00:14Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
00:38Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
01:08Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
01:42Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
02:00Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
02:46Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
02:58Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
03:01Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
04:17Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
04:56Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
06:03Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
12:34joined those talks.
12:44Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
12:47are non-stop now.
12:48Can European assistant keep up with this space of aggression?
12:52We have no choice.
12:54This is our own security, which is at stake.
12:57You know, this afternoon, all the member states were concerned about the hybrid attacks, sabotage.
13:03It was Italy.
13:04You know, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has been victim of sabotage.
13:07Yes.
13:08But it was also Romania in the Black Sea where you have vessels that are sinking into the economic zone.
13:17No one of us is not victim, you know, of these hybrid threats.
13:24Everybody is suffering.
13:26Everybody is suffering.
13:27And I think that Russia is playing also with this grey zone.
13:32You know, we are not at war. We are not at peace.
13:35So this is very malicious attack and it should only reinforce our determination.
13:42Just finally, is there a possibility that the Russian strikes could trigger a new wave of Ukrainian refugees to Europe
13:49due to the suffering inside Ukraine?
13:52As a commissioner for crisis management and preparedness, I'm preparing for even the worst case scenario.
13:59And but for the moment, we try to help Ukrainians to stay safe, to stay warm and inside Ukraine.
14:09That was our correspondent Jorge Liborero speaking to the European Commissioner for Humanitarian Aid, Hadja Labib.
14:16Also tonight, following the meeting of EU foreign ministers in Brussels,
14:21Europe's top diplomat Kaya Kalas told reporters that Russia is not serious about peace negotiations while insisting that she should
14:30be at the negotiating table.
14:32This comes as the European Commission prepares to unveil a new financing plan for cash strapped Ukraine later this week.
14:40Let's get more on this.
14:42Joining me now in the studio are Europe editor Maria Tadeo.
14:46Good evening, Maria. Great to have you.
14:48As well as Teysa Reuten, who is a member of the European Parliament.
14:52Welcome both.
14:53Let me come to you first, Maria.
14:55Kalas has clearly been sidelined here from the talks, but she's insisting today that she wants to play a role.
15:02Is she fighting a losing battle?
15:03Yes.
15:04And Marit, first the good news.
15:05Congratulations for the show.
15:07And of course, this new studio is great to be with you now on Europe tonight.
15:11And now on to the serious matters.
15:12This is a high representative that has been sidelined.
15:15The leadership has made it clear they want to lead the process of hypothetical talks because we're very much in
15:22a hypothetical stage of potential talks between the Europeans, Russia and the United States of America over peace with Ukraine.
15:30But Kayakalas just a few hours ago insisting the treaties are clear.
15:34It is a high representative who should be also at the table and she should be involved.
15:39She also said the idea that Russia is ready for talks at this point is a fantasy, especially we've seen
15:45now reports suggesting that Russia is dead set on the idea that they want to see a NATO pullback in
15:51Europe.
15:52But nonetheless, the train has left the station.
15:55Kayakalas has been sidelined.
15:57There is now a real almost campaign and I'd say a brutal campaign to undermine not just her figure, but
16:03really the institution she represents.
16:06But there is a fundamental question, which is why do you appoint a high representative if you don't think she
16:12is fit for purpose?
16:14Why appoint Kayakalas if you think she's simply not up to the job?
16:17It says a lot, too, about the people who put her there.
16:20Thijs, let me bring you in.
16:22Interested to get your thoughts on what Maria just said there.
16:25Is Kayakalas' credibility and her institution's credibility now on the line, would you say?
16:31The undermining of her position, the HRVP role, but also the external action service needs to stop immediately.
16:37I really cannot accept that anymore, what I'm seeing in front of me.
16:42And it's actually really strange because we have Kayakalas as the high representative exactly because Europe to speak with one
16:49voice.
16:50So it's really strange to leave her out of the room when we need exactly that, Europe to speak with
16:54one voice.
16:55And secondly, I hear a lot of people saying yes, but Kayakalas is not so much appreciated by the Russians.
17:01Well, that's, I think, an argument to actually use her position because she understands what is happening.
17:07It's Ukraine that wants peace. It's Europe that wants peace.
17:10It's Russia that only wants to talk about it.
17:12Yet we have seven voices more or less now going into hypothetical, as you said, peace talks between Ukraine, Russia,
17:20the US and the Europeans.
