00:02Essentially, the proposal is to require gas producers to sell one-fifth of the gas that
00:11they produce, own or purchase or have a contract for in Australia to make that available in
00:19the Australian market.
00:22There are many details to it and that can be reduced based on a number of factors, so
00:28it need not be necessarily a hard number.
00:31The main point is that it's an obligation to sell a proportion of the gas that they produce
00:37to the local market.
00:39Now, the government claims that it will put downward pressure on prices, while some in
00:42the industry are warning that it could create oversupply.
00:46Could it potentially do both of those things, or how do you see the impact of this policy?
00:52I think if it's enforced in a vigorous way, it may well reduce prices in the short term,
01:01but in the longer term, it may well increase prices to the extent that gas producers are
01:07effectively being forced to sell gas at a price that's not profitable for them.
01:12They won't have incentives to expand production, and that means that gas supply will actually
01:19decline in the longer term, which in turn will drive up prices in the domestic market and
01:26will undermine export capability.
01:31Any more detail on how it might be implemented?
01:34Because there are concerns from the opposition around excessive ministerial discretion and
01:40also a requirement to supply gas regardless of market demand.
01:44Yes.
01:46This legislation essentially gives considerable discretion to the regulator and to the minister
01:52on the implementation.
01:53So there are large penalties for failing to abide by the obligations, but the minister and
02:01the regulator will have a lot of discretion in varying how the scheme is implemented.
02:07Essentially, it seems to me, in large, this is legislation that essentially gives the minister
02:13a very great deal of authority to determine outcomes.
02:17So it really depends on the decisions that the minister and that the energy regulator will then
02:23make as to the implications on it for gas producers and hence also for prices.
02:31What might it mean for new investment in new gas projects?
02:37I think it will greatly increase uncertainty to the extent that obligations are then subject to
02:46ministerial controls.
02:48There will be uncertainty because who knows what choices the minister might make and what a
02:54future government might make.
02:56And I think that will therefore be expressed in a higher hurdle rate or a higher cost of capital
03:02that the gas producers will want to achieve before they're going to expand production.
03:08So I think there's many reasons to be worried about this.
03:13OK.
03:14I want to ask you two more things before we wind up.
03:17I understand that the Greens would prefer to see a gas export tax.
03:21Is that good policy and why are some companies attracted to that?
03:25I think a gas export tax administratively is very much clearer and simpler.
03:33It simply puts an impost on gas that's sold abroad and as a consequence brings in a price differential
03:42between the international export price and price that gas producers will achieve here,
03:48which forces down prices here.
03:50The problem is it may well undermine exports and in turn may well undermine gas expansion
03:57to meet both domestic demand and export demand to the extent that that export tax can't be
04:04passed on to the international consumers.
04:06And international consumers have been extremely worried about international export taxes to
04:14the extent that the gas producers try to pass it on to them.
04:17And so that greatly decreases the range of competitive gas that they can access.
04:24So different buyers and sellers will have different attitudes to it and the price effects
04:30might be relatively clear in the short term, but in the longer term, it may well be the case
04:34that they push prices up.
04:36One of the other points of contention we might likely see in the Senate this week is around
04:41the WA gas reservation policy.
04:44How will it impact that scheme?
04:46And should there indeed be a carve out, which we've heard calls for?
04:51So right now it's framed as a national scheme.
04:55I think there's good reason to think of west gas quite differently from east and south gas.
05:01The balance of export demand and local demand in the west relative to the supply in the west
05:07is quite different.
05:08And so trying to shoehorn one national policy into areas that have very different economics
05:17just makes no sense.
05:18The legislation recognises that inasmuch as the minister can choose to vary things
05:24as the minister sees fit.
05:27And almost certainly the minister will have to.
05:29But that, of course, begs the question why in the legislation there's not the separation.
05:34The legislation can choose from.