37to the local market.
00:39Now, the government claims that it will put downward pressure on prices, while some in
00:42the industry are warning that it could create oversupply.
00:46Could it potentially do both of those things, or how do you see the impact of this policy?
00:52I think if it's enforced in a vigorous way, it may well reduce prices in the short term,
01:01but in the longer term, it may well increase prices to the extent that gas producers are
01:07effectively being forced to sell gas at a price that's not profitable for them.
01:12They won't have incentives to expand production, and that means that gas supply will actually
01:19decline in the longer term, which in turn will drive up prices in the domestic market and
01:26will undermine export capability.
01:31Any more detail on how it might be implemented?
01:34Because there are concerns from the opposition around excessive ministerial discretion and
01:40also a requirement to supply gas regardless of market demand.
01:44Yes.
01:46This legislation essentially gives considerable discretion to the regulator and to the minister
01:52on the implementation.
01:53So there are large penalties for failing to abide by the obligations, but the minister and
02:01the regulator will have a lot of discretion in varying how the scheme is implemented.
02:07Essentially, it seems to me, in large, this is legislation that essentially gives the minister
02:13a very great deal of authority to determine outcomes.
02:17So it really depends on the decisions that the minister and that the energy regulator will then
02:23make as to the implications on it for gas producers and hence also for prices.
02:31What might it mean for new investment in new gas projects?
02:37I think it will greatly increase uncertainty to the extent that obligations are then subject to
02:46ministerial controls.
02:48There will be uncertainty because who knows what choices the minister might make and what a
02:54future government might make.
02:56And I think that will therefore be expressed in a higher hurdle rate or a higher cost of capital
03:02that the gas producers will want to achieve before they're going to expand production.
03:08So I think there's many reasons to be worried about this.
03:13OK.
03:14I want to ask you two more things before we wind up.
03:17I understand that the Greens would prefer to see a gas export tax.
03:21Is that good policy and why are some companies attracted to that?
03:25I think a gas export tax administratively is very much clearer and simpler.
03:33It simply puts an impost on gas that's sold abroad and as a consequence brings in a price differential
03:42between the international export price and price that gas producers will achieve here,
03:48which forces down prices here.
03:50The problem is it may well undermine exports and in turn may well undermine gas expansion
03:57to meet both domestic demand and export demand to the extent that that export tax can't be
04:04passed on to the international consumers.
04:06And international consumers have been extremely worried about international export taxes to
04:14the extent that the gas producers try to pass it on to them.
04:17And so that greatly decreases the range of competitive gas that they can access.
04:24So different buyers and sellers will have different attitudes to it and the price effects
04:30might be relatively clear in the short term, but in the longer term, it may well be the case
04:34that they push prices up.
04:36One of the other points of contention we might likely see in the Senate this week is around
04:41the WA gas reservation policy.
04:44How will it impact that scheme?
04:46And should there indeed be a carve out, which we've heard calls for?
04:51So right now it's framed as a national scheme.
04:55I think there's good reason to think of west gas quite differently from east and south gas.
05:01The balance of export demand and local demand in the west relative to the supply in the west
05:07is quite different.
05:08And so trying to shoehorn one national policy into areas that have very different economics
05:17just makes no sense.
05:18The legislation recognises that inasmuch as the minister can choose to vary things
05:24as the minister sees fit.
05:27And almost certainly the minister will have to.
05:29But that, of course, begs the question why in the legislation there's not the separation.
05:34The legislation can choose from.

Recommended