00:00All right, joining me now is Ms. Shobha Day, author, columnist, someone who has an opinion on Sonia Gandhi's memoirs
00:07after reading it.
00:08Ms. Day, so what do you make of Ms. Gandhi's memoirs?
00:16Well, it's readable, it's interesting, it's mushy.
00:20I think I said it somewhere in a column, it's more Mills and Boone than Machiavelli.
00:26That kind of says it all.
00:27For me, it's not a political bomb, let's put it that way, that people were anticipating and were nervous about.
00:33It's more like a loving housewife's account of her early years as a woman in love, getting to the most
00:41powerful family in India.
00:43And basically, it's a kind of a prem patra, prem kahani, which is written perhaps for the Khan market crowd,
00:54because I don't see people outside of that crowd hanging on to every line and every word.
01:01I expected much more political depth, analysis, heft, some kind of a perspective, more incisive commentary.
01:11And she had help writing the book, so it's not as if it's just her lone voice.
01:15It's a very important memoir from any which point of view, because all these years we knew virtually nothing about
01:22Sonia Gandhi,
01:24she being the original The Sphinx.
01:27So her silence was her strength, according to me.
01:30If she's chosen to break through that wall of silence, then the memoir certainly should have been much more than
01:38talking about whether she loves gardening
01:42or whether it took her a while to get used to eating tandoori chicken or enjoying ice cream in the
01:51Khan market with her husband.
01:52All of it very, very, very charming, no doubt, but not compelling enough for someone like myself.
02:02Maybe I wanted more.
02:04We are the same age, and her life has been so dramatic and filled with such a monumental tragedy.
02:12I kept thinking about Jackie Kennedy while I was reading the book.
02:16There are lots of parallels, and Jackie chose not to write a memoir, even though she was a book editor.
02:22But I'm also thinking about people who are actively, as Sonia has been, but, I mean, she chose not to
02:29become the prime minister,
02:30but, say, Golda Meyers' book, for example, or take a mail of, like, a Henry Kissinger's book.
02:36Golda Meyers wrote it over two volumes.
02:38I mean, gave an overall perspective of change, of a radical approach, her politics.
02:47Even Maggie Thatcher's book, that was the one in two volumes.
02:50I felt also, starting from very humble beginnings and then getting on to be the Iron Lady and things,
02:58I wanted more insights.
03:00There weren't too many.
03:02There were people who were completely missing from the memoir.
03:05I don't see her son-in-law featuring very much.
03:08But, above all, it's the lapses.
03:11When you get into the politics of the book, that you choose to gloss over the 1984 riots, the Bhopal
03:18tragedy, the emergency, for Christ's sake.
03:22It's all sort of, the blame is pinned exclusive, almost, onto the brat brother-in-law and the brat Bahu,
03:32who sound like two really, extremely, what shall I say, selfish and unintelligent people,
03:39who dominated the scenario, dominated Indira Gandhi, for heaven's sake.
03:45So, Indira Gandhi didn't think the emergency was a good idea, says her Bahu now.
03:50But, at the time, those of us who lived through it, there's so many things, the 26-11 riots in
03:58Mumbai,
03:59so many where she could have provided an insider's view, even if she was defending whatever she wanted to defend.
04:08But, you cannot pretend all of this was not a part of her history and certainly the history of the
04:14country.
04:15You know, Ms. Day, you know, of course, you're allowed to have your views and you must have your views.
04:19But, having said that, you know, for someone who's also read the book,
04:22Sonia Gandhi was never really a politician because you're comparing her to figures who started out as politicians,
04:30who entered the public space of their own volition.
04:34And Sonia Gandhi, in a lot of ways, was an accidental politician.
04:37I have to interrupt you.
04:39Yeah, yeah, go ahead.
04:41Accidental politician sounds so wonderful.
04:44I'm just saying, but it's also so convenient.
04:48She just happened to be the most powerful woman in politics at the time,
04:53when she very shrewdly declined to become the Prime Minister.
04:59I think that was her smartest move.
05:01She had all the power, but no responsibility, no accountability.
05:05She was the power behind the throne.
05:08She certainly was the de facto leader of the country.
05:12She was very much a political figure.
05:14Of course.
05:15No, she was not just a...
05:16The title.
05:17No, I'm just...
05:18How can you say she was not...
05:19How can you say she was not a politician?
05:22No, I never said that.
05:23She's still a politician.
05:25She started off, maybe...
05:27Misty, I didn't say that.
05:28I didn't say that.
05:29What I was saying was that she was pivotal to Indian politics,
05:33and I would think pivotal to the Congress Party,
05:37more than any other leader, possibly, you know, even more than Indira Gandhi,
05:42in terms of the kind of years that she had,
05:44as being the fulcrum of the Congress.
05:46Nobody's denying that.
05:47But as in...
05:49Yes, exactly.
05:50My comparison was primarily because you named certain leaders,
05:55and they always started off as politicians.
05:57I don't think Sonia Gandhi actually began as a housewife,
06:00and that was the role that she chose for herself.