17:21And but we know, Maria, that there's a lot of cacophony, a lot of conflicting viewpoints now about how Europe
17:28should approach those talks.
17:29And an Austrian paper coming out today with some ideas that have not really been well received by all parts.
17:35Well, absolutely. And again, that reinforces the point of there was a need for a special EU envoy to put
17:42together and coordinate those positions.
17:44Also noting that the idea of a threat when it comes to Russia really changes by country and the eastern
17:50flank may have different positions when it comes to other countries.
17:54In this case, you mentioned Austria is not even a NATO country.
17:57So, of course, the idea was that a single person was going to put them all together and bring them
18:02very much in line and marriage to add to that point.
18:05We saw at this ministerial meeting today that some are suggesting we should not even be making points about the
18:10negotiation with Russia at this point.
18:12We should just be enforcing that ceasefire, which has not taken place.
18:16And that was really seen by many as a sign of goodwill for real negotiations or not.
18:21Whether Russia would commit to a ceasefire, to that energy ceasefire, we see in reality is not really happening.
18:26And we're talking very much about a hypothetical, but the reality still stands.
18:30This is a high representative who is not going to be at the table.
18:33You say she should be used.
18:35It's clear now that the Europeans have decided she's simply not fit for purpose.
18:38But the question still remains to me, why the hell do you have a high representative if you don't think
18:45she is fit for purpose?
18:46To me, this is going to do real damage to the institution and that figure.
18:49We have another problem because it should be first about the mandate.
18:53What does Europe exactly want to achieve?
18:55Once you have that figured out, you actually don't need any more such a big delegation because you know what
19:01you want to discuss.
19:03And the problem of having too many people on behalf of Europe at the table means that they also can
19:08say contradictory things, which also doesn't help with speaking with one voice.
19:13So it's really problematic that we are now again talking about people at the table instead of what we want
19:19to achieve.
19:20And the point about the ceasefire is a test for Russia.
19:23It's not a result.
19:24The ceasefire is not a result.
19:26It's a test because what we really need is serious talks.
19:29And that only happens when we force Russia to sit down in a serious manner.
19:33We also know there's another pressing issue, which is the financing for Ukraine.
19:37And we are expecting the Commission to come forward with a proposal on this, Maria, on Wednesday.
19:42How crucial a moment is this?
19:44Well, it's very crucial because Ukraine needs the money.
19:48And as your news reported, this is going to happen on the Wednesday.
19:51The idea is that there is going to be a proposal for an additional 45 billion euros for next year
19:56will be very similar to the loan that was approved just a year ago in December.
20:01So you borrow money.
20:02This is more debt.
20:03And you back up that debt against the European budget.
20:06But this is complicated, of course, because the political cycle is changing.
20:10We've heard from Marine Le Pen, who at this stage would be the president of France, saying she would not
20:15pay.
20:15There are three countries that already do not pay into this loan.
20:18A fourth one, Bulgaria, has said they will ask to for an exception.
20:22And there's a reality here, Marit.
20:24The war is costing more than the leadership, the EU leadership, anticipated in December.
20:30Remember, they said 90 billions for two years.
20:32Now we're talking about another 45 billion.
20:35Is the political will to keep that momentum?
20:37It's hard to see.
20:39Because the bill keeps on mounting.
20:40And I know that you are skeptical about a more joint borrowing.
20:44First priority is to keep the finance of Ukraine in place.
20:48But I am disappointed that the commission again resorts to a loan, which is actually not necessary if we unlock
20:55the discussion again on the frozen Russian assets.
20:57There are 210 billion euros that is now idle and that could get the burden away from the taxpayers, which
21:05are now paying the interest.
21:07But we know that this is legally very complex.
21:10It's been the subject of intense negotiations in the past that have collapsed.
21:14It seems right now that the only direction is actually raising more joint borrowing.
21:17But the thinking didn't stop and there are actually new proposals with new insights also to make sure that the
21:23Belgian concerns in particular, but also the concerns of other member states are covered.
21:28And I think we need to revisit it also because this is actually also another pressure tool for Russia.
21:34We need to make clear to Russia that their assets are becoming part of the equation.
21:39If we don't use them now, we might lose them because they will be used by someone else at the
21:44negotiation table as a bargaining chip.
21:46And we know the U.S. has obviously expressed interest in that.
21:49Well, it's not just someone else. It's President Trump, who you mean.
21:51And of course, that's been the concern throughout.
21:53And I've heard this multiple times from multiple officials suggesting the United States will put those 200 billion on the
21:59table for a potential deal because they want to cut a deal and get this done, sorted as soon as
22:04possible.
22:04Having said that, President Trump has not been successful in the negotiation.
22:08But to your point, I get the logic of it, but you know there is big resistance among the European
22:12Central Bank.
22:13Maybe a new head of Central Bank can change that at the ECB.
22:16I don't see how for the time being.
22:18And I think at this point, it really is a German Chancellor who is saying, if you do not contribute
22:23to this loan, we will not pay into the European common budget.
22:27This is the only avenue that I see for the time being.
22:30The first and assets to me remain still a fantasy.
22:33Well, I think we have a hearing this Thursday in the Parliament because we are keeping the pressure on this
22:38topic.
22:39And I think it's not only the right thing to do vis-a-vis the European taxpayers, but also the
22:44morally right thing to do because there's nothing radical about making the aggressor pay.
22:48And that is what we need to do also using the frozen assets.
22:51And we also know that politically, it's becoming more difficult to justify asking the taxpayer to put the bill because
22:58of what's happening in many countries.
23:00So, Maria, you know, we've seen now another 45 billion.
23:04We know that the war for now looks like it will continue.
23:08How difficult is it now becoming for European leaders to justify putting this bill time after time?
23:14Look, we spoke with the Ukrainian finance minister, Sergei Marchenko, who told us they are preparing for a budget and
23:20they have indeed budgeted.
23:212027 will be another year of war.
23:23So, of course, Ukraine is counting on the idea that the war will not only just continue, but it will
23:28also grow in intensity.
23:30The more they grow, the war becomes intense.
23:32Obviously, that means you blow through the cash faster, which is exactly what the Ukrainians are saying.
23:37They will now need more cash in 2027.
23:39Remember, the Europeans have said 90 billion would be enough for two years.
23:43Now we see it is simply not the case.
23:45Of course, Maret, you allude to what is the central political question at this point.
23:50We have seen unity so far in the European big countries, but we also know there are big elections happening
23:55next year.
23:56You look at France.
23:57Le Pen has said we don't have money.
23:59Look, she said we are broke.
24:00The French cannot continue to pay for this.
24:02As it stands, she would be the president.
24:04I'm saying as it stands, obviously polls can change, but that is the line she is pursuing.
24:08And when you look at Italy, Georgia Milani wants to run again for an election.
24:12But, you know, in Italy, the idea of more money for Ukraine is simply not popular.
24:16And then, of course, you had Poland.
24:18There's been real tensions between the Polish and the Ukrainians so far.
24:21So this is a delicate political question, which explains why they want to get it done before Christmas.
24:27The last word to you.
24:29I know, you know, the Netherlands also in political turmoil at the moment.
24:33Do you fear that the question of support of Ukraine could come back in a possible election if that does
24:39happen?
24:39There's a lot to say about the political situation in the Netherlands.
24:42But one thing is for sure.
24:43There is a large majority among population and in politics that wants to continue the strong support that we have
24:49been giving to Ukraine.
24:51But all the arguments here also tonight on the table show once more why it's so important to revisit with
24:57a good legally sound proposal that is there on the table to revisit the frozen assets.
25:03Because it seems that countries are really not doing that.
25:06It's been discarded of the table.
25:08How will you push for that?
25:09Well, we said that this would happen also after the December last year.
25:14Well, now it is on the table again.
25:16Some countries push for it.
25:17Sweden, also the Netherlands.
25:18We need to revisit it because it's a matter of principle also vis-à-vis our taxpayers,
25:23because it's also important that we cannot ask the taxpayers to continue to pay the interest while we have this
25:30option,
25:30which is a viable and legally sound option also taking into account the interests of Belgium.
25:35Thais, Maria, thank you so much for joining and for your analysis tonight.
25:39But that's it from us for now.
25:43Thank you so much for your company on tonight's show.
25:46Keep with us, stay with us here on Euronews.
25:49We'll have more analysis and more breaking news coming throughout the night.
25:54Thank you so much.
26:13We'll be right back.
26:56Ευχαριστώ.
27:15Υπότιτλοι AUTHORWAVE
Comments