06:03And when you reflect in your memoirs,
06:04and you might be pivotal to some of the biggest moments in history,
06:08you chose to view it from your perspective.
06:10And for example, and you are right,
06:12where important, you know, topics or important events in Indian history,
06:17like emergency, she...
06:19And you are right, because it seems to be that, yes,
06:22she's decided to give her perspective, her view lens,
06:25and she's spoken of her brother-in-law.
06:27But she has never said that Indira Gandhi said it wasn't a good idea.
06:31She said both, Indira Gandhi and Sanjay, in the book.
06:34At least that's what she's mentioned.
06:36And Sanjay Gandhi convinced her that that was the best way to go.
06:39But she did say that Rajiv thought it wasn't a good idea.
06:42That's what I would think, you know,
06:43in terms of where emergency was concerned.
06:46The 84 riots, she actually talks quite a bit of,
06:49where she says that Rajiv Gandhi even apologized
06:51on the floor of the parliament,
06:52and we've apologized after that.
06:58What about the 1984 riots?
07:00There's very little about...
07:02There's a lot of stuff that one can nitpick.
07:04I'm not here to attack a book.
07:07Please understand.
07:08And it's a readable book.
07:10Like I said, it's readable for a lot of people
07:12in Khan market and in Delhi, perhaps.
07:14I don't know that the rest of India is going to say,
07:17oh, we really are dying to know
07:20what exactly happened when they fell in love
07:24and how she...
07:24Mrs. Gandhi took her from room to room
07:27and showed her where the ashes were and so on.
07:29All of it is great if it's a part of a narrative
07:33which has something much more to offer to a reader.
07:37Coming from a person like her,
07:39a very powerful figure in the imagination
07:42of the Indian political system,
07:45there's no getting away from it.
07:46There's no getting away from the role
07:49that she plays in politics today,
07:52right now as we speak.
07:54Or we wouldn't be...
07:55She wouldn't be on every channel
07:56talking about her memoir.
07:57She'd just be another person
08:00who happens to have married
08:01into a political family
08:03who has written a memoir.
08:04That's not the case.
08:05If the BJP was concerned enough
08:07to ask for certain cuts,
08:09it's because she is a politician.
08:12So I don't understand
08:14why we are refusing to acknowledge her
08:17as an important political person.
08:20She's one of the most enigmatic
08:22and one of the most important
08:24political figures
08:26in India's recent time.
08:28But a memoir is usually seen
08:29from the person's lens.
08:31It's not even an autobiography.
08:33There's a difference
08:33between a memoir and an autobiography.
08:35And who knows that better
08:36but you, Ms. Day.
08:37So fair point, ma'am.
08:38And I'll ask you one final question
08:39before we let you go,
08:41which is, because you know what,
08:42as a political journalist,
08:44I thought, yes,
08:45a lot of political juice
08:46which she was in the center of
08:48was missing.
08:48But then I look at it from her,
08:50you know, it's her perspective,
08:51it's her lens.
08:52Having said that,
08:53do you also think,
08:54because some would suggest
08:56that it also offers
08:57a greater insight
08:58on who Indira was.
08:59I would think it's actually
09:00a love story
09:01where two people are concerned.
09:02One is Rajiv
09:03and the other one
09:04is Indira Gandhi,
09:05how she builds that relationship
09:06with her over time
09:07where from what can be
09:09clearly, you know,
09:11that she was petrified
09:12of Indira Gandhi
09:13and then she grows
09:14to accept and love her.
09:16And Indira Gandhi
09:17as a mother-in-law
09:18was rather overbearing.
09:20And, you know,
09:20and she's quite candid
09:21about that.
09:25No, I love that part
09:27because, like I said,
09:28like, don't we all hang on
09:29to the SAS Bahu serials
09:31on television
09:32for exactly the same reasons.
09:34We want to know
09:35how daughters-in-law
09:37negotiate relationships
09:39with their mothers-in-law
09:40and that mother-in-law
09:41happens to be Indira Gandhi.
09:42My God,
09:43it makes for perfect television.
09:45It's like a saga.
09:46I mean,
09:47I'd love to see this book
09:48as a saga,
09:49pretty much like,
09:50I'm sure we all have watched
09:52Love Story
09:52with John F. Kennedy Jr.
09:54and his Carolyn Bissett
09:57and the tragedy
09:58of their lives
09:59seen through
10:00a certain perspective.
10:02So I just feel
10:03it's a very readable book
10:06and a bestseller for sure.
10:09And congratulations
10:10to the publishers.
10:11They took a bold step
10:14in going ahead
10:15when the other big publisher,
10:17Penguin Random House,
10:18got cold feet.
10:18So HarperCollins,
10:20you have a winner
10:20on your hands.
10:21So good luck to all
10:23and let the party begin.
10:25All right,
10:25Miss Day,
10:26thank you.
10:27And, you know,
10:28thank you for joining us
10:29with your review
10:30on India Today.
10:32There was no way that,
10:33you know,
10:33I was trying to argue with you.
10:34I was just giving you
10:35my perspective.
10:36But thank you.
10:37I appreciate it.